We agree that the accounting literature cited in your comment letter is the appropriate guidance that governs the accounting for our acquisition of Hillandale, LLC
(“Hillandale”). We also agree that the transfer of rights, risks, and rewards of ownership (“Ownership Rights”) is the key factor in determining the most appropriate accounting for the transaction.
Rest of the answer
In your comment letter, you cite specific instances in the acquisition agreement and in the
Hillandale operating agreement which indicate that certain Ownership Rights were not transferred to the Company until such time as the membership units were purchased. While we acknowledge that certain Ownership Rights were retained by the minority unit holders of Hillandale, we believe the intent of the agreement, as well as the operation of Hillandale subsequent to the acquisition date, resulted in effectively transferring all substantive Ownership
Rights of Hillandale to the Company as of July 28, 2005 (the “Acquisition
Date”). We considered this intent and actual operation of Hillandale subsequent to the acquisition in our decision to account for the transaction as a 100% purchase as of the Acquisition Date.
It may be useful to consider that our accounting treatment for the acquisition resulted in the Company recording a purchase commitment liability of $25,947 thousand as of the Acquisition Date compared to recording minority interest of $11,492 thousand had we accounted for the purchase under the step acquisition method. At the time of the Hillandale acquisition, we were in a cyclical downturn with no clear indications of when the industry would return to profitability. In addition, Hillandale was operating at a proportionately higher operating loss than the Company due to inefficiencies in
Hillandale’s operations. Although the accounting treatment we chose resulted in the least attractive balance sheet presentation and resulted in our recording 100% of the losses of Hillandale in our financial statements, we chose this method of accounting based upon our strong belief that it represented the substance of our arrangement with the sellers of Hillandale and because it was the most conservative treatment at the time of the acquisition.
While we believe our accounting for the acquisition most appropriately reflects the substance of the acquisition agreement, we acknowledge that the legal structure of the transaction has resulted in valid questions about when the transfer of certain Ownership Rights occurred. We have addressed in detail below under the
Transfer of Ownership Rights section why we believe the substantive Ownership
Rights were transferred to the Company on the Acquisition
Date. We have also included below under the Materiality
Analysis section an analysis of the impact on the Company’s historical balance sheets and statements of income of treating the Hillandale acquisition as a 100% purchase on the Acquisition Date rather than as a step acquisition.
In August
2009, the Company will make its payment for the final 12% of the membership units of Hillandale in accordance with the terms of the acquisition agreement.
At that time we will have legal ownership of 100% of the membership units. We have fully disclosed the methods we used to account for the acquisition in our annual filings on Form 10-K and quarterly filings on Form 10-Q since the acquisition in fiscal 2006. Considering the transparency of our disclosure of the transaction, the intent of our agreement to transfer substantially all
Ownership Rights on the Acquisition Date and the analysis of the impact of the step acquisition method of accounting on the historical financial statements, which is attached as Exhibit
I, we respectfully suggest that it would not be very meaningful to the users of the financial statements to restate our prior financial statements or to reflect any adjustments to the Hillandale accounting in the 2009 Form 10-K to be filed.
respectively request that you consider the information provided below in addition to the information provided in our previous letter in assessing the appropriateness of our accounting for the Hillandale acquisition.
Transfer of Ownership Rights
Background of the Deal
Structure
The
Company operates primarily in the fresh shell egg business. The shell egg industry is fragmented with many small producers that developed from family farms over the last 40 to 50 years. The Company started in the 1950s as Adams Foods. Our chairman is Fred Adams who started the
Company. He is still active in our business and was the primary negotiator for the Company in the Hillandale acquisition. We are the largest producer and marketer of shell eggs in the United States and the only publicly traded company in our industry. A key part of our strategy is to grow through acquisitions. We are known in the industry as an acquirer and have completed 16 acquisitions since 1989.
