Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001061219 /10-K filed Feb 27, 2026, compared with Feb 28, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE, OTC Energy · Pipelines

Enterprise Products Partners L.P. EPD

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

6 reviews of EPD's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 6 latest letter Apr 20, 2022
Questions asked 28 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 3 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 8 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 28 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 9 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 3 of 6 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 15 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2021

2022-04-20 to 2022-05-04 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2022-05-04
Liquidity and cashRisk factorsResults discussion (MD&A)
Item 1A. Risk Factors, page 34
SEC asked (1)
You disclose in your 2022 Analyst Day presentation that Oil & Gas industry is currently facing post-COVID supply chain shortages (labor, steel, sand), oilfield service equipment cannibalization and cost inflation 20%+. Please disclose in a risk factor the potential negative effects of inflation on your financial results, financial position and liquidity.
EPD answered
We acknowledge your comment 1, and note that the above-referenced presentation disclosure relates to the broader energy industry generally, and not to Enterprise or any other midstream company specifically. Our intent in disclosing this information was to address the challenges that exploration and production and oilfield services companies are facing and why we were not expecting to see a rapid response in production growth, notwithstanding recent increases in commodity prices.

We have further considered Regulation S-K Item 105, which expressly discourages disclosure of risks that could
Rest of the answer

apply to any registrant, while directing registrants to explain how each risk affects the registrant.

In response to the foregoing comment, Enterprise will include the following additional Risk Factor in its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the three months ending March 31, 2022:

Changes in price levels could negatively impact our revenue, our expenses, or both, which could adversely affect our business.

The operation of our assets and the execution of capital projects require significant expenditures for labor, materials, property, equipment and services. As a result, such costs may increase during periods of general business inflation, including as a result of higher commodity prices, supply chain disruptions and tight labor markets. Recent inflationary pressures affecting the general economy and the energy industry have increased our expenses and capital costs, and those costs may continue to increase. While the majority of long-term contracts for our services contain index-based changes and inflation adjustments, we may not be able to pass all of these increased costs to our customers in the form of higher fees for our services. In addition, we use the FERC’s PPI-based price indexing methodology to establish tariff rates in certain markets served by our pipelines. As such, our revenues and operating margins are impacted by changes in price levels. Prior to adjustments to applicable rates, material cost increases may affect our operating margins, even if margins in subsequent periods may be normalized following applicable rate adjustments. Accordingly, increased costs during periods of general business inflation that are not passed through to customers or offset by other factors may have a material adverse effect on our financial position, results of operations and cash flows.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2022: 10-Q filed May 10, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2021 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of · Operations, page 57
SEC asked (2)
You disclose in your 2022 Analyst Day presentation that Oil & Gas industry is currently cannibalization and cost inflation 20%+. You also disclose that gross operating margins decreased due to higher operating costs or higher maintenance costs for a number of your operations. Discuss and analyze the underlying reasons for the higher operating and maintenance costs. Refer to Item 303(b) of Regulation S-K.
Rest of the question

Please also discuss and analyze the potential negative effects of inflation on your financial results and liquidity. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

EPD answered
Item 303 of Regulation S-K requires disclosure of information relevant to assessing our financial condition and results of operations to enable readers of our reports to view the Company from management’s perspective. We acknowledge that the discussion must focus specifically on material events and uncertainties known to management that are reasonably likely to cause reported financial information not to be necessarily indicative of future operating results or of future financial condition.

In our Item 7, Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Rest of the answer

in our 2021 Form 10-K filed February

28, 2022, we disclosed certain impacts where gross operating margins decreased due to higher operating costs or higher maintenance costs for several of our operations. The year-to-year increases in operating expenses and maintenance costs for the operations we discussed were primarily attributable to (1) scheduled maintenance and integrity management activities performed in 2021, including hydrotesting of our pipelines and mechanical integrity activities completed in accordance with standards set by the American Petroleum Institute; (2) unscheduled repairs and maintenance activities performed as a result of weather related events, as was described under the heading “Estimated Impact of Hurricane Ida on Results for 2021” within Item 7 of the Form 10-K; and (3) higher utility costs for natural gas and electricity used in operating our processing and fractionation facilities as a result of higher commodity prices and rates charged by utility providers. We note that such higher energy costs represent a material cause of overall inflation, among other causes, and not vice versa.

To the extent that inflation impacts our operating costs, including the situations described above, there are typically offsetting benefits either inherent in our business or that result from other steps we take proactively to reduce the impact of inflation on our net operating results. These benefits include: (1) provisions included in our fee-based revenue contracts that offset cost increases in the form of rate escalations based on positive changes in the U.S. Consumer Price Index, Producer Price Index for Finished Goods or other factors; (2) provisions in other revenue contracts that enable us to pass through higher energy costs to customers in the form of gas, electricity and fuel rebills or surcharges; and (3) higher commodity prices, which generally enhance our results in the form of increased volumetric throughput and demand for our services. Additionally, we take measures to mitigate the impact of cost increases in certain commodities, including a portion of our electricity needs, using fixed-price, term purchase agreements. While a significant or prolonged period of high inflation could adversely impact our results if costs were to increase at a rate greater than the increase in revenues we receive, we believe that the benefits and mitigating factors described above would help alleviate the negative impact that inflation could have on our financial condition and results of operations. In order to enable our readers to understand the impact inflation has on our results of operations, we will include the following discussion under the heading “Impact of Inflation” immediately preceding our “Income Statement Highlights” section in our Form 10-Q for the three months ended March 31, 2022:

Impact of Inflation

After being relatively moderate in recent years, inflation in the United States increased significantly in late 2021 into 2022. This rise in inflation, coupled with supply chain disruptions, labor shortages and increased commodity prices, has generally resulted in higher costs in 2022. However, to the extent that a rising cost environment impacts our results, there are typically offsetting benefits either inherent in our business or that result from other steps we take proactively to reduce the impact of inflation on our net operating results. These benefits include: (1) provisions included in our fee-based revenue contracts that offset cost increases in the form of rate escalations based on positive changes in the U.S. Consumer Price Index, Producer Price Index for Finished Goods or other factors; (2) provisions in other revenue contracts that enable us to pass through higher energy costs to customers in the form of gas, electricity and fuel rebills or surcharges; and (3) higher commodity prices, which generally enhance our results in the form of increased volumetric throughput and demand for our services. Additionally, we take measures to mitigate the impact of cost increases in certain commodities, including a portion of our electricity needs, using fixed-price, term purchase agreements. For these reasons, the increased cost environment, caused in part by inflation, has not had a material impact on our historical results of operations for the periods presented in this report. However, a significant or prolonged period of high inflation could adversely impact our results if costs were to increase at a rate greater than the increase in the revenues we receive.

See “Capital Investments” within this Part I, Item 2 for a discussion of the impact of inflation on our capital investment decisions. Additionally, see Part II, Item 1A “Risk Factors - Changes in price levels could negatively impact our revenue, our expenses, or both, which could adversely affect our business.”

We will continue to include disclosures in future periodic reports that describe any significant components of operating costs that, in our judgement, would be material to understanding our results of operations and discuss any trends or uncertainties that we consider reasonably likely to have a material impact on our future operating results or financial condition.

The amount of capital resources we have available for growth capital investments could be negatively impacted by inflation in the form of higher costs for labor, steel, aluminum, electronic components and other materials necessary to construct new midstream energy infrastructure assets. Higher borrowing costs due to higher interest rates on future debt issuances could also add downward pressure on our operating results. Our management has taken steps to mitigate the effect of these higher costs in several ways, including executing fixed-bid construction agreements with contractors for certain large projects, leveraging our size and scale in the purchasing process and increasing inventory stock levels in certain materials to avoid future price increases. Additionally, we seek to maintain the expected levels of return on our investments by ensuring that any cost increases we incur are adequately factored into the fees we charge customers prior to proceeding with any large project. However, a significant and prolonged period of high inflation could adversely impact our liquidity and returns on investment and, as a result, we may need to allocate additional capital to growth projects, modify the scope of projects or cancel projects altogether. In light of these risks, we will refine our discussion under the heading “Capital Investments” within our Liquidity and Capital Resources section in our Form 10-Q for the three months ended March 31, 2022 to more fully address the negative impact inflation could have on our forecast of capital investments as follows (additions marked in underlined text while deletions are shown as strikethrough compared to the disclosure in the Form 10-K):

Our forecast of capital investments is dependent upon our ability to generate the required funds from either operating cash flows or other means, including borrowings under debt agreements, the issuance of additional equity and debt securities, and potential divestitures. We may revise our forecast of capital investments due to factors beyond our control, such as adverse economic conditions, weather-related events and changes in supplier prices resulting from raw material or labor shortages, supply chain disruptions or inflation. Furthermore, our forecast of capital investments may change due to over time based on future decisions made by management at a later date, which may include unforeseen acquisition opportunities changing the scope or timing of projects or cancelling projects altogether. Our success in raising capital, including partnering having the ability to increase revenues commensurate with cost increases and our ability to partner with other companies to share project costs and risks, continue to be a significant factors in determining how much capital we can invest. We believe our access to capital resources is sufficient to meet the demands of our current and future growth needs and, although we currently expect to make the forecast capital investments noted above, we may adjust the timing and amounts of projected expenditures revise our plans in response to changes in economic and capital market conditions.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2022: 10-Q filed May 10, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 8, 2021 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2022-05-04

Form 10-K

2016-06-22 to 2016-07-07 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2016-07-07
RevenueNon-GAAP measuresSegments
Gross operating margin, page 102
SEC asked
We note your response to comment 4. Since you adjust a GAAP measure to accelerate the recognition of revenue, it appears your presentation of total segment gross operating margin reflecting adjustments for shipper make-up rights may be inconsistent with Questions 100.04 and 104.04 of the updated Non-GAAP Financial Measures Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations issued on May 17, 2016.
Rest of the question

Please review this guidance and explain to us whether and how it will impact your disclosures in future filings.

EPD answered
Applicability of Question 100.04

The text of Question 100.04 is presented below:

Question: A registrant presents a non-GAAP performance measure that is adjusted to accelerate revenue recognized ratably over time in accordance with GAAP as though it earned revenue when customers are billed. Can this measure be presented in documents filed or furnished with the Commission or provided elsewhere, such as on company websites?

Austin Beijing Dallas Dubai Houston London New York

Research Triangle Park The Woodlands Washington, DC

Answer: No.
Rest of the answer

Non-GAAP measures that substitute individually tailored revenue recognition and measurement methods for those of GAAP could violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G. Other measures that use individually tailored recognition and measurement methods for financial statement line items other than revenue may also violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G.

As presented on page F-40 of the Form 10-K, we evaluate segment performance based on gross operating margin, which is an important performance measure of the core profitability of our operations and a component of unlevered return on investment. This measure forms the basis of our internal financial reporting and is used by our executive management in deciding how to allocate capital resources among business segments.

When reviewing the gross operating margin amounts generated by certain new pipeline projects, management includes deferred transportation revenues relating to the make-up rights of committed shippers. From an internal (and segment) reporting standpoint, executive management considers the transportation fees paid by committed shippers on these major new pipeline projects, including any non-refundable revenues that may be deferred under GAAP related to make-up rights, to be important in assessing the financial performance of these pipeline assets.

Question 100.04 does not impact the segment reporting disclosures we make in accordance with Accounting Standards

Codification (“ASC”) 280 in the footnotes to our consolidated financial statements. The same holds true for our presentation and discussion of individual segment results in Management’s Discussion and Analysis where the amounts are sourced from the ASC 280 disclosures. Amounts presented in response to the requirements of ASC 280 are deemed to be in compliance with GAAP (i.e., not considered to be a non-GAAP performance measure). As a result, individual segment gross operating margin amounts, including those that reflect adjustments for shipper make-up rights, are not within the scope of Question 100.04.

However, as noted below in our response to the applicability of Question 104.04, we will adjust our measure of total gross operating margin (when presented outside the context of the ASC 280 segment reporting disclosures) to exclude the adjustments for shipper make-up rights.

Applicability of Question 104.04

The text of Question 104.04 is presented below:

Question: In the footnote that reconciles the segment measures to the consolidated financial statements, a company may total the profit or loss for the individual segments as part of the Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) 280 required reconciliation. Would the presentation of the total segment profit or loss measure in any context other than the ASC 280 required reconciliation in the footnote be the presentation of a non-GAAP financial measure.

Answer: Yes. The presentation of the total segment profit or loss measure in any context other than the ASC 280 required reconciliation in the footnote would be the presentation of a non-GAAP financial measure because it has no authoritative meaning outside of the ASC 280 required reconciliation in the footnotes to the company’s consolidated financial statements.

Per Question 104.04, the presentation of total gross operating margin outside of the ASC 280 segment reporting disclosures represents the presentation of a non-GAAP measure. This non-GAAP measure appears within Management’s Discussion and Analysis on pages 79 and 102 of the Form 10-K. In light of the guidance in Question 100.04, we will modify tabular or other references to non-GAAP total gross operating margin in future filings to reflect the removal of adjustments for shipper make-up rights.

The following tables are examples of how we would modify disclosures in future filings to comply with the guidance in Question 100.04. These examples are based on information currently presented on pages 79 and 102 of the Form 10-K.

Excerpt from Page 79:

“The following table presents gross operating margin by segment and total gross operating margin for the years indicated (dollars in millions):

For the Year Ended December 31,

2015

2014

2013

Gross operating margin by segment:

NGL Pipelines & Services

$

2,771.6

2,877.7

2,514.4

Crude Oil Pipelines & Services

961.9

762.5

742.7

Natural Gas Pipelines & Services

782.6

803.3

789.0

Petrochemical & Refined Products Services

718.5

681.0

625.9

Offshore Pipelines & Services

97.5

162.0

146.1

Total segment gross operating margin (1)

5,332.1

5,286.5

4,818.1

Net adjustment for shipper make-up rights

7.1

(81.7

)

(4.4

Total gross operating margin

5,339.2

5,204.8

4,813.7

(1)

Within the context of this table, total segment gross operating margin represents a subtotal and corresponds to measures similarly titled within our business segment disclosures found under Note 10 of the Notes to

Consolidated Financial Statements included under Part II, Item 8 of this annual report.

Gross operating margin by segment for NGL Pipelines & Services and Crude Oil Pipelines & Services reflect adjustments for shipper make-up rights that are included in managements’ evaluation of segment results. However, these adjustments are excluded from non-GAAP total gross operating margin in compliance with recently issued guidance from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The GAAP financial measure most directly comparable to total gross operating margin is operating income. See

“Other Items – Non-GAAP Reconciliations” with this Part II, Item 7 for reconciliations of gross operating margin to operating income for each period presented.”

