The Trust respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment but declines to make the suggested revision since the differences, as noted in the Staff’s comment, between the Solactive Index and the LBMA pricing methodology previously used by the Trust are no longer relevant to investors.
The Trust’s analysis pertaining to the switch in pricing methodologies is further discussed below.
Gold Price as the benchmark price for purposes of calculating the net asset value (“NAV”) of the Trust.
Rest of the answer
The LBMA Gold
Price has several attributes that caused the Trust to adopt the Solactive Index.
First, the LBMA Gold Price methodology does not represent a pricing determination by broad industry participation. The LBMA Gold Price is calculated by the ICE Benchmark Administration
(the “IBA”), which determines a gold price fixing for the London bullion market. The LBMA Gold Price is calculated twice daily (at 10:30 a.m. London Time and 3:00 p.m. London Time) and is determined through an electronic auction process involving a daily varying subset of 16 direct participants.
Second, the LBMA Gold Price determination occurs at times that are not synchronized with important times of trading in the Shares. The most significant daily trading for the Shares typically occurs at the close of trading on the NYSE Arca. Thus, the LBMA Gold Price determination in London several hours before such trading period does not, by itself, provide a current valuation evaluation usable to Share investors. There are also days where the IBA observes a U.K.
banking holiday schedule while the NYSE Arca observes a U.S. market calendar. This holiday schedule mismatch further reduces the LBMA
Gold Price’s utility to Share investors.
In contrast, the Solactive Index is a U.S. dollar denominated index that aims to provide a price fixing for the gold spot price for London delivery gold bullion quoted as U.S. dollars per Troy Ounce (“XAU”) and determined once a day as of the time trading closes on the New York Stock Exchange (the
“NYSE”). The Solactive Index is calculated based on thousands of transaction prices for gold bullion spot that are captured by ICE Data Services (“IDS”) during two time periods.
The sponsor of the Trust, Merk Investments LLC
(the “Sponsor”), believes that the Solactive Gold Spot Index provides an improved benchmark price because it reduces timing differences between the basis for NAV calculation and market price for the Shares, and promotes market liquidity by aligning the timing of the calculation of the benchmark price with the closing time for trading of the Shares and the time at which NAV is determined.
Additionally, when price moves occur, the use of the Solactive Index provides a timelier value of the NAV calculation and promotes consistency between the NAV and market price of the Shares. The Sponsor also believes that using the Solactive Index, which is calculated based on timing that mirrors the trading hours of the Shares, to calculate the NAV of the Shares permits market makers and liquidity providers for the Shares to manage their overnight risk exposure more effectively. More effective risk management by these market participants is the primary benefit to these Share liquidity providers from a change to the Solactive Index.
Further, the Solactive Index is derived from data recorded during two time periods – a total period of five minutes and six seconds. Thus, the Solactive Index calculation reflects several thousand trade ticks of actual transactions from hundreds of data contributors for a given calculation day. The Sponsor believes that the broad base of data underlying the Solactive Index calculation reduces the potential for price manipulation affecting NAV calculation.
The Sponsor also believes that the Solactive Index provides enhanced transparency to the calculation of the NAV of the Shares. The Solactive Index is calculated and published by the index calculator no later than 30 minutes following the close of trading on the NYSE on each business day, disseminated to major financial data providers, and made publicly available via the Trust’s website. In contrast, the LBMA Gold Price is only made available to the general public at midnight London time on the day it is set.
As a final background point, the change in the
Trust’s Benchmark Price occurred on August 7, 2023. When the Benchmark Price was changed, no significant discontinuity in the valuation of the Trust’s gold bullion was observed. This continuity of valuation through the index change indicates that both the LBMA Gold
Price and the Solactive Index were and are, respectively, valid measures of the value of the Trust’s gold bullion.
The Trust respectfully informs the Staff that the change in pricing index to the Solactive Index was previously approved, via listing rule amendment process, by the NYSE and the SEC, and took effect on August 7, 2023. As discussed with the Staff, the Sponsor believes that referring to the LBMA Gold Price, or comparing the LBMA Gold Price with the Solactive Index, in the Registration Statement, or in the Trust’s periodic reports under the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, is no longer necessary as the LBMA Gold Price is no longer relevant information for investors in the
Shares. As such, the Trust does not believe any modifications to the disclosures in the Registration Statement are required in response to the Staff’s comment.