Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2016
Organization and Basis of Presentation, page 66 Principles of Consolidation, page 67 1. Throughout your filing, you refer to “controlled builders,” which are your homebuilding subsidiaries in which you own at least a 50% controlling interest.Rest of the question
On page 20, you disclose that because your controlled builders are not wholly-owned, pursuant to each of their applicable operating agreements, you share decision-making authority with the other members of your controlled builders regarding certain major decisions of your controlled builders. In addition on page 3, your table appears to suggest that all of your home sales revenue and lot sales revenue were generated by your controlled builders. Given that you have a 50% interest and share decision making authority with other members of your controlled builders, please tell us how you determine that you have a controlling interest in these controlled builders. Please enhance your accounting policy as well as your critical accounting policy to specifically address how you account for your controlled builders in your financial statements. Please provide a comprehensive analysis of how you determined that you control these entities. Please cite the accounting literature used to support your conclusion.
Pursuant to ASC 810, Consolidation, we consolidate our controlled builders under the voting interest entity model. We prepared our consolidation analysis using the flowcharts under ASC 810-10-05-6. When determining which of the two consolidation models to apply, we first considered the scope exceptions in paragraphs ASC 810-10-15-12 and 15-17, which we did not meet. While each controlled builder is deemed to be a “business,” we provide more than half of their financial support through our first lien construction loans.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Pursuant to paragraphs ASC 810-10-55-16 through 55-41, we concluded that through our right to receive the expected residual returns and obligation to absorb the expected losses we have a variable interest in our controlled builders. In accordance with ASC 810-10-15-14, our controlled builders are not variable interest entities due to the following factors: we have sufficient equity investment at risk in each controlled builder, we have characteristics of controlling financial interests in each controlled builder (ability to make decisions about the controlled builders activities through voting rights, and the right to receive the expected residual returns and the obligation to absorb the expected losses of the controlled builders), and each controlled builder is not structured with disproportionate voting rights where substantially all of the activities are conducted on behalf of the member with disproportionately few voting rights. Therefore, we applied the voting interest entity model in ASC 810-10 to each controlled builder. Per ASC 810-10-05, “Under the voting interest entity model, for legal entities other than limited partnerships, the usual condition for a controlling financial interest is ownership by one reporting entity, directly or indirectly, of more than 50 percent of the outstanding voting shares of another entity.”
We have determined that we exercise control over the operations of each controlled builder under the voting interest entity model, because in addition to owning a 50% equity interest, we also hold a 51% voting percentage interests, and have the ability to appoint two of the three managers of each controlled builder’s board of managers. The board of managers of each controlled builder has the full and exclusive right, power and authority to manage the affairs of the controlled builder and makes all decisions without requiring any consent or approval by the members for routine decisions (including the designation of the officers that manage the day to day operations, etc.). Only certain extraordinary decisions (such as assigning rights in the controlled builder, engaging in any act that would make it impossible to carry on the ordinary/primary business, etc.) require the unanimous approval of all members. As a result, we consolidate our controlled builders' results of operations and financial condition into our financial statements.
In future filings, we will enhance our accounting policy and critical accounting policy to specifically address how we account for our controlled builders in our consolidated financial statements in a form substantially as follows:
The Company evaluated its wholly-owned subsidiaries and controlled builders under ASC Topic 810, Consolidation (“ASC 810”) and concluded that the controlled builders are not variable interest entities. The Company accounts for its controlled builders under the voting interest entity model in accordance with ASC 810. Under the voting interest entity model, the usual condition for a controlling financial interest is ownership by one reporting entity, directly or indirectly, of more than 50 percent of the outstanding voting shares of another entity. The Company owns a 50 percent controlling interest and 51 percent of the voting percentage interests in each controlled builder. In addition, the Company holds two of the three board seats in each controlled builder and is able to exercise control over the operations of the controlled builder. Given that the Company directly or indirectly has an interest of more than 50 percent and can exercise control over the operations through the voting of its board seats, the operations of its controlled builders have been consolidated and noncontrolling interests are stated separately in the consolidated financial statements. All intercompany balances and transactions have been eliminated in consolidation. Generally, the Company forms subsidiaries for each selling community and or homebuilding project in which it invests. As of December 31, 20XX, we had XX direct or indirect subsidiaries.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 14, 2017: 10-Q filed Nov 6, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Significant Accounting Policies, page 67 Revenue Recognition, page 72 2. Please revise your revenue recognition policy to provide the following: Please revise your disclosure to specifically address each type of revenue recognized and the accounting method used to account for each specific type of revenue.Rest of the question
Accordingly, please specifically address how you account for sale of residential units, sale of land and lots, title and settlement services, and the generation of revenue through first lien construction loans to your controlled builders, as applicable; With regards to your sale of residential units, please specifically address how you account for sales incentives, including but not limited to cash discounts, incentives on options and option upgrades and seller-paid financing or closing costs; and Please also address how you account for rebates from vendors, if applicable.