Excerpt from Page 102:

The following table presents a reconciliation of non-GAAP total gross operating margin to GAAP operating income for the periods indicated

(dollars in millions):

5,204.7

Adjustments to reconcile non-GAAP total gross operating margin to GAAP operating income:

Subtract depreciation, amortization and accretion expense amounts not reflected in gross operating margin

(1,428.2

(1,282.7

(1,148.9

Subtract impairment charges not reflected in gross operating margin

(162.6

(34.0

(92.6

Add net gains or subtract net losses attributable to asset sales and insurance recoveries not reflected in gross operating margin

(15.6

102.1

83.4

Subtract general and administrative costs not reflected in gross operating margin

(192.6

(214.5

(188.3

Operating income

3,540.2

3,775.7

3,467.3

* * * * *

In response to the foregoing Staff comment, Enterprise acknowledges that:

• the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 1, 2016: 10-Q filed Aug 3, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 6, 2016 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2016-07-07

Form S-3

2016-05-18 to 2016-07-11 · 10 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 2 from the company
No closing letter
Results discussion (MD&A)RevenueLiquidity and cashGoodwill and impairmentSegmentsNon-GAAP measuresDebtCritical estimatesDerivatives and hedging
General
SEC asked (1)
At this time, a review is open for your annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015. We will coordinate any request for acceleration of effectiveness for this registration statement with resolution of all comments regarding the Form 10-K review. Please confirm your understanding in this regard.
EPD answered
We hereby confirm our understanding that (i) at this time a review is open for our annual report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2015, and (ii) you will coordinate any request for acceleration of effectiveness for the registration statement on Form S-3 with resolution of all comments regarding the Form 10-K review.
Read in the reply
Where you can find more information, page 36
SEC asked (2)
Since the filing date of this registration statement, we note that you have filed certain Exchange Act reports. Please update this section to include the appropriate reports. Further, should you wish to incorporate by reference other Exchange Act reports filed during the period prior to the effectiveness of this registration statement, please also revise your disclosure in this section to state that any applicable
Rest of the question

filings made after the date of the initial registration statement and prior to effectiveness of this registration statement will be deemed incorporated by reference. See Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations – Securities Act Forms Question 123.05, which is available on our website. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.

EPD answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comments and confirm that we will (i) update the “Where You Can Find More Information” section of the registration statement to include the appropriate Exchange Act reports filed with the Commission since the filing date of the initial registration statement and (ii) revise the disclosure in such section to state that any applicable filings made after the date of the initial registration statement and prior to effectiveness of the registration statement will be deemed incorporated by reference.

Form 10-K for Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2015

Management’s
Rest of the answer

Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.

Read in the reply
Results of Operations, page 72
SEC asked (3)
Based on the table on page F-44, it appears that there was a significant increase from 2014 to 2015 in the gross margin on your product sales. Please explain to us in detail, and disclose in summary, the reason(s) for fluctuations in gross margin on product sales.
Rest of the question

To the extent material to an understanding of your segment results, please also provide such disclosures, including quantification of gross margins on product sales, on a segmental basis.

EPD answered
We provide midstream energy services across our integrated asset network. As stated on page 3 of our Form 10-K, our marketing activities (or groups) perform a supporting role to increase the utilization and expansion of our assets by increasing the volumes handled by such assets. In performing these support roles, our marketing groups also seek to participate in supply and demand opportunities provided by the marketplace.

In general, our marketing groups purchase energy commodities (e.g., natural gas liquids or

“NGLs”, crude oil and natural gas) based on index prices less a discount for
Rest of the answer

location, quality, etc. The discount is a negotiated fixed dollar amount per unit of volume that is based on the costs our marketing activities incur to transport such energy commodities from the purchase location to a market hub (e.g., Mont Belvieu, Texas for NGLs and Houston, Texas for crude oil) for further processing or storage. In turn, our marketing groups sell the energy commodities based on index prices plus, if applicable, a premium. Sales prices typically include a premium when we sell energy commodities at locations other than market hubs. The premium is a negotiated fixed dollar amount per unit of volume that is generally determined based on the costs our marketing groups incur to deliver such energy commodities to the point of sale (e.g., the fees paid to our marine terminals or similar marine facilities owned by third parties).

In order to fulfill their obligations under purchase and sales contracts, our marketing groups enter into both intersegment and intrasegment transactions with our assets. These transactions result in additional fee-based earnings for the assets in each of our business segments. For example, our NGL marketing group takes title to mixed NGLs at our natural gas processing plants in the

Permian Basin. NGL marketing then transports the mixed NGLs on our Seminole Pipeline to our Mont Belvieu complex for NGL fractionation and storage before selling the purity NGL products to third parties. In this example, our NGL marketing group purchases mixed NGLs from our natural gas plants and pays intercompany fees to our pipeline transportation, NGL fractionation and storage assets. When reviewing business segment results, our marketing activities generate incremental earnings for us to the extent that sales prices exceed the sum of the costs, which include intercompany fees paid by the marketing groups to our assets.

Due to the interrelated nature of our assets and marketing activities, management assesses segment performance before the elimination of intercompany transactions using the non-GAAP financial measure of gross operating margin. Assessing marketing results before intercompany eliminations allows us to quantify the incremental earnings generated by the underlying marketing activities on the sales of product to customers. For these reasons, management believes that gross operating margin is the most appropriate performance measure (as opposed to consolidated gross margin) for our operations.

In our Management’s Discussion and Analysis, we discuss year-to-year changes in gross operating margin from our marketing activities to the extent such changes are material to an understanding of our segment results. This detailed discussion is included in the “Business Segment Highlights” section beginning on page 79 of our Form 10-K. In order to provide additional information regarding the results of our marketing activities, we propose to add the following types of disclosures to our discussion of gross operating margin in future filings (where such information is considered material). The following is an excerpt from our Form 10-K with the type of disclosure we propose to add (added disclosure is underlined):

“Comparison of 2015 with 2014

Gross operating margin from natural gas processing and related NGL marketing activities for 2015 decreased $267.0 million when compared to 2014. Gross operating margin from our natural gas processing plants decreased $243.0 million year-to-year primarily due to lower processing margins. In addition, gross operating margin from our NGL marketing activities for 2015 decreased a net $24.0 million when compared to 2014 primarily due to lower sales margins, which accounted for a $167.4 million decrease, partially offset by a $152.0 million increase due to higher sales volumes. Gross operating margin from our sale of LPGs into export markets decreased $25.1 million year-to-year. During 2015, a higher percentage of volume in the LPG export business was associated with long-term, fee-based marketing contracts rather than spot business, which is typically contracted at higher margins and was prevalent in 2014. Gross operating margin from the remainder of our NGL marketing spot and term contract transactions decreased $50.9 million year-to-year primarily due to lower sales margins.

Lastly, gross operating margin from NGL marketing increased a net $52.0 million year-to-year attributable to margins on forward contracts and associated commodity derivative contracts.”

We acknowledge the Staff’s comment that our consolidated gross margin on product sales increased from 2014 to 2015. However, for the reasons noted above, gross margin is not a measure we use to manage our business, analyze consolidated financial results or assess segment performance. Since gross margin is calculated based on our consolidated revenues and cost of sales (i.e., after the elimination of intercompany transactions), we do not believe gross margin is an appropriate measure of asset performance or incremental earnings from our marketing activities.

Read in the reply
Gross operating margin, page 102
SEC asked (4)
Please explain how “make-up rights” operate and whether inclusion of such amounts in your non-GAAP measure is limited to only new pipeline projects. If such revenue required by GAAP to be deferred but included in your non-GAAP measure contains other types of non-refundable fees on existing pipelines, please explain.
Rest of the question

To the extent helpful to an understanding of such rights, please provide an example of the provisions of a standard “make-up right” included in your transportation contracts. Please also consider using plain English in describing the difference between the two “make-up rights” line items included in your reconciliation.

EPD answered
The deferred revenue amounts attributable to “make-up rights” included in our non-GAAP gross operating margin are limited to those recent major liquids pipeline projects described in the table on page 103 of our Form 10-K.

Pipeline transportation revenue is typically recognized when volumes have been transported and delivered; however, under certain of our transportation agreements (e.g., those associated with committed shippers on our Texas Express Pipeline, Front Range Pipeline, ATEX, Aegis Ethane Pipeline and

Seaway Pipeline), customers are required to ship a minimum volume over an
Rest of the answer

agreed-upon period, with make-up rights. Under agreements with make-up rights, the customer typically pays for transportation services using a tiered arrangement as follows:

•

For volumes shipped up to their minimum volume commitment to the pipeline, a contractually fixed, non-refundable dollar amount. This amount is paid to the pipeline regardless of whether the customer ships the minimum volume or not. To the extent that a customer is not able to ship its full minimum volume commitment, the customer is allowed to “make up” the deficient volume (i.e., the excess of minimum volume commitment for that period over the actual volume shipped) over an agreed-upon period (typically a one-year contractual period).

For volumes shipped in excess of a minimum volume commitment, and not associated with the make-up of deficient volumes for prior periods, a contractual excess volume transportation fee.

We also reference the summaries of shipper “make-up” rights for NGL pipelines set forth on page 7 of our Form 10-K and for crude oil pipelines set forth on page 15 of our Form 10-K, as well as on pages 102-103 of our Form 10-K.

With respect to agreements with make-up rights, we initially recognize as revenue only that portion of the fees collected that are attributable to actual volumes transported and delivered. The remaining portion of the fees paid by the shipper (i.e., attributable to the deficient volume that can be “made up” in future periods) is initially deferred and subsequently recognized at the earlier of when (i) the deficiency volume, or make-up volume, is shipped, (ii) the shipper’s ability to meet the minimum volume commitment has expired (typically a one-year contractual period), or (iii) the pipeline is otherwise released from its transportation service performance obligation.

We believe adjusting our non-GAAP gross operating margin measure for the receipt of these deferred revenues and subsequently adjusting the measure upon recognizing the related revenues is appropriate since under the terms of these contracts, we receive non-refundable payments from these customers. Once any make-up rights are extinguished regarding these payments, the amounts are recognized in revenue and we adjust our gross operating margin to reduce those recognized amounts.

We note your comment regarding the descriptions used in the reconciliation table for the make-up rights adjustments. In order to clarify our intention, we propose changing these adjustments in future filings to read “Subtract non-refundable payments attributable to shipper make-up rights on new pipeline projects reflected in gross operating margin” and “Add subsequent revenue recognition of deferred revenues attributable to make-up rights not reflected in gross operating margin.” We believe these subtle edits will allow readers to interpret our intentions in making these adjustments in reconciling our gross operating margin to operating income.

Read in the reply
Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies · Allowance for Doubtful Accounts, page F-9
SEC asked (5)
We note your disclosures on pages 44 and 91 that “adverse economic conditions in [your] industry, such as those experienced throughout 2015 and that [you] continue to experience at the beginning of 2016, increase the risk of nonpayment and nonperformance by customers, particularly customers that have sub-investment grade credit ratings or small-scale companies.” You also indicate that approximately 4.5% of your
Rest of the question

consolidated revenues were associated with 22 independent oil and gas producers with sub-investment grade credit ratings. Given these circumstances, please tell us why your allowance for doubtful accounts and amounts charged to bad debt expense for 2015 declined from the prior year. Tell us if you have any material accounts receivable balances from customers with sub-investment grade credit ratings, customers currently in bankruptcy, and/or, as noted on page 68, any of the 120 energy companies Moody’s placed on review for a possible downgrade in January 2016. If so, please tell us how any of the factors cited impacted your determination of the allowance for doubtful accounts.

EPD answered
The table of activity for our allowance for doubtful accounts on page F-9 of our Form 10-K shows that we charged $0.8 million to expense in 2015 compared to $8.4 million in 2014. Our allowance for doubtful accounts was $12.1 million at December 31,

2015 and $13.9 million at December 31, 2014.

Our allowance for doubtful accounts is determined based on two components:

(i) specific identification of accounts that we have reason to believe will not be collected (i.e., by reviewing accounts receivable aging or upon learning of significant customer credit risks); and (ii) a calculation based on
Rest of the answer

the rolling average receivable balance and a risk factor based on the credit ratings of our top 30 customers, which represents approximately 70% of our total revenues. The risk factor increased 11.6% from 2014 to 2015. However, the overall allowance for doubtful accounts balance declined year-to-year due to a significant decrease in the overall receivable balance driven by lower commodity prices in 2015 as compared to 2014.

Although our allowance for doubtful accounts decreased year-to-year on an absolute basis, our allowance for doubtful accounts actually increased when viewed as a percentage of total revenues and total accounts receivable. The total allowance for doubtful accounts as a percentage of our consolidated revenues was 0.045% in 2015 and 0.029% in 2014. The total allowance for doubtful accounts as a percentage of consolidated accounts receivable was 0.471% in 2015 and 0.364% in 2014. Revenues decreased by 43.6% from 2014 to 2015, while our accounts receivable and allowance accounts decreased 32.8% and 12.9%, respectively, year-to-year.

We manage our exposure to credit risk through credit analysis, credit approvals, credit limits and monitoring procedures, and for certain transactions may utilize letters of credit, prepayments, net out agreements and guarantees. See our credit risk disclosure on page F-71 of the Form 10-K. After considering our credit risks and information known at the time, we determined our allowance for doubtful accounts balance was appropriate.

At both December 31, 2015 and at the time of filing of the

Form 10-K, we had no material accounts receivable balances from customers with sub-investment grade credit ratings or customers currently in bankruptcy. While Moody’s placed 120 energy companies on review for a possible downgrade in January

2016, the outstanding accounts receivable balance that was considered uncollectible by us from all customers at December 31, 2015 was immaterial. During the first quarter of 2016, we had no material write-offs of uncollected balances, and we collected substantially all of the December 31, 2015 balances due to us. A review of our accounts receivable balances as of March 31, 2016 indicated that amounts outstanding greater than

90 days were immaterial.

Read in the reply
Note 3. Revenue Recognition, page F-16
SEC asked (6)
We note your disclosures on pages F-17 and -18 that certain NGL and crude oil pipeline transportation agreements have minimum volume requirements. We further note from page 69 that you expect certain of your assets in the Eagle Ford, Rockies and Haynesville areas to be impacted by lower volumes in 2016.
Rest of the question

Please tell us whether you have renegotiated or are in the process of renegotiating the fees or minimum volume commitments for any material contracts as a result of recent production declines and projections and their resulting impact on your customers’ liquidity. If so, please revise MD&A to discuss and quantify the related impact of such trend on your results of operations. Please also quantify the amount of minimum volume contracts that expire over the next 12 months, to the extent material, in future quarterly and annual reports.

EPD answered
We have renegotiated contracts with certain customers where the agreements include minimum volume commitments. These renegotiated contracts are not “material contracts,” as that term is defined in Item 601(b)(10) of Regulation S-K.

Furthermore, the renegotiated contracts are immaterial to our overall results of operations, financial position and liquidity, and as such, we do not believe a revision to MD&A is necessary as the impact of such a trend is immaterial.

We acknowledge your comment regarding quantifying the amount of minimum volume commitment contracts that expire over the next 12
Rest of the answer

months and have determined that there are no material minimum volume contracts that are set to expire within this time frame. We will continue to evaluate any future minimum volume contract expirations that are material to our financial statements and will add disclosures detailing any such expirations in our future quarterly and annual reports, as applicable.

Read in the reply
Note 3. Revenue Recognition, page F-16
SEC asked (7)
We note your disclosures on pages F-17, -18, and -19 that reservation fees related to NGL, crude oil, and refined products storage agreements are “recognized ratably” over the respective storage periods. Please explain to us and clarify in future filings how ratable recognition of such reservation fees is accomplished.
Rest of the question

If similar, please compare ratable recognition to straight-line recognition or some other analogous method. An example of how storage fees contracts are structured and recognized in revenue may be helpful to an understanding of your method.

