Form 10-K for the Year Ended December 31, 2023
We note that Central and Other is not listed as a reportable segment, rather it is defined as a category and appears to include intercompany and corporate functions as well as a business unit. As such, please tell us your consideration of the guidance in ASC 280-1050-1 through 50-5 for the identification of your operating segments and/or reportable segments.Rest of the question
Please note that if your Central and Other category is presented under ASC 280-10-50-15, it does not represent a reportable segment and should be excluded from the reportable segment total.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of Central and Other, we advise the Staff that because our internal management reporting, and the way our chief operating decision maker (CODM) regularly reviews the results of our business in order to make decisions about allocating resources and assessing performance, separately includes the results of Sunrise, Telenet, VM Ireland, Central and Other, the VMO2 JV and the VodafoneZiggo JV, our reportable segments must reflect the same presentation.Read in the replyRest of the answer
These reportable segments each have discrete financial information and either exceed the required quantitative thresholds or provide information we believe is separately useful to our investors. Our internal management reporting also separately reports the results of our Slovakian business, however due to its immateriality (less than 0.75% of each of revenue and Adjusted EBITDA) we simply include such amounts in our Central and Other segment.
Central and Other meets the criteria to be identified as a reportable segment included in paragraph 280-10-50-1 through 50-5, including engaging in business activities from which it recognizes third-party and related-party revenues and expenses related to services provided for network operations, technology, marketing, facilities, finance and sales of customer premises equipment and related support, all as described in the notes to our consolidated financial statements. Our strategy is to continue to commercialize these activities at scale to third parties, including entities we may spin-off in the future. Since the nature of the revenue generating activities of our fixed and mobile converged businesses differs from the nature of revenue generating activities within Central, we used different terminology to describe Central and Other. In light of the Staff’s comment, we believe this has caused confusion with the technical wording in ASC 280 with respect to a reportable segment versus an “all other” category, as defined by ASC 280. As such, prospectively, we will clearly indicate Central and Other is a reportable segment and group Central and Other in the same section as all other reportable segments. (See below for our proposed clarifying presentation).
As of June 30, 2024, our reportable segments are as follows:
Consolidated:
•Sunrise
•Telenet
•VM Ireland
•Central and Other
Nonconsolidated:
•VMO2 JV
•VodafoneZiggo JV
First report after the company's reply of Jun 5, 2024: 10-Q filed Jul 25, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note the presentation of Total Adjusted EBITDA in the reconciliation on page II-119 does not appear to comply with ASC 280-10-50-30(b) as the inclusion of Adjusted EBITDA for Central and Other in the total does not appear to represent the total of the reportable segments' measure of profit or loss.Rest of the question
As such, Total Adjusted EBITDA would represent a non-GAAP measure which is specifically prohibited in your financial statement footnotes by Item 10(e)(1)(ii)(c) of Regulation S-K. Furthermore, the total of your reportable segments’ measure of profit or loss should be reconciled to consolidated net income/(loss) before income taxes. Accordingly, please revise your presentation of your reportable segments’ measure of profit or loss and the accompanying reconciliation to comply with ASC 280-10-50-30(b). To this end, please reverse the order of the reconciliation such that you start with the total of your segment measure of profit or loss and reconcile to consolidated net income on a pre-tax basis.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of Total Adjusted EBITDA, we advise the Staff that because our internal management reporting, and therefore the way our CODM regularly reviews the results of our business in order to make decisions about allocating resources and assessing performance, includes Central and Other, our total segment Adjusted EBITDA appropriately represents the total of the segments as reported internally and viewed by management in compliance with ASC 280-10-50-30(b).Read in the replyRest of the answer
