(a)We believe management’s ability to determine if and when to incur certain maintenance
is relevant to our Available Cash before Reserves measure due to the nature and purposes of that multi-dimensional financial measure. As discussed in more detail below, we believe it would be inappropriate to derive our Available Cash before Reserves measure by deducting discretionary maintenance capital expenditures, which we believe are similar in nature in this context to certain other discretionary expenditures, such as growth capital expenditures, distributions/dividends and
Rest of the answer
equity buybacks. We believe a more appropriate measure to deduct in arriving at our Available Cash before Reserves measure is our maintenance capital utilized/realized measure, which functions as a proxy for non-discretionary maintenance capital requirements and takes into consideration the relationship between operating expenses (including maintenance expenses) and discretionary maintenance capital expenditures from period to period.
Consequently, we have implemented a modified and additive disclosure format that assists the public in identifying the change in the nature of certain of our maintenance expenditures and understanding how management views that change. Our new disclosure format includes (i) disclosing an additional measure called “maintenance capital utilized/realized,” (ii) deducting that measure in arriving at our Available Cash before Reserves measure, which results in our Available Cash before Reserves measure being more consistent with management’s use of that measure, and (iii) continuing to disclose our maintenance capital expenditures measure, thereby allowing external users to make their own analyses, regardless of management’s views.
Available Cash before Reserves, also referred to as distributable cash flow, is commonly used by management and by external users of financial information--such as investors, commercial banks, research analysts and rating agencies--as a supplemental financial measure to aid in assessing, among other things:
(1) the financial performance of our assets;
(2) our operating performance;
(3) the viability of potential projects, including our cash and overall return on alternative capital investments as compared to those of other companies in the midstream energy industry;
(4) the ability of our assets to generate cash sufficient to satisfy certain non-discretionary cash requirements, including interest payments and certain maintenance capital requirements; and
(5) our ability to make certain discretionary payments, such as distributions on our units, growth capital expenditures, and early payments of indebtedness.
Available Cash before Reserves and similar measures typically represent some form of income and/or cash flows generated by operations during a particular period. They often are derived by starting with net income, EBITDA or a similar measure and increasing and decreasing that amount for specified items, such as deductions for maintenance capital expenditures to the extent management determines such expenditures are non-discretionary in nature. For that reason, we believe deducting discretionary maintenance capital expenditures would be inappropriate in this context.
We have enhanced our disclosure format relating to our maintenance capital requirements because we expect a substantial portion of our future maintenance capital expenditures from time to time will be discretionary in nature and material in amount as compared to our Available Cash before Reserves measure. We believe using our old disclosure format prospectively would be inconsistent with our use of our Available Cash before Reserves measure and would be confusing and potentially misleading to external users.
Historically, substantially all of our maintenance capital expenditures have been (a) related to our pipeline assets and similar infrastructure, (b) non-discretionary in nature and (c) immaterial in amount as compared to our Available Cash before Reserves measure. Those historical expenditures were non-discretionary (or mandatory) in nature because we had very little (if any) discretion as to whether or when we incurred them. We had to incur them in order to continue to operate the related pipelines in a safe and reliable manner and consistently with past practices. If we had not made those expenditures, we would not have been able to continue to operate all or portions of those pipelines, which would not have been economically feasible.
Prospectively, we believe a substantial amount of our maintenance capital expenditures from time to time will be (a) related to our assets other than pipelines, such as our marine vessels, trucks and similar assets, (b) discretionary in nature and (c) potentially material in amount as compared to our Available Cash before Reserves measure. Those future expenditures will be discretionary (or non-mandatory) in nature because we will have significant discretion as to whether or when we incur them. We will not be forced to incur them in order to continue to operate the related assets in a safe and reliable manner and consistently with past practices. If we chose not make those expenditures, we would be able to continue to operate those assets economically, although in lieu of maintenance capital expenditures, we would incur increased operating expenses, including maintenance expenses.
