Schedule 14C
Please tell us how you considered the guidance in Article 11-01(a)(7-8) of Regulation S-X and if you intend to provide pro forma financial information giving effect to the Spin-off, including consideration of SAB Topic 1.B.2 and SAB Topic 5.Z.7.
The Sponsor acknowledges the Staff’s comment, and confirms that it has considered the guidance in ArticleRead in the reply
11-01(a)(7-8) of Regulation S-X regarding the requirements on presentation of pro forma financial information, as well as Staff
Accounting Bulletin Topic 1.B.2 (“SAB 1.B.2”) and Staff Accounting Bulletin Topic 5.Z.7 (“SAB 5.Z.7”).Rest of the answer
Although the Sponsor believes that no pro forma financial information is required pursuant to Article 11-01(a)(7) or (8) of Regulation S-X, as a pro forma financial presentation is not necessary to reflect the operations of the BTC Trust as an autonomous entity, or any other significant changes which would not be readily apparent as a result of other disclosures in the Information Statement, the Sponsor has revised the disclosure on pages 21-22 of the Information Statement, and on pages 60-65 of the BTC
Trust Registration Statement (which is incorporated by reference in the Information Statement), to include pro forma financial information of the BTC Trust giving effect to the Initial Distribution in response to the Staff’s comment.
The Sponsor advises the Staff that no pro forma financial information of the GBTC Trust giving effect to the Initial Distribution is or will in the future be required to be presented by the GBTC Trust. The Sponsor notes that Article 11-01(a)(4) of Regulation
S-X requires the filing of pro forma financial information when the disposition of a significant portion of a business either by sale, abandonment or distribution to shareholders by means of a spin-off, split-up or split-off has occurred or is probable and such disposition is not fully reflected in the historical financial statements. Per Article 11-01(b)(2) of Regulation S-X, a business disposition will only be considered “significant” if the business disposition meets the definition of a significant subsidiary in Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X, substituting 20 percent for 10 percent each place it appears therein. Although the
Sponsor does not believe the Initial Distribution constitutes the disposition of a “business” as such term is defined in Article 11-01(d), and instead constitutes an asset disposition, pro forma financial statements would not be required even if it did constitute a “business disposition,” because it would not be considered “significant” under such tests. The Sponsor advises the Staff that (i) the amount of Bitcoin to be contributed from the GBTC Trust to the BTC Trust in connection with the Initial Distribution is expected to be less than 20% of the Bitcoin held by the GBTC Trust, and (ii) neither the GBTC Trust nor the BTC Trust generates any revenues.
As such, with respect to the GBTC Trust, the disposition of Bitcoin and/or shares of the BTC Trust occurring in connection with the Initial Distribution is not “significant” for purposes of Article
11-01 of Regulation S-X, and no pro forma financial information is required to be presented.
Please provide us with your legal analysis as to whether the distribution of BTC Shares to the GBTC Shareholders as described in the information statement constitutes a sale or distribution for value within the meaning of Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act.
TheRead in the reply
Sponsor submits that the Initial Distribution does not constitute a sale or distribution for value within the meaning of Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act, because a GBTC Shareholder neither gives value for, nor makes an independent investment decision about, the BTC Shares and, therefore, does not need the protection afforded by the Securities Act.Rest of the answer
In fact, consummation of the Initial Distribution does not require that GBTC Shareholders pay any consideration, exchange or surrender existing GBTC Shares or take any other action to receive BTC Shares, and no vote or consent of GBTC Shareholders is required or is being requested.
Staff Legal Bulletin No. 4, dated December 16, 1997 (“SLB 4”), addresses the Staff’s views regarding whether
Section 5 of the Securities Act applies to spin-offs. In particular, SLB 4 provides that a subsidiary is not required to register a spin-off under the Securities Act if the following five conditions are met: (1) the parent stockholders do not provide consideration for the spun-off shares; (2) the spin-off is pro rata to the parent stockholders; (3) the parent provides adequate information about the spin-off and the subsidiary to its stockholders and to the trading markets; (4) the parent has a valid business purpose for the spin-off; and (5) if the parent spins off “restricted securities,” it has held those securities for at least two years.
The Sponsor believes that the Initial Distribution meets the conditions outlined in SLB 4 in all material respects, and that the GBTC Trust therefore should be permitted to complete the Initial Distribution without requiring registration of the Initial Distribution under the Securities Act. While the Initial Distribution may not ultimately be characterized as a “spin-off” for purposes of presentation under U.S. generally accepted accounting principles (“U.S. GAAP”), and the Sponsor therefore acknowledges that the fact pattern presented may not be fully aligned with customary fact patterns in corporate spin-offs, the Sponsor notes that SLB 4 defines a “spin-off” as occurring when “a parent company distributes shares of a subsidiary to the parent company’s shareholders,” as is the case with the Initial Distribution (as noted in the Sponsor’s response to Comment 3 below). Further, the Sponsor submits to the Staff that the basic principles underlying the Staff’s guidance in SLB 4 are addressed by the fact pattern presented by the Initial Distribution, and that for purposes of analyzing whether a sale or distribution for value has occurred within the meaning of Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act, there are no material differences between the Initial Distribution and a more customary corporate spin-off that comports with SLB 4. In particular, the
Sponsor advises the Staff that the purpose of the Initial Distribution is not to (i) create a market in the spun-off securities without providing adequate information to its shareholders or to the trading markets; (ii) create a public market in the shares of a company that has minimal operations or assets; or (iii) create a public market in the shares of a company that is a development stage company that has no specific business plan or whose business plan is to engage in a merger or acquisition with an unidentified company, and therefore not inconsistent with the policy rationale underlying SLB 4.
A detailed analysis of the five conditions in SLB 4 to the Initial Distribution is set forth below:
A. The parent shareholders do not provide consideration for the spun-off shares
The Commission has taken the position that a dividend of securities generally does not constitute a “sale” within the meaning of
Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act because such dividend does not constitute a disposition “for value” within the meaning of that section. See Securities Act Release No. 33-929 (July 29,
1936). The rationale for this position is that the recipient of a dividend of securities neither gives value for, nor makes an independent investment decision about, such securities and, therefore, does not need the protection afforded by the
Securities Act. As described in the Information Statement, the GBTC Shareholders will receive BTC Shares in connection with the Initial Distribution solely by virtue of their ownership of GBTC Shares on the Record Date, and will not be required to pay any consideration, exchange or surrender existing GBTC Shares or take any other action to receive BTC Shares. Furthermore, the GBTC Shareholders will not be making any investment decision about the BTC Shares or about the Initial Distribution.
