Form 10-K for the year ended September 30, 2018
With regard to your discussion of consolidated revenues you indicate that the increase in revenue from continuing operations for the year ended September 30, 2018 was driven by revenue at HBP from both recent acquisition and organic growth offset by decreased revenues at Telephonics.Rest of the question
Your discussion of the increase in segment revenues also refers to the favorable impact of acquisitions as well as increased favorable mix and price at CBP and AMES, and volume increases at CBP and AMES' non US locations offset by AMES US decrease due to unfavorable weather. Please quantify each factor identified as a cause for the 48% increase in your consolidated and segment revenues. Refer to Item 303(a)(3)(iii) of Regulation S-K.
In future filings, we will expand ourRead in the reply
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations. Below is a revised revenue discussion of 2018 compared to 2017 for the Home and Building Products segment; see underlines and strikethroughs for changes.
712 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor, New York, NY
T.212.957.5000
F.212.957.5040 www.griffon.com
Segment revenue increased $538,311, or 48%, compared to the prior year period, with 41% due to the AMES acquisitions of La Hacienda, Tuscan Path, ClosetMaid (“CM”),
Harper and Kelkay, and CBP’s acquisition of CornellCooksonRest of the answer
(“CC”); as well as 6% due to increased favorable mix and price at CBP and AMES; and 1% resulting from an increase in volume increase at driven by CBP and AMES’ non US locations partially offset by AMES US decrease due to unfavorable weather. 2018 CM and CC revenue was $311,568 and $66,654, respectively. Organic growth was 7%.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note you present certain adjustments in your non-GAAP performance measures Adjusted income from continuing operations and Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations net of income taxes. Please revise to present the effect of income taxes as a separate adjustment and expand your disclosure to clearly explain how the tax effects of non-GAAP adjustments are calculated.Rest of the question
Refer to Question 102.11 of the Non- GAAP Financial Measures Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations issued April 4, 2018. Please address this comment as it relates to similar presentations in press releases included in your Item 2.02 Forms 8-K.
In future filings we will revise the reconciliation table to present the effect of income taxes as a separate adjustment and disclose how the tax effects of non-GAAP adjustments are calculated as follows:Read in the reply
2018
2017
2016
Income from continuing operations
$ 33,255
$ 17,783
$ 19,781
Acquisition costs
7,597
9,617
-
Contract settlement charges
5,137
Special dividend ESOP charges
3,220
Secondary equity offering costs
1,205
Cost of life insurance benefit
2,614
Tax impact of above items
(6,421 )
(5,309 )
Discrete and other certain tax benefits
(9,384 )
(8,274 )
(857Rest of the answer
)
Adjusted income from continuing operations
$ 32,086
$ 18,954
$ 18,924
Earnings per common share from continuing operations
$ 0.78
$ 0.41
$ 0.45
Adjusting items, net of tax
(0.03 )
0.03
(0.02 )
Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations
$ 0.76
$ 0.44
$ 0.43
Weighted-average shares outstanding (in 000)
42,422
43,011
44,109
The tax impacts for the above reconciling adjustments from GAAP to non-GAAP Income from continuing operations and EPS are determined by comparing the company’s tax provision including the reconciling adjustments to the tax provision excluding the adjustments.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please explain the nature of the $17.4 million acquisition related accruals. Please also explain the reason for the $13.1 million increase in the insurance accrual.
The $17.4 million acquisition related accruals included $8.0 million for contingent consideration related to the Kelkay acquisition to be paid, if certain earnings goals are met, in equal increments in fiscal 2019, 2020 and 2021, $9.2 million for post-closing adjustments for the CornellCookson acquisition, which was paid in the first fiscal quarter of 2019 and $0.2 million related to accrued legal costs.Read in the reply
The increase in insurance accruals relates primarily to an approximately $10.0 million life insurance benefit related to the passing of a former executive with the balance related to theRest of the answer
inclusion of insurance reserves, primarily workers compensation, for the CornellCookson acquisition and normal course operational accrual fluctuations.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You disclose on page 88 that the decrease in the valuation allowance of $8.9 million is primarily the result of the disposition of PPC and its related valuation allowance on accumulated Germany net operating losses. The deferred tax gain on assets held for sale results from the book versus tax outside basis difference and was removed concurrent with the sale of PPC.Rest of the question
In light of this disclosure, please explain how you determined the 13.4% change in valuation adjustment (approximately $4.5 million) in your reconciliation of the statutory rate to your effective tax rate on page 87. Refer to ASC 740-20-45.
