Form 10-K
We note your disclosure that DraftKings Marketplace "is a digital collectibles (nonfungible token or “NFT”) ecosystem designed for mainstream accessibility that offers curated initial NFT drops (“Primary Sales”). In addition to Primary Sales, owners of NFTs on Marketplace can list their NFTs for sale to other Marketplace customers (“Secondary Sales”).Rest of the question
The revenue that the Company earns from Marketplace is primarily based on a specific percentage of the gross value of each Primary Sale or Secondary Sale." Your website also indicates that you are actively engaging in primary sales and facilitating secondary sales of NFTs. In connection with such activities, please: • Provide proposed disclosure that includes a materially complete description of your Marketplace, including identifying the underlying protocol, and the NFTs that are listed and traded on your Marketplace, and clarify who creates the NTFs; and • Explain to us how your Marketplace operates with respect to NFTs and your role in it. In this regard, describe in greater detail the services the Marketplace provides, both in the creation of the NFTs and the subsequent listing and trading of the NFTs on your platform, and how prices are set in primary and resale transactions.
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that additional disclosure in future annual and periodic reports filed with the Commission regarding Marketplace would, at this point and for the foreseeable future, not be material to investors in the Company’s securities. For the year ended December 31, 2022 and the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company earned net revenues of $2.24 billion and $2.43 billion, respectively, of which Marketplace comprised approximately one-half of one percent (0.50%), or less, of net revenues in each period.Read in the replyRest of the answer
As disclosed in the 2022 Annual Report, the vast majority of the Company’s revenue comes from online gaming, which includes online Sportsbook, iGaming, and DFS product offerings—none of which include Marketplace. Although the Company believes that additional disclosure regarding Marketplace, beyond that which is included in its 2022 Annual Report, would not be material for investors in its securities, the Company respectfully advises the Staff as follows:
During the third quarter of 2021, the Company launched
Marketplace, a platform through which Marketplace customers can purchase NFTs from the Company and third parties and purchase NFTs from, and sell NFTs to, other Marketplace customers. Only the Company’s current account holders can buy or sell NFTs on Marketplace.
As described in the Company’s 2022 Annual Report:
Marketplace is a NFT ecosystem designed for mainstream accessibility that offers curated initial NFT drops (“Primary Sales”) and allows owners of NFTs on Marketplace to list their NFTs for sale to other Marketplace customers (“Secondary Sales”). Once marked for sale with a chosen selling price, the NFT will appear on the Marketplace secondary market. Customers can browse all available NFTs within the secondary market and can opt to purchase based on the selling price. The revenue we earn on Primary Sales and Secondary Sales is based on a specific percentage of the gross value of each such sale.
(2022 Annual Report, at 5.) Initially, NFTs available on
Marketplace (“Marketplace NFTs”) were linked to static or animated collectible images or physical cards, most of which are of professional athletes (“Collectible NFTs”). Some Collectible NFTs are linked to intellectual property created by third parties (“Third-Party Collectible NFTs”), while other Collectible NFTs are linked to intellectual property created by the Company (“DraftKings Collectible NFTs”).1 The Company provides certain services to these third parties—such as minting and custody services—and receives a license from these third parties to facilitate the sales of the Third-Party Collectible NFTs on Marketplace.
1 One third party that licenses intellectual property linked to Third-Party Collectible NFTs is LFG NFTS, Corp. (“Autograph”). As disclosed in the Company’s definitive proxy statements for its 2022 and 2023 annual meetings, the Company is party to a commercial agreement with Autograph and certain of the Company’s directors and executive officers serve on the board of advisors of, and/or have invested in equity securities of,
Autograph.
In May 2022, the Company launched “Reignmakers” a fantasy sports-style contest of skill (“Reignmakers Contests”). Reignmakers contestants use NFT player cards that are minted by the Company and sold on Marketplace or occasionally given away by the Company to customers through promotions. Contestants use these NFT cards to build a lineup of real-world athletes and then compete against each other in Reignmakers Contests. Each NFT card represents a real-world athlete who accrues fantasy points based on that athlete’s statistical performance in a given event or game. We refer to NFTs used or available in connection with Reignmakers Contests as “Reignmakers NFTs.” Initially,
Reignmakers NFTs featured players from the National Football League Players’ Association. In early 2023, the Company began offering
Reignmakers NFTs and Reignmakers Contests for two other professional sports. Reignmakers NFTs represented approximately 93% and 99% of
Marketplace NFTs transacted on Marketplace since inception and for the year ended December 31, 2023, respectively.
