Form 10-K
Please provide a detailed legal analysis regarding whether the Company and each of its subsidiaries meets the definition of an “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the Investment Company Act of 1940. Please include in your analysis all relevant calculations under Section 3(a)(1)(C) as of the most recent fiscal quarter end, identifying each constituent part of the numerators and denominators.Rest of the question
Please also describe and discuss any substantive determinations and/or characterizations of assets that are material to your calculations.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that neither the Company nor any of its subsidiaries is an “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the “1940 Act”), because the Company and each of its subsidiaries meets the requirements under Section 3(a)(1)(C) or under Section 3(c)(12) and/or qualifies for the safe harbor from “investment company” status provided in Rule 3a-8 under the 1940 Act.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company provides an analysis of each of Section 3(a)(1)(C), Section 3(c)(12) and Rule 3a-8 under the 1940 Act below.
A.Section 3(a)(1)(C)
Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the 1940 Act defines an “investment company” as any company that [1] is in the business of investing, reinvesting, owning, holding, or trading in securities and [2] owns or proposes to acquire “investment securities” having a value exceeding 40% of its total assets (other than U.S. government securities and cash items) on an unconsolidated basis (such second prong, the “40% Test”). For purposes of the 40% Test, direct voting interests in majority-owned subsidiaries that neither are “investment companies” under the 1940 Act nor rely on a “private fund” exclusion from the definition of an “investment company” provided by Section 3(c)(1) or Section 3(c)(7) of the 1940 Act are excluded from the definition of investment securities and instead are considered as operational assets that are included in the total assets of the issuer.1 i.Section 3(a)(1)(C) – Engaging in the Business of Investing, Reinvesting, Owning, Holding, or Trading in Securities
With respect to the first prong of Section 3(a)(1)(C), neither the Company nor any of its subsidiaries is in the business of investing, reinvesting, owning, holding, or trading in securities, because they each have been collectively engaged in the business of developing an all-electric, vertical take-off and landing (“eVTOL”) air taxi. The Company respectfully directs the Staff to the analysis set forth in response to comment 2 below concerning the business of the Company and its subsidiaries.
ii.Section 3(a)(1)(C) – 40% Test
The Company is a holding company engaged in business exclusively through a total of one direct and sixteen indirect operating subsidiaries [***] (collectively, the “Operating
1 See 1940 Act Section 3(a)(2) (defining “investment securities” as used in Section 3 of the 1940 Act).
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
Subsidiaries”). Appendix A hereto includes a list of the Company’s Operating Subsidiaries and a chart showing the Company’s legal structure.2 Each of the Operating Subsidiaries is wholly owned, either directly or indirectly, by the Company.3 As of September 30, 2024 (the Company’s most recent fiscal quarter end), the Company’s sole asset on an unconsolidated basis was its interest in Joby Aero, Inc. (“Legacy Joby”), its wholly owned subsidiary. Accordingly, whether the Company is an investment company under the 40% Test depends primarily on whether Legacy Joby and any of its subsidiaries meet the definition of investment company or rely on one of the 1940 Act’s private fund exclusions.
Legacy Joby is the only Operating Subsidiary that owns any investment securities (each such Operating Subsidiary that is a subsidiary of Legacy Joby, a “Legacy Joby Subsidiary”). Under the 40% Test, therefore, the ratio of investment securities to total assets (less U.S. government securities and cash items) on an unconsolidated basis (the “Asset Ratio”) of each Legacy Joby Subsidiary is 0%, and no Legacy Joby Subsidiary is an “investment company” as defined in Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the 1940 Act.4
2 Note that the number of subsidiaries referenced in Exhibit 21.1 of the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023, is fewer than the number of entities listed in Appendix A, as the Company has omitted subsidiaries that are not, in the aggregate, “significant” from Exhibit 21.1 as permitted by Item 601(b)(21)(ii) of Regulation S-K, but has listed all of its subsidiaries in Appendix A.
3 [***].
4 As discussed above, the 40% Test also includes investment securities that an issuer “proposes to acquire.” No Legacy Joby Subsidiary currently proposes to acquire investment securities.
