The Company notes the Staff’s comment regarding the determination of reporting units for purposes of
testing. The
Company continually assesses its reporting units and notes that we have had no changes in reporting units since MSG separated from Cablevision Systems Corporation in February 2010.
, the Company first reviewed the guidance of ASC 350-20-35-34, which discusses the definition of a component of an operating segment as follows:
Rest of the answer
unit if the component constitutes a business or a nonprofit activity for which discrete financial information is available and segment management, as that term is defined in paragraph 280-10-50-7, regularly reviews the operating results of that component. Subtopic 805-10 includes guidance on determining whether an asset group constitutes a business….”
In evaluating the above guidance, the Company determined that there are several components of both the Sports and Entertainment operating segments, listed as follows:
•
Sports: New York Knicks (“Knicks”), New York Rangers (“Rangers”) (including its primary player development team, the Hartford Wolf Pack), New York Liberty (“Liberty”), an NBA
Development League team, the Westchester Knicks (collectively, the “Franchises”) and Sports Properties
Note: Sports Properties is the component of the Sports segment that promotes, produces and/or presents a broad array of live sporting events outside of the Franchises’ games.
Entertainment: Bookings and Productions
As discussed in further detail later in this response, the Company has aggregated components within both the Sports and Entertainment operating segments in the determination of reporting units pursuant to ASC 350-20-35-35. The Company concluded that each component of the Sports and
Entertainment operating segments constitute businesses as they are comprised of activities and assets that are capable of providing, and have historically provided, a return and economic benefits to the Company’s investors. Further, the Company assessed the information that segment management (in the context of ASC 350-20-35-34) regularly reviewed when performing this function. As a result of this assessment, the Company noted that since the separation of MSG from Cablevision Systems
Corporation and for all periods presented in the Form 10, the segment manager received and regularly reviewed discrete financial information for each of the components discussed above.
The Company notes that ASC 350-20-35-35 permits the aggregation of components of an operating segment into a single reporting unit if the components have similar economic characteristics. In determining whether the components of an operating segment have similar economic characteristics, the Company assessed the following guidance included in ASC 280-10-50-11:
Operating segments often exhibit similar long-term financial performance if they have similar economic characteristics. For example, similar long-term average gross margins for two operating segments would be expected if their economic characteristics were similar. Two or more operating segments may be aggregated into a single operating segment if aggregation is consistent with the objective and basic principles of this Subtopic, if the segments have similar economic characteristics, and if the segments are similar in all of the following areas (see paragraphs 280-10-55-7A through 55-7C and Example 2, Cases A and B
[paragraphs 280-10-55-33 through 55-36]):
The nature of the products and services;
The nature of the production processes;
The type or class of customer for their products and services;
The methods used to distribute their products or provide their services; and
If applicable, the nature of the regulatory environment, for example, banking, insurance, or public utilities.
We note that ASC 350-20-55-6 states “Evaluating whether two components have similar economic characteristics is a matter of judgment that depends on specific facts and circumstances. That assessment should be more qualitative than quantitative.” Furthermore, ASC 350-20-55-7 states “…all of the factors in paragraph ASC 280-10-50-11should be considered. However, every factor need not be met in order for two components to be considered economically similar. In addition, the determination of whether two components are economically similar need not be limited to consideration of the factors described in ASC
280-10-50-11.” ASC 350-20-55-7 also lists incremental factors to consider in assessing economic similarity, in addition to the guidance set forth in ASC 280-10-50-11 as follows:
a)
The manner in which an entity operates its business or nonprofit activity and the nature of those operations b)
Whether goodwill is recoverable from the separate operations of each component business (or nonprofit activity) or from two or more component businesses (or nonprofit activities) working in concert (which might be the case if the components are economically interdependent) c)
The extent to which the component businesses (or nonprofit activities) share assets and other resources, as might be evidenced by extensive transfer pricing mechanisms d)
Whether the components support and benefit from common research and development projects.
The Company assessed whether the components of the Sports and Entertainment operating segments have similar economic characteristics, pursuant to the above guidance in ASC 280 and ASC 350, which is discussed in further detail below.
Aggregation of the Components of the Sports
Operating Segment
Components included in the assessment: Knicks, Rangers (including the Hartford Wolf Pack), Liberty, Westchester
Knicks and Sports Properties.