Both types of Marketplace NFTs—Collectible NFTs and
Reignmakers NFTs—are minted by the Company on a public blockchain developed by Polygon Labs (“Polygon”), which is an unaffiliated commercial counter-party of the Company, and recorded on its public ledger.2 The Polygon blockchain serves as a distributed and decentralized ledger for a multitude of digital asset projects and applications built by a variety of entities.
Minting an NFT on the Polygon blockchain serves as a certificate of authenticity.
DraftKings Collectible NFTs and Reignmakers NFTs are sold by the Company in Primary Sales. Third-Party Collectible NFTs are sold in Primary Sales by the third party. The Company is not a party to the Primary Sales of Third-Party Collectible NFTs. Reignmakers NFTs are sold to Marketplace customers in Primary Sales by the Company primarily in digital packs of multiple NFTs. In some cases, Reignmakers NFTs are given away by the Company to Marketplace customers in promotions or as prizes. After the Primary Sale, both Collectible NFTs and Reignmakers NFTs are generally available for purchase and sale in Secondary Sales between customers in Marketplace. Once marked for sale with a selling price established by the seller (subject to a de minimis price floor set by the Company), the NFT appears on the Marketplace secondary market. Customers can browse all available Marketplace NFTs within the secondary market and can opt to purchase based on the selling price. The Company does not buy or sell Marketplace NFTs in the secondary market.
While approximately 99.999% of Marketplace NFTs were minted on the Polygon blockchain, the remaining 0.001% of Marketplace
NFTs were minted by the Company on Ethereum, which are disregarded as immaterial for purposes of this discussion.
Collectible NFTs and Reignmakers NFTs are held in the Company’s omnibus digital asset wallet and ownership is tracked using the Company’s internal ledger. Collectible NFTs can be removed by the customer from the Company’s digital asset wallet into the customer’s own digital wallet with the Company’s permission.
Third-Party Collectible NFTs may be removed only if allowed by the licensing agreement with the third party that licenses the intellectual property linked to the Marketplace NFT. The revenue the Company earns on Secondary Sales and Third-Party Collectible NFT Primary Sales is based on a specific percentage of the gross value of each such sale.
Provide us with your legal analysis that such NFTs sold on your Marketplace are not securities under Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act of 1933 and, therefore, you are not facilitating, or causing you to engage in, transactions in unregistered securities. In responding to this comment, please address your operation of the Marketplace. See Gary Plastic Packaging Corp. v.Rest of the question
Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc., 756 F.2d 230 (2d Cir. 1985).
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that the federal securities laws define “security” to include, in addition to the more common forms of securities such as stocks and bonds,Read in the reply
“any investment contract.” See 15 U.S.C. §§ 77b(a)(1) & 78c(a)(10). Marketplace NFTs—both Collectible
NFTs and Reignmakers NFTs—are not securities because they are not “investment contracts” under Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act. 15 U.S.C. § 78b(a)(1). The Supreme Court held in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co.Rest of the answer
that “a particular financial instrument constitutes an investment contract (and, hence, a security)” only if it “comprises (1) the investment of money (2) in a common enterprise (3) with an expectation of profits to be derived solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party.” SEC v. SG Ltd., 265 F.3d. 42, 46 (1st Cir. 2001) (citing SEC v. W.J. Howey Co.,
328 U.S. 293, 298-99 (1946)).
As the Staff may be aware, in March 2023, a litigation was filed in federal district court in Massachusetts alleging, among other things, that NFTs bought or sold on Marketplace constitute securities that were required to be, but were not, registered with the Commission in accordance with federal and Massachusetts law, and that Marketplace is a securities exchange that is not registered as required by federal and Massachusetts law (the “Massachusetts Litigation”).
