Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001161728 /10-K filed Feb 24, 2026, compared with Feb 25, 2025 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
Nasdaq Utilities · Electric, Gas & Sanitary Services

MGE Energy Inc MGEE

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

5 reviews of MGEE's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 5 latest letter Sep 7, 2022
Questions asked 24 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 0 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 7 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 24 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 7 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 5 of 5 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 41 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year ended December 31, 2021

2022-09-07 to 2022-09-23 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2022-09-23
Non-GAAP measuresSegmentsResults discussion (MD&A)
Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Results of Operations, page 37
SEC asked
We note that you identify electric margin and gas margin as non-GAAP measures on page 37, tabulate their composition on page 38, and provide discussions and analyses of changes in these metrics on pages 39 and 40.
Rest of the question

Please revise your disclosures to reconcile these non-GAAP measures individually to the most directly comparable GAAP-based measures, which we believe would be the segment GAAP measures of gross margin, to comply with Item 10(e)(1)(i)(B) of Regulation S-K. Also provide comparable tabulations and narratives, having equal or greater prominence on the GAAP measures of gross margin, to comply with Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K. Please submit the revisions that you propose to address these concerns. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

MGEE answered
We have considered the Staff's comment and, for the reasons that follow, we will remove the discussion of electric margin and gas margin in Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, beginning with our quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2022.

We presented electric and gas margins as we believe they provide a meaningful basis for evaluating and managing electric and gas utility operations since fuel for electric generation, purchase power costs, and cost of gas sold are passed through without mark-up to customers in
Rest of the answer

current rates. We note that other utility companies use similar measures and presentations.

We also believe operating income is the most directly comparable non-GAAP measure for reconciliation of electric margin and gas margin since our regulated utility business make up the majority of our operations. We do not present gross margin in our financial statements as gross margin is not a relevant metric for our industry.

Rather than reconcile to a financial measure that does not appear in our financial statements and is not used in our industry, we will remove the discussion of electric margin and gas margin in our Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, beginning with the Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2022.

* * * * *

We hereby acknowledge we are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of the disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.

If you would like to discuss our response to the Staff's comment or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7238. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by email, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Sep 13, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 3, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 4, 2022 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2022-09-23

MGE Energy, Inc. · Forms 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2015 · Filed February 25, 2016 · File No. 0-49965 and 0-1125

2016-07-25 to 2016-08-18 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2016-08-18
Liquidity and cashLegal and contingencies
Note 18. Commitments and Contingencies · d. Legal Matters – MGE Energy and MGE, page 98
SEC asked
We note your disclosure that you are involved in various legal matters, that you maintain accruals for such litigation that are probable and reasonably estimable and that the accruals are not material. Please tell us and disclose in future filings whether litigation losses are expected to have a material impact on income, financial position or cash flows and/or disclose the range of reasonably possible losses.
Rest of the question

Please refer to ASC 450-20-50-3 and 4.

MGEE answered
The statements noted in the staff's comment refer to claims being defended and handled in the normal course of business. None of these items, either individually or in the aggregate, are expected to have a material effect on our consolidated results of operations, financial condition, or cash flows. Unless that assessment changes, we will include the following statement in our discussion of these items in our future filings: "MGE does not expect the resolution of these matters to have a material adverse effect on its consolidated results of operations, financial condition, or cash flows."

*
Rest of the answer

* * * *

We hereby acknowledge:

·

We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and

We may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you would like to discuss our response to the staff's comments or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7149. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by email, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2016-08-18

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2011

2012-08-14 to 2012-11-09 · 3 questions · 3 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
Review closed 2012-11-09
Legal and contingenciesResults discussion (MD&A)Executive pay
SEC asked
Commitments and Contingencies, page 92 Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation, page 98 1. Refer to the disclosure in your filing related to the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation where you state “[a]t this time, MGE is unable to predict with certainty the impact of these claims on its financial condition or results of operations but believes that should there ultimately be an adverse outcome, it could have a significant
Rest of the question

effect.” Please note that when a loss contingency exists, ASC 450-20-25-1 contemplates an assessment as to whether the loss is probable, reasonably possible or remote. In light of the existence of a loss contingency for this matter, please tell us what consideration you gave to making such assessment as to the likelihood of where the loss falls. Alternatively, please make the required assessment for this loss contingency, describe to us the basis for your conclusion, and provide us with any proposed revised disclosures related to each current loss contingency. 2. Refer to your Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation disclosure where you state, “[t]he parties are exploring possible settlement.” Tell us if you held settlement talks with either the EPA or the Sierra Club. If so, then explain in detail the status of the settlement talks and any proposed settlement amount(s); including any counter-offer(s) made by you. Lastly, tell us if you have reserved for this matter. If not, then explain why you have not made an accrual in light of the settlement options you disclose. h. Other Legal Matters - MGE Energy and MGE, page 98 3. We note your disclosure of various other legal matters and your statement, “[m]GE has accrued for such matters in the financial statements.” Tell us and disclose the amount(s) of your accrual for these matters. Further revise your disclosure by providing in aggregate an estimated reasonably possible range of loss for these matters, if any, in excess of the accrual to the extent they are material. Executive Compensation, page 15 Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 15 4. Please disclose the information required by Item 402(b)(1)(vii) of Regulation S-K. Compensation/Benefits Structure, page 18 Base Salaries, page 20 5. Please disclose the factors that you considered to increase your named executive officers’ base salaries from fiscal 2010 to fiscal 2011. See Item 402(b)(2)(ix) of Regulation S-K. Short-Term Incentive, page 20 6. Please explain how achievement of the metric-specific targets, the other corporate goals, and the individual performance goals resulted in the amounts paid to each named executive officer, as disclosed in the “Bonus” column of the Summary Compensation Table. Please also disclose the size of the incentive pool for 2011 and 2010 and explain the reasons for any material increase in the size of such pool. Summary of Short-Term Incentive Payouts, page 21 7. In addition to disclosing the actual payout as a percentage of maximum opportunity, please also disclose the actual payout as a percentage of target level performance. 2011 Grants of Plan-Based Awards Table 8. Given that the performance units are settled in cash and no shares of stock are issued pursuant to the awards, please provide us with your analysis for why awards under the Performance Unit Plan are classified as stock awards in the Summary Compensation Table and as equity incentive plan awards in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards and Outstanding Equity Awards Tables. We also note that in response to Item 12 of Form 10-K, you stated that you do not have or maintain any equity compensation plans. Please cite to relevant authority in your response. Please also explain to us how the awards will be settled in cash. Please also tell us if settlement will occur at the same time as the vesting of the awards.

MGEE answered
In accordance with ASC 450-20-25-1, we evaluate our loss contingencies at least quarterly to determine whether it is probable that a loss has been incurred and, if so, whether the amount of that loss can be reasonably estimated. These quarterly assessments are made by our General Counsel and our Chief Financial Officer. Our General Counsel reviews pending matters with applicable external counsel for the purpose of assessing any claims and potential liabilities, including facts and available defenses.
Rest of the answer

Our Chief Financial Officer assesses that information in consultation with our internal accounting personnel in light of applicable accounting requirements. Our General Counsel also consulted with the other owners of the generating plant that is the subject of the Columbia Clean Air Litigation regarding their assessment of that litigation and the related claims.

In the case of the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation, we performed the above-described assessment as to whether a liability was probable. We determined that a loss was probable and then sought to arrive at a reasonable estimate of that loss—ultimately recording the lower end of a range of possible loss. As described in the final paragraph under "Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation" in Footnote 18.g. on page 98 of our Annual Report on Form 10-K, we examined the remedies that had been awarded in similar proceedings to assess the range of possible loss. That paragraph provides:

In response to similar EPA CAA enforcement initiatives, certain utilities have elected to settle with the EPA, while others have elected to litigate. If the EPA and/or Sierra Club successfully prove their claims that projects completed in the past at Columbia required either state or federal CAA permits, MGE may, under the applicable statutes, be required to pay civil penalties in amounts up to $37,500 per day for each violation and/or complete actions for injunctive relief. Payment of fines and/or injunctive relief could be included in a settlement outcome. Injunctive relief contained in settlements or court-ordered remedies for other utilities in similar matters required the installation of pollution control technology, changed operating conditions (including the use of alternative fuels other than coal), surrender of excess emission trading allowances, caps for emissions and limitations on generation (including retirement of generating units) and other beneficial environmental projects. If similar remedies are required for final resolution of these matters at Columbia, MGE would likely incur additional capital and operating expenditures. At this time, MGE is unable to predict with certainty the impact of these claims on its financial condition or results of operations but believes that should there ultimately be an adverse outcome, it could have a significant effect.

We recorded an accrual at December 31, 2011, representing our best estimate of the lower end of the range of our potential liability based upon the information known to us at that time.