In future filings, we will enhance our revenue recognition policy to provide disclosure on each type of revenue recognized and the accounting method used to account for each type, along with how we account for sales incentives and rebates from vendors in our consolidated financial statements in a form substantially as follows:Read in the reply
Revenue Recognition
Sales of residential units and Sale of land and lots: In accordance with ASC 360-20, Real Estate Sales, we recognize revenue from sales of residential units, land and lots when a sale is consummated.Rest of the answer
Consummation occurs when the following criteria are met: (a) the parties are bound by the terms of the contract; (b) all net consideration has been exchanged; (c) any permanent financing for which the seller is responsible has been arranged; (d) continuing investment is adequate to demonstrate a commitment to pay for the home, land or lot; and (e) all conditions precedent to closing have been performed. Typically, these criteria are met at closing, at which time we recognize revenue under the full accrual method, which allows full recognition of the gain on the sale of the home, land or lot.
We recognize sales incentives, such as cash discounts and incentives on options and option upgrades as a reduction of sales revenue at the time the home is closed and revenue is recognized. We record seller-paid financing and other closing costs within cost of sales of residential units at the time the home is closed and revenue is recognized. From time to time, we receive vendor rebates for certain materials that are utilized in our construction of homes. Pursuant to ASC 605-50-S99-1, we recognize these rebates as a reduction of cost of sales of residential units at the later of (a) the home closing (when revenue is recognized), or (b) when such amounts are reasonably estimable.
We also serve as the general contractor for certain custom homes where the customers, and not our company, own the underlying land and improvements. We recognize revenue for these mechanics lien contracts on the percentage of completion method, where progress toward completion is measured by relating the actual cost of work performed to date to the current estimated total cost of the respective contracts. During the years ended December 31, 20XX, 20XX and 20XX, we recognized revenue of $X.X million, $X.X million and $X.X million, respectively, and incurred costs of $X.X million, $X.X million and $X.X million, respectively, associated with mechanics lien contracts, which is presented on a net basis in other income, net in the consolidated statements of income.
We recognize amounts earned from third parties for title and settlement services as home closings occur, and funds are received, however, given that these amounts are immaterial, we do not believe that incremental disclosures related to our title and settlement services is necessary. During the years ended December 31, 20XX, 20XX and 20XX, we earned $X.X million, $X.X million and $X.X million of such fees, which are included in other income, net in our consolidated statements of income.
With regards to the Staff’s question regarding the generation of revenue through first lien construction loans with our controlled builders, our activity with our controlled builders is eliminated in consolidation, in accordance with ASC 810. In response to your comment, we will revise our Revenues disclosure in Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations on page 36 as follows.
Revenues
We primarily generate revenue through (a) the sale of lots from our land development segment to public builders and large private builders, and (b) the closing and delivery of homes through our builder operations segment. We recognize revenue on homes and lots when completed and title to, and possession of, the property have been transferred to the purchaser.
All customer deposits are treated as liabilities. We also serve as the general contractor for certain custom homes where the customers, and not our company, own the underlying land and improvements. We recognize revenue for these contracts on the percentage of completion method.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 14, 2017: 10-Q filed Nov 6, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You disclose that Builder operations consist of three operating segments: Texas, Georgia, and corporate and other. In addition, the operations of the your controlled builders were aggregated into the builder operations reporting segment because they have similar (1) economic characteristics; (2) housing products; (3) class of homebuyer; (4) regulatory environments; and (5) methods used to construct and sell homes.Rest of the question
Please demonstrate to us how you determined that the aggregation of your three operating segments (including the operations of your controlled builders) into one reportable segment is appropriate and complies with ASC 280-10-50-11.
