Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0000860748 /10-K filed Feb 11, 2026, compared with Feb 7, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Financials · Property & Casualty Insurance

KEMPER Corp KMPR

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

4 reviews of KMPR's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 4 latest letter Dec 7, 2018
Questions asked 10 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 0 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 5 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 10 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 5 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 4 of 4 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 51 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2017

2018-12-07 to 2019-02-25 · 4 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2019-02-25
Non-GAAP measuresLegal and contingenciesAcquisitions
Non-GAAP Financial Measures · Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income, page 35
SEC asked (1)
You state that you exclude significant non-recurring or infrequent items that may not be indicative of ongoing operations from your non-GAAP measures and that significant nonrecurring items are excluded when the nature of the charge or gain is such that it is reasonably unlikely to recur within two years and there has been no similar charge or gain within the prior two years.
Rest of the question

You state that no such adjustments are made in the determination of adjusted consolidated net operating income for the nine and three months ended September 30, 2018 or 2017. We note that your adjusted consolidated net operating income includes a tax benefit of $26.0 million from the impact of tax law changes and the $28.2 million after-tax gain contingency recorded related to the partial satisfaction of your software arbitration. Please tell us how these two items were considered within the context of your disclosed non-GAAP policy on page 36 and why you believe they are indicative of your ongoing operations.

KMPR answered
Kemper Corporation (the “Company”) has received and reviewed your letter dated December 7, 2018, regarding the Commission's review of the above-mentioned filings. The Company’s response is submitted below. Form 10‐Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2018 Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income, page 35 You state that you exclude significant non-recurring or infrequent items that may not be indicative of ongoing operations from your non-GAAP measures and that significant non-recurring items are excluded when the nature of the charge or gain is such that it is reasonably unlikely to recur
Rest of the letter

within two years and there has been no similar charge or gain within the prior two years. You state that no such adjustments are made in the determination of adjusted consolidated net operating income for the nine and three months ended September 30, 2018 or 2017. We note that your adjusted consolidated net operating income includes a tax benefit of $26.0 million from the impact of tax law changes and the $28.2 million after-tax gain contingency recorded related to the partial satisfaction of your software arbitration. Please tell us how these two items were considered within the context of your disclosed non-GAAP policy on page 36 and why you believe they are indicative of your ongoing operations. As noted, the Company excludes non-recurring items when (a) the nature of the charge or gain is such that it is reasonably unlikely to recur within two years and (b) there has been no similar charge or gain within the prior two years. State and federal tax law changes routinely occur and affect the Company’s financial statements, with differing impacts, albeit not generally to the extent of the impact included in the Company’s Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended September 30, 2018. Accordingly, the Company includes the impact of tax law changes in adjusted consolidated net operating income. In addition, when evaluating the presentation of the $26.0 million tax benefit from the impact of tax law changes, the Company considered that it previously recorded a tax benefit of $10.5 million in 2017, including certain provisional amounts pursuant to Staff Accounting Bulletin 118, for the estimated income tax effects of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the “Tax Act”) in its Consolidated Statement of Income within the prior two years and indicated in its 2017 Form 10-K that final determination of the effects of the Tax Act on deferred income tax would require additional information. The $26.0 million tax benefit recorded during the third quarter of 2018 resulted from the finalization of certain effects of the Tax Act based on additional information received from third parties and the completion of additional actuarial computations which impacted tax elections made for the 2017 and earlier tax years. The tax benefit recognized includes the estimated benefit of elections to reset the interest rates used to discount and compute the tax-basis of reserves on certain post-1987 life insurance contracts reported in the Company's 2014 through 2017 income tax returns. With regard to the $28.2 million after-tax gain contingency recognized in the third quarter of 2018 related to the partial satisfaction of the Company’s software arbitration, the Company considered the following primary factors: a.the gain contingency is in partial satisfaction of a final judgment and additional recoveries are expected to result from the final resolution of this matter. Accordingly, the Company is unable to assert that the gain is reasonably unlikely to recur within two years; and b.the gain contingency recognized in the third quarter of 2018 relates to recovery of certain costs that the Company had previously written off or otherwise expensed and included in the Company’s adjusted consolidated net operating income. Given these factors, the Company included the $28.2 million after-tax gain contingency in adjusted consolidated net operating income. We note numerous instances throughout the furnished exhibits where your non-GAAP measures are more prominent than your most directly comparable GAAP measure. Examples of greater prominence of non-GAAP measures include, but are not limited to: The presentation of Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income before the most directly comparable GAAP measure in the tables on page 1 of your earnings release furnished as Exhibit 99.1; Reconciliations beginning with the non-GAAP measure and reconciling to the GAAP measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliations on page 7 and adjusted consolidated net operating income and related per share reconciliations on page 9 of the earnings release); Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income and related per share amounts are presented before the most directly comparable GAAP measures in the table on page 3 of the investor supplement furnished as Exhibit 99.2; Reconciliations beginning with the non-GAAP measure and reconciling to the GAAP measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliations on pages 14, 16 through 22, and 25 and adjusted consolidated net operating income and related per share reconciliations on page 34 of the investor supplement); The presentation of full non-GAAP statements of income beginning on page 26 of the investor supplement; Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income Per Share and Book Value Per Share Excluding Net Unrealized Gains on Fixed Maturities amounts are presented in bold type on page 9 of the earnings call presentation furnished as Exhibit 99.3; Reconciliations beginning with the non-GAAP measure and reconciling to the GAAP measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliations on page 22 and adjusted consolidated net operating income per share reconciliation on page 19 of the earnings call presentation); and The presentation of full non-GAAP statements of income beginning on page 24 of the earnings call presentation. Please represent to us that you will address these prominence issues in your future earnings releases, investor supplements and earnings call presentations furnished on Forms 8-K accordingly, consistent with the requirements in Instruction 2 to Item 2.02 of Form 8-K and Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K. See Question 102.10 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (CDIs) on Non-GAAP Financial Measures. The Company has reviewed the Staff’s comments and confirms that it will address the prominence issues in future earnings releases, investor supplements and earnings call presentations furnished on Forms 8-K, beginning with the fourth quarter of 2018. Specifically, comparable GAAP financial measures will be presented before non-GAAP financial measures and reconciliations for non-GAAP financial measures will be adjusted to begin with the GAAP financial measure. In addition, the presentation of non-GAAP financial measures will be modified to be in compliance with all requirements and the guidance set forth in the CDIs regarding the presentation of full non-GAAP statements of income. Your non-GAAP financial measures presented on an ‘as-adjusted’ basis in Exhibits 99.2 and 99.3 include the historical results of Infinity prior to the acquisition and exclude the impact of “purchase accounting adjustments.” Please address the following: Tell us why you believe that the combined results represents a non-GAAP measure that complies with Item 10(e) and does not represent the use of an individually tailor recognition and measurement method that may violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G. With respect to the three and nine months ended September 30, 2017 and the nine months ended September 30, 2018, tell us the nature of any adjustments made to historical results to arrive at the legacy results of Infinity and why they were made. With respect to the three month period ended September 30, 2018, provide us a schedule showing the nature and amount of each of the “purchase accounting adjustments” netting to $39.5 million. Explain to us why you adjust each item. See Answer to Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Financial Measures CDIs. The Company has considered the Staff’s comments and reviewed the CDIs on Non-GAAP Financial Measures, specifically the answer to Question 100.04. The “As Adjusted for Acquisition” results for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2017 are computed by adding the historical results of Infinity reported on a GAAP basis to the comparable historical consolidated GAAP results reported by Kemper. The Company does not believe presenting a combined total of the two companies' historical results constitutes an individually tailored recognition and measurement method. The purpose of the “As Adjusted for Acquisition” disclosure is to provide visibility and comparability into the Company’s operations and financial results preand post-Infinity acquisition. The Company believes the inclusion of this presentation benefits investors and other users of the financial statements in assessing and understanding the Company’s financial results and underlying trends on an “As Adjusted for Acquisition” basis for 2018 and in comparison, to prior periods. For example, on a reported GAAP basis, the Company’s earned premiums for the third quarter increased 76.0% year over year, due largely to the acquisition of Infinity. The Company does not believe this year over year increase is indicative of the underlying operations and trends of the combined business. However, on an “As Adjusted for Acquisition” basis, earned premiums for the third quarter increased 11.6% year over year, which is more indicative of the underlying operations and trends. No adjustments were made to historical results to arrive at the legacy results of Infinity included in the three and nine month ended September 30, 2017 and the nine months ended September 30, 2018. The table below outlines the “purchase accounting adjustments” for the three months ended September 30, 2018. The nature of such purchase accounting adjustments is comparable to the types of adjustments made in the Company’s pro forma financial statements. Amortization of Value of Business Acquired (“VOBA”) Amortization of Estimated Legacy Infinity Deferred Acquisition Costs (“DAC”) Amortization of VOBA, Net of Legacy Infinity DAC Amortization of Fair Value Adjustment to Infinity’s Unpaid Loss and Loss Adjustment Reserves Amortization of Finite Life Intangible Assets Acquired: Total Purchase Accounting Adjustments before Income Taxes Total Purchase Accounting Adjustments after Income Taxes The Company believes disclosing the amortization / depreciation of purchase accounting adjustments and the “As Adjusted for Acquisition” results for the period provides visibility and comparability into the Company’s operations and financial results for 2018 and in comparison, to prior periods. Please tell us why it is appropriate to adjust your non-GAAP underlying operating performance measure by each of the adjustments identified as sources of volatility identified on page 10 of Exhibit 99.3. In your response specifically tell us why it is appropriate to remove catastrophe losses from your measure when they are recurring and the premiums you collect specifically cover those losses. See Question 100.01 of the Non-GAAP Financial Measures CDIs. The Company has considered the Staff’s comments and reviewed the CDIs on Non-GAAP Financial Measures, specifically Question 100.01. The purpose of the sources of volatility disclosure is to provide the reader visibility into items which can be highly volatile, both in terms of timing and magnitude, within Income from Continuing Operations and our non-GAAP financial measure, Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income. The Company believes providing this level of disclosure allows market participants to make more informed decisions on underlying operations and trends. As it relates to catastrophes, the premiums earned by the Company, inclusive of premiums to cover catastrophe losses, are not a significant source of volatility as they are generally predictable in nature. Conversely, catastrophe losses are highly volatile, both with respect to the timing and geographic scope of a catastrophic event and severity of an event.

