Form S-1
2014-11-06 to 2015-04-21 · 84 questions
· 5 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
No closing letter
Liquidity and cashReserves and insuranceRevenueResults discussion (MD&A)Critical estimatesAcquisitionsRisk factorsGoodwill and impairmentNon-GAAP measuresLeasesExecutive payDebtDerivatives and hedging
General
SEC asked (1)
We may have additional comments once you supply the information you omit throughout the prospectus, file all omitted exhibits and any material contracts, supply the partnership agreement, and update the disclosure as necessary. Please remember to allow enough time to respond to all such staff comments.Rest of the question
Also please provide updated information regarding the status of your NYSE listing application, promptly provide any omitted disclosure which has not been omitted pursuant to Securities Act Rule 430A, and update your disclosure accordingly.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (2)
Please supplementally provide us with copies of all written communications, as defined in Rule 405 under the Securities Act, that you, or anyone authorized to do so on your behalf, present to potential investors in reliance on Section 5(d) of the Securities Act, whether or not they retain copies of the communications.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
General
SEC asked (3)
Please provide the information required by Item 404 of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Prospectus Cover Page
SEC asked (4)
Please revise the first bulleted item to reference the distribution priority held by the preferred unitholders.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Prospectus Cover Page
SEC asked (5)
Please expand or revise your second bullet point to disclose that your partnership agreement does not require you to pay any distribution at all.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Industry and Market Data, page iv
SEC asked (6)
We note your statements that industry data and forecasts have not been verified by independent sources and that there can be no assurance as to the accuracy or completeness of such data. Under the federal securities laws, you are responsible for all information contained within your registration statement and you should not include language that suggests otherwise.Rest of the question
Please revise these statements or remove the related disclosures.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary, page 1 · Formation Transactions and Structure, page 10
SEC asked (7)
Please revise your filing to provide an organizational chart that reflects your equity holders prior to giving effect to the formation transactions and proposed offering. Please advise whether any holders of units issued in the merger or your general partner and its affiliates will have a controlling equity interest in the registrant.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary, page 1 · Formation Transactions and Structure, page 10
SEC asked (8)
Please disclose the terms of the preferred units in your prospectus summary.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
The Offering, page 18
SEC asked (9)
We note you disclose that you intend to distribute a “substantial majority of the available cash [you] generate.” Please revise to clarify the meaning of “substantial majority” and disclose how “available cash” and “cash available for distribution” will be determined or defined.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary Historical and Pro Forma Financial Data, page 21
SEC asked (10)
Please review your presentation to ensure that the chronological ordering of your financial statements and other financial data presented in tabular form throughout the submission is consistent, as contemplated by SAB Topic 11E.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Non-GAAP Financial Measures, page 23
SEC asked (11)
It appears that you have made adjustments in calculating EBITDA beyond those identified as part of Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K (e.g., impairment of oil and natural gas properties, accretion of asset retirement obligations, etc.). Please revise this presentation to present EBITDA as defined.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Non-GAAP Financial Measures, page 23
SEC asked (12)
Disclosure on pages 67-68 of your submission states that EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA are used to assess 1) your ability to make distributions to unitholders, 2) the ability of your assets to generate sufficient cash to pay interest costs and support your indebtedness, and 3) the feasibility of acquisitions and other capital expenditures.Rest of the question
As these factors appear to imply that your non-GAAP measures are liquidity measures, please revise to provide a reconciliation to net cash provided by operating activities. Refer to Item 10(e)(1)(i)(B) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 48
SEC asked (13)
Please revise this section to disclose the amount of offering proceeds you intend to use (i) to repay your outstanding indebtedness and (ii) to fund future capital expenditures.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 48
SEC asked (14)
Please revise to include the term of your credit facility. See Instruction 4 to Item 504 of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 51 · Estimated Cash Available for Distribution for the Year Ending December 31, 2015, page 51
SEC asked (15)
We note your disclosure that if you make distributions, your preferred unitholders will have priority with respect to rights to share in those distributions over common unitholders for so long as your preferred units are outstanding. Please revise to describe the terms of such priority.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 51 · Estimated Cash Available for Distribution for the Year Ending December 31, 2015, page 51
SEC asked (16)
We note your disclosure that you intend to make distributions on a quarterly basis. Please revise your filing to show your ability to make such distributions on a quarterly basis. In that regard, please revise your disclosure to state your estimated generated available cash and expected quarterly distribution for each individual quarter during the Year Ending December 31, 2015.Rest of the question
Please also revise your tabular disclosures at pages 56 and 58 and related disclosure to support such disclosure.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 51 · Estimated Cash Available for Distribution for the Year Ending December 31, 2015, page 51
SEC asked (17)
We note your disclosure that to the extent that you do not withhold cash for capital expenditures in the future, a portion of your future cash available for distribution will represent a return of capital. Please revise to disclose any material impact on investors.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Results of Operations, page 65 · Results of Operations, page 69
SEC asked (18)