ASC 280, Segment Reporting, recognizes that separate reporting of internal operating segments is not necessary if the characteristics from segment to segment are so similar that they can reasonably be expected to have the same future prospects. The determination of whether two or more operating segments are similar is dependent on the individual facts and circumstances and is subject to a high degree of judgment.Read in the replyRest of the answer
We determined that the aggregation of our Texas, Georgia and Corporate and Other operating segments into one reportable segment, Builder Operations, is appropriate after assessing the considerations described in ASC 280-10-50-11 as follows:
Similar Economic Characteristics. Except for its reference to similar long-term average gross margins, ASC 280 does not specify which measures should be considered when an enterprise is assessing the “historical and expected future financial performance.” Therefore, we also assessed other standard homebuilding industry performance measures such as average sales price of homes delivered, and average sales price of homes in backlog.
The gross margins of our operating segments vary somewhat based on several factors, including the stage of market development, level of competition, and the amount of development risk that each operating segment bears. From 2014 through 2016, our controlled builders in Texas and Georgia have experienced similar gross margins and we expect similar results to exist going forward. During the aforementioned time frame, the average gross margin for our controlled builders in Texas was 24% compared to 25% for our controlled builder in Georgia. During the six months ended June 30, 2017, our controlled builders in Texas and Georgia have experienced gross margins of 25% and 22%, respectively, which we expect to trend accordingly through the end of 2017. The difference in the margins between our controlled builders is due to timing, due to significant growth in some controlled builders. While the gross margins of our controlled builders may vary somewhat from time to time, our expectation is that our controlled builders would moderate to a comparable long-term average gross margin given the similarities in their business models.
For the year ended December 31, 2016, the average selling price per home delivered was approximately $450,000 and $466,000 in Texas and Georgia, respectively. For the six months ended June 30, 2017, the average selling price per home delivered was approximately $493,000 and $507,000 in Texas and Georgia, respectively. For the year ended December 31, 2016 the average sales price of homes in backlog was approximately $402,000 and $477,000 in Texas and Georgia, respectively. For the six months ended June 30, 2017, the average sales price of homes in backlog was approximately $493,000 and $507,000 in Texas and Georgia, respectively.
Competition in the homebuilding industry is intense, and there are relatively low barriers to entry into our business. Homebuilders compete for, among other things, homebuyers, desirable land parcels, financing, raw materials and skilled labor. The homebuilding competitive environment, and operating and financial risks in Texas and Georgia are relatively similar. We have one controlled builder in Georgia. While our controlled builders in Texas offer several products (i.e. townhomes, single-family homes, and luxury homes), we concluded that they have similar competitive, operating and financial risks. The 2017 expected average adjusted operating margin from homebuilding attributable to Green Brick Partners, Inc. (adjusted for eliminations) for our Texas controlled builders were similar except for one builder whom individually does not meet the quantitative disclosure thresholds in ASC 280.
While there are comparable economic characteristics across the internal operating segments for our controlled builders, these characteristics are not comparable to Green Brick Title, LLC (“Title”).
The Nature of the Products and Services. Although ASC 280 does not define what is meant by the “nature” of products and services, SFAS No. 14 employed a similar concept and stated “…related products and services have similar purposes or end uses. Thus, they may be expected to have similar rates of profitability, similar degrees of risk, and similar opportunities for growth.” Our controlled builders construct townhomes, and single-family and luxury homes (product) within master designed communities which have similar purposes and end uses (home to live in). Additionally, our controlled builders in Texas often sell homes alongside each other in communities that we have developed. Title provides the services required for a potential homebuyer to close on a home and for our land business to close on lots sold to our controlled builders. As such, the nature of the products and services for our title operations are not similar to our homebuilding operations.
The Nature of the Production Processes. Our controlled builders have similar production processes to build and construct communities. The service provided by Title to close on the sale of a house or land are different than the processes to build houses.