In addition, consummation of the Initial Distribution does not require any action whatsoever to be taken on the part of GBTC Shareholders, and GBTC Shareholders are expected to retain the same proportionate exposure in the Bitcoin underlying their
GBTC Shares (including their GBTC Shares and BTC Shares) as a result of the Initial Distribution. Therefore, the first condition of SLB 4 is met.
B. The spin-off is pro rata to the parent shareholders
As described in the Information Statement, the distribution of BTC Shares to GBTC Shareholders will be effected on a pro rata basis, such that each GBTC Shareholder on the Record Date will be entitled to receive BTC Shares pro rata based on a 1:1 ratio, such that for each one share of the GBTC Trust held by each GBTC Shareholder, such GBTC Shareholder will be entitled to receive one BTC
Share on the Distribution Date. Therefore, the second condition of SLB 4 is met.
C. The parent provides adequate information about the spin-off and the subsidiary to its shareholders and to the trading markets
SLB 4 states that, if the subsidiary to be spun-off is a non-reporting company, the parent provides adequate information if, by the date it spins-off the securities: (i) it gives its shareholders an information statement that describes the spin-off and the subsidiary and that substantially complies with
Regulation 14A or Regulation 14C under the Exchange Act; and (ii) the subsidiary registers the spun-off securities under the Exchange Act. With respect to a reporting subsidiary that has not been reporting for 90 days (such as the BTC Trust, as of the Distribution Date), the parent may provide adequate information in the same manner as a non-reporting subsidiary.
On or prior to the Distribution Date, the GBTC Trust will have satisfied each of these requirements in respect of providing adequate information. The GBTC Trust will give GBTC Shareholders the Information Statement, which describes the Initial Distribution and the BTC Trust, and substantially complies with the disclosure requirements set forth in Regulation 14C under the Exchange Act. In addition, in connection with the effectiveness of the BTC Trust Registration Statement and prior to the consummation of the Initial Distribution, the BTC Trust intends to register the BTC Shares under the Exchange Act by filing a registration statement on Form 8-A (the “BTC Trust Form
8-A”). The BTC Trust Form 8-A is expected to become effective concurrently with the effectiveness of the BTC Trust Registration Statement, each of which will occur on or prior to the Record Date prior to the distribution of any BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution. As such, as of the Distribution Date, the BTC Trust will have registered the BTC Shares under the Exchange Act and be subject to the reporting requirements of the Exchange Act. Therefore, the GBTC Trust satisfies the third condition of SLB 4 as applicable for a spin-off of a non-reporting subsidiary.
D. The parent has a valid business purpose for the spin-off
The Sponsor believes the Initial Distribution will accomplish a number of important business objectives and is in the best interests of GBTC
Shareholders for a number of reasons. The Initial Distribution will result in GBTC Shareholders incurring lower fees, because the BTC Trust will have a materially lower fee than the GBTC Trust, thereby creating a lower blended fee for investors across the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust. In addition, the Initial Distribution will not alter GBTC Shareholders’ exposure to Bitcoin underlying the GBTC Shareholders’ aggregate shareholdings. Furthermore, for U.S. federal income tax purposes the Initial Distribution is expected to be a non-recognition event for both the GBTC Trust and the GBTC Shareholders as of the Record Date, effectively enabling GBTC Shareholders to shift a portion of their spot Bitcoin exchange-traded product (“ETP”) exposure into a lower fee investment vehicle without recognizing gain or loss for U.S. federal income tax purposes. Finally, following the Initial Distribution, the BTC Trust and the GBTC
Trust will operate as independent NYSE Arca, Inc. (“NYSE Arca”) listed ETPs, and neither will have any share ownership, beneficial or otherwise, in the other, providing all investors with another cost-effective spot Bitcoin ETP option.
These reasons, among others, are set forth on page 3 of the Information Statement under “Purpose of the Initial Distribution” and constitute a valid business purpose in satisfaction of the fourth condition of SLB 4.
The Sponsor further advises the Staff that the purpose of the Initial Distribution is not to (i) create a market in the spun-off securities without providing adequate information to its shareholders or to the trading markets; (ii) create a public market in the shares of a company that has minimal operations or assets; or
(iii) create a public market in the shares of a company that is a development stage company that has no specific business plan or whose business plan is to engage in a merger or acquisition with an unidentified company, and therefore not inconsistent with the policy rationale underlying this condition of SLB 4.
E. If the parent spins-off “restricted securities,” it has held those securities for at least two years
The BTC Trust is a newly formed Delaware statutory trust which will not have any independent assets or operations prior to the Initial
Distribution. SLB 4 states that the two-year holding period condition does not apply where the parent formed the subsidiary being spun off, rather than acquiring the business from a third party. The Sponsor formed the BTC Trust on March 12, 2024, among other reasons, to receive the contemplated contribution of Bitcoins from the GBTC Trust and effectuate the Initial Distribution as described in the Information Statement, and the BTC Trust will have no material assets or operations prior to the occurrence of such events. Although a parent-subsidiary relationship between the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust will not exist until immediately prior to the Initial Distribution on the Distribution Date, the Sponsor advises the Staff that the fact the BTC Trust was formed by the Sponsor (and not formed by the GBTC Trust) is a distinction without a difference. The BTC Trust was formed by the Sponsor for the administrative purpose of filing the BTC
Trust Registration Statement and having an audit performed over its initial balance sheet (which consists of an insignificant amount of cash and no other assets), and the BTC Trust will not have any material assets or operations prior to the Initial
Distribution. The Sponsor further advises the Staff that the GBTC Trust could theoretically accomplish the same end result by forming a new trust as a subsidiary on the Distribution Date, contributing Bitcoin to such new trust, and immediately distributing the new trust’s shares as a dividend to GBTC Shareholders – and the Sponsor does not believe the Staff intended for this hypothetical fact pattern to result in a different outcome under SLB 4 than the fact pattern presented. Therefore, the fifth condition of SLB 4 does not apply to the proposed Initial Distribution.
Based on the discussion above, the Sponsor believes that the
Initial Distribution satisfies the requirements of SLB 4, and in any event does not constitute a sale or distribution for value within the meaning of Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act. Accordingly, the Initial Distribution will not require registration under the Securities Act.