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
With respect to Legacy Joby, the Company has determined that unconsolidated Legacy Joby’s Asset Ratio exceeds 40% as follows:
Balance Sheet Amount as of September 30, 2024
(in thousands)
1940 Act Categorization
Cash items
$ [***]
Cash
Restricted Cash
[***]
Short-term marketable securities
Investment Securities
Non-interest bearing, ordinary course intercompany and other receivables
Operating assets
Interest-bearing intercompany receivables
Prepaid expenses
Property and equipment, net
Operating lease right-of-use assets
Intangible assets
Goodwill
Investments in majority-owned subsidiaries
Other assets5
Total assets
As of September 30, 2024
(in thousands, except percentage)
Total Assets Less Cash [Denominator]
Investment Securities [Numerator]
40% Test Asset Ratio 67%
However, as described more fully below, Legacy Joby is not an “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the 1940 Act because it qualifies for the non-exclusive safe harbor from the definition of “investment company” for certain “research and development” companies provided by Rule 3a-8 under the 1940 Act (any such company relying on Rule 3a-8, an “R&D Company”). [***]. Accordingly, neither Legacy Joby nor any Legacy Joby Subsidiary relies on a “private fund” exclusion from the definition of an “investment company” provided in Section 3(c)(1) or Section 3(c)(7) of the 1940 Act, and as a result, the Company’s interest in Legacy Joby is not an “investment security” within the meaning of the 1940 Act.
In light of the foregoing analysis, the Company’s interest in Legacy Joby is attributed to the Company’s total assets but not to its investment securities in determining the Asset Ratio of the Company. Based on the Company’s assets as of September 30, 2024, on an unconsolidated basis, investment securities account for 0% of the Company’s total assets exclusive of U.S. government securities and cash items.
5 Primarily Uber acquisition related contractual agreement asset, disclosed in Note 5 of the financial statements included in the Form 10-K.
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
B.Rule 3a-8
Each of the Company and Legacy Joby is not an “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(C) of the 1940 Act in reliance on the non-exclusive safe harbor from the definition of “investment company” for R&D Companies provided by Rule 3a-8 under the 1940 Act. Consistent with the purpose of the Rule 3a-8 safe harbor, the Company and Legacy Joby have a need to maintain liquid capital in order to fund their research and development activities. The Company and Legacy Joby rely on Rule 3a-8 in order to make investments in capital preservation investments, which typically allow for a marginally higher rate of return than cash and U.S. government securities at an acceptable level of risk. Consequently, Legacy Joby’s investment securities may exceed the 40% Test at any given time without sacrificing its ability to manage its liquid assets in a prudent manner by investing in capital preservation investments.
Under Rule 3a-8, an issuer will not be deemed to be an “investment company” if the following requirements, among others, are satisfied:6
•For the last four fiscal quarters combined:
◦Research and development expenses7 are a substantial percentage of its total expense for the same period;
◦Net income derived from investments in securities does not exceed twice the amount of research and development expenses;
◦Expenses for investment advisory and management activities, investment research and custody (“Investment-Related Expenses”) do not exceed 5% of total expenses;
•All investments in securities are “capital preservation investments,” except that (i) no more than 10% of the issuer’s total assets consist of “other investments,” or (ii) no more than 25% of the issuer’s total assets consist of “other investments” if at least 75% of such other investments are investments made pursuant to a collaborative research and development arrangement;
•The issuer does not hold itself out as being engaged in the business of investing, reinvesting or trading in securities, and it is not a “special situation investment company”;
6 Note that the relevant consolidated financial information of the Company and Legacy Joby for purposes of Rule 3a-8 are the same. Accordingly, we have not provided a separate analysis for each such entity, as the analysis is identical for both entities.
7 Under Rule 3a-8, “research and development expenses” means research and development costs as defined in FASB ASC Topic 730, Research and Development, as currently in effect or as it may be subsequently revised.