We believe we have complied with the segment disclosure requirements under Regulation S-K and ASC 280 in providing the required material disclosures for Central and Other. Further, we believe that in light of the reconciliation requirements and the net economics on the results of our consolidated businesses, it would be misleading not to include the immaterial eliminations in our presentation of total segment Adjusted EBITDA. That is, our internal management reporting only includes total segment Adjusted EBITDA post-eliminations. Thus, we interpreted the provisions of ASC 280-10-50-30(b) and ASC 280-10-50-22 to require disclosure of the total segment Adjusted EBITDA including eliminations, as that is the measure that our CODM reviews to assess performance. Additionally, we believe that having symmetry between the total segment Adjusted EBITDA in our financial statements and consolidated Adjusted EBITDA in our MD&A is consistent with how our business is evaluated by our CODM, as well as our analysts, and thus avoids investor confusion. Given we do not internally evaluate or report a total segment Adjusted EBITDA measure pre-eliminations, we interpreted the guidance under ASC 280 in such a manner that we should include these eliminations in our total segment Adjusted EBITDA measure, as showing a total amount pre-elimination introduces a measure we do not report or use internally. As indicated in our response to question 1, we advise the Staff that on a prospective basis we will more clearly label Central and Other as one of our reportable segments.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of the reconciliation of Total Adjusted EBITDA to net income on a pre-tax basis, we advise the Staff that we will prospectively revise the reconciliation and reverse the order of the reconciliation to start with the total of the segment performance measure and reconcile to consolidated net income on a pre-tax basis.
First report after the company's reply of Jun 5, 2024: 10-Q filed Jul 25, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We refer to your measure of Adjusted EBITDA less P&E additions. It is not clear to us how this measure provides any meaningful information for your investors. Please explain and tell us how you considered Questions 100.01 and 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding our measure of Adjusted EBITDA less P&E additions, we advise the Staff that we believe this measure provides meaningful information to our investors because it provides (i) a transparent view of Adjusted EBITDA that remains after deducting our capital spend, which we believe is important to take into account when evaluating the overall performance of our business given the magnitude and recurring nature of our capital intensive business, and (ii) a comparable view of our performance relative to our peers that use the same or similar measure.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Our internal management reporting includes Adjusted EBITDA less P&E additions measures for all our reportable segments and is used by our CODM and our board to (i) determine, in part, compensation of our employees, and (ii) assist in evaluating M&A transactions (we use multiples of Adjusted EBITDA less P&E additions in both determining acquisition and disposition valuations of businesses). Further, our analysts use this measure to evaluate our performance and that of our peers.
Our measure of Adjusted EBITDA less P&E additions does not exclude any normal, recurring, cash operating expenses necessary to operate our business and as such we believe our measure does not violate the principles in Question 100.01 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations, but rather includes such recurring operating expenses within our Adjusted EBITDA measure, from which we further deduct the as reported property and equipment additions (P&E additions) necessary to operate our business. We are not changing the pattern or recognition of these expenses as required by GAAP in any way and therefore we do not believe we are violating the principles in Question 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. We believe our approach is (i) transparent and well understood by our investors and analysts, (ii) is consistent with similar measures used by, and allows for comparability to, our peers, and (iii) provides important information to our investors with respect to the amount of Adjusted EBITDA that remains after deducting our as reported capital spend and therefore does not result in misleading information or an individually tailored accounting measure that violates the principles in Questions 100.01 and 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. As such, we believe reporting this measure to readers is essential to providing them with key information in the way we evaluate our business.
