Form S-4
We note your response to comment 38. We also note your disclosure in your Form S-1 (File No. 333-249368) that, "[i]n the event we seek to complete our initial business combination with a company that is affiliated with our sponsor, officers or directors, we, or a committee of independent directors, will obtain an opinion from an independent investment banking firm or an independent accounting firm that our initialRest of the question
business combination is fair to our company from a financial point of view." Considering the discussions in your related party section and the disclosures in your initial public offering, please provide us with your legal analysis as to how you determined that an opinion from an independent investment banking firm or an independent accounting firm is not required in connection with this business combination.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant advises the Staff that the analysis as to whether or not to obtain a fairness opinion in connection with this business combination took into account several factors, including, among others, the following: First, as disclosed in Altimar’s registration statement, an undertaking to obtain a fairness opinion was made only in connection with a business combination involving “a company affiliated with our sponsor, officers or directors.” Cognizant of the passive minority investments by Dyal Fund IV in entities affiliated with our sponsor asRead in the replyRest of the answer
described in the related party section of the S-4, Altimar’s board of directors, with the assistance of counsel, reviewed the contractual arrangements between Dyal Fund IV and those entities affiliated with our sponsor to determine whether Dyal Fund IV is an affiliate of our sponsor. The conclusion of this review was that Dyal Fund IV is not an affiliate of our sponsor because Dyal Fund IV holds a minority interest of less than 20% in each such entity, does not have contractual rights that indicate any indicia of control over any such entity and does not have representation (or a contractual right thereto) on any decision making committee or board of any such entity and does not otherwise exercise control over any such entity. This conclusion was consistent with commonly accepted definitions of control as articulated under applicable law, including the Securities Act and the rules promulgated thereunder. Second, the business combination was negotiated on an arm’s length basis among the parties. Third, there is no requirement to obtain a fairness opinion under Cayman corporate law which governs Altimar and the duties of its directors, and a fairness opinion is not obtained in the vast majority of business combination transactions between other SPACs and non-affiliated companies.
Please revise adjustment (e) to discuss how you determined the value of equity consideration for acquired stock and if this measurement represented fair value or refer to the section of the filing that provides this information.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has revised its disclosure on page 217 of Amendment No. 2.Read in the reply
You disclose that FRE and DE adjusts for performance income and performance related compensation. However, the reconciliation on page 288 does not appear to have any adjustments related to these items. Please advise or revise to clarify your disclosure of FRE and DE to more clearly explain your adjustments and why they are appropriate.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has revised its disclosure on page 280 of Amendment No. 2 to clarify that these items are not applicable to Owl Rock.Read in the reply
Please refer to comment 29. In your AUM and FPAUM roll forwards, we note you present changes on a net basis. Please revise each relevant roll forward line item to provide additional detail of the change on a gross basis to the extent material with specific attention to the “Net change to assets” line item.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant advises the Staff that it believes the net presentation of the line items in the AUM and FPAUM rollforwards is useful for investors and appropriate given the substantial majority of each of its AUM and FPAUM is comprised of permanent capital vehicles which do not include material redemption features. In addition,Read in the reply
100% of its AUM and FPAUM is concentrated in products with a remaining life in excess of five years, and is not subject to material fluctuation as a result of market forces.Rest of the answer
As noted under “Available Capital and AUM Not Yet Paying Fees” on pages 283-284 of Amendment No. 2 a number of factors, such as the addition of new funds, may cause fluctuations within AUM and FPAUM. In future periods, to the extent it experiences material redemptions, realizations or other gross reductions in AUM and/or FPAUM, the Registrant undertakes to present those reductions on a gross basis in its rollforwards.
Please refer to comment 35. Please revise your AUM rollforward to present the change in total commitments on a gross basis if materially different than your current net basis presentation.
toRead in the reply
Comment 5
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant advises the Staff that it believes the net presentation of the line items in the AUM rollforward is useful for investors and appropriate given that all of Dyal’s AUM, which is defined as total commitments, is comprised of permanent capital vehicles whose interests have not been subject to redemption and are not redeemable for an extended period. As noted under “Assets Under Management” on page 309 of Amendment No. 2, a number of factors, such as the addition of new funds, may cause fluctuations within AUM.Rest of the answer
In future periods, to the extent Dyal experiences material redemptions, realizations or other gross reductions in AUM, the Registrant undertakes to present those reductions on a gross basis in its rollforward.
