Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2019
We note your disclosure that the majority of your advertising space contracts do not meet the definition of a lease under ASC 842. Please provide us with a summary of the typical terms of your advertising space contracts by source (i.e. billboard, logo and transit) and explain to us how you determined these contracts do not meet the definition of a lease.Rest of the question
In your response, please tell us the amount of revenue for the year ended December 31, 2019 and quarterly period ended September 30, 2020 for each source derived from contracts that do meet the definition of a lease, and explain to us how these contracts differ from those contracts that are not leases.
, please tell us the amount of revenue for the year ended December 31, 2019 and quarterly period ended September 30, 2020 for each source derived from contracts that do meet the definition of a lease, and explain to us how these contracts differ from those contracts that are not leases.Read in the reply
RESPONSE:
Lamar is a non-traditional real estate investment trust (a “REIT”) and generates a majority of its net revenues by selling advertising space on billboards, buses, shelters, benches, logo plates and in airport terminals.Rest of the answer
As of December 31, 2019, the Company had approximately (a) 154,200 static billboard advertising displays, (b) 3,500 digital billboard advertising displays, (c) 151,200 logo sign advertising displays, and (d) 52,800 transit and airport advertising displays.
January 5, 2021
Page
The majority of the Company’s net revenues are generated through its outdoor static and digital billboard advertising displays. For the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, these billboard displays accounted for approximately 88% and 89% of its total net revenues, respectively. Lamar’s outdoor advertising revenues are further broken down into two categories for purposes of this response—local and national outdoor advertising revenues. The Company’s local outdoor advertising revenues comprised approximately 76% and 80% of its outdoor net revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively. These local advertising revenues are generated on highly standardized contracts, including contract terms and conditions. The remaining 24% and 20% of its outdoor advertising revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively, are from national advertising contracts which are generated through contracts with approximately 35 national advertising agencies. These national contracts, including contract terms and conditions, are unique to each advertising agency.
Lamar has also entered into operating agreements with 23 states and Canada to operate their respective logo advertising programs. These agreements allow Lamar to erect and operate interstate roadside signs within the specified state and are typically for a term of 3-5 years. Logo advertising customers must meet certain criteria stipulated within each contract in order to participate in the advertising program. These programs accounted for approximately 5% of the Company’s net revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020.
Lastly, Lamar enters into operating agreements with transit and airport authorities to operate advertising displays on buses, benches, shelters and within airport terminals. These operating agreements are typically for a period of 3-5 years. Net revenues generated from customers advertising within these agreements accounted for approximately 7% and 6% of the
Company’s net revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively.
Below we will discuss
Lamar’s contract terms and conditions and management’s accounting analysis and conclusion for each category of revenues.
Outdoor advertising revenues:
As noted above, Lamar utilizes a highly standardized contract for its local billboard outdoor advertising displays, which comprised approximately 76% and 80% of its outdoor advertising revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively.
The Company’s standardized local advertising contract contains the following summarized terms and conditions:
•
Clauses for late artwork – Artwork is generally provided by the advertiser prior to the start date of the contract, and if late, billing will occur on the contract service start date.
Copyright/trademark—The advertiser must warrant that all approved advertisement designs do not infringe on state or federal trademarks and copyrights.
Payment terms—Stipulates the advertiser’s obligations of payments on invoices for advertising, including fees for late payment.
Service interruptions—Limits Lamar’s liability for service interruptions related to acts of
God, work stoppages, or damage or destruction of the asset. It also includes loss limits for illumination interruptions.
Copy acceptance—Lamar reserves the right to determine if the advertising copy and design are in good taste and meet its moral standards. Lamar reserves the right to reject or remove copy either before or after installation and to terminate the contract.
Termination—All contracts are non-cancellable by the advertiser without written consent by Lamar.
Materials and storage - Production materials will be held at a customer’s request, in which case fees may apply.
Installation lead time—Leeway of a certain number of days from the initial service date is required to complete installation on all non-digital displays.
Customer provided production—The advertiser is responsible for the production and shipping of advertising copy and is responsible for all space costs involved in the event the advertising copy does not reach Lamar by the established service dates. Production must meet Lamar’s specifications.
Billboard enhancements—Where allowed, extensions/cutouts to be placed on billboards as part of the ad campaign are limited in their size.
Assignment—The advertiser shall not sublet, resell, transfer, donate or assign any advertising space without the prior written consent of Lamar.
All of Lamar’s local standardized contracts specifically identify the fixed asset
(specific billboard) on which the advertising content will be advertised, which cannot be substituted absent a contract amendment. Further, the contracts convey substantially all of the economic benefits from the use of the billboard display to the customer throughout the period of use, and therefore meet the criterion of ASC 842-10-15-4a.