EPD answered
When using the phrase “recognized ratably,” we mean a straight-line revenue recognition approach over the term of the applicable storage agreement. In future filings, we will use the term “straight-line” when describing our revenue recognition policy for such agreements.
Read in the reply
Note 6. Investments in Unconsolidated Affiliates, page F-23
SEC asked (8)
Please tell us how the decline in crude oil prices and related drilling activity has impacted your evaluation of impairment in investments in Crude Oil Pipelines and Services, specifically your Seaway and Eagle Ford crude oil pipeline investments.
EPD answered
As discussed in our response to Comment #10, we view the overall decline in energy commodity prices and drilling activity as temporary events.

In fact, as stated on page 69 of the Form 10-K, we believe that crude oil supply and demand fundamentals will likely begin to balance by the end of 2016. The International Energy Agency (“IEA”) currently forecasts the same trend.
Rest of the answer

The expectation of global crude oil supply and demand balancing during 2016 is further supported by recent news from the industry and an approximately 75% increase in crude oil prices between the lows experienced in February 2016 and current market prices.

We believe that the future expected earnings of Seaway Crude Pipeline Company LLC (“Seaway”) and Eagle Ford Pipeline LLC

(“Eagle Ford”) fully support the carrying amount of these investments. The assets owned by both Seaway and Eagle Ford are supported by long-term, fee-based contracts with minimum volume commitments, which help to insulate both investees from temporary periods of energy price fluctuations and declines in drilling activity. The remaining terms of these contracts range from one year to 18 years. Furthermore, the Seaway and Eagle Ford pipelines are connected to upstream crude oil pipelines that are owned by our joint venture partners in each investee. These upstream pipelines continue to provide significant throughput volumes for Seaway and Eagle Ford.

We have the intent and ability to hold our investments in Seaway and Eagle Ford during periods of temporary market fluctuations, and our long-term outlook for these investments remains very positive. The assets owned by Seaway connect the Cushing, Oklahoma crude oil market hub with refineries and marine terminals along the Texas Gulf Coast, including two marine terminals owned by

Seaway. The assets owned by Eagle Ford transport crude oil produced from the Eagle Ford Shale and Permian Basin to refineries and marine terminals along the Texas Gulf Coast, including a marine terminal owned by Eagle Ford. As crude oil supply and demand fundamentals begin to balance resulting in increased drilling activity, we believe Seaway and Eagle Ford are poised to take advantage of expected increases in domestically produced crude oil. Also, we believe that the U.S. government’s action in December 2015 to completely lift its ban on exporting domestically produced crude oil should have a beneficial impact on the crude oil pipelines and marine terminals owned by Seaway and Eagle Ford.

Read in the reply
Note 7. Intangibles Assets and Goodwill, page F-27
SEC asked (9)
We note your disclosure on page F-29 that you used a 15% discount rate to value the discounted cash flows related to EFS Midstream customer relationships and used a 6.5% discount rate related to acquired Oiltanking customer relationships. Please tell us in sufficient detail how you determined these discount rates and clarify why the EFS Midstream rate is more than double that of Oiltanking.
Rest of the question

In this regard, please provide a detailed description of how you develop the input assumptions for each fair value model and the reason(s) for differences in the discount rates.

EPD answered
discount rates selected were determined in relation to the overall weighted-average cost of capital (“WACC”) analysis we performed for EFS Midstream LLC (“EFS Midstream”) and Oiltanking Partners, L.P. (“Oiltanking”).

The WACC we estimated for each of EFS Midstream and Oiltanking is representative of a market participant’s required return for investing in the overall business of each entity.
Rest of the answer

Inputs used in our estimates were based on data obtained from market research and an analysis of peer group companies as of the respective acquisition dates.

The input assumptions for our WACC estimates, and adjustments to reconcile to the discount rates we selected for acquired customer relationships, are summarized in the following table:

EFS Midstream

Oiltanking

As of July 2015

As of October 2014

Cost of equity:

Risk-free rate of return

2.9

%

Product of beta multiplied by equity market risk premium

4.8

4.0

Company specific risk premium

7.0

—

Company size risk premium

3.7

Cost of equity

18.4

6.9

Weight applied to cost of equity

65.0

12.0

75.0

5.2

Cost of debt

5.3

4.7

Weight applied to cost of debt

35.0

1.9

25.0

1.2

Weighted average cost of capital, rounded

14.0

6.5

Adjustments

1.0

Selected discount rate for customer relationships

15.0

The primary difference in our WACC estimates for EFS Midstream and Oiltanking is the risk premium that market participants would apply to EFS Midstream’s cost of equity, which is based on the higher perceived risk of its operations.

EFS

Midstream provides condensate gathering and processing services as well as gathering, treating and compression services for associated natural gas. The operations of EFS Midstream are confined to a single geographic region, and volumes handled by

EFS Midstream are produced from a single supply basin (i.e., a specific region of the Eagle Ford Shale). Further, a majority of EFS Midstream’s revenues are earned from two customers, both of which have a focus on crude oil and natural gas exploration and production activities. These factors represent company specific risks that market participants would consider before investing in EFS Midstream.

In contrast, the operations of and services provided by Oiltanking are much more diverse and established. In October 2014, Oiltanking owned marine terminals located on the Houston Ship Channel and at the Port of Beaumont that have been in continuous operation for several decades. Unlike EFS Midstream’s focus on serving upstream producers, Oiltanking’s services are geared to downstream customers and include the loading and unloading of marine vessels and product storage and distribution. Oiltanking’s marine terminals handle a wide variety of commodities including crude oil, crude oil derivatives such as naphtha, refined petroleum products, natural gas liquids, octane additives and certain petrochemicals. Oiltanking serves a diverse customer base including major integrated oil companies, petrochemical companies, midstream energy companies and refiners. When compared to EFS Midstream, all of these factors translate into a lower risk profile for a potential investor in Oiltanking. In consideration of these factors, a company specific risk premium was deemed unnecessary.

In July 2015, EFS Midstream was a privately-held entity that we purchased for approximately $2.1 billion. In October 2014, Oiltanking was a well-known, publicly traded partnership with a fair value of approximately $6.0 billion. Accordingly, a company size risk premium was applied to estimate EFS Midstream’s cost of capital; whereas, a similar risk premium was not applied for Oiltanking.

Several tests were performed as part of our overall valuation analyses for EFS

Midstream and Oiltanking to ensure that the assumptions used were reasonable (both individually and in the aggregate) and that the resulting fair value estimates were reasonable. The most common test to ensure the reasonableness of discount rates selected to estimate fair value of individual assets is a comparison of the estimated WACC and the estimated weighted-average return on assets (“WARA”). The WACC is a computation based on rates of return for debt and equity. In contrast, the WARA computation is based on estimated required rates of return for individual assets (e.g., working capital, property, plant and equipment, intangible assets and goodwill), which are weighted by the assets’ respective fair values. Based on the fundamental accounting equation that assets must equal liabilities plus equity, it follows that the estimated WARA should approximate the WACC. Based on our analyses for EFS Midstream and Oiltanking, we confirmed that the WARA calculated for each entity was equivalent to the WACC we estimated for each entity.

It is also common practice to calculate the implied internal rate of return (“IRR”) for a transaction, which is compared to the WACC as a test for reasonableness. The IRR is a discount rate that equates (i) the present value of forecasted cash flows that an acquiring entity expects to receive as a result of the transaction with (ii) the purchase price paid by the acquiring entity to gain access to and control of the forecasted cash flows. We calculated the implied IRR in our analyses for EFS Midstream and Oiltanking and compared these

IRRs to our WACC estimates for both EFS Midstream and Oiltanking. In both cases, we concluded that our WACC estimates were reasonable in light of the IRR computations.

Read in the reply
Note 14. Derivative Instruments, Hedging Activities and Fair Value Measurements, page F-53
SEC asked (10)
We note your disclosure on page F-60 that you recorded asset impairments during fiscal 2015 primarily in connection with the sale of your Offshore Business and the abandonment of certain natural gas and crude oil pipeline assets in Texas.
Rest of the question

Please address the following comments related to your long-lived asset impairments:  We note your disclosure on page 98 that circumstances indicating the carrying amount of long-lived assets may not be recoverable could include production declines or long-term decreases in the demand or price of commodities. Considering the declines in commodity prices and drilling activity discussed on pages 68-69, tell us why your fiscal 2015 impairments appear to be primarily limited to assets sold and abandoned as opposed to assets held and used. If you tested other long-lived assets for impairment but the estimated cash flows from such assets exceeded the carrying amount, please summarize the results.  We note your disclosure on page 69 regarding certain operating regions where you may see 2016 crude oil and condensate production declines of 10-20% and natural gas production declines of 5-15%. To the extent not covered in the preceding bullet point, please tell us how such forecasts were factored into whether an impairment assessment was necessary for such assets.  Please quantify for us the long-lived assets associated with each of your supply basins and/or regions as well as the long-lived assets within each region that you tested for impairment during fiscal 2015. Explain to us in sufficient detail how you determined such tested assets were not impaired. For material asset groups tested for impairment, tell us the significant estimates and assumptions used in your tests and how such estimates and assumptions were determined. Quantify for us the long-lived assets considered at risk of impairment at the end of fiscal 2015.  Although your disclosures on page 69 indicate that the Barnett, Fayetteville, and Haynesville regions may experience natural gas production declines in 2016, your disclosures on page 71 indicate that such regions “could experience an increase in drilling activity to maintain, and potentially increase, their future production levels.” Please revise your disclosures to clarify any perceived inconsistencies between these statements.

EPD answered
to bullets 1 and 2:

Based on our reviews and analysis during 2015 of material assets to be held and used, none were deemed impaired. Long-lived assets, which include property, plant and equipment and intangible assets with finite useful lives generally ranging from 20 to 40 years, are reviewed for impairment whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that their carrying amount may not be recoverable.
Rest of the answer

The carrying value of a long-lived asset is not recoverable if it exceeds the sum of undiscounted estimated cash flows expected to result from the use and eventual disposition of the asset. As discussed in more detail below, three of our asset groups to be held and used were tested for impairment during 2015, and we concluded that their undiscounted estimated cash flows exceeded their respective carrying amounts.

Based on our analysis, we determined that impairment tests for the remainder of our long-lived assets to be held and used were not required. On a quarterly basis, we review our long-lived assets to identify events or changes in circumstances that could potentially impact recoverability of the underlying carrying values. When such events or changes are identified, we review all relevant information before concluding that the asset’s carrying amount may not be recoverable. The factors we consider may include, but are not limited to, the following:

The estimated duration of an adverse event or change in circumstances (i.e., short-term versus long-term) relative to the asset’s remaining useful life;

Changes in hydrocarbon reserve estimates that impact long-term throughput volumes on the affected assets and production forecasts (i.e. the timing of crude oil and natural gas production volumes) that are influenced by energy commodity prices;

The expiration of any material contractual terms (particularly those associated with minimum volume commitments or minimum cash payments), contract renegotiations that have a material adverse effect on future cash flows, and a change in our expectations regarding contract renewals;

An analysis of payback periods relative to an asset’s remaining useful life. Payback period represents a quotient where an asset’s carrying amount (i.e., the numerator) is divided by an annual cash flow amount

(i.e., the denominator). We may consider both actual and budgeted cash flows in our analysis. As a sensitivity analysis, we may reduce the annual cash flow amount to consider customer-specific credit risk (i.e., customers that have sub-investment grade credit ratings), the renegotiation or non-renewal of contracts, or other known events;

A comparison of year-over-year cash flows and throughput volumes (both actual and budgeted amounts) to assess the impact of changing economic conditions; and

Material changes in the use or physical condition of our long-lived assets (e.g., obsolescence).

On page 98 of our Form 10-K, we provide two examples of events or changes in circumstances that may impact our long-term cash flows:

(i) production declines that are not replaced by new discoveries; and (ii) long-term decreases in the demand or price of natural gas, NGLs, crude oil, petrochemicals or refined products. A production decline that is not replaced by new discoveries represents the depletion of a crude oil or natural gas resource base. We believe that each of the major supply basins connected to our long-lived assets have sufficient crude oil and/or natural gas reserves to support long-term throughput volumes on our material assets for at least their remaining useful lives.

Our expectations regarding short-term and long-term changes in the demand or price of energy commodities are discussed on pages 68-71 of our Form 10-K. As noted, the global supply of hydrocarbons began to exceed demand in 2014, which resulted in a dramatic decline in energy commodity prices from 2014 to 2015. In response to the lower energy commodity prices, domestic producers began to reduce their drilling activity in 2015. Many producers have announced that additional reductions in drilling activity will occur in 2016, and most forecasters predict that production of crude oil and natural gas in the U.S. could decline in the range of 5% to 10% during 2016. However, certain supply basins may experience production declines that exceed the forecasted range.

In contrast to the negative impacts on upstream energy producers, we also discuss how lower energy commodity prices are contributing to an increase in energy demand by individual consumers and energy intensive industries (e.g., steel manufacturing and petrochemicals). We believe that an increase in demand for crude oil, natural gas and

NGLs from these types of industries, along with other positive consumer-driven demand responses to lower prices, will balance crude oil supply and demand fundamentals by the end of 2016. Furthermore, we believe that as U.S. supply and demand for natural gas and certain NGLs becomes more balanced over the next few years through exports and incremental demand from new or expanded ethylene facilities that the prices of these energy commodities will stabilize and increase.

Given our expectations for the next few years, we view the current decline in energy commodity prices and drilling activity as temporary events that do not impact the recoverability of our material assets. In relation to the useful lives of our assets (i.e., which generally range from 20 to 40 years), we believe that these temporary events do not impact our assets’ ability to generate sufficient undiscounted cash flows that will recover the underlying carrying values. Further, we do not believe that these temporary events will have a material impact on the long-term development of the underlying crude oil and natural gas resource bases that will support our assets’ ability to generate cash flows for the remainder of their useful lives. Lastly, we believe that our long-term contracts serve to insulate our material assets from this period of temporary declines in energy commodity prices and drilling activity.

The majority of our long-lived assets generate fee-based revenues that are not directly impacted by fluctuations in energy commodity prices. These assets are supported by long-term contracts that may provide for minimum cash payments (e.g., demand and reservation fees paid regardless of whether or not the customer uses our services, or deficiency fees paid if a customer does not meet a contractual specified volume commitment) or the dedication of volumes produced within certain geographical boundaries (i.e., acreage dedications). For example, substantially all of the midstream energy assets we constructed in recent years were done so after our customers committed to long-term contracts with minimum cash payments.

Please quantify for us the long-lived assets associated with each of your supply basins and/or regions as well as the long-lived assets within each region that you tested for impairment during fiscal 2015. Explain to us in sufficient detail how you determined such tested assets were not impaired. For material asset groups tested for impairment, tell us the significant estimates and assumptions used in your tests and how such estimates and assumptions were determined. Quantify for us the long-lived assets considered at risk of impairment at the end of fiscal 2015.