The reconciliation of the statutory rate from continuing operations to the effective rate on page 87 reflects a $4.5 million change in valuation allowance related to continuing operations primarily for the impact of a $4.0 million valuation on foreign tax credits and a change in allowance for state net operating losses (NOLs).Read in the replyRest of the answer
The $8.9 million change in valuation allowance reported on page 88 includes both continued and discontinued operations and is primarily related to the disposition of PPC and the related valuation allowance on Germany net operating losses of $13.5 million, partially offset by the recording of a valuation allowance against foreign tax credits of $4.0 million generated by a provision related to the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that you conduct your operations through two reportable segments, Home & Building Products (“HBP”) and Defense Electronics. Your Form 10-K indicates that the HBP reportable segment consists of two companies, The AMES Companies, Inc. (“AMES”) and Clopay Building Products Company, Inc. (“CBP”). Your website indicates that the HBP segment consists of three companies, AMES, CBP and ClosetMaid.Rest of the question
We also note from your website that your segment leadership includes a president of CBP and a president of AMES and ClosetMaid. Please tell us how you assessed whether these companies are operating segments as defined in ASC 280-10-50-1. Please identify your CODM and describe the frequency and content of the discrete financial information for these companies that is regularly reviewed by your CODM to make decisions about resources to be allocated and assess performance. In this regard, we note your website indicates that Griffon oversees the operations of its subsidiaries, allocates resources among them and manages their capital structures.
The AMES business, of which ClosetMaid is a part, is managed by the President of AMES. ClosetMaid is one of the brand names for storage and organizational products withinRead in the reply
AMES. The Griffon website is being redesigned to reflect this organizational structure and further display more of our brands.
For instance, in the future, the AMES description will line up with our SEC filings and press releases, as well as highlight the many brands under AMES such as AMES, True Temper, Razor-Back, ClosetMaid, Jackson, Cyclone, Nylex, Kelkay, etc.
ASC 280-10-50-1 lists three criteria that are required toRest of the answer
be met in order for a component of a public entity to be defined as an operating segment:
a. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expenses.
b. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s CODM to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.
c. Its discrete financial information is available.
AMES and CBP each meet both criterion a. and c. above; however, neither meets criterion b. above, as Griffon’s CODM does not make decisions regarding the allocation of resources to each of these components. Rather, Griffon’s CODM allocates resources to the HBP and Defense Electronics segments based on the operating results of each of these segments. Further, we considered 50-7, which states:
Generally, an operating segment has a segment manager who is directly accountable to and maintains regular contact with the CODM to discuss operating activities, financial results, forecasts, or plans for the segment. The term segment manager identifies a function, not necessarily a manager with a specific title.
Griffon’s Chief Operating Officer is the segment manager of HBP and performs the functions set forth in 50-7, including reporting to Griffon’s CODM, Ronald
Kramer, Griffon’s Chief Executive Officer. On a monthly basis Mr. Kramer receives both consolidated and operating segment information, which includes profit and loss statements for Defense Electronics and HBP, as well as information for the product lines in each of the segments. The segment information is used to analyze how the Griffon segments are performing and to provide a basis for Griffon’s CODM to make decisions regarding the allocation of resources to each of Griffon’s operating segments.
For instance, the HBP segment has performed well in recent years and significant capital has been invested for capital expenditures as well as acquisitions.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
If the three companies underlying HBP are individual operating segments, please provide us with a comprehensive analysis of the aggregation guidance in ASC 280-10-50-11, including financial information such as gross margin information to support your conclusion that these companies are economically similar.
As discussed above, CBP and AMES are not individual operating segments, and therefore there is no aggregation analysis. See the response to comment number 5 above.Read in the reply
Also, please note this was addressed in Griffon’s the May 23, 2011 letter, responding to comment number 1 in the April 29, 2011 SEC staff comments letter.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please provide disclosure of revenue for each product and service or each group of similar products and services, as required by ASC 280-10-50-40. In this regard we note your discussion of AMES' primary product lines, CBP's residential and commercial garage doors, and Telephonics' primary business lines within your Business section.Rest of the question
In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
ASC 280-10-50-40 states “A public entity shall report the revenues from external customers for each product and service or each group of similar products and services unless it is impracticable to do so.”Read in the reply
HBP is a segment and each of AMES and
CBP contains a group of similar products within the HBP segment.Rest of the answer
Regarding Telephonics, the product group is Defense Electronics.
