Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001023128 /10-K filed Feb 25, 2026, compared with Feb 24, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Consumer discretionary · Auto Dealers

Lithia Motors Inc LAD

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

4 reviews of LAD's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 4 latest letter Jan 12, 2024
Questions asked 23 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 0 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 7 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 23 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 8 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 4 of 4 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 57 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Schedule 14A

2024-01-12 to 2024-02-01 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2024-02-01
Executive payNon-GAAP measures
Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A filed March 8, 2023 · Pay Versus Performance, page 56
SEC asked (1)
We note that you have included adjusted-EPS, a non-GAAP measure, as your Company- Selected Measure pursuant to Regulation S-K Item 402(v)(2)(vi). Please provide disclosure showing how this number is calculated from your audited financial statements, as required by Regulation S-K Item 402(v)(2)(v).
Rest of the question

If the disclosure appears in a different part of the definitive proxy statement, you may satisfy the disclosure requirement by a cross-reference thereto; however, incorporation by reference to a separate filing will not satisfy this disclosure requirement.

LAD answered
The Company confirms that to the extent its future pay versus performance disclosures in its definitive proxy statements include non-GAAP financial measures, it will provide a reconciliation of the measures to the closest GAAP measure in the proxy statement, consistent with the staff’s comment.
Read in the reply
Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A filed March 8, 2023 · Pay Versus Performance, page 56
SEC asked (2)
We note the disclosure provided under the heading "Description of Relationships Between Compensation Actually Paid and Specified Performance Measures." Please ensure that you provide a clear description of each separate relationship indicated in Regulation S-K Item 402(v)(5)(i)-(iv), including clear descriptions of the relationship between compensation actually paid and each of your TSR, net income, Company-Selected
Rest of the question

Measure, and any additional performance measures included in the pay versus performance table.

LAD answered
The Company confirms that it will provide pay versus performance disclosures in its 2024 proxy statement consistent with the staff’s comment.

We greatly appreciate your prompt response to this letter. If you have any further comments or questions regarding this letter, please contact the undersigned at (541) 618-5724.
Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-02-01

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2019

2020-09-17 to 2020-09-30 · 3 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2020-09-30
SegmentsNon-GAAP measures
Operations · Segments, page 28
SEC asked (1)
The presentation of the subtotal of Total Segment Income in any context other than the ASC 280 required reconciliation in the footnotes to the financial statements represents the presentation of a non-GAAP measure. Refer to Question 104.04 of the Non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. Please revise your reconciliation or identify Total Segment Income as a non-GAAP measure.
LAD answered
In future filings, the Company will either revise its reconciliation as requested or identify Total Segment Income as a non-GAAP measure and reconcile that disclosure to the most directly comparable GAAP measure.
Read in the reply
Note 1. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies · Stock-Based Compensation, page F-12
SEC asked (2)
Please explain to us what you mean when you disclose that the fair value of non-vested stock awards is based on the intrinsic value on the date of grant. We are aware of the definition of intrinsic value in ASC 718-10-20 that a non-vested share may be described as an option on that share with an exercise price of zero. Thus, the fair value of a share is the same as the intrinsic value of such an option on that share.
LAD answered
The Company currently utilizes restricted stock awards (“RSUs”) as our main form of stock awards, which have an exercise price of zero. Because the fair value of these RSUs at grant date when valued like an option with an exercise price of zero is the same as the intrinsic value, we had disclosed the fair value as equal to the intrinsic value.
Rest of the answer

The Company respectfully submits that in future filings the disclosure will be updated to the following:

“Compensation costs associated with equity instruments exchanged for employee and director services are measured at the grant date, based on the fair value of the award. If there is a performance-based element to the award, the expense is recognized based on the estimated attainment level, estimated time to achieve the attainment level and/or the vesting period. Estimates of fair value are not intended to predict actual future events or the value ultimately realized by persons who receive equity awards. The fair value of non-vested stock awards is based on the closing price of our common stock on the date of grant.”

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 28, 2020: 10-Q filed Oct 23, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 24, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 18. Segments, page F-33
SEC asked (3)
Please tell us your consideration of disclosing total expenditures for each reportable segment for additions to long-lived assets. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-25b. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
LAD answered
The Company observes that, per ASC 280-10-50-25b, a public entity is required to disclose total expenditures for additions to long-lived assets for each reportable segment if the specified amounts are included in the determination of segment assets reviewed by the chief operating decision maker or are otherwise regularly provided to the chief operating decision maker, even if not included in the determination of segment assets.

The most significant assets within segment assets for our individual stores, which we have identified as our reporting unit level, are inventories and accounts
Rest of the answer

receivable and do not include property and equipment, operating lease assets, goodwill, franchise value and other non-current assets. These long-term assets are generally reported as a component of Corporate and Other. Our chief operating decision maker (“CODM”), in the review of segment assets, does not regularly review or receive regular reporting on capital expenditures by individual stores. Based on the considerations above, we believe that the disclosure of expenditures for additions to long-lived assets for each reportable segment is not required.

To clarify this matter, we will update our future disclosure to the following:

“We define our chief operating decision maker ("CODM”) to be certain members of our executive management group. Historical and forecasted operational performance is evaluated on a store-by-store basis and on a consolidated basis by the CODM. We derive the operating results of the segments directly from our internal management reporting system. The accounting policies used to derive segment results are substantially the same as those used to determine our consolidated results, excepted for the internal allocation within Corporate and other discussed above. Our CODM does not regularly review capital expenditures on a reporting unit level. Performance measurement of each reportable segment by the CODM are based on several metrics, including earnings from operations. The CODM uses these results, in part, to evaluate the performance of and to allocate resources, mainly associated with expected inventory and working capital requirements, to each of the reportable segments.”

We greatly appreciate your prompt response to this letter. If you have any further comments or questions regarding this letter, please contact the undersigned at (541) 618-5724.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 28, 2020: 10-Q filed Oct 23, 2020 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 24, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2020-09-30

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2014

2015-09-01 to 2015-10-28 · 10 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2015-10-28
SegmentsGoodwill and impairmentRevenueResults discussion (MD&A)Reserves and insuranceLegal and contingenciesIncome taxes
Operations · Finance and Insurance, page 41
SEC asked (1)
Please tell us and revise future filings to disclose the types of vehicle sales the penetration rates presented on page 41 relate to. For example, if the rates apply to all vehicles, or only apply to new and used retail vehicle sales but not used vehicle wholesale, please advise and clarify in future filings.
LAD answered
The penetration rates presented on page 41 relate to only new and used retail vehicle sales and do not include used vehicle wholesale transactions, where finance and insurance products are not offered for sale. We will revise future filings to clarify the disclosure.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segments, page 43
SEC asked (2)
We note your inclusion of a separate section within MD&A related to your reportable segments starting on page 43, which contains revenue, segment income, retail new vehicle unit sales and a brief general discussion for each reportable segment that makes reference to your consolidated results of operations discussion to explain significant changes.
Rest of the question

Help us understand how your discussion of consolidated results of operations explains the results of each of your reportable segments. For example, from 2013 to 2014, revenue attributable to your Import segment increased by 54.4%, segment income increased by 23.6% and retail new vehicle unit sales increased by $37.6%. Similarly, from 2013 to 2014, revenue attributable to your Luxury segment increased by 47.2%, segment income increased by 52.2% and retail new vehicle unit sales increased by 50.2%. Please tell us in detail how the general discussion within the separate segments section of MD&A and the discussion of your consolidated results of operations best explains material changes in the results of operations of each of your reportable segments. Additionally, please tell us why you included the retail new vehicle unit sales metric for each reportable segment but then excluded units, revenue and gross profit information of other revenue streams recorded at each reportable segment. To the extent these changes are explained by the discussion within your consolidated results, duplication is unnecessary.

LAD answered
In light of our review of the Staff’s comments, we have reconsidered how the discussion explains material changes in each of our reportable segments. The following paragraphs have been re-written to provide a more detailed discussion as an example of the format within MD&A Lithia will adopt in future filings.