Please clarify whether GBTC Trust has a parent-subsidiary relationship with BTC Trust prior to the date on which the proposed transaction is consummated. To the extent that no parent-subsidiary relationship between GBTC Trust and BTC Trust exists prior to the date on which the proposed transaction is consummated, please tell us why you characterize this transaction as a spin-off.Rest of the question
In your response, please provide us a detailed explanation of how the proposed transaction will be conducted, including a step-by-step description of the transaction mechanics, the related timing of each step and a comprehensive description of all parties involved, including any intermediary parties, and their respective roles in the transaction. Please also tell us how the transaction is being conducted under and consistent with Delaware law. In addition, please tell us whether the transaction constitutes a spin-off for purposes of the application to list the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca.
The Sponsor acknowledges the Staff’s comment, and responds to each component in turn below. Capitalized terms used but not defined herein shall have the meaning given to them in the Information Statement.Read in the reply
Parent-subsidiary relationship
The Sponsor advises the Staff that the GBTC Trust and BTC Trust will have a parent-subsidiary relationship as of immediately prior to consummation of the Initial Distribution.Rest of the answer
On the Distribution Date, the BTC Trust will issue 100% of its issued and outstanding shares to the GBTC Trust in consideration for the corresponding contribution of Bitcoin from the GBTC Trust to the BTC
Trust, thereby becoming a subsidiary of the GBTC Trust. Also on the Distribution Date, the GBTC Trust will then distribute such BTC Shares to its shareholders.
As noted above in response to Comment 2, while the Initial Distribution may not ultimately be characterized as a “spin-off” for purposes of presentation under U.S. GAAP, the Sponsor notes that SLB 4 defines a “spin-off” as occurring when “a parent company distributes shares of a subsidiary to the parent company’s shareholders,” as is the case with the Initial Distribution. The Sponsor further advises the Staff that the GBTC Trust could theoretically accomplish the same end result by forming a new trust as a subsidiary on the Distribution Date, contributing Bitcoin to such new trust, and immediately distributing the new trust’s shares as a dividend to GBTC Shareholders – SLB 4 does not contemplate any minimum period of time following a subsidiary’s formation by a parent which must elapse before such subsidiary’s shares can be distributed. Therefore, the Sponsor submits that the proposed Initial Distribution is properly characterized as a spin-off insofar as it relates to the parent-subsidiary relationship between the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust. However, in order to avoid confusion in light of the fact that the proposed transaction may not ultimately be characterized as a “spin-off” for purposes of presentation under U.S. GAAP, the Sponsor has revised its terminology throughout the Information Statement and the BTC Trust Registration
Statement to refer to the proposed transaction as the “Initial Distribution.”
Step-by-step description of transaction mechanics
Overview
The GBTC
Trust intends to effectuate the Initial Distribution by contributing a certain amount of Bitcoin (which is expected to be less than 20% of the Bitcoin held by the GBTC Trust) to the BTC Trust. On the Distribution Date, newly-created BTC Shares will be issued to the GBTC Trust, and will be distributed to GBTC Shareholders as of the close of business on the Record Date, pro rata based on a 1:1 ratio, such that for each GBTC Shares held by each GBTC Shareholder, such GBTC Shareholder will be entitled to receive one BTC Share on the Distribution Date.
Prior to the Record Date
The BTC Trust initially filed the BTC Trust Registration Statement on March 12, 2024, and the GBTC Trust initially filed the Preliminary
Information Statement on Schedule 14C on March 22, 2024.
After filing one or more amendments to the BTC Trust Registration Statement and upon receiving indication from the Commission that the BTC Trust Registration Statement is expected to be declared effective on a suitable timeline, the Sponsor will set and announce a record date (the “Record Date”) pursuant to appropriate approval by its Board of Directors in accordance with Delaware law. The Sponsor will also provide notice to NYSE Arca at least 10 calendar days in advance of such Record Date.
On March 12, 2024, the Sponsor, which manages the affairs of both the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust, formed the BTC Trust, and prior to the Record Date, intends to purchase beneficial interests of the BTC Trust (the “Seed Shares”) in exchange for an insignificant amount of cash. Prior to the Initial Distribution, the Seed Shares will constitute all of the issued and outstanding beneficial interests in the BTC Trust. The Seed Shares will be redeemed for an insignificant amount of cash in connection with, and immediately prior to the consummation of, the Initial Distribution. The cash proceeds to the BTC Trust received in consideration for the sale of the Seed Shares will serve as the basis for the audit described in the sections entitled “Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” and “Statement of Financial Condition” in the BTC Trust Registration Statement.
The BTC Trust intends to file the BTC Trust Form 8-A to register the BTC Shares under the Exchange Act, which will become effective on or prior to the Record Date concurrently with the effectiveness of the BTC Trust Registration Statement, such that the BTC Trust will have an Exchange Act reporting obligation prior to consummation of the Initial Distribution in satisfaction of the “adequate information” requirement in SLB 4. Although the BTC Trust Registration Statement will be declared effective on or prior to the Record Date, the
BTC Trust will not create or redeem any shares through Authorized Participants thereunder until after the Initial Distribution has been consummated.
Concurrently with filing of the BTC Trust Form 8-A, NYSE Arca is expected to file Form CERT in connection with the effectiveness of NYSE Arca’s 19b-4 application for listing and trading of the BTC Shares and the commencement of the BTC Trust’s creation and redemption programs. The Sponsor expects that trading in the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca will commence on the trading day immediately following the Distribution Date.
Sponsor intends to submit an acceleration request with respect to the BTC Trust Registration Statement, requesting effectiveness on or prior to the Record Date. On or prior to the Record Date, subject to satisfactory resolution of any outstanding comments from the Staff, the Sponsor expects the BTC Trust Registration Statement to be declared effective, causing the Form 8-A and NYSE Arca’s Form CERT to become automatically effective.
On the Record Date
The Record Date is expected to be approximately four business days prior to the Distribution Date.
On the Record Date, the portion of Bitcoin to be transferred to the BTC Trust will be determined as a ratio of the GBTC Trust’s total
Bitcoin holdings as of the Record Date, and such Bitcoin (the “BTC Bitcoin Portion”) will be set aside and locked until the Distribution Date, reduced by the portion of the applicable sponsor’s fee that is attributable to the BTC
Trust between the Record Date and the Distribution Date. However, the BTC Bitcoin Portion cannot otherwise be reduced, used for redemptions or sold to pay the sponsor’s fee attributable to the GBTC Trust between the Record Date and the
Distribution Date.
