Form 10-K for the Fiscal Period Ended December 31, 2023
We note you have a Chief Operating Officer for Tinder, Hinge, Match Group (Asia), and Evergreen & Emerging Brands. Tell us how those leaders align with your segment structure. Disclose the factors used to identify your reportable segments, including whether operating segments have been aggregated. We refer to the guidance in ASC 28010-50-21.Rest of the question
Also, please describe the disaggregated financial information the CODM receives, the frequency it is provided, and how it is used by the CODM. In your response, specifically tell us what financial information the CODM receives about each business / brand, if any. Finally, tell us what disaggregated financial information is provided to the Board of Directors.
The Company respectfully submits that it consists of one operating segment based on the guidance in ASC 280 and management’s approach to making key operating decisions and assessing performance, which are based primarily on consolidated revenue and profitability metrics.Read in the reply
In response to the Staff’s comment and to further clarify the determination of our reportable segment conclusion to readers of our consolidated financial statements, the
Company respectfully submits that in its future Form 10-K and 10-Q filings with the Commission, it will explicitly state that the operating segment andRest of the answer
reportable segment are the same.
Match Group operates under a portfolio approach which offers various social connection apps with very similar offerings which feature a profile set up, discovery of matches, post-match experience, and paid subscription and à la carte features. While some of our apps (which we also call brands) are focused on a specific target audience based on age, sexual orientation, ethnicity or race, religion, and/or relationship intent, there is a significant amount of overlap in the customer base for our apps. In fact, our users frequently engage with more than one of our apps whether consecutively or concurrently. The underlying purpose of our apps overlap, therefore many of our apps could easily be substituted for one another.
We have identified our operating segment at the overall Match Group level because the Chief Operating Decision Maker (the “CODM”) assesses performance and allocates resources at this level given the similarity in the business model, risks, service offerings, and technology among the brands. Our primary focus is to manage our portfolio to maximize our consolidated market share and revenue growth regardless of our individual brands, while attaining consolidated profitability targets, as further described below.
Each of the four brands or brand groupings mentioned in the Staff’s comment, which are Tinder, Hinge, Match Group Asia, and Evergreen & Emerging Brands (each, a “Brand Group”), has a Chief Executive Officer (collectively the “Brand CEOs”) who oversees the day-to-day operations and go-to-market strategy for their respective Brand Group. These leaders report directly to Bernard Kim, Chief Executive Officer of Match Group, who we consider the Company’s CODM. Other direct reports of the CODM include Match Group’s President & Chief Financial Officer, Chief Legal Officer, Chief People Officer, and Chief Technology Officer (collectively the “Functional Leaders”). The CODM’s interactions with the Brand CEOs are focused on product innovation, brand positioning and monetization initiatives, which are critical to driving revenue expansion for our business. While the Brand CEOs are empowered with the authority to manage and grow their respective Brand Group, they are subject to and limited by strategic and budgetary oversight from the CEO and central Functional Leaders. The primary role of the Brand CEOs is to drive users and revenue for their respective Brand Groups. The Functional Leaders who report directly to the CODM manage their respective functions on an enterprise-wide basis given the brands all have very similar risks and strategies.
There are multiple examples of key initiatives being driven from the CODM for application across the portfolio of brands. For instance, our Chief Technology Officer is currently working across our portfolio at the direction of our CODM on a variety of artificial intelligence initiatives to drive product innovation and, ultimately, revenue expansion. There are also numerous other functions that are centralized to be an efficient use of resources and avoid duplicative efforts across the portfolio of brands, which underpins the approach to managing profitability and overall decision making at the consolidated level.
Below are a few significant examples that allow the CODM to make decisions and assess performance at the Match Group level:
•Our apps are almost exclusively accessed through the Apple App Store and the Google Play Store. We rely on these key partners to distribute and process payments for our apps. Our relationships with these key vendors are managed centrally and any beneficial or adverse impacts from our relationships with these distribution partners or changes to their policies would impact all Match Group apps. In-app purchases fees represent our single largest expense and totaled over $600 million in 2023.
•We rely on cloud-based, hosted web service providers, such as Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud Platform, in connection with the provision of our services generally, as well as to facilitate and process certain transactions with our users. These contractual arrangements are managed centrally to leverage the combined efficiencies of scale and boost consolidated profitability.