One letter for all the questions, without numbered answers. Read the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 21, 2018: 10-K filed Feb 20, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 13, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Exhibits
SEC asked (2)
We note numerous instances throughout the furnished exhibits where your non-GAAP measures are more prominent than your most directly comparable GAAP measure. Examples of greater prominence of non-GAAP measures include, but are not limited to: • The presentation of Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income before the most directly comparable GAAP measure in the tables on page 1 of your earnings release furnished as
Rest of the question

Exhibit 99.1; • Reconciliations beginning with the non-GAAP measure and reconciling to the GAAP measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliation on page 7 and adjusted consolidated net operating income and related per share reconciliations on page 9 of the earnings release); • Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income and related per share amounts are presented before the most directly comparable GAAP measures in the table on page 3 of the investor supplement furnished as Exhibit 99.2; measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliations on pages 14, 16 through 22, and 25 and adjusted consolidated net operating income and related per share reconciliations on page 34 of the investor supplement); • The presentation of full non-GAAP statements of income beginning on page 36 of the investor supplement; • Adjusted Consolidated Net Operating Income Per Share and Book Value Per Share Excluding Net Unrealized Gains on Fixed Maturities amounts are presented in bold type on page 9 of the earnings call presentation furnished as Exhibit 99.3; measure instead of vice versa (e.g., underlying combined ratio reconciliation on page 22 and adjusted consolidated net operating income per share reconciliation on page 19 of the earnings call presentation); and • The presentation of full non-GAAP statements of income beginning on page 24 of the earnings call presentation. Please represent to us that you will address these prominence issues in your future earnings releases, investor supplements and earnings call presentations furnished on Forms 8-K accordingly, consistent with the requirement in Instruction 2 to Item 2.02 of Form 8-K and Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K. See Question 102.10 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (CDIs) on Non-GAAP Financial Measures.

KMPR answered

See the reply above.

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 21, 2018: 10-K filed Feb 20, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 13, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Exhibits
SEC asked (3)
Your non-GAAP financial measures presented on an ‘as-adjusted’ basis in Exhibits 99.2 and 99.3 include the historical results of Infinity prior to the acquisition and exclude the impact of "purchase accounting adjustments." Please address the following: • Tell us why you believe that the combined results represents a non-GAAP measure that complies with Item 10(e) and does not represent the use of an individually
Rest of the question

tailored recognition and measurement method that may violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G. • With respect to the three and nine months ended September 30, 2017 and the nine months ended September 30, 2018, tell us the nature of any adjustments made to historical results to arrive at the legacy results of Infinity and why they were made. • With respect to the three month period ended September 30, 2018, provide us a schedule showing the nature and amount of each of the "purchase accounting adjustments" netting to $39.5 million. Explain to us why you adjust each item. See Answer to Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Financial Measures CDIs.

KMPR answered

See the reply above.

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 21, 2018: 10-K filed Feb 20, 2019 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 13, 2018 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Exhibits
SEC asked (4)
Please tell us why it is appropriate to adjust your non-GAAP underlying operating performance measure by each of the adjustments identified as sources of volatility identified on page 10 of Exhibit 99.3. In your response specifically tell us why it is appropriate to remove catastrophe losses from your measure when they are recurring and the premiums you collect specifically cover those losses.
Rest of the question

See Question 100.01 of the Non- GAAP Financial Measures CDIs.

KMPR answered

See the reply above.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2019-02-25

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2016

2017-11-06 to 2017-12-15 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2017-12-15
Critical estimatesControlsReserves and insurance
Property &Casualty Insurance · Overall, page 39
SEC asked
You attribute the $18.6 million in adverse loss and LAE reserve development for the first nine months of 2017 primarily to preferred personal automobile insurance. In the second paragraph on page 17 you attribute $18.1 million of adverse development in personal automobile insurance "primarily to the emergence of loss patterns that were worse than expected in both the physical damage and liability insurance lines for
Rest of the question

the 2016 accident year." We note that overall development during the third quarter of 2017 was not significant and that during your August 2, 2017 conference call discussing your second quarter results, your President of the Property & Casualty Division attributed most of the adverse development in the preferred automobile line to "new information" associated with "older claims that have been...around...for a while" and discussed how "new management might interpret the information differently than what prior management did." Please address the following: • Tell us the causes for adverse development in your preferred personal automobile insurance line for the first six months of 2017 and for the third quarter of 2017. • Tell us the changes you made in your claims processing procedures, when these changes were made and your consideration for disclosing these changes especially considering your critical accounting estimates disclosure in the second paragraph on page 58 of your 2016 Form 10-K indicating that changes in business processes are likely to affect development patterns and by extension loss reserve estimates. • Tell us whether the changes identified in the preceding bullet resulted in any changes in your internal controls over financial reporting that would warrant disclosure under Item 4(b) of Form 10-Q. If not, explain why not. • Tell us what "new information" was obtained during 2017 and how this information was interpreted differently by "new management" as compared to "prior management." Tell us why this information was not available in prior periods and why your adverse development is not the correction of an error especially considering that you characterized your past processes as being "horrible" during your August 2, 2017 earnings conference call. • Reconcile for us your statements that adverse development relates primarily to the 2016 accident year versus "older claims."