The Company has moved to dismiss the Massachusetts Litigation, asserting, among other things, that Marketplace NFTs do not qualify as investment contracts under the Howey test. As more fully set forth in that motion, at a minimum, Marketplace NFTs fail both the second and third prongs of the Howey test for the following reasons.
Common Enterprise:
Most courts assess whether the purchase of a particular instrument constitutes an investment in a “common enterprise” by examining whether there is “horizontal commonality” among purchasers—i.e., whether the promoter “pools” contributions “from multiple investors so that all share in the profits and risks of the enterprise.” SG Ltd., 265 F.3d. at 49. Some courts also consider whether there is
“vertical commonality” between the purchasers and the promoter. See, e.g., Brodt v. Bache & Co., Inc.,
595 F.2d 459, 461 (9th Cir.1978). “Strict” vertical commonality requires “that the investors’ fortunes be interwoven with and dependent upon the efforts and success of those seeking the investment or of third parties.” SG Ltd., 265 F.3d.
at 49 (internal quotation marks omitted).3 Marketplace NFTs satisfy none of these standards.
The Company does not “pool” the proceeds of Marketplace NFT sales for the benefit of purchasers. In contrast to the matters where the Commission has deemed other NFTs to constitute securities, among other things, Marketplace was built before any NFTs were sold, and the Company does not devote any net proceeds to develop or promote Marketplace or Marketplace NFTs.4 Marketplace is only a small part of the Company’s business, which the Company believes is not material for investors in its securities, as noted in response to Comment 1, and like any other revenues, the Company deploys revenues earned from sales of Marketplace NFTs across its operations as it sees fit. Cf., SG
Ltd., 265 F.3d at 50 (finding pooling to be satisfied when funds were “pooled in a single account used to settle participants’ on-line transactions”). Moreover, a Marketplace NFT does not give its owner a participatory interest in the Company, Marketplace, or any other enterprise. See Hocking v. Dubois, 839 F.2d 560, 566 (9th Cir. 1988), adhered to on reh’g, 885 F.2d 1449 (9th Cir. 1989) (no horizontal commonality where investors do not “pool their investments together and split the net profits and losses in accordance with their pro rata investments”). A Marketplace NFT also does not provide its owner voting rights in the Company or a right to receive dividends from the Company.
Marketplace NFTs are unique digital assets with utility as collectibles, in the case of Collectible NFTs, and utility as game pieces in Reignmakers Contests, in the case of Reignmakers NFTs.
Any value that Marketplace NFTs have is a function of these utilities as well as other factors beyond the Company’s control, including the popularity and real-world performance of athletes and supply and demand forces. The value of any Marketplace NFT fluctuates in accordance with its utility, which may be more or less than the purchase price at any given time. Thus, commonality is absent because, among other things, the fortunes of each Marketplace NFT purchaser is independent of the fortunes of other purchasers. See Revak, 18 F.3d at 88 (holding that horizontal commonality was lacking where, as here, an individual purchaser may “make profits or sustain losses independent of the fortunes of other purchasers”). Indeed, purchasers of Reignmakers NFTs (which represented approximately 93% and 99% of Marketplace NFTs transacted on Marketplace since inception and for the year ended December 31, 2023, respectively) compete against one another in Reignmakers Contests. Thus, the fortunes of any Reignmakers NFT owner is primarily determined by his or her success or failure in Reignmakers Contests.
A minority of courts apply a “broad” vertical commonality test. Broad vertical commonality is established where the “investor’s fortunes are tied to the promoter’s success.” Id. But many courts reject this approach because it “effectively merge[s] into a single inquiry” the “two separate questions posed by Howey—whether a common enterprise exists and whether the investors’ profits are to be derived solely from the efforts of others.” Revak v. SEC Realty Corp., 18 F.3d 81, 88 (2d Cir. 1994). In any event, Marketplace NFTs do not satisfy the broad vertical commonality standard for the same reasons, described below, that Marketplace NFTs do not satisfy the third prong of the Howey test.
4 Substantial portions of any revenues from Marketplace NFT sales are paid in license fees to the licensors that own the intellectual property embodied in the Marketplace NFT, and as prizes in Reignmakers Contests.