We refer to your measure of Distributable Cash Flow. We note that the measure adjusts for “Other affiliate dividends” which "are funded by activities outside of their normal course of operations." As it appears this adjustment may have the effect of changing recognition and measurement principles required to be applied under GAAP, please explain in detail the nature of and reasons for this adjustment and why it doesRest of the question
not result in the presentation of an individually tailored measure pursuant to Question 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding our measure of Distributable Cash Flow, we advise the staff that we have not tailored our metric in such a way to change the pattern of recognition or measurement principles required to be applied in accordance with GAAP and therefore are not violating the principles in Question 100.04 of the non-GAAP Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. Under U.S.Read in the replyRest of the answer
GAAP, distributions from affiliates are accounted for either as returns on capital when they are principally funded through cash generated in the normal course of operations (distributions are reflected as a cash flow from operating activity in the statement of cash flows) or as returns of capital when they are funded by cash generated outside the normal course of operations, for example, distributions funded by a recapitalization activity of the affiliate (distributions are reflected as a cash flow from investing activities in the statement of cash flows), each fundamentally based on their underlying nature. Our Distributable Cash Flow metric includes both of these actual cash returns by simply adding return of capital distributions, as reported separately within our cash flows from investing activities section of our statement of cash flows, to our Adjusted Free Cash Flow measure to provide the reader with a clear understanding of the total amount of distributions received from our affiliates. We believe our approach is (i) transparent and well understood by our investors and analysts, (ii) provides important information to our investors with respect to total amount of distributions received from our affiliates, and (iii) provides important information to our investors with respect to total cash available to service debt and fund new investment opportunities. We believe our approach does not result in a tailored measure that violates the principles of Question 100.04 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
If you should have any questions regarding our comments or require any further information regarding this matter, please contact the undersigned.
Please revise your disclosure to separately present each of revenues from external customers and revenues from transactions with other operating segments for each of your reportable segments. Refer to ASC 280-10-50-22(a) and (b). You disclose that you present 100% of the revenue and Adjusted EBITDA of VMO2 JV and VodafoneZiggo JV despite only holding a 50% noncontrolling interest in both.Rest of the question
Please revise your disclosure to clarify the differences between how amounts related to these reportable segments are measured in the consolidated financial statements as compared to the segment disclosures. See ASC 280-10-50-29(b) and (c). In this regard, please clarify whether: • These reportable segments are accounted for under the equity method in your consolidated financial statements; 2. • Financial information of each of these reportable segments is presented in the segment disclosures as if they were consolidated subsidiaries or some other basis; and • The financial information is prepared using the same accounting policies that are used in the Company’s consolidated financial statements or if they are different, and if different, describe those differences. 3. We note your response to prior comment 2. ASC 280-10-50-30(b) requires the total of the reportable segments’ measures of profit or loss be reconciled to the public entity’s consolidated income before income taxes and discontinued operations. Please revise your reconciliations to start with the total of the measures of profit or loss for all of your reportable segments. In this regard, we note your reconciliation does not include all reportable segments and does not include all eliminations, such as intersegment eliminations, that should be presented as reconciling items to arrive at consolidated income before income taxes rather than included in the starting point. See ASC 280-1050-31 and 280-10-55-49. Please similarly revise other required reconciliations, such as reportable segments’ revenues and assets, to start with the total of the reportable segments’ amounts. See ASC 280-10-50-30(a), (c), and (d).
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of revenues from external customers and revenues from transactions with other operating segments, we respectfully advise the Staff that we separately disclose the amount of revenue received from the VMO2 JV and the VodafoneZiggo JV, our non-consolidated reportable segments, in our investment note to our consolidated financial statements, and revenue derived from transactions with other consolidated reportable segments in our reconciliation of reportable segment amounts to our consolidated amounts within our segment disclosures.Read in the replyRest of the answer
In light of the Staff’s comment, we will prospectively make this disclosure clearer by including the specific disclosure of the revenue derived from consolidated reportable segments, non-consolidated reportable segments and external parties all within our segment note to our consolidated financial statements.
First report after the company's reply of Aug 5, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 29, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your responses to prior comments 1 to 3. Please provide us your proposed disclosures, including any changes you plan to make in MD&A.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of revenues from external customers and revenues from transactions with other operating segments, we respectfully advise the Staff that we separately disclose the amount of revenue received from the VMO2 JV and the VodafoneZiggo JV, our non-consolidated reportable segments, in our investment note to our consolidated financial statements, and revenue derived from transactions with other consolidated reportable segments in our reconciliation of reportable segment amounts to our consolidated amounts within our segment disclosures.Read in the replyRest of the answer
In light of the Staff’s comment, we will prospectively make this disclosure clearer by including the specific disclosure of the revenue derived from consolidated reportable segments, non-consolidated reportable segments and external parties all within our segment note to our consolidated financial statements.