•Certain internally developed technology assets and capabilities are utilized by multiple brands across the portfolio. We also frequently deploy new monetization features (e.g., subscription or à la carte features) to various brands across the portfolio when they have been proven to be successful.
•Over the past several years, Match Group has been centralizing additional functions, such as Trust & Safety and IT Security Engineering, to reduce duplication and redundancy across the portfolio and drive increased consolidated profitability.
Please refer to page 6 in our Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023 where the centralized functions are further discussed under the heading “Our Portfolio Strategy.”
Match Group holds annual planning meetings with each Brand Group which are attended by the CODM. In these meetings, leaders from the Brand Groups discuss their goals, initiatives, potential marketing campaigns, and revenue generating ideas. From these meetings, our centralized financial planning and analysis team, together with the Brand Group’s financial planning and analysis teams, are tasked with preparing a forecast for each Brand Group for the upcoming fiscal year, all of which are combined, along with certain enterprise function considerations, to create a consolidated Match Group forecast.
The consolidated Match Group financial forecast is then generally updated monthly throughout the year. Updates to each Brand Group’s forecasts result from monthly meetings with leaders from each Brand Group. These monthly forecast update meetings are attended by individuals from the centralized financial planning and analysis team and consist of a presentation prepared by the Brand Groups which include projections of quarterly and full-year revenue, Adjusted Operating Income (“AOI”), and key operating metrics, including number of paying users (“Payers”) and Revenue-per-Payer (“RPP”). The CODM does not generally attend the individual Brand Group forecast update meetings.
Once the monthly forecast meetings are completed, the central financial planning and analysis team holds an initial consolidated Match Group forecast meeting to review the forecast at the consolidated Match Group level with the Company’s President & Chief Financial Officer. Additional adjustments to the Brand Group level forecasts that are deemed appropriate, if any, are made at that time and the updated consolidated Match Group forecast reflecting these adjustments is then finalized.
The updated Match Group consolidated forecast is then presented to the CODM by the President & Chief Financial Officer and the central financial planning and analysis team on a monthly basis. This presentation (the “CODM Reporting Package”) only includes profitability measures at the consolidated Match Group level. Specifically, the CODM Reporting Package includes actual results and forecasted data for the following:
•Consolidated revenue;
•Consolidated AOI and AOI margins;
•Consolidated Operating Income (“OI”) and OI margins;
•Disaggregated information on revenue and cost of acquisition (“COA” or “customer acquisition”) for each Brand Group;
•Foreign exchange currency impacts on consolidated revenue and revenue at the most impacted Brand Groups (i.e., Brand Groups with significant revenue in non-USD currencies); and
•Key operating metrics (Payers and RPP) at a consolidated level and for certain individual brands.
Revenue, Payers, RPP, and COA metrics are the only metrics presented to the CODM below the consolidated level. Profitability below the consolidated level is not a measure the CODM reviews regularly nor is it utilized by the CODM when making resource allocation decisions or assessing performance.
The CODM works with the President & Chief Financial Officer and the central financial planning and analysis team to develop consolidated revenue and profitability targets. The CODM uses the information from the CODM Reporting Package to evaluate consolidated Match Group performance against our consolidated forecast. He also uses this information to understand how the various revenue-related initiatives are performing by evaluating key operating metrics such as RPP and Payer metrics. Based on input provided by the President & Chief Financial Officer and the central financial planning and analysis team, the CODM is provided with strategic options to achieve our consolidated targets during the monthly consolidated forecast meetings. After being presented with the options that would align with our strategic goals, the CODM makes the final decision on which options to implement and how resources will be allocated.
The CODM Reporting Package, particularly consolidated revenue and AOI, supplemented by disaggregated Brand Group revenue information, serves as the basis for the CODM’s performance evaluations and resource allocation decisions. The CODM does not regularly review disaggregated profitability metrics. While more detailed revenue information is regularly reviewed by the CODM at the Brand Group level, revenue information alone is not sufficient for the CODM to make resource allocation decisions at any level other than the consolidated level.
The quarterly reporting to our Board of Directors in connection with the fiscal period ended December 31, 2023 included forecasted and actual results for revenue, AOI, and OI (including AOI and OI margins) on a consolidated basis and at the Brand Group level.