By way of example, we will analyze a single hypothetical-whether to retain an older marine vessel that requires higher than average operating expenses or to replace that older vessel with a new vessel of substantially similar specifications (but with greater operating efficiencies), which acquisition would constitute a maintenance capital expenditure in the period in which we would acquire that new vessel. Although we can essentially operate any given marine vessel well beyond our initial assessment of its economic life, as time passes, the economics of doing so become less and less favorable as compared to replacing that existing vessel. The underlying economics of such a replacement decision are based primarily on the comparison of the operating expenditures (including maintenance expenses and maintenance capital expenditures) attributable to that existing vessel as compared to the acquisition cost and operating expenditures of a new vessel. In addition to a vessel-by-vessel analysis, certain economies of scale come into play from time to time. Because our marine fleet has increased in size, we have experienced an increasing ability to negotiate volume discounts from time to time for the acquisition prices of new vessels acquired in packages, which lower acquisition prices make it more economical for us to replace (should we elect to do so) some existing vessels sooner and in larger numbers than we otherwise would have, rather than to retain and maintain those existing vessels over a longer period (should we elect to do so).
A new vessel will have lower operating expenditures (including lower maintenance expenses and lower recurring maintenance capital expenditures exclusive of the acquisition cost) than an older existing vessel. Under our previous definition of Available Cash before Reserves, we would have deducted the total acquisition cost of the new vessel (i.e. a maintenance capital expenditure) in the quarter in which we purchased it, and we would have experienced lower maintenance expenses and maintenance capital expenditures (other than the acquisition cost) in that and subsequent quarters. Under our refined definition of Available Cash before Reserves, we would not deduct the total acquisition cost of the new vessel (i.e. a maintenance capital expenditure) in the quarter in which we purchase it, we still would experience lower maintenance expenses in subsequent periods, and we would deduct the maintenance capital utilized/realized attributable to that vessel ratably over that vessel’s useful life.
In summary, as we continue to expand certain non-pipeline portions of our business, we are experiencing changes in the nature (discretionary vs. non-discretionary), timing and amount of our maintenance capital expenditures that merit a more detailed review and analysis than was required historically. Management’s recently increasing ability to determine if and when to incur certain maintenance capital expenditures is relevant to the manner in which we analyze aspects of our business relating to discretionary and non-discretionary expenditures. Consequently, we have implemented a modified and additive disclosure format that assists the public in identifying those changes in our maintenance capital expenditures and understanding how management views them. Our new disclosure format includes (i) disclosing an additional measure called “maintenance capital utilized/realized,” (ii) deducting that measure in arriving at our Available Cash before Reserves measure, which results in our Available Cash before Reserves measure being more consistent with management’s use of that measure, and (iii) continuing to disclose our maintenance capital expenditures measure, thereby allowing external users to make their own analyses, regardless of management’s views. As discussed in more detail above, we believe it would be inappropriate to derive our Available Cash before Reserves measure by deducting discretionary maintenance capital expenditures, which we believe are similar in nature in this context to certain other discretionary expenditures, such as growth capital expenditures, distributions/dividends and equity buybacks. We believe a more appropriate measure to deduct in arriving at our Available Cash before Reserves measure is our maintenance capital utilized/realized measure, which acts as a proxy for non-discretionary maintenance capital requirements and takes into consideration the relationship between operating expenses (including maintenance expenses) and discretionary maintenance capital expenditures from period to period.
(b)In our Form 8-K, we state that “maintenance capital is capitalized costs that are necessary to maintain the service capability of our existing assets.” As mentioned above, maintenance capital can be discretionary or non-discretionary, depending on the facts and circumstances. An example of a non-discretionary (or mandatory) maintenance capital expenditure would be replacing a segment of an old pipeline because one can no longer operate that pipeline safely, legally and/or economically in the absence of such replacement. An example of a discretionary (or non-mandatory) maintenance capital expenditure would be replacing an older marine vessel with a new marine vessel with substantially similar specifications, even though one could continue to economically operate the older vessel in spite of its increasing maintenance and other operating expenses.