We believe Griffon’s current disclosure reflects the grouping of similar products and is in compliance with the above guidance.
in Griffon’s May 23, 2011 letter, responding to comment number 2 in the April 29, 2011 SEC staff comments letter.
Should you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
First report after the company's reply of May 17, 2019: 10-Q filed Aug 1, 2019 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 2, 2019 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We have read your response to comment 2 in our letter dated May 7, 2019. Similar to that of your proposed disclosure for the reconciliation of Adjusted income from continuing operations, please revise the reconciliation for Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations to present each adjusting item gross with the effect of income taxes as a separate adjustment.
In future filings we will revise the reconciliation table for Earnings per share from continuing operations to Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations to reflect the EPS impact for each adjustment. The disclosure will be as follows:Read in the reply
Griffon Corporation and Subsidiaries
Reconciliation of Income from Continuing Operations to Adjusted Income from Continuing Operations
2018
2017
2016
Income from continuing operations
$ 33,255
$ 17,783
$ 19,781
Acquisition costs
7,597
9,617
-
Contract settlement charges
5,137
Special dividend ESOP charge
3,220
Secondary equityRest of the answer
offering costs
1,205
Cost of life insurance benefit
2,614
Tax impact of above items
(6,421 )
(5,309 )
Discrete and other certain benefits
(9,384 )
(8,274 )
(857 )
Adjusted income from continuing operations
32,086
18,954
18,924
Earnings per common share from continuing operations
$ 0.78
$ 0.41
$ 0.45
Adjusting items, net of tax:
0.12
0.14
0.08
0.05
0.02
0.01
Discrete and other certain tax
(0.22 )
(0.19 )
(0.02 )
Adjusted earnings per share from continuing operations
$ 0.76
$ 0.44
$ 0.43
Weighted-average shares outstanding
42,422
43,011
44,109
The tax impact for the above reconciling adjustments from GAAP to non-GAAP Income from continuing operations and EPS is determined by comparing the Company’s tax provision, including the reconciling adjustments, to the tax provision excluding such adjustments.
We note your responses to comments 5 and 6 in our letter dated May 7, 2019. Please address the following: a. Provide us with details about your management structure and how your company is organized. b. Describe the role of your CODM and each of the individuals reporting to the CODM. c. We note you identified your COO as the segment manager of HBP.Rest of the question
Please expand on the description you provided in your response regarding the functions performed by your COO to discuss his specific role and responsibilities. d. Please identify and describe the role of the Defense Electronics segment manager. e. Describe the key operating decisions, who makes these decisions, how performance is assessed and how resources are allocated within your business. f. Tell us how often the CODM meets with his direct reports, what is typically discussed in those meetings, the financial information the CODM reviews in conjunction with those meetings, and the other participants at those meetings. g. Explain how budgets are prepared, who approves the budget at each step of the process, the level of detail discussed at each step, and the level at which the CODM makes changes to the budget. h. Describe the basis for determining the compensation for each individual that reports to the CODM.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Aug 6, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please describe the financial information reviewed by the CODM for the purpose of allocating resources and assessing performance. Tell us how frequently that information is prepared and reviewed. Also describe the financial information reviewed by your Board of Directors and how frequently that information is reviewed.Rest of the question
In this regard, you state in your response that on a monthly basis, the CODM receives operating segment information, which includes profit and loss statements for Defense Electronics and HBP, as well as information for the product lines in each of the segments. Please describe in detail each type of financial information you refer to in your response, identify the businesses or product lines this information is provided for, and tell us whether it is reviewed by the CODM for the purposes of allocating resources and assessing performance.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Aug 6, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note you disclose disaggregated revenue information for AMES and CBP on page 95. You state in your response to comment 5 that discrete financial information is available for both AMES and CBP. Please describe this discrete financial information in detail, whether and how often it is provided to the CODM, and whether it is reviewed by the CODM for the purpose of allocating resources and assessing performance.Rest of the question
In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
PLEASE NOTE: Below is a collective response to comments numbered 2 (including 2.a. through 2.h.), 3 and 4. We have added references to help link back to the individual comments.Read in the reply
We will first address our organizational structure then will discuss our management structure, as we believe this approach will best present a clear and thorough understanding of our management structure.
