Staff Accounting Bulletin 99 (“SAB 99”) directs that a registrant assess both the quantitative and qualitative aspects of an error in assessing its materiality to the financial statements. The quantitative review focuses on the numerical “magnitude” of the error (e.g., its percentage impact on the relevant reported metric).
Rest of the answer
The qualitative review focuses on the facts and circumstances surrounding the reporting of the error.
Immediately after discovering that the Company had recorded certain compensation and benefits expenses twice, the Company performed a SAB 99 analysis and, pursuant to this analysis, management determined that the effect of the errors (and the correction of the errors) was not quantitatively material under either the rollover method or the iron curtain method (the Company analyzed the error under both approaches pursuant to Staff Accounting Bulletin 108). When evaluating the error under the rollover method, the Company found (i) the impact on operating income was 1.2% or less in every quarter from fiscal 2005 through fiscal 2008, and was less than 0.7% in each fiscal year from fiscal 2005 to fiscal 2008, (ii) the impact on stockholders’ equity in any one quarter from fiscal
2005 to fiscal 2008 was less than 0.05% (and less than 0.13% in any fiscal year) and (iii) the impact on earnings per share was less than approximately one half of one cent in any one quarter and less than one and one half cent per year in fiscal 2005 to 2008.
Management also concluded that the correction of the errors was not material to the Company’s consolidated financial statements under the iron curtain method. The correction of the error in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2009 using the iron curtain method reduced operating losses by approximately $3.7 million where the Company otherwise would have recorded an operating loss of
$33.9 million, a difference of 10.91%. While this is greater than a 5% difference, SAB 99 cautions that exclusive reliance on a 5% (or any other percentage or numerical) threshold has no basis in the accounting literature or the law. As such, this quantitative difference does not itself make the errors material and should, instead, be viewed in relation to the total mix of information available. When analyzed along with the rollover impacts described above and the qualitative factors discussed below, management does not believe that the adjustment to the fourth quarter of fiscal 2009 using the iron curtain was material to the consolidated financial statements.
The Staff noted that the correction of the errors resulted in approximately a 20% effect on net loss and a 100% effect on operating income in fiscal 2009. While the
Page: 6
Company determined that the correction of the errors was not material under the iron curtain method, the Company recognizes that the correction of the error using the iron curtain method in fiscal 2009 (as opposed to the fourth quarter) creates some differences in operating income that appear to be large on a percentage basis; however, this is solely because the Company had a break-even year in large part caused by the global economic downturn over the final six months of fiscal 2009. While operating income (or loss) in each quarter of fiscal 2009 was approximately equal to or in excess of $20 million (with the exception of the third quarter, in which there was an operating loss of $11.3 million), operating income in fiscal 2009 was approximately $54,000
(prior to giving effect to the correction of the errors), so even a very small numerical change would have created a large percentage change. In this regard management notes that if the application of the iron curtain method resulted in a change of $54,000 in operating income, the percentage impact on operating income would have been 100%, which the Company would similarly determine not to be material to the consolidated financial statements. To this end, the Company also points out that Todd Hardiman, SEC Associate Chief Accountant, Division of Corporation
Finance, noted in a 2007 speech that “a large error can be immaterial” and that “[w]ith this renewed focus, accountants started asking: if qualitative factors can cause small errors to be material, can qualitative factors cause large errors to be not material? With the benefit of hindsight, it’s pretty clear that the answer is yes.”2 Mr. Hardiman also stated in a 2006 speech that one example of where a large error could be immaterial is in a break-even year.3 Management determined and continues to believe that the situation contemplated by Mr. Hardiman is what occurred in fiscal 2009, and therefore its materiality analysis should not be affected by the fact that the Company had a break-even year in fiscal 2009. Because the denominator in fiscal 2009 operating income was so small (prior to giving effect to the correction of the errors), the percentage results were significantly skewed, making what in reality is an immaterial adjustment appear large on a percentage basis. By way of example, if the error were viewed in terms of the
Company’s past operating income numbers it would clearly not be quantitatively material. A $3.7 million adjustment to operating income in any of the Company’s past three fiscal years when the
Company’s operating income was $91.9 million, $82.3 million and $76.2 million, would only be a percentage difference of 4.0%, 4.5% and 4.9%, respectively on an iron curtain basis. Further, in the first half of fiscal 2009, the Company had operating income of $45.2 million. Had the
Company’s operations not been significantly impacted by the global economic downturn, and assuming the Company’s performance during the second half of the fiscal year continued as it had in the first half of the fiscal year (creating a fiscal 2009 operating income of $90.4 million, which is in line with previous years), the
Todd E. Hardiman (SEC Associate Chief Accountant, Division of
Corporation Finance), Remarks Before the 2007 AICPA National Conference on
Current SEC and PCAOB Developments (December 11, 2007).
See Todd E. Hardiman, Remarks before the 2006 AICPA National
Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments (Dec. 12, 2006) (noting that one example where a large error could be immaterial is in a break-even year).
Page: 7 percentage impact of the error on an iron curtain basis would have been only 4.1% in fiscal
2009. The Company does not believe the $3.7 million error became material based on an iron curtain analysis solely because (a) income from operations from the first half of fiscal 2009 were offset by operating losses in the second half of fiscal 2009 and (b) the Company corrected the errors in fiscal 2009, as opposed to any other recent fiscal year.