Response:

The following table presents the carrying amounts of our long-lived assets at December 31, 2015 by region as well as the long-lived assets to be held and used within each region that we tested for impairment during fiscal 2015 (dollars in millions):

Total

Tested for

Impairment

Assets that derive economic benefit from a single supply basin summarized by region:

Rocky Mountains

$

3,659.4

South Eastern New Mexico / West Texas

1,004.9

Southern Oklahoma / North & South Texas

2,575.4

East Texas / North Louisiana

1,849.0

1,662.1

Southern Louisiana / Mississippi / Alabama

380.8

Assets that derive economic benefit from multiple supply basins

26,602.4

Total long-lived assets

36,071.9

We tested our Haynesville Gathering System and our Fairplay Gathering System for impairment during 2015. A third asset group to be held and used was also tested; however, it is immaterial to our consolidated financial position and results of operations. Undiscounted estimated cash flows were forecasted for each of these asset groups, which we then compared to the respective asset carrying amounts. The sum of the undiscounted estimated cash flows forecasted for our Haynesville and Fairplay Gathering Systems exceeded the asset carrying amounts by more than 100% and approximately 70%, respectively. Based on our analysis of undiscounted estimated cash flows and comparisons to asset carrying amounts, we concluded that the carrying values of these asset groups are recoverable.

The significant estimates and assumptions used to forecast undiscounted estimated cash flows in our impairment tests for the Haynesville and

Fairplay Gathering Systems are primarily our natural gas gathering volume forecasts and the gathering fees applied to forecasted volumes. Management prepares long-term volume forecasts for multiple purposes including analyzing potential capital investments, acquisitions, divestitures and impairment testing. The Haynesville and Fairplay Gathering Systems are both supported by long-term, fee-based contracts, some of which include minimum cash payments. As such, the gathering fees applied to forecasted volumes for our impairment tests reflected the terms of existing contracts. Beyond the terms of existing contracts, we also consider current market-based fees and our expectations for contract renewals when estimating natural gas gathering fees.

We employ a team of geologists and engineers (i.e., our Supply Appraisal group) whose primary responsibilities are estimating the crude oil and natural gas resource bases of U.S. supply basins and forecasting the hydrocarbon production that will supply throughput volumes for our assets. These individuals have decades of experience forecasting hydrocarbon supplies in the U.S., hold industry certifications (e.g., Certified Petroleum Geologist) and contribute to industry organizations that publish hydrocarbon-related estimates. Our Supply Appraisal group routinely reviews publicly available information

(e.g., data published by the Energy Information Association, information disclosed by crude oil and natural gas producers, etc.) and producer forecasts provided to us under confidentiality agreements. The experience and knowledge held by our Supply

Appraisal group makes them uniquely qualified to prepare long-term volume forecasts for our impairment tests.

Based on our quarterly reviews to identify events or changes in circumstances that could potentially impact recoverability of our asset carrying values and the results of our impairment testing completed during 2015, we concluded that none of our material long-lived assets were considered at risk of impairment at December 31, 2015.

Although your disclosures on page 69 indicate that the Barnett, Fayetteville, and Haynesville regions may experience natural gas production declines in 2016, your disclosures on page 71 indicate that such regions

“could experience an increase in drilling activity to maintain, and potentially increase, their future production levels.” Please revise your disclosures to clarify any perceived inconsistencies between these statements.

Response:

We note the Staff’s comment; however, we believe that when both statements are read in context, there are no inconsistencies. The statement on page 69 of our Form 10-K discusses circumstances that are specific to fiscal 2016. Whereas, the statement on page 71 of our Form 10-K discusses events and circumstances that we believe will occur over the next few years.

In response to the foregoing Staff comments, Enterprise acknowledges that:

the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Jul 11, 2016

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2014

2015-05-12 to 2015-07-29 · 6 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2015-07-29
Liquidity and cashLegal and contingenciesIncome taxesAcquisitionsDerivatives and hedging
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked
We note that in connection with Step 1 of the Oiltanking acquisition, you entered into a put option with the ultimate parent company of Oiltanking Holding Americas, Inc. (“OTA”), whereby you granted the parent the option to sell to you 100% of the issued and outstanding capital stock of OTA at any time within a specified period commencing in 2020.
Rest of the question

Please explain the business purpose of the put option and describe any tax or liquidity objectives of the option as well as the benefits to each of the parties. Please explain how you view such option from an accounting standpoint, including whether it represents a free standing derivative and the entries to initially record it and any future entries. Please also tell us what consideration was given to classification of the shares subject to the put option as mezzanine equity pursuant to ASR 268. On a separate note, we note that the $119.4 million liability recognized for the Liquidity Option Agreement represents the “the present value of estimated federal and state income tax payments that we would make on the taxable income of OTA, a corporation, over a stated period of time following exercise of the option.” Since consideration paid under the put option would approximate the then-current average fair value of your units owned by OTA, please help us understand why a liability is necessary under GAAP for the tax aspect of the agreement. Please be detailed in your explanation. In addition, please explain to us in greater detail how you were able to accurately estimate future federal and state tax payments for 2020 and beyond. In doing so, tell us the exact “stated period of time” included in your present value calculations and how and why you determined that timeframe was appropriate. Please also clarify if you would have the ability to avoid or postpone future tax obligations by dissolving OTA upon exercise of the put. Please cite any authoritative accounting guidance you utilized in determining your accounting treatment. We may have further comment.

EPD answered
On October 1, 2014, we acquired the general partner of Oiltanking Partners, L.P. (“Oiltanking”) and related incentive distribution rights and approximately 65.9% of the limited partner interests in Oiltanking from OTA, a Delaware corporation, and its affiliates. We paid total consideration of approximately $4.4 billion to OTA and its affiliates comprised of approximately $2.2 billion in cash and 54.8 million EPD common units for these ownership interests and rights.
Rest of the answer

Collectively, we refer to this transaction as “Step 1” of the Oiltanking acquisition.

The Step 1 transaction was treated as a partnership contribution transaction for U.S. federal income tax purposes, such that OTA and Marquard & Bahls (“M&B,” a German corporation and the ultimate parent company of OTA) were able to defer recognition of any taxable gain with respect to the equity consideration we issued. The taxable gain (or “built-in gain”) represents the difference between (i) OTA’s historical tax basis in the interests we acquired in Step 1 and (ii) the fair market value at October 1, 2014 of the EPD common units OTA received in Step 1.

In connection with Step 1, we entered into a put option (the “Liquidity Option”) with OTA and M&B, whereby we granted M&B the option to sell us 100% of the issued and outstanding capital stock of OTA at any time within a 90-day period commencing on February 1, 2020, or prior to the exercise period upon the occurrence of certain trigger events. At the time of exercise, we expect that OTA’s only significant asset will be any remaining EPD common units it received in connection with Step 1 that have not been previously disposed of by OTA, including sales on the open market made pursuant to a registration rights agreement between OTA and EPD, together with certain deferred tax liabilities.

The Liquidity Option, which was negotiated by M&B, would permit M&B indirectly to dispose of any remaining equity consideration we issued to OTA in Step 1, assuming that M&B has not caused OTA to liquidate the EPD common units held by OTA prior to exercise of the option. M&B’s ability to dispose of any such remaining equity consideration, as well as other assets and liabilities of OTA, in a tax efficient manner enhances the liquidity of M&B, hence the name “Liquidity Option.”

From our perspective, the Liquidity Option was not viewed as a material component of the Step 1 transaction. Rather, its execution was necessary in order to entice M&B to consummate the transaction by providing M&B with an additional means to achieve liquidity.

(b)

Please explain how you view such option from an accounting standpoint, including whether it represents a free standing derivative and the entries to initially record it and any future entries.

Response:

In connection with Step 1 of the Oiltanking acquisition, M&B received the Liquidity Option that, if exercised, will require us to purchase all of M&B’s equity interest in OTA. We view the Liquidity Option as freestanding and not embedded in the EPD common units held directly by OTA. The determination of whether an instrument or feature is freestanding or embedded is largely dependent on the specific facts and circumstances surrounding a transaction, and also involved judgment by our management. Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) 480-10-20 defines a “freestanding financial instrument” as a financial instrument that meets either of the following conditions:

§

It is entered into separately and apart from any of the entity’s other financial instruments or equity transactions; or

It is entered into in conjunction with some other transaction and is legally detachable and separately exercisable.

In our evaluation of the Liquidity Option as a freestanding financial instrument, we considered whether it could be considered embedded in the EPD common units held directly by OTA. Pursuant to the second bullet point above, a financial instrument entered into in conjunction with some other transaction must be legally detachable and separately exercisable to be considered a freestanding instrument. Although entered into contemporaneously in conjunction with Step 1 of our acquisition of Oiltanking, the Liquidity Option held by M&B is on M&B’s equity interest in OTA, not on the EPD common units held directly by OTA, and therefore is legally detachable from the EPD common units as OTA is a separate legal entity from M&B and OTA may hold assets and liabilities other than EPD common units (e.g. deferred tax balances). In addition, the Liquidity Option is separately exercisable from the EPD common units as M&B has the ability to cause OTA to sell, exchange or distribute the EPD common units held by OTA to another entity at any time, resulting in the potential sale of EPD common units by OTA prior to the exercise of the Liquidity Option.

Considering that upon exercise of the Liquidity Option, we expect the only significant asset that will be held by OTA will be the EPD common units, we considered whether the option on M&B’s equity interest in OTA is effectively the same as an option on the EPD common units held by OTA. ASC 480 does not provide much interpretive guidance on the definition of a “freestanding” financial instrument. The guidance states that determining whether a financial instrument is embedded or freestanding involves substantial judgment and an understanding of the form and substance of the transaction. Factors that are important to assess are whether the instrument is (i) legally detachable and (ii) separately exercisable. Those concepts can be further described as follows:

Legally detachable — generally, whether two instruments can be legally separated and transferred such that the two components may be held by different parties.

Separately exercisable — generally, whether one instrument can be exercised without terminating the other instrument (e.g., through redemption, simultaneous exercise or expiration).

If the exercise of one instrument must result in the termination of the other, the instruments would generally not be considered freestanding pursuant to ASC 480. Alternatively, if one instrument can be exercised while the other instrument continues to be outstanding, the instruments would be considered freestanding under ASC 480.

Since the EPD common units held by OTA are effectively redeemed upon exercise of the Liquidity Option, the above guidance might suggest that the option would not be freestanding. However, we ultimately rejected this view because OTA not only holds the EPD common units, but it also is expected to have a significant deferred tax liability. We believe that, if exercised, the Liquidity Option conveys to us more than just EPD common units held by OTA, and the option is legally detachable and separately exercisable from the EPD common units. Therefore, we concluded the Liquidity Option is a freestanding financial instrument.

Given that the Liquidity Option is a freestanding financial instrument, we first evaluated whether the option meets the definition of a derivative pursuant to ASC 815. ASC 815-10-15-83 defines a derivative financial instrument as a financial instrument or other contract with all of the following characteristics:

Underlying, notional amount, payment provision – The contract has both of the following terms, which determine the amount of the settlement or settlements, and, in some cases, whether or not a settlement is required:

a)

One or more underlyings; and b)

One or more notional amounts or payment provisions or both.

Initial net investment – The contract requires no initial net investment or an initial net investment that is smaller than would be required for other types of contracts that would be expected to have a similar response to changes in market factors.

Net settlement – The contract can be settled net by any of the following means:

Its terms implicitly or explicitly require or permit net settlement;

It can readily be settled net by a means outside the contract; or c)

It provides for delivery of an asset that puts the recipient in a position not substantially different from net settlement.

As stated in ASC 815-10-15-83, all of the criteria above must be met in order for a financial instrument to meet the definition of a derivative instrument. The Liquidity Option does not meet the net settlement criterion listed above as the Liquidity Option cannot be readily settled net by means outside of the Liquidity Option Agreement because there is no market mechanism to facilitate a settlement outside of the agreement.

Further, the Liquidity Option is not exchange-traded and an over-the-counter market for such contracts does not exist. As there is no market mechanism to net settle the instrument outside its contractual terms, and since OTA, as a wholly owned subsidiary of M&B, is a private company, the OTA capital stock underlying the Liquidity Option is not publicly traded and hence is not considered readily convertible to cash.

As the Liquidity Option does not provide for explicit or implicit net settlement, cannot be readily settled net by a means outside of the Liquidity Option Agreement, and does not provide for delivery of an asset that is readily convertible to cash, the Liquidity Option does not satisfy the net settlement criterion (c) in ASC 815-10-15-83. As ASC 815-10-15-83 requires all criteria to be met, consideration of criterion (a) and (b) was not deemed necessary, and therefore we concluded the Liquidity Option does not meet the definition of a derivative.

An equity-linked financial instrument that does not meet the definition of a derivative instrument in ASC 815 should be evaluated under ASC 815-40-15-7 to determine whether it is subject to the classification and measurement guidance in ASC 815-40-25. ASC 815-40-15-7 applies to equity-linked freestanding financial instruments (or embedded features) that are not within the scope of ASC 718 or ASC 480-10. Examples of equity-linked instruments include stock purchase warrants, convertible debt, convertible preferred stock, call and put options on equity securities, and forward contracts to purchase or sell equity securities.

If the equity-linked instrument is indexed to the reporting entity's stock under ASC 815-40-15-7, it is within the scope of ASC 815-40-25 (i.e., it is classified and measured in accordance with ASC 815-40-25). If the equity-linked instrument is not indexed to the reporting entity's stock under ASC 815-40-15-7, it is not within the scope of ASC 815-40-25.

As the Liquidity Option is on the OTA capital stock rather than the EPD common units received by OTA in Step 1, the fair value of the OTA capital stock is impacted by items other than the market value of EPD common units, such as any other liabilities held by OTA (e.g., deferred taxes). Therefore, we concluded that the Liquidity Option is not indexed to the market price of EPD common units under ASC 815-40-15-7. For a financial instrument to be deemed to be indexed to an entity’s own stock, paragraph 15-7C of ASC 815-40 requires the following:

“An instrument (or embedded feature) shall be considered indexed to an entity's own stock if its settlement amount will equal the difference between the following:

The fair value of a fixed number of the entity's equity shares

A fixed monetary amount or a fixed amount of a debt instrument issued by the entity”

Since the exercise and settlement of the Liquidity Option results in us receiving capital stock in OTA (which we expect will have significant deferred tax liabilities related to its ownership of its EPD common units received in Step 1), we determined that the Liquidity Option does not meet criterion (a) above.

We also considered whether the guidance in ASC 718 should apply given the potential (at our discretion) for settlement of the Liquidity Option through the issuance of new EPD common units. After examining each of the share-based payment transactions described within ASC 718, we determined that the exchange of new EPD common units for OTA capital stock upon settlement of the Liquidity Option is not within the scope of ASC 718.

The accounting literature within 815-40-15 indicates that an equity-linked freestanding financial instrument that is not within the scope of ASC 718, ASC 480-10, or ASC 815 is not subject to the classification and measurement guidance in ASC 815-40-25 if the instrument is not considered indexed to the reporting entity's equity securities. Given that ASC 815-40 precludes equity classification for such an instrument, we determined that we should classify the Liquidity Option as a liability, initially recognized at fair value and subsequently marked to fair value through earnings in accordance with ASC 815-10-S99-4.