The existence of that accrual was intended to be covered primarily by the statement in Footnote 18.h, "Other Legal Matters – MGE Energy and MGE," on page 98, which provides: "MGE maintains accruals for such costs that are probable of being incurred and subject to reasonable estimation. MGE has accrued for such legal matters in the financial statements." In future filings, we will make clearer the connection between the description of a loss contingency, the existence in the financial statements of an accrual for that matter, and the manner in which that accrual was determined.

Finally, the quoted sentence in the Staff's comment above (the last sentence of the above-quoted paragraph) was intended to express our uncertainty as to the final impact of the matter due to the difficulty we experienced in estimating the upper end of the range of reasonably possible loss based on what we had observed as possible remedies in prior similar proceedings. We will clarify that intent in future filings.

2. Refer to your Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation disclosure where you state, "[t]he parties are exploring possible settlement." Tell us if you held settlement talks with either the EPA or the Sierra Club. If so, then explain in detail the status of the settlement talks and any proposed settlement amount(s); including any counter-offer(s) made by you. Lastly, tell us if you have reserved for this matter. If not, then explain why you have not made an accrual in light of the settlement options you disclose.

Response: We have held settlement talks with both the EPA and Sierra Club. The status of those talks, and the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation, were updated in Footnote 8.a., "Environmental – MGE Energy and MGE," under the caption "Columbia – Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation" on pages 19 to 20 of our Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2012. That update includes the following paragraphs:

MGE believes that the parties have reached a tentative agreement on the general terms of a settlement with the EPA and Sierra Club regarding the various facilities, including Columbia. The Sierra Club has stipulated to dismissal of the lawsuit, without prejudice, while the parties attempt to reach a final settlement. The parties are currently negotiating a consent decree based upon those general terms, which may change during the negotiations. Based on a review of existing EPA consent decrees, the final consent decree could include the installation of emission control technology, changed operating conditions (including use of fuels other than coal and retirement of units), limitations on emissions, beneficial environmental mitigation projects, and a civil penalty.

Once the parties agree to the final terms, the Court must approve the settlement agreement. MGE cannot predict the outcome of these claims, but believes the outcome could be significant if the parties are unable to reach final agreement, or reach final agreement on different terms than currently anticipated, or if the Court does not approve the final settlement agreement and should there ultimately be an adverse outcome.

As noted in response to comment no. 1, MGE had recorded an accrual for the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation at December 31, 2011. This accrual was adjusted at June 30, 2012, based on the facts described in the quoted paragraphs from our June 30, 2012, Form 10-Q report. Neither the accrual at December 31, 2011, nor the adjusted accrual at June 30, 2012, was material to our financial statements. We will clarify that point in our future filings.

h. Other Legal Matters – MGE Energy and MGE, page 98

3. We note your disclosure of various other legal matters and your statement, "[m]GE has accrued for such matters in the financial statements." Tell us and disclose the amount(s) of your accrual for these matters. Further revise your disclosure by providing in aggregate an estimated reasonably possible range of loss for these matters, if any, in excess of the accrual to the extent they are material.

Response: As noted in response to comment no. 1, this statement was intended primarily to reflect that an accrual had been made for the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation. That accrual reflected our best estimate of the lower end of the range of our potential liability in that litigation and, as noted in our response to comment no. 2, (i) was updated as of June 30, 2012, based upon the information then known to us and (ii) was not material to our financial statements. We will clarify these points in the disclosures we make regarding the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation in our future filings.

The statement noted in the Staff's comment above also refers to accruals for several other matters, none of which are individually or in the aggregate material to our financial statement presentation. Those other matters are not currently considered to be material, and we will make a statement to that effect if that is the assessment of those matters at the time of our future filings.

Executive Compensation, page 15

Compensation Discussion and Analysis, page 15

4. Please disclose the information required by Item 402(b)(1)(vii) of Regulation S-K.

Response: Please note that our proxy statement contained the following statement in the last paragraph of "Role of the Compensation Committee" under "Compensation Discussion and Analysis" on page 18 of our proxy statement:

The committee also considered the results of the most recent shareholder advisory vote on executive compensation in which shareholders expressed strong support for their approval of our executive compensation as disclosed in our proxy statement.

As reported in our Current Report on Form 8-K dated May 17, 2011, we received a strong favorable vote (83.7% of the shares voting at our 2011 annual meeting) on the advisory proposal to approve our executive compensation as disclosed in our proxy statement. Our Board considered that vote as indicating our company had an effective executive compensation program in place that did not require, in the view of our shareholders, significant changes.

We will modify our future disclosure to include a discussion of any changes that our Compensation Committee and our Board have made as a result of the most recent shareholder advisory vote on executive compensation.

Compensation/Benefits Structure, page 18

Base Salaries, page 20

5. Please disclose the factors that you considered to increase your named executive officers' base salaries from fiscal 2010 to fiscal 2011. See Item 402(b)(2)(ix) of Regulation S-K.

Response: Please note that our proxy statement contained the following statement in the paragraph labeled "Base Salaries" under "Compensation/Benefits Structure" in "Compensation Discussion and Analysis" on page 20 of our Proxy Statement:

We adjust salaries taking into consideration changes in the market, changes in responsibilities and performance against job expectations. We also consider the nature of the position, responsibilities, skills and experience of the officer and his or her past performance.

This statement was intended to describe the factors that were taken into account in the determination of base salary changes from fiscal 2010 to fiscal 2011. We will modify our future disclosures to describe more specifically the factors considered in making any material increase or decrease in base salaries.

Short-Term Incentive, page 20

6. Please explain how achievement of the metric-specific targets, the other corporate goals, and the individual performance goals resulted in the amounts paid to each named executive officer, as disclosed in the "Bonus" column of the Summary Compensation Table. Please also disclose the size of the incentive pool for 2011 and 2010 and explain the reasons for any material increase in the size of such pool.

Response: Please note that our proxy statement contained the following statements in the bulleted paragraph "Short-Term Incentives:" under "Compensation/Benefits Structure" in "Compensation Discussion and Analysis" on page 19 of our Proxy Statement:

·

Short-Term Incentives: For 2011, incentives were determined by the board. The incentives are based on objective metric-specific targets, a subjective assessment of overall corporate performance and a subjective assessment of individual performance. Achieving the target bonus opportunity for all categories would yield a 100 percent payout of the target bonus amount. The target bonus amount for the CEO is 50 percent, and the remaining NEOs is 35 percent, of annualized base pay at December 31, 2011. The components that make up the target bonus opportunity are shown below:

–

40 percent upon the achievement of objective targets (actual payout for all NEOs was 55.375 percent, see page 20).

30 percent upon a subjective assessment of the degree of achievement of specified corporate goals. The corporate goals are not formula-based and require judgment to be applied on the part of the committee and board (actual payout for all NEOs was 35 percent, see page 21).

30 percent upon a subjective assessment of the degree of achievement of specified individual goals. The individual goals are not formula-based and require judgment to be applied on the part of the committee and board (actual payout for the CEO was 36 percent and between 30 percent and 36 percent for the remaining NEOs, see page 21).

We believe that the foregoing disclosure, together with the paragraphs that follow describing the metric-specific targets, the other corporate goals, and the individual performance goals, provide the information needed to appreciate the connection between the achievement of those targets and goals and the bonus amounts shown in the Summary Cash Compensation Table. The third sentence of the lead-in paragraph notes the percentage of annualized compensation that can be achieved at the target level of performance, and the following subparagraphs summarize the actual performance relative to target. In future filings, we will modify our future disclosures regarding our short-term incentive arrangement to clarify the relationship between the amounts reported in the Summary Compensation Table as Bonus and the actual performance/achievement under the short-term incentive arrangement.

We will modify our future disclosures with respect to the short-term incentive arrangement to indicate the dollar size of the incentive pool at the target level of performance for the current year as compared to the dollar size of the incentive pool at the target level of performance for the immediately preceding year. In 2011, the incentive pool for the named executive officers at the target level of performance was $602,889. Our short-term incentive program in effect during 2010 was based upon subjective evaluations of the named executive officers' performance and involved aggregate payments of $673,000. As noted in our proxy statement dated March 23, 2011, our Compensation Committee undertook "a review of our short-term incentive programs, with the objective of basing them in 2011 and thereafter more on objective performance measures and setting threshold, target and maximum payment levels." ("Executive Compensation – Compensation Discussion and Analysis" on page 19 of our proxy statement dated March 23, 2011.) As the quoted language indicates, we expect the 2011 and 2012 short-term incentive arrangements to be more directly comparable.

Summary of Short-Term Incentive Payouts, page 21

7. In addition to disclosing the actual payout as a percentage of maximum opportunity, please also disclose the actual payout as a percentage of target level performance.