Please tell us about the extent to which management analyzes certain performance indicators such as lease operating expenses and production and ad valorem taxes on a per barrel basis and explain how you considered providing a discussion of these financial statement line items on a per barrel basis in this section of your submission.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Results of Operations, page 65 · Results of Operations, page 69
SEC asked (19)
Please revise your disclosure for each period presented to quantify the impact of each of the factors cited as a cause for material changes in each of your financial statement line items. For example, quantify in dollars the effect of price variances compared to volumes produced on revenues by product.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73 · Capital Expenditures, page 74
SEC asked (20)
Disclosure in your submission states the amount and timing of capital expenditures is largely discretionary and within your control. Please expand your disclosure to address the potential ramifications associated with a deferral of planned capital expenditures. For additional guidance, refer to Section IV of SEC Release No. 33-8350.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 75 · Equity-Based Compensation, page 77
SEC asked (21)
Disclosure in your submission identifies the methods used to determine the fair value of equity-based awards. Please expand this disclosure to address the nature of the material assumptions involved with each valuation method. In addition, explain the extent to which similar estimates will be necessary to determine the fair value of new awards once your common units begin trading.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 75 · Equity-Based Compensation, page 77
SEC asked (22)
We note your disclosure referring to the use of a third party valuation specialist in determining the value of equity-based awards. Please tell us how you considered providing valuation reports and consents from third party valuation experts or remove all references to the use of third party valuation experts from your submission (e.g., as part of the footnotes to the financial statements).Rest of the question
Refer to Question 233.02 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations regarding Securities Act Rules.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 75 · Equity-Based Compensation, page 77
SEC asked (23)
Please provide us with detailed valuation information for the restricted common units granted from January 1, 2014 through the date of this letter. As part of your response, please address the significant factors, assumptions, and methodologies used.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 75 · Equity-Based Compensation, page 77
SEC asked (24)
You state that it is reasonable to expect that the completion of an initial public offering will add value to your restricted common units because they will have increased liquidity and marketability. Please revise to provide additional disclosure describing the impact, if any, this is expected to have on your financial statements.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Oil and Natural Gas Production Prices and Production Costs, page 99 · Production and Price History, page 99
SEC asked (25)
We note disclosure in the reserves report filed as Exhibit 99.1 that states “gas prices are adjusted to account for NGL revenue for properties from which NGL volumes are actually recovered and sold separately.” Please tell us and revise your disclosure here and elsewhere in your filing to clarify whether your oil and condensate production includes natural gas liquids and explain the extent to which such volumes areRest of the question
material. Also clarify your disclosure if such volumes are incorporated into the calculation of the average realized price of your oil and condensate for each of the periods disclosed.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Oil and Natural Gas Production Prices and Production Costs, page 99 · Production and Price History, page 99
SEC asked (26)
The footnote disclosure provided on page 99 indicates that production volumes have been determined on a value-equivalent basis using a conversion factor of 20 Mcf per barrel of oil. Please tell us and expand your disclosure to explain the time period, source and basis of the prices used in deriving the 20 Mcf per barrel conversion factor and the extent to which this factor is relevant to your oil and natural gasRest of the question
revenues for the periods presented. Also provide us with copies of internal or third-party reports, studies or calculations that support the use of a 20 Mcf per barrel conversion factor. Please mark your furnished support or provide page references in your response to the sections you rely upon to support the use of this specific factor.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Oil and Natural Gas Production Prices and Production Costs, page 99 · Production and Price History, page 99
SEC asked (27)
The footnote disclosure provided on page 99 also indicates that the conversion factor of 20 Mcf per barrel of oil equivalent represents an estimation of “value equivalence over time” and “better correlates with the respective contribution of oil and natural gas to our revenues.” Separately, disclosure on page 97 indicates that you determined a price equivalent conversion based on the twelve-month average prices forRest of the question
the year ended December 31, 2013 of approximately 26 Mcf per barrel of oil. Given the disparity between the 20:1 conversion factor used and the December 31, 2013 conversion factor you disclose, explain to us your basis for the statement that the 20:1 conversion factor “better correlates with the respective contribution of oil and natural gas to our revenues.” As part of your response, explain how you have considered a separate conversion ratio based on actual realized prices for each period for which financial and production information have been presented. Additionally, explain how you use the 20:1 conversion factor in your business.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Oil and Natural Gas Production Prices and Production Costs, page 99 · Production and Price History, page 99
SEC asked (28)
We note your disclosure of production for the periods shown on page 99; however, it does not appear that you provide disclosure here or elsewhere of the annual production quantities, by final product sold, for each field that contains 15% or more of your total proved reserves. Please advise or revise your disclosure to comply with the presentation requirements set forth in Item 1204(a) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Productive Wells, page 99
SEC asked (29)
Please revise the disclosure relating to your productive wells to separately express the total number of oil and gas wells. Refer to Item 1208(a) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Executive Compensation and Other Information, page 113 · Outstanding Equity Awards at 2013 Fiscal Year-End, page 115
SEC asked (30)
Please clarify your reference to a “reverse unit split of BSMC’s common units”