The Type or Class of Customer for Their Products and Services. Our controlled builders core markets are in the high growth U.S. metropolitan areas of Dallas, Texas and Atlanta, Georgia. Per the November 2016 US Census Bureau News Release, Atlanta and Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington were two of the nation’s 12 largest metropolitan statistical areas, with the fastest rate of job growth in Dallas-FortWorth-Arlington at 3.3%, followed by Atlanta at 2.6%. Dallas and Georgia are also similar with median household income of $61,644 and $60,219, respectively. Our controlled builders have similar types and classes of customers which include individual homeowners (generally not first time home buyers). Title’s customers are homebuyers of our controlled builders and our land business when we sell land and lots.
The Methods Used to Distribute Their Products or Provide Their Services. Each controlled builder has its own sales force, but operates in a similar fashion to distribute their products through similar marketing and sales methods. Our controlled builders use their websites and signages to market and promote their products (houses). Title provides its service through its connection with our controlled builders and our land business.
The Nature of the Regulatory Environment. Our developments are subject to numerous local, state, federal and other statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations concerning zoning, development, building design, construction and similar matters that impose restrictive zoning and density requirements, the result of which is to limit the number of homes that can be built within the boundaries of a particular area. We are also subject to a variety of local, state, federal and other statutes, ordinances, rules and regulations concerning the environment. The local and state rules and regulations vary, but are generally similar, between Texas and Georgia. Title is also subject to numerous Texas and federal rules and regulations.
Our controlled builders have nearly identical building practices, product mixes, customer demographics and marketing plans, which supports our analysis that they should be aggregated into one reportable segment. Additionally, combining builders with similar economic characteristics, albeit in separate geographies, is consistent with industry practice including the disclosures of other publicly-traded homebuilders.
While Title’s operations are not economically similar to either the Builder Operations or Land Development segments, it did not meet the quantitative thresholds to be separately reported and disclosed. Accordingly, Title’s results are included within our Builder Operations segment within “Corporate and Other”.
As a result of the foregoing, we respectfully submit to the Staff that the aggregation of our controlled builders Texas and Georgia operations, and title operations into one reportable segment is appropriate and complies with ASC 280-10-50-11. The segment disclosure presents our Texas, Georgia and Corporate and Other operating segments separately under the Builder Operations reportable segment.
If you have any further questions, need any additional information or wish to discuss this letter in greater detail, please contact me at (813) 220-5855 or Alice Hsu of Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP at (212) 872-1053.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 14, 2017: 10-Q filed Nov 6, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2017 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Organization and Basis of Presentation, page 66 Principles of Consolidation, page 67 1. We note your response to prior comment one. You indicate that your controlled builders are not variable interest entities due to the fact that you have (a) sufficient equity investment at risk in each controlled builder, (b) characteristics of controlling interest in each controlled builders, and (c) each controlled builder isRest of the question
not structured with disproportionate voting rights where substantially all of the activities are conducted on behalf of the member with disproportionately few voting rights. Given that you provide more than half of the financial support of your controlled builders through your first lien construction loans, please provide us with a more robust analysis of how you determined that your controlled builders are not variable interest entities. Please specifically address how you determined that each of your controlled builders have sufficient equity to finance their activities without additional subordinated financial support pursuant to ASC 810-10-25-45 through 25-47. Please also enhance your discussion of how you determined that you have characteristics of a controlling financial interest including but not limited to the specific responsibilities of your board of managers to approve budgets and allocate resources and your specific rights to absorb expected losses and receive expected residual returns. If you conclude that your controlled builders are variable interest entities, please provide your comprehensive analysis of how you applied the Variable Interest Model.
Per ASC 810-10-15-17(d), a legal entity that is deemed to be a business need not be evaluated by the reporting entity to determine if the legal entity is a variable interest entity (“VIE”) unless certain conditions exists, including if the reporting entity provides more than half of the total subordinated debt or other forms of subordinated financial support to the legal entity.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Each controlled builder is deemed to be a business; however, since we participated significantly in the design of each controlled builder, our controlled builders do not meet the “business” scope exception.
Per ASC 810-10-15-14, a legal entity shall be subject to consolidation as a VIE if, by design, condition (a) or (b) below is present:
(a) The total equity investment at risk is not sufficient to permit the legal entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support.