Domestic

Our domestic segment revenue increased 19.7% in 2014 compared to 2013 primarily as a result of the increase in retail new and used unit sales, increases in new and used vehicle selling prices, increases in finance and insurance as a function of greater retail vehicle unit
Rest of the answer

volume and improving service body and parts sales. These increases were driven by an improving economic environment, new product introductions from our manufacturer partners, enhanced availability of late model used vehicles and better operational execution within our stores. Chrysler, which represents 54% of our domestic segment revenue, increased its U.S. market share to 12.6% in 2014 from 11.5% in 2013. Segment retail new vehicle unit sales increased 15.2% as same store new unit sales increased 8.7% with the remaining increase a primarily function of six stores acquired in 2014.

Our domestic segment income increased 14.2% in 2014 compared to 2013, which was lower than both of the increases in revenue and retail new vehicle unit sales primarily as a result of a volume based retail vehicle strategy. Additionally, a shift in mix to new trucks and SUVs from cars and to more expensive, late model used vehicles increased average selling prices resulting in revenue growth outpacing increases in gross profit.

Our domestic segment revenue increased 17.2% in 2013 compared to 2012 primarily as a result of the increase in retail new and used unit sales, increases in finance and insurance as a function of greater retail vehicle unit volume and increased service body and parts sales as a result of recall activity. These increases were driven by an improving economic environment, increasing new vehicle SAAR rates and better operational execution within our stores. Domestic new vehicle unit sales increased 14.9% as same store new unit sales increased 11.8% with the remainder a function of full year operations of prior year acquisitions.

Our domestic segment income increased 21.8% in 2013 compared to 2012, which was higher than both of the increases in revenue and retail new vehicle unit sales as a result of improved gross profit on used vehicles as we shifted mix towards value autos, which tend to have a higher gross margin percentage as they carry a lower average selling price, and improvement in our domestic store cost structure as SG&A expense increased by approximately two thirds of the amount that revenue improved.

Import

Our import segment revenue increased 54.4% in 2014 compared to 2013 primarily as a result of the acquisition of the DCH auto group. Of the 27 stores acquired in the DCH auto group, 17 of the locations were import branded and over 90% of their revenues were import segment based.

Our import segment income increased 23.6% in 2014 compared to 2013 primarily as a result of the DCH acquisition discussed above. While revenues increased 54.4%, gross profit increased less in all business lines as DCH uses a high volume, low margin strategy and faces more competitive dynamics as their stores are in high density metropolitan locations. Additionally, DCH has less efficient SG&A expense control than Lithia which resulted in lower total import segment income, as a percentage of revenue, due the averaging of the cost structure.

Our import segment revenue increased 25.3% in 2013 compared to 2012 primarily as a result of increases in retail new vehicle sales and service, body and parts sales. The improving economic environment coupled with our focus on a volume based new vehicle strategy drove most of the increase in new vehicle revenue. Within service, body and parts, warranty work driven by manufacturer recalls accounted for the majority of the increase in revenue. Segment retail new vehicle unit sales increased 26.2% as same store new unit sales increased 17.5% with the remaining increase a function of six stores acquired in 2013.

Our import segment income increased 31.2% in 2013 compared to 2012 primarily as a result of higher revenue and unit sales augmented by additional efficiencies in SG&A expense which did not increase at the same rate as revenue or gross profit, partially offset by an increase in flooring cost as our stores carried more new vehicle inventory.

Luxury

Our luxury segment revenue increased 47.2% in 2014 compared to 2013 primarily as a result of the acquisition of the DCH auto group, which included nine luxury stores in metropolitan markets that are typically higher volume stores than the markets Lithia operates in. As a result, the addition of these luxury locations to our historically high domestic and import store footprint caused a large percentage increase.

Our luxury segment income increased 52.2% in 2014 compared to 2013 primarily as a result of the DCH acquisition discussed above. Additionally, on a same store basis, segment income increased as a result of lower SG&A and floorplan expenses which improved operational performance.

Our luxury revenue increased 26.3% in 2013 compared to 2012 primarily as a result of an increase in retail used vehicle and service, body and parts sales. Retail used vehicle sales improved due to an increased availability of late model, off lease vehicles which had been in scarce supply in prior years. Service, body and parts sales benefitted from increased warranty revenues as a result of significant recall activity. All business lines increased due to a strengthening macroeconomic environment, higher SAAR level and improved consumer confidence. Segment retail new vehicle unit sales increased 25.0% as same store new unit sales increased 15.0% with the remaining increase a function of two stores acquired in 2013.

Our luxury segment income increased 43.1% in 2013 compared to 2012 primarily as a result of increased revenue as discussed above augmented by improved efficiency in SG&A expense which did not increase at the same rate as revenue or gross profit, partially offset by an increase in flooring cost as our stores carried more new vehicle inventory.

As previously discussed, in future filings we will include a similar discussion to the above paragraphs.

We operate as an automotive retailer, selling new vehicles made by a number of Original Equipment Manufacturers (“OEMs”) such as GM, Chrysler and Ford who are supplied by a number of parts manufacturers such as American Axle, Dana, Lear, and Tenneco. As many of these OEMs and parts manufacturers are public companies, significant industry data is released both monthly and quarterly. Such data includes the number of absolute and annualized number of new cars sold, new vehicle production schedules, market share by make and model, incentive payments and recall data. Additionally, there are five other publicly traded automotive retailers. They also release monthly and / or quarterly new vehicle sales results by OEM and by reportable segment.

As a result, many users of our financial statements such as investors and creditors, ‘read-through’ new vehicle data released by OEMs, parts manufacturers and other public automotive retailers to gauge trends impacting the broader automotive retail environment or Lithia specifically.

In light of these considerations, we believe providing the retail new vehicle unit sale metric for each OEM allows investors to gauge our relative performance. We have historically provided the percentage breakdown of our retail new vehicle unit sales by OEM in our press release and financial filings and the aggregation of the retail new vehicle unit totals by segment is a convenience to the users of our financial statements as they could perform the calculation independently if so disposed.

Given the nature of our store operations, new vehicle sales are the only ‘homogenous’ component by location, as a store may choose to sell used vehicles that are not the same brand as the franchise they operate under, or may service vehicles that are outside the brand as the franchise they operate under.

Additionally, within retail used vehicle sales and service, the age of vehicles that are sold or serviced may differ based on store personnel focus and ability, as does the space available for the display or repair of vehicles given metropolitan versus rural market dynamics.

The inclusion of retail used vehicle unit sales, or any disclosure of revenue stream or gross profit by business line would include information that could be competitively disadvantageous for Lithia and provide a presentation that does not reflect the way our CODM reviews the business. Therefore, we elect to include only retail new vehicle unit sales in our segment disclosure.

Read in the reply
Segments, page 43
SEC asked (3)
We note on page 43 that revenues attributable to “Corporate and other” for 2013 and 2014 were $4,950 thousand and $4,452 thousand, respectively, whereas on page 44 segment income attributable to “Corporate and other for 2013 and 2014 was $24,918 thousand, and $39,657 thousand, respectively.
Rest of the question

Please explain to us the relationship between these amounts and changes between the periods, and how MD&A contains adequate explanation. Note that all components of your results of operations, including those that may not be allocated to the segments in determining the segmental profit or loss should be discussed. If these relationships and changes are explained elsewhere in MD&A please direct us where discussed and provide a cross reference in future filings.

LAD answered
Revenues attributable to “Corporate and other” are amounts associated with our sole stand-alone body shop offset by general ledger entries required under GAAP for reserve adjustments that are not be allocated to a reportable segment, for example, the reserve for vehicle sales that will ‘unwind’ or be reversed but have yet to occur.
Rest of the answer

The decrease in revenues from 2014 to 2013 of approximately $0.5 million was primarily associated with higher required reserve adjustments due to a greater number of store locations and higher gross revenues on a same store basis.

Segment income attributable to “Corporate and other” exceeds revenues attributable to “Corporate and other” as a result of corporate expense allocations, allocated to reportable segments, which are not recorded as revenue. Segment income attributable to “Corporate and other” are amounts associated with the operating income from the stand-alone body shop; certain internal corporate expense allocations that reduce reportable segment income but increase “Corporate and other” income; and Depreciation and amortization, Other interest expense, and Other income, net, which are not allocated to reportable segments. The change in segment income from 2014 to 2013 of approximately $14.8 million was primarily associated with increased internal corporate expense allocations as a result of a greater number of store locations and higher gross revenues on a same store basis.

In future filings, we will provide an expanded discussion similar to the above paragraphs.