The accounting entry, as part of the provisional purchase price allocation, to initially record the Liquidity Option was as follows:

DR. Goodwill

$119.4 million

CR. Liquidity Option Agreement Liability

Each reporting period thereafter until the Liquidity Option expires or is exercised, we will record the following entry to adjust the option to its fair value:

DR./CR. Liquidity Option Agreement Liability

$xxx

DR./CR. Gain/Loss on change in fair value of Liquidity Option

If the Liquidity Option is exercised, we believe the substance of the transaction is the acquisition of treasury stock within the scope of ASC 505-30 in addition to the settlement of an existing liability (the Liquidity Option Agreement Liability). Upon exercise of the Liquidity Option, the Liquidity Option Agreement Liability is extinguished and deferred tax liabilities associated with the acquisition of OTA will be measured and recorded in accordance with ASC 740. More specifically, the entry to be recorded upon exercise of the option is as follows:

DR. Liquidity Option Agreement Liability (1)

DR. Treasury Stock (EPD common units indirectly acquired) (2) xxx

CR. Deferred Tax Liabilities (liabilities indirectly acquired) (3)

CR. Cash/EPD Common Units (consideration upon exercise of option) (4)

_________________

(1)

Amount would be the then current book value of the option liability

(2)

Represents the net of (i) proceeds paid to acquire capital stock of OTA (cash/units and assumption of tax liability) and (ii) settlement of option liability (ASC 505-30)

(3)

Measured in accordance with ASC 740

(4)

The fair value of any newly issued units would be measured in accordance with ASC 845

(c)

Please also tell us what consideration was given to classification of the shares subject to the put option as mezzanine equity pursuant to ASR 268.

Response:

The EPD common units held by OTA are not liabilities under ASC 480-10, nor do they meet the criteria provided within Commission Accounting Series Release No. 268 (“Release No. 268”) (FRR Section 211), Redeemable Preferred Stocks, as interpreted by ASC 480-10-S99-3A, (formerly Emerging Issues Task Force (“EITF”) D-Topic No. 98 (Classification and Measurement of Redeemable Securities) (“Topic D-98”)), which would require “mezzanine equity” classification outside of permanent equity. Since settlement of the Liquidity Option and the resulting indirect acquisition of the EPD common units would meet the requirements within ASC 815-40, formerly EITF Issue 00-19, Accounting for Derivative Financial Instruments Indexed to, and Potentially Settled in, a Company's Own Stock (“Issue 00-19”), permanent equity classification is appropriate.

In reaching this conclusion, we first considered whether the EPD common units held by OTA meet any of the criteria described in ASC 480-10 to be classified as liabilities. ASC 480-10 applies to the following forms of freestanding financial instruments: 1) mandatorily redeemable instruments unless redemption is required to occur only upon liquidation or termination of the entity, 2) financial instruments other than shares which represent an obligation to repurchase an issuer’s equity shares by transferring assets and 3) a financial instrument representing an unconditional obligation, or a financial instrument other than an outstanding share that embodies an unconditional obligation, that an issuer may settle by issuing a variable number of shares of its own equity if at inception the obligation meets certain specified criteria.

The EPD common units held by OTA do not meet any of the criteria described in ASC 480-10, and thus do not represent a financial instrument within the scope of liability accounting guidance provided therein. Each of the ASC 480-10 criteria provided above has been assessed as follows:

Mandatorily redeemable financial instruments – No mandatory redemption exists. Indirect acquisition of the EPD common units held by OTA is conditional and is allowable only in specific situations including at M&B’s option upon the occurrence of a trigger event, or at M&B’s sole discretion during the exercise period.

Obligations to repurchase issuer’s equity shares by transferring assets – This criterion only applies to instruments other than outstanding shares. As the EPD common units held by OTA are outstanding “shares,” this criterion does not apply.

Certain obligations to issue a variable number of shares – If settled in EPD common units, the number of EPD common units to be issued to M&B is fixed to the remaining EPD common units held by OTA at the time of exercise of the Liquidity Option. The indirect acquisition of the EPD common units does not encompass any obligations that would cause us to issue a variable number of units.

Since liability classification under ASC 480-10 does not apply to the EPD common units held by OTA, the guidance within ASC 480-10-S99-3A (Release No. 268) and Topic D-98 should be assessed to determine whether “mezzanine equity” treatment is necessary. Note that application of Release No. 268 and Topic D-98 are required to be assessed for publicly traded companies whose securities are registered with the Commission. Our securities are registered with the Commission, and thus the provisions of Release No. 268 and Topic D-98 apply. Paragraph 2 of Topic D-98 states the following:

“Rule 5-02.28 of Regulation S-X requires preferred securities that are redeemable for cash or other assets to be classified outside of permanent equity if they are redeemable (1) at a fixed or determinable price on a fixed or determinable date, (2) at the option of the holder, or (3) upon the occurrence of an event that is not solely within the control of the issuer. Although the rule specifically describes and discusses preferred securities, the SEC staff believes that Rule 5-02.28 of Regulation S-X also provides analogous guidance for other equity instruments including, for example, common stock, derivative instruments, noncontrolling interests, and share based payment arrangements that are classified as equity pursuant to FASB Statement No. 123 (revised 2004), Share Based Payments.”

Each of the provisions provided above have been assessed as follows:

Fixed or determinable price on a fixed or determinable date – This provision is not applicable as the EPD common units held by OTA are not mandatorily redeemable on a fixed or determinable date. M&B holds the option to transfer its OTA stock to us. Because OTA’s sole asset is expected to consist of EPD units, this amounts to an ability to indirectly redeem the EPD common units (through exercise of the Liquidity Option) in full, or in part, during the exercise period at the strike price on the exercise date or upon the occurrence of a trigger event. However, the ultimate date at which the shares may be redeemed is not contractually fixed or set, and the redemption right is entirely within the discretion of M&B to exercise.

At the option of the holder – This provision is not applicable as M&B does not hold an unconditional redemption option. M&B may indirectly, through a put of OTA shares, put the EPD common units back to us only during the exercise period or upon the occurrence of certain trigger events. However, we have discretion as to the form of payment to the holders (e.g., either in EPD common units or cash).

Upon the occurrence of an event that is not solely within the control of the issuer – As discussed above, M&B has the ability indirectly, through a put of OTA shares, to redeem the EPD common units through exercise of the Liquidity Option during the exercise period or upon the occurrence of certain trigger events. When the redemption right is exercised during the exercise period, we are given the option to settle the redemption through the issuance of EPD common units or cash.

However, if M&B exercises its redemption right upon the occurrence of a trigger event, we are required to deliver cash to M&B in exchange for the OTA capital stock.

To analyze the second and third provisions further, we first considered the nature of events which would cause control over whether to settle in cash or EPD common units to not rest with us (i.e., through a change of control). Any event, circumstance, or transaction, except for ordinary liquidation events, which could cause a trigger event to occur are all under our control. If we were required to settle with M&B only through the issuance of cash, we would be required to classify the shares outside of permanent equity (e.g. “mezzanine equity”). However, paragraph 6 of Topic D-98 states the following [emphasis added]:

“Some financial instruments issued in the form of shares that are not required to be classified as assets or liabilities under Statement 150 or other applicable GAAP are redeemable at the option of the holder or upon the occurrence of an event that is not solely within the control of the issuer. Upon redemption of these financial instruments in other than an ordinary liquidation or deemed liquidation that meets the exception in paragraph 5), the issuer may be required or may have a choice to settle the contract by delivery of its own shares. For these instruments, the guidance in paragraphs 12–32 of Issue No. 00-19, "Accounting for Derivative Financial Instruments Indexed to, and Potentially Settled in, a Company's Own Stock," should be used to evaluate whether the issuer controls the actions or events necessary to issue the maximum number of shares that could be required to be delivered under share settlement of the contract. If the issuer does not control settlement by delivery of its own shares, cash settlement of the instrument would be presumed and the instrument would be classified as temporary equity. For example, if preferred shares are redeemable at the option of the holder (that is, puttable shares) and the issuer is permitted to settle the redemption amount in cash or by delivery of a variable number of its common shares with an equivalent value, the absence of a cap on the number of common shares that could be potentially issuable upon redemption requires classification of the preferred shares outside of permanent equity.”

In consideration of this guidance, we determined that if we can establish that the criteria in paragraphs 1232 of Issue No. 00-19 (codified within ASC 815-40-25-10) are met, we may classify the common units as permanent equity. However, in the case the provisions are not met, classification as “mezzanine equity” would be appropriate. Each of the requirements from paragraphs 12-32 have been further assessed as follows. Note that the purpose of each of these assessments is to ultimately ensure that no conditions exist which might require us to net cash settle the conversion of OTA capital stock by M&B.

The contract permits the company to settle in unregistered shares – Met. We believe that we will be able to settle the potential indirect acquisition of the EPD common units held by OTA through the issuance of unregistered EPD common units to M&B.

The company has sufficient authorized and unissued shares available to settle the contract after considering all other commitments that may require the issuance of stock during the maximum period the derivative contract could remain outstanding – Met. We have sufficient authorized and unissued units available to settle the potential indirect acquisition of the EPD common units.

The contract contains an explicit limit on the number of shares to be delivered in a share settlement – Met. The Liquidity Option Agreement limits the number of units to be issued to the same number of EPD common units held by OTA on the date of exercise.

There are no required cash payments to the counterparty in the event the company fails to make timely filings with the SEC – Met. The Liquidity Option Agreement does not require net-cash settlement in the event that we do not make timely filings with the Commission.

There are no required cash payments to the counterparty if the shares initially delivered upon settlement are subsequently sold by the counterparty and the sales proceeds are insufficient to provide the counterparty with full return of the amount due (that is, there are no cash settled “top-off” or “make-whole” provisions) – Met. There are no “top-off” or “make-whole” provisions specified in Liquidity Option Agreement.

The contract requires net-cash settlement only in specific circumstances in which holders of shares underlying the contract also would receive cash in exchange for their shares – Met. The Liquidity Option Agreement requires cash settlement only in the occurrence of a trigger event, which is under our control, or an ordinary liquidation event, at which OTA would be paid out in ranking order preference along with other interest holders.

There are no provisions in the contract that indicate that the counterparty has rights that rank higher than those of a shareholder of the stock underlying the contract – Met. There are no provisions in the Liquidity Option Agreement that indicate M&B or OTA has rights that rank higher than those of other EPD common unit holders.

There is no requirement in the contract to post collateral at any point or for any reason – Met. There is no requirement in the Liquidity Option Agreement to post collateral at any point or for any reason.

We then considered whether any of the defined trigger events would cause us to not control the settlement of the Liquidity Option and the indirect acquisition of EPD common units held by OTA by delivery of our own EPD common units to M&B. However, as stated above, each of the trigger events are within our control. Therefore, based on the analysis above we concluded that the EPD common units held by OTA should be classified as permanent equity.

(d)

On a separate note, we note that the $119.4 million liability recognized for the Liquidity Option Agreement represents the “the present value of estimated federal and state income tax payments that we would make on the taxable income of OTA, a corporation, over a stated period of time following exercise of the option.” Since consideration paid under the put option would approximate the then-current average fair value of your units owned by OTA, please help us understand why a liability is necessary under GAAP for the tax aspect of the agreement. Please be detailed in your explanation.

Response:

Exercising the Liquidity Option requires us to pay consideration in exchange for the capital stock of OTA. We expect that OTA’s assets and liabilities at the closing of any exercise of the Liquidity Option will consist of the EPD common units it received in Step 1 (to the extent not sold by OTA prior to exercise of the Liquidity Option) and deferred tax balances, respectively. The aggregate consideration to be paid by us for OTA’s capital stock would equal 100% of the then-current fair market value of the EPD common units owned by OTA at the exercise date (the “Strike Price”). As a result of acquiring OTA’s capital stock, we would indirectly acquire the EPD common units owned by OTA and assume all future income tax obligations of OTA associated with (i) owning common units encumbered by the entity-level taxes of a U.S. corporation and (ii) OTA’s tax liabilities resulting from a difference in the book and tax basis of such common units. Since the Strike Price is based solely on the fair market value of EPD common units and is not reduced to account for future income tax obligations, the Liquidity Option represents an acquired potential obligation from an economic standpoint.

We then analyzed the Liquidity Option to determine whether the accounting treatment should result in equity or liability classification on the balance sheet and the resulting timing of the related accounting entries. In our response to item (b) above, we explained our accounting analysis and conclusion that the Liquidity Option does not meet the definition of a derivative pursuant to ASC 815, does not meet the definition of an equity-linked freestanding financial instrument that should be classified as equity on our financial statements, and is not within the scope of ASC 718.

The accounting literature within 815-40-15 indicates that an equity-linked freestanding financial instrument that is not within the scope of ASC 718, ASC 480-10, or ASC 815 is not subject to the classification and measurement guidance in ASC 815-40-25 if the instrument is not considered indexed to the reporting entity's stock. Given that ASC 815-40 precludes equity classification for such an instrument, we determined that we should classify the Liquidity Option as a liability, initially and subsequently recognized at fair value in accordance with ASC 815-10-S99-4.

This is supported by statements made by an SEC staff member at the 2003 AICPA National Conference on Current SEC Developments, who indicated that when a written option based on share prices is not subject to a specific measurement attribute based on other applicable GAAP, a registrant should initially and subsequently measure the written option at fair value, with changes in fair value recorded in earnings in each reporting period. This further supports our accounting position taken with respect to the initial recording of the Liquidity Option liability.

In arriving at this accounting conclusion that the Liquidity Option should be treated as a liability, we also considered two alternative viewpoints as follows:

Alternative Viewpoint #1

Since the Liquidity Option was entered into as part of a business combination and will have a negative value to us if it is exercised, we considered whether the Liquidity Option should be accounted for as contingent consideration under ASC 805-20-25.

However, since the accounting for contingent consideration is to record the consideration at fair value both at inception and subsequently until the contingency is settled (ASC 805-30-25), the accounting would be no different than following the written option guidance cited above.

Alternative Viewpoint #2

As the exercise of the Liquidity Option will result in our indirect acquisition of our own EPD common units and a deferred tax liability associated with those common units in exchange for the issuance of up to the same number of common units acquired (or cash, at our option), we considered whether the Liquidity Option is effectively the acquisition of a deferred tax liability and therefore should be recognized, classified and measured in accordance with principles in ASC 740 as part of the business combination. Under this alternative view, any recognizable deferred tax balances recorded on OTA’s financial statements under ASC 740 would be used to measure and recognize the Liquidity Option liability on our financial statements as we will ultimately inherit such obligations upon exercise of the Liquidity Option.

Because the measurement of deferred taxes under ASC 740 is not a fair value measure (deferred tax balances are recorded based on gross, rather than discounted, cash flows) this alternative view would cause the Liquidity Option liability to be classified and measured differently (as a tax liability measured at something other than fair value).

We ultimately rejected this alternative view based on the following:

Any deferred tax liability or other obligation recognized by OTA based on OTA’s investment in EPD common units is ultimately an obligation of OTA and is not our obligation prior to the Liquidity Option being exercised.

M&B is not required to exercise the Liquidity Option, and therefore there is no certainty that any deferred tax obligation of OTA would ultimately become our obligation in the future.

