The Company respectfully advises the Staff that on April 17, 2013, it entered into a joint venture, IAGM Retail Fund I, LLC (“IAGM”), with PGGM Private Real Estate Fund (“PGGM”), for the purpose of acquiring, owning, managing, supervising, and disposing of properties and sharing in the profits and losses from those properties and its activities.
Rest of the answer
The Company is the managing member of IAGM, responsible for the day-to-day activities, and earns fees for venture management, property management, leasing and other services provided to IAGM.
In connection with entering into the joint venture in 2013, the Company first analyzed the joint venture agreement to determine whether IAGM would be considered a variable interest entity (“VIE”). Under the provisions of ASC 810-10-15-14, an entity is a VIE if it has any of the following characteristics:
a)
The total equity investment (equity investments in a legal entity are interests that are required to be reported as equity in that entity’s financial statements) at risk is not sufficient to permit the legal entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support provided by any parties, including equity holders.
b)
As a group, the holders of the equity investment at risk lack any one of three specified characteristics of a controlling financial interest: (i) the direct or indirect ability through voting rights or similar rights to make decisions about the legal entity’s activities that have a significant effect on the success of the legal entity, (ii) the obligation to absorb the losses of the legal entity, and (iii) the right to receive the expected residual returns of the legal entity.
c)
The equity investors as a group are also considered to lack the characteristic in (b)(i) above if (x) the voting rights of some investors are not proportional to their obligations to absorb the expected losses of the legal entity, their rights to receive the expected residual returns of the legal entity, or both, and (y) substantially all of the legal entity’s activities either involve or are conducted on behalf of an investor that has disproportionately few voting rights. For purposes of applying this requirement, reporting entities shall consider each party’s obligations to absorb expected losses and rights to receive expected residual returns related to all of that party’s interests in the legal entity and not only to its equity investment at risk.
Based on its assessment of the above criteria, the Company concluded that IAGM was not a VIE. The Company determined that there was sufficient equity investment at risk to permit IAGM to finance its activities without additional subordinate financial support, and therefore it did not exhibit the first characteristic noted above. The Company also determined that as a group the holders of the equity investment at risk did not lack any of the three specified characteristics outlined in the second criterion. Jointly, the Company and PGGM retain all decision-making power and will benefit financially (either from losses or income) from the operations of IAGM. Though the decision-making power of each equity holder is not necessarily proportional to its obligations to absorb losses or right to receive returns (for example, the Company has an equity stake of 55%, but equally shares decision-making power with PGGM for all major decisions, as further described below), substantially all of IAGM’s activities are conducted on behalf of both members and not on behalf a member with disproportionately few voting rights. Therefore, the Company determined that the group has the power to direct the activities of IAGM, and that IAGM lacked the second and third characteristics noted above.
After concluding that the joint venture was not a VIE pursuant to the guidance found in ASC 810-10-15-14, the Company then relied upon ASC 810-20, Control of Partnerships and Similar Entities, to determine the proper accounting treatment for its investment in IAGM. If the Company had a controlling financial interest in IAGM, consolidation under the Voting Model in ASC 810 would have been appropriate.
ASC 810-20-25-3 states that “the general partners in a limited partnership are presumed to control that limited partnership regardless of the extent of the general partners’ ownership interest in the limited partnership.”
ASC 810-20-25-5 further states that “the assessment of whether the rights of the limited partners shall overcome the presumption of control by the general partners is a matter of judgment that depends on facts and circumstances. The general partners do not control the limited partnership if the limited partners have either of the following:
The substantive ability to dissolve (liquidate) the limited partnership or otherwise remove the general partners without cause (as distinguished from with cause)
Substantive participating rights.
The guidance noted above refers to limited partnerships, but the scope applies to similar entities that have governing provisions that are the functional equivalent of a limited partnership, such as a limited liability company. Therefore, the Company used ASC 810-20, Control of Partnerships and Similar
Entities to determine whether the joint venture should be consolidated.
As the Company is the managing member (the equivalent of a general partner), the Company initially presumed that it controlled IAGM. Based upon the agreements, PGGM (the equivalent of a limited partner), does not have kick-out rights and cannot remove the Company as the managing member without cause. Therefore to overcome the presumption that the Company controls IAGM, the Company analyzed whether PGGM has substantive participating rights.
Substantive participating rights are defined in ASC 810-20-25-12 as follows: Participating rights are different from protective rights. Limited partners’ protective rights that are only protective in nature do not overcome the presumption that the general partners control the limited partnership. Limited partners’ rights, individually or in the aggregate, that provide the limited partners with the right to effectively participate in significant decisions that would be expected to be made in the ordinary course of the limited partnership’s business while being protective of the limited partners’ investment overcome the presumption that the general partners control the limited partnership.
Specific examples of substantive participating rights as outlined in ASC 810-20-25-13 include: (a) Selecting, terminating, and setting the compensation of management responsible for implementing the limited partnership’s policies and procedures
(b) Establishing operating and capital decisions of the limited partnership, including budgets, in the ordinary course of business.
The Company was appointed as the initial managing member of IAGM, an action that required unanimous consent from the Company and PGGM. Although this position gave the Company the right to manage IAGM on a day-to-day basis, certain decisions, defined as “Major Decisions” in the operating agreement of IAGM, require the consent of PGGM through its representatives on IAGM’s executive committee. The executive committee contains two representatives from the Company and two representatives from PGGM, and must give unanimous consent for any Major Decision. Major Decisions include operating and capital decisions of IAGM that would be made in the ordinary course of business, including, but not limited to, 1) the sale or transfer of properties, 2) determination and modification of loan terms and conditions, 3) approval of operating and capital budgets and modification of the budgets resulting in a change to any expense or revenue item in excess of 10% in aggregate, and 4) execution, modification, or termination of a “Major Lease” (tenant greater than 10,000 square feet). The
Company considers these Major Decisions to be significant decisions expected to be made in the ordinary course of business, in-line with the purpose of IAGM to acquire, own, manage, supervise and dispose of properties.
Based on this assessment, the Company determined that PGGM has substantive participating rights that overcome the presumption that the Company controls IAGM. Because the Company does not have a controlling financial interest, IAGM is not consolidated. ASC 810-20-25-11 states “[i]f the limited partners have substantive participating rights, the presumption of control by the general partners would be overcome and each of the general partners would account for its investment in the limited partnership using the equity method of accounting.” Therefore, the
Company accounts for the investment via the equity method. The equity method requires the Company measure the investment in IAGM initially at cost, adjust the carrying amount of the investment for its share of the earnings or losses of IAGM after the date of investment and report the recognized earnings or losses in income.
The Company also respectfully advises the
Staff that because Major Decisions require unanimous consent, it is considered a deadlock if the executive committee is unable to agree on a decision. Written notice of a failure to agree is required to be delivered from the applicable member to the other, and a deadlock occurs if agreement is not reached within 60 days of such notice. If a deadlock has occurred per the terms of the operating agreement of IAGM, then the Company can exercise a call right to buy out PGGM, or the entity can liquidate. The Company, as managing member, does not have the ultimate authority regarding Major Decisions and is unable to override the vote of PGGM.