Response: We note that we showed the percentage of the incentive pool that could be achieved at the target level of performance in the headings to the discussions of each of the components of the short-term incentive arrangement—metrics-specific targets (40%), other corporate goals (30%), and individual performance goals (30%); and we showed the actual performance percentages for each of those items from which the requested disclosure could be calculated. We will modify our future disclosures regarding the short-term incentive arrangement to include the requested disclosure of the actual payout as compared to the target level performance.

2011 Grants of Plan-Based Awards Table

8. Given that the performance units are settled in cash and no shares of stock are issued pursuant to the awards, please provide us with your analysis for why awards under the Performance Unit Plan are classified as stock awards in the Summary Compensation Table and as equity incentive plan awards in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards and Outstanding Equity Awards Tables. We also note that in response to Item 12 of Form 10-K, you stated that you do not have or maintain any equity compensation plans. Please cite to relevant authority in your response. Please also explain to us how the awards will be settled in cash. Please also tell us if settlement will occur at the same time as the vesting of the awards.

Response: We follow Accounting Standards Codification 718 in our accounting for the awards made under our performance unit plan because the ultimate payout under those awards is based on the difference between the value of shares of our common stock at the beginning of the award period versus the value of those shares at the end of the award period. Under our performance unit plan, awards are made annually to participants in an amount based upon a percentage of their respective base salaries. That dollar amount is converted to units based upon the price per share of our common stock on the date of award grant. At the end of a five-year performance period, those units are multiplied by the price of our common stock at that time to determine the dollar amount to be paid to the holder of the award. Dividend equivalents are paid to the holders of awards under the plan during the five-year performance period.

Section (a)(6)(ii) of Regulation S-K Item 402 (Executive Compensation) defines an "equity incentive plan" and "non-equity incentive plan" as follows:

An equity incentive plan is an incentive plan or portion of an incentive plan under which awards are granted that fall within the scope of FASB ASC Topic 718, Compensation – Stock Compensation. A non-equity incentive plan is an incentive plan or portion of an incentive plan that is not an equity incentive plan.

Based upon that definition and the related accounting for the performance unit plan, we have presented the performance unit plan as an equity incentive plan in the Summary Compensation Table, the Grants of Plan-Based Awards Table and the Outstanding Equity Awards table.

We do not have any plans that involve the issuance of shares of stock, as indicated by the statement that the Staff noted in Item 12 of our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2011. A more specific statement is contained in the "Executive Summary" appearing in "Compensation Discussion and Analysis" on page 16 of our Proxy Statement where we state: "We do not have a stock award plan and thus have not issued any stock options or restricted stock." We make the point that the performance unit plan is a cash-based plan at several points in our proxy statement – including under "Compensation Benefits/Structure – Long-Term Incentives" on page 22 in "Compensation Discussion and Analysis," where we refer to "a cash long-term incentive plan known as the 2006 Performance Unit Plan," and later under the "Grant of Plan-Based Awards Table" on page 25, which contains the following disclosure:

In 2006, our board approved a cash-based long-term incentive plan known as the Performance Unit Plan. Under the Performance Unit Plan, certain key executives of the Company received performance units, whose value is tied to changes in the Company's share price and any dividend payments made by the Company during the vesting period. Performance units are settled by the Company in cash. Because the value of the awards is derivative of the value of our common stock, the awards are accounted for much the same as stock-based awards. That accounting also determines the presentation under applicable SEC disclosure rules, including the tables presented above and below. No shares of stock are issued pursuant to the awards.

Payment under the awards occurs at the end of the five-year performance period, or term, of the awards and not upon vesting of the award-holders rights under the award. We will modify our disclosures in future filings to clarify the time of payment and the manner of its calculation.

* * * * *

We hereby acknowledge:

The company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and

The company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you would like to discuss any of the responses to the Staff's comments or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7149. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by email, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Aug 27, 2012: 10-Q filed Nov 6, 2012 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 7, 2012 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

SEC asked
Commitments and Contingencies, page 92 Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation, page 98 1. We note your responses to comments 1 - 3 and your intention to make clearer in your disclosure the existence of an accrual for the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation. We also note your statement that the accruals for this matter were not material to your December 31, 2011 or June 30, 2012 financial statements.
Rest of the question

Please note that paragraphs 38 of ASC 450-20-50 require disclosure of the additional exposure to loss if there is a reasonable possibility that the additional amounts will be paid. Since you stated in your response to us that you cannot predict the outcome of these claims and believe the outcome could be significant if an adverse outcome results we believe you should disclose the estimated reasonable possible amount of loss or range of loss which could result in excess of the amount accrued related to the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation. Please show us what your disclosure will look like.

MGEE answered
In response to your request, our proposed disclosure (based upon the information contained in our quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2012) would look like the following:

Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation

In December 2009, the EPA sent a notice of violation (NOV) to MGE as one of the co-owners of the Columbia generating station.
Rest of the answer

The NOV alleges that WPL, as operator, and the co-owners failed to comply with appropriate pre-construction review and permitting requirements and, as a result, violated the PSD program requirements, the Title V operating permit requirements of the CAA, and the Wisconsin SIP. In September 2010, Sierra Club filed a lawsuit against WPL alleging violations of the CAA at Columbia and other WPL-operated Wisconsin facilities. WPL has stated it believes the projects at Columbia were routine, or not projected to increase emissions, and therefore did not violate the permitting requirements of the CAA. MGE and the other Columbia co-owners are defending against these allegations while actively pursuing settlement options with the EPA and Sierra Club.

MGE believes that the parties have reached a tentative agreement on the general terms of a settlement with the EPA and Sierra Club regarding various facilities, including Columbia. Sierra Club has stipulated to a dismissal of its lawsuit, without prejudice, while the parties attempt to reach a final settlement. The parties are currently negotiating a consent decree based upon those general terms, which may change during the negotiations. Once the parties agree to final terms, the court must approve the settlement agreement.

In accordance with applicable accounting standards, MGE has accrued an amount for this matter representing its best estimate of the lower end of the range of the probable liability, based upon its assessment of the settlement discussions. That accrued amount is not material to the financial statements. However, if the parties are unable to reach a final settlement, or if the court does not approve any settlement that is reached, then MGE could be exposed to liabilities materially greater than the amount that has been accrued in its financial statements. Those liabilities would be based upon MGE's share, based upon its 22% ownership interest in Columbia, of the fines, penalties, capital expenditures, and operating costs associated with the final resolution of this matter. Under applicable statutes, and based upon a review of the various remedies ordered in similar matters, the Columbia owners could be required to do some or all of the following: (i) pay civil penalties in amounts of up to $37,500 per day for each violation, (ii) purchase and install additional pollution control equipment at Columbia, (iii) change operating conditions (including use of fuels other than coal), (iv) surrender excess emission trading allowances and caps for emissions, (v) limit generation (including retirement of generating units), and (vi) undertake other beneficial environmental projects. Each of the mentioned items includes potentially significant costs and could affect generation at Columbia. The actual remedies will depend upon the final resolution of the matter. The actual costs, and timing of their incurrence, will depend upon the timing and nature of the resolution that is reached. Due to the various possible results, the uncertain time frame in which those results will be known, and the possible effect of capital expenditures and operating changes made at Columbia as a part of its environmental upgrades, the Company is unable to estimate any loss or range of loss in excess of the amount accrued for this matter.

* * * * *

We hereby acknowledge:

·

The company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and

The company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you would like to discuss the response to the Staff comment or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7149. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by email, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply
SEC asked
Commitments and Contingencies, page 92 Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation, page 98 1. We note your response to comment 1 and your statement, “[i]n accordance with applicable accounting standards, MGE has accrued an amount for this matter representing its best estimate of the lower end of the range of the probable liability, based upon its assessment of the settlement discussions.
Rest of the question

That accrued amount is not material to the financial statements. However, if the parties are unable to reach a final settlement, or if the court does not approve any settlement that is reached, then MGE could be exposed to liabilities materially greater than the amount that has been accrued in its financial statements.” Based on your response, it appears you have determined a range of possible loss amounts and you have accrued for the amount at the lower end of the range of loss. We reissue our prior comment and advise you that paragraphs 3-8 of ASC 450-20-50 require disclosure of the additional exposure to loss if there is a reasonable possibility that the additional amounts will be paid. Please revise to disclose the additional exposure of loss in excess of the amounts accrued in your financial statements. In this regard, we do not believe your proposed disclosure complies with the basic disclosure requirements of the above referenced literature or is transparent to allow an investor to understand the entire range of loss with respect to the Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation. Please show us what your disclosure will look like.

MGEE answered
In reviewing that disclosure, please note the following:

·

We have recorded our best estimate of our probable liability in the Columbia Clean Air Act litigation based upon our assessment of the currently pending settlement discussions. As we noted in our disclosure, the recorded amount was not material to our financial statements.

