Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2024
We note your disclosure that the Board’s action to reduce the size of the Board and the number of Class II directors is “unlawful.” Please provide a formal opinion of counsel, supported by appropriate legal analysis, that such actions were in violation of Pennsylvania law.
No reply letter found.
Refer to comment 1. Please revise to disclose any pending legal proceedings regarding this matter. Refer to the following disclosure, which appears multiple times in your proxy statement: “The GOLD universal proxy card shall be null and void ab initio and of no force or effect if it would have the effect of entitling shareholders of the Company to demand payment for their shares under Subchapter E of Chapter 25 ofRest of the question
the Pennsylvania Business Corporation Law.” Please revise to clarify when such card would have the effect of entitling shareholders of the Company to demand payment for their shares under Subchapter E of Chapter 25 of the Pennsylvania Business 3. Corporation Law. 4. We note the references throughout your proxy statement to the Company’s “white universal proxy card.” However, the Company does not appear to be using a universal proxy card. Please revise or advise.
No reply letter found.
We note that your proxy statement was filed under EDGAR tag "DEF 14A," as opposed to EDGAR tag "PREC14A," the latter of which is used for contested solicitations. Please provide a detailed legal analysis supporting your determination that your solicitation does not constitute a contested solicitation.
SummaryRead in the reply
We respectfully submit to the Staff that PENN’s solicitation of proxies in connection with its 2025 annual meeting of shareholders (the “2025 Annual Meeting”) does not constitute a contested solicitation because, as described in greater detail below, (i) PENN’s Board of Directors (the “Board”), pursuant to its clear authority under Pennsylvania corporate law and PENN’s organizational documents, has determined that there will only be two director seats available for election at the 2025 Annual Meeting, (ii) both PENN and HG Vora (as defined below), as set forth in their respectiveRest of the answer
recent public filings, intend to solicit proxies in favor of the same two candidates—Johnny Hartnett and
Carlos Ruisanchez—for election to those two available seats and (iii) HG Vora has publicly stated that it does not make any recommendation with respect to any other proposal included in the PENN Proxy Statement.
Factual Background
The Board is a classified board which, prior to April 25, 2025, had nine directors consisting of three directors in each of Class I, Class II and Class III serving three year terms. The three directors in Class II—Ronald J. Naples, Barbara Shattuck Kohn and Saul Reibstein—had terms of office expiring at the 2025 Annual Meeting.
On April 25, 2025, Mr. Naples resigned from the Board effective immediately.
In connection with Mr. Naples’ resignation, acting pursuant to its authority under Section 4.03(a) of the Fifth Amended and Restated
Bylaws of PENN (the “PENN Bylaws”) and Section 1723(a) of the Pennsylvania Business Corporation Law, the Board decreased the size of the Board from nine to eight members and decreased the number of Class II directors from three to two. Also on April 25, 2025,
Ms. Kohn and Mr. Reibstein notified the Board of their respective decisions not to stand for reelection to the Board at the 2025 Annual
Meeting, resulting in two (and only two) Class II Board seats becoming available for other candidates to be nominated and elected thereto.
On the morning of April 28, 2025, PENN filed the PENN Proxy Statement setting forth, among other things, the Board’s unanimous nomination and recommendation that PENN shareholders vote in favor of Messrs.
Hartnett and Ruisanchez for the two director seats available for election at the 2025 Annual Meeting.
Later on April 28, 2025, HG Vora Capital Management, LLC (“HG
Vora Capital”), HG Vora Special Opportunities Master Fund, Ltd. (“Master Fund”), Downriver Series LP –
Segregated Portfolio C (“Downriver”) and Parag Vora (collectively with HG Vora Capital, Master Fund and Downriver,
“HG Vora”) filed a preliminary proxy statement (the “HG Vora Proxy Statement”). The HG Vora Proxy
Statement stated that “If there are two Class II director seats up for election, then the enclosed GOLD universal proxy card will only be voted in accordance with your instructions with respect to Messrs. Hartnett and Ruisanchez and will not be voted with respect to William Clifford. If there are three Class II director seats up for election, the enclosed GOLD universal proxy card will be voted in accordance with your instruction with respect to Messrs. Hartnett, Ruisanchez and Clifford.”1
The HG Vora Proxy Statement also provided that HG Vora makes no recommendation with respect to any other proposal included in the PENN
Proxy Statement.2
Under Pennsylvania Law, the Size of PENN’s Board Is Set Solely by PENN’s Board
PENN is a Pennsylvania corporation. The Pennsylvania Business
Corporation Law provides that “The number of directors shall be fixed by, or in the manner provided in, the bylaws. If not so fixed, the number of directors shall be the same as that stated in the articles or three if no number is so stated.”3
The Second Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation of PENN (the “PENN Articles”) provide that “the number of Directors of the Corporation shall be fixed from time to time by or pursuant to the Bylaws of the Corporation”4 and the PENN Bylaws provide that “the number of directors of the Corporation constituting the whole board and the number of directors constituting each class of directors as provided by Section 4.03(d) [Classified Board of Directors] shall be fixed (and may be changed from time to time) solely by resolution of the board of directors” (emphasis added).5
Pursuant to the Board’s actions on April 25, 2025, the Board is comprised of eight members and there are two Class II director seats up for election at the 2025 Annual Meeting.