The GBTC Shareholders who are entitled to receive BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution will be determined as of the close of business on the Record Date, at which point the GBTC Trust will file the Definitive Information Statement on Schedule 14C, in which it will disclose any previously omitted information regarding the Initial Distribution.
Between the Record Date and the Distribution Date
Between the Record Date and the Distribution Date, the GBTC Shares will continue to trade, and creations and redemptions of GBTC Shares will continue to be processed in the ordinary course. Such creations and redemptions will only impact the calculation of the net asset value of the portion of Bitcoin held by the GBTC Trust which is not set aside as part of the BTC Bitcoin Portion.
On the Distribution Date
The Initial Distribution will be consummated on the Distribution Date. Shortly after 4:00 p.m. ET on the Distribution Date: (i) the BTC
Trust will issue a number of BTC Shares to the GBTC Trust equal to the number of GBTC Shares that were outstanding as of the Record Date, and simultaneously redeem the Seed Shares held by the Sponsor in exchange for an amount of cash equal to the amount the Sponsor paid for the Seed Shares, (ii) the GBTC Trust will contribute the BTC Bitcoin Portion to a separate Bitcoin wallet custodied by the custodian of the BTC Trust and (iii) newly-issued BTC Shares will be distributed by the
GBTC Trust to GBTC Shareholders and entitlements held by GBTC Shareholders will cease to have effect. As a result of step (i) and prior to the Initial Distribution being consummated, the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust will have a parent-subsidiary relationship as described above in this response to Comment 3.
On the first trading day following the
Distribution Date
At market open on the first trading day following the Distribution Date and consummation of the Initial
Distribution, trading of the BTC Shares is expected to commence on NYSE Arca, and creations and redemptions of the BTC Trust through Authorized Participants will begin to occur in the manner contemplated in the BTC Trust Registration Statement.
The GBTC Trust and BTC Trust will operate as independent NYSE Arca listed exchange-traded commodity products, and neither will have any share ownership, beneficial or otherwise, in the other, providing all investors another spot Bitcoin ETP option.
Delaware law
With respect to Delaware law, both the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust are Delaware statutory trusts under the Delaware Statutory Trust Act, as amended (the “DSTA”), that are governed by their respective Trust
Agreements (as to the GBTC Trust, the “GBTC Trust Agreement,” as to the BTC Trust, the “BTC Trust Agreement” and together, the “Trust Agreements”), and the mechanics for enacting the Initial Distribution structure are a function of each Trust Agreement. The provisions of the DSTA are largely default provisions that can be changed or modified in a governing instrument, intending to provide for maximum freedom of contract. Under both Trust Agreements, the Sponsor has broad authority to cause each of the GBTC Trust and the BTC Trust to act in accordance with the terms of each Trust Agreement, in particular in respect of making distributions in-kind (Section 3.7 of the GBTC Trust Agreement) and permitting the holding of interests in vehicles that hold Bitcoin pending distributions of such interests to GBTC Shareholders (Section 6.4(b) of the GBTC Trust
Agreement). Under the DSTA, except for certain extraordinary circumstances, shareholders do not have any default voting rights, and even in those extraordinary circumstances, the default rights may be overridden in the governing instrument for the trust. Here, GBTC Shareholders only have the right to vote in limited circumstances: on the merger or reorganization of the Sponsor with a non-affiliate; the appointment of a successor Sponsor; the election to continue the affairs of the Trust when the Sponsor is no longer able to act by appointing a successor Sponsor; and amendments to the Trust Agreement that have a material adverse effect on the GBTC Shareholders. Given the limitations under the GBTC
Trust Agreement on voting rights, and no statutory defaults under the DSTA for distributions to shareholders, the Sponsor can cause the GBTC Trust to act in furtherance of the Initial Distribution without the vote of the GBTC Shareholders. Further, under the DSTA, unless the governing instrument provides otherwise, no appraisal rights are available to the beneficial holders of the beneficial interests of a trust. The Trust Agreement for the GBTC Trust does not provide any appraisal rights for any GBTC Shareholders. Therefore, the Initial Distribution is being conducted in a manner that is consistent with Delaware law.
NYSE
Arca listing application
The Sponsor submits that the BTC Shares are expected to already be listed on NYSE Arca as of the Record Date, and prior to the consummation of the Initial Distribution, by virtue of the BTC Trust Registration Statement having been declared effective. Therefore, the application to list the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca does not specifically depend on or relate to the manner of the distribution of BTC Shares to GBTC Shareholders in the Initial Distribution, as such events will occur after the BTC Shares have been listed on NYSE Arca.
We note your disclosure on page 18 that: • To the extent an investor’s GBTC Shares are “pledged as collateral or included in the calculation of financial covenants in financing arrangements or other securities, the liquid value of such GBTC Shares (excluding the value of any entitlements to BTC Shares) would decrease after the Record Date to the extent of the value of the BTC Bitcoin Portion”; and • An investor’sRest of the question
ability to pledge the full value of its GBTC Shares, including corresponding entitlements to BTC Shares with respect thereto, as collateral during the period between the Record Date and the Distribution Date may similarly be impaired. Please provide your analysis as to whether any such impairment of an investor’s ability to pledge the full value of its GBTC Shares as collateral during the period between the Record Date and the Distribution Date constitutes a waiver of any substantive rights. In this regard, we note that the Trust’s investment objective is for the value of the Shares (based on Bitcoin per Share) to reflect the value of the Bitcoin held by the Trust. If so, please tell whether, and if so how, such waiver impacts your analysis whether the transaction constitutes a sale or disposition for value under Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act.
The Sponsor advises the Staff that an investor is not waiving any substantive rights during the period between the Record Date and theRead in the reply
Distribution Date. During this period, an investor could, in theory, continue to pledge the full value of its GBTC Shares (measured as of immediately prior to the Record Date) by pledging their entitlement to receive the BTC Shares on the Distribution Date, such that the overall value of the Bitcoin that an investor has exposure to and is able to pledge is unchanged through the duration of the proposed Initial Distribution.Rest of the answer
Furthermore, the Sponsor advises the Staff that it is customary in margin loan agreements and other debt arrangements under which an investor may pledge his or her securities as collateral to include provisions providing for the automatic pledge of the “proceeds of collateral,” which may include spin-off shares received as part of a distribution with respect to the original collateral. Therefore, absent unforeseen circumstances, shareholders should still be permitted to pledge the full value of the
Bitcoin underlying their GBTC Shares (including entitlements to BTC Shares), whether that happens automatically or through a contractual pledge of the entitlement to receive BTC Shares on the Distribution Date. The Sponsor has advised GBTC
Shareholders who have pledged their GBTC Shares to consult with their financial advisors out of an abundance of caution.