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
•The issuer is primarily engaged in a business or businesses other than that of investing, reinvesting, owning, holding, or trading in securities, as evidenced by: (i) the activities of its officers, directors and employees, (ii) its public representations of policies, (iii) its historical development, and (iv) an appropriate resolution of its board of directors, which resolution or action has been recorded contemporaneously in its minute books or comparable documents; and
•The issuer’s board of directors has adopted a written investment policy with respect to its capital preservation investments.
i.Rule 3a-8 Financial Tests
The Company’s and Legacy Joby’s R&D Expenses are a substantial percentage of their total expenses.
The term “substantial” is not defined under Rule 3a-8; however, the Staff has stated that a ratio of R&D Expenses to total expenses greater than or equal to 20% will generally be considered a substantial percentage where an issuer otherwise meets the requirements of Rule 3a-8.8 Based on such guidance, each of the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s R&D Expenses9, for the last four fiscal quarters combined on a consolidated basis with its wholly owned subsidiaries, constitute a substantial percentage of its total expenses (inclusive of costs of revenue10) over the same period.
The Company’s and Legacy Joby’s R&D Expenses as a percentage of total expenses comprise the following for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024 on a consolidated basis:
Four Quarters Ended September 30, 2024
R&D Expenses $ 456,894
Total Expenses $ 576,232
Ratio 79 %
Each of the Company and Legacy Joby meet this requirement of Rule 3a-8, as each had R&D Expenses that exceeded 20% of its total expenses for the last four fiscal quarters combined.
8 See Cooley Godward Kronish LLP, SEC Staff No-Action Letter (July 12, 2007).
9 The Company’s research and development expenses consist primarily of personnel expenses, including salaries, benefits, and stock-based compensation, costs of consulting, equipment and materials, depreciation and amortization and allocations of overhead, including rent, information technology costs and utilities incurred in connection with the design, development and testing of the Company’s eVTOL air taxi. The Company’s R&D Expenses comply with Rule 3a-8(b)(9).
10 See Applied Materials, Inc., Investment Company Act Rel. No. 27064 (Sept. 13, 2005) (application for exemptive order).
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
Each of the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s net income derived from investments in securities did not exceed twice the amount of its R&D Expenses for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024.
To rely on Rule 3a-8, an issuer’s net income derived from investments in securities, for the last four fiscal quarters combined, must not exceed twice the amount of its R&D Expenses for the same period.
Each of the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s net income derived from investments in securities as a percentage of R&D Expenses consisted of the following for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024:
Net Income from Securities Investments
2x R&D Expenses $ 913,788
Each of the Company and Legacy Joby meets this requirement of Rule 3a-8, as its net income derived from investments in securities was less than twice the amount (or 200%) of R&D Expenses for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024.
Each of the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s Investment-Related Expenses were less than 5% of its total expenses for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024.
Reliance on Rule 3a-8 also requires that an issuer’s Investment-Related Expenses, for the last four fiscal quarters combined, do not exceed 5% of its total expenses for the same period. Investment-Related Expenses include the investment advisory fees paid by the issuer to its outside investment managers.
Each of the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s Investment-Related Expenses as a percentage of its total expenses consisted of the following for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024:
Investment-Related Expenses
Ratio less than 1%
Each of the Company and Legacy Joby meets this requirement of Rule 3a-8, as each had Investment-Related Expenses that were less than 5% of total expenses for the four quarters ended September 30, 2024.
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83
The Company’s and Legacy Joby’s investments in securities are capital preservations investments.
Under Rule 3a-8, an issuer’s investments in securities11 must be capital preservation investments, which, pursuant to Rule 3a-8, include investments made to conserve capital and liquidity until the funds are used for the company’s primary business; provided that “other investments,” which are investments in any securities that do not qualify as capital preservation investments, compose no more than 10% of an issuer’s total assets (or 25% of the issuer’s total assets if at least 75% of such other investments are investments made pursuant to a collaborative research and development arrangement). Although Rule 3a-8 does not enumerate specific investments as capital preservation investments, the Staff has indicated that capital preservation investments generally (1) are liquid in that such investments can be readily sold to support the company’s research and development activities, as necessary; (2) present limited credit risk; and (3) are not speculative.12
The Company’s and Legacy Joby’s investments in securities consist primarily of (1) corporate debt securities and commercial paper rated at least A-/A-3 by at least one Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organization (“NRSRO”); (2) U.S. government and agency securities; (3) money market funds that have at least $1 billion in assets and are rated AAA or equivalent; and (4) asset-backed securities that are rated AAA or equivalent.