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Index to Financial Statements, page F-1
SEC asked (31)
Please monitor the requirement to update the financial statements to comply with Rule 312 of Regulation S-X and provide corresponding updated disclosures throughout the submission.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Unaudited Pro Forma Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-2 · Introduction
SEC asked (32)
We note from the disclosure that Black Stone Natural Resources, LLC will make a cash contribution in exchange for common units representing a 1% limited partner interest in Black Stone Minerals Company, LP and common units representing a 1% limited partner interest in Black Stone Minerals, LP. Please tell us whether there is a pro forma adjustment to record this transaction.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Unaudited Pro Forma Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-2 · Introduction
SEC asked (33)
Please clarify for us whether pro forma adjustments will be made to reflect items (i) through (v) described in the third bullet point on page F-2.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Unaudited Pro Forma Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-2 · Introduction
SEC asked (34)
Please clarify for us how you considered providing the separate break-out of Partners’ equity between general and limited partner interests as contemplated by SAB Topic 4F.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Notes to Balance Sheet, page F-11 · Note 1 – Organization, page F-11
SEC asked (35)
Please revise to clarify the fiscal year end that has been adopted for this entity.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Interim Financial Statements · Consolidated Balance Sheets, page F-12
SEC asked (36)
We note the line item titled Prepaid expenses and other current assets represents 8% of total current assets and increased by more than 25% since the end of the preceding fiscal year. Please evaluate your compliance with Regulation S-X, Rules 5-02(7) and (8) and 10-01(a)(2) and advise.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Interim Financial Statements · Consolidated Balance Sheets, page F-12
SEC asked (37)
Please add disclosure to explain the nature of the Accrued partners’ distribution payable – related party.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Consolidated Statement of Equity, page F-15
SEC asked (38)
Please clarify why the Net income of $130,895 does not tie to the Net income of $131,995 reflected on page F-14.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 2 – Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F-32 · Oil and Natural Gas Properties, page F-34
SEC asked (39)
We note your accounting policy stating that “DD&A of proven oil and natural gas properties is calculated using the unit-of-production method based on estimates of proved producing oil and natural gas reserves on a field-by-field basis.” Please revise your disclosure to clarify your policy for the depletion of capitalized acquisition costs of proved properties. Refer to FASB ASC 932-360-35-6.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Revenue Recognition, page F-35
SEC asked (40)
Please revise to provide additional detail regarding your accounting policy for sources of revenue other than from sales of oil and natural gas.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 4 – Acquisition, page F-37
SEC asked (41)
We note the Predecessor acquired the remaining 19.3% noncontrolling interests in “Pure” for $323M. It appears from the disclosure that the transaction was reflected as an equity transaction. Please tell us if this transaction is reflected in the equity statement on page F-29 as “Contributions - property.” In addition, please tell us whether this transaction is a step acquisition and, if so, how you considered theRest of the question
guidance per FASB ASC 805-10-2510.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Supplemental Oil and Gas Disclosures, page F-52 · Oil and Gas Natural Reserve Information, page F-53
SEC asked (42)
Please revise to separately disclose the quantities of proved developed reserves and proved undeveloped reserves as of December 31, 2011. Refer to FASB ASC 932-23550-4.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Standardized Measure of Discounted Future Net Cash Flows, page F-54
SEC asked (43)
We note that you have included a line item for “development costs incurred during the period” as part of the disclosure of changes in standardized discounted cash flows. Please tell us whether this line item is meant to represent previously estimated development costs incurred during the period. Refer to FASB ASC 932-235-50-35.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibits
SEC asked (44)
Please file your limited partnership agreement as currently in effect. See Item 601(b)(3) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibits
SEC asked (45)
Please file all agreements required by Item 601(b)(10) of Regulation S-K. For example, please file the following: your employment Agreement with Mr. Carter; the 2012 Executive Incentive Plan and restricted unit award agreements; and the long-term incentive plan.Rest of the question
Closing Comments Prior to the effectiveness of your registration statement, please be sure that we receive a copy of the letter, or a call, from FINRA, stating that FINRA has finished its review and has no additional comments with respect to the proposed underwriting arrangements.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary, page 1 · Formation Transactions and Structure, page 10
SEC asked (1)
We note your revisions in response to prior comment 7. Please further revise your organizational structure charts to disclose the names of the limited partners and their ownership of common units and preferred units, or tell us why you do not believe such disclosure is material.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Summary, page 1 · Formation Transactions and Structure, page 10
SEC asked (2)
We note that you disclose an accrued partners’ distribution payable of $51.179 million at September 30, 2014 that reflects distributions that have not been paid. If such amount will not be paid to the partners in connection with the formation transactions and this offering, please discuss this payable in the context of your liquidity and ability to pay distributions.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
The Offering, page 19
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to prior comment 9, and your disclosure that in connection with the closing of this offering, the board of directors of your general partner will adopt a policy pursuant to which you will distribute a substantial majority of the cash you generate from operations each quarter.Rest of the question
Please revise your disclosure to clarify the meaning of “substantial majority” and to provide a narrative description of how you will determine or define “cash generated from operations.”