See page 21 of the HG Vora Proxy Statement.
See page 24 of the HG Vora Proxy Statement.
15 PA Cons Stat § 1723(a) (2024).
Article Ninth, Section 6(a) of the PENN Articles. The PENN Articles were filed as Exhibit 99.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed by PENN on June 21, 2021.
Section 4.03(a) of the PENN Bylaws. The Penn Bylaws were filed as Exhibit 3.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed by PENN on November
12, 2024.
PENN Is Not Required to File a Preliminary Proxy Statement Unless
There Is a “Solicitation in Opposition”
Rule 14a-6(a)6 of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Exchange Act”) provides that a registrant shall not file a preliminary proxy statement with the SEC if the solicitation relates to an annual meeting and only to, among other things, the election of directors, the election, approval or ratification of accountant(s), a security holder proposal included pursuant to Rule 14a-8 of the Exchange Act, the approval or ratification of a plan as defined in paragraph (a)(6)(ii) of Item 402 of Regulation S-K of the Exchange Act and/or a shareholder advisory vote on executive compensation.7
The PENN Proxy Statement satisfied such requirements.8
Rule 14a-6(a) further provides that this exclusion from filing a preliminary proxy statement “does not apply if the registrant comments upon or refers to a solicitation in opposition in connection with the meeting in its proxy material.”9 Note
3 to Rule 14a-6(a) clarifies that for these purposes a “solicitation in opposition” includes: “(a) Any solicitation opposing a proposal supported by the registrant; (b) any solicitation supporting a proposal that the registrant does not expressly support, other than a security holder proposal included in the registrant’s proxy material pursuant to § 240.14a-8; and (c) any solicitation subject to § 240.14a-19.”10
The HG Vora Proxy Statement provides no recommendation with respect to any proposal other than the election of the Class II directors; accordingly, clauses (a) and (b) of Note 3 to Rule 14a(6)(a) are not applicable to the PENN Proxy Statement. With respect to clause (c) (relating to solicitations subject to Rule 14a-19 of the Exchange Act11), we note that both PENN and HG Vora are soliciting proxies in support of the same two individuals for the only two Class II director seats up for election at the 2025 Annual Meeting—Johnny Hartnett and Carlos Ruisanchez, and neither PENN nor HG Vora is soliciting proxies in opposition to any other candidate or proposal set forth in either the PENN Proxy Statement or the HG Vora Proxy Statement.
The HG Vora Proxy Statement purports to additionally solicit votes in favor of Mr. Clifford, but only if there are three Class II director seats up for election: HG Vora states clearly that the gold proxy card will not be voted with respect to the Mr. Clifford if (as the Board has determined is the case) there are only two Class II director seats up for election. Therefore, PENN has determined that Rule 14a-19 no longer applies to its solicitation, and there is no
“solicitation in opposition” to PENN’s proposal to elect Messrs. Hartnett and Ruisanchez or any other proposal set forth in the PENN Proxy Statement.
17 CFR § 240.14a-6(a).
The PENN Proxy Statement has five proposals: (i) the election of the two Class II directors; (ii) the ratification of appointment of PENN’s independent registered public accounting firm, (iii) an advisory vote to approve the compensation of Named Executive Officers, (iv) approval of the second amendment to PENN’s 2022 Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plan and (v) approval, on an advisory basis, of a shareholder proposal regarding the commissioning of a report on the effects of a company-wide non-smoking policy.
Id.
17 CFR § 240.14a-19.
Applicable Staff Guidance
We note that the Staff has provided guidance on analogous circumstances involving a potential dispute under state law between a registrant and a dissident shareholder with respect to director nominations. Question
139.05 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations for the Proxy Rules and Schedule 14A/14C (the “C&DI”) provides guidance in a circumstance where (i) a registrant determines that a dissident shareholder’s director nominations do not comply with its advance notice bylaw requirements, (ii) the registrant accordingly excludes the dissident shareholder’s nominees from its proxy card and (iii) the dissident shareholder then initiates litigation challenging the registrant’s determination regarding the validity of the director nominations.