KMPR answered
Regarding the first bullet, for the first six months of 2017, adverse development in preferred personal automobile insurance was due primarily to the emergence of loss patterns that were worse than expected in both the physical damage and liability coverages with the most significant impact being to the 2016 accident year.
Rest of the answer

The actual case-incurred loss activity realized during the first six months of 2017 for preferred personal automobile insurance related to the 2016 accident year exceeded the Company’s expected case-incurred loss activity by $8.3 million using the historical incurred loss development factors selected at December 31, 2016. Such case-incurred loss activity in this product line was higher than expected primarily in the bodily injury and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverages. In the first six months of 2017, this deterioration became more evident as the Company obtained additional data including, but not limited to, newly reported claims with accident dates prior to 2017, slowing claim closure rates and higher than expected case-incurred development. The case-incurred development was driven, in part, by a higher than expected amount of large loss adjustments (those exceeding $100,000) in the first six months of 2017. In property damage and collision coverages, the Company experienced higher than expected incurred frequency development, particularly for the fourth accident quarter of 2016, as more claims subsequently closed with payment in 2017 than the Company previously estimated would close with payment. The Company also observed a slowdown in claim closure ratios. As discussed further below, a claims initiative to reduce the time from first notice of loss to initial estimate had unintended consequences and contributed to the development.

Collectively, the data and experience observed during the first six months of 2017 increased management’s ultimate personal automobile insurance loss and loss adjustment expense (“LAE”) estimates for prior accident years by $15.3 million, of which $10.8 million related to the preferred personal automobile insurance line’s 2016 accident year. For the third quarter of 2017, adverse development in preferred personal automobile insurance was $0.8 million, or 0.08% of property and casualty insurance reserves, which the Company believes to be clearly immaterial.

Regarding the second bullet, Kemper is continuously seeking to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of its operations, and the claims function has received particular attention. Since the appointment of Joe Lacher as President and Chief Executive Officer of Kemper in November 2015, there have been changes in leadership in the Property & Casualty organization, including the additions of George “Chip” D. Dufala, Jr. in July 2016 as President of the Property & Casualty Division and Kim Leggette in April 2017 as Chief Claims Officer. Throughout 2016, the Company implemented initiatives to reduce claims cycle times and improve service, all while lowering costs. Significant efforts were made in 2016 to improve staffing levels and reduce a claims backlog. In the second half of 2016, the Company targeted a reduction in time from first notice of loss to initial estimate, anticipating a favorable impact to overall loss costs on property damage and collision coverages. However, this initiative had unintended negative consequences as the frequency of supplemental payments and claim severity increased. The changes to the Company’s claims service model are operational in nature, relating to the adjudication of claims rather than the reserving process. The Company believes that the purpose of its disclosure beginning on page 58 of Kemper’s 2016 Form 10-K is to illustrate the significant level of professional judgment that all actuaries, including the Company’s actuaries, must exercise in making actuarial selections. Accordingly, the Company believes that disclosure of specific changes to its claims processes in its 2016 Form 10-K and 2017 Form 10-Q filings is unnecessary. In assessing the significance of the impact of changes, the Company provides a sensitivity analysis in the “Critical Accounting Estimates” of its 2016 Form 10-K filing to illustrate the significance that a potential change in development factors can have on the Company’s reserves. The example that is disclosed estimated that the Company’s personal automobile insurance loss and LAE reserves could have varied by $66.8 million using one standard deviation of variability in the cumulative development factors observed in the incurred loss development methodology. The adverse development of $18.1 million in personal automobile insurance for the nine months ended September 30, 2017 is well within the estimated variability. It is difficult to quantify and measure what portion of this development was due to changes in claim practices, particularly in relation to the estimated ultimate losses and LAE, reserve balances and reasonably likely scenarios of variability.

Regarding the third bullet, as noted above, the changes made within the Company’s claims process were operational in nature, focusing on increasing efficiency while lowering costs within the claims adjudication process. The Company has an internal control in place related to estimating loss and LAE reserves whereby its actuaries discuss such operational changes with appropriate management to help form their actuarial indication. Such discussion and evaluation is a normal part of the estimation process. From a financial reporting perspective, the operational changes in the claims process did not result in a change in the design and/or operation of identified key controls within the Company’s internal control over financial reporting. Accordingly, the Company believes that disclosure is not warranted under Item 4(b) of the Company’s Form 10-Q.

Regarding the fourth bullet, management has enhanced certain of the Company’s adjudication and review procedures. One of these enhancements has been more frequent review of certain case files. In preparation for these reviews, claims personnel obtain updates on the current status of such claims. For example, if outside counsel is utilized, Kemper personnel may reach out to the external attorney to discuss the status of the claim, evolution of the defense strategy, changes in the legal environment, opposing legal counsel, potential venues for litigation, etc. In addition, claims personnel will gather additional information about the likely claim value. For example, if a medical treatment is unsuccessful, costlier medical treatments and/or surgeries may become necessary and increase the expected claim value. This new information is coalesced with other available information in the file and discussed with the group. These discussions may result in a change in the adjudication strategy for the claim, which may result in changes to the amounts reserved for both losses and LAE. The changes in management, both in the claims function and the executive team that resides higher in the organizational structure, have impacted certain of the strategies used by the Company to settle complex claims with the intent of minimizing unnecessary loss costs and adjudication expenses.

Section 250-10-20 of Accounting Standards Codification Topic 250, “Accounting Changes and Errors Corrections,” defines a change in accounting estimate as:

“A change that has the effect of adjusting the carrying amount of an existing asset or liability or altering the subsequent accounting for existing or future assets or liabilities. A change in accounting estimate is a necessary consequence of the assessment, in conjunction with the periodic presentation of financial statements, of the present status and expected future benefits and obligations associated with assets and liabilities. Changes in accounting estimates result from new information. Examples of items for which estimates are necessary are uncollectible receivables, inventory obsolescence, service lives and salvage values of depreciable assets, and warranty obligations.”

The Company believes that any resulting changes to ultimate incurred losses and LAE from individual claim developments or evolving adjudication strategies are consistent with the definition of a change in accounting estimate. As a point of clarification, the Company notes that certain versions of the transcript for the Company’s earnings conference call on August 2, 2017 have misquoted Mr. Lacher as characterizing certain of the Company’s processes as being “horrible.” In actuality, Mr. Lacher said that “we think we've actually got it right and then what we're now going to see is not the effect of sort of the farbled [emphasis added] processes from the past but we’re going to start to see the effect of the stronger one’s going forward.” Mr. Lacher was referring to some of the unintended consequences of certain actions taken related to the Company’s claims initiatives (e.g., the cycle time item previously discussed) which resulted in missed opportunities to implement best practice operational processes that could have potentially lowered settlements costs, but instead led to some of the adverse development recognized. Mr. Lacher also indicated, with this understanding and given the actions taken by the Company, that management does not expect meaningful deterioration from the currently recorded amounts based on the information available as of the evaluation date.