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Risk Factors, page 26 · The volatility of oil and natural gas prices due to factors beyond our control…, page 27
SEC asked (4)
Please update this risk factor to reflect recent changes in oil prices.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Our partnership agreement includes exclusive forum, venue…, page 44
SEC asked (5)
We note your discussion in this risk factor of the fee-shifting provision in the partnership agreement. Please revise this risk factor to explain that the fee-shifting provision may increase the cost of bringing lawsuits and may effectively discourage unitholder claims.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Use of Proceeds, page 49
SEC asked (6)
We note your revised disclosure in response to prior comment 13 and reissue such comment. Please revise your disclosure to quantify the offering proceeds you intend to use (i) to repay your outstanding indebtedness and (ii) to fund future capital expenditures.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 52 · Estimated Cash Generated from Operations for Distribution for the Year Ending December 31, 2015, page 56
SEC asked (7)
We note your response to prior comment 15, and your revised disclosure that provides a cross-reference to disclosure elsewhere in your filing. Please revise to describe the terms of the distribution priority in this section.Rest of the question
In addition, please tell us how the order of priority described on page 132 is reflected in your tabular disclosure of estimated cash available for distribution for the year ending December 31, 2015. For example, we note that your description on page 132 contemplates that your common unitholders and preferred unitholders will share in distributions after a certain amount of distributions have been made to common unitholders.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 80 · Equity-Based Compensation, page 81
SEC asked (8)
We note your statement on page 81 that “As of the valuation date of January 1, 2014, we were not planning to pursue an initial public offering.” Please tell us when you first initiated discussions with underwriters and when the underwriters first communicated their estimated price range and amount for your common unit.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Estimated Proved Reserves, page 99 · Estimated Proved Undeveloped Reserves, page 103
SEC asked (9)
Please expand the disclosure for proved undeveloped reserves to provide a narrative explanation for the material changes relating to the line item entries for acquisitions of reserves for the period ending September 30, 2014 and for revisions of previous estimates for the periods ending December 31, 2013 and September 30, 2014, respectively. Refer to Item 1203(b) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Oil and Natural Gas Production Prices and Production Costs, page 104 · Production and Price History, page 104
SEC asked (10)
We note your response to comments 26 and 27 in our letter dated November 6, 2014 and your revised footnote disclosure on page 104 and elsewhere on pages 92 through 99 relating to the presentation of production volumes that have been determined on a valueequivalent basis using a conversion factor of 20 Mcf per barrel of oil.Rest of the question
We reissue our comments in-part relating to expanding your disclosure, here, and additionally on page 102 in reference to your reserves, to provide a brief description of the parameters used in the calculation of the metric, e.g. the time period, source and basis of the prices used in deriving the 20 Mcf per barrel conversion factor. Additionally and as part of your expanded disclosure, please: explain that there is no identifiable standard for this metric and that such disclosure is provided supplementally, explain that the metric represents the mean ratio of a range of values over time, provide the high and low values within the range, and include the conversion factors relating to each of the periods disclosed to illustrate the variability, and caution the reader as to any limitations applicable to the use of this metric.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
The Partnership Agreement, page 136 · Applicable Law; Forum, Venue and Jurisdiction, page 140
SEC asked (11)
Please expand your disclosure regarding the fee-shifting provision to clarify the following: the parties who may be subject to the provision, the meaning of the phrase “substantially achieves, in substance and amount,” and the parties who may be allowed to recover their fees and expenses.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Unaudited Pro Forma Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-2
SEC asked (12)
We note you revised the unaudited pro forma consolidated balance sheet to reflect the general partner and limited partner interests separately within Partners’ equity. Please clarify why you did not also revise the pro forma statements of operations to show the aggregate amount of net income allocated to the general partner and the aggregate amount allocated to the limited partners and the per common unit basis asRest of the question
contemplated by SAB Topic 4F.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Note 2 – Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F-33 · Revenue Recognition, page F-36
SEC asked (13)
We note your response to comment 40 in our letter dated November 6, 2014 regarding revenue from lease bonuses and delay rentals. With reference to the relevant guidance, please tell us how you concluded that it was not necessary to recognize the associated revenue over the lease term. As part of your response, please describe any relevant contractual terms associated with these arrangements.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
General · Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 54
SEC asked (1)
Please revise your pro forma tabular disclosure to clarify the meaning of the caption “cash paid to noncontrolling interests.” Form of First Amended and Restated Agreement of Limited Partnership of Black Stone Minerals, L.P.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
General · Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 54
SEC asked (2)
Please advise as to why you have removed from your filing Annex A (Series A Preferred Units) to your partnership agreement.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibits · Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to prior comment 5. It does not appear appropriate to assume “(ix) that the General Partner will have duly authorized the issuance of any Common Units to be issued by the Partnership.” For guidance, please refer to Section II.B.3.a.Rest of the question
of Staff Legal Bulletin 19, which advises that counsel should not assume that the registrant has taken all corporate actions necessary to authorize the issuance of the securities.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Exhibits · Exhibit 5.1
SEC asked (4)
We note your response to prior comment 6, and reissue the comment in part. Please tell us why it is both necessary and appropriate for counsel to include the assumptions included in (iii), (v) and (vi) on page 3 of the opinion with respect to Black Stone Natural Resources, L.L.C. and Black Stone Minerals Company, L.P. In that regard, we note that Black Stone Minerals Company, L.P.Rest of the question
is your predecessor, and Black Stone Natural Resources, L.L.C. is the general partner of your predecessor. In the alternative, please obtain and file a revised opinion that does not include such assumptions.
BSM answered
No reply letter found.
Risk Factors, page 28 · The volatility of oil and natural gas prices due to factors beyond our control…, page 29
SEC asked (1)
It appears that your risk factor disclosure makes reference to full cost accounting rules. However, we note that you use the successful efforts method of accounting for your oil and natural gas operations. Please revise this disclosure to explain the potential impact of the factors discussed as part of this risk factor on impairment under the successful efforts method of accounting.
Oil prices have declined substantially from historical highs …, page 30
SEC asked (2)
Please expand this risk factor to address the potential impact of decreases in the prices of oil on your ability to fund planned capital expenditures.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 55
SEC asked (3)
Your disclosure indicates that you intend to pay a specified increasing quarterly distribution beyond the forecasted twelve month period ending June 30, 2016. However, your disclosure does not provide any support for your ability to make such distributions, nor does it indicate the underlying assumptions that would be material to understanding how this would occur.Rest of the question
If you continue to retain this provision, provide such information or explain to us why it is appropriate to quantify such future distributions given the inherent business and price uncertainty over such an extended period of time. We may have further comment once we are able to consider your response.
BSM answered
The Registration Statement has been revised to remove any expression of intent, or ability, to pay the specified increasing quarterly distribution beyond the twelve months ending March 31, 2016 and to clarify that the specified increasing quarterly distribution amount only provides the common unitholders a priority right to distributions over the subordinated unitholders if a distribution is paid. Please see the cover page to the prospectus and pages 19, 20, 43, 55, 56, 57, 58, 62, and 65 of Amendment No. 1.
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 55
SEC asked (4)
We note your disclosure on page 56 that your credit facility contains certain financial tests and covenants that you must satisfy. You also state that if you are unable to satisfy the restrictions under your credit facility you could be prohibited from making distributions notwithstanding your stated distribution policy. Please revise to disclose such restrictions.
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page · Business Environment, page 84
SEC asked (5)
Please expand your discussion of how the oil and natural gas business environment affects you to include a discussion of the expected impact to your results of operations from the current commodity price declines noted in other sections of your registration statement.Rest of the question
As part of this disclosure, please provide an analysis of known trends or uncertainties that may have a material impact on your revenues in future periods. To the degree that you have taken steps to address material risks associated with recent declines in commodity prices, please include a discussion of these actions as part of your revised disclosure. Refer to Item 303(a)(3)(ii) of Regulation S-K.
How We Evaluate Our Operations, page 85 · Commodity Prices, page 85
SEC asked (6)
Disclosure provided as part of the analysis of your operating results for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2014 states that you used derivative instruments to mitigate the risk and resulting impact of recent volatility in the price of oil and natural gas.Rest of the question
Please expand your disclosure to describe the types of derivative contracts into which you have entered to mitigate your exposure to changes in commodity prices and state the period through which you have entered into these types of contracts. As part of this disclosure, explain how current market conditions may impact your ability to enter into similar types of derivative instruments and describe the potential impact this may have on your revenues in future periods.
Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 90 · Credit Facility, page 91
SEC asked (7)
We note that the next borrowing base redetermination for your credit facility is scheduled for April 2015. Disclosure in your filing indicates that your borrowing base may be decreased if prices do not return to former levels.Rest of the question
Please revise to provide quantitative disclosure explaining the expected impact to your borrowing base and address the steps management intends to take to address the resulting uncertainty to your liquidity position. Refer to Item 303(a)(1) of Regulation S-K.