Outlined below are the factors discussed in ASC 280-10-50-11 that management assessed in determining the presence of similar economic characteristics:
Nature of products and services – the Franchises and Sports Properties each provide live sporting events that are primarily presented at The Madison Square Garden Arena (“The Garden”), which is located in the New York metropolitan area. For example, the Franchises include the Knicks, a professional basketball team, and Sports Properties includes the presentation of college basketball games.
Nature of the production processes – The production process for each component is substantially identical, as it relates to the presentation of live sporting events. Although some of the components represent different sports, the presentation for each of them is fundamentally the same, including the preparation of the playing surface and the arena for attendance of a live audience.
Type or class of customer for products and services – The type or class of customers is generally the same, as customers are viewing live sporting events as a form of entertainment (primarily in the
New York metropolitan area), with purchases made from the consumers’ pool of discretionary income. The Sports segment also generate revenues from the sale of suite licenses which includes, for each seat in the suite, tickets to generally all sporting events at The Garden for which tickets are sold to the general public. The Company also sells a combined ticket product, which entitles the customer access to all Knicks and Rangers home games, as well as certain Sports Properties events.
Methods used to distribute products or provide services – Each component presents live sporting events as a form of entertainment through the same means of distribution (primarily The Garden).
Further, MSG Media holds the local telecast rights to Knicks, Rangers and Liberty games, as well as programming related to Sports Properties events. National television broadcast rights to the games are held by the respective leagues.
Nature of regulatory environment – Substantially all of the Sports segment’s events are subject to laws and regulations governing the sale and resale of tickets and consumer protection statutes.
In addition, many of the events produced or promoted by each component are presented in our venues which are, like all public spaces, subject to building and health codes and fire regulations imposed by the state and local governments in the jurisdictions in which our venues are located.
In addition, the Franchises are members of their respective leagues and, as such, are required to comply with their respective league constitutions and collective bargaining agreements. Similarly the exhibition of our Sports Properties events is subject to professional, collegiate and other sports sanctioning authorities.
Additionally, the Company assessed the factors listed above in ASC 350-20-55-7 and notes the following. The primary business of each component within the Sports segment is the promotion, production and/or presentation of a live sporting event. The components share assets including, but not limited to, the Company’s venues (primarily The Garden). Decisions regarding the level and amount of capital investments at the venues and the related recovery of those costs are viewed based on the revenues of all of the components of the Sports segment. The Company makes joint capital investments benefiting all components of the segment. Furthermore the following departments: sponsorship sales, ticketing, marketing and food and merchandise operations are shared and serve the Sports segment. More specifically, the Company’s integrated approach to the sale of sponsorships allows it to use and sell its broad array of assets in a complementary manner in order to maximize their collective value, both for the Company and for its marketing partners. Another example of shared resources is the Company’s proprietary customer database which drives revenue and engagement across all components, benefiting the Company through ticket sales, merchandise sales and sponsorship activation. This database provides the Company a greater opportunity to cross-promote its products and services, introducing customers to its wide range of assets and brands. Given the interdependencies of the components of the Sports segment, the recoverability of the goodwill allocated to the Sports segment is supported by the combined results of the Sports segment.
The Company’s primary measure used to assess the financial performance of its operating segments and components is adjusted operating cash flow (“AOCF”). The Company notes that its AOCF margin percentages for the components are dissimilar for various reasons, such as: (i) team personnel transactions, (ii) the Franchises’ financial performance dependence on actions taken by the NBA and NHL, (iii) the rights fees from MSG Media for carriage of proprietary professional sports content could vary, (iv) the operation of the Liberty and Westchester Knicks by the Sports segment as an integral part of its ownership of an NBA team (v) the mix of non-Franchise live sporting events, and (vi) the success of the Franchises and whether each team makes the playoffs. The Company determined that when assessing the qualitative factors listed above, the components meet the ‘economically similar’ criteria, despite differing AOCF margins.
Based on the above analysis, the Company believes that the aggregation of the Knicks, Rangers, Liberty, Westchester Knicks and Sports
Properties components into a single reporting unit is appropriate as these components have similar economic characteristics. In addition, each component is considered to be similarly affected by general economic conditions, in particular those in the New York City metropolitan area, and the effect of these conditions on its customers.
Aggregation of the Components of the
Entertainment Operating Segment
Components included in the assessment: Bookings and Productions.
