The Company acknowledges errors with respect to the collectability of tuition from students who become responsible for payments due to withdrawal or loss of financial aid. The Company does not believe these errors for 2012, 2013 and 2014 to be material pursuant to the guidance outlined in SAB 99. The Company has provided the following SAB 99 analysis for the Staff’s consideration:
To assess errors, management uses a quantitative benchmark for identifying items over which to perform additional quantitative and qualitative analysis.
Rest of the answer
The primary financial statement users currently are the Company’s debt holders and private equity investors, who focus primarily on cash flows and Adjusted EBITDA (as defined in the MD&A included in the Registration Statement), a non-GAAP measure, to assess financial performance. The items over which the Company’s management performs these analyses are:
· Pre-tax Income: This is the benchmark of greatest significance to the investors in profit-oriented entities. However, as the Company is highly leveraged and has experienced losses, and often operates at close to a break-even level, its current investors focus primarily on Adjusted EBITDA and Revenues.
· Revenues: This is a more stable measure than pre-tax income and is a strong indicator of the scale of the Company and relative materiality.
· Adjusted EBITDA: The Company’s current financial statement users focus primarily on cash-based performance measures, including cash flows from operations and Adjusted EBITDA, which exclude expenditures such as depreciation and amortization, which are non-cash, as well as derivative gains/losses, interest expense and income taxes. Adjusted EBITDA is a factor in certain covenants in the Company’s credit agreement and is also regularly reported to the Board of Directors and the Audit Committee.
The Company currently uses a materiality benchmark of approximately $20 million, based on consideration of the above factors, as a guideline to assess materiality prior to performing further quantitative and qualitative analysis. This benchmark was in a similar range during 2012, 2013 and 2014.
Quantitative Analysis
The Company performed inquiries and sensitivity analyses on the aggregated misstatements identified related to revenue recognition of withdrawn students and deemed that the policy elections that the Company made, as described in its response submitted to the Staff in the Company’s previous response letter, does not result in a material adjustment. The Company has aggregated all these identified misstatements for both the Title IV program as per this comment and the CAE program, as discussed in comment 10.
Table 1 (below) summarizes the aggregate misstatements accumulated during the calendar years 2012, 2013 and 2014 and the current year-to-date period ended September 30, 2015 and their impacts to Income (Loss) from Continuing Operations, Income Tax Expense (Benefit) and Net Income (Loss) under the “rollover” method. Table 2 (below) summarizes the aggregate misstatements accumulated as of September 30, 2015 and their impacts to Income (Loss) from Continuing Operations, Income Tax Expense (Benefit) and Net Income (Loss) under the “iron curtain” method. Table 3 (below) summarizes the aggregate misstatements accumulated for the quarter ended September 30, 2015 and their impacts to Income (Loss) from Continuing Operations, Income Tax Expense (Benefit) and Net Income (Loss) under the “iron curtain” method. The Company intends to record immaterial out-of-period adjustments related to these errors during the fourth quarter of 2015. When recording the cumulative catch-up entry in the fourth quarter of 2015, the Company will reflect this revenue on a cash basis.
Aggregate Income Statement Analysis: The overall impacts of the misstatements to the Company’s prior period’s consolidated income statements are as follows:
Table 1-Rollover
[***]
[***] Confidential Treatment Requested by Laureate Education, Inc. under 17 C.F.R. §§ 200.80(b)(4) and 200.83.
Table 2- Iron Curtain YTD 2015
Table 3 — Iron Curtain Q3 2015
The Company notes that certain of the percentages shown for 2013 appear high because the Company operated at close to a break-even level for that year.
Table 4
Income statement impact of misstatement (Rollover)
Aggregate Balance Sheet Analysis (Iron Curtain): The overall impacts of the misstatements to the Company’s prior periods’ consolidated balance sheets are as follows:
Table 5
Balance Sheet impacts of misstatements
Aggregate Statement of Cash Flows Analysis: As none of the identified misstatements impacted the reported amounts of cash and cash equivalents, and all of the adjustments net to a zero impact on the cash provided by (used in) operating activities, with no impact to any of the other sections of the statement of cash flows, the Company concludes that there are no material misstatements affecting the Statement of Cash Flows for any period presented.
Qualitative Analysis
With regard to qualitative factors, the Company performs the following analysis:
1. Whether the misstatement masks a change in earnings or other trends.
2. Whether the misstatement hides a failure to meet analysts’ consensus expectations for the enterprise.
3. Whether the misstatement changes a loss into income or vice versa.
The misstatements do not result in a change in earnings or other trends nor do they change any measure from income to loss or vice versa in any period presented in the analysis. Further, with respect to all misstatements, each of Revenues, Operating Income (Loss), Income (Loss) from Continuing Operations, Income Tax Expense (Benefit), Net Income (Loss) and Adjusted EBITDA display a trend that is not significantly impacted nor distorted by the errors. The graphs below show these trends for Revenues, Direct Costs and Adjusted EBITDA.
4. Whether the misstatement concerns a segment or other portion of the registrant’s business that has been identified as playing a significant role in the registrant’s operations or profitability.
The Company considered the impact of the misstatements on a segment basis and the misstatements do not change any individual segment measure trend or relationship with the other segments. Both misstatements identified occurred within significant operating segments and the misstatements, both individually and in the aggregate, are not significant quantitatively.
5. Whether the misstatement affects the registrant’s compliance with regulatory requirements.
The misstatements do not result in the Company’s non-compliance with any of the United States Department of Education rules and regulations or rules and regulations of any similar governmental authority in other jurisdictions.
6. Whether the misstatement affects the registrant’s compliance with loan covenants or other contractual requirements.
Given the small amount of the misstatements discussed above, the Company concludes that such errors do not impact its compliance with its debt covenants. Furthermore, the Company’s credit facilities do not have a maintenance covenant which, if not met, would trigger a default. Rather, the facilities have incurrence-based covenants that limit the amount of debt the Company can borrow on a prospective basis. In other words, the Company would be restricted from incurring additional debt (subject to a number of baskets) or making an acquisition until it has met the leverage ratios contained in the credit facility. The misstatements do not impact any of the key ratios that would have resulted in a covenant violation. Lastly, the interest rates under the credit facilities could escalate based on the extent that the Company’s leverage ratios exceed the prescribed limits. The interest rate under the credit facilities for the years 2012 through 2014 would not have changed had the Company recorded all the unadjusted misstatements.
7. Whether the misstatement has the effect of increasing management’s compensation — for example, by satisfying requirements for the award of bonuses or other forms of incentive compensation.
The Company believes that due to the small size of the misstatements in each of the periods presented, no material impact to incentive compensation occurred as a result of the misstatements.
8. Whether the misstatement is intentional and involves concealment of an unlawful transaction?
The Company does not believe that any of the unadjusted misstatements were an intentional action taken or involved the concealment of an unlawful transaction.
Overall Conclusion
The Company considered all the quantitative and qualitative factors described above and believes that none of the identified unadjusted misstatements is material to the fair presentation of any of its previously issued financial statements. The Company has reviewed this analysis with its Audit Committee, which concurred with management’s conclusion.