Pursuant to ASC 810-10-25-45, we performed a qualitative assessment to determine whether the equity investment at risk at the inception of each controlled builder was sufficient. Our controlled builders were designed such that we would finance their purchases of land, from us, at an unlevered internal rate of return of at least 20% (which is consistent with our return on land sales to third-party homebuilders) and provide construction financing at an approximate 13.8% interest rate. These first lien loans are secured and unsubordinated, which we believe is consistent with most of our public homebuilders peer group (i.e. Hovnanian Enterprises, Inc., Lennar Corporation, MI Homes, Inc., Standard Pacific Corp., Toll Brothers, Inc., and KB Home) mortgages and notes payables. Our controlled builders were formed for us to provide the financing while the other members provide their local relationships with land sellers, brokers and investors to pursue the purchase of additional land parcels in the applicable local market. The initial capital contribution for each controlled builder was $0.2 million or less, which accounted for less than 1% of the total assets of each controlled builder. While the equity investment at risk was less than 10% of our controlled builders’ total assets, our controlled builders would have been able to obtain commercial financing on customary terms without additional subordinated financial support. During 2011 through 2013, the years that our controlled builders were formed, we noted that our public homebuilders peer group had outstanding mortgage and notes payable related to land and construction with interest rates ranging from 3% to 10%, with most of the rates in the range of 6% to 10%. We would expect the public homebuilders to obtain lower interest rates due to their size and long-standing credit history. During 2011 through 2013, the homebuilding industry and mortgage loan market were coming out of a downturn, as such there were more risks involved for banks lending money to newly formed homebuilding companies. As such, our private controlled builders would have been subjected to higher interest rates on their land and construction loans compared to public homebuilders. Therefore, the interest rate we charge to our controlled builders was reasonable at the time they were designed. We concluded that this condition (a) does not exist, since at the time of formation, our controlled builders would have been able to obtain unsubordinated financing, even if at higher interest rates than public homebuilders.
(b) The holders of the equity investment at risk lack the power to direct the activities of a legal entity that most significantly impact the entity’s economic performance, lack the obligation to absorb expected losses of the legal entity, or lack the right to receive the expected residual returns of the legal entity.
The board of managers of each of our controlled builders, who are appointed by the holders of the equity investment at risk, have the power to direct the activities that significantly impact our controlled builders’ economic performance. Pursuant to our agreement with each controlled builder, we have the ability to appoint two of the three managers of each controlled builder’s board of managers. The exclusive authority to manage, control and operate the controlled builder is vested collectively in the individuals appointed to the board of managers. The action of a majority of the board of managers present at a meeting constitutes a quorum to transact business, so long as one of our managers is present. If any action is taken without a meeting, a written consent describing the action must be signed by the majority of the board of managers, as long as one of our managers consent. As such, no action can be approved by the board of managers without the approval from at least one individual we have appointed at each controlled builder. Each year, our controlled builders submit an annual budget and plan which is approved by the board of managers. The annual budget and plan cannot be approved without our input and final approval. In addition, pursuant to our typical controlled builder agreements, profits and losses are allocated pro rata based on each member’s ownership interest. While we have a 51% voting right, we have the obligation to absorb 50% of the expected losses and the right to receive 50% of the expected residual returns of each controlled builder. Our controlled builders’ activities are not conducted on behalf of any one member. As such, we concluded that this condition (b) does not exist.
Based on the analysis above that neither condition (a) nor (b) are present, we concluded that our controlled builders are not VIEs. Therefore, we applied the voting interest entity model in ASC 810-10 to each controlled builder. Our analysis under the voting interest entity model was explained in our response dated September 14, 2017, and under that model, we concluded that we should consolidate our controlled builders’ results of operations and financial condition into our financial statements.
Alternatively, if it was determined that the equity investment at risk is not sufficient to permit our controlled builders to finance their activities without additional subordinated financial support, we would continue to analyze whether we should consolidate our controlled builders under the VIE model pursuant to ASC-810. Regarding that analysis, we have the power to direct the activities of our controlled builders that most significantly impact their economic performance, and the obligation to absorb losses and the right to receive benefits that could potentially be significant to our controlled builders. The agreements with our controlled builders do not include kick-out rights or substantive rights; thus, we would conclude that we should consolidate our controlled builders as the primary beneficiary under the VIE model.