Therefore, we concluded we should not recognize any tax obligation (through the application of ASC 740) under the alternative view described above as part of the business combination. Instead, the liability is recognized at fair value, based on a discounted analysis of estimated future cash tax payments, using an income approach as described in response to item (e) below.

(e)

In addition, please explain to us in greater detail how you were able to accurately estimate future federal and state tax payments for 2020 and beyond. In doing so, tell us the exact “stated period of time” included in your present value calculations and how and why you determined that timeframe was appropriate.

Response:

We prepared a provisional fair value estimate for the Liquidity Option Agreement at December 31, 2014 using the income approach, specifically, a discounted cash flow analysis. The market and cost approaches to valuation are not relevant in this fact pattern. Our view is that a market participant would acknowledge the existence of OTA’s built-in tax gain and that the associated income taxes on such gain would need to be paid in the future. We believe that a market participant would develop tax mitigation strategies that would allow for the long-term deferral of the tax impact of any built-in gain. The long-term nature of our forecast period is consistent with how we believe market participants evaluate opportunities involving investments and projects associated with master limited partnerships. The application of the income approach was considered the best methodology to enable us to quantify the estimated fair value of future tax payments associated with ownership of OTA.

In order to capture the long-term nature of the tax mitigation strategies being modeled, we forecasted OTA’s cash flows over a 30-year period following exercise of the Liquidity Option (i.e., through 2050). Corporations such as OTA can remain in existence for many decades with no legal impediments. We believe that the 30-year time horizon reflected in our modeling is appropriate since a reasonable market participant would choose to maintain the OTA corporate structure and continue to legally defer the tax liability over a long-term period.

Our discounted cash flow analysis is based on a forecast of the estimated federal and state income tax payments that we expect would be required on OTA’s taxable income, including recognition of the built-in gain amounts. Prior to the projected dissolution of OTA in 2050, OTA’s taxable income would be based on an allocation of a portion of our partnership’s taxable income to the EPD common units held by OTA (following exercise of the Liquidity Option) and reflect any tax mitigation strategies we believe could be employed by OTA to allow the long-term deferral of a substantial portion of its tax obligation associated with the built-in gains.

Our analysis begins with an estimate of our taxable income over the forecast period. As a flow-through entity, our taxable income, which reflects tax depreciation and amortization amounts, is allocated among our limited partners, including a proportionate share to our common units held by OTA. The allocation of such amounts represents OTA’s taxable income, before the impact of tax mitigation strategies. The forecast of OTA’s taxable income was further reduced by interest expense associated with OTA’s expected assumption of approximately $2.2 billion of long-term debt (30-year maturity) from Enterprise Products Operating LLC immediately after the option is exercised.

We applied an assumed aggregate federal and state income tax rate of 38% to OTA’s resulting taxable income to determine its estimated tax payments in each period. The cash distributions that OTA receives from its EPD common units would enable OTA to meet its recurring tax obligations during the forecast period.

We believe the information gathered as of December 31, 2014 provides a reasonable basis for estimating the fair value of the Liquidity Option; however, we were awaiting the availability of certain 2014 federal income tax return calculations that are necessary to finalize our fair value estimate. As such, our provisional estimate was subject to change. Furthermore, subsequent changes in the fair value of this option (other than those attributable to the finalization of our provisional estimate) will be recorded in earnings each reporting period until the option expires or is exercised.

(f)

Please also clarify if you would have the ability to avoid or postpone future tax obligations by dissolving OTA upon exercise of the put.

Response:

We do not believe that we would be able to avoid or postpone OTA’s future tax obligations if it were dissolved upon exercise of the Liquidity Option. Dissolution of OTA would trigger the need to pay all deferred taxes at that point in time.

However, as discussed in response to comment (e) above, our view is that a market participant would acknowledge the existence of OTA’s built-in tax gain and that the associated income taxes on such gain would need to be paid in the future. We believe that a market participant would develop tax mitigation strategies that would allow for the long-term deferral of the tax impact of any built-in gain.

In response to the foregoing Staff comments, Enterprise acknowledges that:

· the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of May 21, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked (1)
We have reviewed your response to comment 1. After determining that the Liquidity Option constituted a freestanding instrument, we note that you next evaluated whether or not the instrument qualified as a derivative under ASC 815 rather than assessing if it was within the scope of ASC 480.
Rest of the question

Please provide us with your assessment of whether or not the Liquidity Option is within the scope of ASC 480, particularly ASC 480-10-25-8a. Since the aggregate consideration to be paid to settle the agreement would equal 100% of the then-current fair market value of your common units owned by OTA, please tell us your consideration of whether the Liquidity Option is indexed, on a net of tax basis, to an obligation to repurchase your units.

EPD answered
We do not believe that the Liquidity Option is within the scope of ASC 480, Distinguishing Liabilities from Equity. Our analysis considered the following topics within the scope of ASC 480:

§

The Liquidity Option does not represent a Mandatorily Redeemable Financial Instrument as described in ASC 480-10-25-4 through 25-7.
Rest of the answer

A mandatorily redeemable financial instrument embodies an unconditional obligation requiring the issuer to redeem the instrument by transferring assets at a

Austin Beijing Dallas Dubai Houston London New York Research Triangle Park The Woodlands Washington, DC specified or determinable date (or dates) or upon an event that is certain to occur. Given that exercise of the Liquidity Option is at the discretion of Marquard & Bahls (“M&B”) and is not certain to occur, the Liquidity Option is not a mandatorily redeemable financial instrument within the scope of ASC 480.

The Liquidity Option does not represent the type of agreement described in ASC 480-10-25-14, Certain Obligations to Issue a Variable Number of Shares. With respect to criteria (a) of this guidance, the monetary value of the Liquidity Option is not fixed; rather it is based on the estimated fair value of the tax obligations of Oiltanking Holding Americas, Inc. (“OTA”). With respect to criteria (b) of this guidance, there is no requirement under the Liquidity Option to issue a variable number of units to M&B. The number of units issuable to M&B under the Liquidity Option is fixed based on the number of units held by OTA at the time of exercise. Lastly, with respect to criteria (c) of this guidance, the fair value of the Liquidity Option is not inversely proportional to the fair value of the EPD units.

The Liquidity Option does not represent an Obligation to Repurchase Issuer’s Equity Shares by Transferring Assets. ASC 480-10-25-8 states the following:

An entity shall classify as a liability (or an asset in some circumstances) any financial instrument, other than an outstanding share, that, at inception, has both of the following characteristics:

a.

It embodies an obligation to repurchase the issuer’s equity shares, or is indexed to such an obligation.

If exercised, the Liquidity Option requires us to pay consideration in exchange for the capital stock of OTA; therefore, it does not embody a direct obligation to solely repurchase EPD common units. As a result of the Liquidity Option being exercised, we would acquire the net assets of OTA, which we expect would consist of EPD common units owned by OTA less the income tax obligations of OTA associated with (i) owning EPD common units encumbered by the entity-level taxes of a U.S. corporation and (ii) OTA’s tax liabilities resulting from a difference in the book and tax basis of such common units.

If the Liquidity Option is exercised (other than in a Trigger Event scenario), we expect to issue new EPD common units to M&B. The number of EPD common units issued to M&B will equal the number of EPD common units held by OTA at the time of exercise (which would be indirectly acquired by us). Following exercise of the Liquidity Option, we would effectively assume the tax obligations of OTA, which would represent an economic benefit to M&B.

The Liquidity Option is not indexed to an obligation to repurchase EPD common units. If the Liquidity Option is exercised, we will indirectly acquire both the EPD common units owned directly by OTA as well as OTA’s then-current and future tax obligations. The fair value of the Liquidity Option is based on the present value of OTA’s estimated tax obligations using various assumptions. Changes in OTA’s estimated tax obligations will not correlate with changes in the market value of EPD common units over time. OTA’s estimated tax obligations will change over time in response to changes in numerous variables, which include EPD’s future earnings and cash distributions and tax mitigation strategies, among others. Given these facts, we concluded that the Liquidity Option is not indexed to the market price of EPD common units.

b.

It requires or may require the issuer to settle the obligation by transferring assets.

We have control over the settlement method of the Liquidity Option, which may be settled either in EPD common units or in cash, including control over circumstances that would give rise to a Trigger Event. At the time of execution of the Liquidity Option agreement and through December 31, 2014, we had the ability and intent to settle the contingent obligation solely through the issuance of EPD common units. Since the Liquidity Option does not require settlement by transferring assets, we do not believe that the criteria under ASC 480-10-25-8b is met.

In conclusion, as the Liquidity Option does not have any of the characteristics of the financial instruments identified in ASC 480, we believe the Liquidity Option is not within the scope of ASC 480. Furthermore, if the Liquidity Option had been deemed within the scope of ASC 480, it would result in the same liability accounting treatment we have applied in connection with ASC 815 (i.e., fair value at inception and remeasured subsequently through earnings).

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 29, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked (2)
We note your response to comment 1 includes the journal entry you intend to record upon exercise of the Liquidity Option. Since it appears the assumed undiscounted deferred tax liabilities measured under ASC 740 will exceed the discounted value of the relieved Liquidity Option liability, we assume the amount you will be recognizing as treasury stock will exceed the value of the cash and/or units issued to settle the
Rest of the question

Liquidity Option. Please confirm if our understanding is correct and tell us your basis in GAAP for recording treasury stock in excess of its fair market value on the date of its issuance.

EPD answered
Your understanding is correct. We are applying the guidance found in ASC 505-30-30-4, which states (emphasis added):

Transactions do arise, however, in which a reacquisition of an entity’s stock may take place at prices different from routine transactions in the open market. For example, to obtain the desired number of shares in a tender offer to all or most shareholders, the offer may need to be at a price in excess of the current market price.
Rest of the answer

In addition, a block of shares representing a controlling interest will generally trade at a price in excess of market, and a large block of shares may trade at a price above or below the current market price depending on whether the buyer or seller initiates the transaction. An entity’s reacquisition of its shares in those circumstances is solely a treasury stock transaction properly accounted for at the purchase price of the treasury shares. Therefore, in the absence of the receipt of stated or unstated consideration in addition to the capital stock, the entire purchase price shall be accounted for as the cost of treasury shares.

Upon exercise of the Liquidity Option, the debit entry to treasury stock represents the fair value of the newly issued EPD common units plus our assumption of additional tax-related liabilities (i.e., the difference between the actual deferred tax liabilities of OTA and the fair value of the Liquidity Option prior to exercise). As noted previously, the fair value of the Liquidity Option is based on the present value of OTA’s estimated tax obligations using various assumptions.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 29, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked (3)
We note your response to comment 1 indicates that you believe a market participant would develop tax mitigation strategies that would allow for the long-term deferral of the tax impact of any built-in gain. We also note that if you were to acquire OTA, you could maintain the OTA corporate structure for an extended timeframe since you have the ability to issue EPD units versus liquidate assets of OTA to satisfy your
Rest of the question

liquidity needs whereas a market participant would not have the same option. Accordingly, please tell us in further detail why you also believe a market participant’s sole objective would be to maintain the OTA structure for a 30-year timeframe as opposed to possible liquidation of OTA’s EPD units at some point during the assumed 30-year timeframe.

EPD answered
We believe that a market participant who acquires common units of EPD, a publicly-traded partnership (“PTP”), by acquiring OTA, a U.S. corporation that owns such PTP units, would choose to maintain the corporate structure of OTA following acquisition for an extended time horizon due to the significant tax implications of an early divestiture of the EPD common units.
Rest of the answer

Since corporations such as OTA can remain in existence for many decades, we believe that a reasonable market participant would choose to maintain the OTA capital structure and legally defer its associated tax liabilities over a long period of time. Specifically, we hold that a market participant would develop tax mitigation strategies for OTA that would allow for the long-term deferral of the adverse tax impact of the built-in gain assumed by the buyer at acquisition. In order to capture the long-term nature of the tax mitigation strategies being modeled, our discounted cash flow analysis assumes that OTA would not be liquidated for 30 years following exercise of the Liquidity Option. We believe that the 30-year timeframe is representative of the type of long-term holding period that a market participant would adopt in this situation. Generally speaking, the 30-year period correlates with the long-term average expected useful life of our assets, from which a market participant would expect to generate distribution income.

Following exercise of the Liquidity Option, a market participant would assess the cost/benefit of liquidating OTA’s corporate structure and selling the EPD common units (and immediately paying the associated taxes) or maintaining the OTA corporate structure over a long time horizon to maximize the benefits of owning the EPD common units (e.g., receipt of regular cash distributions) and deferring the associated taxes on the underlying built-in gain assumed at acquisition. Due to the sizeable built-in gain, we believe a reasonable market participant would seek methods that would defer recognition of the gain for an indefinite period of time, similar to the life of the business enterprise and underlying assets, rather than a shorter definite period of time.

Based on projected taxable income and cash distributions from the EPD common units (excluding any tax mitigation strategies), we estimate that a market participant would be able to sustain an overall positive cash flow by holding OTA over the long-term holding period used in our financial projections. An owner of OTA would be able to continue to defer the tax on its underlying built-in gain since the estimated cash distributions received by OTA (through its ownership of the underlying EPD common units) would be in excess of the annual tax liability due on its share of EPD’s taxable income. Based on historical experience, our investors have been able to maintain such positive cash flows (typically referred to as “coverage” or “tax shield” by market participants and analysts) for a prolonged period of time. A market participant that acquires OTA would have a strong tax incentive to hold the EPD common units over an extended time horizon in order to maximize the collection of tax free cash distributions and to defer any tax obligations associated with their underlying basis in the EPD common units. As stated above, we believe that the 30-year forecast period used in our valuation model is representative of the type of long-term holding period that a market participant would adopt in this situation.

In response to the foregoing Staff comments, Enterprise acknowledges that:

· the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 29, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked (1)
We have reviewed your response to comment 2. We are still unclear why, upon exercise of the Liquidity Option, the difference between the undiscounted deferred tax liabilities recognized under ASC 740 and the relieved discounted liability should be included in treasury stock as opposed to deferred tax expense.
Rest of the question

Although the tender offer and controlling interest acquisition examples cited in ASC 505-30-30-4 each represent “solely a treasury stock transaction,” it appears your transaction is not solely a treasury stock transaction considering the transaction originated with a business combination, the transaction involves the assumption of material tax obligations and since you do not control exercise of the put option (unlike a treasury stock acquisition which is at the option of the purchaser). We also believe any premium associated with the treasury stock examples represented fair market value, whereas the excess “debit” in your case is due to the interplay between a discounted liability and a nominal deferred tax liability. Given that you recognize expense associated with changes in the fair value of the Liquidity Option and that the amount is based on a forecast of estimated tax payments and would be reversed to income in the event the option is not exercised, it seems inconsistent not to similarly reflect ultimate recognition of the deferred tax liabilities within income. Accordingly, please provide us with further evidence supporting your proposed accounting treatment upon exercise of the Liquidity Option.