Please refer to comment 35. Please revise your fee paying AUM rollforward to present the change in fee paying investor capital base on a gross basis if materially different to your current net basis presentation.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant advises the Staff that it believes the net presentation of the line items in the fee paying AUM rollforward is useful for investors and appropriate given that all of Dyal’s fee paying AUM is comprised of permanent capital vehicles whose interests have not been subject to redemption and are not redeemable for an extended period, and is not subject to material fluctuation as a result of market forces. As noted under “Fee Paying Assets Under Management” on pages 309-310 of Amendment No.Read in the replyRest of the answer
2, a number of factors, such as the addition of new funds, may cause fluctuations within fee paying AUM. In future periods, to the extent Dyal experiences material redemptions, realizations or other gross reductions in fee paying AUM, the Registrant undertakes to present those reductions on a gross basis in its rollforward.
****
If the Staff has any questions concerning this response letter or requires further information, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (212) 373-3309 or David A. Curtiss at (212) 373-3146.
We note adjustments (p), (q) and (ii) appear to relate to similar share-based awards. • Please revise to provide all the facts and circumstances related to the awards discussing any modifications or accelerated vesting provisions, comparing and contrasting the key terms related to each entity, or disclose where this information is presented in your filing.Rest of the question
• Please clearly explain the impact on the pro forma financial information for each entity discussing any key differences. Specifically discuss the impact recognized as part of the business combination and the impact recognized post-combination. • Please clarify why there is not an income statement impact for Owl Rock similar to the charge recognized for Dyal in adjustment (ii).
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has revised its disclosure in (p), (q) and (ii) on pages 223, 224 andRead in the reply
226, respectively, of Amendment No. 3.
We note your disclosure regarding Altimar stockholders having filed lawsuits and others have threatened to file lawsuits. Please update us on the status of these potential lawsuits. Please also provide us with copies of any plaintiff complaints if applicable, or advise. Legal Proceedings, page 270
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant advises the Staff that three purported Altimar stockholders have filed separate complaints in the Supreme Court of the State of New York against Altimar and its board of directors and, in one of the cases, against Owl Rock and Neuberger Berman as well. A fourth purported shareholder has sent Altimar a draft complaint against the Company and its board. Finally, Altimar has also received a demand letter from a fifth purported stockholder.Read in the replyRest of the answer
All of the complaints and the demand letter make materially similar allegations concerning supposed omissions in the
Company’s disclosures. None of these purported shareholders, as of now, has moved for injunctive relief.
The
Registrant advises the Staff that concurrently with the submission of this Response Letter, it has provided a zip file containing the publicly available plaintiff complaints via e-mail to Mr. Envall.
Please advise us on the current status of the legal proceedings discussed here and whether you anticipate they will be resolved prior to effectiveness. Please also include a Question and Answer regarding these legal proceedings, as well as those being brought by Altimar shareholders as discussed under "Legal Proceedings," at page 233.
to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant represents that it has been advised that Neuberger Berman and Dyal continue to vigorously defend these lawsuits and that Neuberger Berman and Dyal continue to believe that the suits and the requests for injunctive relief are meritless.Read in the reply
In GCDM Holdings LP, et al. v. Dyal Capital Partners Mirror Aggregator (A) LP, et al., Index No. 651226/2021 (Sup.
Ct. New York Cnty.) (the “Golub State Court Litigation”), the court issued an order denying the plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction in aid of arbitration on April 2, 2021.Rest of the answer
The court evaluated all of the requirements for granting an injunction, including the likelihood that the plaintiffs’ claims would succeed on the merits of the case, and found that the plaintiffs failed to satisfy any of these requirements. This decision is subject to appeal which, if pursued by the plaintiffs, may not be resolved prior to effectiveness. The Registrant understands that the plaintiffs have not as yet filed an appeal. The Registrant understands that there remains a claim for tortious interference with contract against certain defendants-respondents, and that the defendants-respondents anticipate that this claim will not be resolved before effectiveness.
The Registrant has also been advised that the plaintiffs in the Golub State Court Litigation have separately initiated an arbitration raising similar claims in the American Arbitration Association (“AAA”), captioned GCDM Holdings, LP, GCDM Holdings GP, LLC, v. Dyal Capital Partners Mirror Aggregator A LP, Case 01-21-0002-2092.
The Registrant understands that the respondents in the arbitration do not believe it will be resolved before effectiveness.
In Sixth Street Partners Management Company, L.P., et. al v. Dyal Capital Partners III (A) LP, et. al., C.A.
