The Company’s operating segments, each of which consists of a legal subsidiary (or in limited cases, the combination of two or more subsidiaries), totaled 30 segments in fiscal 2013. These 30 operating segments provided specialty contracting services on a decentralized basis predominantly to customers in the telecommunications industry. Each of our operating segments’ presidents report directly to Dycom’s Chief Operating Officer (“COO”). Dycom’s COO reports directly to Dycom’s Chief Executive Officer, who is the chief operating decision maker (“CODM”).
Rest of the answer
There are not any geographic or functional management structures between the operating segments and Dycom’s COO. Additionally, no detailed financial information is prepared by the Company to summarize its operating segments by geographic or other functional measures. Further, during fiscal 2013 the Company acquired substantially all of the telecommunications subsidiaries of Quanta Services, Inc. The nature of business, services, customers, methods and industry environment for these newly acquired subsidiaries are the same as Dycom’s existing operating segments and the Company’s reporting and organization structure did not change as a result of the acquisition.
The Company has aggregated its operating segments into one reportable segment based on their similar economic characteristics, along with consideration of the other criteria of ASC Topic 280 including: (a) the nature of the products and services; (b) the nature of the production processes; (c) the type or class of customer for their products and services; (d) the methods used to distribute their products or provide their services; and (e) the nature of the regulatory environment. The Company has more fully described each of these areas and management’s consideration of the aggregation criteria, including the evaluation of key qualitative and quantitative metrics.
Background information regarding our operating segments is noted below:
All of our operating segments provide services to one or more customers in the telecommunications industry. During fiscal 2013, nearly 90% of revenue was from telecommunications customers. To a lesser extent, the operating segments also provide similar services to electric and gas utility and other customers.
Revenues from Dycom’s Top 10 customers, who were all in the telecommunications industry, for fiscal 2013 were approximately 74%. Substantially all of the operating segments have worked for at least one of Dycom’s Top 10 customers.
There were more than 75 common customers between the operating segments (individual customers that contracted with more than one of Dycom’s operating segments). Each of Dycom’s Top 5 customers generated revenues for 10 or more of the operating segments. One of the Top 5 customers generated revenues in over two-thirds of the 30 operating segments.
Many of the operating segments subcontract from sister operating segments when additional labor crews are needed in specific areas. For fiscal 2013, there were over 60 arrangements between sister operating segments to perform subcontracted work. More than half of the operating segments had intercompany arrangements with multiple other operating segments to perform or receive subcontracted services.
The nature of the products and services
The Company is a provider of specialty contracting services. These services are provided on a decentralized basis through its operating segments throughout the United States and, to a small extent, in Canada. These services include engineering, construction, maintenance, locating and installation services to telecommunications providers, electric and gas utilities and others. The vast majority of the operating segments provide a combination of these tasks for their various customers. Operating segments are evaluated by their performance as a whole and are not segregated or reviewed by task. The Company’s operating segments provide the labor, tools and equipment necessary to design, engineer, locate, maintain, expand, install and upgrade the infrastructure on behalf of these customers.
The Company has determined that the nature of services is the same among the operating segments.
The nature of the production processes
The services provided by each operating segment are labor intensive and are completed based on job criteria specified by the customer. Labor and subcontracted labor combined was the largest cost component for all the operating segments. Each of the Company’s operating segments:
a) recruit, hire and train similarly skilled employees;
b) respond to customer requests for specialty contracting services by:
providing skilled labor crews to a site designated by the customer and managing their productivity and quality of work; and supplying the specialty tools and equipment necessary for the labor crew to complete the specified service; and c) bill and administer the production process.
Many of the operating segments subcontract from sister operating segments when additional labor crews are needed in specific areas. For fiscal 2013, there were over 60 arrangements between sister operating segments to perform subcontracted work. More than half of the operating segments had intercompany arrangements with multiple other operating segments to perform or receive subcontracted services.
Each of the operating segments have similar capital spending requirements for vehicles and equipment. In many cases these assets are transferred between the operating segments to address fluctuations in demand. During fiscal 2013, substantially all of the operating segments either bought or sold similar fixed assets from a sister operating segment.
The Company has considered the nature of the production process and believes that it is similar throughout all of the operating segments.