We wish to clarify our previous responses by noting that we have not determined a range of possible loss amounts.

We believe the likelihood of a materially greater liability than the recorded amount to be remote based upon the current status of the settlement
Rest of the answer

discussions. Given that belief and our current assessment of the matter, we determined that it was not necessary to discuss the consequences if a settlement is not reached.

We have revised accordingly our previous proposed disclosure. Our proposed disclosure is shown below:

Columbia Clean Air Act Litigation

In December 2009, the EPA sent a notice of violation (NOV) to MGE as one of the co-owners of the Columbia generating station. The NOV alleges that WPL, as operator, and the co-owners failed to comply with appropriate pre-construction review and permitting requirements and, as a result, violated the PSD program requirements, the Title V operating permit requirements of the CAA and the Wisconsin SIP. In September 2010, Sierra Club filed a lawsuit against WPL alleging violations of the CAA at Columbia and other WPL-operated Wisconsin facilities. WPL has stated it believes the projects at Columbia were routine, or not projected to increase emissions, and therefore did not violate the permitting requirements of the CAA. MGE and the other Columbia co-owners are defending against these allegations while actively pursuing settlement options with the EPA and Sierra Club.

MGE believes that the parties have reached a tentative agreement on the general terms of a settlement with the EPA and Sierra Club regarding various facilities, including Columbia. Sierra Club has stipulated to a dismissal of its lawsuit, without prejudice, while the parties attempt to reach a final settlement. The parties are currently negotiating a consent decree based upon those general terms, which may change during the negotiations. Once the parties agree to final terms, the court must approve the settlement agreement before it becomes final and effective. In accordance with applicable accounting standards, MGE has accrued an amount for this matter representing its best estimate of its probable liability, based upon its assessment of the settlement discussions. That accrued amount is not material to the financial statements. MGE believes the likelihood of a materially greater liability than the accrued amount is remote based upon the current status of the settlement discussions.

* * * * *

We hereby acknowledge:

The company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and

The company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you would like to discuss the response to the Staff comment or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7149. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by email, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply

Also in this review: closing letter, 2012-11-09

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2007

2008-12-30 to 2009-02-09 · 12 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2009-02-09
Results discussion (MD&A)Executive payRevenueLiquidity and cashSegments
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 30, 2007 · General
SEC asked (1)
On your corporate website, please include a hyperlink directly to the Forms 3, 4 and 5 filed by section 16 reporting persons. Currently, the link that you provide is to the list of all of your SEC filings. Please refer to Final Rule: Mandated Electronic Filing and Website Posting for Forms 3, 4 and 5, Release No. 33-8230 (May 7, 2003) and Rule 16a- 3(k) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
MGEE answered
We have changed our Web site to include a hyperlink directly to the Forms 3, 4, and

5 filed by our Section 16 reporting persons. The direct hyperlink is contained below for your reference.
Read in the reply
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (2)
We note that some of your disclosure in the Management’s Discussion and Analysis section would benefit from providing relevant material information within the same context. For example, we note on page 36 you indicate that in fiscal year 2007 MGE Energy received $2.5 million in cash proceeds as a result of the Congestion Cost and Line Loss Allocation Services Agreement to which MGE Energy is a party.
Rest of the question

This agreement is not explained until footnote 6 of the consolidated financial statements. Please revise your disclosure to ensure that relevant material elements of your disclosure are provided within the same context.

MGEE answered
have noted your comment and will structure our disclosures to discuss relevant material information within the same relative context in the Management's

Discussion and Analysis section of our future filings. As an example, using the

Congestion Cost and Line Loss Allocation Services Agreement mentioned in the liquidity discussion on page 36, we would revise the text as follows:

During the twelve months ended December 31, 2007, MGE Energy received $2.5 million in cash proceeds as a result of a Congestion Cost and Line Loss Allocation Services

Agreement.
Rest of the answer

In 2007, MGE, along with several other load serving entities in

Wisconsin and Upper Michigan, signed a five year agreement in which the parties agreed to aggregate and equitably allocate specified costs that have not been perfectly allocated by the MISO Day 2 electricity market. Amounts collected in

2007 related to this agreement were returned to customers in 2008.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations, page
SEC asked (3)
Please expand this section to discuss known material trends and uncertainties that will have, or are reasonably likely to have, a material impact on your revenues or income or result in your liquidity decreasing or increasing in any material way.
Rest of the question

In doing so, provide additional information about the quality and variability of your earnings and cash flows so that investors can ascertain the likelihood of the extent past performance is indicative of future performance. In addition, please discuss in reasonable detail: • economic or industry-wide factors relevant to your company, and • material opportunities, challenges and risks in short and long term and the actions you are taking to address them. See Item 303 of Regulation S-K and SEC Release No. 33-8350.

MGEE answered
have noted your comment and in future filings will revise and expand the

"General" section to summarize the more important aspects of the text that follows. That discussion will include known material trends and uncertainties that have had, and are reasonably likely to continue to have, a material impact on our business, including the quality and variability of earnings and cash flows.
Rest of the answer

As presently discussed in other areas of our periodic reports, we will address the following items that primarily affect our business:

Weather, and its impact on customer sales of electricity and gas, conditions, including current business and financing conditions,

Regulation and regulatory issues,

Energy commodity prices,

Interest rates and our debt credit rating,

Environmental laws and regulation, including pending environmental rule changes,

Construction risk in connection with the Elm Road generating units, and

Other matters as they are identified.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Results of Operations, page 23
SEC asked (4)
For the twelve month period ended December 31, 2007, we note you indicate that your utility operations experienced an increase in electric revenues due in part to an increase in sales for resale. It does not appear that you describe the mechanics of sales for resale in your filing. Please revise your disclosure to explain sales for resale.
MGEE answered
will include a description of sales for resale in our future filings. We anticipate that the disclosure will be written as follows:

Sales for resale represent wholesale sales made to third parties who are not ultimate users of the electricity. Those sales may include spot market transactions on the markets operated by Midwest Independent System Operator, Inc. (MISO) or PJM

Interconnection, LLC (PJM). Those sales may also include bilateral sales to other utilities or power marketers.

Exhibits 31.1,
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Exhibits 31.1, 31.2, 31.3 and 31.4
SEC asked (5)
Your certifications should appear exactly as set forth in current Item 601(b)(31) of Regulation S-K. As such, please include the parenthetical that states “the registrant’s fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report” as set forth in subparagraph 4(d) and use the word “information” rather than “data” as is currently set forth in subparagraph 5(a).
Rest of the question

We note similar issues in the certifications filed with the Forms 10-Q for the quarters ended March 31, June 30 and September 30, 2008.

MGEE answered
confirm that future certifications will conform to the requirements of Item

601(b)(31) of Regulation S-K.
Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations · Environmental Matters, page 47
SEC asked (6)
We note on page 48 you state that a “final report from Governor Doyle’s Global Warming Task Force was approved on July 24, 2008, concluding over a year’s work by the task force.” Please discuss, with a view towards future disclosure, any material effect the issuance of this report has on you.
MGEE answered
The discussion of the impact of this final report was set forth in our Form 10-Q quarterly report for the fiscal quarter ended September 30, 2008, which stated:

"A final report from Governor Doyle's Global Warming Task Force was approved on

July 24, 2008, concluding over a year's work by the task force.
Rest of the answer

While several

Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW) dockets have been created as a result of Task Force recommendations, it is unknown at this time the extent to which the Task Force recommendations will be implemented in Wisconsin or the effect that these recommendations might have on MGE operations."

As noted in the third quarter report, we are unable at this time to determine if any material effect will result from these recommendations, since they are non-binding recommendations and are in a proposal phase. In future filings, we will expand, as applicable, the existing description of the report to include a brief summary of the general nature of the proposals along with a description of any reasonably foreseeable effects.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A
SEC asked (7)
Please describe your policies and procedures for the review, approval or ratification of any transaction required to be reported under Item 404(a) of Regulation S-K. See Item 404(b) of Regulation S-K. It is unclear from the disclosure regarding the Audit Committee on page 9 whether you have a separate related person transaction policy. Please clarify.
MGEE answered
will clarify our policies and procedures with respect to the review, approval or ratification of transactions required to be reported under Item 404(a) of

Regulation S-K in future filings. Under our Audit Committee's Charter, that

Committee is responsible for reviewing all related party transactions that are required to be disclosed under applicable rules of the Securities and Exchange

Commission. That Committee has a procedure for reviewing those transactions.
Rest of the answer

We are taking formal steps with our Audit Committee to reduce that procedure to writing, which we expect will be completed in time for our next proxy statement.

