While the notional amount of the swap will be equal to the value of 100% of the Trust’s assets, this amount does not reflect the
Fund’s contractual exposure to the Gold Delivery Provider as the counterparty to the Gold Delivery Agreement. The Registrant therefore respectfully declines to accept the Staff’s comment.
As noted in the Registrant’s response to comments 5 and 6 in the Registrant’s letter to the SEC Staff dated August 28, 2015, only a small percentage of the Fund’s assets (less than 1%) are expected to move into and out of the Fund on a daily basis pursuant to the Gold Delivery
Rest of the answer
Agreement (i.e., the “swap”). Specifically, the amount of Gold transferred each day between the Fund and the Gold Delivery Provider reflects only the impact of the day-to-day change in the value of the Reference Currencies reflected in the Index against the U.S. dollar. This amount is only a small portion of the Gold held by the Fund. Since only a small percentage of the Fund’s assets are subject to the Gold Delivery Agreement each day only a small percentage of the Fund’s assets are exposed to counterparty risk each day. Basing a discussion of counterparty exposure on the notional amount would therefore overstate counterparty risk and the Fund’s exposure.
Moreover, the Registration
Statement notes on page 4 under Fund Objective that “[s]ubstantially all of the Fund’s Gold Bullion holdings are delivered by Authorized Participants in exchange for Fund Shares.” More specifically, disclosure under the same heading with respect to the Gold delivered pursuant to the Gold Delivery Agreement states that “[t]he amount of Gold Bullion transferred approximates the performance of the Fund’s holdings of Gold Bullion as though they had been denominated in the Reference Currencies in the proportions in which the Reference Currencies are reflected in the Index. In general, if there is a currency gain (i.e., the value of the USD against the Reference Currencies increases), the Fund receives Gold Bullion. In general, if there is a currency loss (i.e., the value of the USD against the Reference Currencies decreases), the Fund delivers Gold Bullion. In this manner, the amount of Gold Bullion held by the Fund will be adjusted to reflect the daily change in the value of the Reference Currencies against the USD.” Further, as noted, on page 26 of the Registration Statement, under normal circumstances the Sponsor expects that day-to-day changes in the value of the Reference Currencies would have “no more than a 1 or 2 percent impact on the price of the
Fund.” This disclosure demonstrates that the notional amount of the Gold Delivery Agreement (i.e., the “swap”) is only a small percentage of the Fund’s assets and is not equal to the value of 100% of the Fund’s assets.
For the reasons stated above, the Registrant respectfully declines to make the Staff’s suggested changes.
Disclosure in your filing also indicates that you intend to have a single counterparty for the swap. Given such counterparty concentration, please include disclosure regarding such counterparty in the registration statement and disclose how such information will be provided on an ongoing basis.
RESPONSE:
As noted above, although the Fund is expected to have exposure to only a single counterparty, this exposure is expected to be limited to a small percentage of the Fund’s assets. With respect to the Staff’s comment that the Registrant “include disclosure regarding such counterparty in the registration statement and disclose how such information will be provided on an ongoing basis” we note that the Registration Statement already includes significant disclosure regarding the Gold Delivery Provider.
For example, the Registrant discloses the fact that the Fund is exposed to the Gold Delivery Provider, that the Fund does not expect to enter into transactions with any entity other than the Gold Delivery Provider and discusses the operation of the Gold Delivery Agreement in detail. As an example, please refer to the risk factor at page 27 entitled “The Fund has entered into an agreement with the Gold Delivery Provider pursuant to which …“in which the Registrant discloses that “to the extent that the Gold Delivery Provider could not honor its obligations under the Gold Delivery Agreement, such as due to bankruptcy or default under the agreement, or if the Gold Delivery Agreement is terminated, the Fund would need to find a new entity to act in the same capacity as the Gold Delivery Provider. If the Fund could not quickly find someone to act in that capacity, the operations of the Fund may be adversely affected... The Sponsor would likely terminate and liquidate the Fund if the Gold Delivery Agreement is terminated and the Sponsor is unable to appoint a successor Gold delivery agent within a reasonable amount of time” and the disclosure at Page 27 that “Upon the resignation of the … Gold Delivery Provider … the Sponsor would likely terminate and liquidate the Fund if a replacement cannot be found within a short period.”
The Registrant intends for this disclosure to serve as disclosure on an ongoing basis of the
Fund’s exposure to the Gold Delivery Provider and will update this disclosure as needed on a go-forward basis.
