Arkhouse Management Co. LP · Macy's, Inc. · Soliciting Materials filed pursuant to Rule 14a-12 by Arkhouse Management Co. LP et al. · Filed February 20, 2024 · File No. 001-13536
In written soliciting materials used before a proxy statement is furnished, Rule 14a12(a)(1)(i) requires the soliciting party to include a description of each participant’s direct and indirect interests in the solicitation, or a legend advising where that information can be found. Such interests are not limited to the participant’s share ownership in the registrant.Rest of the question
See the last sentence of CDI 132.03 under Proxy Rules and Schedules 14A/14C Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (November 17, 2023). In future soliciting materials filed pursuant to Rule 14a-12, please include disclosure about the fact that Arkhouse Management recently made a proposal to acquire Macy’s, which was rejected.
No reply letter found.
We note that your preliminary proxy statement was filed under EDGAR tag "PRE 14A," as opposed to EDGAR tag "PREC14A," the latter of which should be used for contested solicitations. Please keep this in mind for future reference, and please ensure that subsequent filings are filed under the correct EDGAR tag.
No reply letter found.
We note your reference to Jefferies' materials at a virtual meeting on December 19 reflecting a "proposed common equity contribution of only 25% of the required capital." However, Arkhouse's preliminary proxy statement (page 4) refers to that same presentation showing a 50% equity financing figure. Please advise or revise. Summary of other Material Terms of the 2024 Plan, page 70
No reply letter found.
Refer to the last bullet on page 73 summarizing the 2024 Plan's definition of "change in control." Please revise to include the description from the 2024 Plan referenced in this bullet, summarizing as may be appropriate.
No reply letter found.
We note a number of blanks throughout this section, such as on pages 86, 88, 92-93, 101, 106-107, and 1127-117. Please fill in the blanks (information subject to change may be bracketed).
No reply letter found.
Please disclose the impact that a change in control could have on the Company as a result of this proxy contest, including with regards to the Company's material agreements and compensation plans (including the 2024 Plan).
No reply letter found.
State the deadline for timely notice of a solicitation of proxies in support of director nominees by someone other than the Company. See Rule 14a-5(e)(4). In addition, to the extent the Company's advance notice bylaw provisions do not require the same information as Rule 14a-19, revise to include a statement that any dissident party must also comply with the information requirements of Rule 14a-19(b).Rest of the question
See also, CDI 139.03 under "Proxy Rules and Schedule 14A" (August 25, 2022).
No reply letter found.
Please revise to fill in the date of the scheduled annual meeting, consistent with the disclosure throughout your preliminary proxy statement.
No reply letter found.
Please revise to disclose the maximum number of nominees for which authority can be granted. Refer to Rule 14a-19(e)(6).
No reply letter found.
We note your reference to Jefferies' materials at a virtual meeting on December 19 "that reflected 50% equity financing for the Acquisition Proposal." However, the Company’s preliminary proxy statement (page 12) states that the Jeffries' materials reflected a proposed common equity contribution of only 25% of required capital. Please advise or revise.Rest of the question
If I vote for the Arkhouse Nominees, am I agreeing to a transaction between the Company and Arkhouse?, page 19
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it is electronically transmitting the Amended Preliminary Proxy for filing under EDGAR tag “PREC14A,” concurrently with the delivery of this response letter.Read in the reply
Clarify whether, if elected, the Arkhouse Nominees will advocate for an "auction process" or other method of identifying other potential buyers for the Company, in addition to advocating for substantive engagement with respect to the Acquisition Proposal. The current reference to a "strategic review process for the Company" is unclear. How do proxies work?, page 20
The Company respectfully advises the Staff that Arkhouse’s 50% equity financing figure treats debt-like preferred securities as “equity,” whereas our figure more accurately differentiates between true-risk equity (i.e., common stock) and debt-like preferred equity. In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company has included revised disclosure on page 12 of the Amended Preliminary Proxy.Read in the reply
Refer to the following disclosure which appears in multiple places throughout the proxy statement, including on the form of proxy card: "IF YOU RETURN A VALID BLUE UNIVERSAL PROXY CARD OR BLUE VOTING INSTRUCTION FORM AND DO NOT MARK A VOTE WITH RESPECT TO ANY NOMINEE ON PROPOSAL 1, THE SHARES OF COMMON STOCK REPRESENTED THEREBY WILL BE VOTED “FOR” THE ELECTION OF EACH OF THE NINE ARKHOUSE NOMINEES, “WITHHOLD” ON THERest of the question
ELECTION OF THE OPPOSED COMPANY NOMINEES (I.E. [·], [·], [·], [·], [·], [·], [·], [·] and [·]), AND “WITHHOLD” ON THE ELECTION OF THE ACCEPTABLE COMPANY NOMINEES (I.E. [·], [·], [·], [·] AND [·])." Please revise to clarify that you are referring to a scenario where a shareholder returns a signed proxy card but does not vote for one single director nominee (versus a situation where the shareholder votes for some but fewer than fourteen nominees which is addressed in the last paragraph on page 20). The word "ANY" as used above is unclear in this regard. Please make corresponding changes to clarify throughout the proxy statement and on the proxy card. In this regard, the disclosure in the third from the last paragraph on page 30 is much clearer on this point.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on pages 73-74 of the Amended Preliminary Proxy summarizing the 2024 Plan’s definition of “change in control.”Read in the reply
State here that directors will be elected by a plurality vote, as noted on page 22.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on pages 86-88, 94, 101, 108, 119, 120, 124, 125 and certain other pages of the Amended Preliminary Proxy to fill-in blanks with respect to information previously unavailable or subject to change.Read in the reply
