At December 31, 2012, Prosperity had net deferred tax assets totaling $17.2 million. The majority of the deferred tax assets related to net operating losses (“NOLs”) totaling $21.3 million at December 31, 2012. Prosperity believes it is more likely than not that it will utilize the NOLs within five years based on conservative earnings assumptions.
Prosperity reported its first annual operating loss in 2008. In the five years prior to 2008, Prosperity earned $42.4 million, or an average return on assets of 0.97% (after tax).
Rest of the answer
Pre-tax income during this five-year period totaled $48.9 million.
The operating losses have been accumulated during the periods 2008 to 2012. These losses are highly correlated to both the elevated levels of non-performing assets and the trend in non-performing assets. The following table illustrates this correlation:
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
(Dollar Amounts in Thousands)
Pre-tax losses
$
(18,706
)
(16,326
(11,204
(5,631
436
Total provision
25,082
15,256
13,825
5,261
3,583
Non-performing assets
34,498
26,478
20,430
29,496
22,567
Current levels of non-performing assets at June 30, 2013 total $15.6 million, evidencing an acceleration in the trend that began in 2011. This improvement in credit quality has already greatly impacted earnings, and the trend supports Prosperity’s belief that the NOLs will be utilized in the near term.
Analysis of Past Operating Results
Prior to the economic downturn:
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
(Dollars in Thousands)
Total assets
561,877
688,376
931,307
1,086,366
1,103,764
Total non-performing assets
2,577
739
1,163
2,692
17,959
Net interest income
18,947
22,874
27,780
31,003
30,085
Provision
780
1,063
2,165
1,009
3,075
Non-interest income
6,614
8,919
9,533
9,069
8,375
Non-interest expense
16,687
21,005
24,396
26,441
27,717
Pre-tax income/(loss)
8,094
9,725
10,752
12,622
7,668
Net interest income/average assets
3.83
%
3.76
3.82
3.07
2.67
Non-interest income/average assets
1.12
1.15
0.0091
0.74
Non-interest expense/average assets
3.33
0.0341
0.0331
0.0261
0.0246
Efficiency ratio
67.07
69.24
66.35
65.46
71.91
Provision/assets
0.14
0.15
0.23
0.09
0.28
Return on average assets
0.97
1.03
1.41
1.25
0.68
Prior to the economic downturn, Prosperity was able to achieve a higher than normal growth rate in total assets due, in part, to a de novo style branching strategy in new and existing markets. This branching strategy focused on retail growth in deposits, which built a substantial base of long-term, low-cost deposits that supported a strong margin even during the economic downturn. However, this retail strategy had a negative impact on the operating efficiency of Prosperity Bank because it caused occupancy and personnel costs to increase. Loan growth in commercial loans, such as construction and development loans, caused higher non-performing assets and credit costs as the economic downturn worsened.
During the economic downturn:
1,108,117
935,234
844,423
783,742
741,708
28,988
26,381
25,975
24,573
21,997
10,723
2,440
4,800
(90
4,813
33,335
29,891
28,154
24,853
22,791
3.03
2.90
3.34
3.43
3.17
0.70
0.27
0.22
-0.10
0.49
2.95
2.93
3.16
3.06
81.09
100.48
99.23
102.71
86.95
2.26
1.63
1.64
0.67
0.48
-1.23
-0.90
-0.77
-0.59
During the economic downturn, Prosperity greatly reduced risk concentrations by focusing available cash flows on problem assets and the resolution of non-performing assets. Net interest income decreased as the balance sheet contracted over 30% from 2008. Non-interest income was negatively affected by the losses and write-downs recorded on OREO. In addition to the efforts to resolve non-performing assets, management worked to restructure the operations of Prosperity Bank to be more efficient and scalable to the contracted size of Prosperity and anticipated a recovery in which asset value could again increase. The sales force remained focused on retail-oriented deposits, while the lending side focused more on residential lending, rather than commercial lending.