The Brand Group information is included to help provide further clarity and context on the details of our overall consolidated performance and does not drive strategic decision making. The consolidated Match Group amounts are always presented prior to any Brand Group level detail, and consolidated Match Group performance remains the primary focus for both the Board of Directors and Company management.
The Board of Director information packages also generally include certain metrics and detailed business updates (e.g., new features, marketing campaigns, focus areas and initiatives, etc.) for Tinder and sometimes Hinge, which are two of our largest and fastest growing brands. These metrics may include the following, but not all are consistently presented in the materials for every period or every Brand Group:
•Payers;
•RPP;
•Number of application downloads;
•Monthly active users; and
•Registrations/new users.
Depending on recent trends in a certain period, management may include other financial information in the Board of Director materials on an ad-hoc basis for a specific Brand Group and not for others. However, this information may not necessarily be presented to the Board of Directors again or at the same level of disaggregation in subsequent periods.
The disaggregated information is provided to the Board of Directors to illustrate the driving factors behind the consolidated results. However, the primary focus is on the consolidated results of Match Group, which is evidenced by the order in which information is presented in the materials (i.e., in order of significance/prominence). Furthermore, this is only one factor in the analysis of the identification of operating segments under ASC 280, which we do not believe should be considered determinative.
While the CODM does have access to this disaggregated information in his capacity as a member of the Board of Directors, such information is provided less frequently than the monthly CODM Reporting Package. Therefore, such information cannot easily be used by the CODM to assess performance below the consolidated level on a timely basis. Furthermore, the disaggregated information provided to the Board of Directors varies meeting to meeting. Moreover for the reasons explained above, which include the similarity of our apps and users as well as the centralized nature of significant functions, the CODM utilizes the monthly consolidated results for decision making purposes, particularly regarding resource allocations and performance assessments. These factors align with the Company’s structure of one operating segment and one reportable segment.
We note you reported legal settlement costs, an operating expense, within the income statement line-item "Other income (expense) net" below "Operating Income." Separately report operating and non-operating expenses on your income statement and clearly identify them as such, pursuant to Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X.
The Company acknowledges the guidance in Rule 5-03 of Regulation S-X and respectfully submits that we believe the legal settlement reflected in the income statement line item “Other income (expense)” for both 2021 and 2022 is properly reflected outside of operating income.Read in the reply
Both the $441.0 million loss in 2021 and the $3.5 million gain in 2022 are related to a legal settlement pertaining to a dispute over the merger of Tinder into another Match Group subsidiary and the related process to prepare an independent valuation of Tinder.Rest of the answer
The litigation related to this settlement was centered around the plaintiffs’ claim that Match Group wrongfully merged Tinder, thereby depriving certain of the plaintiffs of their contractual right to later valuations of Tinder on a stand-alone basis. Our view is that this settlement involved a claim regarding a merger of a subsidiary rather than a claim involving our operations; therefore, we classified the settlement outside of operating income within non-operating expenses. In accordance with the instructions regarding “non-operating expenses” in Regulation S-X Rule 5-03, we included in Note 16 to the consolidated financial statements for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2023 the amount related to the material non-operating expense and the nature of the transaction. Legal costs and settlements with other litigants that we believe are costs of operations, such as litigation with users of our services or litigation pertaining to the use of intellectual property, are all included within operating income.
First report after the company's reply of Apr 15, 2024: 10-Q filed May 8, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your presentation of a non-GAAP measure, free cash flow. Please tell us your consideration of providing disclosures required by Item10(e)(1)(i) of Regulation S-K, including a reconciliation from the most directly comparable measure calculated in accordance with GAAP.
The Company respectfully submits that the free cash flow reconciliation as required by Item 10(e)(1)(i) of Regulation S-K is included on page 26 of the exhibit.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Apr 15, 2024: 10-Q filed May 8, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note you have provided several forward-looking non-GAAP measures, but have not provided quantitative reconciliations to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures. Please revise your presentation in future filings to provide the required reconciliations, or, if relying on the exception provided by Item 10(e)(1)(i)(B) of Regulation S-K, provide the reason such reconciliation has not been provided, theRest of the question
information that is not available, and the significance of that information. Refer to Question 102.10(b) of the non-GAAP C&DI.
