We note your response and proposed disclosures provided as a result of comment one from our letter dated October 14, 2014. However, we only note brief disclosures explaining how incremental credit quality changes are reflected in your provision for loan losses and corresponding allowance for loan losses. Please tell us and revise your future filings to provide a detailed understanding into the reasons for the changes in your asset quality and how these are reflected in the provision for loan losses and allowance for loan losses.
Rest of the answer
Please provide us with your proposed disclosures.
Page
As noted in the proposed disclosure below, changes in the Company’s asset quality are reflected in the allowance for credit losses in several ways. Any specific reserves included in the allowance are calculated on a loan-by-loan basis and reflect current changes in the credit quality of those loans. Accordingly, when a specific reserve is required, the allowance for credit losses is increased by that amount. The historical credit loss factor used in the allowance methodology, on the other hand, is based on a three-year look back period, which is then applied to estimate credit losses inherent in the loan portfolio. The historical loss factor is calculated quarterly so as to accurately reflect the losses during the prior three-year period. A deterioration in the credit quality of the loan portfolio in the current period would increase the historical credit loss factor to be applied in future periods, just as an improvement in credit quality would decrease the historical credit loss factor.
In addition to the specific reserves identified for impaired loans and historical credit loss information, a change in the allowance for credit losses can be attributable to changes in environmental factors and growth in the balance of legacy loans and the re-categorization, or migration, of fair-valued acquired loans to acquired legacy loans, which subjects such loans to the Company’s allowance methodology.
Because the Company has historically had sound asset quality, resulting in minimal specific reserves and low historical credit losses, the allowance for credit losses is heavily determined by the size of the loan portfolio subject to the allowance methodology and environmental factors that include Company-specific risk indicators and general economic conditions, both of which are constantly changing.
The allowance for credit losses totaled $73.3 million at June 30, 2014 compared with $67.3 million at December 31, 2013, an increase of $6.0 million or 8.9%. At June 30, 2014, $60.0 million of the allowance was attributable to legacy loans, which was essentially unchanged from the allowance of $60.1 million attributable to legacy loans at December 31, 2013. Although the legacy loan balance increased over this period, the increase did not impact the allowance because of the amount of fully secured loans and the lower environmental factors that resulted from the robust regional economy in the Company’s market areas.
At June 30, 2014, $1.9 million of the allowance was attributable to Non-PCI loans compared with $321 thousand of the allowance at
December 31, 2013, an increase of $1.6 million or 500.6%. The increase was primarily attributable to a specific reserve identified for a commercial real estate loan that became impaired.
The remaining $11.3 million of the allowance for credit losses at June 30, 2014 was attributable to acquired legacy loans compared with $6.8 million of the allowance at December 31, 2013, an increase of $4.5 million or 65.5%. The increase was primarily due to the increase in the acquired legacy loan balance as a result of the recategorization of fair valued acquired loans to acquired legacy loans, partially offset by the lower environmental factors.
The Company respectfully submits the following proposed disclosure, which would replace the last paragraph on page 4 and the first and second full paragraphs on page 5 of the Company’s November 12, 2014 response to the Commission’s October 14, 2014 Comment Letter (the “Prior Response”). The proposed disclosure below would also replace the same language that is reproduced on pages B-7 and B-8 of the Prior Response. The Company proposes to include a similar disclosure in its future quarterly and annual reports.
The Company further disaggregates its allowance for credit losses to distinguish between the portion of the allowance attributed to legacy loans and the portion of the allowance attributed to acquired loans. The following table shows the allocation of the allowance for credit losses among various categories of loans disaggregated between legacy loans, acquired legacy loans, Non-PCI loans and PCI loans. The allocation is made for analytical purposes and is not necessarily indicative of the categories in which future losses may occur. The total allowance is available to absorb losses from any loan category, regardless of whether allocated to a legacy loan or an acquired loan.
