In the section below titled “Non-Purchased Credit Impaired Loans” we (1) provide a detailed summary of our fair value calculation for non-purchased credit impaired loans, (2) discuss premium attributes recorded on those loans, and (3) describe how we incorporated expected renewals into our calculation of fair value. The remainder of our response provides a detailed summary of our fair value calculations for all other intangible assets acquired, and includes (1) Trade Name, (2) Customer Relationship, (3) Licenses, and (4) Value of insurance businesses acquired (VOBA).
Rest of the answer
We contracted with an accounting firm of nationally recognized standing (Third-Party Expert) to support management in valuing both the non-purchased credit impaired (Non-PCI) loans and intangibles assets (excluding value of business acquired, VOBA) as of the acquisition date.
Non-Purchased Credit Impaired Loans
The fair value of Non-PCI loans was calculated using a discounted cash flow model. The discounted cash flow model started with the contractual cash flows of the loans and then adjusted such cash flows for the following assumptions: (1) probability of default, (2) portfolio derived loss given default, and (3) constant prepayment rates. These assumptions were derived using the historical data of the acquired company and encompassed both performance and credit risk metrics. We believe these assumptions are consistent with those a third-party would use to value the portfolio. The expected cash flows were then discounted at a market-based discount rate to arrive at the fair value of the portfolio. We developed our discount rates based on the Capital Asset Pricing Model which builds a discount rate based on risk free pricing, beta, equity market premium, and size and company risk premiums to arrive at a discount rate. We also compared our calculated fair value to recent market transactions and trades and determined that the ultimate pricing was consistent with recent market activity.
Recorded Premium
The premium recorded on the Non-PCI loans can primarily be attributed to the excess contractual yield on the cash flows expected from the portfolio over a market participant discount rate. We believe the market would also attribute a premium to the portfolio given the seasoned performance of the portfolio and our proven collection strategies. We further validated this premium based on our own “all in” cost to originate loans through our branch network noting that loans originated through our branch network also carry a premium subsequent to origination.
The discount rate applied to the expected cash flows was developed with the assistance of the Third-Party Expert and reflected a market participant perspective. Key inputs to the discount rate were benchmarked against both internal and market participant based metrics. The application of the market discount rate resulted in a premium on the Non-PCI portfolio, which would be commensurate with a return on assets that the market would expect on a personal loan.
The premium can also be attributed to the significant customer acquisition related expenses (both successful and unsuccessful) associated with organically originating personal loans. Many companies in the consumer finance market maintain a branch network and marketing campaigns to solicit customers. The acquisition of a seasoned and performing portfolio without having to incur these costs would command a premium for an existing performing personal loan portfolio.
Consideration of Renewals
In the models used to derive expected cash flows for the Non-PCI loan portfolio, renewals of accounts were treated as liquidations. Renewal value was incorporated into the Customer Relationship intangible asset discussed below.
Other Intangible Assets
Trade Name
The valuation of the trade name used a discounted cash flow method based on an estimate of relief from royalty.
The Company utilized a royalty rate assumption to estimate the amount of revenue that is generated based on the entity’s brand. In selecting the royalty rate, management considered the advertising expenses as the key factor in supporting the overall value of the trade name. The royalty rate incorporated several qualitative factors as well, including the age longevity, consumer recognition, production, geographic coverage, advertising, and association. These qualitative factors were benchmarked with market comparable metrics in consultation with the Third-Party Expert. We used the same methodology to derive the discount rate that was utilized for the valuation of the Non-PCI loan portfolio.
Customer Relationship
The customer relationship asset reflects the embedded renewal value of loans in the acquired portfolio. We valued these customer relationships using a discounted cash flow model. In working with the Third-Party Expert, we provided historical renewal data for the acquired portfolio and built assumptions based on our five-year forecast, including the propensity of a loan to renew and the average renewal per unit. These assumptions were used to derive the expected cash flows related to renewals and discounted using a market participant discount rate. We used the same methodology to derive the discount rate that was utilized for the valuation of the Non-PCI loan portfolio.
Licenses
Insurance
An insurance operating license is required for a company to enter markets and underwrite insurance policies. We acquired multiple insurance operating licenses in each state that the acquired company did business. Our valuation process used the market approach. With the support of our Third-Party Expert, we identified a range of current market prices to determine the market value for each insurance license and applied that value to the number of licenses acquired.
Lending
We are subject to the consumer lending laws specific to each state in which we operate and these states require the Company to carry lending licenses. The lending license allows a company to originate loans for its customers. Lending companies must comply with the state lending laws for each state in which it conducts business. We valued our consumer lending licenses using the cost approach to determine the market value per lending license.
VOBA
Management utilized a third party insurance valuation and actuarial specialist to provide a valuation of the insurance business acquired utilizing the projected cash flows of the insurance entities. Management worked with the third party to align their assumptions with those used in internal forecasts. These assumptions include lapse rates, mortality and morbidity rates, and expense rates, which vary by product, as well as future investment returns for the assets underlying the business. Lapse and mortality rates are based on recent studies. Morbidity rates are based on recent experience and, for some products such as involuntary unemployment insurance, forecasts of future economic conditions. Actual commission rates vary by state but are modeled as a weighted average. Other expenses are based on company-wide expense studies. For most products, the third party used the assumptions provided by management. For certain products, the third party reselected morbidity assumptions and expense assumptions, and re-projected the timing of certain benefit payments. Future investment returns were based on the runoff of existing assets together with conservative re-investment assumptions.
The elements of the VOBA calculation beyond cash flows were verified to match the third party’s stated calculation methodology. These cash flows were discounted to arrive at the recorded VOBA. We used the same methodology to derive the discount rate that was utilized for the valuation of the Non-PCI loan portfolio.