We note that in order to “track the performance of the index,” there will be payments to the Fund in Gold Bullion under the swap that are intended to measure the daily Gold Bullion returns as if the investor had invested in Gold Bullion in the specific Reference Currencies. Through the Fund’s structure, investors will be provided with exposure to the referenced currencies that they would not necessarily be able to obtain directly. Please provide us with a detailed analysis as to why the offering of the Trust interests would not involve the offer and sale of the swap to investors, including to persons who are not eligible contract participants. In that regard, please also provide us with a detailed analysis as to how these swap transactions would be consistent with the provisions of the Commodity Exchange Act, including the restrictions on swaps transactions with persons who are not eligible contract participants.
RESPONSE:
The Gold Delivery Agreement (the “GDA”) is a bilateral contract between the Trust and the Gold Delivery Provider and may be considered to be a swap contract. Section 6 of the GDA requires the daily calculation of the “Net Currency Gain or Loss” or “Net FX PnL”. This amount is intended to reflect (i) unrealized currency gain or loss based on ounces of gold and (ii) the market cost of resizing the currency hedge as a result of changes in net asset value (“NAV”) of the Fund. If the Net FX PnL is positive, it is converted into a number of gold ounces equal to the Gold
Delivery Amount, and the Gold Delivery Provider delivers the Gold Delivery Amount to the Fund. If the Net FX PnL is negative, it is converted into a number of gold ounces equal to the Gold Delivery Amount and the Fund delivers the absolute value of the Gold Delivery Amount to the Gold Delivery Provider. According to Section 6 and Appendix A-1 of the GDA, the Net FX PnL is intended to reflect the gain or loss in dollars on the currency FX position held by the Fund per ounce of gold. This is, arguably, a currency swap which is reset daily and which is settled in cash (although the cash settlement is effected through a conversion into gold and the subsequent delivery of gold). Although the GDA contemplates the physical delivery of gold between the Trust and the Gold Delivery Provider on a daily basis, the Registrant believes it is arguably a “swap” within the meaning of Section 1a(47) of the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC regulations adopted thereunder.
The Trust and the Gold Delivery Provider are the only parties to the GDA. Investors in the Fund (as a series of the Trust) will participate in the economic performance of the GDA through their ownership of interests in the Fund (but do not have any rights to the specific Gold Bullion held by the Fund). In this sense, the Fund is not seeking to offer or sell the GDA or any individual transaction thereunder pursuant to its prospectus (much like a fund that holds stocks or bonds does not seek to sell those securities to investors through its offering of shares). In addition, it is worth noting that only a small percentage of the Fund’s daily returns (typically less than 1%) will result from the GDA.
The Trust is mindful that Section 2(e) of the Commodity Exchange Act makes it unlawful for any person other than an eligible contract participant (“ECP”) to enter into a swap, unless that swap is entered into on a designated contract market. With this provision in mind, to the extent the transactions contemplated by the GDA are a swap, the Trust believes that it is able to enter into the GDA because it qualifies as an ECP within the meaning of Section 1a(18) of the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC Regulation 1.3m(8).
In particular, Section 1a(18)(A)(iv) provides, in relevant part, that a commodity pool is an ECP if it “has total assets exceeding
$5,000,000” and “is formed and operated by a person subject to regulation under [the Commodity Exchange Act] . . . (regardless of whether each investor in the commodity pool . . . is itself an eligible contract participant). . . .”
However, sub-paragraph (A)(iv) is qualified with respect to transactions in foreign currency subject to Sections 2(c)(2)(B) and 2(c)(2)(C) of the Commodity Exchange Act, which limits transactions in foreign currency swaps with persons who are not ECPs. In that regard, the sub-paragraph mandates that a person look-through a commodity pool to its investors: [generally] a commodity pool that engages in transactions (including swaps) in foreign currency will not qualify as an ECP if “any participant is not otherwise an [ECP].”
Importantly, CFTC Regulation 1.3(m)(8) provides an exception to this look-through requirement for a commodity pool, regardless of whether each participant in the commodity pool is an ECP, if all of the following conditions are satisfied:
The commodity pool is not formed for the purpose of evading regulation under Section 2(c)(2)(B) or Section 2(c)(2)(C) of the Commodity Exchange Act or related CFTC rules, regulations, or orders;
The commodity pool has total assets exceeding $10,000,000; and
The commodity pool is formed and operated by a registered commodity pool operator or by a commodity pool operator who is exempt from registration as such pursuant to CFTC Regulation 4.13(a)(3).
The Fund will satisfy the exception to the look-through provision and will qualify as an ECP for the following reasons. First, the Fund will be operated by a registered commodity pool operator. Second, the Fund has been formed for the bona fide purpose of offering participants access to its investment program in gold denominated in designated Reference Currencies through an offering of shares registered under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended. The
Fund was not formed for the purpose of evading the restrictions on non-ECPs transacting in foreign currency swaps. Finally, the Sponsor will ensure that the Fund will have total assets exceeding $10,000,000 when it seeks to enter into each transaction under the GDA.