Regarding the last bullet, the Company disclosed in Note 3 that, for the nine months ended September 30, 2017, personal automobile insurance loss and LAE reserves developed adversely by $18.1 million due primarily to the emergence of loss patterns that were worse than expected for both physical damage and liability coverages for the 2016 accident year. The 2016 accident year accounted for $16.6 million of the adverse development. The statement on adverse development made by Mr. Dufala in the Company’s August 2, 2017 earnings conference call was limited to the first two quarters of 2017 and related specifically to preferred personal automobile insurance, which represents 31% of the Company’s personal automobile insurance book of business. During the first quarter of 2017, the Company recognized adverse development of $9.9 million in personal automobile insurance with significant contributions from longer-tailed coverages such as bodily injury and uninsured/underinsured motorists as well as shorter-tailed coverages like property damage and collision. However, during the second quarter, personal automobile insurance adverse development was $5.5 million and was driven primarily by the longer-tailed bodily injury and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverages, which tend to be “older” on the claim aging spectrum.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Nov 20, 2017: 10-K filed Feb 13, 2018 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 13, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2017-12-15

Schedule 14A

2015-03-18 to 2015-03-24 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2015-03-24
Proposal 3, page 46
SEC asked
We note that your Board of Directors approved an amendment to your Bylaws to add an exclusive forum provision for intra-corporate disputes. Please highlight that such provisions may limit a shareholder’s ability to bring a claim in a judicial forum that it finds favorable for disputes with directors, officers or other employees, and may discourage lawsuits with respect to such claims.
KMPR answered
In response to your comment, the Company proposes to amend the paragraph on page 47 that immediately precedes the “Required Vote” section of Proposal 3 to read as follows, with the new language underlined below:

The Board is aware that certain proxy advisors, and some institutional investors, have policies that do not support exclusive forum provisions unless the company proposing such a provision can show that it already has suffered material harm as a result of multiple shareholder suits filed in different jurisdictions regarding the same matter.
Rest of the answer

However, the Board believes it is in the best interest of the Company and its shareholders to take preventive measures against the potential harm from such litigation tactics. An exclusive forum provision may limit a shareholder’s ability to bring a claim in a judicial forum that the shareholder favors and some shareholders may take the view that such a provision may discourage lawsuits with respect to such claims. However, as the Amendment addresses only where a suit may be filed and does not deprive a shareholder the right to assert claims or obtain any type of relief, the Board believes that the Amendment’s benefits outweigh any perceived harms. Based on existing case law enforcing exclusive forum provisions in a number of states, including our headquarters state of Illinois, the Board believes that it is unlikely that a court in a state other than Delaware would not be willing to enforce the Amendment, but there can be no assurances in that regard.

In connection with the Company’s response to your comments, the Company acknowledges that:

•

The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in its filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and

The Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2015-03-24

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2013

2014-12-03 to 2015-01-23 · 4 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2015-01-23
Reserves and insuranceResults discussion (MD&A)Liquidity and cashLegal and contingenciesSegments
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Investment Results, page 46
SEC asked (1)
You disclose on page 18 that the interest rate environment has a significant impact on your financial results and position and a protracted low interest rate environment would continue to place pressure on net investment income.
Rest of the question

Please provide us proposed disclosure to be included in future periodic reports that discloses the expected effects of this known trend or uncertainty on your future financial position, results of operations and cash flows. To the extent that information about cash flows you expect to have to reinvest at lower rates due to potential maturities or calls of your investments, or cash flows that you are committed to pay due to products with guaranteed features is necessary to understand these effects, please include information such as the amount of maturing and callable investments and their weighted average yields and the amount of products with guaranteed features and their rates in your proposed disclosure.

KMPR answered
While a protracted low interest rate environment could impact investment income in all of the Company’s operating segments, it is more likely to have the greatest impact in the Company’s Life & Health Insurance segment, and in particular on its life insurance products. The Company’s primary life insurance products are traditional whole-life and term life insurance. The Company’s interest-sensitive life insurance product has been in run-off for more than 15 years.
Rest of the answer

Interest-sensitive life insurance reserves were not material at December 31, 2013, representing only 2% of Life and Health Insurance Reserves reported in Kemper’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2013 (the “2013 Annual Report”). Accordingly, cash flows related to interest-sensitive life insurance products or other products with guaranteed features are not material. The investment portfolio supporting the Company’s Life & Health Insurance segment was comprised of $3,330 million, or 81%, of investments in fixed maturities, $116 million, or 3%, of investments in equity securities, $64 million, or 2%, of equity method limited liability investments and $564 million, or 14%, of other investments at December 31, 2013. A protracted low interest rate environment will have its greatest impact on the Life & Health Insurance segment’s net investment income from investments in fixed maturities. The weighted-average book yield on the Life & Health

Insurance segment’s investments in fixed maturities was approximately 5.7% at December 31, 2013, and the weighted-average book yield on investments in fixed maturities maturing over the next five years was 7.6%. The Life & Health Insurance segment’s reinvestment rate for investments in fixed maturities was approximately 5.4% in 2013 with an average duration of 6.2 years.

Beginning with Kemper’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2014, the Company proposes to include additional information regarding book yields of investments in the Life & Health Insurance segment maturing over the next five years and the segment’s reinvestment rate in its Management Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operation (“MD&A”). If the Company had made the disclosure in the 2013 Annual Report, the discussion of the Life & Health Insurance segment in the first full paragraph on page 44 would read as follows (proposed disclosure has been underlined).

Net Investment Income increased by $5.6 million for the year ended December 31, 2013, compared to 2012, due primarily to a higher level of investments in fixed maturities, higher investment income from Equity Method Limited Liability Investments and higher dividends on equity securities, partially offset by lower book yields on fixed maturities. Net investment income from Equity Method Limited Liability Investments was $8.4 million for the year ended December 31, 2013, compared to $1.8 million in 2012. The weighted-average book yield on the Life & Health Insurance segment’s investments in fixed maturities was approximately 5.7% at December 31, 2013, compared to 6.1% at December 31, 2012. A protracted low interest rate environment could adversely impact the Life & Health Insurance segment’s weighted-average book yield on investments in fixed maturities. For example, the weighted-average book yield on investments in fixed maturities will decline if new money is invested at yields below the portfolio rate. Also the weighted-average book yield on investments in fixed maturities will decline, to the extent that investments maturing over the next five years are not used for such purposes as paying claims and expenses, if the reinvested portion is at a yield that is lower than the book yield of the maturing investment. The Life & Health Insurance segment’s investments in fixed maturities that are maturing over the next five years totaled $561 million at December 31, 2013. The weighted-average book yield on such investments was 7.6% at December 31, 2013. The Life & Health Insurance segment’s reinvestment rate for investments in fixed maturities was approximately 5.4% in 2013 with an average duration of 6.2 years.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 17, 2014: 10-K filed Feb 12, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 14, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies and Accounting Changes · Insurance Reserves, page 74
SEC asked (2)
Please refer to ASC 944-40-25-1. Tell us the estimated amount of claim costs for insured events incurred but not reported to you included in your liability for unpaid claims and claim adjustment expenses at December 31, 2013 for your traditional life insurance products.
Rest of the question

In addition, tell us:  How you determined the amount of this liability including to what extent you used the database of reported deaths maintained by the Social Security Administration or a comparable database;  Where you classify this liability within your balance sheet;  Why you do not provide the disclosures required by ASC 944-40-50-3 for these products; and,  The basis for your statement in Note 23. Contingencies that “Kemper cannot reasonably estimate the amount of loss that it would recognize if the Life Companies were subjected to such requirements on a retroactive basis.”

