GENWORTH FINANCIAL INC · Preliminary Proxy Statement filed March 24, 2023 · SEC File No. 1-32195
We note the disclosure in multiple places in the proxy statement that a plurality voting standard will apply to the election of directors. However, we also note your disclosure that the Company is not using a universal proxy card here because Mr.Rest of the question
Scott Klarquist has not met the deadline to provide the information required by Rule 14a-19 within the time period specified in that Rule, although he did meet the deadline under the Company's own advance notice bylaw provision. We note that the Company amended its bylaws in October 2022 and filed those amendments under cover of a Form 8-K filed October 19, 2022. Please identify the specific bylaw amendment language and provide an analysis supporting your view that Mr. Klarquist's nomination is invalid but triggers the use of a plurality rather than a majority voting standard here.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment.Read in the reply
GNW SEC RESPONSE LTR
000001
Under Section 2.7 of the Company’s Amended and Restated Bylaws, effective as of
October 19, 2022 (the “Bylaws”), directors are elected by a majority of votes cast “unless the election is contested, in which case directors shall be elected by a plurality of votes properly cast.” The same section provides that an election is contested if:
“(i) the Secretary receives a notice that a stockholder has nominated or intends to nominate a person for election to the Board of Directors in compliance with theRest of the answer
requirements for stockholder nominees for director set forth in Section 2.12 of these bylaws and (ii) such nomination has not been withdrawn by such stockholder on or prior to the tenth (10th) day before the corporation first mails its notice of meeting for such meeting to the stockholders.”
In short, the Bylaws provide for a plurality voting standard for director elections in the event that a stockholder has delivered a nomination notice under the Bylaws and not withdrawn such notice by the tenth day before the mailing of the
Company’s notice of meeting.
As described in the Preliminary Proxy Statement, Scott Klarquist delivered notice of his intent to nominate himself for election to the Company’s board of directors at the Company’s 2023 Annual Meeting of Stockholders (the “Annual Meeting”) in accordance with Section 2.12 of the Bylaws. If Mr. Klarquist has not withdrawn such notice on or prior to the tenth day before the Company mails its notice of the Annual Meeting (which the Company expects to do as soon as possible), the election of directors at the Annual Meeting will be “contested” under the Bylaws and, accordingly, will have a plurality voting standard.
Although Mr. Klarquist delivered a nomination notice under the Bylaws, he did not provide the notice required by Rule 14a-19(a)(1) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, by March 20, 2023, the deadline for such notice calculated in accordance with
Rule 14a-19(b)(1). Neither Mr. Klarquist’s nomination notice nor any subsequent communications from him have provided the information required by Rule
14a-19(b). To the contrary, Mr. Klarquist affirmatively represented in a letter to Company, dated as of February 20, 2023, that he “currently intend[s] to solicit proxies from 10 or fewer GNW shareholders (i.e., not pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 14a-19).” Because Mr. Klarquist did not comply with the requirements of Rule 14a-19 by failing to provide timely notice under Rule 14a-19(a)(1), the Company omitted Mr. Klarquist from its proxy card in accordance with Rule 14a-19(e)(1).1
Rule 14a-19(e)(1) requires that a proxy card “set forth the names of all persons nominated for election by the registrant and by any person or group of persons that has complied with this section . . . .” (emphasis added)
GNW SEC RESPONSE LTR
000002
The Commission has made clear that the notice required by Rule 14a-19(a)(1) is in addition to any notice required under a registrant’s advance notice provisions.2 Mr. Klarquist delivered the notice required by the
Bylaws for director nominations, but did not deliver the notice required by Rule 14a-19(a)(1). As a result, the election of directors will be “contested” under the Bylaws and will have a plurality voting standard, but Mr. Klarquist has not been included on the Company’s proxy card.