For these reasons, among others, each Marketplace NFT purchaser’s fortunes are also independent of the fortunes of the Company or Marketplace. See Marini v. Adamo, 812 F. Supp. 2d 243,
256 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) (“[S]trict vertical commonality exists where there is a ‘one-to-one relationship between the investor and investment manager’ such that there is ‘an interdependence of both profits and losses of the investment.’”);
Copeland v. Hill, 680 F. Supp. 466, 468 (D. Mass. 1988) (For horizontal commonality, “[t]he fortunes of each investor must be intertwined with the success of the pool.”). The Company collects fees from sales of Marketplace NFTs even when purchasers sell their NFTs at a loss. See Austin v. Bradley, Barry & Tarlow, P.C., 1992 WL 560915, at *7 (D. Mass. June 17,
1992) (plaintiffs “failed to demonstrate strict vertical commonality” because neither the company’s annual fee nor its percentage-based commissions were “inherently contingent upon the plaintiffs’ potential profits or losses.”). And the value of any particular NFT, or NFTs generally, has no correlation to the success of the Company or the Marketplace.
Reasonable Expectation of Profits to Be Derived from the Managerial Efforts of Others:
For an instrument to qualify as an investment contract, purchasers must be led by the promoter to reasonably expect to profit on the success of the common enterprise through earnings participation or capital appreciation derived from the “significant” and “essential” managerial efforts of the promoter (or some other third party). SG Ltd., 265 F.3d at 53-55. “These situations are to be contrasted with transactions in which an individual purchases a commodity for personal use or consumption.” Id. at 53.
The Company does not promote Marketplace NFTs as a means to invest in the Company or its Marketplace. Far from “being promoted primarily as an investment,” SEC v. Aqua-Sonic
Prod. Corp., 687 F.2d 577, 582 (2d Cir. 1982), Marketplace NFTs are marketed as collectibles and game pieces. See Bronstein v. Bronstein, 407 F. Supp. 925, 930 (E.D. Pa. 1976) (distinguishing ventures with “an eye towards personal use or consumption of the underlying interest” from those with “the purpose of acquiring an interest in a profit-making venture”). In fact, the Company told purchasers that Reignmakers NFTs naturally would decline in value as their utility declined and the associated professional sports season progressed. The Company also does not promise any managerial efforts to generate profits for Marketplace NFT purchasers. See SEC v. Life Partners, Inc., 87 F.3d 536, 545 (D.C. Cir. 1996) (third prong of Howey test satisfied only where investment profits are derived from the efforts of others). Again, whether or not Reignmakers NFT purchasers profit is entirely dependent on how they make use of their Reignmakers NFTs, not on the Company’s efforts. See Aqua-Sonic Prod. Corp., 687
F.2d at 585 (“If, by contrast, the reasonable expectation was one of significant investor control, a reasonable purchaser could be expected to make his own investigation of the new business” without the protections of the securities laws.).
Marketplace NFTs also are not securities under Gary
Plastic:
The existence of the Marketplace does not transform Marketplace
NFTs into securities under Gary Plastic Packaging Corp. v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Inc., 756 F.2d 230,
240 (2d Cir. 1985). Gary Plastic did not announce any novel rule of law, but reversed the grant of summary judgment finding that the certificates of deposit (CDs) at issue were not securities because it was “difficult to discern if there is merit to plaintiff’s claims against these defendants.” 756 F.2d at 232. The court found that, although insured CDs typically were not securities, a program designed by a broker-dealer to create a separate “negotiable bearer form” and “liquid” interest in the underlying CDs could constitute a security. The court reasoned that all investor funds were pooled for purposes of acquiring the underlying
CDs, and a common enterprise existed by virtue of activity “significantly greater than that of an ordinary broker or sales agent,” including “investigating issuers, marketing the CDs, and creating a secondary market” for the interests in the CDs, and the sharing of profits through apportionment of the interest paid. Gary Plastic at 240. Furthermore, in Gary Plastic, the investment was “motivated by the expectation of a return of cash investment, the potential for price appreciation,” and the “skill and financial stability” of the promotor, its “implicit promise to maintain its marketing efforts,” and its “ongoing monitoring of the issuing banks.” Id. at 240-241.5
Gary
Plastic is entirely consistent with the discussion above demonstrating that Marketplace NFTs are not securities. Among other things:
· Reignmakers
NFTs are marketed as game pieces for use in Reignmakers Contests. Collectible NFTs are marketed as collectibles.