KMPR answered
The Company’s liability for unpaid claims and claims adjustment expenses on traditional life insurance products was $37.6 million at December 31, 2013, of which $9.1 million was related to incurred but not reported (“IBNR”) claims. The Company’s liability for unpaid claims and claims adjustment expenses on traditional life insurance is disclosed in the MD&A in the table captioned “Insurance Reserves” on page 44 of the 2013 Annual Report.

With respect to the first bullet of the Staff’s comment, except as described below, the Company does not utilize a database of reported deaths maintained by
Rest of the answer

the Social Security Administration or a comparable database (a “Death Master File”) to determine its IBNR liability. Instead of using such a database, the Company calculates its IBNR liability by line of business using Company-specific historical information, which includes analyzing average paid claims and the average lag between incurred and reported claims.

Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries do not use a Death Master File to identify potentially deceased insureds unless, and then only to the extent, required by applicable law. Applicable laws requiring the use of a Death Master File are effective in the states of Kentucky and Maryland. In the case of Kentucky, Kemper’s life insurance companies are required to compare policies issued and delivered in Kentucky after January 1, 2013 with a Death Master File. In the case of Maryland, Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries were required to compare all in-force life insurance policies in the state with a Death Master File by April 1, 2014 and periodically thereafter. The Company’s liability for unpaid claims and claims adjustment expenses on traditional life insurance products includes a provision for unpaid claims and expenses that it expects to pay as a result of complying with the Maryland and Kentucky statutes.

With respect to the second bullet of the Staff’s comment, the Company classifies its liability for claims and claim adjustment expenses, including IBNR, for traditional life insurance products under the caption “Life and Health Insurance Reserves” in its consolidated balance sheets.

With respect to the third bullet of the Staff’s comment, disclosures described in ASC 944-40-50-3 were not included in the 2013 Annual Report because the liability was not material. As noted above, the liability for incurred losses and LAE reserves on life insurance products at December 31, 2013, as reported in the MD&A on page 44 of the 2013 Annual Report, was $37.6 million, which represented only 1.2% of the Company’s Life and Health Insurance Reserves.

With respect to the fourth bullet of the Staff’s comment, Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries do not use a Death Master File to identify potentially deceased insureds unless, and then only to the extent, required by applicable law. As noted in the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2014, the Company believes that, absent a statutory requirement to use a Death Master File, it is under no obligation to do so. As of December 31, 2013, only a few states had adopted statutes requiring life insurers to use a Death Master File to identify deceased insureds, and those states represent a very small percentage of Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries’ in-force life insurance business. Because Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries do not use a Death Master File with respect to the vast majority of their in-force life insurance, as of December 2013 and with respect to subsequent reporting periods, it has not been possible for the Company to estimate the impact of using a Death Master File on a retroactive basis.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 17, 2014: 10-K filed Feb 12, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 14, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Notes to the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements · Note 10 – Business Segments, page 22
SEC asked (3)
Please provide us an analysis explaining the reasons and nature of the realignment in the first quarter of 2014 resulting in the property and casualty businesses being reported as a single business segment. In your response, address what happened to the three previous reporting segments and what operating segments (ASC 280-10-50-1) comprise your current reporting segment (ASC 280-10-50-10).
Rest of the question

Address in your response the applicable paragraphs within ASC 280-10 including ASC 280-10-50-11.

KMPR answered
Prior to 2014, the Company reported its property and casualty insurance business using three separate reportable segments-Kemper Preferred, Kemper Specialty and Kemper Direct (collectively, the “Prior Operating Segments”). The Prior Operating Segments, as previously defined and operated, no longer exist.
Rest of the answer

In the first quarter of 2014, the Company realigned these operations largely along functional lines, with the exception of certain limited aspects of the Company’s California non-standard personal automobile insurance business and certain limited aspects of its direct-to-consumer business, which is in run-off. Under the new structure, many functions, processes, and systems that were performed or previously existed separately within each of the Prior Operating Segments were consolidated and standardized into a single function, process, or system supporting the entire property and casualty insurance organization.

Due to the significance of the change in internal structure/organization, the Company reevaluated its segment reporting in accordance with ASC 280, concluding that the realigned property and casualty insurance operation (the “Property & Casualty Insurance segment”) was an operating segment in accordance with guidance in ASC 280-10-50-1 through 50-9. Prior to realignment, each of the Company’s property and casualty insurance businesses had its own management structure and primarily functioned separately from each other. Central to the realignment effort has been the merging and/or sharing of certain primary functions across the entire property and casualty insurance operation, including finance, information technology, claims, legal, human resources, strategy, business transformation, and some portion of actuarial and analytics. In addition, with the exception of the Company’s California non-standard personal automobile insurance business, substantially all of marketing and agency management was consolidated. Prior to the consolidation, agents that represented the Company’s standard and preferred insurance products were managed separately from agents that represented the Company’s non-standard personal and commercial automobile insurance products. While some aspects of the Company’s California non-standard personal automobile business, including its agency force and product development, are managed on a separate basis, they are managed in this manner to comply with certain regulations in the state of California. Each of the functions identified above reports directly to the Property & Casualty Group Executive, who reports directly to Kemper’s Chief Executive Officer, who is the Company’s chief operating decision maker (“CODM”) as he is ultimately responsible for allocating resources and assessing performance of the segments. The CODM holds the Property & Casualty Group Executive directly accountable for management of the Property & Casualty Insurance segment as a whole.

Operating results for the Property & Casualty Insurance segment level are reviewed on a monthly basis by the Company’s CODM. As is typical in the insurance industry, certain disaggregated data is also analyzed (e.g., line of business); however, the primary evaluation by the CODM is at the Property & Casualty Insurance segment and Life & Health Insurance segment levels. The CODM also evaluates resource/capital allocation primarily at the Property & Casualty Insurance segment and Life & Health Insurance segment levels. The Company has processes to allocate expenses and derive estimated profitability by product (primarily for pricing and assessing product performance), which is typical in the insurance industry. The Company manages its property and casualty insurance business in a holistic manner as many of the products are linked and even interdependent. This philosophy is consistent with what is presented to the Company’s rating agencies. Over the past several years, the Company has been developing and refining Company-specific risk-based capital requirements and allocating capital at a product level; however, the first cut for both begins at the total Property & Casualty Insurance and total Life & Health Insurance levels. Furthermore, beginning in 2014, the executive incentive compensation plan was revised such that financial measures were based on the entire realigned Property & Casualty Insurance segment. Prior to realignment, an executive’s incentive compensation was based on the standalone financial results for his or her Prior Operating Segment. This provides further weight to the position that performance is assessed at the Property & Casualty Insurance segment level.

The Company considered whether operating segments exist at a more disaggregated level but concluded that these levels do not meet all operating segment criteria in either form or substance. Notably, consideration was given to Kemper Personal and Commercial lines (“KPCL”), Kemper Specialty California (“KSCA”), and Kemper Direct (“KD”). Effective with the realignment, the Company has segregated certain blocks of business within the Property & Casualty Insurance segment, due primarily to distribution and regulatory reasons. KSCA was segregated due primarily to California regulations and to provide additional focus on one of the Company’s key markets. Kemper Direct is in run-off, and a specialized team and focus are being used to successfully run off the business.