The type or class of customer for their products and services
The operating segments all provide services to the same type of customer. Each of our operating segments have multiple customers and most operate in multiple states. Dycom’s customer base consists of telecommunication providers, electric and gas utilities and other utilities. There is concentration of customers in the telecommunications industry and these customers offer competing products for voice, video and data services to their end users. The Company provides its services to these customers through its operating segments. For fiscal 2013, Dycom’s top ten customers were all in the telecommunications industry and accounted for approximately 74% of total revenues and included AT&T, CenturyLink, Comcast, Verizon, Windstream, Charter, Time Warner Cable, Frontier Communications, Ericsson, and Cablevision. For fiscal 2013, 29 of our 30 operating segments provided services to one or more of these top ten customers. The one operating segment that did not work for a top ten customer worked for a smaller telecommunication customer and represented only 0.2% of the Company’s revenues during fiscal 2013.
The Company has considered the customer base of the operating segments and believes that the type or class of customers are similar throughout all of the operating segments.
The methods used to distribute their products or provide their services
The vast majority of our operating segments provide services in multiple states. The operating segments work in all 50 states and there is overlap of operating segments in 49 out of the 50 states. For operating segments which represented over 5% of revenue in fiscal 2013 or budgeted for fiscal 2014, all worked in at least 7 states in 2013 and overlapped in 28 states. Based on the extensive overlap of operating segments across service areas and customers, geographic summaries of operating performance would not be meaningful and are not analyzed by the Company. Although insignificant, the Company generates less than 1% of revenue from services provided in Canada and discloses this amount in accordance with ASC 280.
Each operating segment is marketed primarily through the efforts of the management of the segment and each operating segment provides services for customers under contracts to customers that are competitively bid or individually negotiated. Dycom’s CODM is also involved in determining which operating segments will pursue certain larger opportunities and consideration is based on existing customer relationships and other factors contributing to the success of the bid. Services are provided by each operating segment through skilled labor crews performing work at a site designated by the customer. Additionally, our operating segments supply the specialty tools and equipment necessary for the labor crew to complete the specified service. The operating segments do not manufacture any products. However, certain customer contracts require the operating segments to furnish materials such as fiber optic cable. These materials are inventoried, handled and distributed by the operating segments in a similar manner.
The Company believes all of the operating segments have similar methods used to provide their services.
Regulatory environment
Although none of the Company’s operating segments fall specifically under a regulatory body, such as the banking or insurance industry, all of the operating segments have oversight by occupational safety agencies such as OSHA. Additionally, many of our telecommunications customers are regulated by the Federal Communications Commission (“FCC”). As a result, if the FCC alters its application of current regulations or imposes additional regulations, each of our operating segments could be impacted as our customers may reduce expenditures which could impact the demand for specialty contracting services among our operating segments.
Similar economic characteristics
ASC Topic 280 notes operating segments have similar long-term financial performance if they have similar economic characteristics. As noted by ASC Topic 280, many different factors may be considered in determining whether the economic characteristics of a company’s segments are similar. While performance factors such as revenues and gross margins are considered by the Company when assessing whether our segments have substantially similar economic characteristics, the Company also considers other qualitative factors, such as the manner in which the segments are operated, cost structure, opportunities for growth and inherent risks.
The risks of the business are the same throughout each operating segment. Each operating segment is impacted by the Company’s operational risks as outlined in the risk factors of the Fiscal 2013 Form 10-K, including that the demand for our services is cyclical and vulnerable to downturns affecting the customers we serve. Each of the segments operate within the same economic environment characterized by swings in demand brought about by rapid changes in economic or technological factors. An example of this occurred during the recession in fiscal 2009 when lower operating results were experienced as customer spending declined. Demand for the services provided is also influenced by the level of overall economic activity, including construction and housing activity.
In addition to the similar risks, each of the operating segments have similar opportunities for growth within the industry in which we operate. For example, beginning in fiscal 2011, the Company has been experiencing the effect of an improving environment as a result of industry opportunities such as cellular backhaul initiatives, broadband stimulus funding, customers accelerating the deployment of fiber to small and medium businesses, wireless carriers upgrading technologies, and customers deploying Fiber to the Home or Node technologies to enable video offerings. Although demand levels may vary by operating segment based on customer spending during the a specific period, we believe the opportunities for growth are the same throughout all operating segments.
We have provided supplemental information to the Staff presenting the key quantitative metrics for each of the Company’s operating segments in excess of 3% of Dycom’s total contract revenues in either fiscal 2013 or budgeted 2014. This information consists of the 13 operating segments representing approximately 75% of the Company’s revenue in either fiscal 2013 or budgeted 2014. The Company has provided details of revenue and gross margin percentages for each of the last five fiscal years and budgeted full year fiscal 2014. Budgeted full year fiscal 2014 information is based on our actual results for the first two fiscal quarters and the budgeted third and fourth quarters of fiscal 2014. The Company has not prepared budget information for the operating segments beyond fiscal 2014. The remaining 17 of the 30 operating segments each represent less than 3% of the Company’s total revenues and were not included in the supplemental information provided based on their individual insignificance. These remaining 17 operating segments have similar economic characteristics as those provided in the supplemental information provided to the Staff.