The same analysis applies with respect to the Company’s net income calculations when analyzed on an iron curtain basis, as the Company’s net income was similarly significantly impacted by the global economic downturn. For example, the $2.3 million adjustment, net of taxes, to net income in any of the past three years when the Company’s net income was $66.2 million, $55.5 million and
$59.4 million, respectively, would only be a percentage difference of 3.5%, 4.1% and 3.9%, respectively on an iron curtain basis. Clearly, the $2.3 million adjustment would not have been quantitatively material on an iron curtain basis if it were applied to any of these fiscal years.
Further, in the first half of fiscal 2009, the Company had net income of $29.5 million. Had the
Company’s net income not been significantly impacted by the global economic downturn, and assuming first half of the fiscal year (creating fiscal 2009 net income of $59.0 million, which is in line with previous years), the percentage impact of the error would have been only 3.9% on an iron curtain basis in fiscal 2009. Again, the Company does not believe the $2.3 million adjustment, net of taxes, became material on an iron curtain basis solely because (a) net income from the first half of fiscal 2009 was offset by net losses in the second half of fiscal 2009 and (b) the Company corrected the errors in fiscal 2009, as opposed to any other recent fiscal year.
The Company’s qualitative materiality assessment also supports the conclusion that the errors and the correction of the errors were not material. SAB 99 states that an error is material if,
“in the light of surrounding circumstances, the magnitude of the item is such that it is probable that the judgment of a reasonable person relying upon the report would have been changed or influenced by the inclusion or correction of the item.” Thus, registrants must evaluate whether qualitative factors cause errors of quantitatively small amounts to be material to the financial statements taken as a whole. The Advisory Committee on Improvements to Financial Reporting
(“ACIFR”) also states the converse: that qualitative factors can decrease the importance of an error to reasonable investors.4
See ACIFR Final Report, August 1, 2008, at 80-82 available at http://www.sec.gov/about/offices/oca/acifr/acifr-finalreport.pdf; see also John W. White (Director, SEC Division of Corporation Finance), Corporation
Finance in 2008 – A Focus on Financial Reporting, January 23, 2008 (noting that the ACIFR believes that “the evaluation of errors should be made on a ‘sliding scale,’ recognizing that qualitative factors can lead to a determination that a quantitatively significant error may not be material (just as qualitative factors can be used to lead to a conclusion that a quantitatively small error is material”).
Page: 8
Among the qualitative factors to be considered under SAB 99 is whether the error of the item masks a change in earnings or trends and whether errors hide a failure to meet analysts’ consensus expectations for the enterprise. In considering these factors, SAB 99 directs that “the factual context in which the user of financial statements would view the financial statement item” is an important consideration in assessing the total mix of information that a reasonable person can be expected to rely on. Here, the errors did not impact the trend in operating income or net income and did not impact the Company’s estimates or projections. The impact was relatively uniform across all periods and would not be considered material to any period by a reasonable user of the consolidated financial statements. As noted above, the impact on stockholders’ equity in any one quarter from fiscal 2005 to fiscal 2008 was less than 0.05% (and less than 0.013% in any fiscal year) and the impact on earnings per share was less than approximately one half of one cent in any one quarter and less than one and one half cents per year in fiscal 2005 through 2008. Metrics used by analysts and investors to evaluate the Company’s financial position were either not impacted at all, such as the Company’s revenue, or were not materially impacted, as is the case with operating income or net income. The impact of the errors was also on the largest line item of the Company’s income statement (compensation and benefit expense), so it did not materially impact any one line item in the income statement. Further, the Company’s liquidity was not significantly impacted by the correction (and was positively impacted). Liquidity increased by approximately $4 million, but when compared to cash, cash equivalents and marketable securities of
$326 million (prior to giving effect to the correction of the errors) at April 30, 2009, the impact was 1.2%.
The Company also does not believe that a correction that reduced the amount of operating loss by $3.7 million for amounts that accumulated over the past eight years was seen as material by analysts or other reasonable users of the consolidated financial statements who evaluate the results of the business. In support of this point, the Company notes that on June 26, 2009, the trading day before the Company publicly amended its fourth quarter fiscal 2009 results of operations, the Company’s stock price closed at $10.86 on the New York Stock Exchange. The Company publicly amended its fourth quarter fiscal 2009 results of operations on June 29, 2009 before the market opened, and on that date, the Company’s stock price closed at $10.64, a trading change from
June 26 that should not be viewed as indicative of the occurrence of a material event (especially one that had a positive effect on the Company’s liquidity). Even more telling is that the
Company’s trading volume on June 29 was only 282,300, well below the Company’s average daily trading volume in the month of June (of 402,586), and the seventh lightest trading day that month.
Another qualitative factor to be considered is whether the corrections will affect compliance with loan covenants or other contractual requirements. Although the Company did not have any borrowings outstanding, the errors did not have any negative impact on the Company’s debt covenants under its credit facilities.
Page: 9
SAB 99 makes clear that neither intentional errors nor illegal acts are necessarily material, yet states that intent may be probative of the importance that the registrant’s management assigns to the misstated item and, therefore, of the importance that investors may assign to the item by inference. Here, there was no evidence of any intent to manage earnings or to commit an illegal act in relation to the errors, the errors were unintentional and there was no evidence of fraud.
There was no misappropriation of cash or Company assets related to the errors. Finally, accounting for all other benefit arrangements (including two very similar to the arrangements adjusted for) were accounted for properly.
The Company believes that the disclosure it made regarding the errors clearly disclosed the nature and reason for the correction so users of the financial statements could easily determine or discern: (i) that the correction was not an ongoing part of operations; (ii) the actual earnings capacity of the Company; and (iii) that the past trend in earnings was not impacted by the error.
In light of each of the considerations set forth above, the Company determined that the correction of the error was not material to the consolidated financial statements.