Read in the reply
Selling, General and Administrative Expense (“SG&A”), page 46
SEC asked (4)
You disclose on page 47 that during the first quarter of 2014, you recorded non-core charges of $3.9 million related to an incremental increase to a reserve associated with a lawsuit filed in 2006 and settled in 2013.
Rest of the question

Please describe the facts and circumstances of this matter to us, the information available to you related to this matter at the time your financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2013 were issued, as well as your basis for recognizing costs in 2014 that, based on your disclosure, appear to have been probable and estimable during 2013. Refer to ASC 450-20-25-2. Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements (1) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies

LAD answered
The $3.9 million in non-core charges were related three separate items: the lawsuit mentioned above; a loss associated with a hailstorm; and a reserve for a contract assumed in an acquisition. The lawsuit contributed approximately $0.7 million of the charge in the quarter. As part of the settlement of the lawsuit, in 2013, customers with a potential claim were required to submit a response that Lithia validated for eligibility.
Rest of the answer

Due to the timing of the response period, we utilized an estimate of the number of eligible plaintiffs associated with the lawsuit, and recorded a charge of $2.4 million in the fourth quarter of 2013. In the first quarter of 2014, after the response period had ended and we validated all forms to determine eligibility, we determined our estimate of eligible claims was insufficient and increased the liability to account for the additional claimants. This change in estimate resulted in an additional charge of $0.7 million.

Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements

(1) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Goodwill, page F-10
SEC asked (5)
You disclose on page F-10 that you test goodwill for impairment at the “operating unit” level, which is not consistent with disclosure on page 32 that it is tested at the “reporting unit” level, which is consistent with ASC 350-20-35-1. Please advise and revise for consistency in future filings. (5) Goodwill and Franchise Value, page F-17
LAD answered
Due to a clerical error, we erroneously referred to the “operating unit” level on page F-10. The disclosure should have reflected the impairment testing at the “reporting unit” level. We will revise future filings to clarify the disclosure.

(5) Goodwill and Franchise Value, page F-17
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Goodwill, page F-10
SEC asked (6)
You currently disclose the accumulated goodwill impairment loss on a consolidated basis. Please revise to disclose the accumulated impairment loss for each reportable segment as required by ASC 350-20-50-1. (19) Segments, page F-36
LAD answered
We recorded a goodwill impairment loss in 2008, when we wrote off the entire balance of goodwill as our market capitalization was below the tangible book value of Lithia. At the time, we operated as one reporting unit, automotive retailing, and did not allocate or test goodwill at a lower level than the reporting unit. Therefore, disclosing the accumulated impairment loss at the current reportable segment level is not practicable per the requirements of ASC 280-10-50-34 as it was never allocated at that level at the time of acquisition or impairment.

(19) Segments, page F-36
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Goodwill, page F-10
SEC asked (7)
You disclose on page F-15 that management measures the performance of each operating segment based on several metrics, including earnings from operations, which are used, in part, to evaluate the performance of, and to allocate resources to, each of your operating segments.
Rest of the question

We also note your disclosure on page F-36 of “Segment income,” which we assume is the profit or loss measure you have disclosed for each reportable segment to comply with ASC 280-10-50-22. Please tell us which of the measures are used and reconcile your disclosure on page F-15 with the measure presented on page F-36. Additionally, if your reference to “management” on page F-15 is intended to be the CODM, please revise future filings to clarify or define “management.”

LAD answered
The CODM reviews store level revenues, gross profit, and earnings from operations. The most important metric is earnings from operations which include internal corporate expense allocations and exclude Depreciation and amortization, Other interest expense and Other income, net. The total of all store level earnings from operations is equivalent to “Segment income” as redefined in our response in question 8 below.

Our reference to “management” on page F-15 is intended to be the CODM. We will revise future filings to clarify this reference.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Goodwill, page F-10
SEC asked (8)
We note your disclosure of “Segment income” as a measure of profit or loss for each of your reportable segments, as well as your inclusion of an asterisk to denote that it is defined as operating income less floor plan interest expense.
Rest of the question

We also note your reconciliation on page F-36, wherein the sum of your three reportable segments and “Corporate and other” is equal to “Income from continuing operations before income taxes” on your income statement on page F-4. As the “Income from continuing operations before income taxes” line item includes “Floor plan interest expense,” as well as “Other interest expense” and “Other income, net,” please tell us, and clearly disclose in future filings, where these amounts are presented in the reconciliation. For example, if included within “Corporate and other,” please clearly disclose this in future filings. This comment also applies to the use of this measure within MD&A.

LAD answered
“Corporate and other” includes Depreciation and amortization, Other interest expense and Other income, net. However, in future filings we will remove these amounts from “Corporate and other” and present them as separate lines below “Corporate and other” within both the footnotes and MD&A.

We will redefine “Segment income” as Income from continuing operations before income taxes less Depreciation and amortization, Other interest expense, and Other income, net.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Goodwill, page F-10
SEC asked (9)
Please revise future filings to include all of the items specified in ASC 280-10-50-22 that are included in “Segment income,” which is the measure of profit or loss disclosed for each of your reportable segments. For example, depreciation and amortization expense appears to be included in this measure.
LAD answered
Depreciation and amortization is included in “Corporate and other”, along with Other interest expense and Other income, net. In future filings, we will remove these amounts from “Corporate and other” and present them as separate lines below “Corporate and other” within both the footnotes and MD&A.

* * * * *

Lithia believes the responses provided above address the staff's comments, and further acknowledges that:

○

Lithia is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the Filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the
Rest of the answer

Commission from taking any action with respect to the Filing; and

Lithia may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 15, 2015: 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Jul 31, 2015 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Operations · Segments, page 43
SEC asked
We note your response to comment 3 and have the following comments:  Please tell us more about what you refer to as the reserve for vehicle sales that will “unwind” or be reversed but have yet to occur, including the amount of the reserve at each balance sheet date.
Rest of the question

Assuming this represents a reserve against vehicle sales, please tell us why the reserve is recorded within corporate and other as opposed to being recorded against the related vehicle sales recorded in your respective reportable segments. Additionally, as the aforementioned reserve was an example of the reserve activity recorded in corporate and other, please tell us what other material reserves are recorded within corporate and other, if any.  Please tell us more about the corporate expense allocations that are allocated to the reportable segments, and specifically how allocating costs from corporate and other results in income that appears to be in excess of costs incurred based on the income that is significantly in excess of revenues reported at corporate and other. In your response, please provide us with a categorical summary including amounts of the income statement activity included in corporate and other for each period presented.

LAD answered
Lithia Motors, Inc. (“Lithia”) submits this letter in response to comments from the staff (the “Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission received by letter dated October 6, 2015, relating to the above referenced filing.

In this letter, we have recited the Staff’s comments in italicized, bold type, and have followed each comment with Lithia’s response.

Item 7.
Rest of the answer

Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations

Segments, page 43

1 We note your response to comment 3 and have the following comments:

●

Please tell us more about what you refer to as the reserve for vehicle sales that will “unwind” or be reversed but have yet to occur, including the amount of the reserve at each balance sheet date. Assuming this represents a reserve against vehicle sales, please tell us why the reserve is recorded within corporate and other as opposed to being recorded against the related vehicle sales recorded in your respective reportable segments. Additionally, as the aforementioned reserve was an example of the reserve activity recorded in corporate and other, please tell us what other material reserves are recorded within corporate and other, if any.

Based on historical experience, a small number of new and used vehicle sales transactions “unwind” in the subsequent reporting period due to the inability to meet certain loan stipulations or other technical issues. The vast majority of these transactions are consummated in the subsequent period under new terms acceptable to both the lender and customer, but nonetheless did not meet the criteria for revenue recognition in the period originally recorded. We record amounts associated with this revenue reversal on our balance sheet impacting several accounts including inventory, accounts receivable and floor plan notes payable. The reserve increases both assets and liabilities on the balance sheet; the net of these amounts affect the cumulative gross profit on the vehicle sales which are immaterial. At December 31, 2014 and 2013, the total net reserve was $177,345 and $172,725, respectively. There are incremental increases in the reserve, reducing revenue and impacting these balance sheet accounts, as our total revenues increase, as average sales prices change and as we acquire more dealership locations. The annual reduction to revenues due to the change in the reserve totaled $1.1 million, $0.2 million and $0.9 million, respectively, or less than one tenth of a percentage point of revenue for each full year period. On a cumulative unit count basis, as of December 31, 2014, we estimated 201 units failed to meet the criteria for revenue recognition in that year. For the year ended December 31, 2014, the increase in unit count expected to unwind was 35 units. The total units reserved compare to 190,696 units sold in 2014, or approximately one tenth of a percentage point of unit sales.