In addition, as discussed in response to Comment 2 above, the Commission has taken the position that a dividend of securities generally does not constitute a “sale” within the meaning of Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act because such dividend does not constitute a disposition “for value” within the meaning of that section. See Securities Act Release No. 33-929 (July 29, 1936). The rationale for this position is that the recipient of a dividend of securities neither gives value for, nor makes an independent investment decision about, such securities and, therefore, does not need the protection afforded by the Securities Act. Therefore, the Sponsor submits that an investor is not waiving any substantive rights and any impairment of an investors’ ability to transact in entitlements does not impact the Sponsor’s analysis of whether the transaction constitutes a sale or disposition for value under Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act.
The Sponsor has revised the disclosure on page 18 of the Information Statement to make clear that investors will not be able to sell or transfer entitlements to receive BTC Shares on NYSE Arca prior to or on the Distibution Date, and to the extent an investor’s GBTC Shares are pledged as collateral or included in the calculation of financial covenants in financing arrangements or other securities, such investors are encouraged to consult their financial advisor to determine the extent to which corresponding entitlements to receive BTC Shares may automatically or voluntarily be pledged as proceeds of such collateral under the contractual terms of such financial covenants in financing arrangements or other securities, in response to the Staff’s comment.
To the extent material, please discuss the risk that there may be less liquidity or wider spreads in the market for the BTC Shares as compared to the GBTC Shares.
The Sponsor has revised the disclosure on page 17 of the Information Statement in response to the Staff’s comment. The Sponsor has also revised the disclosure on pages ii, 5 and 57 of the BTC Trust Registration Statement, which is incorporated by reference in the Information Statement, in response to the Staff’s comment.Read in the reply
We note that your discussion of tax consequences is based on the assumption that each of the GBTC Trust and BTC Trust will be treated as a grantor trust for U.S. federal income tax purposes. Please revise to describe the reasons for and level of any uncertainty associated with grantor trust status.Rest of the question
Please also disclose whether you have or will receive an opinion of counsel that neither the GBTC Trust nor any Holder will recognize gain or loss for U.S. federal income tax purposes as a result of the transaction.
The Sponsor has revised the disclosure on pages 16-17 and 23-25 of the Information Statement in response to the Staff’s comment. TheRead in the reply
Sponsor has also revised the disclosure on pages 51-52 and 125-126 of the BTC Trust Registration Statement, which is incorporated by reference in the Information Statement, in response to the Staff’s comment.
Please tell us why you believe you are permitted to incorporate by reference to the registration statement on Form S-1 (333-277837) filed by BTC Trust on March 12, 2024. We remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
Sponsor advises the Staff that the GBTC Trust is permitted to incorporate by reference the information in the BTC Trust Registration Statement that is required under, and in accordance with, Item 13 of Schedule 14A under the Exchange Act. As a large accelerated filer and well-known seasoned issuer that has been subject to the reporting requirements of Section 12 since January 31, 2020, the GBTC Trust is permitted to utilize incorporation by reference in the filings it makes, including the Information Statement on Schedule 14C which has been filed for purposes of providing adequate informationRead in the replyRest of the answer
about the Initial Distribution and the BTC Trust to GBTC Shareholders in compliance with SLB 4.
Item 13(a) of Schedule 14A specifies financial and other information required to be included in respect of any matter specified in Item 12.
Item 12 relates to actions to be taken with respect to the modification of any class of securities of the registrant, and specifies information required to be furnished in connection therewith. The Sponsor submits that the proposed transaction constitutes a modification of the GBTC Trust’s outstanding GBTC Shares within the scope of Item 12 as it reduces the Bitcoin underlying such GBTC Shares in connection with the distribution of such Bitcoin to the BTC Trust in connection with the
Initial Distribution.
Item 13(b)(1) permits registrants meeting the requirements of Form S-3 to incorporate by reference to previously filed documents any of the financial and other information required by Item 13(a). Section (a) of Note E of Schedule 14A provides that a registrant “meets the requirements of Form S-3” if: (A) the registrant meets the requirements of General Instruction I.A. of Form S-3; and (B) the registrant meets the aggregate market value requirement of General Instruction I.B.1 of Form S-3, which requires that the aggregate market value of the voting and non-voting common equity held by non-affiliates of the registrant is $75 million or more. The Sponsor advises the Staff that the GBTC Trust, which is a large accelerated filer and well-known seasoned issuer and has an effective shelf registration statement on Form S-3 on file with the Commission, meets the requirements of General Instruction I.A and the aggregate market value requirement of General Instruction I.B.1 of Form S-3, and therefore meets the requirements of Form S-3 as specified by Section (a) of Note E of Schedule 14A, as required by Item 13(b)(1) for a registrant to incorporate by reference information required by Item 13(a) of Schedule 14A.
Section (c) of Rule 12b-23 under the Exchange Act provides that any document filed with the Commission may be incorporated by reference as an exhibit to any statement or report filed with the Commission by the same or any other person. Therefore, the GBTC Trust, in satisfaction of the requirements of Item 13 of Schedule 14A, is permitted to incorporate by reference the filings of the BTC Trust, including the BTC Trust Registration Statement. The Sponsor further notes that the Definitive Information Statement on Schedule 14C is expected to incorporate by reference the BTC Trust Registration Statement at a time when such registration statement has been declared effective by the Staff.
* * *
In connection with its response to the Staff’s comments, the Sponsor acknowledges that the Sponsor and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of its disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the Staff.
Please provide us with a comparison of how the trading of GBTC and BTC Shares between the Record Date and the Distribution Date would compare with a typical corporate spin-off transaction. In particular, please explain why there will be no regularway market for GBTC Shares or when-issued market for BTC Shares. Please also discuss how this impacts your no sale analysis under Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act.
The Sponsor has addressed each of the Staff’s comments as follows:Read in the reply
•
Please provide us with a comparison of how the trading of GBTC and BTC Shares between the Record Date and the
Distribution Date would compare with a typical corporate spin-off transaction.