EPD answered
We acknowledge your comment and would record the following journal entry if the Liquidity Option is exercised:

DR. Liquidity Option Agreement Liability (1)

$xxx

DR. Income Tax Expense (2) xxx

DR. Treasury Stock (EPD common units indirectly acquired) (3)

CR. Deferred Tax Liabilities (liabilities indirectly acquired) (4)

CR.
Rest of the answer

Cash/EPD Common Units (consideration upon exercise of option) (5)

_________________

(1)

Amount would be the then current book value of the option liability

(2)

Represents the difference between the (i) Liquidity Option Agreement Liability at the time of option exercise and (ii) the deferred tax liability assumed at the time of option exercise. Income tax expense would be recorded to the extent that the assumed deferred tax liability exceeds the then current book value of the option liability.

(3)

Equals the fair value of any newly issued EPD common units at the option exercise date as measured in accordance with ASC 845

(4)

Measured in accordance with ASC 740

(5)

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 17, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-70
SEC asked (2)
We have reviewed your response to comment 3. Please substantially expand on why you believe a marketplace participant would assume the liability and relinquish the option to liquidate its position prior to the 30-year timeframe assumed in your valuation. Explain why, for example, a 1, 5, 10, 15 or 20-year timeframe would not be a more appropriate assumption given the “liquidity preference” of investors.
Rest of the question

Also tell us how your fair value measurement incorporated a risk premium reflecting the amount that a market participant would demand for the uncertainty inherent in the cash flows of holding the OTA stock and collecting the distributions for 30 years then selling the units and incurring a tax obligation. In this regard, show us the internal rate of return calculation of holding OTA stock for 30 years and why it would represent a reasonable rate of return given the long-term nature of the investment relative to its risk. See ASC 820-10-55-8. Finally tell us whether you sought any bids from marketplace participants that would assume the put obligation. If so, please summarize the results and compare to your internally generated calculation of the liability. We may have further comment.

EPD answered
We acknowledge your comment regarding the potential “liquidity preference” of investors. An investor might elect to liquidate OTA at various dates prior to the 30-year timeframe used in our discounted cash flow analysis. Accordingly, we will adjust the financial model used to estimate the fair value of the Liquidity Option to reflect the possible liquidation of OTA at the end of each year following the exercise date for a period of 30 years (a “multiple liquidation date” approach).
Rest of the answer

Using this approach and assuming no changes in the other assumptions previously reflected in our discounted cash flow analysis, the estimated fair value of the Liquidity Option at October 1, 2014 would increase to approximately $212 million. We do not consider the $93 million increase in fair value of the Liquidity Option from our original estimate of approximately $119 million to be material to our consolidated financial statements.

To further illustrate the potential impact of the two approaches to fair value of the Liquidity Option on our financial results, we have prepared the following example. This example assumes that we ratably adjust our expectations (i.e., probabilities) of acquiring all of the EPD common units held by OTA from approximately 70% at inception to 100% by the time the option nears its exercise date. In addition, while the actual amount of the deferred tax liability to be recorded upon exercise is not known, this example assumes that the deferred tax liability recorded by EPD at the time of exercise is $500 million for illustrative purposes. All amounts presented in the following table are in millions of dollars.

Single

Multiple

30-Year

Liquidation

Forecast

Date

Approach

Initial fair value estimate of Liquidity Option at October 1, 2014

$

119

212

Expense recognized in connection with accretion and changes in the estimated number of EPD common units to be acquired upon exercise of Liquidity Option (1)

122

216

Liquidity Option Agreement Liability at time of exercise in February 2020 (2)

241

428

Income tax expense to be recognized upon exercise of Liquidity Option (3)

259

Deferred tax liability recorded at exercise date in February 2020 (4)

500

We would present these expense amounts as “Changes in the fair value of Liquidity Option Agreement” within “Other expenses” on our consolidated statements of operations

Amount would be the then current book value of the Liquidity Option

Represents the difference between the (i) Liquidity Option Agreement Liability at the time of option exercise and (ii) the nominal deferred tax liability assumed at the time of option exercise. Income tax expense would be recorded to the extent that the assumed deferred tax liability exceeds the then current book value of the option liability.

The deferred tax liability would be measured in accordance with ASC 740. The $500 million amount used in this example is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent a known deferred tax liability.

In response to your question regarding possible bid solicitations, we did not seek any bids from marketplace participants in connection with developing our estimate of fair value for the Liquidity Option. The fair value of the Liquidity Option was derived using a discounted cash flow analysis.

Lastly, we used EPD’s weighted-average cost of capital (“WACC”) at October 1, 2014 (as determined by Bloomberg) to discount the cash flows used in our valuation analysis. The WACC represents an average rate that a company is expected to pay to its security holders to finance its assets; therefore, it includes a risk premium sought by debt and equity investors. At October 1, 2014, the WACC for EPD was estimated by Bloomberg at 7.4%.

* * * * *

In response to the foregoing Staff comments, Enterprise acknowledges that:

· the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 17, 2015: 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 8, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2015-07-29

Form S-4

2014-12-23 to 2015-01-07 · 3 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
No closing letter
General
SEC asked (1)
Please disclose throughout the joint proxy statement/prospectus a dollar value for the aggregate merger consideration to be received by Oiltanking Partners L.P.’s unitholders, using a representative date to value the stock consideration (e.g., the last trading day before the public announcement of the merger).
EPD answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised pages 9, 51 and 66 of the Registration Statement accordingly.
Read in the reply
The Merger, page 41 · Background of the Merger, page 41
SEC asked (2)
Please disclose in greater detail the potential alternative transactions available to Oiltanking that were discussed during the October 24, 2014 meeting between the Oiltanking Conflicts Committee and representatives of Jefferies and Latham.
EPD answered
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement to include the following language on page 46:

The members of the Oiltanking Conflicts Committee also discussed among themselves, and with representatives of Jefferies and

Latham, the risks and merits of the proposed merger with Enterprise and whether other potential alternative transactions that may be available to Oiltanking.
Rest of the answer

The Oiltanking Conflicts Committee considered whether it would be appropriate to seek other prospective bidders for the assets or control of Oiltanking and to make further inquiry of Enterprise with respect to other alternatives. The Oiltanking Conflicts Committee considered that Enterprise, in the merger proposal, previously had asserted that it was interested only in acquiring the Oiltanking common units it did not already own and that it was not interested in disposing of its controlling interest in Oiltanking to a third party at such time, meaning that a prospective bidder would not be able to gain control of Oiltanking. The Oiltanking Conflicts Committee concluded that prospective bidders would not be interested in purchasing the common units held by Oiltanking public unitholders without gaining control of Oiltanking. As a result, the Oiltanking Conflicts Committee determined that it was unlikely that it could conduct a meaningful auction for the acquisition of the assets or control of Oiltanking.

In addition, the Oiltanking Conflicts Committee discussed potential alternatives for Oiltanking remaining as a standalone public company, including, among other things, the current and expected growth prospects for Oiltanking, current and expected market conditions for the storage and terminaling business and the potential financial performance and related implications for Oiltanking. The Oiltanking Conflicts Committee concluded that the current and prospective growth prospects for Oiltanking if it were to continue as a standalone public entity would be more limited following Enterprise’s acquisition of

Oiltanking GP. In reaching that conclusion, the Oiltanking Conflicts Committee considered (i) the loss of visible growth prospects, such as complimentary potential “drop downs” from affiliates of M&B, upon Enterprise acquiring

Oiltanking GP and approximately 66% of Oiltanking’s limited partner interests on October 1, 2014, (ii) potential reduced incentives for Enterprise to grow Oiltanking as a standalone public entity in view of Enterprise’s business relationship with Oiltanking, including the fact that Enterprise represented approximately 29% of Oiltanking’s revenues for the year ended December 31, 2013, as well as Enterprise’s 50-year service agreement with Oiltanking relating to Enterprise’s LPG export terminal at Oiltanking’s complex on the Houston Ship Channel, (iii) the lack of any duty or other obligation for Enterprise to support Oiltanking’s growth or otherwise adopt a business strategy that is favorable to Oiltanking and (iv) the potential unwillingness of third parties, including current and potential competitors of Enterprise, to do business with Oiltanking as a controlled subsidiary of Enterprise.

Read in the reply
Where You Can Find More Information, page 172
SEC asked (3)
We note that you have incorporated by reference “[a]ny later information that you file with the Commission pursuant to Section 13(a), 13(c), 14 or 15(d) of the Exchange Act up until the date of the special meeting . . .
Rest of the question

.” You may wish to revise this section to state that all filings filed by you pursuant to the Exchange Act after the date of the initial registration statement and prior to effectiveness of the registration statement shall be deemed to be incorporated by reference into the prospectus. Please see Securities Act Forms Compliance and Disclosure Interpretation 123.05, which is available on our website, for more information.

EPD answered
We acknowledge the

Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see page 142.
Read in the reply

Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2013

2014-06-03 to 2014-06-16 · 6 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
No closing letter
Results discussion (MD&A)Liquidity and cashRevenueDerivatives and hedgingDebtLegal and contingencies
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of · Operations, page 66
SEC asked (1)
We note your disclosure on page 54 that you are required to distribute all available cash on a quarterly basis. Please disclose how you define available cash.
EPD answered
We note the Staff's comment and will include in future filings a discussion of available cash within the Liquidity and Capital Resources section of Item 7 of the Form 10-K. As an example of the new disclosure, it would have appeared as follows in the current Form 10-K:

Cash Distributions to Limited Partners

Our partnership agreement requires us to make quarterly distributions to our unitholders of all available cash, after any cash reserves established by Enterprise GP in its sole discretion.
Rest of the answer

Cash reserves include those for the proper conduct of our business including, for example, those for capital expenditures, debt service, working capital, operating expenses, commitments and contingencies and other significant amounts. The retention of cash by the partnership allows us to reinvest in our growth and reduce our future reliance on the equity and debt capital markets. Based on the level of available cash, management proposes a quarterly cash distribution rate to the Board of Directors of Enterprise GP, which has sole authority in approving such matters. Unlike most master limited partnerships, our general partner has a non-economic ownership interest in us and is not entitled to receive any cash distributions from us based on incentive distribution rights or other equity interests.

Austin Beijing Dallas Dubai Houston London New York Research Triangle Park The Woodlands Washington, DC

We measure available cash by reference to distributable cash flow. The following table summarizes our calculation of distributable cash flow for the years indicated (dollars in millions):

For the Year Ended December 31,

2013

2012

2011

Net income attributable to limited partners (1)

$

2,596.9

2,419.9

2,046.9

Adjustments to GAAP net income attributable to limited partners to derive non-GAAP distributable cash flow:

Add depreciation, amortization and accretion expenses

1,217.6

1,104.9

1,007.0

Add asset impairment charges

92.6

63.4

27.8

Add losses or subtract gains attributable to asset sales and insurance recoveries, net

(83.3

)

(86.4

(155.7

Add cash proceeds from asset sales and insurance recoveries (2)

280.6

1,198.8

1,053.8

Add cash distributions received from unconsolidated affiliates (3)

251.6

116.7

156.4

Subtract equity in income of unconsolidated affiliates (3)

(167.3

(64.3

(46.4

Subtract sustaining capital expenditures (4)

(291.7

(366.2

(296.4

Subtract losses from monetization of interest rate derivative instruments accounted for as cash flow hedges (5)

(168.8

(147.8

(23.2

Add deferred income tax expense or subtract benefit, as applicable

37.9

(66.2

12.1

Other, net

(15.7

(39.5

(25.8

Distributable cash flow

3,750.4

4,133.3

3,756.5

Total cash distributions paid to limited partners with respect to year

2,461.9

2,225.8

2,024.9

Cumulative quarterly cash distributions per unit declared by

Enterprise GP with respect to year (6)

2.7400

2.5725

2.4350

Total cash retained by partnership with respect to year (7)

1,288.5

1,907.5

1,731.6

Distribution coverage ratio (8)

1.52x

1.86x

(1) For a discussion of significant changes in our comparative income statement amounts underlying net income attributable to limited partners, along with the primary drivers of such changes, see "Consolidated Income Statements Highlights" within this Part II, Item 7.

(2) For a discussion of significant changes in cash proceeds from asset sales and insurance recoveries as presented in the investing activities section of our Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows, see "Cash Flows from Operating, Investing and Financing Activities" within this Part II, Item 7.

(3) For information regarding our unconsolidated affiliates, see Note 9 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements included under Part II, Item 8.

(4) For a discussion of our capital spending activity, see "Capital Spending" within this Part II, Item 7.

(5) For information regarding these losses, see "Interest Rate Hedging Activities" under Note 6 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements included under Part II, Item 8.

(6) See Part II, Item 5 for additional information regarding our quarterly cash distributions declared with respect to each year presented.

(7) At the sole discretion of Enterprise GP, cash retained by the partnership with respect to each of these years was primarily reinvested in our growth capital spending program, which substantially reduced our reliance on the equity and debt capital markets to fund such major expenditures.

(8) Distribution coverage ratio determined by dividing distributable cash flow by total cash distributions paid to limited partners with respect to year.

For additional information regarding non-GAAP distributable cash flow, see "Other Items – Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" within this Part II, Item 7. Our use of distributable cash flow for the limited purposes described above and in this report is not a substitute for net cash flows provided by operating activities, the most comparable GAAP measure.

Other Items

Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures

Gross operating margin. [This section would remain as presented in the current Form 10-K.]

Distributable cash flow. Our management compares the distributable cash flow we generate to the cash distributions we expect to pay our partners. Using this metric, management computes our distribution coverage ratio. Distributable cash flow is an important non-GAAP financial measure for our limited partners since it serves as an indicator of our success in providing a cash return on investment. Specifically, this financial measure indicates to investors whether or not we are generating cash flows at a level that can sustain or support an increase in our quarterly cash distributions. Distributable cash flow is also a quantitative standard used by the investment community with respect to publicly traded partnerships because the value of a partnership unit is, in part, measured by its yield, which is based on the amount of cash distributions a partnership can pay to a unitholder. The GAAP measure most directly comparable to distributable cash flow is net cash flows provided by operating activities.

The following table presents a reconciliation of non-GAAP distributable cash flow to GAAP net cash flows provided by operating activities for the periods indicated (dollars in millions):

Distributable cash flow ("DCF")

Adjustments to reconcile distributable cash flow to net cash flows provided by operating activities:

Add sustaining capital expenditures reflected in DCF

291.7

366.2

296.4

Subtract cash proceeds from asset sales and insurance recoveries reflected in DCF

(280.6

(1,198.8

(1,053.8

Add losses from monetization of interest rate derivative instruments accounted for as cash flow hedges

168.8

147.8

23.2

Net effect of changes in operating accounts not reflected in DCF

(97.6

(582.5

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Capital Spending, page 94
SEC asked (2)
We note your disclosures of spending for growth capital projects and sustaining capital projects. Please expand your disclosure to provide management’s insight into any trends or significant fluctuations for each type of capital expenditure. In your response, please show us what your disclosure would have looked like had such disclosures been provided in your current Form 10-K.
EPD answered
We note the Staff's comment and will expand our disclosure in future filings to further elaborate on management's insight into any material trends or fluctuations for each type of capital expenditure. Our revised disclosure beginning on page 94 of the current Form 10-K would have appeared as follows (marked to show changes – underlines represent additions of text and strikethroughs represent deletions of text):

Capital Spending

An important part of our business strategy involves expansion through growth capital projects, business combinations and investments in joint ventures.
Rest of the answer

We believe that we are positioned to continue to expand our system of assets through the construction of new facilities and to capitalize on expected increases in natural gas, NGL and crude oil production resulting from development activities in the Rocky Mountains, Mid-Continent, Northeast and U.S. Gulf Coast regions, including the Niobrara, Barnett, Eagle Ford, Permian, Haynesville, Marcellus and Utica Shale plays and deepwater Gulf of Mexico production fields.