We estimate the number and value of unwind transactions based on historical experience. However, the precise store or manufacturer brand of the unwound vehicle sales is variable and therefore the reserve is recorded at the corporate level. Additionally, the CODM evaluates store performance excluding the impact of any ‘unwind’ transactions. That is, the re-signing of paperwork related to an unwind is not reported in performance metrics, either as a reduction of revenue or as an adjustment to the individual store level balance sheet accounts, such as inventory, used by our CODM for purposes of making decisions about allocating resources to the segments or assessing their performance. Therefore, we believe our disclosures are consistent with the requirements of ASC 280-10-50-27 to report measures of segment performance that are consistent with those reported to the CODM. Historically, we have not disclosed the asymmetry between the results of our reportable segments and corporate and other because the effect of the unwind transactions has been immaterial. If the unwind reserve become material in a future period, we will evaluate the need for additional disclosure.

We have one other material elimination in Corporate and other, which is associated with certain intercompany vehicle sales and gross profit related to new vehicles sold by our stores for use as demonstrator vehicles by general managers, executive management or charitable organizations. This elimination reduced revenue within Corporate and other by $5.9 million, $3.8 million, and $2.6 million for fiscal 2014, 2013 and 2012, respectively, or approximately one tenth of a percentage point of revenue for each full year period.

Our store-level personnel, as well as the vehicle manufacturer, consider these transactions to be retail sales. Therefore, the reportable segments report these transactions as revenue; however, they are eliminated within Corporate and other to accurately present our consolidated financial statements. The elimination does not affect performance metrics used by our CODM to evaluate segment results.

Please tell us more about the corporate expense allocations that are allocated to the reportable segments, and specifically how allocating costs from corporate and other results in income that appears to be in excess of costs incurred based on the income that is significantly in excess of revenues reported at corporate and other. In your response, please provide us with a categorical summary including amounts of the income statement activity included in corporate and other for each period presented.

Our CODM evaluates store performance on an individual store basis. Because we have 130 locations that have been acquired at various points in time and under various circumstances, we standardize certain expenses across our stores to improve comparability between stores. For example, we use standard commission based pay plan templates for store personnel. To facilitate the potential to move them between stores without altering their individual pay plans, ensuring all stores have a common expense structure based on current market conditions requires internal adjustments between the reportable segments and Corporate and other.

The following table is a three year summary of our segment income reflecting the changes in presentation we discussed in our previous letter dated September 15, 2015 (in thousands):

For the year ended December 31,

2014

2013

2012

Segment Income

Domestic

$

96,863

84,500

69,236

Import

50,418

40,264

30,701

Luxury

25,386

16,133

11,189

172,667

140,897

111,126

Corporate and other

71,734

50,283

41,555

Depreciation and amortization

(26,363

)

(20,035

(17,128

Other interest expense

(10,742

(8,350

(9,621

Other (expense) income, net

3,199

2,993

2,525

Income from continuing operations before income taxes

210,495

165,788

128,457

We note that the $71,734 presented for Corporate and other for 2014, for example, is different than the $39,657 in our 2014 Form 10-K. The change is due to presenting Depreciation and amortization, Other interest expense and Other (expense) income, net as reconciling items in the new presentation. The sum of these four items is within $2 million of the previously disclosed number. The remaining difference is due to the reclassification of certain depreciation expense originally included in the Domestic, Import and Luxury segments to the Depreciation and amortization line item.

The following table provides a detailed breakout of the material components of segment income within corporate and other (in thousands):

Corporate and Other

Revenues - Corporate and other

4,451

4,950

9,312

Corporate personnel costs

(35,532

(31,540

(31,844

Other corporate costs

(16,597

(16,249

(10,280

Income from internal rent, net

59,665

49,682

41,728

Income from internal management fees

25,057

19,992

24,458

Income from internal insurance and advertising fees, net

11,548

8,445

4,921

Income from internal floorplan interest cost, net

18,528

13,256

5,521

Other

4,614

1,747

(2,261

Segment income – Corporate and other

In the previous table, Corporate personnel costs represent wages and variable compensation paid to personnel within our corporate department. Other corporate costs include items such as legal expense, corporate overhead, and other general and administrative expenses.

Income from internal rent, net is the net sum of the internal rent charge we assign each store offset by the rent or property tax expense incurred. We assign all stores an internal rent charge based on current market values of locations to normalize locations that may be leased, owned or a combination of the two. Therefore, whether the particular location is owned or leased and regardless of any change in fair value compared to cost basis, the store sees a market rent expense each month.

Income from internal management fees is the charge we assign to each store location for the support functions performed by corporate employees whose wages are recorded in Corporate personnel costs.

Income from internal insurance and advertising fees, net is the difference between the insurance and advertising expenses we charge each store offset by the actual costs recorded with third party vendors. We maintain an in-house advertising agency that charges our stores an amount similar to what they would pay an outside vendor. We also maintain insurance deductible levels far in excess of levels a stand-alone store would maintain and, therefore, charge a higher internal insurance premium to offset the cost of risk that our corporate division is maintaining.

Income from internal floorplan interest cost, net is the difference between the charges assessed to each store based on our internal cost of financing new vehicle inventory, offset by our actual cost which is lower than an individual store could receive given our broad geographic and brand diversity, along with our parent company’s ability to access the capital markets.

In summary, while our Corporate and other segment does not produce material revenue compared with other segments, we believe our corporate infrastructure provides significant benefits to our stores and affords Lithia a more efficient mechanism for selling and servicing automobiles. We also manage our store operations on an individual basis so providing reporting for our CODM to improve comparability between stores is critical. Therefore, we charge our stores a competitive market rate for certain expenses and services and record the corresponding income and actual costs in Corporate and other, consistent with how we report to the CODM and evaluate the business internally. In future filings, we will expand the disclosure of Corporate and other to provide additional transparency regarding these cost allocation objectives.

* * * * *

Lithia believes the responses provided above address the staff's comments, and further acknowledges that:

○

Lithia is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the Filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the Filing; and

Lithia may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2015-10-28

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2013

2014-09-26 to 2015-03-19 · 8 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 4 from the company
Review closed 2015-03-19
SegmentsResults discussion (MD&A)Risk factorsControls
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of · Operations, page 31
SEC asked (1)
We have read your risk factor disclosure on page 13 addressing sub-prime lenders and the potential risk of a decrease in the availability of credit in the lending market. Tell us and disclose how you define sub-prime auto loans.
Rest of the question

Further, since it appears you would be affected by deterioration in the sub-prime auto loan industry, tell us what consideration you gave to disclosing the percentage of vehicle sales that are financed by sub-prime lenders in your MD&A discussion.

LAD answered
We define sub-prime auto loans as loans with a Fair, Isaac and Company (FICO) score of 620 or lower. Sub-prime auto loans make up approximately 10-12% of our total auto loan originations. This percentage has been relatively consistent over the past several quarters and is regularly communicated during our prepared remarks on our quarterly earnings conference call and within our investor presentation posted at www.lithiainvestorrelations.com.

In future filings, we will disclose in our MD&A both our definition of sub-prime auto loans and the percentage of sub-prime vehicle financing that we
Rest of the answer

arrange.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 10, 2014: 10-Q filed Oct 31, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules, page 58 · Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm, page F-1
SEC asked (2)
We note the audit opinion on the financial statements refers to Lithia Motors, Inc. and subsidiaries while the audit opinion on internal control over financial reporting refers to Lithia Motors, Inc. Please confirm our assumption that both audit reports relate to Lithia Motors, Inc. on a consolidated basis, or explain to us any difference in the entities covered by these reports.
Rest of the question

Additionally, please consider requesting that your auditor conform the wording in future filings to avoid any confusion on the part of investors. Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-8 (1) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F-8

LAD answered
We confirm that both audit reports relate to Lithia Motors, Inc. on a consolidated basis and have requested that our auditor conform the wording in future filings.

Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements, page F-8

(1) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F-8
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 10, 2014: 10-Q filed Oct 31, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked (3)
We note your disclosure that historical and forecasted operational performance is evaluated on a store-by-store basis. Please provide us with a specific and comprehensive discussion of what consideration you gave to each factor in ASC 280-10-50-1 in evaluating whether your individual stores are operating segments.
Rest of the question

Please also provide us with your organizational structure, including the identities of the executive management group that comprise your CODM and the roles of the individuals who report to them. Finally, please further explain your statement that no individual store is significant enough to meet the definition of a segment. In this regard, tell us how you have considered ASC 280-10-50-14.

LAD answered
ASC 280-10-50-1 states that an entity must meet the following three criteria to be defined as an operating segment:

A.

It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expense (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

B.

Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

C.

Its discrete financial information is available.

Criterion A: Overview of the
Rest of the answer

Company’s Business

We operate automotive franchises, retail new and used vehicles in conjunction with arranging financing and selling service contracts, vehicle protection products and credit insurance and provide vehicle maintenance, warranty, paint and repair services. As of December 31, 2013, we had 94 operating franchised locations and one stand-alone body shop facility.

The revenue generating elements of our business—new vehicle sales, used vehicle retail sales, used vehicle wholesales, finance and insurance product commissions, service sales, parts sales and body shop sales—are complementary to each other. Though it is possible to operate each one of these revenue generating elements independently, our stores manage the business holistically to maximize the synergies and benefits of operating an automotive franchise.

Certain expenses related to these revenue generating activities can similarly be evaluated independently; however, there is significant inter-dependence and expenses are best analyzed in total. For example, the service, body and parts departments do internal work to prepare vehicles for retail sale. To manage service, parts and body shop department capacity, internal work is tracked separately with its own revenue and cost. As a result, for our internal reporting of store financial performance, the service, parts and body shop departments show profit, while the vehicle sales departments show additional cost. These items are eliminated for consolidated financial reporting. This expense metric is useful to evaluate individual department performance; however, the impact it has on the overall business is only the cost of the labor and parts for the reconditioning of the vehicle.

Additionally, the store shares several expenses among all of the revenue generating activities: facilities, support staff, information systems, etc. are all shared among the departments. For internal reports, these cost are allocated departmentally based on allocations set annually for measurement purposes, but the overall cost structure is only evaluated on a combined level.

Based on the considerations above, we believe each individual store engages in business activities which earns revenues and incurs expenses and meets the definition of criterion A.

Criterion B: Decision Making by the CODM

Criterion B considers the Company’s management style of its business and the basis at which decision making occurs. To evaluate this criterion, we identified our chief operating decision maker (CODM) and considered whether there is evidence the business is managed based on operating segments. Consideration was given to the organization structure/decision making process used to manage the business and operating/financial information available to the CODM.

Organization Structure and Overview of the CODM

ASC 280-10-50-5 defines the CODM as “a function, not necessarily a manager with a specific title. That function is to allocate resources to and assess the performance of segments of a public entity.” We have defined our CODM as an executive management group comprised of Bryan DeBoer, President and CEO; Scott Hillier, Senior VP of Operations and Chris Holzshu, Senior VP and CFO. The three members of the CODM manage performance and determine how to allocate Company resources.

Bryan DeBoer is our key decision-maker and is the main leader in determining the strategy for growing top-line revenues. When he was promoted to CEO in early 2012, Bryan retained the title of Chief Operating Officer. He evaluates overall and certain store performance results and works with Chris and Scott to identify opportunities and improve performance. Additionally, Bryan manages our legal, manufacturer relations, information technology and real estate teams. Bryan, as President and CEO, spends time communicating the Company’s results to investors and analysts; however, this amount is relatively small compared to other areas of his involvement.

Scott Hillier’s main focus is personnel and human development. Scott oversees HR, training and recruiting to appropriately staff each store with management personnel. When a store has turnover at a management level and requires support, Scott’s team is responsible for recruiting replacement candidates and providing in-store training as needed. The store operational management team reports directly to Scott, through two Regional Vice Presidents who oversee each store General Manager.

Chris Holzshu manages the Company’s administrative functions (e.g. office operations, payroll, benefits, treasury and accounting) and both operational and external reporting. Additionally, he executes cost control strategies, prepares the financial forecast and manages external reporting to investors and creditors. Chris identifies opportunities to reduce costs, oversees the development of the financial forecast and reviews monthly actual results against this forecast.

This team of executives comprises the CODM, and collectively makes decisions regarding the allocation of resources and evaluation of operational performance as a group.

Operational Structure and Decision Making Process

As of December 31, 2013, we had 94 dealerships in 11 states. Our culture and leadership style builds an entrepreneurial culture unique to each store and empowers each store’s leadership team to define a customer experience that fits the local market and brand of the store. This culture is supported by the centralization of administrative and reporting functions, which do not directly impact the customer experience, at the corporate level.

Store leadership teams are responsible for the store-level controllable aspects of their location including top line revenue, inventory levels and valuation and certain SG&A costs such as personnel and advertising expense. Support Services operational teams assist in training, manage consolidated programs and may assist in stores when personnel changes occur.

Administrative and reporting functions are centralized and managed at the corporate level. Administrative functions include selected store back office functions (e.g. accounts payable, accounts receivable, and vehicle loan funding), tax, payroll, treasury, real estate, purchasing and advertising design and placement. Reporting functions such as operational budgeting/forecasting, consolidation, financial reporting and operational reporting are performed centrally at corporate. We manage our cash and debt, including financing of vehicle inventories, at a consolidated level. Decision making regarding capital investments is performed by the CODM based on available cash and credit availability, internal return on investment (ROI) criteria and forecasted consolidated capital expenditure, acquisition and divestiture expectations.

Significant store-level capital expenditures are evaluated based on an ROI criterion. This criterion is aligned with ROI expectations for acquisitions as well as the Company’s overall cost of equity. Decision making on allocation of resources is performed at a consolidated corporate level.

Strategically, these processes, managed at a consolidated level, have minimal impact on the customer while also relieving our stores of the burden of back office, administrative functions. The centralization of these functions allow for efficiencies that could not be achieved on a stand-alone basis. Additionally, our store population shares characteristics such as similar working capital requirements, capital structures, historical sales trends and gross margins, products and services, target markets and customers, and distribution and marketing practices. Performance management and decision making on a consolidated level allows for increased efficiency and effectiveness within the organization.

Based on our CODM, organizational structure and decision-making process, we believe we operate as one single operating segment as it relates to criterion B.

Criterion C: Discrete Financial Information

Criterion C requires that discrete financial information be available for each operating segment. Discrete financial information for each dealership is generated and available for sales and cost of sales. However, assumptions are made in the allocation of expenses among each store. Many expenses are managed on a consolidated level, such as financing of vehicle inventory, general insurance, IT services and utilities. We utilize various methodologies to allocate these expenses to each store. This results in financial information that has elements not directly correlated to store operations.

Additionally, within the broader organization, there are a number of expenses that are aggregated at the corporate level and are not distributed to each store. Depreciation expense on property, plant and equipment, interest cost for both variable and fixed rate debt, corporate overhead charges for both management and support staff and federal and state income taxes are some examples of charges that are not allocated to individual store locations.

We also manage several programs holistically. For example, selected incentive programs with commercial lending institutions and vendors are managed on a consolidated, corporate level. The incentives received from these entities are based on sales and purchases generated by each store with the income recorded at the parent entity. As a result, these items are excluded of store operational results even though the benefits are determined by store performance.

While store budgets and results are reviewed on a store-by-store basis, this is primarily used to monitor performance of individual store leadership and allows for the assessment of potential personnel changes and effectiveness of field management. These results are also typically only associated with revenue and cost of sales, with the exception of payroll and advertising costs. When reviewing financial results at the CODM level for making capital allocation decisions, evaluating overall operational results and when communicating results to investors, individual store performance is neither the primary consideration nor a part of the monthly reporting package. Within a retail operation, an evaluation of store performance on an individual store basis is a required component of effective operational management. In our opinion, such a review does not indicate that each location is an individual segment merely because the results, which are impacted by the allocation of centralized costs and services as discussed above, are available and may be viewed by certain employees within the organization.