Organizational Structure (#2a)
Griffon Corporation (the “Company” or “Griffon”) is a diversified management and holding company that conducts business through wholly-owned subsidiaries.
Griffon oversees theRest of the answer
operations of its subsidiaries, allocates resources among them and manages their capital structures. Griffon provides direction and assistance to its subsidiaries in connection with acquisition and growth opportunities as well as in connection with divestitures. Griffon, to further diversify, also seeks out, evaluates and, when appropriate, will acquire additional businesses that offer potentially attractive returns on capital.
Griffon conducts its operations through two Operating Segments (OS), which are also its Reportable Segments (RS):
Home & Building Products (“HBP”)
Operating Segment consists of two Components, The AMES Companies, Inc. (“AMES”) and Clopay Building Products Company,
Inc. (“CBP”):
· AMES, founded in 1774, is the leading North
American manufacturer and a global provider of branded consumer and professional tools, landscaping products, and outdoor lifestyle solutions. In 2018, we acquired ClosetMaid, a leader in wood and wire closet organization, general living storage and wire garage storage products for homeowners and professionals.
· CBP, since 1964, is a leading manufacturer and marketer of residential and commercial garage doors and sells to professional dealers and some of the largest home center retail chains in North America. In 2018, we acquired CornellCookson, a leading U.S. manufacturer and marketer of rolling steel door and grille products designed for commercial, industrial, institutional and retail use.
The Defense Electronics (DE) Operating
Segment consists of Telephonics Corporation, founded in 1933, a globally recognized leading provider of highly sophisticated intelligence, surveillance and communications solutions for defense, aerospace and commercial customers.
Pursuant to 17 C.F.R. 200.83 (“Rule 83”)
The following chart illustrates Griffon’s Organizational
Structure:
The following discussion and analysis supports why Griffon believes the HBP and DE OSs form the most relevant and logical organization structure in which to manage the daily operations of Griffon’s businesses.
HBP
The HBP Operating Segment consists of the AMES and CBP Components, or Product Groups. Both Product Groups distribute products under premier, nationally recognized brands through similar distribution channels to similar customers using similar sales processes. Further, both AMES and CBP are subject to the same economic cycles tied to discretionary residential repair and remodel and the home and commercial building markets. The following table identifies the similarities among HBP’s businesses and brands among the AMES and CBP Product
Groups, by product type, across HBP’s distribution channels and customers, to illustrate that both the AMES and CBP Product
Groups sell their products across similar distribution channels, to similar customers, and in similar markets, which are subject to the same economic cycles.
Distribution Channel / Customer
Product Group / Product
Home Centers, Mass Market, Specialty & Hardware
Industrial Distributors, Home and Commercial Builders & Architectural
Specification
Professional Installing Dealers
Market / Economic
Cycle
AMES PRODUCT GROUP
Long Handle Tools, Wheelbarrows and Snow Tools
AMES®, True Temper®, Garant®, Harper®,
UnionTools®, Kelso™, Westmix™, Cyclone® Razor-Back® Professional
Tools and Jackson® Professional Tools
Razor-Back® Professional Tools and Jackson® Professional Tools
Residential Repair and Remodel, Residential Housing and Commercial
Construction
Landscaping, Pots and Planters
Southern Patio®, Dynamic Design®™, Northcote, Kelkay®,
Tuscan Path®, La Hacienda®
Residential Repair and Remodel
Watering
AMES®, Nylex®
Storage, Organization and Accessories
ClosetMaid®, Hills®
ClosetMaid®
Customers
The Home Depot, Inc., Menards, Lowe’s Companies, Inc., Rona Inc., Bunnings Warehouse, Woodies,
WalMart Stores Inc., Target Corporation, Canadian Tire Corporation, Costco Wholesale Corporation, Ace, Do-lt-Best and True
Value Company
W.W. Grainger, Inc., ORS Nasco, D.R. Horton, KB Home, Lennar and NVR,
Inc., Regional Builder Networks
Independent Professional Installing Dealer Network
CBP PRODUCT GROUP
Sectional Doors
Clopay®, Holmes Garage Door Company® and IDEAL Door®
Clopay®
Rolling Steel
Clopay®, Cornell® and Cookson®
Cornell® and Cookson®
Commercial Construction
The Home Depot, Inc., Menards
Pulte, DR Horton, Toll Bros., Lennar, LGI Homes. Architects pertain only to rolling steel
Distribution Channel / Customer: Similar sales process
Both Product Groups participate in periodic Product Line Reviews (PLR) with their customers. During the PLR cycle, customers review historical product performance of the Product Groups’ offerings (profitability, on-time delivery, product quality etc.), review product placement options and negotiate related pricing for the upcoming sales cycle. We note that the Product Groups invest in new product development and cost-savings initiatives to offer customers new product offerings and competitive pricing during each PLR cycle. This enables the
Product Groups to remain competitive in the marketplace as each Product Group is at risk of losing business to competitors during each PLR cycle. We also note that AMES and CBP share some of their largest customers in both The Home Depot, Inc., and Menards.