June 30, 2014
Acquired Loans
Acquired
Total
Percent of Loans
Legacy Loans
Non-PCI Loans
PCI Loans
Allowance to Total Loans
(Dollars in thousands)
Balance of allowance for credit losses applicable
Commercial and industrial
$
4,410
4,809
1,738
—
10,957
23.0
%
Real estate
51,262
6,180
135
57,577
69.4
Agriculture and agriculture real estate
1,172
249
1,448
5.8
Consumer and other
3,167
3,284
1.8
Total allowance for credit losses
60,011
11,327
1,928
73,266
100.0
December 31, 2013
Percent of
Legacy
Non-PCI
Loans to
Loans
Total Loans
Balance of allowance for credit losses applicable to:
6,139
1,831
197
8,167
16.5
51,235
4,889
110
56,234
73.9
1,174
1,229
6.8
1,567
1,652
2.8
60,115
6,846
321
67,282
The allowance for credit losses totaled $73.3 million at June 30, 2014 compared with $67.3 million at
December 31, 2013, an increase of $6.0 million or 8.9%. At June 30, 2014, $60.0 million of the allowance was attributable to legacy loans, which was essentially unchanged from the allowance of $60.1 million attributable to legacy loans at
December 31, 2013. Although the legacy loan balance increased over this period, the increase did not impact the allowance because of the amount of fully secured loans and the lower environmental factors that resulted from the robust regional economy in the Company’s market areas.
At June 30, 2014, $1.9 million of the allowance was attributable to Non-PCI loans compared with $321 thousand of the allowance at December 31, 2013, an increase of $1.6 million or 500.6%. The increase was primarily attributable to a specific reserve identified for a commercial real estate loan that became impaired.
The remaining $11.3 million of the allowance for credit losses at June 30, 2014 was attributable to acquired legacy loans compared with
$6.8 million of the allowance at December 31, 2013, an increase of $4.5 million or 65.5%. The increase was primarily due to the increase in the acquired legacy loan balance as a result of the recategorization of fair valued acquired loans to acquired legacy loans, partially offset by the lower environmental factors.
At June 30, 2014, the Company had $224.1 million of total outstanding discounts on Non-PCI and PCI loans, of which $138.0 million was accretable.
A change in the allowance for credit losses can be attributable to several factors, most notably (1) specific reserves identified for impaired loans, (2) historical credit loss information, (3) changes in environmental factors and (4) growth in the balance of legacy loans and the re-categorization of fair-valued acquired loans to acquired legacy loans, which subjects such loans to the allowance methodology.
Changes in the Company’s asset quality are reflected in the allowance in several ways. Specific reserves are calculated on a loan-by-loan basis and reflect current changes in the credit quality of the loan portfolio. Historical credit losses, on the other hand, are based on a three-year look back period, which are then applied to estimate current credit losses inherent in the loan portfolio. A deterioration in the credit quality of the loan portfolio in the current period would increase the historical credit loss factor to be applied in future periods, just as an improvement in credit quality would decrease the historical credit loss factor.
The allowance for credit losses is further determined by the size of the loan portfolio subject to the allowance methodology and environmental factors that include Company-specific risk indicators and general economic conditions, both of which are constantly changing. The Company evaluates the environmental and economic factors on an annual basis to determine both the factors considered and the relative weighting of such factors. Through the application on a quarterly basis of such factors, including credit concentrations; delinquency trends; economic and business conditions; the quality of lending management and staff; lending policies and procedures; loss and recovery trends; nature and volume of the portfolio; nonaccrual and problem loan trends; and other adjustments for items not covered by other factors, the Company ensures the allowance methodology incorporates recent trends and economic conditions as it estimates the imminent losses embedded in the loan portfolio.
As described in the section captioned “Critical Accounting Policies” above, the Company’s determination of the allowance for credit losses involves a high degree of judgment and complexity. The Company’s analysis of qualitative, or environmental, factors on pools of loans with common risk characteristics, in combination with the quantitative historical loss information and specific reserves, provides the Company with an estimate of possible future losses. The allowance must reflect changes in the balance of loans subject to the allowance methodology, as well as the estimated imminent losses associated with those loans. In the Company’s case, due to the strong regional economy reducing the environmental factors, minimal specific reserves and historically low credit losses, the $6.0 million increase in the allowance for credit losses during the first six months of 2014 was primarily attributable to the growth in the loan portfolio.