We note the disclosure in this section of the preliminary proxy statement regarding the plurality voting standard for contested elections as it relates to Mr. Klarquist's director nomination. Please revise here and where appropriate in the proxy statement to explain the Company's determination, as outlined in your response letter dated April 4, 2023, that a plurality voting standard applies here, where Mr.Rest of the question
Klarquist has not included an affirmative representation of compliance with the requirements of Rule 14a-19 with respect to his solicitation. Your revised disclosure should explain how the Company interprets the specific applicable bylaw provisions to reach this conclusion, as presented in your April 4, 2023 response letter. In addition, the revised proxy statement should explain that whether a nominating shareholder states that it will or will not comply with Rule 14a19(b)(3)'s minimum solicitation requirement, an election may be contested for purposes of the Company's amended bylaws, and would thus be subject to a plurality versus a majority voting standard.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment.Read in the reply
Scott Klarquist delivered valid notice of his intent to nominate himself for election to the Company’s board of directors in accordance with Section 2.12 of the Company’s Amended and Restated Bylaws (the “Bylaws”) because his notice, as supplemented, set forth the information required to be included therein under Section 2.12. The validity of
Mr. Klarquist’s notice is subject to any information learned by the Company after the date hereof and compliance by Mr.Rest of the answer
Klarquist with the provisions of Section 2.12 of the Bylaws that require compliance after the date hereof, such as the supplements required by Section 2.12(c)(2).
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Page
In addition to providing the other information required by Section 2.12 of the Bylaws,
Mr. Klarquist’s notice complied with Section 2.12(a)(3)(G) because he provided the required representation. Section 2.12(a)(3)(G) requires that a stockholder’s notice set forth
“a representation from such Noticing Party as to whether such Noticing Party or any Stockholder Associated Person intends or is part of a group that intends to (i) solicit proxies in support of the election of any Proposed Nominee in accordance with Rule 14a-19 under the Exchange Act or (ii) engage in a solicitation (within the meaning of Exchange Act Rule 14a-1(l)) with respect to the nomination or other business, as applicable, and if so, the name of each participant (as defined in Item 4 of Schedule 14A under the Exchange Act) in such solicitation.”
In a letter to the Company, dated as of February 20, 2023, Mr. Klarquist stated that “I currently intend to solicit proxies from 10 or fewer GNW shareholders (i.e., not pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 14a-19)” (emphasis added). This representation satisfied Section 2.12(a)(3)(G) of the Bylaws because it stated that Mr. Klarquist did not intend to engage in a solicitation of proxies in accordance with Rule 14a-19 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (as required by clause (i)), but did intend to engage in a solicitation (as required by clause (ii)).
Although Mr. Klarquist represented that he did not intend to solicit proxies in accordance with Rule 14a-19, his representation still satisfied the requirements under Section 2.12(a)(3)(G). Under
Section 2.12(a)(3)(G)(i), a stockholder is not required to solicit proxies in accordance with Rule 14a-19, but only to represent to the Company whether (or not) it intends to do so. Therefore,
Mr. Klarquist’s representation that he did not intend to solicit proxies in accordance with Rule 14a-19 satisfies this provision under the Bylaws.
Neither Mr. Klarquist’s representation, nor any other information provided by Mr. Klarquist, constituted the notice required by
Rule 14a-19(a)(1) because it did not include the information required therein, including a statement that Mr. Klarquist intends to solicit the holders of at least 67% of the Company’s voting power (Rule 14a-19(b)(3)). Notably, Mr. Klarquist could not solicit 67% of the Company’s stockholders even if he solicited the Company’s ten largest stockholders, consistent with his representation.1
In sum, Mr. Klarquist’s nomination notice complied with
Section 2.12 of the Bylaws, including by setting forth a representation that he does not intend to solicit proxies in accordance with Rule 14a-19. However, his notice did not also satisfy Rule 14a-19(a)(1) because it lacked all of the information required thereby.
The Company’s ten largest shareholders own 46.96% of the Company’s outstanding common stock. FactSet, as of April 3, 2023.