Industrial Distribution, Home and Commercial
Builders & Architectural Specification
Personnel within the AMES and CBP Product
Groups create and execute sales and marketing strategies targeting landscapers, residential and commercial builders and architects to highlight the benefits using AMES and CBP products. With respect to AMES long handled tools, wheelbarrows and snow tools, these strategies are targeted at landscapers, and residential and commercial builders, to purchase AMES products through the Company’s
Industrial distributors. With respect to AMES’ ClosetMaid brand storage, organization and accessory products and CBP’s sectional and commercial rolling steel doors, sales and marketing personnel incentivize architects and national home builders to incorporate these products into their residential home and commercial construction design specifications, thereby requiring residential and commercial builders to purchase these products during construction.
Both Product Groups develop relationships with independent professional installing dealer networks that sell and install AMES and CBP products into local housing markets serving the residential new construction and repair and remodel market, and into local commercial new construction and replacement markets. As noted above, AMES’ installed products consist of storage, organization and related accessories and for CBP, products consist of sectional and commercial rolling steel doors.
Market / Economic Cycle
Each of the AMES and CBP Product Groups sell into the residential repair and remodel, residential housing and commercial construction markets across all of its product lines. These markets, collectively what Griffon management considers to be the Home and Building Products market, are heavily linked to residential home prices, consumer confidence, unemployment and the availability of consumer credit which means product sales and profitability within both Product Groups ebb and flow during the same cycles driven by discretionary consumer or commercial construction spending.
Defense Electronics
DE consists of the Telephonics Component which is recognized globally as a leading provider of highly sophisticated intelligence, surveillance and communications solutions that are deployed across a wide range of land, sea and air applications. Telephonics designs, develops, manufactures and provides logistical support and lifecycle sustainment services to defense, aerospace and commercial customers worldwide. Telephonics is organized into five primary business lines: Radar, Surveillance, Communications, Systems Engineering and Analysis (SEG), and Telephonics
Large Scale Integration (TLSI). We believe the Telephonics Component is appropriately managed under the Defense Electronics Operating
Segment as all of its five business lines serve the defense electronics market consisting of similar customers, all of which are heavily impacted by the U.S. defense budget approved by the Department of Defense, as well as international defense spending.
Management Structure (#2a, #2b)
[*** Information Omitted Pursuant to Confidential Treatment
Requested by Griffon Corporation Pursuant to Rule 83(b) ***]
CEO / CODM: Ronald J. Kramer (#2e)
The CEO, with input from Griffon’s
Board, develops business strategies and establishes short and long-term objectives designed to increase shareholder value. In order to meet these strategic and financial objectives in the most effective manner, the CEO / CODM oversees all operations and business activities and solely is responsible for allocating resources, in the form of capital expenditures or by acquiring new businesses, to the Operating Segments that have the highest probability of meeting those objectives. The CEO / CODM assesses how to allocate capital resources among the Operating Segments in the most effective manner by measuring financial performance against budget, historical results and competitors and with consideration to the economic environments likely to impact an Operating Segment at a given time. Further, the CEO / CODM, with the input from and approval of Griffon’s Board, may also allocate resources to shareholders by returning capital to shareholders in the form of dividends and/or through repurchases of Griffon’s common stock. We believe these responsibilities distinctly qualify the CEO as the CODM.