· The proceeds from Marketplace NFT sales and transaction fees are not pooled in any NFT “enterprise,” and the Company has not devoted any net proceeds to develop or promote Marketplace or Marketplace
NFTs.
Company does not share in the profits or losses of any Marketplace NFT purchaser.
· Although the Company created the secondary sale Marketplace, unlike Gary Plastic it did not promise any level of liquidity or to maintain the Marketplace, Gary Plastic at 233.
Also, the secondary market in Gary Plastic “would enable [purchasers] to sell their [CDs] back to” the promotor, which left the entire selling point of the investment—CD liquidity—dependent upon the promotor. Gary Plastic at 233,
241.
· For each underlying CD in Gary Plastic, the insured was the promotor, not the investor, so the availability of the promised FDIC insurance protection depended entirely upon the future efforts of the promotor. There is no promise by the Company of any managerial efforts to evaluate or manage NFTs, generate profits for NFT purchasers or expectation of investment return from Marketplace NFTs.
· Contrary to promoting
Marketplace NFTs for profit, the Company informed potential purchasers that the value of all Reignmakers NFTs would decline during the sports season for the applicable
Reignmakers Contests.
5 Following remand, the Gary Plastic district court denied class certification because the plaintiff likely did not rely on the defendants’ marketing statements, and the case was later dismissed for failure to prosecute, which was affirmed by the Second Circuit. Gary Plastic Packaging Corp. v. Merrill
Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc., 903 F.2d 176, 177 (2d Cir. 1990).
Accordingly, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that because, among other reasons, Marketplace NFTs are not associated with a common enterprise and there is no reasonable expectation of profits derived from the managerial efforts of others, Marketplace NFTs are not investment contracts under the Howey test, including as applied in Gary Plastic, and accordingly are not securities under federal or state securities laws.
Please provide proposed disclosure that includes a description of your internal processes for how you determine, or will determine as you expand your business, whether the NFTs listed and traded on your Marketplace are securities within the meaning of the U.S. federal securities laws.Rest of the question
Please also clarify that such processes are risk-based assessments made by the company and are not a legal standard or binding on any regulatory body or court. Further, please include a risk factor addressing the uncertainty of such assessments and the consequences of making an incorrect assessment or a regulatory body or court disagreeing with the company’s assessment. Finally, please address the potential regulatory risks under the U.S. federal securities laws if such NFTs are determined to be securities, such as compliance with Section 5 of the Securities Act or whether the company could become subject to regulation as a national securities exchange or as a broker-dealer under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Only Marketplace NFTs described above are available for sale on Marketplace. No other NFTs and no fungible digital assets are available on Marketplace. The Company has recently discontinuedRead in the reply
Primary Sales of Collectible NFTs and does not intend to open the Marketplace more broadly to other NFTs or fungible digital assets.
As discussed in response to Comments 1 and 2 above, the Company does not believe that Marketplace represents a significant portion of its business that is material to investors nor that Marketplace NFTs are securities for purposes of the federal or state securitiesRest of the answer
laws.
Nevertheless, the Company included a discussion of the Massachusetts Litigation in Note 12. Leases, Commitments and Contingencies to its unaudited financial statements for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023, filed with the Commission as part of its interim report on Form 10-Q for those periods. In addition, with respect to the risks associated with the Company’s determination that Marketplace NFTs are not securities, the Company intends to include additional risk factor disclosure in its annual report on Form 10-K for the year ending December 31, 2023, substantially as set forth in the draft text in Annex A.