BSM answered
The Registration
Statement has been revised. Please see pages 94 and 95 of Amendment No. 1.
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates,
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 92 · Successful Efforts Method of Accounting, page 93
SEC asked (8)
Please expand this disclosure to specifically address how uncertainties associated with the recent decline in oil and natural gas prices will affect the significant estimates used to account for your oil and natural gas operations. Specifically, your revised disclosure should more clearly address the potential impact of a sustained low price environment on further impairment charges.Rest of the question
In addition, please include a discussion of how this could impact your estimates of proved reserve quantities.
Equity-Based Compensation, page 94
SEC asked (9)
Please reconcile and explain any difference between the fair value of the underlying units granted by your Board of Directors in February 2015 and the midpoint of your estimated IPO offering range. This reconciliation should describe significant intervening events within the Partnership and changes in assumptions as well as weighting and selection of valuation methodologies employed that explain the changes in theRest of the question
fair value of your common unit up to the filing of the registration statement. In addition, describe the impact of changes in the oil and natural gas business environment such as the extent to which recent volatility of oil and natural gas prices has had an effect on your most recent valuation. As part of this analysis, please tell us how many common units in Black Stone Minerals, LP will be issued in exchange for the 7.3 million units granted in February 2015.
BSM answered
The fair value of the underlying units granted by the Board of Directors (the
“Board”) of Black Stone Minerals Company, L.P. (“BSMC”) on February 23, 2015 was based on a valuation performed as of December 31, 2014 and was based on a probability-weighted analysis of the likelihood of two scenarios occurring: remain private (the “Private scenario”) or go public (the “Public
Securities and Exchange Commission, April 10, 2015, Page 5 scenario”).
Rest of the answer
Additionally, management and the Board considered if there were any significant changes in our operations or market conditions between the valuation date and grant date. As of the grant date, the Board determined that the fair value of the units was consistent with the valuation as of December 31, 2014.
Under the Private scenario, the fair value of the underlying units was determined using methods consistent with prior valuations of the units of BSMC. This scenario was based on the weighting of several methods including a Net Asset Value Method under the Asset Approach, a Dividend Discount Model under the Income Approach, and the Guideline Public Company and Transaction Methods under the Market Approach. The Private scenario resulted in a valuation of approximately $1.17 per unit. This scenario resulted in a decline in the fair value of the units of approximately $0.51 per unit, or 30.4%, relative to the fair value of units issued granted in January 2014. The primary reason for this decline in fair value was a significant drop in commodity prices between the two valuation dates. From December 31, 2013 to December 31, 2014, the spot price of crude oil dropped from $98.17 per barrel to $53.24 per barrel, or 45.6%, and the spot price of natural gas dropped from $4.31 to $2.99 per MMBtu, or 30.6%. Additionally, the NYMEX strip used for the valuation as of December 31, 2014 was significantly lower than the strip used for the valuation as of December 31,
2013. As of the grant date, the NYMEX strip was down slightly from the strip used for in the valuation as of December 31, 2014; however, the differences between these forward curves was minimal and did not indicate an adjustment to the fair value of the units was warranted.
Under the Public scenario, the fair value of the units was estimated using inputs from the underwriters leading our initial public offering (“IPO”) process. The fair value of the units under this scenario was determined using a Single Period Capitalization Method under the Income Approach. The Public scenario resulted in an estimated fair value for the units of $1.53, or 9.0% lower than the fair value of the units as of the January 2014 grant. This methodology and valuation are consistent with the derivation of the expected IPO offering range. The fair value of the units under the Public scenario is substantially similar to the current estimate of the midpoint of the offering range provided to us by our underwriters. However, units for the February 2015 grant will convert into both common and subordinated units. We believe that subordinated units have less value than our common units as they are subject to increased risk due to common units having a priority right to distributions and accruing minimum-quarterly-distribution arrearages.
To estimate the fair value of the units for the February 2015 grant, we assigned a 1/3 probability of remaining private and a 2/3 likelihood of a public offering. At the time of grant, there was significant uncertainty regarding the viability of completing a public offering. This uncertainty was evidenced by feedback the company received during the testing-the-waters meetings, the volatility of commodity prices preceding the grant date, and the volatility in the trading ranges of publicly traded companies in the oil and gas industry. Additionally, in response to this uncertainty in the market and to provide protection for the potential buyers in our IPO, we modified the structure of our offering after the grant date of the units to include a stated minimum quarterly distribution and subordinated a significant portion of the units held by our existing owners. As a result, we believe the selected weighting is appropriate given the uncertainty in the market at the time of the valuation and the likelihood of completing a public offering.