While Lamar’s standardized contracts meet the criterion of ASC 842-10-15-4a, they do not meet the criterion in ASC 842-10-15-4b. In reaching this conclusion, we first considered that these contracts do not provide the customer with the right to change the content of the billboard display during the term of the contract. They require the customer to provide advertising content to the supplier (i.e. Lamar) for approval and installation on the billboard display within the first five days of the contract period, and the customer has no right to change the advertising displayed during the period without Lamar’s agreement. The output produced (advertising display) by the identified billboard asset is therefore predetermined. Furthermore, there are no other relevant “how and for what purpose” decisions that the customer controls during the advertising period
– i.e. the customer (and Lamar) cannot change where the output is produced because the billboard is stationary; neither party can change when the output is produced (the billboard constantly displays the content), or how much it is displayed
(it is displayed continuously throughout the period). Therefore, because all of the relevant how and for what purpose decisions are predetermined, the contracts do not convey decision making rights that grant the customer the right to direct how and for what purpose the billboard is used throughout the period of use (i.e. ASC 842-10-15-20(a) is not met).
Management then considered the criterion in ASC
842-10-15-20(b). Lamar noted the customer does not have the right to operate the asset (or direct others to operate the asset in a manner that it determines) throughout the period of use without Lamar having the right to change those operating instructions. Lamar installs, maintains and later removes the customer displays, and the customer has no right to change that.
Further, the customer does not design the billboard asset itself (only the content that will be displayed thereon). As a result, the criterion in ASC
842-10-15-20(b) is not met. Because these arrangements do not meet the criterion in ASC 842-10-15-20(b), the criterion in ASC
842-10-15-4(b) are also not met and, consequently, these arrangements do not meet the definition of a lease and are accounted for under ASC 606.
The 35 national agencies that contract with Lamar each have unique contract terms and conditions. Of these, ten have terms that expressly provide the agency/advertising customer the right to change the advertising on the identified billboard at its discretion during the contract term. For these contracts, the output display on the billboard is not predetermined (i.e. agency/advertising customer has the right to change the output at its discretion). In these contracts, the criterion in ASC
842-10-15-20(a) is met and, consequently, so is the criterion in ASC 842-10-15-4(b). Contracts that give the agency/customer the enforceable right to change the advertising content during the term, even if for a fee, are accounted for as a lease under ASC 842. These contracts comprised approximately 6% and 4% of the Company’s total net advertising revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019 and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively. The remaining national agency advertising revenues are accounted for under ASC 606, as their contract terms and conditions relevant to evaluating whether a lease exists are consistent with those in our standard local outdoor advertising contracts (described above).
Logo advertising revenues
The
Company’s logo advertising contracts allow customers who meet logo program criteria to place advertisements on roadside exit signs. The signs are designed and operated in a manner to include advertising from a number of customers (up to nine in certain states) on a single logo structure. Lamar’s logo advertising contract terms and conditions are standardized by each state program. While there are some minor variations by state, below is a summary of the significant terms and conditions for the Company’s logo advertising contracts.
Advertiser Criteria—Advertisers that participate in the state advertising program must continue to meet the minimum criteria (i.e. must be a gas, food or motorist service establishment within a certain distance from the interchange) in order to continue participation.
Maintenance - Lamar (the program operator) is responsible for maintaining the business signs for the duration of the contract.
Advertisement Criteria—Advertisers who supply Lamar logo advertising displays understand that those displays must meet certain criteria as stipulated by the state contract in order to be installed on logo structures by Lamar.
Payment - Advertisers agree to pay the consideration included in the contract.
Similar to the Company’s local outdoor advertising contracts, its logo advertising contracts do not allow customers the ability to change the advertising content during the advertising term (i.e. the advertising content is predetermined).
The remaining relevant “how and for what purpose” decision about the use of the identified sign space is also predetermined – i.e. where the customer’s advertising signs will appear (the location of the sign) and when the signs will display the customer’s logo during the advertising term
(continuously), are not able to be changed during the period of use. The customers do not operate, nor have the right to operate, the signs. Lamar installs and changes the logo display when a customer enters into a new contract. Lastly, customers are not involved in the design of the logo sign structures (i.e. the signs upon which the customer’s advertising appears).
As a result of the above, the Company’s logo customers do not have the right to direct the use of the identified sign space during the period of use. Therefore, the criterion of ASC 842-10-15-4(b) is not met and the logo advertising contracts do not meet the definition of a lease under ASC 842. All of our logo customer contracts are accounted for under ASC 606.