In accordance with ASC 280-10-50-10, the Company determined that its two operating segments were also its reportable segments. The Company also evaluated the aggregation criteria noted in ASC 280-10-50-11 and determined that aggregation was not appropriate.

In connection with the Company’s response to your comments, the Company acknowledges that:

The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in its filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and

The Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 17, 2014: 10-K filed Feb 12, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 14, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies and Accounting Changes · Insurance Reserves, page 74
SEC asked
Please refer to your response to our prior comment two.  Regarding the first bullet, provide us disclosure to be included herein in future periodic reports that indicates how you estimate IBNR and that your method does not use the Death Master File.
Rest of the question

Tell us your understanding as to industry practice for using the Death Master File to identify potentially deceased insureds and determining IBNR liability, and why you believe your method of estimating this liability results in a better estimate than one that uses the Death Master File.  Regarding the fourth bullet, provide us disclosure to be included in Note 23 in future periodic reports that further explains the basis for your inability to estimate the amount of loss or range that you would recognize if the “Life Companies” were subjected to “such requirements on a retroactive basis.” In this regard, it is not clear why you are not able to make a reasonable estimate as, although you are not legally required to use the Death Master File, you do not appear to be precluded from doing so.

KMPR answered
With respect to the first bullet of the Staff’s comment above, beginning with Kemper’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2014, the Company proposes to include additional information regarding the calculation of its IBNR liability in the “Insurance Reserves” section of Note 2., Summary of Accounting Policies and Accounting Changes.
Rest of the answer

If the Company had made the disclosure in its 2013 Annual Report, the second paragraph on page 74 would read as follows (proposed new disclosures have been underlined).

For traditional life insurance products, the reserves for future policy benefits are estimated on the net level premium method based on rates for expected mortality, lapse rates and interest rates, including provisions for adverse mortality. These assumptions vary by such characteristics as plan, age at issue and policy duration. Mortality assumptions are based on the Company’s historical experience and industry standards. Interest rate assumptions principally range from 3% to 7%. Lapse rate assumptions are based on actual and industry experience. Insurance Reserves also includes an estimate of the Company’s liability for unpaid life insurance claims and claims adjustment expenses, which includes an estimate for incurred but not reported (“IBNR”) life insurance claims. Except when required by applicable law, the Company does not utilize a database of reported deaths maintained by the Social Security Administration or a comparable database (a “Death Master File”) to determine its IBNR liability. Instead of using such a database, the Company calculates its IBNR liability for life insurance products using Company-specific historical information, which includes analyzing average paid claims and the average lag between date of death and the date that due proof of death is reported.

Kemper is not aware of any published guidance or industry practice regarding whether a Death Master File is used by the industry, and if used, how it is used in the determination of IBNR. Furthermore, there is lack of comprehensive disclosure from other companies on the topic. However, Kemper is aware that there is diversity in practice in how companies use a Death Master File in their claims operations. For example, a number of Companies utilize it solely with respect to their annuity business, others utilize it with respect to both their life and annuity businesses and others, such as Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries (the “Life Companies”), do not utilize a Death Master File in their claims operations, unless required to do so by applicable law. Moreover, for those companies that do use a Death Master File in their claims operations, it is unclear whether such companies also use it in the calculation of IBNR. Because there is diversity in practice in how companies utilize a Death Master File in their claims operations, Kemper believes that it is also likely that there is diversity in practice in how companies may or may not use a Death Master File in their determination of IBNR.

There are several reasons why Kemper believes that its method for computing IBNR produces a better estimate than one that could be obtained using a Death Master File.

Kemper believes that under applicable law and in accordance with the Life Companies’ life insurance contracts, the Life Companies’ obligation to pay benefits under their life insurance contracts arises when either (i) the policy is surrendered with value by the policyowner, (ii) due proof of death is provided by the beneficiary or (iii) the policy matures (an insured reaches a certain attained age under the policy) and a beneficiary has not provided due proof of death prior to such maturity. Kemper believes that it is appropriate to consider when the Life Companies’ expected payment obligations arise when calculating their liabilities under their life insurance contracts. Because these obligations arise under three separate scenarios, each should be viewed separate and apart when determining the appropriate accounting. Kemper believes that its liability for unpaid claims and claims adjustment expenses, including IBNR, should be based on the expected payments that will be made for individuals who have died and whose beneficiaries are expected to provide proof of death. Kemper’s method for computing IBNR described in the proposed disclosure above provides an appropriate estimate. It is important to note that this benefit is payable to a beneficiary only upon due proof of death. Surrender benefits and matured benefits do not meet the definition of a claim since neither includes a demand for payment due to an insured event. As such, it is more appropriate to consider them in the determination of future policyholder benefits. One key assumption used to determine future policyholder benefits is when those benefits will be paid. For in-force policies that may be surrendered at some future date or that are expected to mature at some future date without due proof of death being provided, Kemper believes those contractual obligations should be included in the determination of future policyholder benefits.

Kemper believes that a Death Master File is an imperfect source and using it would produce a significant number of false matches. Based on provisions in various state statutes enacted in recent years and the terms of published settlements between certain life insurance companies and state regulators and treasurers, matching criteria can range from exact matches of social security number, name and date of birth to partial matches, including “fuzzy” matches, of two criteria. Fuzzy matches use various derivations of the criteria. For example, a fuzzy match based on name might result in a false match when the name “Al” is considered a match for names such as “Allen,” “Alan, “Albert,” or “Alfonso.” A fuzzy match of birthdate might be based on month and year of birth instead of exact date of birth. Depending on the matching criteria used, an insured of the Life Companies may match multiple individuals in a Death Master File. Investigating false matches and multiple matches would require the Life Companies to incur significant costs in addition to those costs that they otherwise incur under the contractual terms of their life insurance policies. In addition, no single Death Master File is complete as all deaths are not required to be reported. For example, individuals that are not covered by Social Security such as certain governmental workers are not included in the Social Security Administration’s database. In some cases, due to privacy considerations, some governmental entities have also begun to restrict what they report to data aggregators.

With respect to the second bullet of the Staff’s comment above, we believe that some clarification is in order as to the nature of the contingency described in Note 23, Contingencies, of Kemper’s 2013 Form 10-K and as updated in Note 12, Contingencies, of Kemper’s September 30, 2014 Form 10-Q. The contingency does not principally involve the method of estimation of the Life Companies’ life insurance reserves and whether the use of a Death Master File would provide a better estimation methodology than the methodologies currently used. Given the laws currently in place and the terms of the Life Companies’ outstanding life insurance contracts (which have been approved by insurance regulators), Kemper believes that its estimates of future policyholder benefits and claims and claims adjustment expenses have been appropriately determined in accordance with GAAP. The contingency described in the aforementioned Notes relates to the ultimate outcome of potential changes in the interpretation of existing laws that could have the effect of altering the terms of the Life Companies’ existing life insurance contracts by imposing new requirements that did not exist and were not contemplated at the time the Life Companies entered into such contracts. As described in the aforementioned Notes and in Kemper’s Risk Factors disclosures, these circumstances encompass initiatives by various governmental entities that are aimed at effectuating such changes, and involve a combination of litigation, regulatory and legislative measures in multiple jurisdictions. Since life insurance is regulated at the state level, the outcome of these initiatives could theoretically result in 50 different changes to the applicable requirements. This is already evidenced in the fact that legislation enacted to date in some 15 states is not uniform and in some cases is the subject of constitutional and other legal challenges that are working their way through various courts.