Securities and Exchange Commission, April 10, 2015, Page 6
BSMC’s limited partnership agreement contains an annual repurchase obligation of 1% of the outstanding units. An annual valuation of BSMC is required to establish a value basis for the repurchase obligation, which valuation is the same valuation we have used to estimate the fair value of the units in prior grants.
The per-unit numbers included in this response are on a pre-merger and pre-conversion basis. We will advise you of the number of common and subordinated units of the Partnership that we expect the 7.3 million units granted in February 2015 to convert into based on the pricing information provided to us when we submit the pricing information confidentially. The total number of Partnership units issued in connection with the merger and conversion will be considerably less than the number of BSMC units currently outstanding.
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Description of Our Preferred Units, page 150
SEC asked (10)
We note that you have removed disclosure regarding additional distributions that may be payable to the holders of the preferred units. We also note that such distribution rights are reflected on page A-27 of the annex to the limited partnership agreement.Rest of the question
Your revised disclosure indicates that you believe it is unlikely any additional distributions will be required, and if they are required, you believe they would not materially adversely affect the per unit distribution rate you would otherwise make on your common and subordinated units. Please disclose the basis for this belief.
Financial Statements · Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows, pages F-17- F-18
SEC asked (11)
We note you reflect repayments and borrowings under your senior line of credit on a net basis. Please tell us whether this presentation complies with FASB ASC 230-10-45-7 through 45-9 or revise your disclosure to show cash receipts and payments on a gross basis.
BSM answered
We have considered the guidance provided by FASB ASC 230-10-45-7 through 45-9 in determining whether information about gross cash receipts and payments is more relevant than net cash receipts and payments. FASB ASC 230-10-45-9 provides that if the original maturity of the liability is three months or less, cash receipts and payments for debt can qualify for net reporting.
Rest of the answer
Borrowings under our senior line of credit typically comprise several tranches of borrowings with one-month maturations that are based on LIBOR plus a margin that varies depending on the borrowing-base-utilization percentage. If they are not
Securities and Exchange Commission, April 10, 2015, Page 7 rolled into a new LIBOR-based borrowing or repaid, these tranches automatically convert to borrowings at the then-existing prime rate plus a margin depending on the borrowing-base-utilization percentage. During 2014, there were 125 separate instances in which a tranche was rolled into a new LIBOR-based borrowing, converted to a prime borrowing, or repaid with 60 separate cash receipts and principal repayments. As such, we have determined that information about net cash receipts and payments are more relevant to users of the financial statements in accordance with FASB ASC 230-10-45-7 through 45-9.
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 2 – Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F-19
SEC asked (12)
We note you removed disclosure explaining the nature of the Accrued partners’ distribution payable. Please revise to include this disclosure or tell us why you do not believe this disclosure is necessary.
Supplemental Oil and Natural Gas Disclosures · Standardized Measure of Discounted Future Net Cash Flows, page F-41
SEC asked (13)
Despite the decrease in proved undeveloped reserves (“PUDs”) from 2,856MBoe at December 31, 2013 to 595 MBoe at December 31, 2014, we note that future development costs used to calculate the standardized measure of discounted future net cash flows increased from approximately $53.2 million to approximately $65.0 million.Rest of the question
Please tell us whether you expect the PUDs recorded as of December 31, 2014 to require greater expenditure for development to proved developed status than PUDs converted in prior periods. As part of your response, please address the disclosure on page 116 of you registration statement which states that estimated future development costs relating to PUDs at December 31, 2014 were projected to be approximately $11.5 million in the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015.
BSM answered
The increase in our future development costs used to calculate the standardized measure of discounted future net cash flows from 2013 to
2014 resulted primarily from a revision to our estimated undiscounted costs related to our asset retirement obligation (“ARO”) liability. Please see page F-24 of Amendment No.1 for the reconciliation of changes to our estimated discounted ARO liability.
Rest of the answer
Our future development costs of $65.0 million at December 31, 2014 comprise $11.6 million of costs required to convert non-producing reserves, including both proved developed nonproducing reserves
(“PDNPs”) and proved undeveloped reserves (“PUDs”), to proved developed status and $53.4 million of estimated undiscounted ARO costs associated with our proved developed reserves. We estimate PDNPs will only require $0.1 million of additional development costs.
Securities and Exchange Commission, April 10, 2015, Page 8
On a dollar per MBoe basis, we expect an increase in the costs required to convert our PUDs at
December 31, 2014 to proved developed status when compared to December 31, 2013. The Registration Statement has been revised. Please see page 119 of Amendment No. 1.