Transit and airport advertising revenues
Lamar enters into advertising contracts for display on the side of buses, benches, bus shelters and spaces within airport terminals. The Company’s customer contracts for transit and airport advertising are also on highly standardized contracts with the same terms and conditions as its local outdoor advertising contracts described above.
Management determined that these advertising spaces (i.e. outside of a wall of a bus or bus shelter, the airspace where a banner is hung in an airport terminal) are not physically distinct, separately identifiable assets. In each case, the advertising space in question is not physically or mechanically separable from the bus, bench, shelter or airport wall primarily being used for a purpose other than for advertising. Therefore, the space where the customer’s advertising is displayed is not an identified asset, and no lease exists because the advertising customer is not obtaining substantially all of the economic benefits from use of the larger identifiable asset. There is no lease because the criterion in ASC 842-10-15-4(a) is not met. These advertising contracts are accounted for under ASC 606 and there are no transit and airport advertising contracts that meet the definition of a lease.
* * *
We hope this letter is responsive to your comments and request for information. We acknowledge that the Company and management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures. The Company’s goal is to address the comment in a manner that is acceptable to the Staff. If you or any member of the Staff has any questions regarding the responses set forth herein, please contact the undersigned at (225) 926-1000.
Please address the following with respect to your response to our prior comment: • Please provide us with a more detailed description of the design process for all revenue sources. Your discussion should include a description of the involvement of both the customer and the company in the design of the advertisement, and the rights and obligations of each party.Rest of the question
In your response, please address how you considered the guidance in ASC Topic 842-10-15-20b. • With respect to transit and airport advertising revenues, please clarify for us the nature of the arrangement that permits you to sell advertising space on the identified asset. Tell us whether you own and operate the identified asset, own a billboard attached to the identified asset or have entered into a contractual arrangement with the owner of the identified asset that allows you to display advertisements. If your ability to sell advertising space on the identified asset is derived from a contractual arrangement, please provide us with a summary of the typical terms of those contracts.
The Company operates outdoor advertising on billboards, logo signs, and transit advertising displays. The Company derives its net revenues from two distinct sources, production revenues and advertising space revenues.Read in the reply
In response to the Staff’s comment, we note that our production revenues consist of production services, which include the artistic design of billboard, logo, and transit advertisements for display and printing those advertisements on vinyl or logo plates for customers. In order to generate our production revenues, we employ full service art design and vinyl printing staff.Rest of the answer
A customer may contract with Lamar to only complete
February 17, 2021
Page art design and vinyl printing services. Production service customers may or may not contract with Lamar for advertising space on billboards, logo signs, on the sides of buses, or within airport terminals. Regardless of whether they do or do not contract with us for advertising space, at the conclusion of these production services, the design and/or printed vinyl is owned by the customer, so it is no longer Lamar’s asset. If the customer contracts with the Company for advertising space, at no point in the design or production process does the customer participate in the design of the advertising space (i.e. the billboard) it obtains from us to display the production. Our production services accounted for approximately 6% of our total net revenues for the year ended December 31, 2019.
The majority of the
Company’s net revenues are derived from the sale of advertising space on billboards, logo structures, buses, benches and bus stop shelters and within airport terminals. These revenues are obtained by a customer contracting with Lamar, for Lamar to place their advertisement on a billboard, logo structure, bus, bench, bus stop shelter or within an airport terminal. As described in our prior response, our contract terms specify that the advertising customer is responsible for providing artwork and production that is both timely received and meets any copyright/trademark requirements, and the customer cannot change those during the contract period without Lamar’s agreement. In all cases, Lamar reserves the right to determine if the advertising copy and design are in good taste and meet its moral standards. Lamar reserves the right to reject or remove copy either before or after installation and to terminate the contract.
A customer’s design and production of their advertisement, as noted above, is unrelated to the design of the underlying identified asset (e.g. billboard or logo structure) on which we are contracting with the customer to allow placement of their advertisement. Because our customers have no input into the design of the identified asset, we have concluded that our contracts do not meet the criterion in ASC 842-10-15-20(b)(2), and are therefore not leases. Furthermore, we have considered that ASC
842-10-15-20(b)(2) applies only when the asset has been designed ‘in a way that predetermines how and for what purpose the asset will be used throughout the period of use.’ In our outdoor advertising scenarios, it is not the design of the asset (or specific aspects thereof) that predetermine how and for what purpose the asset will be used, it is the terms of the contracts with our customers, as explained in our prior response.