Analysis of Projected Future Results
Projected after economic downturn:
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
750,000
811,625
872,497
937,934
1,008,279
1,083,900
9,370
7,496
5,997
4,798
3,838
3,070
21,417
23,452
25,680
28,119
30,790
33,715
3,756
2,441
2,617
3,283
3,529
3,794
3,961
9,743
10,572
11,470
12,445
13,503
20,997
21,627
22,276
23,501
25,028
26,906
625
9,127
11,358
12,806
14,678
16,519
Remaining available NOL
20,675
11,548
190
2.84
2.89
2.94
3.00
3.05
3.11
0.52
1.20
1.21
1.22
1.23
2.78
2.66
2.55
2.51
2.48
82.74
65.15
61.45
59.36
57.89
56.98
0.50
0.30
0.35
0.05
0.73
0.85
0.89
0.95
0.99
Significant Assumptions. Set forth below are the significant assumptions underlying the projections set forth above:
•
Overview – The overriding theme of Prosperity’s current five-year forecast is that Prosperity believes it can incrementally improve its operating results and grow its total assets to achieve results similar to those reported before the economic downturn.
Assets – The projections assume that assets will increase at an annual rate of 7.50% and that Prosperity’s focus will center on commercial banking in existing markets with its current sales force. If this assumed level of growth is achieved, then Prosperity’s total assets would return to approximately 90% of their pre-downturn level. Prosperity believes this growth is achievable due to the reduced levels of competition in its markets, resulting from banking failures and consolidation in its markets, as well as recent expansion in its loan and deposit pipelines.
Net interest income (to average assets) – The projections assume that net interest income (to average assets) increases to approximately 3.11% of Prosperity’s pre-downturn level by 2018 due to improved mix in earning assets and higher spreads than experienced during 2010 to 2012. This level represents a conservative 3.35% net interest margin (to average earning assets) which Prosperity believes is achievable due to its higher than average level of low cost deposits. Although not reflected in the projections, Prosperity believes a higher interest rate environment would allow it to realize an expansion in the net interest margin in the long-run and thereby surpass the estimates used in the projections.
Provision – The projections assume a decline in provision expense relative to the expected decrease in non-performing assets. Prosperity believes non-performing assets will decrease ratably over the coming years to a more historical level and that costs associated with elevated problem assets will almost completely abate. Incremental provisions included in the projections largely reflect those customary with loan growth.
Non-interest income – Currently, the majority of Prosperity’s non-interest income is generated from service charges and other loan and deposit related fees. Mortgage production is booked largely on the balance sheet to the extent liquidity and interest rate sensitivity guidelines can accommodate it. Due to the increase in commercial loan demand, Prosperity anticipates that it will transition its mortgage production toward the secondary market and, accordingly, Prosperity has assumed in the projections an increase in non-interest income by $2.5 million in 2014 and each year thereafter. Prosperity has conservatively included only 70% of the fees that would be generated if Prosperity maintains current production levels once it shifts to selling loans in the secondary market. Current levels of non-interest income have been negatively impacted by losses on OREO that Prosperity does not anticipate will continue in the years projected.
Non-interest expense – Recognizing the changes in the banking industry, Prosperity has implemented numerous initiatives that would accommodate growth with limited investment in human talent or retail banking facilities, including a robust and effective mobile banking solution, an aggressively streamlined loan processing and administration function, and a fully staffed in-house data processing division that once managed the operations of a $1.2 billion
Prosperity business. Prosperity anticipates being able to drive operating efficiency into the 55% range by the end of 2016.
Potential Risks. Although Prosperity believes the projections are realistic based upon its past performance and the improvements Prosperity has made to its operations, several risks exist that could materially impact Prosperity’s projected performance, including:
A change in economic trends that would impact Prosperity’s markets and potentially reverse the positive trend in non-performing assets.
Lower spreads between short-term and long-term rates than are now present or anticipated in the near term. Prosperity did not incorporate in the projections an increase in interest rates or an expansion in spreads, although Prosperity believes this trend will continue and present better investment and loan yield opportunities than have been present over the past few years.
An inability to grow earning assets in Prosperity’s markets due to weaker economic activity or new competitors, or both. Additionally, if the merger with Ameris were not to occur, Prosperity would need to raise additional capital to support its necessary growth. Although multiple interests in capital investment were made, there is no guarantee that a recapitalization would occur.