We note your response to prior comment 1, particularly your view that information about the Marketplace would, at this point and for the foreseeable future, not be material to investors in your securities. You supported this view with quantitative information, but did not address materiality in qualitative terms. Please tell us why you believe the information about the Marketplace is not qualitatively material.Rest of the question
In addition, for Collectible NFTs, please tell us the breakdown of the percentage of Collectible NFTs created by you and separately by the third parties. Additionally, please tell us the names of the third parties that are linked to the Third-Party Collectible NFTs, and tell us which services, minting and/or custody services, you provide to each such third-party and the estimated value of payments that you receive in connection with providing such services. With respect to the Reignmakers NFTs, which we note make up approximately 99% of your Marketplace NFTs for the year ended December 31, 2023, please state whether such NFTs were minted by you, while you were a validator for Polygon. If you did not mint such NFTs, please identify the party that minted them. In that light, we note your statements that “[m]inting an NFT on the Polygon blockchain serves as a certificate of authenticity” and that Polygon is an “unaffiliated commercial counter-party of the Company.” To the extent there are or were conflicts of interest between you and Polygon, please state as much, including any previous relationship you had as a validator for Polygon and any payment, fees, or incentives that you received from Polygon. Finally, with respect to Primary Sales by the Company, please explain in further detail how you price Collectible NFTs and Reignmakers NFTs, both individually and in digital pack of multiple NFTs. For secondary sales, please explain how you set the de minimis price floor. Explain in further detail the revenue you earn on Secondary Sales and Third- Party Collectible NFT Primary Sales.
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that it believes additional disclosure regarding Marketplace would not be material—on a quantitative or qualitative basis—to investors in the Company’s securities. The Company created Marketplace in connection with its mission to invest in and launch new product innovations to responsibly create the best real-money games and betting experiences. In this context, the 2022 AnnualRead in the reply
Report provided appropriate disclosure regarding Marketplace’s operations and stage of development as an example of the
Company’s continuous product innovation.Rest of the answer
Another example cited in the 2022 Annual Report is the expansion of our iGaming product offering which is a more significant source of revenue than Marketplace, which as noted in the Company’s First
Response Letter, represented one-half of one percent (0.50%), or less, of the Company’s net revenues for both the year ended
December 31, 2022 and the nine months ended September 30, 2023. Simply put, the Company believes its investors are focused on the growth and performance of its core online gaming product offerings (online Sportsbook, iGaming, and DFS), together with its ability to innovate and launch new product offerings over time, some but not all of which are likely to become significant to the Company or its investors in the future.
To the extent that the Company’s determination that
Marketplace NFTs are not securities involves risk and uncertainty that could become qualitatively material, the Company intends to include the additional risk factor disclosure noted in Annex A to the First Response Letter in its annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended
December 31, 2023 (the “2023 Annual Report”). Nevertheless, the Company believes the disclosure in the 2022 Annual
Report presents the information that a reasonable investor would have considered important when making an investment decision or voting decision with respect to the Company’s securities. See TSC Indus., Inc. v. Northway, Inc., 426 U.S. 438, 449 (1976).
The Company believes that that disclosure, when supplemented with the additional risk factor disclosure requested by the Staff and set out in Annex A to the First Response Letter, for the 2023 Annual Report will continue to satisfy that standard.
In addition, responses to the Staff’s other questions in Comment 1 of the Second Comment Letter are set forth below:
A. Additional Information on Collectible NFTs
As noted in the First Response Letter, Collectible NFTs comprise a small portion of Marketplace NFT transactions, with Reignmakers NFTs comprising 93% and 99% of Marketplace NFTs transacted since inception and for the year ended December 31, 2023, respectively. Focusing on Collectible NFTs, since inception through December
31, 2023, 83% of Collectible NFTs were linked to intellectual property created by third parties, which we refer to as Third-Party Collectible
NFTs. The Company created the remaining 17% of Collectible NFTs, which we refer to as DraftKings Collectible NFTs. The creators of Third-Party
Collectible NFTs are LFG NFTS, Corp. (d/b/a Autograph), I Got It Holdings Corp. (d/b/a Metabilia), The Aoki Milkshake Company, LLC, and MegaVolt Corp. (d/b/a SupDucks) (collectively, “Third-Party Collectible NFT Creators”).