The Company has determined gross margin is the key metric for assessing similarity among its operating segments and notes that the operating segments each achieve gross margins that vary over time but are within a similar range. The CODM uses gross margins to assess performance and allocate resources. Gross margins are strong indicators of how well an operating segment manages its contract negotiations, labor productivity and cost containment. Based on the significant overlap of customers between the operating segments and all of the other similarities, gross margins provide a good comparative measure. If gross margins realized over a period of time are not at an acceptable level at a specific operating segment, measures are taken to improve the results to be in line with the Company’s expectations. Other financial measures besides gross margins are available; however, they are of lesser importance in evaluating the operating segments as they provide less insight into the potential resource needs and performance of the operating segments.
For analysis purposes, the Company has presented more details on the key metrics of the top 7 operating segments (comprised of those with over 5% of revenue). Background information on these 7 is as follows:
Of these 7 operating segments, only 2 have revenues over 10% and the highest significance for either of these was only 11.3% of revenue in fiscal 2013. In total, these 7 represent approximately 54% of the Company’s total revenues for fiscal 2013.
The 7 operating segments received approximately two-thirds of their revenue from Dycom’s Top 5 customers and 85% of their revenues from customers within Dycom’s Top 10 customers for fiscal 2013.
Each of the 7 operating segments had revenues from more than one of Dycom’s Top 5 customers. In addition, there were more than 15 common customers between these operating segments.
Between these 7 operating segments, there were over 20 intercompany arrangements where sister operating segments performed or received work on behalf of the operating segments.
These 7 operating segments worked in 42 states in 2013, with each of the 7 working in at least 7 states in fiscal 2013. Additionally, they overlapped in 28 states.
Each of the 7 operating segments have gross margins within a similar range and are expected to be within a similar range over the long-term.
The Company notes that the gross margins of all the Company’s operating segments have averaged 19% since 2009. Additionally, the Company averaged the low and high gross margins of its operating segments from fiscal 2009 through fiscal 2014 which resulted in an average low and high range of 16% to 22%. For 5 of the top 7 operating segments (Segments B, D, E, F, and I in the supplementary information provided to the Staff), the gross margins were closely aligned to the overall average of 19%. The other two operating segments (Segment A and L) were slightly further from the average gross margin, which is discussed below:
Operating Segment A with 11% of total revenue in fiscal 2013 achieved an average gross margin of 25%. This operating segment has worked for its primary customer for over a decade. It has experienced operating efficiencies over time and benefits from the larger relative scale of its operations. The Company notes that Segment A’s range of gross margins is similar to the other operating segments, and other operating segments have periodically achieved gross margins higher than Segment A. For example, Segment D (24.3% in 2009), Segment F (23.3% and 24.4% in fiscal 2009 and 2010, respectively) and Segment K (23.1% in 2011). All of these are near Segment A’s average and above Segment A’s 22.8% in 2009. The Company has determined that Segment A and the other operating segments have similar economic characteristics over the long-term.
Operating Segment L with less than 8% of revenue had an average gross margin of 15% with a high of 19.8% in fiscal 2009. In recent periods, Segment L has exited contracts that were not achieving acceptable margin levels. The impact of these contracts and the related costs to scale back operations have negatively impacted Segment L’s margins over the recent periods. Through tighter cost control and focus on productivity, the segment’s gross margins are expected to improve in the near term during fiscal 2014 and over the long-term. The Company has determined that Segment L and the other operating segments have similar economic characteristics over the long-term and that Segment L’s margins being slightly further from the average is temporary.
The Company considered budgeted 2014 and its long-term gross margin expectations for these and other operating segments. Based on the continued similarity of customer opportunities and operating methods between the operating segments, gross margins are expected to continue to converge over time.
The Company has determined that each of the operating segments has similar economic characteristics. As the supplementary information provided to the Staff further demonstrates, the level of revenue varies from operating segment to operating segment and within an individual operating segment from period to period. These changes are based on the level of contract activity as well as the number of contracts the particular operating segment has been successful in being awarded. For example, if two operating segments are working for the same customer in different areas, one operating segment may have recently completed a project while the other operating segment is just beginning a project. While understanding this change assists management in the allocation of resources, the variability of the revenue change between the operating segments does not change the economic similarities of the two operating segments. Accordingly, total revenue trend comparisons between operating segments are less meaningful than overall customer activities across the operating segments.