Trading in corporate spin-off transactions
While the Sponsor cannot speak with any authority as to what a “typical” corporate spin-off transaction entails, and the Sponsor notes that corporate spin-off transactions have been consummated without the issuers involved facilitating “regular-way” or “when-issued” trading markets for theRest of the answer
securities involved, the Sponsor has included the below description of what would occur in a corporate spin-off transaction in which the issuers involved do elect to facilitate such trading markets between the relevant record date and distribution date:
The “when-issued” trading market refers to the period of time after the declaration of a spin-off distribution has been authorized by the parent entity’s board of directors, and a record date has been established, but prior to the actual issuance and/or distribution of shares of the spin-off subsidiary’s stock (which occurs on the distribution date). During this time, the subsidiary’s stock trades on a conditional or when-issued basis, often commencing on the trading date immediately prior to the record date for the distribution and ending on the distribution date.
During this time, in addition to the when-issued market for the subsidiary’s stock, it is possible that a second market will be established for the parent company’s stock, which is referred to as the “regular-way” trading market, in which the parent’s shares trade along with the right to receive shares of the subsidiary’s stock on the distribution date.
Finally, the “ex-distribution” market describes the trading market that will continue for the parent company’s shares, without the right to receive shares of the subsidiary’s stock on the distribution date. In the “ex-distribution” market, on the
“ex dividend” date (i.e., the day on which the parent company’s shares first trade without the right to receive shares of the subsidiary’s stock), the parent company’s stock price will decline by an amount equal to the amount of the distribution, i.e., the value attributable to the shares of the subsidiary’s stock that will be distributed (and is therefore no longer reflected in the parent company’s stock price).
Investors who purchase parent company shares in the “regular-way” trading market or subsidiary shares in the “when-issued” market between the record date and the distribution date receive a “due bill,” and such trades are typically settled two days following the distribution date.
Trading of the GBTC Shares and the BTC Shares
The Sponsor advises the Staff that the GBTC Shares will go “ex dividend” on the Record Date, meaning that any investors who purchase
GBTC Shares in the open market on the Record Date will not be entitled to receive the distribution of BTC Shares in respect of such GBTC Shares (since such trades will settle after the Record Date). As such, and consistent with the “ex-distribution” market described above with respect to parent company shares in a corporate spin-off, the Sponsor expects that the secondary market trading price of GBTC Shares will decline as of the opening of trading on the Record Date (which is also the “ex dividend” date), in an amount that corresponds to the value attributable to the BTC Shares that will be distributed and amount of Bitcoins that will be contributed to the BTC Trust on the Distribution Date (i.e, the value of the Bitcoin comprising the BTC Bitcoin Portion). For purposes of this discussion, the Sponsor refers to the secondary market trading price of GBTC Shares prior to such expected decline in share price as the “pre-distribution price,” and the price of GBTC Shares following such expected decline in share price as the “post-distribution price.”
If a GBTC Shareholder sells GBTC Shares prior to the Record Date, they will be selling shares at the pre-distribution price, because the settlement of such trade will occur on or prior to the close of trading on the Record Date (and the purchaser will therefore be entitled to receive their pro rata portion of the distribution of BTC Shares on the Distribution Date, assuming such purchaser continues to hold such GBTC Shares through the Record Date). Conversely, if a GBTC Shareholder sells GBTC Shares on the Record Date, they will be selling shares at the post-distribution price, because the settlement of such trade will occur after the Record Date (and the seller will therefore remain entitled to receive their pro rata portion of the distribution of BTC Shares on the Distribution Date. As such, neither buyers nor sellers of GBTC Shares will sacrifice any value as a result of trading activity during this period of time despite the expected decline in GBTC Share price which will occur on the Record Date, as the expected difference between the pre-distribution price and the post-distribution price is equal to the expected value of the BTC Shares – and the entitlement to receive such BTC Shares will rest with (i) the buyer, in situations where the buyer has paid the pre-distribution price for GBTC Shares (i.e. trades struck prior to the Record Date) or (ii) the seller, in situations where the buyer has paid the post-distribution price for GBTC Shares (i.e. trades struck on the Record Date).
Moreover, the Sponsor has determined that it will waive the Sponsor’s Fee with respect to the BTC Bitcoin Portion during the period between the Record Date and the commencement of trading of the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca (which the Sponsor currently anticipates will be the trading day following the
Distribution Date), such that no GBTC Shareholder will pay any fees or otherwise forgo any value with respect to their pro rata entitlement to the BTC Bitcoin Portion during this time. The Sponsor advises the Staff that this waiver will further accrue to the benefit of GBTC Shareholders, who on the Distribution Date will receive BTC Shares corresponding to their pro rata share of the BTC Bitcoin Portion as of the close of business on the Record Date, without any reduction in the number of
Bitcoin underlying such BTC Shares to account for the accrual of the Sponsor’s Fee in such intervening period (in addition to the materially lower Sponsor’s Fee that will be applicable to the BTC Shares once they begin trading on NYSE Arca vis-à-vis the GBTC Shares). The Sponsor has revised the disclosure on pages 1, 2, 4, 5, 13, 21 and 26 of the Information Statement to reflect its waiver of the
Sponsor’s Fee with respect to the BTC Bitcoin Portion during the period between the Record Date and the commencement of trading of the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca (which the Sponsor currently anticipates will be the trading day following the
Distribution Date).
In particular, please explain why there will be no regular-way market for GBTC Shares or when-issued market for BTC Shares.
The Sponsor advises the Staff that it does not intend to take steps to facilitate a “regular-way” trading market for the GBTC Shares or “when-issued” trading market for the BTC Shares due in large part to the inherent nature of exchange-traded commodity products, which do not lend themselves to this tripartite model of trading that is often seen in corporate spin-offs. Because both the GBTC Trust and BTC Trust (for purposes of this discussion, each a “Trust”) are investment vehicles with an investment objective for the value of their respective shares to reflect the value of the Bitcoin held by the respective Trust, determined by reference to the Index Price, less the Trust’s expenses and other liabilities, the
Sponsor believes that allowing three distinct trading markets to emerge for this very limited period of time (the Sponsor currently anticipates that the Distribution Date will be on the trading day immediately following the Record Date, with BTC
Shares beginning to trade on NYSE Arca on the trading day immediately following the Distribution Date) could create confusion in the market, and the potential for undesired volatility to the extent of any unexpected divergence between the trading price of GBTC Shares in a hypothetical “regular-way” market as compared with the combined trading price of the GBTC Shares in the “ex-distribution” market and the trading price of BTC Shares in a hypothetical “when-issued” market.