(#2e) The CEO / CODM reviews and measures the financial performance of the Operating Segments by analyzing financial information contained in Griffon’s report to the
Board of Directors (Board Report); through “Scorecard” Meetings with Segment Managers and through informal meetings with Griffon and Segment management. Further, the CEO / CODM is able to assess the state of the markets and economies into which the HBP and DE Operating Segments sell products through meetings with stock analysts, equity and bond investors, industry leaders, and with banking, legal and other advisors. A more in-depth discussion of the resources the CEO uses to measure financial performance includes:
I. Board
Report
(#3
& 4):
Griffon’s COO and CFO distribute a monthly financial reporting package to the CEO / CODM and Board of Directors which includes the following financial information:
a. Consolidated
Operating
Results:
· Financial statements (income statements, balance sheets and cash flows compared to budget and prior-year periods).
· Analytical comments analyzing actual financial performance as compared to budget and comparative prior-year periods b. Operating
Segment
Results
(HBP and
Defense
Electronics
Segments)
· Income
Statements as compared to budget and comparative prior-year periods
§ HBP and DE income statement results as compared prior-year periods.
§ AMES and CBP Product Group income statement results as compared to budget and comparative prior-year periods to supplement the CEO / CODM’s analysis of HBP’s financial results. This information is not used by the CODM for the purpose of allocating resources to the AMES and CBP Product Groups. The purpose of including AMES’s and CBP’s disaggregated financial information1 is to assist the CEO / CODM to better understand the drivers behind the HBP Operating Segment’s financial performance, which the CEO / CODM uses in making decisions to allocate resources and capital to the
HBP Operating Segment.
1 Historically, the SEC staff has placed emphasis on the financial information included in the reporting package reviewed by the CODM, with the presumption that if information is included in the reporting package provided to the CODM, it must be used by the CODM to assess performance and allocate resources.
However, a company must assess how that financial information is being used by the CODM to make key operating decisions, and the
SEC staff has stated that inclusion of information in a reporting package should not be the only factor considered in the analysis.
See speech made by SEC Deputy Chief
Accountant Dan Murdock, Office of the Chief Accountant, at the 2014 AICPA National Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments and speech made by SEC Professional Accounting Fellow Courtney D. Sachtleben, Office of the Chief Accountant, at the 2015 AICPA
National Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments.
· Discrete Financial Information
§ HBP Operating Segment o AMES Product Group
· Revenue by geographic location and product
· Revenue for top 10 customers
· Profitability by geographic location
· Capital expenditures
· Headcount o CBP Product Group
· Revenue and volume by customer type
· Profitability by customer type
§ DE Operating Segment o Revenue by product line o Gross profit by product line o Bookings and Backlog o Capital expenditures o Headcount
· Balance sheet statistics, capital expenditures and headcount (by product group and their product lines), compared to prior-year periods.
II. [*** Information
Omitted Pursuant to Confidential Treatment Requested by Griffon Corporation
Pursuant to Rule 83(b) ***]
III. [*** Information Omitted Pursuant to Confidential Treatment Requested by Griffon Corporation Pursuant to Rule 83(b) ***]
IV. Meetings with Stock Analysts, Equity and Bond Investors, Industry
Leaders, and with Banking,
Legal and other Advisors
The CEO / CODM attends and presents at various investor conferences throughout the year in which he answers questions regarding Griffon’s financial and operational performance in general sessions as well as in “one-on-one” break-out sessions with equity and bond investors. He also consults with industry peers and with banking, legal and other advisors. Through the cumulative feed-back obtained from the interaction between these parties, the CEO / CODM is able to assess the health of the markets and economies into which the HBP and DE Operating
Segments sell products, which assists him in determining how to allocate resources among the Operating Segments.
[*** Information Omitted Pursuant to Confidential
Treatment Requested by Griffon Corporation Pursuant to Rule 83(b) ***]
CFO and General Counsel: Brian Harris;
SVP & CFO, Seth Kaplan; SVP, General Counsel and Secretary
The CFO supports the CEO / CODM in his interactions with the investor community and leads the financial reporting requirements of Griffon. The General Counsel advises the COO and CEO / CODM on legal issues as they arise. The CFO and General Counsel report into the COO but also dotted-line report into and meet directly with the CEO / CODM, as evidenced within the Management Structure diagram above.