Margins also vary within an individual operating segment from period to period and can vary between the operating segments. The margins and revenue changes are a reflection of variables associated with the particular projects or contracts in place at each of the operating segments during the applicable period of time. Customers are at varying stages of their deployment of infrastructure ranging from the cycle of growth and facility upgrade to the cycle of maintenance and installation. Additionally, customer budgets and spending varies over time and are impacted by phased deployments which affects the timing of demand at an operating segment over the long-term. Operating segments continue to provide services to the customers as they go through their cycles. The margins associated with each activity and within the scope of work of each contract will vary through the cycle and the individual operating results will fluctuate accordingly. These margin variations are not the result of different economic characteristics among the operating segments, or within an individual operating segment. Rather, the margins are influenced by customer spending initiatives and the demand level impacting a particular operating segment at a particular time. Gross margin is also impacted at each operating segment by a number of factors such as labor productivity, the competitiveness of the bidding to obtain the contract, start-up costs, fuel costs, level of direct materials provided, and weather. Inclement weather can have an adverse impact on margins while severe storms and the related storm restoration work can have a favorable impact to margins. Additionally, margins also vary based on how well each operating segment manages its contract negotiations and cost containment. If margins realized over a period of time are not consistent with long-term goals, measures are taken by management to improve the results to be in line with the Company’s expectations. Irrespective of the variances, the Company manages each of the operating segments in the same manner and believes they have the same long-term future opportunities and are expected to achieve similar gross margins.
The Company regularly reviews the criteria used to aggregate its operating segments. Key factors in the Company’s analysis as outlined above include that the operating segments have the same economic characteristics, along with the same:
(a) Nature of the products and services – The specialty contracting services of the operating segments are all similar; revenues are not derived from any other lines of business;
(b) Nature of the production processes - Each of the Company’s operating segments is in the business of providing labor services and supplying tools and equipment necessary for the labor crew to complete the service for the customer. The services provided by each operating segment are all similar;
(c) Type or class of customer for their products and services – Each operating segments’ customer base consists of telecommunication providers, electric and gas utilities and other utilities;
(d) Methods used to distribute their products or provide their services - Each operating segment has a similar cost structure, manages its marketing and sales efforts in the same manner and obtains contracts in a similar manner. Additionally, the majority of the operating segments have overlapping customers and geographies with other sister operating segments and share resources; and
(e) Nature of the regulatory environment – There are no differences in the regulatory environment in which the operating segments provide their services.
Finally, the Company considered that only 2 of the 30 operating segments had revenue which exceeded 10% of total revenue, and the highest significance for either of these was only 11.3% of revenue in fiscal 2013.
In conclusion, the Company has determined that aggregation of the operating segments into one reporting segment is appropriate based on the analysis outlined above. Any grouping of the 30 operating segments, other than as one reportable segment, would be arbitrary and would not be consistent with how management operates the Company.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment with respect to expanded disclosure on how the operating segments are organized and will disclose the following beginning with its Form 10-Q for the quarter ending April 26, 2014 within Item 1, Notes To The Consolidated Financial Statements – Note 1 – Basis of Presentation and Accounting Policies:
Segment Information – The Company operates in one reportable segment as a specialty contractor, providing engineering, construction, maintenance and installation services to telecommunications providers, underground facility locating services to various utilities including telecommunications providers, and other construction and maintenance services to electric and gas utilities and others. The Company operates on a decentralized basis through its operating segments, each of which consists of a legal subsidiary (or in limited cases, the combination of two or more subsidiaries). The management of the Company’s operating segments all report directly to Dycom’s Chief Operating Officer (“COO”). Dycom’s COO reports directly to Dycom’s Chief Executive Officer, who is the chief operating decision maker. All of the Company’s operating segments have been aggregated into one reportable segment due to their similar economic characteristics, nature of services and production processes, type of customers, and service distribution methods. The Company’s services are provided by its operating segments throughout the United States and in Canada. Revenues from services provided in Canada were approximately $x.x million and $x.x million during the three and nine months ended April 26, 2014, respectively, and $3.3 million and $9.7 million during the three and nine months ended April 27, 2013, respectively. The Company had no material long-lived assets in Canada at April 26, 2014 or July 27, 2013.
4. Accounts Receivable, page 53