Based on the considerations above about the availability and quality of discrete financial information, we believe we operate as one single operating segment as it relates to criterion C.

Quantitative Threshold Considerations

ASC 280-10-50-12 sets quantitative thresholds for reporting separate information about an operating segment. The thresholds are as follows:

Its reported revenue, including both sales to external customers and intersegment sales or transfers, is 10 percent or more of the combined revenue, internal and external, of all operating segments.

The absolute amount of its reported profit or loss is 10 percent or more of the greater, in absolute amount, of either:

The combined reported profit of all operating segments that did not report a loss

The combined reported loss of all operating segments that did report a loss.

3. Its assets are 10 percent or more of the combined assets of all operating segments.

Although we do not believe individual stores meet the three criteria of an operating segment, nonetheless, we evaluated each of our locations to determine the number of individual stores that would qualify for disclosure under the quantitative standards. The largest single store, by revenue, was less than 3% of overall sales, 3% of overall assets, and less than 5% of pre-tax income. Based on these thresholds, no individual store would meet the thresholds identified in ASC 280-10-50-12

We also considered the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-14, which requires segment disclosure until at least 75% of total revenue is disclosed on a segment basis. Although we do not believe individual stores meet the three criteria of an operating segment, if they did, we would be required to report 52 individual segments in order to reach the 75% threshold based on revenue. We do not believe this level of disclosure would be beneficial to a user of our financial statements. Additionally, ASC 280-10-50-11 allows for the aggregation of operating segments if the segments have similar economic characteristics and are similar in the nature of their products and services, type of customer, methods of distribution and regulatory environment. All of our stores are economically similar and operate in a similar structure and environment. As a result, aggregation of all of our stores is acceptable and we would present a single reportable segment.

Conclusion

Based on the above, we believe we function as a single operating segment. The economics of the business, structure of our operations, centralization of administrative functions and allocation of capital and other resources support this conclusion. The CODM reviews a consolidated summary of financial and operational data to determine overall results, make capital decisions based on overall results and communicates overall results to investors and creditors. In addition, no individual store meets the quantitative criteria for separate reporting and the level of disclosure that would be required if individual stores were determined to be operating segments would not be beneficial to readers of our financial statements. Because our stores are economically and operationally similar, aggregation of all of our stores would in any case be permitted. Considering these facts and circumstances, we concluded we appropriately report our results as one operating segment identified as automotive retailing.

* * * * *

Lithia believes the responses provided above address the Staff's comments, and further acknowledges that:

○

Lithia is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the Filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the Filing; and

Lithia may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Oct 10, 2014: 10-Q filed Oct 31, 2014 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked (1)
We have read your response to comment 3 of our letter dated September 26, 2014. We understand that the store operational management team reports directly to a member of your CODM group through two Regional Vice Presidents. We also read on page 2 of your Form 10-K that your dealerships are primarily located throughout the Western and Midwestern regions of the United States.
Rest of the question

Explain to us how the regions are structured, tell us the number of stores in each region and clarify for us the role of the two Regional Vice Presidents. In doing so, specifically explain to us the responsibilities of your Regional Vice Presidents and their specific interaction with the CODM. For example, tell us if the vice presidents meet with the CODM to discuss operating activities, financial results, forecasts, budgets, or other operational plans of their regions. In connection with your response, provide to us a chart that depicts your organizational structure. Please supplement this chart with a summary explanation of each manager’s responsibilities and the extent to which they interact with your CODM.

LAD answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 3, 2014: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 21, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked (2)
Please explain to us what involvement the Regional Vice Presidents have in assessing the performance of the stores in their regions and the extent to which they are involved in the allocation of resources. In this regard, explain to us what reports, if any, are provided to or analyzed by your Regional Vice Presidents and whether such reports or materials are shared with your CODM.
Rest of the question

Also explain to us how the Regional Vice Presidents are compensated and the extent to which their compensation is tied to the performance of their regions. Lastly, tell us in further detail how annual capital and operating budgets are determined and explain to us what involvement the Regional Vice Presidents have in establishing these budgets, including the discretion or authority they have to make revisions to the budgets.

LAD answered
We divide our stores into groups primarily based upon residence of the personnel overseeing the stores for travel logistics rather than geographic region, specific franchise or market area. In 2014, we had 3 individuals overseeing store General Managers. Our two Regional Vice Presidents (RVPs) are Bryan Osterhout, who oversees stores in Alaska, Washington, Oregon and California (55 stores), and Ken Wright, who oversees stores in Montana, Iowa, North Dakota, Texas and Hawaii (44 stores).
Rest of the answer

Our Vice President of Human Development, Mark Dundon, is primarily responsible for recruiting and hiring but oversees Idaho locations (7 stores) as an additional responsibility as he is located in Idaho and used to serve as a RVP. Over the last seven years, we have had as many as 6 RVPs at one time and have reorganized stores under the RVPs five times. These reorganizations have been based on multiple factors including: geography, store performance, brand, personnel needs and other considerations. We have also moved individual stores from one RVP to another based on their particular expertise or experience, for example, generating more used sales or achieving cost control objectives. The assignment of stores is not static, nor is it strictly based on a geographic division, e.g. “East” and “West”.

RVPs manage operational sales trends in assigned stores. Utilizing high level metrics such as customer satisfaction scores, new and used unit sales, service hours of labor sold, and personnel and advertising costs, they evaluate performance to ensure it is consistent with market and franchise expectations. In the event a store is not performing at expected levels or demonstrating improving trends, they will utilize more detailed data to identify areas of opportunity, such as types of vehicles sold or number of personnel in a department. The RVP works with the store General Manager to establish specific performance expectations and a timeline for completion. Failure to meet expected performance metrics triggers leadership changes at the General Manager level which the RVP facilitates. Termination decisions require input from Lithia’s executive management team, including the CODM and others, and are not solely within the control of the RVP.

In summary, the RVP is primarily responsible for assessing the operational performance of store leadership, ensuring it is meeting minimum sales and revenue volume and customer service levels. If they are not, the RVP is responsible for hiring and training personnel within the store to achieve an improved result. The RVP is a sales-oriented role, and as such, does not have responsibility or discretion over most store expenses or any corporate expenses.

Individual store forecasts (the Store Performance Expectations or “SPE”) are completed in October for the coming year and revised in May for the second half of the year. The SPE is prepared by each store General Manager and is reviewed by that store’s assigned RVP. The General Manager and RVP use market data including new and used vehicle registration counts and other relevant information to set preliminary revenue expectations focused on sales growth for each department within the store. Using established benchmarks set by corporate, e.g. gross profit per retail unit sold, personnel expense as a percentage of gross profit or advertising spend per unit sold, an operational profit objective for each store is established.

Once the SPE are created, they are summarized by personnel in our corporate offices, combined to a total company level and presented for review by the same personnel that we define to be the CODM. This review is a summary of expected sales and revenue expectations. There is no estimate for interest cost, depreciation, taxes, capital expenditures or maintenance capex in our SPE. All expense items at the store level are based off of current store trends and benchmark guidelines established in corporate. We do not produce an estimate of income or expense recorded on our management company, nor is a consolidated pre-tax profit or earnings per share estimate projected in the SPE.

After the SPE are approved, Chris Holzshu, Senior Vice President and CFO, and John North, Vice President of Finance, complete a financial forecast at the store level to account for required GAAP adjustments, actual expense levels for certain store expenses items that have been subsidized or increased, information on corporate controlled expenses that impact the stores such as medical or other insurance, employee benefits, volume purchasing discounts, capital strategy decisions, depreciation, interest and tax assumptions, and estimated share count to produce an estimate of after tax profit and earnings per share. This financial forecast is consolidated, reviewed and approved with Bryan DeBoer, President and CEO, and utilized to communicate external guidance to our creditors and investors, set variable cash compensation objectives, performance requirements for equity compensation, and to communicate overall strategy and performance expectations with our Board of Directors. We define this financial forecast as our “Company Performance Expectations” or “CPE”

The SPE and actual operational results contain a number of internal charges including management fees, internal rent, internal equipment charges, certain penalties or incentives and other adjustments that are designed to normalize stores across multiple locations to account for differences in time of ownership, adjust for regional cost differences and to incent store behavior within criteria defined by executive management such as penalizing excess inventory levels. Certain locations also receive subsidies if their actual expenses are higher than average, e.g. a metropolitan location with a high facility cost. All of these internal expenses, charges, and if applicable, subsidies, are set by corporate and the RVPs have no authority to change these amounts. As a result, the SPE and actual operational results are used by the RVPs to drive the revenue objectives of the business but do not provide meaningful discrete financial information needed by the CODM and would not be appropriate for disclosure in the financial statements.

