The following is a discussion of the proposed transaction under Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) Topic ASC 805, Business Combinations, guided by applicable sections in ASC 805-10-55 paragraphs 10-15 with commentary in italics and concluding with the determination of Cyberonics as the accounting acquirer.
ASC 805-10-55-12 provides the following considerations for determining the accounting acquirer:
55-12 In a business combination effected primarily by exchanging equity interests, the acquirer
Rest of the answer
usually is the entity that issues its equity interests. However, in some business combinations, commonly called reverse acquisitions, the issuing entity is the acquiree. Subtopic 805-40 provides guidance on accounting for reverse acquisitions. Other pertinent facts and circumstances also shall be considered in identifying the acquirer in a business combination effected by exchanging equity interests, including the following:
a.
The relative voting rights in the combined entity after the business combination. The acquirer usually is the combining entity whose owners as a group retain or receive the largest portion of the voting rights in the combined entity. In determining which group of owners retains or receives the largest portion of the voting rights, an entity shall consider the existence of any unusual or special voting arrangements and options, warrants or convertible securities.
Cyberonics stockholders will receive approximately 54% of the shares of Holdco pursuant to the ultimate exchange ratio, which has been determined, thereby granting Cyberonics the largest portion of voting rights in Holdco. Unusual or special voting arrangements and options, warrants, and convertible securities do not apply. Accordingly, the parties believe that this fact pattern supports the identification of Cyberonics as the accounting acquirer.
b.
The existence of a large minority voting interest in the combined entity if no other owner or organized group of owners has a significant voting interest. The acquirer usually is the combining entity whose single owner or organized group of owners holds the largest minority voting interest in the combined entity.
Cyberonics’s largest stockholder will hold approximately 5.5% of the voting interest in Holdco and will not have any special shareholders’ rights or representation on the board of Holdco. Sorin’s two largest shareholders, which are under common control, will hold approximately 11.7% of the voting interest in Holdco, and the two indirect owners of those shareholders each obtained and exercised the right to designate one of the four allotted seats on the board of Holdco that Sorin will have the right to designate. However, this right does not alter the 4-4-1 composition of the board of Holdco that is discussed further below. Neither these Sorin shareholders nor their indirect owners will have any special shareholders’ rights after closing with respect to Holdco or the Holdco board. Accordingly, the parties do not believe that this fact pattern decisively supports the identification of either Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer.
c.
The composition of the governing body of the combined entity. The acquirer usually is the combining entity whose owners have the ability to elect or appoint or to remove a majority of the members of the governing body of the combined entity.
The board of Holdco will consist of nine directors, consisting of four directors designated by
Cyberonics, four directors designated by Sorin, and one member mutually agreed to by Cyberonics and Sorin. The preliminary structure contemplates that this division of the right to designate the Holdco directors will remain in place for approximately eighteen to twenty-one months. The term of the current Holdco directors and the subsequent election / appointment process for the future terms of Holdco directors have yet to be decided. However, the parties do not expect that either former Cyberonics stockholders or former Sorin shareholders will receive special or preferential rights to appoint Holdco directors, or that there will be any tie-breaking privileges. In addition, if a Holdco director were to resign from the board of Holdco during the initial period, then the original party that designated the director would be entitled to replace that director with a person of its designation. If the neutral director were to resign from the board of Holdco, then a new independent director would be designated by representatives of the parties.
The role of the individual Holdco directors and their committee assignments have not yet been decided, except that the Chair of the Audit Committee and the Compensation Committee will be designated from among the Holdco directors to be designated by Cyberonics, as discussed in the Amended Registration
Statement. While Cyberonics will designate the chair of the board of Holdco, who will be the current chief executive officer of Cyberonics, the intention of the parties is to create equal representation of Cyberonics and Sorin on the board of Holdco and to have that structure remain in place for more than two years. Accordingly, the parties do not believe that this fact pattern decisively supports the identification of either Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer.
d.
The composition of the senior management of the combined entity. The acquirer usually is the combining entity whose former senior management dominates the management of the combined entity.