If you have any further questions, need any additional information or wish to discuss this letter in greater detail, please contact me at (813) 220-5855 or Alice Hsu of Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP at (212) 872-1053.
First report after the company's reply of Nov 13, 2017: 10-K filed Mar 12, 2018 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 13, 2017 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Organization and Basis of Presentation, page 66 Principles of Consolidation, page 67 1. We note your response to prior comment one. Given that you provide more than half of the financial support of your controlled builders through your first lien construction loans, it is still not clear how you determined that your controlled builders are not variable interest entities.Rest of the question
Please provide the following information: You indicated that the initial capital contribution for each controlled builder was $0.2 million or less, which accounted for less than 1% of the total assets of each controlled builder. Please tell us how you determined that the controlled builders would have been able to obtain commercial financing on customary terms without additional subordinated financial support. Please provide a more comprehensive analysis including quantitative and/or qualitative factors considered; Given size and credit history of your controller builders, please tell us how you determined that the interest rate charged to your controlled builders was reasonable. Please provide support that is consistent with similar size builders as your controlled builders, rather than public companies, as these companies are not comparable to your controlled builders. Please specifically tell us whether your controlled builders have enough equity to induce lenders or other investors to provide the funds necessary at “market terms” for your controlled builders to conduct their activities; Given that the homebuilding industry was coming out of a downturn, please tell us how you determined that companies with similar risk profiles as your controlled builders were extended credit from lending institutions; and If you conclude that your controlled builders are variable interest entities, please provide a comprehensive analysis of how you applied the Variable Interest Model and provide your proposed disclosures.
We have reviewed the Staff's comment from its January 8, 2018 letter and we note that the first three bullet points relate to criteria to determine whether each of our controlled builders is a variable interest entity (“VIE”). As noted in the first three bullet points, at formation, the initial capital contribution for each controlled builder was less than 1% of the total assets of each controlled builder, our controlled builders were small private homebuilders with a lack of credit history, and there was a downturn in the homebuilding industry.Read in the replyRest of the answer
After further analysis, we have determined that our controlled builders are VIEs and accordingly have provided the requested comprehensive analysis of how we evaluated and applied the Variable Interest Model and our proposed disclosures.
Variable Interest Model
In summary, pursuant to ASC 810, Consolidation, we will continue to consolidate our controlled builders; however, we will now disclose that the consolidation is based upon application of the Variable Interest Model instead of the Voting Model. We prepared our consolidation analysis using the flowcharts under ASC 810-10-05-6. When determining which of the two consolidation models to apply, we first considered the scope exceptions in paragraphs ASC 810-10-15-12 and 15-17, which we determined we did not meet. While each of our controlled builders is deemed to be a “business,” our controlled builders were designed such that we would finance their purchases of land, from us, and we would provide construction financing through first lien loans that are secured and unsubordinated. Pursuant to paragraphs ASC 810-10-55-16 through 55-41, we concluded that, through our 50% equity interest and associated right to receive the expected residual returns and our obligation to absorb the expected losses of our controlled builders, we have a variable interest in each controlled builder.
Per ASC 810-10-15-14, a legal entity shall be subject to consolidation as a VIE if, by design, (a) the total equity investment at risk is not sufficient to permit the legal entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support, or (b) the holders of the equity investment at risk lack the power to direct the activities of a legal entity that most significantly impact the entity’s economic performance, lack the obligation to absorb expected losses of the legal entity, or lack the right to receive the expected residual returns of the legal entity.
We initially concluded that our controlled builders would have been able to obtain unsubordinated financing, even if at higher interest rates than public homebuilders as discussed in our previous response dated November 13, 2018. However, as stated above, after further analysis, we have determined that our controlled builders are VIEs and we have now applied the Variable Interest Model. Pursuant to ASC 810-10-25-45, we performed a qualitative assessment to determine whether the equity investment at risk at the inception of each controlled builder was sufficient. Our controlled builders were formed under the operating premise that we would provide the financing while the builders provide their home building construction, selling and operating expertise. The initial capital contribution for each controlled builder was less than 1% of the total assets of each controlled builder. Given that the equity investment at risk at inception was less than 10% of each of our controlled builder’s total assets, our controlled builders would not have been able to obtain commercial financing on customary terms without additional subordinated financial support. As such, the equity investment at risk at the time of our investment in our controlled builders was not sufficient to permit them to finance their activities without additional subordinated financial support.