Budget Process (#2g)
On an annual basis, Segment Managers coordinate with their respective Product Group and product line and operational managers to compile a bottom-up five-year strategic plan, which includes a five year financial budget, predicated on their knowledge of customer relationships and the overall market and economic environment including an assessment of the costs to produce, sell and distribute the products within each OS. The
Segment Managers present the strategic plan and related budget to the senior leadership team which includes the CEO / CODM, COO,
CFO and General Counsel. Generally, the CEO / CODM, with input from the senior leadership team, will suggest changes and or approve the strategic plan which includes the budget at either the consolidated and Operating Segment level. For example, the CEO / CODM may change the allocation of capital expenditures among the two operating segments predicated on their projected operating performance or respective market conditions.
Compensation (#2h)
The CEO
/ CODM develops strategy to meet financial objectives designed to increase shareholder value. The COO, along with the CFO and General Counsel, reports into the CEO / CODM and is responsible for establishing tactical objectives with the Segment Managers (including himself as the HBP Segment Manager) that he believes are necessary to execute the strategic and financial objectives set by the CEO / CODM. In this regard, the COO has a significant impact on Griffon’s consolidated financial performance through his ability to establish and execute the relevant tactical objectives to achieve the CEO / CODM’s strategic objectives.
The Company’s Compensation Committee approves the COO’s base pay, and has established short and long-term performance bonus plans tied to and measured against
Griffon’s consolidated financial performance as follows:
· The short-term performance cash bonus program is linked to annual consolidated EBITDA and year end consolidated working capital levels;
· The long-term performance cash bonus program is linked to three-year cumulative Adjusted Earnings Per Share
· The long-term performance equity bonus program is linked to Griffon’s stock price performance, and the vesting and value realized is dependent on Griffon’s stock price reaching certain thresholds, as well as Griffon’s stock price performance compared to the performance of the companies in the Russel 2000 index over a fixed period of time.
Based on the above discussion, Ronald J. Kramer is the CEO / CODM and we believe that we have appropriately identified HBP and DE as the Company’s Operating Segments. Should you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.
First report after the company's reply of Aug 6, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your presentation of combined segment adjusted EBITDA and combined segment operating profit from continuing operations herein and in your earnings release filed August 1, 2019. Please tell us how you determined these measures comply with Rule 100(b) of Regulation G.Rest of the question
We note that the measures remove corporate overhead and other items, which appear to be normal, recurring, cash operating expenses necessary to operate your business. Please refer to Question 100.01 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
We understand your comment. In prospective filings we will remove the Segment Operating Profit and Segment Adjusted EBITDA reconciliations from the Management’s Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) section. The financial tables included in each of HBP’s and DE’s MD&A discussion will include only three lines: Revenue, Segment Adjusted EBITDA, and Depreciation and amortization expense. The MD&A section will refer the reader to our Reportable Segment footnotes for the definition of Segment Adjusted EBITDA, as well the reconciliation of SegmentRead in the reply
Adjusted EBITDA to Income Before Taxes.Rest of the answer
Our earnings release will reflect the same format.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Provide additional detail about the roles and responsibilities of the CEO and COO with accompanying examples. Your response should separately and specifically address, and include examples of, the COO’s role and responsibilities as segment manager of HBP and the COO’s role and responsibilities other than as segment manager of HBP.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to comment 2(e) and have the following comments: a. You state that the CEO is solely responsible for allocating resources, in the form of capital expenditures or by acquiring new businesses, to the Operating Segments. Tell us whether you consider these to be the key operating decisions.Rest of the question
If not, and/or if there are other key operating decisions, describe the key operating decisions in detail and tell us who makes those decisions; b. Describe the resources to be allocated to segments and what is taken into consideration when deciding how to allocate them. Provide examples in your response; and c. You state in your response that the CEO reviews the financial performance of the Operating Segments by analyzing financial information in the Board Report, through “Scorecard” Meetings, and informal meetings. Tell us how each piece of financial information described in your response is used by the CEO to allocate resources and assess performance.
We consider the CEO’s responsibility to allocate resources, in the form of capital expenditures or by acquiring new businesses, to the Operating Segments as strategic decisions, Rule 83 Confidential Treatment Requested by Griffon Corporation [***]. These decisions further support theRead in the reply
CEO’s goals of increasing revenue, cash flow and Segment adjusted EBITDA as well as keeping with a diversified operating model which will be able to operate through various economic cycles.
Rule 83
Confidential Treatment Requested by Griffon Corporation b.Rest of the answer
Describe the resources to be allocated to segments and what is taken into consideration when deciding how to allocate them. Provide examples in your response.