The Company minted all of the Collectible NFTs and, as noted in the Company’s First Response Letter, provides custody and other services to Third-Party Collectible NFT Creators. These services include maintenance and provision of accounts to hold Third-Party Collectible NFTs, primary and secondary sales on Marketplace, services relating to tracking primary and secondary sales on Marketplace, and, in some but not all cases, account linking services, API access, marketing and, where allowed by the agreement with the Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator and the Company, withdrawal of the Third-Party
Collectible NFT to a wallet outside of Marketplace. The Company does not receive separate compensation from Third-Party Collectible NFT
Creators for these services. The Company retains a service fee equal to an agreed-upon percentage of the gross revenues from each Primary
Sale of Third-Party Collectible NFTs, and the Company receives a processing fee equal to 5% of all Secondary Sale of Third-Party Collectible
NFTs, which is described under the first bullet of Item D below.
In connection with Primary Sales and Secondary Sales of Third-Party Collectible NFTs, the Company recognized revenue from customers of approximately $1.1 million for the year ended December 31, 2022 and $20 thousand for the nine months ended September 30, 2023, in each case net of royalty and other payments to Third-Party Collectible NFT Creators. The Company remitted to Third-Party Collectible NFT Creators royalties and other payments in respect of Primary Sales and Secondary Sales of approximately $6.4 million for the year ended December
31, 2022 and $38 thousand for the nine months ended September 30, 2023. As noted in the First Response Letter, the Company has discontinued
Primary Sales of Collectible NFTs.
B. Additional Information on Reignmakers NFTs and the Company’s Relationship with Polygon
The Company does not believe any conflicts of interest exist between the Company and Polygon Labs or its affiliates. As discussed in the First Response Letter, Polygon Labs is the developer of the
Polygon blockchain and is not an affiliate of the Company. As discussed below, the Company minted Marketplace NFTs before it began operating a validator node on the Polygon blockchain and has continued to mint Marketplace NFTs after it ceased operating a validator node on the
Polygon blockchain. The MATIC tokens (the native token of the Polygon blockchain) that the Company owns do not benefit from purchases or sales of Reignmakers NFTs on Marketplace.
The Company began minting Marketplace NFTs on the Polygon blockchain in August 2021. Also, in August 2021, the Company signed an agreement (“Agreement”) with Matic Network BVI
LTD (“Matic Network”), which the Company understands is an affiliate of Polygon Labs. Under the Agreement, the Company purchased 2.5 million MATIC. In addition, under the Agreement, Matic Network committed to delegate 50 million MATIC for two years to a validator node operated by the Company, if the Company commenced operating a validator node on the Polygon blockchain. Under the
Agreement, Matic Network agreed that the Company could retain all validator rewards that would accrue for operating the validator node.
On February 3, 2022, the Company, using a third-party service provider, commenced operating a validator node on the Polygon blockchain and subsequently received the delegation of 50 million MATIC from Matic Network. In September 2022, the Company was delegated an additional 10 million MATIC by Matic Network in connection with an amendment to the Agreement. All delegations of MATIC were set to expire on the earlier of (x) February 29, 2024 or (y) when the Company ceased operating a validator node. On October 19, 2023, the Company ceased operating a validator node on the Polygon blockchain and accordingly all delegations of MATIC to the Company’s validator node expired on that date. After the Company ceased operating a validator node, it continued to mint Reignmakers NFTs on the Polygon blockchain.
During the period that the Company operated a validator node for the Polygon blockchain, the Company could cast one vote in Polygon blockchain governance matters, like any other operator of a validator node (regardless of the amount of its delegated MATIC). Based on publicly available information, there are approximately 100 validators on the Polygon network. As one vote among approximately 100 validators with equal voting rights, the Company neither exercised nor possessed any meaningful governance rights in respect of Polygon or MATIC in its capacity as a validator for the Polygon network.
As of September 30, 2023, the Company owned approximately 7.7 million MATIC and had been delegated approximately 60 million MATIC, which is less than 2% of the aggregate MATIC staked to all validators (3,602,360,611) as of January 31, 2024. The Company’s MATIC holdings of 7.7 million as of
September 30, 2023 represent less than 0.1% of the approximately 9.6 billion MATIC in circulation (including delegated MATIC) as of January 31, 2024. Since it began operating a validator node for the Polygon blockchain, the Company has earned approximately 6.2 million MATIC in the aggregate, as of September 30, 2023. The Company expects to begin operating a validator node for Polygon blockchain through a third party again in the future.