The SPE does not contemplate consolidated charges or corporate overhead. The SPE does not forecast a balance sheet or a statement of cash flows. Additionally, the capital expenditure process is not contemplated in the SPE, and is instead summarized in the CODM’s consolidated forecast. The RVPs and the General Managers do not play any material role in capital allocation, budgeting or significant acquisition or facility investment decisions. The only capital decisions they are involved in is when a particular piece of equipment within a store requires repair or replacement, and the RVPs approval authority is limited to $25,000.

The SPE revenue projection typically exceeds the CPE by a range of 10%-20% and is designed to motivate sales oriented people to achieve higher revenue objectives than we would forecast on a consolidated basis. The SPE also contains a number of internal charges, fees and markups that would not be contemplated by the CODM when assessing individual store performance to determine profitability or capital allocation analysis. The SPE also excludes expenses that would be managed at the store level in a more decentralized model, such as employee benefits, insurance, marketing expense, information technology charges, and corporate contracted services.

At month end, the RVPs receive a three page summary of all store operational results compared to SPE. Based on this report, the RVP may obtain store specific operational information to analyze performance at a more granular level. For example, if a store does not meet its operational profit objective, the RVP may review the store in detail, analyzing each departmental result to determine where the revenue deficiency occurred. This specific information may also be reviewed during the month for locations that have been underperforming or if the RVPs travel schedule takes them to a particular location.

Monthly, a conference call is held that includes all Vice Presidents and higher (12 people) where each RVP provides a recap of certain store performance, pending or completed personnel changes, and other information to ensure all functional areas within Lithia are aware of operational plans. During this call, not every store is reviewed, and members of the CODM may or may not participate depending on availability.

The RVPs do not interact with the CODM to evaluate monthly or quarterly performance or to review the consolidated financial results. The RVPs have no ability to modify or otherwise revise the annual capital or operating budgets of Lithia, their region or within their assigned stores once they have been set by the CODM in the semi-annual forecasting process discussed earlier. The RVPs also do not participate in the financial structure, resource allocation or other investment decision making process for either their stores or the overall consolidated operational entity.

The RVPs compensation is comprised of a base annual salary, a variable compensation cash award, a contribution to a supplemental employee retirement plan (“SERP”), stock awards, and certain perquisites. The base salary, SERP contribution, stock awards and perquisites are fixed annually. The stock awards have performance and time vesting requirements. The performance requirements for the vesting of the awards are tied to overall Company objectives such as consolidated earnings per share targets. The variable compensation cash award is weighted 60% to 75% on the overall objectives that the CODM and other executive officers are compensated on, and 25% to 40% on certain performance expectations of certain stores within their currently assigned area of responsibility, such as obtaining certain Original Equipment Manufacturer (“OEM”) awards for operational excellence, achieving operational objectives on a store-by-store basis, or filling open General Manager positions. We have attached, as Exhibit 1 a variable compensation example and an organizational chart that depicts our corporate structure and management responsibilities. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 1 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014.

We have discussed the roles of Bryan DeBoer, Chris Holzshu and Scott Hillier in our previous letter dated October 10, 2014. We have defined the roles of our RVPs and Mark Dundon above. All the other officers listed on the organizational chart interact within the organization as functional area leaders (e.g. head of marketing; head of information technology).

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 3, 2014: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 21, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked (3)
We note decision making regarding capital investments is performed by the CODM based, in part, on a return on investment criteria approach. Please specify the nature of the capital investment decisions made by the CODM (store level capital expenditures, overall company expansion decisions, etc.). Explain to us in further detail how these capital investments are determined and allocated.
Rest of the question

Detailed examples would facilitate our review.

LAD answered
Our capital investment decisions are divided into two categories: 1) Store level maintenance expenditures related to repairing or replacing equipment necessary to sell and service automobiles or 2) significant investment to either remodel or expand current locations or acquire or build locations where we are purchasing an existing store from a third party or have been awarded a franchise from an OEM.

As discussed in our previous response to questions 1 and 2 above, the store General Manager and RVP have authority to make capital investment decisions up to $25,000 related to the repair or
Rest of the answer

replacement of existing equipment. When a capital investment decision regarding the repair or replacement of equipment at our stores exceeds $25,000 the approval is made by either our CFO or CEO. Examples of these types of decisions may be the replacement of all of the vehicle lifts at a location, the installation of new equipment to work on heavy duty trucks, or the upgrade of certain IT equipment for connectivity or security reasons.

When a significant investment in an existing store is proposed to either remodel or expand a current location, or for acquisitions or new locations, a monthly meeting involving our CODM, Director of Financial Planning and Analysis, and other corporate personnel is held. In this meeting, the Director of Financial Planning and Analysis presents pro-forma projections of the expected increase in revenue, additional vehicles that may be allocated from an OEM upon completion, or impact of the loss of certain incentives provided by the OEM for not maintaining a facility to current image requirements. The projections are used to evaluate the return on investment as a percentage of the total spend that will be incrementally required for the investment. For acquisitions or new locations, market data, such as vehicle registrations, analysis of units in operation in a market area, or expected unit sales volumes provided by the OEM are utilized to produce a pro-forma 5-year projected income statement, which is compared to the total investment and the non-financeable component to generate a return on asset and return on equity calculation.

These investments are contemplated against the current liquidity position of Lithia, previously made investment decisions that will require specific performance now or in the future, the economic outlook for the United States and within our specific markets, and other quantitative and qualitative considerations such as consumer confidence, availability of credit, expectations of projected levels of vehicle sales, the overall health of Lithia, approvability for acquisitions by an OEM, availability of personnel and opportunity costs vis-à-vis other potential investments to make a case-by-case decision on incremental significant investments.

We have attached, as Exhibit 2, an example of the capital investment summary for a recent acquisition, Corpus Christi Ford, in Corpus Christi, Texas, and the purchase of additional land to retail used vehicles at our Springfield Toyota store in Springfield, Oregon. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 2 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 3, 2014: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 21, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked (4)
We note your CEO is part of the CODM group and that he evaluates “overall and certain store performance results.” We further note that store budgets and results are reviewed on a store-by-store basis. Please address the following comments:  Provide to us the reports that your CODM uses to assess performance and allocate resources, including the monthly reporting package you discuss in your response.
Rest of the question

If your CODM group regularly reviews any operating results outside of the formal monthly internal reporting package, please summarize for us the nature of that information.  Considering store budgets and results are reviewed at the individual store level, please explain in further detail how you determined each store does not qualify as an operating segment under Criteria B and C of ASC 280-10-50-1.

LAD answered
We have attached, as Exhibit 3, the monthly consolidated financial reporting package that our CODM uses to assess performance and allocate resources previously discussed in our response dated October 10, 2014. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 3 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014.

We have attached, as Exhibit 4, an operational month end summary report that details individual store gross profit and operational profit on a store-by store basis. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 4 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014.
Rest of the answer

Certain corporate employees, including the individuals who comprise our CODM, receive this report at the end of each month as part of our financial close process.

As discussed above, due to the numerous internal charges, fees or subsidies allocated to the stores from corporate, the operational month end summary report does not contain actual expenses that the CODM would utilize when making decisions about the allocation of resources or to assess performance. Additionally, the operational month-end summary report is structured to align with the SPE discussed in our response to questions 1 and 2 above, and thus contains the internal charges, fees and adjustments noted above, to help identify store trends and performance opportunities. There is not a formal meeting or review where this occurs, other than the monthly operational call led by our RVPs to outline any store General Manager updates or other personnel changes discussed above.

As discussed above and in our responses to questions 1 and 2, SPE are produced and reviewed on an individual store level. Additional consideration was given to the criteria defining an operating segment, specifically criteria B and C, to further evaluate whether or not each store qualifies as an operating segment. ASC 280-10-50-1 states that an entity must meet the following three criteria to be defined as an operating segment:

A. It engages in business activities from which it may earn revenues and incur expense (including revenues and expenses relating to transactions with other components of the same public entity).