The Company respectfully submits that each forward-looking non-GAAP measure included in the exhibit is reconciled to the applicable most directly comparable GAAP financial measure on page 26 of the exhibit.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Apr 15, 2024: 10-Q filed May 8, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 2, 2023 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment one and your statement that the Board of Directors receives forecasted and actual results for revenue, AOI, and OI (including AOI and OI margins) at the Brand Group level in its quarterly reporting. Please confirm whether your CODM also receives this Brand Group-level information, the frequency it is received, and how it is used.Rest of the question
Also confirm if the CODM receives this same Brand Grouplevel of detail during the budgeting process.
The Chief Operating Decision Maker (the “CODM”) is a member of the Board of Directors and does receive the Brand Group-level information solely in his capacity as a member of the Board four times a year, as the Board generally meets in the last month of each fiscal quarter. Because this information is only provided to the CODM four times a year in his capacity as a member of the Board, it cannot be timely utilized (and is not utilized) by the CODM in his decision-making processes or performance assessments.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The CODM is faced with business decisions on a monthly or more frequent basis, and the monthly CODM reporting package is used to inform these decisions. Specifically, the CODM is making strategic decisions from information presented at monthly consolidated forecast meetings, which are informed by the monthly CODM reporting package. The monthly CODM reporting package does not include Brand-Group level AOI or OI and the Brand CEOs do not attend the monthly consolidated forecast meetings.
The Brand Group-level information is provided to the Board of Directors to illustrate the factors driving consolidated results and is not used as part of the CODM’s decision-making process, as noted above. The consolidated amounts are always presented prior to any Brand Group-level detail, in light of their prominence and significance. Consolidated Match Group performance remains the primary focus for both the Board of Directors and Company management, including the CODM.
During the budgeting process, the CODM does not receive the same Brand Group-level of information that is presented to the Board of Directors (AOI and OI at the Brand Group-level), but does receive revenue information at the Brand-Group level. At the point in the budgeting process when the CODM is involved, any profitability information (specifically, AOI, OI and their respective margins) presented to the CODM is focused exclusively on consolidated results.
Please describe how each of the Brand CEOs and other of the CODM’s direct reports are compensated, including whether any compensation is dependent on a measure of profitability at the Brand Group level.
The Company respectfully submits that the compensation packages for the CODM’s direct reports consist of salary, annual cash bonus, and long-term equity award incentives. We have summarized the different components of the 2024 compensation packages and the relative weighted averages of those components for both groups below.Read in the reply
Employee Group Salary Bonus target Stock-based compensation
Brand CEOs 7% 7% 86%
Other CODM Direct Reports 11% 13% 76%
Salary is a specified annual amount that is not tied to any measure of profitability at a Brand Group level or any other specific metric.
TargetRest of the answer
annual bonus is defined as a percentage of the individual’s salary. The actual payout amount can be higher or lower than the target amount based on various factors. With one exception noted below, annual bonus payout decisions for all of the CODM’s direct reports are subjective and are made on a non-formulaic facts and circumstances assessment of Company and individual performance. In determining individual annual bonus amounts, a variety of factors are considered, including the Company’s overall performance, such as growth in revenue and profitability over the prior year and performance against the Company's plan, and an employee’s individual performance and contribution to the Company’s success. For the Brand CEOs, these factors also include their individual Brand Group performance, focused primarily on revenue growth.
For one individual included in the Other CODM Direct Reports group, the bonus payout is determined primarily on the basis of pre-established consolidated Match Group financial metric targets with a smaller portion determined based on an evaluation of the employee’s individual performance.
The equity incentive compensation component, which represents the overwhelming percentage of total compensation for both groups, is determined on an individual basis for all of the CODM’s direct reports and there is no one particular equity vehicle applied across the entire group. We want all of the CODM’s direct reports to be focused on total Company value and the performance of our portfolio of brands as a whole. For three of the four Brand CEOs and all Other CODM Direct Reports, equity incentive compensation included Match Group restricted stock units (“RSUs”). The majority of these individuals also received performance-based RSUs with a performance factor tied to Match Group’s relative total stock return against other companies in a given market index (“TSR Awards”). Both the RSU awards and TSR Awards are tied to the performance and success of Match Group as a whole.