Unlike in a corporate spin-off, where the issuer involved is likely not issuing or repurchasing its shares during the periods between the declaration date, the ex dividend date/record date and the distribution date, the GBTC Trust will continue to process creations and redemptions throughout these periods of time, which is consistent with meeting its investment objective. This continuous creation and redemption of GBTC Shares is necessary in order to allow the arbitrage mechanism to function appropriately. These creations and redemptions will continue to occur based on the NAV of the GBTC Trust, which will be published on the GBTC Trust’s website and continue to be publicly available in the same way that its NAV is currently made available. Similar to the discussion above with respect to secondary market trading prices, the NAV of the GBTC Trust will also decline in an amount that corresponds to the amount of Bitcoins to be contributed from the GBTC Trust to the BTC Trust, reducing the net assets of the GBTC Trust. Any
GBTC Shares that are created on or prior to the Record Date will be entitled to receive the BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution, and any GBTC Shares that are created after the Record Date will not be so entitled. As a result, the NAV of the GBTC
Trust will experience a decline at the end of trading on the Record Date, when a reduced NAV will be published reflecting the net assets of the GBTC Trust after giving pro forma effect to the Initial Distribution. For purposes of this discussion, the Sponsor refers to the NAV of the GBTC Trust prior to such expected decline as the “pre-distribution NAV,” and the NAV of the GBTC Trust following such expected decline as the
“post-distribution NAV.”
To illustrate this further:
Prior to the Record Date, the NAV that the GBTC Trust publishes will be the pre-distribution NAV. This is because any creation or redemption orders placed prior to the Record Date will settle on or prior to the Record Date, and will therefore be consummated prior to determining the
GBTC Shareholders of record for purposes of the Initial Distribution.
In the case of a creation order that settles on or prior to the Record Date, the holder of the created GBTC
Shares will be entitled to receive BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution.
In the case of a redemption order that settles on or prior to the Record Date, the holder of the redeemed GBTC
Shares will not be entitled to receive BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution as the GBTC Shares will no longer be outstanding as of the close of trading on the Record Date.
At the close of trading on the Record Date, the NAV that the GBTC Trust publishes will be the post-distribution
NAV, reflecting a decline in its net assets corresponding to the Bitcoins that are to be distributed in the Initial Distribution. This is because any creation or redemption orders placed on or after the Record Date will settle after the Record Date, and will therefore be consummated after determining the GBTC Shareholders of record for purposes of the Initial Distribution.
In the case of a creation order that settles after the Record Date, the holder of the created GBTC Shares will not be entitled to receive BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution.
In the case of a redemption order that settles after the Record Date, the holder of the redeemed GBTC Shares will be entitled to receive BTC Shares in the Initial Distribution as the GBTC Shares will still be outstanding as of the close of trading on the Record Date.
The Sponsor advises the Staff that allowing three distinct trading markets from and after the time the distribution is declared—representing interests in vehicles (including two hypothetical vehicles) which would have distinct net asset values—would not be feasible or realistic for an exchange-traded commodity product that is continuously creating and redeeming its shares. In order for this to occur, there would need to be a hypothetical entity (and hypothetical authorized participants) creating or redeeming shares representing interests in all three of these vehicles.
One of these vehicles would theoretically create and redeem shares solely on the basis of the pre-distribution NAV of the GBTC Trust throughout these periods – this would be the equivalent of a “regular-way” market for GBTC Shares, and a second of these vehicles would theoretically create and redeem shares representing interests solely on the basis of the anticipated NAV of the BTC Trust throughout these periods – this would be the equivalent of a “when-issued” market for BTC Shares. But in reality, only one entity will actually be creating and redeeming shares during such period, with actual authorized participants as counterparties. If these three hypothetical issuers did exist, and were creating and redeeming shares throughout this period, this would require the publishing and updating of three distinct net asset values, which the Sponsor believes would result in significant confusion among market participants—in particular as new GBTC Shares are actually created (or existing GBTC Shares are actually redeemed) during this period, leading to fluctuations in the actual NAV of GBTC that would have no impact on the net asset value attributable to these other hypothetical entities (which would not actually be creating or redeeming any shares).
As described in the Information Statement, Authorized Participants will not create or redeem any BTC Shares until the commencement of trading of the BTC Shares on NYSE Arca, (which the Sponsor currently anticipates will be the trading day following the Distribution Date), with the BTC Shares to be distributed to GBTC Shareholders serving as the “Initial Distribution Creation
Basket” and Authorized Participants engaging in the continuous creation and redemption of BTC Shares thereafter. The Sponsor believes that this sequencing of events will allow for an orderly trading market for BTC Shares to develop, with full transparency and a fully functioning arbitrage mechanism at the time when investors begin trading the BTC Shares, enabling the BTC Trust to meet its investment objective. This model will also ensure that investors are not buying and selling BTC
Shares (or entitlements to receive BTC Shares) at a time when no authorized participants are creating and redeeming BTC Shares, and therefore no arbitrage mechanism would exist. The Sponsor further advises the Staff that, to the extent a “regular-way” trading market for the GBTC Shares were to exist, it would also not be possible for the arbitrage mechanism to function because the net asset value of the GBTC Trust in such a trading market would be purely hypothetical (again, with no ability for authorized participants to create or redeem shares in a manner that is separate from creations or redemptions of GBTC Shares that trade
“ex-distribution”).
• Please also discuss how this impacts your no sale analysis under Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act.
The Sponsor respectfully advises the Staff that the foregoing discussion does not impact its “no sale” analysis under Section 2(a)(3) of the Securities Act, as previously provided in its response letter dated April 12, 2024, in response to Comment 2 from the Staff. As discussed therein and in the response above, if an investor holds GBTC Shares as of the close of business on the Record Date, they will become entitled to receive their pro rata portion of the BTC Shares on the Distribution Date. As such, GBTC Shareholders will retain the same proportionate exposure in the Bitcoin underlying their GBTC Shares (including their GBTC Shares and BTC Shares) as a result of the Initial Distribution. Furthermore, because the post-distribution share price is expected to equal the pre-distribution share price less an amount equal to the expected value of the BTC Shares, the transaction does not constitute a disposition “for value” as GBTC Shareholders will not provide any consideration for the BTC Shares. What GBTC Shareholders receive and hold immediately following the Initial Distribution will have the same value as what they held prior to the Initial Distribution. This neutral-value proposition is identical to that of the spin-off transactions to which the Staff has expressed its view in Staff Legal Bulletin No. 4 that Section 5 of the Securities Act does not apply, and the presence or absence of a “regular-way” or “when-issued” trading market does not impact such analysis or legal conclusion.
