Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021
We note that Adjusted net income (loss) includes an adjustment to eliminate the depletion expense associated with the step-up in fair value of the mineral rights recorded in connection with the SNR mineral rights acquisition. Please tell us how you determined that the depletion adjustment does not result in presenting a non-GAAP measure that substitutes an individually tailored measurement method for those of U.S.Rest of the question
GAAP since it eliminates depletion expense associated with the mineral rights. Refer to Question 100.04 of the Division's Non-GAAP Financial Measures Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
Company’s Response: The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment. As background, the Company computes AdjustedRead in the reply
Net Income (Loss) by excluding certain expenses that are required in accordance with U.S. GAAP because they are non-recurring, non-cash, and/or not related to the
Company’s underlying business performance. In particular, the periods presented include the effects of the November 2020 acquisition of Secure Natural Resources LLC (“SNR”), a related party to which the Company previously paid a mining royalty (the “SNR Mineral Rights Acquisition”).Rest of the answer
For clarity, prior to the SNR Mineral Rights Acquisition, the Company recognized an expense for the royalties paid to SNR for use of the mineral assets, and afterward recognizes a non-cash depletion expense due to outright ownership of the same mineral assets. As a result, the Company determined that it may be difficult for users of the financial statements to readily compare the
Company’s performance between the periods presented without making certain adjustments. Therefore, the Company excluded both the royalty expense and depletion expense when calculating Adjusted Net Income (Loss) in order to provide a clearer understanding and enhance the comparability of the Company’s performance before and after the SNR Mineral Rights Acquisition.
The Company considered whether excluding depletion expense from GAAP net income resulted in presenting a non-GAAP measure that substitutes an individually tailored measurement method for those of U.S. GAAP, and concluded that the adjustment simply excluded an expense that was not reflective of the
Company’s underlying business performance based on the same criteria used in identifying the other expenses that are excluded when computing Adjusted Net Income (Loss). Importantly, the exclusion did not change the measurement pattern of depletion expense, but rather fully excluded a non-cash expense related to acquired mineral rights that were not previously owned by the Company outright, and were instead subject to a related-party royalty agreement. Production, revenue and other costs were not affected by the SNR Mineral Rights Acquisition.
Nevertheless, the Company will revise future filings to exclude the adjustment for depletion expense when calculating Adjusted Net Income (Loss) for all periods presented in such filings.
Financial Statements
Note 8.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 2, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
The accounting policy at page 59 discloses that the depletion of mineral rights is recognized on a straight-line basis over the estimated remaining useful life of the mine. Please tell us how you concluded that the straight-line method is preferable and determined to be more systematic and rational manner of depletion of your mineral rights compared to the units-of-production method, as a process of equitablyRest of the question
allocating the costs of mineral rights to the periods in the estimated economic life of the mine. Considering significant increase in production volumes during the periods presented, please include in your analysis the impact on depletion expense for the periods presented, from applying the straight-line method compared to units-of-production method of depletion to the periods subsequent to acquiring the mineral rights. Refer to ASC Subtopic 360-10-35.
to the Staff’s inquiry regarding the potential difference in depletion expense that would have been recognized had the Company utilized the UoP method instead of the straight-line method, the Company respectfully refers to the Exhibit A below, which illustrates that such differences would not be material for the periods presented.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Consistent with the Staff’s request, the analysis focuses on the periods after November 17, 2020, the date of the SNR Mineral Rights Acquisition that resulted in the recording of an additional $434.7 million of mineral assets on the Company’s consolidated balance sheet. In addition, the Company analyzed the potential future differences in expected depletion expense between both methods for years after FY2021, and observed that the largest estimated difference in any full annual period would remain immaterial at approximately $1.3 million and would average approximately $0.2 million per year over the life-of-mine.
For clarity, the Company does not regularly compute UoP depletion for any purpose, and does not have a UoP accounting policy that defines how the Company’s depletion expense would be calculated under U.S. GAAP for such a comparison. Therefore, to estimate the historical depletion expense under a theoretical UoP methodology for the purposes of this analysis, the Company calculated depletion using an estimate of ore-tons consumed in each quarterly period in relation to the total proven and probable ore-tons (including those consumed) from the most recent proven and probable reserves statement, which is discussed in our Technical Report Summary with an effective date of September 30, 2021, included as Exhibit 96.1 to the Company’s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021, filed with the Commission on February 28, 2022. Furthermore, the consistency in minerology and grade at Mountain Pass suggests that the differences would remain immaterial across various bases for defining the UoP.
Exhibit A:
Period from
Nov. 17, 2020 to
Dec. 31, 2020
FY2021
Depletion Expense
Recorded under Straight-Line Method
$
1.9 million
17.2 million
Estimated under UoP Method
14.8 million
Difference
—
2.4 million
*
Amount reflects the largest estimated annual difference between the straight-line and UoP methods over the current estimated mine life due to the fact that the Company was ramping toward targeted maximum throughput in FY2021.
The difference in FY2021 represents 0.6% of the carrying amount of the mineral asset, which the Company believes is not material.
Finally, the Company has established processes and controls to regularly review its estimated remaining reserves, thereby incorporating regular updates to the useful life and/or updated depletion calculations supported by independent third-party analyses and modeling of the resource, thus resulting in any deviations from plan being promptly reflected through an updated life-of-mine and resulting depletion expense.
As a result, it remains the Company’s belief that the production profile of the mine will be stable throughout the mine’s life, and that recognizing depletion expense using the straight-line method remains an appropriate, systematic and rational basis for recognizing the economic cost of depletion of the mineral asset.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 2, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2022-09-27