In circumstances where Lamar sells advertising space and production to a customer in a single contract and we have concluded the selling of space to a customer does not meet the definition of a lease, we considered the guidance in ASC
606-10-25-14. Through our analysis we noted that our contracts provide two distinct services, as described above, and are therefore separate performance obligations under ASC 606-10-25-14(a). The Company follows the requirements in ASC 842-10-15-30 for its agency advertising contracts with customers that meet the definition of a lease because of the customer’s right to change the advertising displayed (i.e. the customer’s right to direct and change how and for what purpose the identified asset is used throughout the period of use in accordance with ASC 842-10-15-24). Therefore, our production service and the lease are accounted for as separate components of the contract.
With respect to transit and airport advertising revenues, please clarify for us the nature of the arrangement that permits you to sell advertising space on the identified asset. Tell us whether you own and operate the identified asset, own a billboard attached to the identified asset or have entered into a contractual arrangement with the owner of the identified asset that allows you to display advertisements. If your ability to sell advertising space on the identified asset is derived from a contractual arrangement, please provide us with a summary of the typical terms of those contracts.
RESPONSE:
In response to the Staff’s comment, we note that Lamar enters into agreements with transit and airport authorities that allow Lamar to place advertising on transit or airport authority owned and operated assets. We place advertisements either directly on the identified transit or airport authority asset or within a frame affixed to the identified asset. These operating agreements are typically for a 3-5 year period. Our transit and airport agreements generally provide for payment to the municipality or authority on the greater of a percentage of revenues or a specified guaranteed minimum payment. Our costs determined by a percentage of revenues are expensed as incurred when related revenues are recognized, and our minimum guarantees are expensed over the term of the contract. Although each authority contract has some unique terms and conditions, the typical terms and conditions of these contracts which we considered relevant to our analysis regarding revenue and expense recognition and lease identification are outlined below.
Asset ownership and operation: The municipality owns and operates the assets upon which Lamar’s advertising will appear, including any frame(s) which Lamar may place on the identified asset for advertisement.
Identification of assets for advertising: The municipality is responsible for identifying the number of assets (for example, buses or bus stop shelters for transit authorities) or designated advertising spaces (for example, baggage claim carousels for airport authorities) that will be available to Lamar to install advertising.
Advertising contracts: Contracts between Lamar and its advertising customers are required to be on either uniform contracts or require standardized information in a form approved by the municipality. Copies of these contracts are to be provided to the municipality upon their execution.
Content approval: Lamar is required to provide the advertising to the municipality for final review and approval prior to installation on the municipality’s asset.
Maintenance: Lamar is responsible for all costs associated with installation, maintenance, restoration and removal of its advertising on the municipality’s assets.
Damages: Lamar is responsible for the costs of repairs (either through direct payment of those costs or reimbursement of costs to the municipality) in the event that the underlying asset is damaged during the installation or removal of the Company’s advertising copy.
Contract expiration/termination: Upon expiration of the contract between Lamar and the municipality, Lamar is required to assign and transfer open contracts to the municipality, including all installed advertising copy
To determine whether or not our agreements with municipalities should be accounted for as leases, we considered whether these spaces on, for example, the side of a bus, bus stop shelter or wall or ceiling of an airport terminal were separately identifiable assets from the side of the bus, bus stop shelter or the wall or ceiling of the airport terminal itself. We determined that the space for the placement of advertisements is not a physically distinct, identifiable asset as described in ASC 842-10-15-16. In each case:
The primary use of the identifiable bus, bus stop shelter or wall or ceiling is for a purpose other than advertising.
The space in question (e.g. the space on the side of the bus, on the side of the bus stop shelter or on the wall or ceiling) is not physically or mechanically separable from the side of the bus, wall of a bus stop shelter or wall or ceiling of the airport terminal itself.
In regard of these points, we acknowledge there is judgment, and considered interpretive guidance of the large accounting firms in undertaking our evaluation.1 In considering this guidance, we determined that Lamar’s rights to display advertising are generally only a minor portion of the economic benefits that derive from use of the larger asset. Therefore, the space where advertising is displayed is not an identified asset, and no lease exists because Lamar is not obtaining substantially all of the economic benefits from use of the larger, identified asset (e.g. the bus or bus shelter) in accordance with ASC 842-10-15-4(a).
From the perspective of our contracts with our transit and airport advertising customers, our determination that such contracts are not a lease is based on
(1) the fact that we do not own the assets where we obtain rights to advertising space and (2) our lease identification conclusions above that we have determined our contracts with customers for transit-related advertising space do not include leases (or subleases) to our advertising customers.
* * *
We hope this letter is responsive to your comments and request for information. We acknowledge that the Company and management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures. The Company’s goal is to address the comment in a manner that is acceptable to the Staff. If you or any member of the Staff has any questions regarding the responses set forth herein, please contact the undersigned at (225) 926-1000.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2021-04-12