The board of managers of each of our controlled builders, who are appointed by the holders of the equity investment at risk, have the power to direct the activities that significantly impact each of our controlled builder’s economic performance because the board of managers has the exclusive authority to manage, control and operate the controlled builder. Pursuant to our agreements with each controlled builder, we have and exercise the right to appoint two of the three managers of each controlled builder’s board of managers. The two managers we appoint are not subject to the approval of the other members of our controlled builders, but the removal or replacement of a manager appointed by the other members of our controlled builders is subject to our approval. The other members of our controlled builders do not have any veto rights. A majority of the board of managers present at a meeting constitutes a quorum to transact business, so long as one of the managers appointed by us is present. If any action is taken without a meeting, a written consent describing the action must be signed by the majority of the board of managers, as long as one of the managers appointed by us consents. As such, no action can be approved by the board of managers without the approval from at least one individual we have appointed at each controlled builder. Furthermore, each year, our controlled builders submit an annual budget and plan which must be approved by the board of managers. The annual budget and plan cannot be approved without our input and final approval. Accordingly, we have the power to direct the activities that significantly impact the controlled builders’ economic performance. Unanimous consent of the board of managers is required for a member to transfer its membership interest. However, we have the right to transfer all or part of our interests in our controlled builders to any entity which is controlled directly or indirectly by us without approval from the board of managers. In addition, pursuant to all of our controlled builder agreements, profits and losses are allocated pro rata based on each member’s ownership interest. While we have a 51% voting right in the case of each controlled builder, we have the obligation to absorb 50% of the expected losses and the right to receive 50% of the expected residual returns of each controlled builder. Our controlled builders’ activities are not conducted on behalf of any one member. As such, we have concluded that the members of the equity investment at risk do not lack (i) the power to direct the activities of the controlled builders that most significantly impact the controlled builders’ economic performance, (ii) the obligation to absorb expected losses of the controlled builders, or (iii) the right to receive the expected residual returns of the controlled builders.
While we have the obligation to absorb 50% of the expected losses and the right to receive 50% of the expected benefits of the controlled builders, the equity investment at risk was not sufficient to permit the legal entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support. Therefore, we have now concluded that each of our controlled builders is a VIE and we have further evaluated each controlled builder for consolidation under the Variable Interest Model.
Once a reporting entity concludes that it has a variable interest in a VIE, the first condition under the Variable Interest Model is to evaluate whether the reporting entity is the primary beneficiary. The primary beneficiary is the party that has (a) the power to direct the activities of a VIE that most significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance, and (b) the obligation to absorb losses of the VIE and the right to receive benefits from the VIE that could potentially be significant to the VIE pursuant to ASC 810-10-25-38A through 25-38J and ASC 810-10-25-42. As noted above, we have the ability to control the activities of each controlled builder that most significantly impact the controlled builder’s economic performance. Such activities include, but are not limited to, involvement in the day to day capital decisions, the ability to approve and modify the budget and plan, the ability to control financing decisions, the ability to replace the president and other officers of the building company, and the ability to acquire additional land or dispose of land. In addition, we have the obligation to absorb 50% of the expected losses and the right to receive 50% of the expected residual returns of each controlled builder. Per ASC 810-10-25-38C, the determination of whether an entity has the power to direct the activities of the VIE that most significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance should not be affected by the existence of kick-out or participating rights unless a single reporting entity has the unilateral ability to exercise those rights. None of the members under the controlled builder agreements have the unilateral ability to exercise kick-out or participating rights. Therefore, we concluded that we are the primary beneficiary of each controlled builder.
Based on the further analysis above, we have concluded that our controlled builders are VIEs of which we are the primary beneficiary. This change in position from consolidation under the Voting Model to the Variable Interest Model does not have a material impact on our current or prior years consolidated financial statements as we have always consolidated our controlled builders.
