The nature of Acadia’s external fund business is to acquire assets with more upside potential than would be appropriate for its core business. The Company participates as an investor as well as a manager of Fund III for which it gets treated in the same manner as the other investors, but also is entitled to a “promote” upon achieving certain results, namely a return on and of capital.
All results in excess of that level reward the Company with 20 cents of every additional dollar earned.
Rest of the answer
Much time and effort are required in both sourcing and conducting due diligence for Fund
III deals before acquiring them. Also, the nature of the typical Fund III deal (since they are not stabilized assets) requires efforts to achieve stabilization through the redevelopment, recapitalization or re-leasing of the asset. Furthermore, the nature of these investments typically requires more hands on work for greater periods of time than core assets require. The
Board of Trustees with the assistance of senior management of the Company created the Long Term
Investment Alignment Program (“LTIAP”) for management with the following goals — all as disclosed in the Company’s proxy statement filed April 9, 2010:
•
Reward management for true, long-term performance and not simply for making investment decisions without consideration of actual value realized.
Motivate management to deliver superior returns to external investors, as well as to the Company through its direct investment, through strategic investments and successful liquidation of Acadia Strategic Opportunity Fund III LLC (“Fund III”) and thereby increasing shareholder value.
Provide a retention tool for years to come.
Further align the interests of management and shareholders and external investors.
With the foregoing as background, each person’s role will be described below as it relates to allocations of the percentages of the LTIAP. It is worth noting that the reason the percentage of
LTIAP granted now was not in step with the level of investment, was to incentivize the recipients to ensure that appropriate assets will be acquired with the remaining funds in Fund III and to ensure that diligent efforts will be made to achieve stabilization of those assets.
Kenneth F. Bernstein was granted 6.25% of the LTIAP in 2009 and .625% in 2010. As Chief
Executive Officer of the Company, Mr. Bernstein is the ultimate decision maker on what investments, if any, Fund III will make. He also sources many of the transactions that become investments through his many contacts in the real estate business. His acumen in investing is one of the reasons behind the Company’s success and the independent members of the Board of Trustees believe it is appropriate that he be given the largest grant.
Joel Braun was granted 2.5% of the LTIAP in 2009 and 0.3125% in 2010. Mr. Braun is the Chief
Investment Officer of the Company, specifically charged with running the acquisitions group at the
Company, sourcing investments to be reviewed, heading up the due diligence efforts, coordinating the efforts of the Company’s team, investigating the asset, being responsible for the investment book describing the asset for approval by the Fund III investors as well as the Company’s Capital
Markets and Investments Committee of the Board of Trustees, and negotiating the purchase with the seller. As a result of the critical role Mr. Braun plays in acquiring assets for Fund III, the
Board of Trustees granted him an allocation which it believes reflects his contribution to Fund
III’s success.
Finally, Messrs. Nelsen, Masters and Napolitano were granted equal allocations of 0.75% in
2009 and 0.125% in 2010 reflecting their respective roles in managing both the acquisition process for Fund III, but equally importantly their ongoing role in developing, managing, financing and stabilizing the acquired assets. Although each of them has a role in the all important acquisition process, their roles are subordinate to those of Messrs. Bernstein and Braun. Their responsibilities do extend beyond the acquisition phase and endure until the assets are sold.
Thus, the Board of Trustees concluded that allocations for Messrs. Nelsen, Masters and Napolitano that were smaller than those given to Messrs. Bernstein and Braun were appropriate.