The equity incentive compensation component for the one Brand CEO not included above was split approximately evenly between 1) a TSR Award, and 2) RSUs denominated in the equity of a Company subsidiary which owns the brand, the value of which are based on the equity value of such subsidiary (the “Subsidiary RSUs”). All equity-eligible employees of this brand, including the Brand CEO, received the Subsidiary RSUs. As this brand has experienced high revenue growth, providing a direct link between the brand value created and compensation is important to the brand’s ongoing recruiting and retention efforts. We believe aligning the Brand CEO and employees with the same equity instrument is also important so that all team members have similar incentives to further build the value of the brand.
We considered the compensation of the CODM’s direct reports and concluded that the vast majority of their compensation is tied to overall Match Group performance through the Match Group RSUs and TSR Awards. We believe it is important that we manage our portfolio of brands together to drive overall Company value. While a portion of the annual bonus payouts is tied to Brand Group performance, we did not consider this element to be a significant factor in the overall compensatory arrangements.
We refer to your correspondence dated September 25, 2024, which states, “[t]he segment disclosures will include revenue and Adjusted Operating Income (Loss) (with a corresponding reconciliation to the closest U.S.Rest of the question
GAAP measure, operating income (loss)) for each of the four reportable segments.” Please explain to us how your proposed reconciliations comply with the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-30(b) which requires reconciliation from the total of the reportable segments’ measures of profitability to consolidated income before taxes and discontinued operations. Provide us with your proposed future disclosure.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the lack of clarity in our prior response. We believe Adjusted Operating Income (“AOI”) is our primary measure of profit and loss (at the reportable segment level and otherwise) because the Chief Operating Decision Maker (the “CODM”) and other members of management use AOI for decision-making purposes and evaluations of performance.Read in the replyRest of the answer
AOI is also a measure on which our internal budget is based.
However, as noted in our response to comment 2 below, and as Operating Income (“OI”) is also used by the CODM to assess performance and allocate resources, the segment disclosures to be included in the Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended September 30, 2024 (the “Q3 2024 10-Q”) will include only OI as the measure of profit or loss for each of the reportable segments and a reconciliation of the total of reportable segment OI to consolidated earnings before taxes (as reported on the face of the Company’s financial statements). Refer to Appendix A for an example of the reconciliation we intend to provide within the segment disclosures included in the Q3 2024 10-Q.
As further described in the response to comment 2 below, the Company is adopting ASU 2023-07 in the fourth quarter of 2024, which will result in some changes to the segment disclosures. In the Form 10-K for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2024 (the “FY 2024 10-K”), the Company intends to disclose both AOI and OI for each reportable segment in the segment disclosure, as both are measures used by the CODM to assess performance and allocate resources, along with a reconciliation from AOI to OI at the segment level and a further reconciliation of the total of reportable segment OI to consolidated earnings before taxes (as reported on the face of the Company’s financial statements).
We note in your response to comment 14 in your letter dated April 15, 2024 you indicate that quarterly reporting to the Board of Directors (which includes your CODM) included both Adjusted Operating Income (AOI) and Operating Income (OI) for each Brand Group. Please tell us if the CODM receives OI information in addition to AOI for each reportable segment.Rest of the question
If so, tell us how you determined the required measure of segment profit or loss to report under ASC 280-10-50-28.
The Company respectfully confirms that our response to comment 1 in the letter dated April 15, 2024 acknowledged that the Board of Directors, which includes our CODM, receives both AOI and OI at the Brand Group level (aligned with our reportable segments).Read in the reply
While the Company primarily uses AOI to assess performance across the organization and presents this quarterly to the Board of Directors (including the CODM), the Company also presents OI in the quarterly Board of Directors materials.Rest of the answer
Therefore, in accordance with ASC 280-10-50-28, we will present OI as the measure of segment profit or loss in our third quarter 2024 segment disclosure. Refer to Appendix A for an outline of the proposed segment disclosure to be included in the Q3 2024 10-Q.
The Company acknowledges that there will be additional changes to the segment disclosures with the adoption of ASU 2023-07 in the fourth quarter of 2024. Based on the updated guidance in ASU 2023-07 related to multiple measures of segment profit and loss, we will report both AOI and OI in the segment disclosure within the FY 2024 10-K.
Also in this review: request for more time, Apr 3, 2024, request for more time, Jul 17, 2024, company letter, Jul 24, 2024, company letter, Sep 25, 2024, closing letter, 2024-11-04