Attempting to predict the ultimate outcomes of these efforts and to estimate the resulting effect would entail predicting state-by-state the ultimate outcomes of numerous uncertainties including, but not limited to:

How many states, if any, will eventually enact some type of legislation requiring the use of a Death Master File;

Whether any such required use of a Death Master File will by its terms be prospective or retroactive in application;

In the case of legislation intended to apply retroactively (i.e., to insurance policies issued prior to enactment), to what extent such legislation will ultimately survive challenge on constitutional and other legal grounds;

The extent to which any such legislation might contain provisions allowing the grant of compliance exemptions or variances by regulators and whether applicable regulators would so act;

The extent to which state insurance regulators, whether through new regulations, regulatory examinations or enforcement proceedings, will be successful in imposing new requirements relative to retroactive use of a Death Master File;

The extent to which state treasurers or controllers, whether through unclaimed property audits or litigation, will be successful in imposing new requirements relative to retroactive use of a Death Master File;

To the extent that any of the state insurance regulators, treasurers or controllers may be successful in imposing new legal requirements relative to retroactive use of a Death Master File, what those new requirements will consist of; for example, what the matching criteria would be for comparing the Life Companies’ policy records against a Death Master File (e.g., exact matches or fuzzy match scenarios) and what universe of policies would be covered (e.g., only policies currently in force or also policies that were once in force but have lapsed and, if the latter, how far back a search would have to be done).

In the case of escheatment of unclaimed life insurance benefits to the states, whether the so-called dormancy period which determines when funds must be remitted to the state would be deemed to run from the date of death or the date the Life Companies first learned of a death through a records comparison against a Death Master File.

The foregoing is just a representative sampling of the difficulties involved in any estimation exercise and leaves many other questions unaddressed, such as the additional administrative burdens and costs associated with various potential changes in the laws. Moreover, even if the Life Companies were to voluntarily perform some sort of comparison of their records against a Death Master File, most of the foregoing uncertainties would still be unknowns. Accordingly, the Life Companies continue to believe that the amount of loss that could result from the contingency cannot reasonably be estimated and, therefore, that any attempt to provide an estimate would likely be materially inaccurate and hence misleading to investors.

Beginning with Kemper’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2014, the Company proposes to include additional disclosures related to this matter in its contingencies footnote to assist investors in understanding the nature of the contingency being discussed and why no estimation of the effect of this complex set of circumstances comprising the contingency is currently possible. If the Company had made these additional disclosures in Note 12, Contingencies, to Kemper’s September 30, 2014 Form 10-Q, the full text of Note 12 would read as follows (proposed new disclosures have been underlined and deleted wording marked as stricken):

In the ordinary course of its businesses, the Company is involved in legal proceedings, including lawsuits, regulatory examinations and inquiries. Except with regard to the matters discussed below, based on currently available information, the Company does not believe that it is reasonably possible that any of its pending legal proceedings will have a material effect on the Company’s consolidated financial statements.

Over the last several years, certain state insurance regulators, legislators, treasurers/controllers, and their respective agents have been involved in an array of initiatives that seek, in various ways, to impose new duties on life insurance companies to proactively search for deaths of their insureds and contact the insureds’ beneficiaries even though such beneficiaries may not have submitted claims, including due proof of death, as required under the terms of state-approved life insurance policy forms. These initiatives together comprise a set of circumstances involving potential changes in the law or changes in the interpretation of existing laws that could have the effect of altering the terms of the Life Companies’ existing life insurance contracts by imposing new requirements that did not exist and were not contemplated at the time the Life Companies’ entered into such contracts.

Legislation. One type of initiative involves legislation. Legislation has been enacted in Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Montana, Nevada, New York, North Dakota, Rhode Island and Vermont, with varying effective dates (the “DMF Statutes”), that requires life insurance companies to compare on a regular basis their records for all in-force policies (including those policies issued prior to the effective dates of the legislation) against the database of reported deaths maintained by the Social Security Administration or a comparable database (a “Death Master File”). In contrast, New Mexico and Tennessee have enacted legislation that also requires such comparisons, but exempts life insurance companies, like Kemper’s life insurance subsidiaries (the “Life Companies”), that have not previously utilized a Death Master File, and instead only requires that such companies conduct Death Master File comparisons for life insurance policies issued and delivered in each of those states after the legislation’s effective date. Likewise, Alabama, Georgia and Mississippi have enacted statutes that require such comparisons, but only with respect to policies issued on or after their respective effective dates, without regard to prior Death Master File use. With respect to those DMF Statutes that apply retroactively and which would likely have an adverse effect on the Company’s operations and financial position, the Life Companies have filed declaratory judgment actions in applicable state courts challenging the application of such statutes to policies issued prior to the subject statute’s effective date:

In November 2012, certain of the Life Companies filed a declaratory judgment action in Kentucky state court, asking the court to construe the Kentucky DMF Statute to apply only prospectively, i.e., only with respect to those life insurance policies issued in Kentucky on or after the effective date of the

Kentucky DMF Statute, consistent with what the Life Companies believe are the requirements of applicable Kentucky statutory law, the Kentucky Constitution and the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution. In April 2013, the trial court denied the subject Life Companies’ motion for summary judgment and held that the requirements of the Kentucky DMF Statute apply to life insurance policies issued before the statute’s January 1, 2013 effective date. The subject Life Companies appealed the trial court’s decision and in August 2014, in a unanimous opinion, the Kentucky Court of Appeals reversed the trial court and held that the Kentucky DMF statute fell within Kentucky’s statutory presumption against retroactive legislation. Therefore, the Court ruled, the Kentucky DMF Statute can only apply to policies issued on and after January 1, 2013. In September 2014, the Kentucky Department of Insurance filed a motion asking for the Kentucky Supreme Court to undertake a discretionary review of the Court of Appeal’s ruling. A decision by the Kentucky Supreme Court on whether to review the Court of Appeals’ decision is expected by the third quarter of 2015.

In July 2013, certain of the Life Companies filed a declaratory judgment action in state court in Maryland, asking the court to construe the Maryland DMF Statute to apply only prospectively, i.e., only to policies issued in Maryland after the effective date of the Maryland DMF Statute, consistent with what the Life Companies believe are the requirements of the Maryland Constitution and the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution. The Maryland Insurance Administration filed a motion to dismiss the action, contending that the subject Life Companies were required to exhaust their administrative remedies before filing their action in the trial court. In March 2014, the trial court granted the Maryland Insurance Administration’s motion. The Life Companies have appealed the trial court’s ruling. The Maryland appellate courts have declined to stay enforcement of the Maryland DMF Statute pending the appeal, and the Life Companies are complying with the Maryland DMF Statute while they continue to pursue their appeal. Oral argument on the Life Companies’ appeal before the Maryland Court of Special Appeals has been scheduled for December 2014. A decision by the Maryland Court of Special Appeals is unlikely before the second quarter of 2015.

In August 2014, certain of the Life Companies filed a declaratory judgment action in Indiana state court, asking the court to construe the Indiana DMF Statute to apply only prospectively, i.e., only with respect to those life insurance policies issued in Indiana on or after the effective date of the Indiana DMF Statute, consistent with what the Life Companies believe are the requirements of applicable Indiana statutory law, the Indiana Constitution and the Contract Clause of the United States Constitution. The Indiana Department of Insurance filed an answer in response to the subject Life Companies’ complaint in October 2014.