Proposed Disclosures
In future filings, we will update our principles of consolidation and critical accounting policies to specifically address how we account for our controlled builders in our consolidated financial statements in a form substantially as follows:
Principles of Consolidation
The Company evaluated its wholly-owned subsidiaries and controlled builders under ASC Topic 810, Consolidation (“ASC 810”) and concluded that each controlled builder is a variable interest entity (“VIE”). The Company owns a 50 percent interest and has 51 percent of the voting interest in each controlled builder. In addition, the Company appoints two of the three board managers of each controlled builder and is able to exercise control over the operations of each controlled builder. The Company accounts for its controlled builders under the variable interest model and is the primary beneficiary of each controlled builder in accordance with ASC 810 (see Note 2). All intercompany balances and transactions have been eliminated in consolidation.
The Company uses the equity method of accounting for its investment in an unconsolidated entity over which it exercises significant influence but does not have a controlling interest. Under the equity method, the Company’s share of the unconsolidated entity’s earnings or loss, if any, is included in the consolidated statements of income.
Generally, the Company forms subsidiaries for each selling community and or homebuilding project in which it invests.
Variable Interest Entities and Noncontrolling Interests
The Company accounts for VIEs in accordance with ASC 810. In accordance with ASC 810, an entity is a VIE when: (a) the equity investment at risk in the entity is not sufficient to permit the entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support provided by other parties, including the equity holders; (b) the entity’s equity holders as a group either (i) lack the direct or indirect ability to make decisions about the entity, (ii) are not obligated to absorb expected losses of the entity or (iii) do not have the right to receive expected residual returns of the entity; or (c) the entity’s equity holders have voting rights that are not proportionate to their economic interests, and the activities of the entity involve or are conducted on behalf of the equity holder with disproportionately few voting rights. If an entity is deemed to be a VIE pursuant to ASC 810, the enterprise that has both (i) the power to direct the activities of a VIE that most significantly impacts the entity’s economic performance and (ii) the obligation to absorb the expected losses of the entity or right to receive benefits from the entity that could be potentially significant to the VIE is considered the primary beneficiary and must consolidate the VIE. In accordance with ASC 810, the Company performs ongoing reassessments of whether it is the primary beneficiary of a VIE.
The Company owns 50% equity interests in several controlled builders, deemed to be VIEs under ASC 810 for which the Company is considered the primary beneficiary. Our controlled builders are engaged in all aspects of the homebuilding process in residential neighborhoods and master planned communities in premium locations in the Dallas and Atlanta markets. We sell finished lots or option lots from third-party developers to our controlled builders for their homebuilding operations and provide them with construction financing and strategic planning. The board of managers of each of the controlled builders has the power to direct the activities that significantly impact the controlled builder’s economic performance. Pursuant to the Company’s agreements with each controlled builder, it has the ability to appoint two of the three managers of each controlled builder’s board of managers. A majority of the board of managers constitutes a quorum to transact business. No action can be approved by the board of managers without the approval from at least one individual whom the Company has appointed at each controlled builder. The Company has the ability to control the activities of each controlled builder that most significantly impact the controlled builder’s economic performance. Such activities include, but are not limited to, involvement in the day to day capital and operating decisions, the ability to determine the budget and plan, the ability to control financing decisions, and the ability to acquire additional land or dispose of land. In addition, the Company has the right to receive the expected residual returns and obligation to absorb the expected losses of each controlled builder through the pro rata profits and losses it is allocated based on its ownership interest. Therefore, the financial statements of the controlled builders are consolidated in the Company’s consolidated financial statements following the variable interest model. The noncontrolling interests attributable to the 50% minority interests owned by our controlled builders are included as noncontrolling interests in the Company’s consolidated financial statements.
Our controlled builders creditors have no recourse against us. The assets of two of our consolidated controlled builders can only be used to settle obligations of those controlled builders. The assets of our VIEs that can be used only to settle obligations of the VIEs as of December 31, 2017 totaled $X.X million, of which $X.X million was cash and $X.X million was inventory. The assets of our VIEs that can be used only to settle obligations of the VIEs as of December 31, 2016 totaled $X.X million, of which $X.X million was cash and $X.X million was inventory.
If you have any further questions, need any additional information or wish to discuss this letter in greater detail, please contact me at (813) 220-5855 or Alice Hsu of Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP at (212) 872-1053.
First report after the company's reply of Jan 23, 2018: 10-K filed Mar 12, 2018 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 13, 2017 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2018-02-15