Response:
The resources to be allocated to the
OSs consist of capital expenditures and capital to acquire new businesses.
c. You state in your response that the CEO reviews the financial performance of the Operating Segments by analyzing financial information in the Board Report, through
“Scorecard” Meetings, and informal meetings. Tell us how each piece of financial information described in your response is used by the CEO to allocate resources and assess performance.
Response:
It is important to note that Operating
Segments utilize resources to fund tactical objectives the COO establishes to execute the CEO’s strategic objectives. Consequently, the CEO allocates resources to the Operating Segments that have the highest probability of supporting his strategic objectives.
The CEO believes that the most accurate measure of an Operating Segments ability to support his strategic objectives is their respective financial performance, as measured by Segment Adjusted EBITDA. As stated in our Response Letter, the CEO reviews the financial performance of the Operating Segments by analyzing financial information in the Board Report, through Scorecard Meetings, and informal meetings and uses this financial information to assess Operating Segment performance for the purpose of allocating resources, in the form of capital expenditures and capital to acquire businesses, to the Operating Segments.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You state in your response to comments 3 and 4 that AMES and CBP income statement results as compared to budget and comparative prior-year periods are provided to the CEO to assist the CEO in better understanding the drivers behind the HBP Operating Segment’s financial performance, but not for the purpose of allocating resources to the AMES and CBP Product Groups. We have the following comments: a.Rest of the question
Tell us what specific information about AMES and CBP the CEO is reviewing when he is looking to better understand the drivers of HBP’s financial performance and describe in further detail how this information is used by the CEO; and b. Tell us whether similar information (e.g., budget versus actual) is provided for the DE product lines. If no such information is provided, tell us why.
Rule 83 Confidential TreatmentRead in the reply
Requested by Griffon Corporation b. Tell us whether similar information (e.g., budget versus actual) is provided for the DE product lines. If no such information is provided, tell us why.
Response:
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Although you disclose on page 96 that Segment adjusted EBITDA is the measure by which you evaluate performance and allocate resources, we note that you also present Segment operating profit. If your CODM also uses this measure in assessing segment performance and deciding how to allocate resources, the reported measure should be that which management believes is determined in accordance with the measurementRest of the question
principles most consistent with those used in measuring the corresponding amounts in your consolidated financial statements. Please refer to ASC 280-10-50-28 and advise. Additional segment profit or loss measures may be presented outside of your financial statements and footnotes as non-GAAP measures if they comply with Regulation G and Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K. Lastly, tell us whether Segment adjusted EBITDA and Segment operating profit are included in the financial information you described in response to comments 3 and 4, and if so, which one(s).
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that the CEO and Board of Directors receives profitability by geographic location for AMES, profitability by customer type for CBP, and gross profit by product line for DE. Clarify how “profitability” is defined for each metric, why the profitability information for each differs and how it is used by the CEO in allocating resources and assessing performance.
Profitability means Gross Profit (defined as Sales less Cost of Goods Sold). In our prior response, profitability by geographic location for AMES and profitability by customer type for CBP is the same as the Gross Profit by Product Line for DE.Read in the reply
The Gross Profit information differs between the Product Groups and Lines of Businesses because Product Group or Line of Business management have developed the style, content and format in which they analyze and measure their financial performance that best fits their specific business.Rest of the answer
The CEO is provided the information in this same format and no standardization is required. The CEO is not using this information to make operating decisions or to allocate resources. This process also helps provide an appropriate level of information to support the CEO’s responsibilities in interacting with the investment community.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to comment 2(g). Please provide a more detailed description of your budget process. In your response, tell us: a. Who approves the budget at each step of the process, including any steps prior to the budget being provided to the senior leadership team.Rest of the question
In this regard, your response states that "[g]enerally, the CEO / CODM, with input from the senior leadership team, will suggest changes and or approve the strategic plan which includes the budget at either the consolidated and Operating Segment level.” Please clarify which individual or group of individuals approves the budget, and whether the budget is at the consolidated level, the operating segment level, or some further level of disaggregation; b. The level of disaggregation shown in the budget provided to the senior leadership team; and c. Which individuals attend the meeting that the budget is presented to the senior leadership team and in what capacity.
Based on the above discussion, Ronald J. Kramer is the CEO / CODM and we believe that we have appropriately identified HBP and DE as the Company’s Operating Segments. Should you require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2019: 10-K filed Nov 22, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Nov 19, 2018 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2019-11-25