Each of the risks described above could potentially cause Prosperity’s utilization of the existing NOLs to exceed its anticipated window and potentially increase them. However, there is no evidence that any of these risks would impact Prosperity’s projections in the short term, and Prosperity believes the NOLs can be utilized in the short term.
Sensitivity Analysis
The following sensitivity analysis shows varying return on assets and varying levels of total assets and the resulting number of years to utilize the NOLs. There is no anticipated utilization of the NOLs through short-term realization of gains included in the projections, although Prosperity is aware of $5.2 million of unrealized gains at December 31, 2012 that could quickly utilize a portion of the NOLs.
Sensitivity Analysis - Earn Back Period Assuming No Use of Tax Planning Strategies
Return on Assets (after tax)
Total Assets
0.25%
0.50%
0.75%
1.00%
1.25%
700,000
7.80
3.90
2.60
1.95
1.56
7.28
3.64
2.43
1.82
1.46
800,000
6.83
3.41
2.28
1.71
1.37
850,000
6.42
3.21
2.14
1.61
1.28
900,000
6.07
2.02
1.52
950,000
5.75
2.87
1.92
1.44
1,000,000
5.46
2.73
1.09
As illustrated above, static levels of assets and a sub-return on assets of 0.50% will fully utilize the NOLs in approximately four years.
Actual and Forecasted Taxable Income
Set forth below is an analysis of Prosperity’s actual and forecasted taxable income for 2008 through 2012:
Actual
Year
(Dollars in Thousand)
Consolidated pre-tax book income (loss)
(16,236
Forecasted pre-tax income
5,043
(3,332
(10,603
(3.676
(615
Variance
(23,749
(12,904
(601
(1,955
1,051
Although the variances noted above are meaningful, the financial crisis during 2008 to 2012 was not only unpredictable, but unprecedented. As a result, traditional budgeting methodologies did not hold true to form, and thus meaningful variances occurred. The primary reason for the variances is related to very elevated provisions for loan losses totaling $63.0 million from 2008 through 2012, with 86% of that occurring in the midst of the financial crisis between 2008 and 2010. Over recent years, given the movement away from an unstable financial industry, the variances have subsided. With respect to the 2011 variance, an unforeseen OTTI loss was recorded in the amount of $3.6 million on an investment security.
With respect to 2013 actual numbers compared to the projections, Prosperity revised its 2013 budget in May 2013, decreasing consolidated pre-tax book profit to $902,000 for 2013. As of June 30, 2013, the actual consolidated pre-tax book loss for Prosperity was $(736,000) compared to a projected pre-tax loss of $(715,000).
Please tell us how Ameris determined the fair value of the deferred tax asset for the purchase price allocation in the pro forma financial information.
Ameris determined the fair value of the deferred tax asset for the purchase price allocation in the pro forma financial information in accordance with the guidance provided by Section 382 of the Code (“Section 382”). First, Ameris calculated the adjusted net operating losses for Prosperity, including built-in losses, to be $42.6 million. This amount is the sum of: (i) Prosperity’s existing net operating losses of $21.3 million plus (ii) all of the anticipated losses on OREO plus (iii) one-half of the losses expected on the loan portfolio.
Ameris then compared the potential tax benefits from built-in losses to the maximum allowable benefits under
Section 382. Ameris estimated the value of Prosperity to be $16.4 million (determined by multiplying (i) the number of shares of Prosperity common stock outstanding (377,196), by (ii) the per share stock consideration (3.125), by (iii) the market price of the Ameris common stock on April 30, 2013, the day before the execution of the merger agreement ($13.87)). Ameris then multiplied this value by the then-applicable federal rate of 2.70% and multiplied the resulting product by the 20-year benefit period. This calculation resulted in total deductible benefits under Section 382 of $8.8 million.
Accordingly, Ameris applied a write-down of the Prosperity’s deferred tax asset of $11.8 million (determined by (i) the amount of the adjusted net operating losses for Prosperity, including built-in losses ($42.6 million), minus the total amount of deductible benefits under Section 382 ($8.8 million) multiplied by (ii) an effective tax rate of
35%).