Revise the title of this proposal, consistent with the title on the form of proxy you filed, to reflect that it relates to the election of directors, which may include Company nominees in addition to the Arkhouse Nominees.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on pages 118-119 of the Amended Preliminary Proxy.Read in the reply
Expand to identify all of the director election candidates, including the Acceptable and the Opposed Company Nominees. Explain why you characterize some of the Company nominees as "acceptable" but are not recommending that shareholders vote for those nominees and why you are opposing certain other Company nominees.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on page 134 of the Amended Preliminary Proxy regarding the deadline for timely notice of a solicitation of proxies in support of director nominees by someone other than the Company and compliance with the information requirements of Rule 14a-19. We also respectfully advise the Staff that our advance notice bylaw provisions require the same information as Rule 14a-19.Read in the reply
See our last comment above. For both the Acceptable Company Nominees and the Opposed Company Nominees, you are recommending a "WITHHOLD" vote. Therefore, revise to explain the difference between the two groups, from Arkhouse's perspective and explain why you term certain nominees "acceptable" but are not recommending shareholders vote "FOR" those nominees.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on the form of proxy appended to the Amended Preliminary Proxy to reflect the date of the scheduled meeting.Read in the reply
Refer to the following disclosure on page 26 of the proxy statement: "We further reserve the right to (i) withdraw any or all of the Arkhouse Nominees and/or (ii) nominate fewer than all of the Arkhouse Nominees listed herein and/or to re-designate one or more of such individuals as alternate nominees." Clarify the effect of "re-designating" someone as an "alternate nominee" in this context, including by explainingRest of the question
when and under what circumstances an alternate would or could serve. Similarly, describe the circumstances under which you might withdraw one or all of the Arkhouse Nominees.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that it has included revised disclosure on the form of proxy appended to the Amended Preliminary Proxy to reflect that the maximum number of nominees for which authority can be granted is 13.Read in the reply
* * *
If you would like to discuss any of the responses to the Staff’s comments or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact David A. Katz or Elina Tetelbaum of Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz at (212) 403-1000.
Please update this section generally to reflect the fact that the Company has now filed its proxy statement.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
Please fill in the blanks throughout the proxy statement, including with respect to the identity of the Acceptable Nominees. Information that is subject to change may be bracketed to reflect this fact.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
All materials identified in the Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials must be available at a specified website address that may not be the address of the Commission's electronic filing system. See Rule 14a-16(b)(3). Please revise generally throughout the proxy statement to provide your own website address where shareholders may access your proxy materials.Rest of the question
See for example, page vi under "Important Notice Regarding the
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
Please include clear and easily readable versions of your exhibits, as they are generally not legible. See Rule 12b-12(b).
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
In your next filing, please address the Company’s proposal to approve the Macy’s, Inc. 2024 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan. If you decide not to include this proposal on your card, you must revise your proxy statement to describe it and note that shareholders voting on your blue card will be disenfranchised with respect to this matter.Rest of the question
If you choose to include it, please revise your preliminary proxy card and proxy statement accordingly.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
Where you refer shareholders to the Company's proxy statement for information about its nominees, note that that document may be accessed without cost at the Commission's Web site. See Item 7(f) of Schedule 14A.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
Please disclose the impact that a change in control could have on the Company as a result of this proxy contest, including with regards to the Company's material agreements and compensation in plans (including the 2024 Plan).
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
See our comments above. We continue to believe that labeling a group of director candidates as "Acceptable Company Nominees" without recommending that shareholders vote "FOR" such nominees may cause shareholder confusion.
No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗
We note your response to prior comment 11. Please note that the comment also applies to the form of proxy, which still refers to the address of the Commission's electronic filing system.
No reply letter found.
Refer to comment 6 in our prior letter and your response. We continue to believe that the names of the Opposed and Other Company Nominees must be included in a revised preliminary proxy statement. Please identify those individuals in a revised preliminary filing.
No reply letter found.
Refer to your disclosure about the execution of the Confidentiality Agreement on March 19, 2024. It has come to our attention that in connection with the execution of that agreement, the Company made due diligence materials available for your review in accordance with the Confidentiality Agreement, which materials have been accessed by your representatives. Please revise your disclosure accordingly, or advise.
No reply letter found.