Under the current procedure, which is expected to be reflected in writing, the

Company's internal auditor is charged with identifying to the Audit Committee the transactions to be reviewed. The review considers all material facts in assessing the appropriateness of any identified transactions. Thus, the disclosure in future filings would state the following:

Our

Audit Committee is responsible for reviewing all transactions between our

Company and related parties that require disclosure under applicable rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission. Under that procedure, which is in writing, our internal auditor is responsible for identifying to the Committee the transactions requiring review. In its review, the Committee considers the material facts of the transaction, including the circumstances underlying its initiation or origination and the dollar amounts involved; the related person's relationship to the Company and interest in the transaction; and whether the terms of the transaction are comparable to the terms available to unrelated third parties.

When the written form of the procedure is finalized, the foregoing proposed disclosure would be modified, as needed, to conform to the written procedure.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Executive Compensation, page 11
SEC asked (8)
You provide a general discussion of the elements considered in determining the compensation paid to named executive officers, however, it does not appear that you explain how you determine the specific amount you pay under each element.
Rest of the question

For example, on page 14 you state that “[w]here applicable, peer company information may be supplemented with general and industry-specific survey data that provides positionbased compensation levels across broad industry segments.” As an additional example, you indicate that you utilize benchmarking, but on page 14 you state that “realized total compensation during any given year may be above or below the benchmark compensation levels.” Please provide more detail regarding how you arrive at the amount paid with respect to each element of compensation. Refer to Item 402(b)(1)(v) of Regulation S-K.

MGEE answered
will revise our compensation discussion in future filings to emphasize earlier in the text several points and concepts that are responsive to your comments that now appear later in the body of the text. We believe the existing executive compensation discussion contains information regarding the manner in which specific amounts of compensation are determined.
Rest of the answer

It describes:

· data and elements considered by our Compensation Committee in setting compensation;

use of market information to establish general parameters, but not to establish specific formulae or percentage relationships;

Compensation Committee's policy of targeting annual compensation levels at or below competitive market median levels; and subjective nature of the process by which individual compensation is set, which considers individual roles, responsibilities, experience, skills and accomplishments.

noted, we will emphasize these matters by revising the description of the

Compensation Committee process that will appear in future filings to state earlier in the discussion the aforementioned policy and the subjective nature of the determinations.

noted in several places within the existing discussion, our Compensation

Committee uses market information, but does not rely upon specific formulae based upon, or defined percentage relationships to, that market information. For example, on page 12 of the proxy statement, it is noted that:

Toward this end, specific individual targets or Company performance formulas are not set. Instead, market-based salary ranges are examined for each position, and an executive's positioning within that range is determined by that individual's experience in their position, as well as the Company's evaluation of each individual's performance during that year.

Later, on page 14 of the proxy statement, it is noted:

Relative to the comparative market data, our Committee does not set a specific targeted percentile as part of its compensation philosophy. An executive's positioning against the competitive labor market would reflect that executive's experience, marketability and performance over a period of time. While we use benchmarking as described above in determining appropriate compensation ranges, the Committee avoids making 'automatic' adjustments based on an employee's positioning relative to the market.

process relies heavily upon the individual experience, knowledge of the business, judgment and subjective evaluations of the Committee members, aided by market data and informed advice from their independent compensation consultant,

Pearl Meyer & Partners. The goal of the process, which is discussed in the context of the annual incentive and the long-term incentives on page 15 of the proxy statement, is to achieve a compensation package at or below competitive market median levels. The decision-making structure is generally described under

"Role of the Compensation Committee" on page 12 of the proxy statement. We believe the subjective nature of the process is illustrated by some of the decisional elements mentioned in the previously quoted phrases. It is also expressly noted in passages such as appear under "Annual Incentive Bonus" under

"Pay Mix" on page 14: "Awards are determined on a judgmental basis, taking into account a number of performance dimensions as described below." noted, these concepts appear in the existing discussion, albeit at places throughout the text. We will modify the text in future filings to make the points more directly and earlier in the text.

note on page 12 you state that "specific individual targets or Company performance formulas are not set." We also note that in the third paragraph on the same page you discuss the creation of a long-term incentive plan for your executives pursuant to which award levels for executives are determined based on a variety of factors including "individual performance." Please discuss, with a view towards disclosure, how individual performance is evaluated if you do not utilize targets.

Response:

noted in our response to comment no. 8, the goal of our Compensation Committee is to achieve a structure with compensation levels at or below competitive market median levels. This goal is accomplished by receiving input in the form of market data from the Compensation Committee's independent compensation consultant, Pearl Meyer & Partners, and applying the Committee members' individual experience, knowledge of the business, judgment and subjective evaluation to the individual employee's role, responsibilities, experience, skills and accomplishments, which we believe is the best indicator of appropriate levels of compensation when considered in conjunction with market data. We note that the guidance issued in the Compliance & Disclosure

Interpretations in response to question 118.04 indicates that targets with respect to qualitative and subjective performance goals need not be disclosed.

As noted in our previous response to comment no. 8, we will modify the discussion in future filings to clarify the goal of the process as well as the subjective nature of the determinations.

note on page 15 that 2007 earnings per share finished at $2.27 compared to $2.06 in 2006. If applicable, please disclose the 2007 targeted earnings per share level for named executive officers to receive an award under the annual incentive plan. If you believe that disclosure of this target is not required because it would result in competitive harm, provide us on a supplemental basis a detailed explanation under Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K for this conclusion. If disclosure of the performance-related factor would cause competitive harm, please discuss how difficult it will be for you to achieve the target level. Please see Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K. Also disclose the minimum, targeted and maximum amount of an annual incentive award that each named executive officer could receive under the plan and explain how the registrant determines the amount to pay. See Item 402(b)(1)(v) of Regulation

S-K. Finally, tell us why you did not include amounts payable under the annual incentive plan in the non-equity incentive column of the summary compensation table or in the grants of plan-based awards table. See Item 402 of Regulation

S-K.

Response:

annual incentive plan does not have pre-established performance targets.

Assessments are made by the Compensation Committee at year-end based upon our

Company's overall performance and the individual accomplishments and contributions of the executive officers. The items mentioned under the "Annual

Incentive" heading on page 15 of the proxy statement reflect items that the

Committee considered at year-end in making its determination on the awards. We will clarify that these items are considered, but not used as definitive targets, in future filings.

Earnings per share is not an established performance target under the annual incentive plan. Thus, there is no 2007 targeted earning per share level to disclose.

There is no pre-established minimum, targeted or maximum amount of an award that an individual named executive officer can receive.

Finally, the reason for not reporting the annual incentive plan payment in the

"Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation" column (as opposed to the "Bonus" column) in the Summary Compensation Table is that the performance targets are not (and were not) pre-established and communicated as a part of the annual incentive plan. The same explanation would apply to the omission of the Grants of Plan-Based Awards table.

2007 Summary

Compensation Table, page 17 disclose the assumptions made in the valuation of the stock awards by reference to a discussion of those assumptions in your financial statements, footnotes to the financial statements or in management's discussion and analysis. See the

Instruction to Item 402(c)(2)(v) of Regulation S-K.

Response:

In future filings, we will include a cross reference to the discussion of the assumptions made in the valuation of the stock awards. That discussion appears in Footnote 1 (t) in the 2007 Form 10-K and is quoted below:

"The

MGE Energy Board approved a Performance Unit Plan (the "Plan") on December 15,

2006. Under the Plan, eligible participants may receive performance units that entitle the holder to receive a cash payment equal to the value of a designated number of shares of MGE Energy's common stock, plus dividend equivalent payments thereon, at the end of the set performance period. Per the Plan's provisions, these awards are subject to a prescribed vesting schedule and must be settled in cash. Accordingly, no new shares of common stock will be issued in connection with the Plan. MGE and MGE Energy have adopted the provisions of SFAS 123R,

Share-Based Payment. This guidance establishes standards for the accounting of transactions in which an entity exchanges equity instruments for goods and services. Additionally, this standard addresses the accounting for transactions in which an entity incurs liabilities in exchange for goods or services that are based on the fair value of the entity's equity instruments.

Based on the provisions of SFAS 123R, MGE Energy and MGE will initially measure the cost of the employee services received in exchange for the award based on current market value of MGE Energy common stock. The fair value of the award will be subsequently re-measured at each reporting date through the settlement date. Changes in fair value during the requisite period will be recognized as compensation cost over that period."

12. note on page 22 you state that severance payments to Ms. Euclide differ from those paid to your other named executive officers, but it does not appear that there is a discussion of the reasons for this difference. Please separately discuss materially different compensation policies and decisions for named executive officers. Refer to II.B.l of Securities Act Release 33-8732A.