B. Its operating results are regularly reviewed by the public entity’s chief operating decision maker to make decisions about resources to be allocated to the segment and assess its performance.

C. Its discrete financial information is available.

Criterion B: Decision Making by the CODM

Criterion B considers the Company’s management style of its business and the basis at which decision making occurs. To evaluate this criterion, we identified our chief operating decision maker (CODM) and considered whether there is evidence the business is managed based on operating segments. Consideration was given to the organization structure/decision making process used by the CODM and how store specific budgets and operational reports are utilized.

We have defined our CODM as an executive management group comprised of Bryan DeBoer, President and CEO; Scott Hillier, Senior VP of Operations and Chris Holzshu, Senior VP and CFO. The three members of the CODM manage performance and determine how to allocate Company resources.

The General Manager is responsible for store-level controllable aspects of their location including top line revenue, unit sales and personnel and advertising costs. Trends within individual stores are reported and identified solely for elements that can be addressed by store leadership and follow the structure of the SPE.

Because the General Manager is only accountable for some controllable elements at the store level, SPE exclude costs and expenses which are managed at the consolidated level or are outside of the store’s control. These costs include rent, insurance, taxes, utilities, national vendor contracts, facility management and advertising design and placement. Additionally, we manage our cash and debt, including financing of vehicle inventories, at a consolidated level. None of the store specific SPE or month end operational reports are used in decision making on allocation of resources as discussed in criterion B.

Criterion C: Discrete Financial Information

Criterion C requires that discrete financial information be available for each operating segment. As we have discussed in both this response and in our previous response, we do not produce financial information at the store level that includes key information the CODM would utilize to evaluate performance and allocate resources. The information produced and reviewed at the store level is based on SPE, and as such does not contain key inputs and considerations a segment manager would need to make management and allocation decisions.

When reviewing financial results at the CODM level for making capital allocation decisions, evaluating overall operational results and communicating results to investors, individual store performance is neither the primary consideration nor a part of the monthly reporting package. Within a retail operation, an evaluation of store performance on an individual store basis is a required component of effective operational management and identifying store controllable trends. In our opinion, such a review does not indicate that each location is an individual segment merely because the results, which are impacted by the omission or allocation of certain costs and expenses as discussed above, are available and may be viewed by certain employees within the organization.

The nature of the store level information is operational, which results in differences in store level gross profit, operating income and substantially all other financial measures as compared to the financial information used by the CODM and reported to investors.

ASC 280-10-50-6 states that “…a public entity may produce reports in which its business activities are presented in a variety of different ways. If the chief operating decision maker uses more than one set of segment information, other factors may identify a single set of components as constituting a public entity's operating segments, including the nature of the business activities of each component, the existence of managers responsible for them, and information presented to the board of directors.”

Given our less than 100 store locations and low transaction volume, averaging approximately 3 vehicle sales per location per day, we maintain a relatively small management team. Individuals who comprise our CODM also review other operational reports and data in order to be informed on how store management teams maximize revenue and profitability within our retail business and ensure effective operational performance. As a result, the broader context of performance including all expenses and capital allocation decisions do not occur based on this information.

The evaluation by the executive management group of our consolidated operating results is supported by the similar characteristics of our store population (similar working capital requirements, capital structures, historical sales trends and gross margins, products and services, target markets and customers, and distribution and marketing practices), and by the centralized nature of our operations, such as:

● centrally-located dealer management and other IT systems utilized by the stores;

● centralized cash management, financing and capital markets activity;

● centralized accounting and administrative functions performed by a shared services center;

● centralized forecasting, budgeting and capital expenditure plans;

● centralized store acquisition and divestiture plans;

● common compensation plans; and

● standardized finance and insurance pricing and sales practices.

ASC 280-10-50-7 50-7 states, “an operating segment has a segment manager who is directly accountable to and maintains regular contact with the chief operating decision maker to discuss operating activities, financial results, forecasts, or plans for the segment.” Our store General Managers and RVPs do not directly interact with the entire CODM on a regular basis, nor do they have overall responsibility for financial results including some components of our gross profit or most store level expenses that are negotiated and implemented at corporate. They also do not have authority to allocate resources or make plans for material investment such as improvements or remodels. They do not review information that shows store performance on a GAAP basis, or even reflecting the true costs of the entity based on markups or subsidies that may be provided by or received in certain corporate entities.

ASC 280-10-50-8 discusses that “[t]he chief operating decision maker also may be the segment manager for certain operating segments…If the characteristics in paragraphs 280-10-50-1 and 280-10-50-3 apply to more than one set of components of a public entity but there is only one set for which segment managers are held responsible, that set of components constitutes the operating segments.”

Consideration was given to how our CODM is evaluated to give additional insight to whether decision making occurs on a segment level. Our CODM is evaluated by our Board of Directors for both performance evaluation and to determine compensation. The information provided to the Board of Directors was examined to perform this evaluation.

Our Board of Directors receives two monthly reports with financial information—the monthly consolidated financial reporting package (Exhibit 3) and a monthly operational performance summary, attached as Exhibit 5. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 5 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014. All financial information provided to the Board of Directors is presented on a consolidated basis. Our Board of Directors does not evaluate or hold management accountable at the individual store level. We would also note that the presentation of the CODM reporting package (Exhibit 3) matches our current financial reporting on Form 10-K. Information provided to our Board of Directors supports the management of Lithia as one operating segment.

Our executive management team is incentivized through both cash and stock compensation objectives that are based on overall pre-tax profit and certain earnings per share targets. We have attached, as Exhibit 6, the 2014 second half variable cash compensation objectives for our executive management team, which is substantially unchanged in structure from 2013. Lithia requested confidential treatment of Exhibit 6 by letter to the Commission dated December 3, 2014. Compensation for the CODM is aligned with the concept that Lithia is one operating segment and managed as one operating segment.

As discussed, we do not believe our individual stores meet Criteria B or C under ASC 280-10-50-1. We also believe ASC 280-10-50-6, ASC 280-10-50-7, and ASC 280-10-50-8 support the assertion that our CODM does not act in that capacity when individually reviewing store results, does not interact with the store General Manager or the RVP as the ‘segment manager’, and is not held accountable to performance by the Board of Directors at the individual store level, but rather at the consolidated level.

Therefore, considering these facts and circumstances, we concluded we appropriately report our results as one operating segment identified as automotive retailing.

* * * * *

Lithia believes the responses provided above address the staff's comments, and further acknowledges that:

○

Lithia is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the Filing;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the Filing; and

Lithia may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Dec 3, 2014: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 21, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Segment Reporting, page F-14
SEC asked
We have read your responses to comments 1-4 of our letter dated October 29, 2014 and considered the information you discussed on the January 21, 2015 conference call. Based on the information you presented, we note the following:  Each store is operated in an autonomous manner by a general manager who is responsible for meeting profit targets established by your CODM.
Rest of the question

 Your CODM regularly obtains and actively reviews store-level financial results.  Your CODM participates in termination decisions of general managers at underperforming locations.  Your CODM actively participates in completing financial forecasts at the store level, reviews actual versus budgetary results at the store level, and visits individual stores to discuss and review store performance with store general managers. Given the above factors, each store appears to meet the definition of an operating segment in accordance with ASC 280-10-50-1. As a result, please provide us with an analysis that illustrates how your stores should be aggregated into reportable segments under ASC 280-10-50-11 through 50-14. In determining the appropriate aggregation level(s), please tell us how you have considered each factor based on differences based on geography, manufacturer and type of brand (domestic, luxury and imported), as relevant.

LAD answered
We are in receipt of your comment letter dated February 5, 2015, regarding Lithia Motors, Inc.’s Form 10-K filing. As discussed with Mr. Robert Babula, we are requesting an additional 10 business days to respond. As a result, we will submit our response letter by March 5, 2015.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Feb 12, 2015: 10-K filed Mar 2, 2015 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 21, 2014 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: request for more time, Nov 7, 2014, company letter, Mar 5, 2015, closing letter, 2015-03-19

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 20 letters filed since 2014-09-26. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/LAD/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.