We note that the description of the Basket calculation in this section excludes the BTC Bitcoin Portion for the period between the Record Date and the Distribution Date. Please tell us how this description is consistent with the disclosure in your prospectus for your continuous offering of GBTC Shares.Rest of the question
Please also tell us whether and to what extent your NAV, Principal Market NAV or any other metrics or calculations will be modified during the period between the Record Date and Distribution Date.
TheRead in the reply
Sponsor advises the Staff that, prior to the Record Date, it will declare an in-kind dividend on the GBTC Shares, in the form of a distribution to GBTC Shareholders as of the close of trading on the Record
Date, with BTC Shares serving as a vehicle to distribute the underlying Bitcoin corresponding to the BTC Bitcoin Portion, which dividend will be conditional on the BTC Trust Registration Statement having been declared effective by the Staff on the
Record Date.Rest of the answer
Assuming that such condition is satisfied as of the Record Date, then on the Distribution Date, GBTC will distribute BTC Shares to GBTC Shareholders as of the Record Date.
In this regard, the Sponsor advises the Staff that Section 3805 of the Delaware Statutory Trust Act, to which the GBTC Trust is subject, states that “at the time a beneficial owner becomes entitled to receive a distribution, the beneficial owner has the status of, and is entitled to all remedies available to, a creditor of the statutory trust with respect to the distribution.” As such, GBTC Shareholders will become entitled to receive the previously declared dividend of BTC Shares as of the Record Date, assuming the condition stated above has been satisfied as of such date. At such time, the GBTC Trust will account for the BTC Bitcoin Portion as a Distribution Payable under U.S. GAAP, which will have the effect of reducing the Net Assets of the GBTC Trust by the amount of the BTC Bitcoin Portion. After such time, the Trust’s NAV calculated in accordance with U.S. GAAP will not reflect the BTC Bitcoin Portion, and would only reflect the GBTC Bitcoin Portion, subject to any other required adjustments (such as further reduction for accrual of the Sponsor’s Fee on the GBTC Portion, or further adjustments as a result of pending creation and redemption orders).
The disclosure in the prospectus for the continuous offering of GBTC Shares refers readers to the GBTC Trust’s Annual Report on Form 10-K (the “Annual Report”) for a detailed description of how the GBTC Trust’s NAV and NAV per Share are calculated.
The Sponsor acknowledges the Staff’s comment that the calculation of NAV as previously set forth in the Annual Report did not contemplate situations in which the GBTC Trust incurs an obligation in the form of a Distribution Payable which reduces its Net Assets, and has made a clarifying amendment to the Trust Agreement of the GBTC Trust in order to accurately provide a calculation of NAV that reflects a reduction in the Net Assets of the GBTC Trust resulting from declared in-kind dividends where the GBTC Trust has an obligation to make a distribution to its shareholders. The Sponsor further advises the Staff that the Information Statement has been revised to disclose this clarifying amendment to the calculation of NAV to GBTC Shareholders, and the GBTC Trust filed a current report on Form 8-K on May 7, 2024, which serves to modify and supersede the previously disclosed calculation of
NAV in the GBTC Trust’s Exchange Act reports.
For ease of the Staff’s reference, the Sponsor has provided below the full text of the
GBTC Trust’s calculation of NAV, with changes attributable to the clarifying amendments described above reflected with bold/underlined text:
On each business day at 4:00 p.m., New York time, or as soon thereafter as practicable (the “Evaluation Time”), the Sponsor will evaluate the Bitcoins held by the Trust and calculate and publish the NAV of the Trust. To calculate the NAV, the Sponsor will:
Determine the Index Price as of such business day.
Multiply the Index Price by the Trust’s aggregate number of Bitcoins owned by the Trust as of 4:00 p.m.,
New York time, on the immediately preceding day, less the aggregate number of Bitcoins payable as the accrued and unpaid Sponsor’s Fee as of 4:00 p.m., New York time, on the immediately preceding day.
We note your response to prior comment 1 and your pro forma financial information beginning on page 21. Please address the following: • Revise the third paragraph of your introduction to the unaudited pro forma financial statements to reflect the current requirements of Rule 11-02 of Regulation S-X.Rest of the question
In this regard, pro forma financial statements are no longer limited to adjustments that are directly attributable to the transaction for which pro forma effect is being given, being factually supportable and, with respect to a statement of comprehensive income, expected to have a continuing impact; and • We are unable to recompute all the amounts presented in your pro format financial statements based on the descriptions in the summary. Revise your presentation to include notes for all pro forma adjustments that clearly explain the assumptions underlying the calculations for the adjustments and to separately present transaction accounting adjustments versus management's adjustments. Refer to Rules 1102(a)(6)(i), 11-02(a)(7) and 11-02(a)(8) of Regulation S-X.
Add the U.S. dollar value of Bitcoins, calculated using the Index Price, receivable under pending creation orders, if any, determined by multiplying the number of the Creation Baskets represented by such creation orders by the Basket Amount and then multiplying such product by the Index Price.Read in the reply
We note your response to prior comment 7 that Exchange Act Rule 12b-23(c) permits you to incorporate by reference the filings of the BTC Trust, including the BTC Trust Registration Statement, to satisfy the requirements of Item 13 of Schedule 14A in this filing. However, we note that Exchange Act Rule 12b-23(c) states, "[a]ny document or part thereof filed with the Commission . . .Rest of the question
may be incorporated by reference as an exhibit to any statement or report filed with the Commission by the same or any other person" (emphasis added). Since there is no exhibit provision for Schedule 14C, it does not appear that you may incorporate the BTC Trust Registration Statement by reference into your filing. Please revise to provide the disclosures, as appropriate and required, in the information statement on Schedule 14C.
Subtract the U.S. dollar amount of accrued and unpaid Additional Trust Expenses, if any.Read in the reply
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-07-29