The chief executive officer of Holdco will be the current chief executive officer of Sorin. In addition, the combined business will be organized into three business units and an Intercontinental group. The two legacy Sorin business units (Cardiac Surgery and Cardiac Rhythm Management) and the Intercontinental group will be led by current Sorin employees, while a Cyberonics employee will lead the third business unit (Neuromodulation). In addition, Sorin employees will have three of the four positions on the combined business’s executive leadership team, with Cyberonics having one position. Sorin and Cyberonics have also begun a joint search for the chief financial officer of the combined business, with Cyberonics’ chief financial officer serving as interim chief financial officer should the position not be filled prior to closing. Finally, as discussed above, the chair of the board of Holdco will be the current chief executive officer of Cyberonics.
While there is some weighting towards
Sorin senior management attributable to the legacy business units of each company, the parties do not believe that the fact pattern described above supports the guidance that former Sorin senior management “dominates” the management of the combined business. Accordingly, the parties do not believe that this fact pattern decisively supports the identification of either Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer.
e.
The terms of the exchange of equity interests. The acquirer usually is the combining entity that pays a premium over the precombination fair value of the equity interests of the other combining entity or entities.
For Sorin shareholders, the exchange ratio implies a per share valuation of Sorin that represents approximately 14.2 percent premium to Sorin’s closing share price on February 25, 2015, the last trading day prior to the public announcement of Sorin and Cyberonics entering into the letter of intent. Accordingly, the parties believe that the exchange ratio, which results in the payment of a premium to Sorin shareholders, supports the identification of Cyberonics as the accounting acquirer.
Discussion of ASC 805 – Additional Considerations
As a final part of the parties’ overall analysis, the parties note that ASC 805 provides for additional considerations when determining the accounting acquirer in ASC 805-10-55-13 through 55-14. These considerations are as follows:
55-13 The acquirer usually is the combining entity whose relative size (measured in, for example, assets, revenues or earnings) is significantly larger than that of the other combining entity or entities.
Sorin is significantly larger than Cyberonics with respect to revenues and assets in the historical periods. However, Cyberonics has a greater market capitalization, free cash flow, profit before tax and net income when the financial statements for both companies are placed on a US GAAP basis. Neither entity has convertible securities that would influence the manner in which market capitalization is computed, which is calculated on a fully diluted basis assuming all stock awards currently outstanding vest. Accordingly, the parties do not believe that this fact pattern decisively supports the identification of either
Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer.
55-14 In a business combination involving more than two entities, determining the acquirer shall include a consideration of, among other things, which of the combining entities initiated the combination, as well as the relative size of the combining entities, as discussed in the preceding paragraph.
In connection with its consideration of a potential joint venture, Cyberonics and its financial advisor identified Sorin as a potential joint venture partner in mid-2013, and Cyberonics’ financial advisor facilitated a meeting in July 2014 between Cyberonics and Sorin to discuss a joint venture between the two parties. During the course of discussions between the parties that followed this initial meeting, the parties determined that it was in their respective best interests to explore the possibility of a business combination between the two parties. While Cyberonics’ financial advisor did initiate the discussions with Sorin, the parties do not believe it is clear that Cyberonics “initiated the combination” because the discussions from the initial meeting forward were bilateral and collaborative. Accordingly, the parties do not believe that this fact pattern decisively supports the identification of either Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer.
Conclusion
FASB ASC Topic 805-10-55 paragraphs 10 through 15 provide guidance on identifying the acquirer in a business combination. An analysis of this guidance relative to the specific facts and circumstances of the business combination results in the parties’ determination that Cyberonics is appropriately identified as the accounting acquirer. Facts in support of this determination are:
• the larger portion of the voting rights to be held by the former Cyberonics stockholders, which is approximately 54%; and the payment of an approximate 14.2% premium to the Sorin shareholders as a result of the exchange ratio.
While the parties do not believe that the other indicators set forth in ASC 805 decisively support the identification of either Cyberonics or Sorin as the accounting acquirer, the parties’ determination of Cyberonics as the accounting acquirer was based on the collective weight of all the evidence. The parties believe that the indicators pointing to Cyberonics as the accounting acquirer outweigh those potentially pointing to Sorin.
Due to the judgment necessary in reaching this conclusion and to provide the reader with additional insight into the parties’ judgment, we have revised the above-referenced disclosure on page 91.