Please see proposed disclosure in relation to our response to question 1 included within the proposed disclosure in question 2 below.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 6, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 29, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please revise the MD&A discussions of your reportable segment results so they are consistent with your footnote segment disclosures revised in accordance with ASC 280. Note 19. Segment Reporting, page II-116 We note your response to prior comment 1.Rest of the question
We also note the proposed disclosures present revenues that combines revenues from external customers and intersegment revenues prior to eliminating intersegment revenue. We continue to believe you should separately disclose revenues from external customers and revenues from 2. transactions with other operating segments, as required by ASC 280-10-50-22(a) and (b). Please revise or explain the basis for your presentation. 3. We note your proposed disclosure to prior comment 2. Please explain to us what you mean by "significant accounting policies of our reportable segments are principally the same" as those of Liberty Global. Tell us what "principally the same" means. Also, tell us how the accounting policies differ. 4. We note your response to prior comment 3. We continue to believe your proposed disclosure does not comply with ASC 280-10-50-30(b) that requires the total of the reportable segments’ measures of profit or loss be reconciled to the public entity’s consolidated income before income taxes and discontinued operations. Please revise your reconciliations to start with the total of the measures of profit or loss for all of your reportable segments. Please similarly revise other required reconciliations, such as reportable segments’ revenues and assets, to start with the total of the reportable segments’ amounts. See ASC 280-10-50-30(a), (c), and (d). If you do not agree, please explain the basis for your presentation.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the MD&A discussion of our reportable segment results, we respectfully advise the Staff that prospectively we will revise our MD&A discussion of our reportable segment results so they are consistent with our footnote segment disclosures and will include a discussion of our Central & Other segment.Read in the replyRest of the answer
We advise the Staff that page II-6 of our 2023 10-K includes a cross reference to the Discussion and Analysis of our Consolidated Operating Results — Share of results of affiliates, net, discussion on page II-21, where we include the discussion of our nonconsolidated JV reportable segments. Please see below proposed prospective disclosure for Central & Other.
Revenue of our Reportable Segments
Central and Other. On an organic basis, our Central and Other revenue decreased $146.7 million or 13.4% during 2023, as compared to 2022, primarily attributable to (i) a decrease in revenue earned from the U.K. JV Services and NL JV Services and (ii) lower revenue earned from the sale of CPE to the VodafoneZiggo JV.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 18, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 29, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 1, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment 4. We also note that "Total Reportable Segment" Adjusted EBITDA represents a required ASC 280 measure; however, please note that the measure on a total consolidated basis represents a non- GAAP measure and that Item 10(e)(1)(ii)(C) of Regulation S-K prohibits the presentation of non-GAAP measures in the financial statement footnotes.Rest of the question
If you plan to present such measure outside of your consolidated financial statements, please label it as a non-GAAP financial measure and ensure that your presentation and disclosures fully comply with non-GAAP rules, including Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K and the Non-GAAP C&DI's.
With respect to the Staff’s comment regarding the presentation of Adjusted EBITDA on a total consolidated basis, we respectfully advise the Staff that prospectively we will revise our financial statement segment footnote to exclude this measure on a total consolidated basis, as presented below. If we present this measure elsewhere outside of our financial statements, we will clearly label the measure as non-GAAP and ensure our disclosure and associated reconciliations comply with the non-GAAP rules as laid out in Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K and the non-GAAP C&DI’s.Read in the reply
If you should have anyRest of the answer
questions regarding our comments or require any further information regarding this matter, please contact the undersigned.
First report after the company's reply of Dec 16, 2024: 10-K filed Feb 18, 2025 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 15, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-12-17