Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2023
Please address the following regarding your automobile insurance loss development and payment tables: • Tell us whether these tables include both your personal and commercial automobile lines and represent to us that you will revise your disclosure in future filings to clarify. Otherwise, tell us where you make this disclosure in your filing.Rest of the question
• Tell us your consideration for disaggregating bodily injury from material damage coverage in your tables. In this regard, we note that the majority of your 2023 direct written premium is private passenger automobile lines and we further note your disclosure in the last paragraph on page 65 that time can be a critical part of reserving determinations since the longer the span between the loss event and the settlement of the claim, the more variable the ultimate settlement amount could be and that shorttail claims, such as property damage claims, tend to be more reasonably predictable than long-tail claims, such as those involving bodily injury coverages. In addition, we note the requirement in ASC 944-40-50-4H to not aggregate items that have significantly different characteristics. In your response, provide us the information that would be provided in separate tables for automobile bodily injury coverage and automobile material damages coverage, if available. If not available, tell us why it is not available given your ability to identify the percentage of total reserves attributed to bodily injury versus material damages coverages as disclosed on page 37.
to your first comment, our automobile insurance loss development and payment tables include both personal and commercial automobile lines. We will revise our disclosure in our future filings to make this clear by replacing “Automobile Insurance” in these tables with “Personal and Commercial Automobile Insurance.”Read in the reply
In response to your second comment, as noted on page 37 of our 2023 10-K, loss development on material damage reserves is generally insignificant because material damage claims are generally settled in a shorter period than bodily injury claims.Rest of the answer
However, the underlying loss frequency and loss severity trends, which are contributors to loss development, for material damage claims directionally follow those of bodily injury claims and the Company evaluates and manages its automobile business for all coverages combined, not on a disaggregated basis. In addition, as you point out in your comment, the percentage of total automobile reserves attributable to bodily injury claims, material damages, and loss adjustment expenses is approximately 70%, 10%, and 20%, respectively. In the context of total company reserves (rather than just automobile reserves alone), bodily injury, material damage and loss adjustment expense reserves are 50%, 5% and 12%, respectively. Given the relative insignificance of material damage reserves, the fact that the underlying drivers of development
(loss frequency and loss severity) trend directionally in the same way as bodily injury losses do, and that the Company evaluates and manages the automobile business based on all coverages combined, we believe that disaggregation would not be meaningful or material in the context of our overall reserves and our consolidated financial statements. We also considered guidance in ASC
944-40-55-9B, which states:
“When selecting the type of category to use to aggregate or disaggregate disclosures, an insurance entity should consider how information about the insurance entity’s liability for unpaid claims and claim adjustment expenses has been presented for other purposes, including all of the following:
a. Disclosures presented outside the financial statements (for example, in earnings releases, annual reports, statutory filings, or investor presentations) b. Information regularly viewed by the chief operating decision maker for evaluating financial performance c. Other information that is similar to the types of information identified in (a) and (b) and that is used by the insurance entity or users of the insurance entity’s financial statements to evaluate the insurance entity’s financial performance or make resource allocation decisions.”
We manage the private passenger and commercial automobile business lines at a business line level, and business decisions are made based on evaluation of the financial performance of each business line as a whole, rather than coverage level components of each business line. Further, disclosures of bodily injury and material damage claims are not presented outside the financial statements. As a result of these factors, we do not believe that presenting separate tables for bodily injury coverage and material damage coverage for private passenger and commercial automobile lines would provide meaningful information to readers of the financial statements to understand the amount, timing, and uncertainty of cash flows arising from our loss reserves.
The data required for presenting separate tables detailing ten years of historical information at points in time for all periods shown for separate incurred and paid loss and loss adjustment expense development tables as well as separate incurred loss duration distributions for automobile bodily injury coverage and automobile material damage coverage are not readily available. Extracting such detailed data needed for those tables from our system for the past 10 years would require a large undertaking and extensive time and effort, and obtaining such data at a reasonable time and cost would be impractical given its immateriality. We believe presenting the tables at private passenger and commercial automobile level is more meaningful for the reasons noted above.
First report after the company's reply of Jul 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jul 30, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Apr 30, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note that in addition to your automobile insurance loss development and payment tables you provide separate tables for your homeowners insurance line. Please tell us why you do not provide tables for any of your other insurance lines and reference for us the authoritative literature you rely upon to support your position.Rest of the question
In this regard, we note that your tables present: • About $59.1 million in favorable development ($34.5 million for automobile and $24.6 million for homeowners) in 2023 while your reserve rollforward on page 85 depicts consolidated favorable development of only $35.9 million. Although you disclose on page 85 that you experienced private passenger automobile and homeowner lines losses partially offset by unfavorable development in the commercial property line, the aggregate $23.2 million unfavorable difference between the total presented in the tables and the reserve rollforward appears significant to the overall $175.4 million net reserve at January 1, 2023 for all other short-duration lines and on the surface does not appear insignificant to an understanding of your business as contemplated in ASC 944-40-50-4H. • About $81.8 million in unfavorable development ($80.3 million for automobile and $1.5 million for homeowners) in 2022 while your reserve rollforward on page 85 depicts consolidated unfavorable development of only $47.3 million. Although you disclose on page 85 that the $47.3 million unfavorable development primarily relates to the automobile line, the aggregate $34.5 million favorable difference between the total presented in the tables and the reserve rollforward appears significant to the overall $148.4 million net reserve at January 1, 2022 for all other short-duration lines and on the surface does not appear insignificant to an understanding of your business as contemplated in ASC 944-40-50-4H. In addition, tell us your consideration for separately disclosing the existence and cause of the apparent $34.5 million in favorable development, and tell us the breakout of the $47.3 million of unfavorable development between the private passenger and commercial automobile components.
to your comment on disclosing separately the existence and cause of the $34.5 million in favorable development, we generally disclose overall loss development including unallocated loss adjustment expense reserves as part of explaining the changes in loss ratios year over year in the management’s discussion and analysis section of our periodic filings with the SEC.Read in the replyRest of the answer
However, given that the incurred and paid loss development tables referenced in this comment letter do not include unallocated loss adjustment expenses, we will disclose in future filings the existence of unallocated loss adjustment expense reserves and related reserve development not included in the tables, as well as any material loss reserves and loss development in any lines of insurance that are not disclosed in separate tables along with reasons for material loss development, in the same note to the financial statements that contains separate incurred and paid loss development tables to provide readers with additional useful and clarifying information.
In response to your comment on the breakout of the $47.3 million of unfavorable development in 2022 between the private passenger and commercial automobile components, our private passenger automobile insurance line experienced unfavorable development of approximately $44 million in 2022 and our commercial automobile insurance line experienced unfavorable development of approximately $4 million in the same year.
First report after the company's reply of Jul 2, 2024: 10-Q filed Jul 30, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Apr 30, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-08-19