Jack
Hazen, who is in his late 70s, was one of the principal owners of the former
Hillandale companies and has been involved in the industry for over 40 years. He approached Mr. Adams about selling their business, which consisted of facilities located in Florida and Alabama, to the
Company. In fiscal 2006, when we made the Hillandale acquisition, the egg industry was in the middle of a cyclical downturn. The Company and
Hillandale each experienced significant net losses in their most recent fiscal year ending prior to the acquisition. The egg industry is cyclical with periods of tight supply and demand balance where we enjoy higher prices and stronger margins, usually followed by periods with excess supply and accompanying lower prices and reduced margins. Due to the depressed state of the industry, at the time of the acquisition, the Company was willing to pay, and
Mr. Hazen was willing to accept, a purchase price equal only to our estimate of the fair value of the tangible assets. In contrast our two acquisitions of
Florida companies in fiscal 2009 were at a premium over the fair value of the tangible assets. Jack Hazen proposed the structure of the cash settlement to the
Company as a way to help the Company finance the acquisition while we were in this downturn. The operation of this deferred payment mechanism would also allow the sellers to get a higher price for their business if there was an upturn in the industry. Accordingly, we acquired 51% of the membership units at closing with a commitment to purchase the remaining membership units on a regular schedule over four years. This structure required less up-front cash and the sellers would be able to receive a purchase price adjustment should the commodity environment improve. The adjustment was intended to reflect a possible increase in the value of the acquired
Hillandale assets, should conditions improve. It was not intended as an adjustment to reflect a share in the “risk and rewards” associated with ownership.
Your comment letter cited Section 6.2.3 of the purchase agreement and Article 10.01 and 10.03 of the Hillandale operating agreement as evidence that significant
Ownership Rights were retained by the sellers. While this cash settlement mechanism was in the form of a proportionate share of future earnings as outlined in Section 6.2.3 of the purchase agreement and Article 10.01 of the
Hillandale operating agreement, the intent, as outlined above, was to allow the sellers to be paid more for their business if markets improved, not to condition the transfer of the entire ownership interest. Article 10.03 provides for all distributions to be made to members in proportion to their respective ownership of membership units. Such distributions to the minority interest holders reduced the amount of the purchase obligation and accordingly had no impact on the total purchase price paid for Hillandale.
Management and Operation of
Hillandale management and operation of Hillandale subsequent to the acquisition date is consistent with our belief that all substantive Ownership Rights were transferred to the Company as of the Acquisition Date. The Company currently manages and operates 36 egg production facilities throughout the country. Each of those facilities is overseen by a general manger who reports to one of our five Vice-Presidents of Operations. Prior to the acquisition, Jack Hazen functioned as the Chief Executive Officer of the former Hillandale entities. Within a few months of our acquisition,
Mr. Hazen stepped down from daily operations and Bob Scott, our Regional
Vice-President of Operations, assumed control of the Hillandale facilities. In addition the chief operating manager and certain other members of management of the former Hillandale entities were dismissed within the first year of the acquisition.
Upon our acquisition of Hillandale, we began implementation of all of our production practices which we believe have made us successful and have allowed us to grow to be the largest egg producer in the United States. We have significantly improved key performance factors at Hillandale, such as feed conversion, that have helped to lower costs and make the Hillandale locations more profitable. We brought in new managers from our existing facilities to beef up the management team. We also have integrated the Hillandale production into our marketing program which has resulted in significant improvement in the average selling prices of product produced at the Hillandale facilities. We have conformed Hillandale’s accounting systems and controls to that of the Company’s other operations. In summary, we have operated the Hillandale locations as we have all of our wholly-owned facilities.
comment letter correctly pointed out that the purchase agreement provides that two of the five members of Hillandale’s board of directors be selected by and represent the minority holder of the Hillandale membership units until such time as the Company has acquired all of Hillandale’s outstanding membership units. As a practical matter, all operating, financing, accounting and marketing decisions related to Hillandale rested with the Company and the
Company’s board of directors. As such, we do not believe that the requirement in section 2.2 of the purchase agreement for the minority holders to have two members on the Hillandale board of directors or the requirement in
Article 7.10 of the Hillandale operating agreement requiring one vote for each unit of membership interest are determinative of substantive Ownership
Rights.