C. Additional Information on Pricing – Primary Sales
Additional information with respect to the pricing of each of the categories of Primary Sales is set forth below:
· Primary Sales of Reignmakers NFTs – The vast majority of Reignmakers
NFT Primary Sales are sold in multi-card packs. Primary Sale prices for Reignmakers NFT packs are set based on the Company’s internal models for the expected value of Reignmakers contests, which implies a fair market value of each tier of Reignmakers NFT based on its expected utility in such contest. Since each Reignmakers NFT represents a real-world athlete who accrues fantasy points in Reignmakers contests based on that athlete’s actual statistical performance in a given real-world event or game, players and positions will have different statistical utility. For example, an NFL quarterback is more likely to earn fantasy points than a back-up kicker or defensive end in Reignmakers contests. For Reignmakers NFTs sold in packs, the Company aggregates the fair market value of cards at each utility tier and distributes these cards into packs, which are then sold at a fixed price per pack based on the expected value of all packs sold for a particular Reignmakers contest. This pricing is adjusted for the number of cards in the pack, whether the pack is guaranteed to include particular utility tiers, the overall expected prizes (or prizes remaining) and promotional incentives. Over the course of a season as contest prizes have already occurred, the value of Reignmakers NFTs on Marketplace declines and as a result, the
Company adjusts pack pricing commensurate with the market activity. Reignmakers NFTs are also distributed in a variety of other ways, including at auction in a Primary Sale or given away as prizes or promotions.
· Primary Sales of Third-Party Collectible NFTs – Prices for Primary
Sales of Third-Party Collectible NFTs are set by the Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator in consultation with the Company or as mutually agreed upon by the Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator and the Company.
· Primary Sales of DraftKings Collectible NFTs – Prices for Primary
Sales of DraftKings Collectible NFTs are set by the Company based on expected demand and the value of any other benefits provided to customers holding the DraftKings Collectible NFT (e.g., DK Dollars, loyalty bonuses, etc.).
D. Additional Information on Revenue and Secondary Sales Price Floor.
Additional information with respect to the Company’s transaction-based revenues and the price floor for Secondary Sales is set forth below:
· Revenue from Collectible NFT Primary Sales and Secondary Sales
– In general, the Company retains a service fee equal to a specified agreed-upon percentage of the gross selling price of a
Third-Party Collectible NFT in a Primary Sale, and remits the remainder to the Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator. The Company retains all proceeds from a Primary Sale of DraftKings Collectible NFTs. In a Collectible NFT Secondary Sale, the Company earns a processing fee equal to a specified percentage of the gross selling price. For a Third-Party Collectible NFT Secondary Sale, the Company also collects and pays to the Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator a royalty fee for each such Secondary Sale that is specified by the
Third-Party Collectible NFT Creator.
· Revenue from Reignmakers NFT Primary Sales and Secondary Sales –
The Company receives the proceeds from Primary Sales and earns a processing fee equal to a fixed percentage of the gross selling price in Secondary Sales of Reignmakers NFTs. In each case, the licensor of the Reignmakers NFT content receives royalties on the Primary Sales and Secondary Sales equal to a percentage of the revenues, subject to certain minimum guaranteed royalties.
· Secondary Sale Price Floor – Secondary Sales on Marketplace are subject to a price floor of $0.20 per transaction (before August 2022, it was $1), which is intended to defray the costs incurred by the Company in operating and maintaining Marketplace for Secondary Sales. The Company does not participate in Secondary Sales.
We note your response to prior comment 2. While we do not have any further comments at this time regarding your responses, please confirm your understanding that our decision not to issue additional comments should not be interpreted to mean that we either agree or disagree with your responses, including any conclusions you have made, positions you have taken and practices you have engaged in or may engage in withRest of the question
respect to this matter, including in regards to any NFTs or other crypto assets that you may develop or mint in the future or that you may support or facilitate the minting or trading of in the future.
The Company understands that your decision not to issue additional comments in response to prior Comment 2 should not be interpreted to mean that the Staff either agree or disagree with our response to Comment 2 in the First Response Letter.Read in the reply
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-02-12