Outlined below are the factors discussed in ASC 280-10-50-11 that management assessed in determining the presence of similar economic characteristics:
Nature of products and services – Both components provide live entertainment that is presented in the Company’s owned or controlled venues, which are primarily located in the New York metropolitan area. At the core of the business of both components is revenue generation from live entertainment.
Nature of the production processes – The primary business of both components is to present live entertainment events. This includes providing production services, such as front-of-house and back-of-house staffs, including stagehands, box office staff, ushers, security, staging, lighting and sound, and building services, as well as all of the other technical aspects involved in presenting a live entertainment event. While the
Productions component develops the event’s content, the Bookings component deals with the promoters who generally provide a fully-produced event. From a venue perspective both components share the Company’s venues and facility services, primarily Radio City Music Hall, and the Company has made capital investments that benefit both components. Entertainment currently does not promote or co-promote events outside of the Company’s venues.
Type or class of customer for products and services – The type or class of patrons who view live entertainment in major markets are generally the same. For our Productions and for Bookings events in our venues that we promote, we recognize revenues from the sale of tickets to our audiences. Both components generate revenues from other streams, which are similar in nature and are dependent upon the ability of acts to attract strong attendance at our venues. For example, both Production and Bookings events generate revenue from facility and ticketing fees, concessions, sponsorships and merchandising. Both Bookings and Productions compete, in certain respects and to varying degrees, with other leisure-time activities such as television, radio, motion pictures, sporting events, other live performances and the Internet, in addition to competing for concerts with other event venues for total entertainment dollars in the Company’s marketplace.
Methods used to distribute products or provide services – Each component presents live entertainment events through the same means of distribution, the Company’s venues. In addition, advertising for both Bookings and Productions events is displayed at all of the Company’s events.
Nature of regulatory environment – Each component is subject to laws and regulations governing the sale and resale of tickets and consumer protection statutes. In addition, many of the events produced or promoted by each component are presented in our venues which are, like all public spaces, subject to building and health codes and fire regulations imposed by the state and local governments in the jurisdictions in which our venues are located.
Additionally, the Company assessed the factors listed above in ASC 350-20-55-7 and notes the following. The primary business of each component within the Entertainment segment is to derive revenues from the presentation of live entertainment, presented in the Company’s venues. Both the components share assets including, but not limited to Radio City Music
Hall. Bookings and Productions also share other resources, such as the following departments: sponsorship sales, ticketing, marketing, group sales and food and merchandise operations. More specifically, the Company’s integrated approach to the sale of sponsorships allows it to use and sell its broad array of assets in a complementary manner in order to maximize their collective value, both for the Company and for its marketing partners. Another example of shared resources is the
Company’s proprietary customer database which drives revenue and engagement across all components, benefiting the Company through ticket sales, merchandise sales and sponsorship activation. This database provides the Company a greater opportunity to cross-promote its products and services, introducing customers to its wide range of assets and brands. Entertainment jointly utilizes for both Bookings and Productions the strength of its industry relationships, marketing assets, customer database and live event expertise to create performance, promotion and distribution opportunities for artists, events and productions. Entertainment has also leveraged cross promotional opportunities between the components. Given the interdependencies of the components of the Entertainment segment, the recoverability of the goodwill allocated to the Entertainment segment is supported by the combined results of the Entertainment segment.
AOCF margin percentages for the components vary, depending on whether the Entertainment segment is promoting an event or licensing the venues to a third-party promoter. The Company determined that when assessing the qualitative factors listed above, the components meet the ‘economically similar’ criteria, despite differing AOCF margins.
Based on the above analysis, the Company believes that the aggregation of the Bookings and Productions components into a single reporting unit is appropriate as these components have similar economic characteristics. In addition, both Bookings and Productions are considered to be similarly affected by general economic conditions, and the effect of these conditions on their customers. Weak economic conditions may lead to lower demand for tickets to our live productions, concerts, family shows and other events, which would also negatively affect concession and merchandise sales, as well as lower levels of sponsorship and venue signage. These conditions may also affect the number of concerts, family shows and other events that take place in the future.
The Company believes that the aggregation of the respective components of our Sports and Entertainment operating segments used to determine reporting units is appropriate and in compliance with the guidance set forth by ASC 350-20-35.