Response:

will discuss materially different compensation policies and decisions in future filings. With respect to the referenced matter, the severance payments are set forth in individual agreements with each of the named executive officers. The agreements with each of Messrs. Wolter, Hanson, Neitzel and Newman were entered into at earlier dates (in some cases, 1994) than the agreement with

Ms. Euclide. Ms. Euclide's agreement was entered in November 2001 in connection with the commencement of her employment with the Company and reflected the results of a negotiation of her overall compensation package.

We acknowledge that:

are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the

Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United

States.

If you would like to discuss any of the responses to the Staff's comments or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at (608) 252-7149. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by e-mail, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Executive Compensation, page 11
SEC asked (9)
We note on page 12 you state that “specific individual targets or Company performance formulas are not set.” We also note that in the third paragraph on the same page you discuss the creation of a long-term incentive plan for your executives pursuant to which award levels for executives are determined based on a variety of factors including “individual performance.” Please discuss, with a view towards disclosure,
Rest of the question

how individual performance is evaluated if you do not utilize targets.

MGEE answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Executive Compensation, page 11
SEC asked (10)
We note on page 15 that 2007 earnings per share finished at $2.27 compared to $2.06 in 2006. If applicable, please disclose the 2007 targeted earnings per share level for named executive officers to receive an award under the annual incentive plan.
Rest of the question

If you believe that disclosure of this target is not required because it would result in competitive harm, provide us on a supplemental basis a detailed explanation under Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K for this conclusion. If disclosure of the performance-related factor would cause competitive harm, please discuss how difficult it will be for you to achieve the target level. Please see Instruction 4 to Item 402(b) of Regulation S-K. Also disclose the minimum, targeted and maximum amount of an annual incentive award that each named executive officer could receive under the plan and explain how the registrant determines the amount to pay. See Item 402(b)(1)(v) of Regulation S-K. Finally, tell us why you did not include amounts payable under the annual incentive plan in the nonequity incentive column of the summary compensation table or in the grants of planbased awards table. See Item 402 of Regulation S-K.

MGEE answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

2007 Summary Compensation Table, page 17
SEC asked (11)
Please disclose the assumptions made in the valuation of the stock awards by reference to a discussion of those assumptions in your financial statements, footnotes to the financial statements or in management’s discussion and analysis. See the Instruction to Item 402(c)(2)(v) of Regulation S-K.
MGEE answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

2007 Summary Compensation Table, page 17
SEC asked (12)
We note on page 22 you state that severance payments to Ms. Euclide differ from those paid to your other named executive officers, but it does not appear that there is a discussion of the reasons for this difference. Please separately discuss materially different compensation policies and decisions for named executive officers. Refer to II.B.1 of Securities Act Release 33-8732A.
Rest of the question

Please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response. Please furnish a letter that keys your responses to our comments and provides any requested information. Detailed letters greatly facilitate our review. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments.

MGEE answered

No numbered answer found in the reply. Read the reply ↗

In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 14, 2009: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2009 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 26, 2008 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2009-02-09

Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2005

2006-12-29 to 2007-02-09 · 7 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2007-02-09
RevenueLeasesResults discussion (MD&A)
10-K for the year ended December 31, 2005 · General
SEC asked (1)
In order to facilitate this review and reduce the number of comments we have not issued multiple comments for issues that may be applicable to more than one registrant referenced above in this letter. To the extent any comment applies to more than one registrant, please address the comment individually for each separate registrant.
MGEE answered
We have noted your comment.
Read in the reply
Electric Utility Operations
SEC asked (2)
We noted that 47.7% of your 2005 electric revenues came from commercial customers. Please explain to us if any one customer in particular comprised a material amount of revenue.
MGEE answered
No one customer comprises a material amount of revenue for either MGE or MGE Energy. At December 31, 2005, the total gas and electric revenues of MGE's largest electric customer, a governmental entity, represented less than 5% of total operating revenues, and MGE's second largest electric customer, another governmental entity, accounted for 2% of total operating revenues. None of MGE's remaining commercial customers individually accounted for more than 1% of its total operating revenues.
Rest of the answer

The percentages for MGE Energy are equivalent.

According to SOP 94-6, "financial statements should disclose certain concentrations if the concentration exists at the date of the financial statements, the concentration makes the enterprise vulnerable to the risk of a near-term severe impact, and it is at least reasonably possible that the events that could cause the severe impact will occur in the near term."

Additionally, per the provisions of SFAS 131, "if revenues from transactions with a single external customer amount to 10% or more of an enterprise's revenues, the enterprise shall disclose the fact, the total amount of revenues from each such customer, and the identity of the segment or segments reporting the revenues."

Accordingly, MGE concluded that the circumstances of these customers do not warrant disclosure under SOP 94-6. Principally, the governmental status of these customers and their credit status made it unlikely there would be a rapid decline of these customers in the near term. Additionally, because none of these customers account for 10% or more of the enterprise's revenues, disclosure was not required under SFAS 131.

Based on our assessment of SOP 94-6 and SFAS 131, a disclosure of these two customers was not included in the financial statements or footnotes as neither comprised a material amount of MGE revenue. We will continue to monitor the disclosure requirements in this area for future filings.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 30, 2007: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 8, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Nonregulated Energy Operations
SEC asked (3)
Note 8 to your financial statements indicates that MGE Power West Campus is owned indirectly by MGE Energy and it appears that MGE consolidates MGE Power West Campus and appropriately reflects the minority interest for the portion of MGE Energy’s earnings in MGE Power West Campus. You also indicate University of Wisconsin at Madison owns an interest in the project.
Rest of the question

In this regard, we note that MGE Energy and MGE are consolidating MGE Power West Campus, although we do not see any minority interest reflected on MGE Energy’s Statements of Income. Please clarify what interest the University of Wisconsin holds in the project and how earnings are shared among the owners. Also, please explain the business purpose for structuring facility leases among MGE and an indirectly owned project of MGE Energy, namely MGE Power West Campus.

MGEE answered
We believe it would be helpful to begin with a description of the ownership structure. MGE Energy owns 100% of MGE Power LLC and MGE. MGE Power LLC, in turn, owns 100% of MGE Power West Campus, LLC (MGE PWC). The indirect ownership reference to MGE PWC refers to the fact that it is a second tier subsidiary of MGE Energy.

MGE PWC and the University of Wisconsin at Madison (UW) each own an undivided interest in the assets of the West Campus Cogeneration Facility.
Rest of the answer

Pursuant to the West Campus Cogeneration Facility Joint Ownership Agreement dated as of October 13, 2003, each entity is allocated a portion of the facility to represent its respective interest in the plant. MGE PWC owns 55% of the facility, which represents its interest in the electric generating assets, and the UW owns 45% of the facility, which represents its interest in the steam and chilled water assets. Each owner is severally liable only for the indebtedness it incurs in connection with its own interest in the property. In situations involving jointly owned plants in which the owners have an undivided interest in the plant's assets, such as the cogeneration facility in question, it is established industry practice for each co-owner to account separately for its share of the assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses of the jointly owned plant. In making this assessment, MGE referred to EITF 00-1, "Investor Balance Sheet and Income Statement Display under the Equity Method for Investments in Certain Partnerships and Other Ventures." This issue addressed whether proportionate presentation was appropriate for an investment in an unincorporated legal entity. The legal structure for this transaction did not involve a separate legal entity to own the assets. Instead, the structure had a direct ownership in the assets of the facility. Therefore, MGE concluded it was appropriate for MGE PWC to recognize its share of the facility.

As previously noted, MGE PWC owns the electric generating assets and the UW owns the steam and chilled water assets of the plant. Since the UW does not own the electric generating assets, it does not share in the earnings of MGE PWC, which are derived from the ownership of the electric generating assets. Therefore, MGE PWC has not recognized a minority interest related to the UW's share of the plant since there is no minority interest as a result of the accounting for the jointly held plant.

In 2001, the State of Wisconsin enacted the leased generation law in order to provide financial incentives to encourage the development and construction of new electric generation within the state of Wisconsin. Under the law, nonregulated affiliates of the utility are allowed to propose long-term leasing arrangements for generating assets. These leasing arrangements have established fixed financial terms for the length of the lease. The cogeneration facilities owned by MGE PWC were constructed and financed in accordance with this law and orders issued by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (which regulates public utilities in Wisconsin).

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 30, 2007: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 8, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Nonregulated Energy Operations
SEC asked (4)
Please explain how you evaluated the facility leases of WCCF and the Elm Road interests under SFAS no 13. Please summarize for us the structure of the leases (including all parties involved), the financial terms of the facility leases and how you are accounting for any rent reductions that may be present.
Rest of the question

We note in your section entitled general to your MD&A discussion and note 2 to your financial statements that you are consolidating both the cogeneration project of WCCF and your 8.33% ownership interests in MGE Power Elm Road. Please provide to us your detailed FIN 46 analysis for each project.