No. 2021 – 0127 – MTZ (Del. Ch.), the court held a hearing on the plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction on March 24, 2021. The motion remains pending. The Registrant understands that although it is not certain when the trial court will decide the motion, the court has acknowledged the parties’ target closing timeline of the Business Combination. The Registrant understands that the defendants in this action expect a decision on the motion prior to closing. Even if the motion is decided prior to closing, however, it may nevertheless not be decided prior to effectiveness. In addition, (i) the plaintiffs could seek to appeal the decision, which appeal may not be resolved prior to effectiveness, and (ii) the plaintiffs could continue to pursue the action to trial, which the defendants in this action do not believe will be resolved before effectiveness.
The Registrant advises the Staff that it has revised its Question & Answer disclosure regarding these legal proceedings on page 18 of Amendment No. 3 in response to the Staff’s comment.
****
If the Staff has any questions concerning this response letter or requires further information, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (212) 373 3309 or David A. Curtiss at (212) 373-3146.
We note your revised disclosure for adjustment (p) and that based on an evaluation of the facts and circumstances and in contemplation of the guidance provided in ASC 805, you have determined that the modification would be to the benefit of Owl Rock as the accounting acquirer.Rest of the question
• Please tell us the facts and circumstances evaluated related to the modification and the relevant accounting guidance that supports your determination that the modification would be to the benefit of Owl Rock as the accounting acquirer. • Please provide us an accounting analysis comparing the facts and circumstances related to the modification to the factors noted in ASC 805-10-55-18 in determining if the modification was part of the business combination. Also, tell us how you considered the guidance in ASC 805-10-55-24 through 55-26 in your accounting determination.
The Registrant respectfully advises the Staff that it expects to account for the modified Award Units as replacement awards in accordance withRead in the reply
ASC 805-30 because it is obligated to replace the acquiree awards pursuant to the Business Combination Agreement.
Page
In connection with the Business Combination, the vesting of the award is expected to be modified to accelerate the remaining vesting period.Rest of the answer
The Registrant believes the analysis of such expected modifications in these instances require the use of significant judgment to determine whether a portion of the fair-value-based measure of the awards should be recognized as post-combination compensation expense or as a component of the consideration transferred for the acquiree. When determining if the awards should be recognized as post-combination compensation expense or as a component of the consideration transferred for the acquiree, the Registrant considered the following factors from ASC 805-10-55-18:
(a)
The reason for the transaction: to accelerate the vesting schedule of the Award Units as a part of the
Business Combination to ensure that the incentives provided to certain Dyal management members are aligned with the performance of the accounting acquirer;
(b)
Who initiated the transaction: the accounting acquirer initiated the modification to accelerate the vesting; and
(c)
Timing of the transaction: the accounting acquirer expects to modify the agreement in conjunction with the close of the Business Combination.
In consideration of the aforementioned factors, the modification is deemed to be for the benefit of the accounting acquirer.
While the Registrant considered the guidance in ASC 805-10-55-24 through 55-26, the Registrant respectfully advises the Staff that it expects to account for the modified Award Units in accordance with ASC 805-30-30-9. As such, the modifications of the Award Units will be accounted for in accordance with Topic 718. Consistent with the guidance in ASC 805-30-55-7 and 55-8, and further illustrated in ASC 805-30-55-18 and 55-19, the Registrant will determine the portion of a replacement award that is part of the consideration exchanged for the acquiree and the portion that is compensation for post-combination vesting. The portion of the Award Units attributable to pre-combination vesting is the fair-value based measure of the Award Units multiplied by the ratio of the pre-combination employee’s service period to the greater of the total service period or the original service period of the acquiree award. The remaining portion is attributable to the post-combination service period. The vesting of the Award Units is expected to accelerate under the modification, and therefore, the amount attributable to post-combination compensation is expected to be expensed on day one.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has also revised its disclosure in footnotes (p) and (q) on pages 223 and 224 of Amendment No. 4 to indicate our consideration of the requirements under ASC 805 and ASC 718.
We note your revised disclosure for adjustment (p) and disclosure related to adjustment (q). Please revise to clarify how the Dyal Award Units impact the amount of Seller Earnout Securities issued to each entity.
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Registrant has further revised its disclosure in footnote (q) on page 224 of Amendment No. 4.Read in the reply
****
If the Staff has any questions concerning this response letter or requires further information, please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned at (212) 373-3309 or David A. Curtiss at (212) 373-3146.