Although our current focus is on expansion through growth capital projects, management continues to analyze potential business combinations, asset acquisitions, joint ventures and similar transactions with businesses that operate in complementary markets or geographic regions. In past years, major oil and gas companies have sold non-strategic assets in the midstream energy sector in which we operate. We believe this trend will continue and we expect independent oil and natural gas companies to consider similar divestitures.

See "Significant Recent Developments" within this Part II, Item 7 for information regarding our current major capital projects, including the completion of several new NGL pipelines such as the Front Range Pipeline, Texas Express Pipeline and ATEX Express pipeline.

The following table summarizes our capital spending for the periods indicated (dollars in millions):

Capital spending for property, plant and equipment, net: (1)

Growth capital projects (2)

3,088.0

3,232.7

3,552.3

Sustaining capital projects (3)

294.2

365.8

290.3

Investments in unconsolidated affiliates

1,094.1

609.5

30.0

Other investing activities

1.0

43.1

22.4

Total capital spending

4,477.3

4,251.1

3,895.0

(1) On certain of our capital projects, third parties are obligated to reimburse us for all or a portion of project expenditures. The majority of such arrangements are associated with pipeline construction projects and production well tie-ins. Contributions in aid of construction costs were $26.0 million, $23.4 million and $24.9 million for the years ended December 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively. Growth and sustaining capital amounts presented in the table above are presented net of related contributions in aid of construction costs.

(2) Growth capital projects either (a) result in new sources of cash flow due to enhancements of or additions to existing assets (e.g., additional revenue streams, cost savings resulting from debottlenecking of a facility, etc.) or (b) expand our asset base through construction of new facilities that will generate additional revenue streams and cash flows.

(3) Sustaining capital expenditures are capital expenditures (as defined by GAAP) resulting from improvements to existing assets. Such expenditures serve to maintain existing operations but do not generate additional revenues or result in significant cost savings.

Year-to-year fluctuations in our capital spending for growth capital projects and investments in unconsolidated affiliates are explained in large part by increases or decreases in spending on our major growth capital projects. Year-to-year fluctuations in our capital spending for sustaining capital projects are explained in large part by the timing and cost of pipeline integrity and similar projects. Our most significant growth capital expenditures for the year years ended December 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011 involved projects in the Eagle Ford Shale, Haynesville Shale, at our Mont Belvieu complex, to expand joint venture crude oil pipelines, and for the ATEX Express pipeline.

See "Significant Recent Developments" within this Part II, Item 7 for information regarding our announced major capital projects, including the completion of several new NGL pipelines such as the Front Range Pipeline, Texas Express Pipeline and ATEX Express pipeline and new projects such as the expansion of our Houston Ship Channel LPG Export Terminal and Eagle Ford Crude Oil Pipeline System.

Comparison of 2013 with 2012. Capital spending on growth capital projects for 2013 decreased $144.7 million when compared to 2012. Our spending on growth capital projects in the Eagle Ford Shale region decreased $1.01 billion, partially offset by a combined $803.0 million year-to-year increase in spending on our ATEX and Aegis ethane pipelines and the Rocky Mountain expansion of our Mid-America Pipeline System. Since 2010, expansion of midstream infrastructure in the Eagle Ford Shale region has been a key strategic focus for us. We constructed new NGL, natural gas and crude oil pipelines and the Yoakum natural gas processing plant to facilitate production growth from Eagle Ford Shale producers. Our build-out in this supply basin was substantially completed during 2013 with several projects completed in phases prior to 2013. A majority of the capital expenditures for our ATEX pipeline and the Rocky Mountain expansion of our Mid-America Pipeline System were incurred during 2013 (prior to placing these new pipeline assets into service in January 2014). Capital spending on sustaining capital projects for 2013 decreased $71.6 million when compared to 2012 primarily due to a year-to-year decrease in pipeline integrity work and similar projects associated with our Texas Intrastate System and Mid-America Pipeline System. Investments in unconsolidated affiliates for 2013 increased $484.6 million when compared to 2012 primarily due to the expansion of the Seaway Pipeline and construction of the Texas Express Pipeline, Texas Express Gathering System and Front Range Pipeline.

Comparison of 2012 with 2011. Capital spending on growth capital projects for 2012 decreased $319.6 million when compared to 2011. Our spending for growth capital projects in the Haynesville Shale region decreased $1.1 billion, partially offset by a combined $817.7 million year-to-year increase in spending on our ATEX Express Pipeline, the Rocky Mountain expansion of our Mid-America Pipeline System and Mont Belvieu complex expansion projects. The Haynesville Extension pipeline of our Acadian Gas System was completed and placed into service in November 2011. Capital spending on sustaining capital projects for 2012 increased $75.5 million when compared to 2011 primarily due to a year-to-year increase in pipeline integrity work and similar projects associated with our Texas Intrastate System and TE Products Pipeline. Investments in unconsolidated affiliates for 2012 increased $579.5 million when compared to 2011 primarily due to the expansion and construction of certain joint venture crude oil and NGL pipelines.

We currently expect total capital spending for 2014 to be in the range of $3.9 billion to $4.4 billion, which includes $350 million for sustaining capital expenditures. During the year ended December 31, 2013, we placed approximately $2.3 billion of major capital projects into service. We expect to complete construction and begin commercial operations related to growth capital spending representing approximately $5.0 billion of investment during 2014. These projects include our:

§

ATEX Express pipeline, which commenced operations in January 2014;

Mid-America Pipeline System expansion project in the Rocky Mountains, which commenced operations in January 2014;

Front Range Pipeline, which commenced operations in February 2014;

Seaway Pipeline looping project (expected completion in second quarter of 2014);

ECHO terminal expansion project (Phase II expected completion in second quarter of 2014);

refined products export terminal (expected completion in third quarter of 2014);

SEKCO crude oil pipeline (expected completion in third quarter of 2014); and

Aegis Ethane Pipeline (portions expected to be completed in third quarter of 2014).

At December 31, 2013, we had approximately $1.14 billion in purchase commitments outstanding that relate to our capital spending for property, plant and equipment. These commitments primarily relate to the ATEX Express pipeline and construction projects in Texas and the Rocky Mountains.

Our forecast of capital spending for 2014 is based on our announced strategic operating and growth plans (through the filing date of this annual report), which are dependent upon our ability to generate the required funds from either operating cash flows or other means, including borrowings under debt agreements and the issuance of additional equity and debt securities. We may revise our forecast of capital spending due to factors beyond our control, such as weather related issues, changes in supplier prices or adverse economic conditions. Furthermore, our forecast of capital spending may change as a result of decisions made by management at a later date, which may include the addition of costs in connection with unforeseen acquisition opportunities.

Our success in raising capital, including the formation of joint ventures to share costs and risks, continues to be a principal factor in determining how much capital we can invest. We believe our access to capital resources is sufficient to meet the demands of our current and future growth needs and, although we currently expect to make the forecast capital expenditures noted above, we may adjust the timing and amounts of projected expenditures in response to changes in capital market conditions.

At December 31, 2013, we had approximately $1.14 billion in purchase commitments outstanding that relate to our capital spending for property, plant and equipment. These commitments primarily relate to the ATEX Express pipeline and construction projects in Texas and the Rocky Mountains.

During the year ended December 31, 2013, we placed approximately $2.3 billion of major capital projects into service. We expect to complete construction and begin commercial operations related to growth capital spending representing approximately $5.0 billion of investment during 2014. These projects include our:

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Capital Spending, page 94
SEC asked (3)
Please disclose whether you incurred any capital expenditures that had an element of both sustaining capital expenditures and growth capital expenditures, such as expenditures that both maintained operating capacity and increased operating income or cash flow. If so, please revise your disclosure to quantify the portion allocated to growth capital expenditures for each of the periods presented.
Rest of the question

In your response, please show us what your disclosure would have looked like had such disclosures been provided in your current Form 10-K.

EPD answered
With the exception of certain immaterial production well tie-in projects (see below), we did not incur any capital expenditures that had an element of both sustaining capital expenditures and growth capital expenditures.

Our authorization for expenditure ("AFE") policy (the "AFE Policy") defines two categories of capital expenditures: growth capital projects and sustaining capital projects. In accordance with our AFE Policy, management reviews each capital project and determines whether the project should be classified as either growth or sustaining capital.
Rest of the answer

Growth capital projects are defined as capital spending for property, plant and equipment that provide us the ability to access new sources of cash flow. Growth capital projects either (a) result in new sources of cash flow due to enhancements of or additions to existing assets (e.g., additional revenue streams, cost savings resulting from debottlenecking a facility, etc.) or (b) expand our asset base through construction of new facilities that will generate additional revenue streams and cash flows. Conversely, sustaining capital projects are defined as capital projects that do not generate new sources of cash flows. Sustaining capital expenditures result from improvements to existing assets that serve to maintain existing operations.

Given our definitions for growth and sustaining capital projects, we do not typically encounter projects that have elements of both growth and sustaining capital. The only instance where this occurs is in connection with capital projects to link new producer wells with our natural gas gathering systems. These "well-tie" projects involve both growth capital and sustaining capital spending amounts. Our capital spending disclosures segregate well-tie project costs based on the two classes of expenditures (i.e., growth and sustaining).

Well-tie projects accounted for less than 0.5% of growth capital spending in each of the years ended December 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011. These projects accounted for 6.1%, 4.4% and 5.4% of sustaining capital spending during the years ended December 31, 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively. Given the immateriality of these projects to our overall capital spending amounts, we do not believe it necessary to separately disclose such amounts. If these amounts were to become material, we would quantify such information in our capital spending disclosures.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-8 · Note 4. Revenue Recognition, page F-15
SEC asked (4)
We note that your natural gas processing business includes percent-of-proceeds contracts where you share in the proceeds generated from the sale of mixed NGLs you extract on the producer’s behalf. Please tell us if you present revenues from these contracts on a gross or net basis and how you determined such presentation was appropriate.
EPD answered
With respect to the mixed NGL stream we receive in connection with percent-of-proceeds natural gas processing arrangements (i.e., our equity NGL production), our consolidated revenues reflect only the proceeds we obtain from the sale and delivery of our contractual share of the purity NGLs we extract from the mixed NGL stream. These proceeds represent our earnings from such arrangements with producers. Mixed NGLs must be fractionated (or separated) into their component products in order to be sold to downstream third party customers.
Rest of the answer

We do not recognize as revenue that portion of the proceeds received by the producer for their contractual share of the mixed NGL stream. Title to the producer's contractual share of the mixed NGL stream remains with the producer.

Our NGL marketing activities generate revenues from the sale and delivery of NGLs we take title to. Revenue from these sales contracts is recognized when (i) persuasive evidence of an exchange arrangement exists, (ii) the NGLs are delivered to customers, (iii) the sales price is fixed or determinable and (iv) collectibility is reasonably assured.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 6. Derivative Instruments, Hedging Activities and Fair Value Measurements, page F-21
SEC asked (5)
We note your disclosure on page F-22 that you are amortizing gains on terminated fair value hedges “over the forecasted hedge period.” Please clarify why you do not amortize these gains over the remaining life of the debt.
EPD answered
Although the disclosure on page F-22 does not explicitly state that the gains on the terminated fair value hedges are being amortized over the remaining life of the debt to which the interest rate hedges pertained, the gains are in fact being amortized over the remaining life of the debt. The remaining forecasted hedge period and the remaining life of the debt hedged are the same. We note the Staff's comment and will clarify in future filings.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 17. Commitments and Contingencies, page F-62 · Litigation, page F-62
SEC asked (6)
We note your disclosures on page 35 of your first quarter fiscal 2014 Form 10-Q and in your Form 8-K filed on March 6, 2014 regarding litigation with Energy Transfer Partners L.P. over a proposed pipeline project that was cancelled in August 2011. We further note that a Dallas jury awarded Energy Transfer Partners L.P. $319.4 million in actual damages.
Rest of the question

Please tell us why this contingency was not disclosed pursuant to ASC 450-2050-3. In doing so, tell us, if true, why you believed there was not a reasonable possibility that a loss may have been incurred.

EPD answered
We did not include disclosure regarding this litigation in our Form 10-K since we concluded, based on facts known to us at the time of filing, that there was not a reasonable possibility that a loss had occurred.

The basis for our conclusion included the following rationale and good faith beliefs, among other affirmative defenses, as set forth in our Motion for Directed Verdict, which had been filed with the court prior to the verdict rendered by the jury on March 4, 2014 and prior to the date the Form 10-K was filed with the SEC, which was March 3, 2014:

no partnership existed and we owed
Rest of the answer

Energy Transfer Partners L.P. ("ETP") no partnership duties as a matter of law because the conditions precedent for a partnership formation were not satisfied;

ETP has no evidence or legally sufficient evidence of the partnership factors delineated in Section 152.052(a) of the Texas Business Organizations Code ("BOC");

ETP's testimony regarding an undefined "partnership to market and pursue" a project lacks essential terms and is too indefinite to be enforceable as a matter of law;

even if the alleged partnership was formed, we did not owe ETP fiduciary duties;

because the alleged partnership was terminated on August 15, 2011, the alleged breaches could not have caused the alleged damages as a matter of law;

ETP has no evidence that a breach of the alleged partnership duties proximately caused any damages; and

ETP has no evidence of damages and its expert's speculative damages model is both legally insufficient and untethered to the partnership it alleges.

Following the jury's verdict, we filed a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, for all of the reasons set forth in the Motion for Directed Verdict filed prior to the verdict. Based on the jury verdict rendered, we included disclosure pursuant to ASC 450-20-50-3 in our quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the first quarter of 2014, which was filed on May 9, 2014. However, we continue to believe that the facts strongly support these defenses, notwithstanding the jury's verdict, and intend to vigorously pursue those defenses upon appeal if our motion is denied and judgment is rendered in the case against us.

In the absence of a verdict at the time of the Form 10-K filing, we concluded that a loss was not reasonably possible pursuant to the guidance in ASC 450-20-50-3. We were clearly surprised and disappointed with the verdict, and note that two jurors agreed with our legal positions, which supported our reasonable expectations. If one additional juror had also agreed, the verdict would not have been rendered. As noted above, we continue to believe that the facts support our defenses, notwithstanding the jury's verdict, and intend to vigorously pursue those defenses upon appeal if our motion is denied and judgment is rendered in the case against us.

In response to the foregoing Staff comments, Enterprise acknowledges that:

· the partnership is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and the partnership may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 16, 2014: 10-Q filed Aug 11, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 9, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Letters without questions

Other letters

UPLOAD and CORRESP
10 other letters: notices that a filing will not be reviewed, requests to declare a registration effective, and the like

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 30 letters filed since 2014-06-03. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/EPD/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.