MGEE answered
WCCF Lease

Structure of Lease

MGE PWC owns the electric generating assets of the West Campus Cogeneration Facility (WCCF) and leases those assets to MGE, the regulated utility. MGE is responsible for the lease payments to MGE PWC under a facility lease that was approved by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin. The lease term has a fixed monthly rental payment for a 30-year term, unless plant additions are made by MGE PWC.
Rest of the answer

The fixed rental payments were determined between the various parties assuming a rate regulatory recovery approach with a hypothetical capital structure of 53% equity and 47% long-term debt, and a return on equity of 12.1%. The fixed rental payments are charged to the MGE electric customers and recovered accordingly. The lease is a capital lease under generally accepted accounting principles. MGE (the utility) operates the facility.

Lease Accounting Analysis

The arrangement between MGE and MGE PWC is considered a lease under EITF 01-08. The analysis under SFAS 13 resulted in recognizing the facility lease as a capital lease for MGE and a direct financing lease for MGE PWC. Based on the fact that both MGE and MGE PWC are 100% owned subsidiaries of MGE Energy (MGE PWC is owned by MGE Power LLC, which is owned by MGE Energy), the lease between the parties is considered a related party lease. The lease meets the criteria of paragraph 7(c) and 7(d) of SFAS 13 and is recorded as a capital lease by MGE, the lessee. Both MGE and MGE PWC will account for the lease under identical terms. The lease requires the cost of the plant be recovered during the base term of the facility lease. This recovery period results in the present value of the minimum lease payments equaling 100% of the fair market value of the plant and meets the criteria of SFAS 13, paragraph 7(d). The economic useful life of the plant is 40 years. The base term of the lease is 30 years and represents 75% of the economic useful life of the property and meets the criteria of SFAS 13, paragraph 7(c).

Upon consolidation under the requirements of FIN No. 46(R), the facility lease transaction between the two entities is eliminated.

FIN 46(R) Analysis

MGE PWC is a variable interest entity (VIE) pursuant to FIN No. 46(R), as the equity investment at December 31, 2003, was not sufficient to permit the entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated support. MGE holds an indirect interest in the VIE under FIN No. 46(R) due to the long-term lease arrangement described above between MGE and MGE PWC. MGE PWC leases a major portion of its assets, an electric power plant, to MGE. The substantial risks associated with the power plant asset during operation (including the ability to sell the electrical output and the value of the plant) are assumed by MGE through the leasing arrangement.

Evaluation under FIN 46(R):

The first assessment under FIN 46(R) was to determine if MGE PWC was within the scope of FIN 46(R). MGE PWC was included in the scope of FIN 46(R) since it was not deemed to be a business under the definition in Appendix C of FIN 46(R) or to meet any of the other exceptions listed in FIN 46(R) Section 4(a)-4 (i).

The second assessment was to determine if MGE PWC was a VIE as defined in paragraph 5 of FIN 46(R). As of the date of the evaluation of FIN 46(R), MGE PWC did not have sufficient equity to permit the entity to finance its activities without the additional support of its parent and therefore met the criteria in paragraph 5(a) of FIN 46(R). The member equity represented less than 10% of the total assets of the entity and did not meet the minimum equity levels to satisfy this criteria. In addition, MGE PWC met the criteria under 5(b)(2) of FIN 46(R) since MGE Energy, as the equity investor, has the ability to protect itself directly or indirectly from the expected losses as the 100% owner of MGE.

In accordance with paragraph 16 of FIN 46(R), for purposes of determining whether an entity is the primary beneficiary of a VIE, an enterprise with a variable interest shall treat variable interests in that same entity held by its related parties as its own interests. Under paragraph 17 of FIN 46(R), if two or more related parties hold variable interests in the same VIE, and the aggregate variable interest held by those parties would identify that party as the primary beneficiary, then the party that is most closely associated with the VIE is the primary beneficiary. In our judgment, MGE was the party most closely associated with MGE PWC based on the relevant accounting guidance and known activities of the parties to MGE PWC and thus considered the primary beneficiary.

Elm Road Generating Lease

MGE Power Elm Road, LLC (MGE PER) will own an undivided interest in a new clean-coal plant currently under construction in Oak Creek, Wisconsin. MGE PER's 8.33% interest in the two generating units will represent approximately 50 megawatts for each unit. Similar to the WCCF lease described above, MGE PER will lease the generating assets to MGE, the regulated utility. MGE is responsible for the lease payments to MGE PER under a facility lease that was approved by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin. The lease term has a fixed monthly rental payment for a 30-year term, unless plant additions are made by MGE PER. The fixed rental payments were determined between the various parties assuming a rate regulatory recovery approach with a hypothetical capital structure of 55% equity and 45% long-term debt, and a return on equity of 12.7%. The fixed rental payments will be charged to the MGE electric customers and recovered accordingly. For the first five years, there is a 5% lease payment reduction. The lease is a capital lease under generally accepted accounting principles.

The analysis under SFAS 13 is the same as discussed for the WCCF lease.

Upon consolidation under the requirements of FIN 46(R), the facility lease transaction between the two entities is eliminated.

MGE PER is a VIE pursuant to FIN No. 46(R), as the equity investment at December 31, 2005, was not sufficient to permit the entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated support. MGE holds an indirect interest in the VIE under FIN No. 46(R) due to the long-term lease arrangement between MGE and MGE PER. MGE PER will lease a major portion of its assets, a power plant, to MGE. The substantial risks associated with the power plant asset during operation (including the ability to sell the electrical output and the value of the plant) will be assumed by MGE through the leasing arrangement.

The first assessment under FIN 46(R) was to determine if MGE PER was within the scope of FIN 46(R). MGE PER was included in the scope of FIN 46(R) since it was not deemed to be a business under the definition in Appendix C of FIN 46(R) or to meet any of the other exceptions listed in FIN 46(R) Section 4(a)-4(i).

The second assessment was to determine if MGE PER was a VIE as defined in paragraph 5 of FIN 46(R). As of the date of the evaluation of FIN 46(R), MGE PER did not have sufficient equity to permit the entity to finance its activities without the additional support of its parent and therefore met the criteria in paragraph 5(a) of FIN 46(R). The member equity represented less than 10% of the total assets of the entity and did not meet the minimum equity levels to satisfy this criteria. In addition, MGE PER met the criteria under 5(b)(2) of FIN 46(R) since MGE Energy, as the equity investor, has the ability to protect itself directly or indirectly from the expected losses as the 100% owner of MGE.

In accordance with paragraph 16 of FIN 46(R), for purposes of determining whether an entity is the primary beneficiary of a VIE, an enterprise with a variable interest shall treat variable interests in that same entity held by its related parties as its own interests. Under paragraph 17 of FIN 46(R), if two or more related parties hold variable interests in the same VIE, and the aggregate variable interest held by those parties would identify that party as the primary beneficiary, then the party that is most closely associated with the VIE is the primary beneficiary. In our judgment, MGE was the party most closely associated with MGE PER based on the relevant accounting guidance and known activities of the parties to MGE PER and thus considered the primary beneficiary.

MGE PER, along with others, owns an undivided interest in the assets of the Elm Road generation facility. Pursuant to the Elm Road Generating Station I and II Joint Ownership Agreements, each dated as of December 17, 2004, each owner is allocated a portion of the generating units to represent its respective interest in the plants. MGE PER owns a 8.33% interest in two separate generating units, which represents approximately 50 MW for each unit. Each owner is severally liable only for the indebtedness it incurs in connection with its own interest in the property. In situations involving jointly owned plants in which the owners have an undivided interest in the plant's assets, such as the generating units in question, it is established industry practice for each co-owner to account separately for its share of the assets, liabilities, revenue and expenses of the jointly owned plant. In making this assessment, MGE referred to EITF 00-1, "Investors Balance Sheet and Income Statement Display under the Equity Method for Investments in Certain Partnerships and Other Ventures." This issue addressed whether proportionate presentation was appropriate for an investment in an unincorporated legal entity. The legal structure for this transaction did not involve a separate legal entity to own the assets. Instead, the structure had a direct ownership in the assets of the facility. Therefore, MGE concluded it was appropriate for MGE PER to recognize its share of the facility.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 30, 2007: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 8, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

MGE
SEC asked (5)
You indicate that dividend payments by MGE to MGE Energy are subject to restrictions arising under a PSCW rate order and, to a lesser degree, MGE's First Mortgage Bonds. Please describe the nature of the restrictions on the ability of the subsidiaries to transfer funds to the holding company. Further, disclose the amount of retained earnings or net income restricted. See Rule 4-08 of Regulation S-X.
Rest of the question

In this regard, please tell us what consideration you gave to providing Schedule I and the related disclosures set forth in Rule 12-04 of Regulation S-X.

