When an asset is retired in the normal course of business and the retirement was predicted by the
study for the relevant asset class CP will retire the gross book value of the asset by charging the historical cost, net of salvage, to accumulated depreciation. When CP can specifically identify the historical cost of the asset being retired, this gross book value is retired.
Rest of the answer
When the historical cost cannot be specifically identified, CP estimates the gross book value either by indexation, a first-in, first-out allocation or statistical curves to determine the age of retired property. By charging the retirement of the asset’s gross book value, net of salvage, to accumulated depreciation no gain or loss is recognized. This reflects the fact that when an asset is retired at the time it was predicted to be retired by the depreciation study, the group depreciation method has appropriately allocated the necessary depreciation expense to fully depreciate that asset to its expected salvage value. Any difference between expected and actual salvage value is recorded to accumulated depreciation.
In the event that there is a retirement or retirements that were not predicted by the depreciation study, group depreciation can and does accommodate recognition of the gain or loss through income. CP assesses asset retirements and when a retirement is not in the normal course of business, was not predicted in the depreciation study, and results in a material gain or loss that would distort the remaining net book value of the asset class, the gain or loss is recognized through income. The gain or loss is computed as the difference between the net proceeds and the net book value of the retired asset. The gross book value is retired as discussed above. As a portion of depreciation may be recorded to the specific asset and the remaining depreciation is recorded at the asset class level, upon retirement any asset specific accumulated depreciation as well as a cost-based allocation of the accumulated depreciation at the asset class level is retired. CP estimates the appropriate amount of the asset class level accumulated depreciation to retire considering the historical cost and years in service of the asset.
Commencing with our Form 10-Q for the first quarter of 2017, we will include the following disclosures. For your reference we have noted the changes from the annual disclosure presented in our Form 10-K through blackline.
CP depreciates the cost of properties, net of salvage, on a straight-line basis over the estimated useful life of the class of property. When depreciable property is retired or otherwise disposed of in the normal course of business, the book value, less net salvage proceeds, is charged to accumulated depreciation and if different than the assumptions under the depreciation study could potentially result in adjusted depreciation expense over a period of years. For certain asset classes, the historical cost of the asset is separately recorded in the Company’s property records. This amount is retired from the property records upon retirement of the asset. For assets for which the historical cost cannot be separately identified the amount of the gross book value to be retired is estimated using either an indexation methodology, whereby the current replacement cost of the asset is indexed to the estimated year of installation for the asset, or a first-in, first-out approach, or statistical analysis is used to determine the age of the retired asset. CP uses indices that closely correlate to the principal costs of the assets.
There are a number of estimates inherent in the depreciation and retirement processes and as it is not possible to precisely estimate each of these variables until a group of property is completely retired, CP regularly monitors the estimated service lives of assets and the associated accumulated depreciation for each asset class to ensure depreciation rates are appropriate. If the recorded amounts of accumulated depreciation are greater or less than the amounts indicated by the depreciation studies then the excess or deficit is amortized as a component of depreciation expense over the remaining service lives of the applicable asset classes.
For the sale or retirement of larger groups of depreciable assets that are unusual and were not considered in the Company’s depreciation studies, CP records a gain or loss for the difference between net proceeds and net book value of the assets sold or retired. The accumulated depreciation to be retired includes asset specific accumulated depreciation, when known, and an appropriate portion of the accumulated depreciation recorded for the relevant asset class as a whole, calculated using a cost-based allocation.
Revisions to the estimated useful lives and net salvage projections constitute a change in accounting estimate and are addressed prospectively by amending depreciation rates. It is anticipated that there will be changes in the estimates of weighted average useful lives and net salvage for each property asset class as assets are acquired, used and retired. Substantial changes in either the useful lives of properties or the salvage assumptions could result in significant changes to depreciation expense. For example, if the estimated average life of road locomotives track assets, including rail, ties, ballast and other track material the largest asset group, increased (or decreased) by 5% one year, annual depreciation expense would decrease (or increase) by approximately $36 million.