Accordingly, the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s investment portfolio is highly liquid, does not present a significant credit risk, and is not speculative. The average maturity of the portfolio was approximately five months as of September 30, 2024. Under the Company’s Investment Policy Statement (the “Investment Policy”), described below, the weighted average maturity for all portfolios combined will be no greater than twenty-four months. The maximum maturity of any particular security in the portfolio shall not exceed sixty months.
Moreover, the Investment Policy requires securities with short-term credit ratings to be rated, at a minimum, A-2/P-2/F2 by at least two of three NRSROs, specifically Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s or Fitch. In addition, securities with a long-term credit rating must be rated, at a minimum, Aor A3 by at least one NRSRO. The Company and Legacy Joby selected these criteria for the capital preservation investments because such instruments have sufficient liquidity to be sold to support the Company’s and Legacy Joby’s research and development activities. Such instruments carry with them limited credit risk based on the required credit
11 Under Rule 3a-8, “investments in securities” means all securities other than securities issued by majority-owned subsidiaries and companies controlled primarily by the issuer that conduct similar types of businesses, through which the issuer is engaged primarily in a business other than that of investing, reinvesting, owning, holding, or trading in securities. Because all of the Legacy Joby Subsidiaries are wholly owned and no Legacy Joby Subsidiary holds investment securities, this discussion excludes Legacy Joby’s investments in the Legacy Joby Subsidiaries.
12 See SEC, Certain Research and Development Companies, Investment Company Act Release No. 26077, 68 Fed. Reg. 37046, 37048 (June 20, 2003).
[***] Certain confidential information contained in this document, marked by bracketed asterisks, has been omitted and filed separately with the SEC pursuant to 17 C.F.R. § 200.83 ratings. For these reasons the Company and Legacy Joby believe that the instruments they acquire in accordance with the Investment Policy qualify as capital preservation investments.
For the foregoing reasons, each of the Company and Legacy Joby believes that on a consolidated basis with its wholly owned subsidiaries its investments in securities consist entirely of securities that qualify as capital preservation investments and that it has no investments in “other investments” as of September 30, 2024. Accordingly, each of the Company and Legacy Joby believes that it complies with the requirements set out under of Rule 3a-8(4).
ii.Written Investment Policy
The Company’s Board has adopted a written investment policy for the Company’s capital preservation investments in compliance with Rule 3a-8. The Investment Policy states that the Company’s investment objectives are to:
1)Preserve principal;
First report after the company's reply of Dec 13, 2024: 10-K filed Feb 27, 2025 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 27, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please provide a detailed legal analysis regarding whether the Company (and its subsidiaries) meets the definition of an “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(A) of the Investment Company Act of 1940. In your response, please address, in detail, each of the factors outlined in Tonapah Mining Company of Nevada, 26 SEC 426 (1947) and provide legal and factual support for your analysis of each such factor.Rest of the question
In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
Maintain liquidity that is sufficient to meet operational and capital needs and support the Company’s research and development activities;Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Dec 13, 2024: 10-K filed Feb 27, 2025 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 27, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please update the Company’s risk disclosures to generally describe (i) the Company’s analysis of its/its subsidiaries’ status under Section 3(a)(1)(C), Section 3(c)(12), and under Rule 3a-8 and (ii) the risks to the Company should it/its subsidiaries not be eligible to rely on such exemptions.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that it will update the Company’s risk disclosures in its future filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, to the extent applicable, including in the Company’s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2024, to generally describe (i) the Company’s analysis of its/its subsidiaries’ status under Section 3(a)(1)(C), Section 3(c)(12), and under Rule 3a-8 and (ii) the risks to the Company should it/its subsidiaries not be eligible to rely on such exemptions.Read in the reply
Also in this review: closing letter, 2025-01-15