MGEE answered
There are two potential dividend restrictions that apply solely to dividends that may be declared and paid by MGE to MGE Energy. They do not affect dividend declarations or distributions by MGE Energy's other subsidiaries, such as MGE Power LLC, MGE Power West Campus, LLC or MGE Power Elm Road, LLC.

The first restriction on MGE comes from its regulator. The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW) is an independent state agency that oversees public utilities.
Rest of the answer

As disclosed on page 40 of MGE Energy's/MGE's 2005 Form 10-K, pursuant to the terms of the rate order issued by the PSCW in December 2004, the PSCW may restrict MGE from paying dividends "in excess of the typical level" to MGE Energy if the level of common equity in the utility is lower than 55%. The PSCW computes this ratio based on the utility statements only and does not include the debt or equity of any entities consolidated under FIN 46(R). In other words, these restrictions do not extend to MGE Power West Campus or MGE Power Elm Road as they are nonregulated entities consolidated under FIN 46(R). The PSCW does not have jurisdiction over these entities. The restrictions instituted by the PSCW do not include specific restrictions on net income or retained earnings and do not prevent the company from issuing loans. However, the restrictions could limit the amount of dividends paid to MGE Energy if MGE's capitalization ratio is less than 55%. At December 31, 2005, under the formula prescribed by the PSCW, MGE had a 55.7% level of common equity. Because the level of common equity was above 55%, the aforementioned restriction on dividends was not applicable at December 31, 2005, and there were no restricted assets.

The second restriction on MGE comes from its mortgage bond indenture. As disclosed on pages 83 and 40 of MGE Energy's/MGE's 2005 Form 10-K, per the terms of MGE's mortgage bond indenture, MGE may not declare or pay dividends on its common stock or make any other distribution unless, after giving effect thereto, the aggregate amount of all such dividends and distributions subsequent to December 31, 1945, is less than the earned surplus accumulated subsequent to December 31, 1945. Under the indenture, earned surplus is defined as accumulated or retained earnings excluding the impact of dividends paid. The terms and conditions of the indenture do not extend to entities consolidated into MGE in accordance with FIN 46(R). Accordingly, the earnings or dividend activity of MGE Power West Campus and MGE Power Elm Road are not included in the aforementioned calculation, nor are they impacted by these restrictions. The indenture does not contain any language that specifically restricts net income or retained earnings and does not prevent MGE from issuing loans. At December 31, 2005, MGE had $148.2 million in dividends available for payment. Because the amount of dividends that could be declared exceeded the net assets of MGE at December 31, 2005, the indenture did not restrict any of MGE's net assets.

In accordance with Rules 5-04 and 12-04 of Regulation S-X, condensed parent company financial information is required if the restricted net assets of consolidated subsidiaries exceed 25% of the consolidated net assets as of the end of the most recent fiscal year. Under Rule 4-08(e)(3) of Regulation S-X, restricted net assets include amounts that may not be transferred to the parent company in the form of loans, advances, or cash dividends by the subsidiaries without the consent of a third party. Under Rule 4-08(e)(3), where the restrictions on loans differ from the restrictions on dividends, the least restrictive should be used.

At December 31, 2005, there were no restricted assets or restrictions on issuing loans as a result of either the PSCW order or the mortgage indenture and therefore, MGE concluded that Schedule I was not required.

Read in the reply
Consolidated Balance Sheets
SEC asked (6)
Please explain in detail why the balance of unbilled revenues was larger relative to that of trade receivables for 2004 versus 2005. Please also explain why unbilled revenues constitute 30-34% of total receivables. 1. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
MGEE answered
The 30-34% noted above appears to take into account the impact of fluctuations in MGE and MGE Energy's other accounts receivable balance. As described in Footnote 1 to the financial statements, the other accounts receivable balance represents receivables generated from nonregulated operations or from activities that are outside of the core business. Accordingly, these balances have no bearing on or relation to our trade or unbilled receivables.
Rest of the answer

Below is the computation of MGE's unbilled revenues to total receivables, excluding the impact of other receivables:

2005

2004

$ Change

% Change

Accounts Receivable

$49,230

$34,212

$15,018

44%

Unbilled Receivables

30,432

24,880

5,552

22%

Total Customer Receivables

$79,662

$59,092

$20,570

35%

$30,432

=

38%

$24,880

42%

MGE's accounts receivable balance at December 31, 2005, was 44% higher than the balance at December 31, 2004. MGE's accounts receivable balance includes billed, unpaid metered usage for a portion of the last period in the reporting period (e.g., December) and a portion of the usage for the previous month (e.g., November) plus any unpaid balances from prior months (e.g., September, October, November). On December 21, 2004, the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSCW) authorized increases in 2005 electric and gas revenues, which increased customer receivables. In addition, due to the natural disasters that occurred in the Gulf of Mexico, and the reduced availability of natural gas supplies, fuel and purchased power costs increased during the latter portion of 2005. As a result, MGE applied for, and received authorization from the PSCW to implement, a surcharge to collect a portion of those additional costs, again increasing customer receivables. . Gas and electric sales volumes for the three months ended December 31, 2005, were also higher than those for the same period in the prior year. The aforementioned increases in rates and volumes caused MGE's accounts receivable balance at December 31, 2005, to be higher than that at December 31, 2004.

We have also examined the difference in the amount of unbilled revenues as of December 31, 2004, versus the amount of unbilled revenues as of December 31, 2005. MGE's unbilled receivable balance at December 31, 2005, was 22% higher than the unbilled receivable balance at December 31, 2004. MGE's unbilled receivable balance represents the estimated usage that has occurred between the last meter read and the last day of the accounting period. Due to the volume of customers and the size of MGE's service territory, it is not feasible to read all meters on the last day of the accounting period. Accordingly, MGE employs a methodology to estimate the amount of usage that has occurred between the last meter read and the last day of the accounting period. As a result of higher gas and electric rates and higher gas and electric sales volumes for the month ended December 2005, the unbilled receivable balance at December 31, 2005, was higher than the balance at December 31, 2004.

Based on MGE's experiences and the information available through MGE's billing system, MGE concluded that the relationship between unbilled revenues and accounts receivable is not the most appropriate metric to assess the validity of the unbilled receivable estimate. MGE has identified various factors that may cause anomalies or inconsistencies in this relationship. For instance, this relationship may be skewed by the receivables aging composition, changes in weather during a given period, inconsistencies in consumption patterns, changes in customer rate mix, or movements in rates throughout a given reporting period.

MGE believes a more refined approach for monitoring the balance of unbilled revenue is through the comparison of such things as unbilled receivables to billed sales for electricity, and unbilled sales to system gas available. As mentioned on page 46 of MGE Energy's/MGE's 2005 Form 10-K, MGE monitors the ratio of unbilled electric receivables to total electric sales. MGE expects that this ratio will settle into a range of 40-60%. At December 31, 2005, and December 31, 2004, unbilled electric receivables was 51% and 50% of billed electric sales, respectively. If the ratio is outside of these parameters, further investigation is required. MGE also prepares graphical analysis tracking unbilled gas receivables as a percent of system gas available and billed revenue per therm (a quantity measurement) of delivered gas to unbilled revenue per therm of delivered gas. The results of our assessment of these metrics for December 31, 2004, and December 31, 2005, were consistent with our expectations.

Based on the analysis completed as of December 31, 2005 and 2004, and subsequent review after the unbilled receivables estimates were recorded, we believe the unbilled revenue balances as of December 31, 2005 and 2004, were appropriate and reasonable and fairly stated in all material respects.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 30, 2007: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 8, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Consolidated Balance Sheets
SEC asked (7)
Prospectively disclose and explain to us how you account for costs associated with planned major maintenance activities regarding your generation facilities. Please refer to FASB Staff Position, “Accounting for Planned Major Maintenance Activities,” – FSP AUG AIR-1, which was posted on September 8, 2006. Please respond to these comments within 10 business days or tell us when you will provide us with a response.
Rest of the question

Please furnish a letter with your responses to our comments and provide any requested supplemental information. Please understand that we may have additional comments after reviewing your responses to our comments. Please file your response letter on EDGAR as a correspondence file.

MGEE answered
MGE Energy and MGE account for the cost of planned major maintenance activities via the direct expensing method. In other words, all costs related to such activities are expensed as incurred. MGE Energy and MGE will include a disclosure addressing this treatment in their Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2006.

We acknowledge that:

•

We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;

Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and

We may not
Rest of the answer

assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.

If you would like to discuss any of the responses to the Staff's comments or if you would like to discuss any other matters, please contact me at 608-252-7075. If for any reason it would be useful to contact me by e-mail, my address is [email protected].

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jan 30, 2007: 10-K filed Feb 26, 2007 ↗, against the 10-K filed Mar 8, 2006 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2007-02-09

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 19 letters filed since 2007-01-30. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/MGEE/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.