Unclaimed property compliance audits/litigation. A second type of initiative involves The Life Companies are the subject of an unclaimed property compliance audit of the Life Companies (the “Treasurers’ Audit”) being conducted by a private audit firm retained by the treasurers/controllers of 38 states (the “Audit Firm”) and related litigation. In July 2013, the California State Controller (the “CA Controller”) filed a complaint for injunctive relief against the Life Companies in state court in California, seeking an order requiring the Life Companies to produce all of their in-force policy records to the Audit Firm to enable the firm to perform a comparison of such records against a Death Master File and to ascertain whether any of the insureds under such policies may be deceased. In December 2013, the CA Controller filed a motion for preliminary injunction seeking the same injunctive relief. A hearing on that motion was continued by the court until November 2014 or until the California Court of Appeals rules on a preliminary injunction order issued in a related case involving an unaffiliated life insurance company, entitled Chiang v. American National Insurance Company (the “ANICO Appeal”), whichever is later. In July 2014, the court granted a motion by the CA Controller to stay the litigation in its entirety, including all discovery, pending a decision in the ANICO Appeal. As described below, the Life Companies have filed a counterclaim in this case against the CA Controller. The current stay of the Controller’s case against the Life Companies means that no substantive ruling is likely to occur until sometime in 2015. Pending the outcome of this litigation, the Life Companies have not produced any of their in-force policy records to the CA Controller.

Examinations/enforcement actions by regulators. A third type of initiative involves examinations and other actions by state insurance regulators. The Life Companies are the subject of a multi-state market conduct examination by six state insurance regulators that is focused on the Life Companies’ claim settlement and policy administration practices, and specifically their compliance with state unclaimed property statutes (the “Multi-State Exam”). The Multi-State Exam was originated in June 2012 as a single-state examination by the Illinois Director of Insurance. Insurance regulators from five additional states - California, Florida, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire and North Dakota - joined the examination in May 2013. In August 2014, New Hampshire withdrew from participation in the Multi-State Exam. In July 2013, the Life Companies received requests from the Illinois Department of Insurance, as the managing lead state for the Multi-State Exam, for a significant volume of information beyond that which the Company had already produced, including their records of all in-force policies and other information of the type previously requested by the Audit Firm as part of the Treasurers’ Audit and which is the subject of the CA Controller’s complaint. This request prompted the Illinois litigation noted below. The Multi-State Exam was dormant for almost one year. Then in August 2014, the Illinois Department of Insurance appointed a law firm to act as an additional examiner in the Multi-State Exam. In October 2014, this new examiner sent a letter to the Life Companies seeking requests for interviews, site visits and additional information and documents. The Life Companies are currently in the process of evaluating these requests.

Pending related litigation. In September 2013, certain of the Life Companies filed declaratory judgment actions against the insurance regulators in the states of California, Florida, Illinois and Pennsylvania, asking the courts in those states to declare that applicable law does not require life insurers to search a Death Master File to ascertain whether insureds are deceased. The subject Life Companies are also asking the courts to declare that regulators in those states do not have the legal authority to (i) obtain life insurers’ policy records for the purpose of comparing those records against a Death Master File, and/or (ii) impose payment obligations on life insurers before a claim and due proof of death have been submitted by policy beneficiaries. The declaratory judgment action in California referenced above was filed as a cross-complaint to the CA Controller’s complaint, joining the California Insurance Commissioner and the Audit Firm as parties to the cross-complaint. The CA Controller has filed a motion to dismiss the Life Companies’ cross-complaint, contending that the Life Companies’ request for a declaratory judgment is premature and not ripe for adjudication. A hearing on that motion has been continued until November 2014 or until the Court of Appeals issues its decision in the ANICO Appeal, whichever is later. No date has been set for oral argument in the ANICO Appeal. In the meantime, the CA Controller filed a petition for coordination of the five unclaimed property lawsuits pending in CA to have them all heard by the same court. That petition has not yet been set for hearing. The Life Companies are currently evaluating their response to this petition.

In response to the Illinois declaratory judgment action, the Illinois Department of Insurance and its Director (collectively, the “IDOI”) filed a motion to dismiss, and in July 2014, the court in Illinois denied, in part, such motion. Specifically, the court denied the IDOI’s motion to dismiss the Life Companies’ claim seeking a declaration that the IDOI cannot compel the Life Companies to provide their policy records to the IDOI or persons acting on the IDOI’s behalf so as to permit a comparison against the DMF for purposes of identifying deceased insureds, as well as the Life Companies’ associated claim for injunctive relief. The court dismissed with prejudice the other counts in the complaint. In August 2014, the IDOI filed its answer to the counts of the complaint that the Illinois court allowed to stand, and in October 2014, the Life Companies filed a motion for summary judgment with respect to those remaining counts. Formal briefing and a hearing schedule on the summary judgment motion are expected to be set by the court at a November 2014 status conference. The actions against the insurance regulators in the states of Florida and Pennsylvania have been stayed by agreement of the parties pending the outcome of the Illinois action.

Conclusion. The results of the aforementioned legislative actions, Treasurers’ Audit, Multi-State Exam and the foregoing related litigation matters cannot currently be predicted. The Life Companies continue to maintain that states lack the legal authority to establish new requirements that have the effect of changing the terms of existing life insurance contracts with regard to basic claims handling obligations and processes. If these state officials are able to apply such new requirements retroactively to the Life

Companies’ existing life insurance policies, it will fundamentally alter the nature and timing of their responsibilities under such policies by effectively eliminating contractual terms that condition claim settlement and payment on the receipt of a claim, including “due proof of death” of an insured. The outcomes of the various state initiatives and related litigation could result in changes in the law that could have the effect of altering the terms of the Life Companies’ existing life insurance contracts by imposing new requirements that have a significant effect on, including acceleration of, the Life Companies’ payment and/or escheatment of policy benefits, and significantly increase their claims handling costs. Any attempt to predict the ultimate outcomes (including any estimate of the resulting effect on claim liabilities and reserves for future policy benefits) of these various efforts to change the law would entail predicting on a state-by-state-basis the ultimate outcome of numerous uncertainties including, but not limited to: how many states might eventually enact laws or interpret existing laws to require the use of a Death Master File or may exact such usage through regulation, examinations or audits; the matching criteria to be used in comparing records of the Life Companies against a Death Master File; the universe of policies affected, whether and to what extent any such laws would be applied retroactively; and the results of unclaimed property audits, examinations and other actions by state insurance regulators and litigation, including challenges to the constitutionality of laws purporting to have retroactive application. Due to the complexity and multi-jurisdictional nature of this issue, as well as the indeterminate number of potential outcomes and their uncertain effects on the Life Companies’ business, Kemper cannot reasonably estimate the amount of loss that it would recognize if the Life Companies were subjected to requirements of the types described in this Note on a retroactive basis.

In connection with the Company’s response to your comments, the Company acknowledges that:

The Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in its filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and

The Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 16, 2015: 10-K filed Feb 12, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 14, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2015-01-23

Letters without questions

Other letters

UPLOAD and CORRESP
1 other letter: notices that a filing will not be reviewed, requests to declare a registration effective, and the like

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 15 letters filed since 2014-12-03. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/KMPR/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.