We note that our estimates of proved undeveloped reserves are limited to those relatively few wells for which we have received and approved an authorization for expenditure (“AFE”) from our operators and that remain undrilled at the end of each period. Limiting our PUD estimates on this basis results in a relatively fast conversion rate of PUDs into proved developed status. Between the end of a given reserve period and the end of the next reserve period, we have typically (i) converted substantially all PUDs booked at the end of the first period to proved developed status, (ii) converted additional undeveloped reserves into proved developed status, and
(iii) estimated new PUDs at the end of the reserve period based on the approved AFEs at that time. As a consequence, PUD estimates may vary significantly between periods, and development costs on a dollar per MBoe basis vary based on the nature of the working-interest-participation opportunities at the point in time when reserves are estimated. Development costs associated with our PUDs represent a small portion of our total costs incurred throughout the year to develop our properties.
Furthermore, as a minerals company, we benefit from the booking of cost-free royalty-interest reserves associated with some of our working interest PUDs. These cost-free additions vary from well to well depending on the magnitude of our royalty interest relative to our working interest in each well, which influences the apparent development cost on a dollar per MBoe basis.
For these reasons, we do not feel that the expected future development costs of our PUDs on a dollar per MBoe basis is an accurate representation of the total costs to develop our properties.
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Use of Proceeds, page 52
SEC asked (1)
Please disclose the amount and intended purpose of any net proceeds received in excess of payments to be made on indebtedness outstanding under your credit facility.
Cash Distribution Policy and Restrictions on Distributions, page 55
SEC asked (2)
Please revise your tabular disclosure of Pro Forma Cash Generated from Operations for the Year Ended December 31, 2014 and Estimated Cash Generated from Operations for the Twelve Months Ending March 31, 2016 to disclose estimated annual distributions to common units issued in the merger separately from subordinated units issued in the merger.
Pro Forma Cash Generated from Operations, page 60
SEC asked (3)
Please expand footnote 11 on page 61 to quantify the net impact to the difference between pro forma cash generated from operations available for distribution and total distributions on common and subordinated units assuming preferred units were converted into common and subordinated units on January 1, 2014. Estimated Cash Generated from Operations for the Twelve Months Ending March 31, 2016,
Forecasted Distributions, page 71
SEC asked (4)
Please revise your disclosure regarding the expected aggregate quarterly distributions for the twelve months ending March 31, 2016 to reflect the prorated distribution for the quarter ending June 30, 2015, as you do on page 57.
BSM answered
The expected aggregate quarterly distribution amounts disclosed throughout the Registration Statement include a full quarter of distributions for the quarter ending June 30, 2015. We have revised pages 57 and 58 of the Submission to include additional disclosure to clarify the basis for the expected aggregate quarterly distribution amounts disclosed on pages 57, 58, and 71 of the Registration Statement.
Black Stone Minerals Company, L.P. 1001 Fannin St., Suite 2020 Houston, TX 77002 Telephone: 713.658.0647 Facsimile: 713.658.0943
Read in the replyopen_in_new
Critical Accounting Policies and Related Estimates, page 96 · Successful Efforts Method of Accounting, page 96
SEC asked (5)
The revised disclosure provided in response to prior comment 8 states that a sustained low price environment could decrease your estimate of proved reserves. Please revise to provide additional disclosure addressing the uncertainty resulting from the recent decline in oil and gas prices.Rest of the question
Your revised disclosure should address the extent to which your estimates of proved reserves are reasonably likely to change in the future and provide quantitative disclosure to this effect. As part of your revised disclosure, please include information that reflects the potential impact of outcomes you deem reasonably likely to occur (e.g., the scenario where oil and gas prices do not recover from current levels in the near term). For additional guidance, refer to section V of SEC Release No. 33-8350.
Potential Payments Upon Termination or a Change in Control, page 141 · Severance Agreements, page 143
SEC asked (6)
Please disclose the material terms of your severance agreements for each of the named executive officers. See Item 402(q)(2) of Regulation S-K.
Security Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management, page 147
SEC asked (7)
Please revise footnote 4 to your tabular disclosure to clarify whether the units beneficially owned by Mr. Carter include those of Camden Energy Limited Partnership.
Unaudited Pro Forma Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-2 · Note 2 – Unaudited Pro Forma Adjustments and Assumptions, page F-7
SEC asked (8)
We note from the confidentially submitted materials dated April 15, 2015 that pro forma adjustment (d) includes multiple adjustments related to the issuance of common and subordinated units to existing unitholders of Black Stone Minerals Company, LP. Please provide separate disclosure and reconciliation, as appropriate, so that each adjustment is clearly explained.
Note 3 – Unaudited Pro Forma Net Income Per Unit, page F-7
SEC asked (9)
Please provide us with a reconciliation of the number of common units, subordinated units, and preferred units used to calculate pro forma earnings per share as provided in the confidentially submitted materials dated April 15, 2015.
BSM answered
We have revised pages F-6,
F-7, and F-8 of the Submission accordingly.
Black
Stone Minerals Company, L.P. 1001 Fannin St., Suite 2020 Houston, TX 77002 Telephone: 713.658.0647 Facsimile: 713.658.0943
Read in the replyopen_in_new