Financing of the
Acquisition
Another factor that is consistent with our belief that in essence we acquired 100% of the business on the acquisition date is our financing of this transaction. The Company and Hillandale were co-borrowers on a $28 million term loan secured by the assets of Hillandale for the financing of this transaction. Prior to returning to profitable operations, the Company also provided working capital to finance Hillandale’s cash flow needs through an intercompany line of credit. We believe it is important to note that the Company was liable as co-borrower for the $28 million loan and for working capital loans to Hillandale, while the other Hillandale unit holders had no actual or contingent obligations to make payments to Hillandale or to the
Company. As such, the Company was proportionately more at risk of loss than the minority holders of the Hillandale membership units. As stated in your comment letter, Article 9.03 and 13.03 of the Hillandale operating agreement provides for distribution of assets upon liquidation or dissolution based upon the proportionate ownership of membership units. As indicated above, the Company was proportionately more at risk than the minority holders of membership units due to the Company being a co-borrower on the $28 million term loan and providing an unsecured working capital line to
Hillandale. In addition, with the Company managing and operating
Hillandale consistent with all of its other facilities, the Company was committed to fund any working capital needs of Hillandale as it would any of its wholly-owned facilities until they returned to profitability. The likelihood of any liquidation or dissolution of Hillandale was remote.
In summary, while certain Ownership Rights were retained by the minority holders of
Hillandale membership units, we believe the substance of the acquisition as well as the subsequent operations of Hillandale support our belief that all substantive Ownership Rights were transferred to the Company on the Acquisition
Date, thus supporting our accounting treatment for financial reporting purposes.
Materiality
Analysis
We also reviewed the impact to the Company’s historical consolidated financial statements had the Company accounted for the Hillandale acquisition under the step acquisition method. Attached as Exhibit
I are unaudited pro forma consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of income as of and for the periods ended June 3, 2006, June 2, 2007,
May 31, 2008 and February 28, 2009 which include adjustments necessary to reflect the Hillandale acquisition under the step acquisition method of accounting.
In fiscal
2006, the egg industry continued to be in a cyclical downturn and the Company reported a near break even net loss. The pro forma adjustments would change the net loss in fiscal 2006 to a near break even net income, which we believe is immaterial to the consolidated financial statements in fiscal
2006. The pro forma adjustments would change operating income, income before income taxes, net income and net income per share by less than 5% of the respective totals for the periods ended June 2, 2007, May 31, 2008 and February 28, 2009, with the exception of net income and net income per share in fiscal 2008 which would change 7.9% and 7.8%, respectively. The pro forma adjustments are also less that 5% of total assets and shareholders’ equity as of June 3, 2006,
June 2, 2007, May 31, 2008 and February 28, 2009. Accordingly, we believe the impact of the pro forma adjustments is quantitatively immaterial to all key measures in the consolidated financial statements, with the exception of net income and net income per share for fiscal 2008.
considered qualitative factors in assessing the impact of the adjustments that would be necessary had we used the step acquisition method as follows:
pro forma adjustments would not materially change the earnings trend for the periods impacted. The Company experienced a cyclical upturn in its business in fiscal 2007 and 2008 primarily as the result of a tighter supply and demand balance. In fiscal 2008, the
Company’s operating income, income before income taxes and net income were more than double the amounts reported in any other previously reported annual period in the history of the Company. Accordingly, while the pro forma adjustments are quantitatively significant to fiscal 2008 net income, we do not believe the pro forma adjustments would have materially impacted the users of the consolidated financial statements due to the significance of earnings for the period in relation to historical earnings.
pro forma adjustments would not impact employee bonuses, debt covenant compliance or other significant contractual requirements for any of the periods presented.
Company does not provide earnings guidance due to the volatility in its earnings. Also, the Company did not have analyst coverage until fiscal 2009. Since analyst coverage began in fiscal 2009, the
Company’s results have been under the analysts’ earnings estimates.
upon the above quantitative and qualitative factors, we do not believe the accounting for the Hillandale acquisition as a step acquisition rather than as a
100% purchase on the Acquisition Date would have a significant impact on the users of the Company’s consolidated financial statements.