The C&DI confirms that, in such circumstances, a registrant may proceed with its solicitation utilizing a non-universal proxy card provided that the registrant discloses in its proxy statement its determination that the dissident shareholder’s director nominations are invalid, a brief description of the basis for that determination, the fact that the dissident shareholder initiated litigation challenging the determination, and the potential implications (including any risks to the registrant or its shareholders) if the dissident shareholder’s nominations are ultimately deemed to be valid. The C&DI also states that, in the event the dissident shareholder ultimately prevails in such litigation, registrants should discard previously issued proxy cards that excluded the dissident candidate and ensure shareholders have sufficient time to receive and cast their votes on revised universal proxy cards.
The circumstances here are analogous to those described in the C&DI since, in both cases, the registrant has determined under applicable state law that a dissident’s nominee cannot be elected to the
Board regardless of whether any shareholders purport to vote in favor of such individual. Although no litigation has to PENN’s knowledge been initiated as of the submission time of this letter, a letter dated April 28, 2025 from HG Vora’s outside counsel to PENN’s outside counsel alleges, among other things, that the Board violated its fiduciary duties under Pennsylvania law by reducing the size of the Board and the number of Class II directors and that PENN violated the federal securities laws and universal proxy rules by omitting the name of a validly nominated candidate, Mr. Clifford.
While PENN believes that these assertions are baseless, the Company will of course comply with the C&DI in all respects in the event litigation is initiated.
First report after the company's reply of May 2, 2025: 10-Q filed May 12, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please revise to disclose who recommended Mr. Hartnett and Mr. Ruisanchez to the Board. See Item 407(c)(2)(vii) of Regulation S-K.
Concurrently with the submission of this letter, PENN has filed DefinitiveRead in the reply
Additional Materials on Schedule 14A disclosing that HG Vora recommended Messrs. Hartnett and Ruisanchez to the Board.
First report after the company's reply of May 2, 2025: 10-Q filed May 12, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Refer to your disclosure on the first page of your preliminary proxy statement that “[d]espite the Company naming Mr. Hartnett and Mr. Ruisanchez in its definitive proxy statement, in light of the Company’s eleventh-hour switch regarding its intended nominees, there can be no assurances that either of Mr. Hartnett or Mr.Rest of the question
Ruisanchez will in fact be the Company’s nominees for election to the Board at the Annual Meeting.” The same disclosure appears on page 25. Please revise to remove the implication that, even if Mr. Hartnett and Mr. Ruisanchez will serve as nominees, the Company could use its discretionary authority to nominate a different nominee.
No reply letter found.
We note that your proxy card presents Mr. Hartnett and Mr. Ruisanchez under the title “HG VORA’S NOMINEES.” For clarity, please revise the title to present such nominees as nominees of both HG Vora and the Company.
No reply letter found.
Your disclosure indicates that “under the current circumstances of a contested election, none of the proposals are considered ‘routine’ and, accordingly, if you are a beneficial owner holding shares of Common Stock through a broker and we have provided our solicitation materials to you with respect to such shares, your broker is not permitted to vote your shares of Common Stock on any proposal without receivingRest of the question
instructions from you.” We note, however, that the Company’s proxy statement indicates that Proposal 2, the ratification of the selection of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as the Company’s independent registered public accounting firm, is considered routine, without qualification. Please revise your disclosure accordingly, or provide support for your assertion that brokers, in the circumstances you describe, will not be permitted to vote shares of Common Stock on the auditor ratification proposal without receiving instructions from shareholders.
No reply letter found.
First report after the SEC's letter of May 8, 2025: 10-Q filed May 12, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your disclosure that Adjusted EBITDAR is presented on a consolidated basis outside the financial statements solely as a valuation metric and that it should not be viewed as a measure of overall operating performance. We further note your inclusion of Adjusted EBITDAR margin on a consolidated basis.Rest of the question
Please tell us what consideration you gave to your inclusion of this margin resulting in Adjusted EBITDAR also being viewed as a measure of your overall operating performance. This comment also applies to your earnings release. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
This letter responds to the comment from the staff (the “Staff”) of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) set forth in its letter dated July 29, 2025 (the “Comment Letter”) in connection with the AnnualRead in the reply
Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2024 (the “2024 Form 10-K”) of PENN Entertainment, Inc.Rest of the answer
Except where indicated otherwise, the terms “PENN,” the “Company,” “we,” “our,” or “us” shall mean PENN Entertainment, Inc., and its consolidated subsidiaries.
For the convenience of the Staff, the Company has restated in this letter the comments in the Comment Letter in bold italics, followed by the Company’s response. Capitalized terms used but not defined herein have the meanings given to them in the relevant SEC filing. All references to page numbers and captions (other than those in the comments) correspond to the page numbers in the 2024 Form 10-K.
P 610.373.2400
825 Berkshire Blvd.
Wyomissing, PA 19610 pennentertainment.com
Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Results of Operations, page 38
Comment 1.
We note your disclosure that Adjusted EBITDAR is presented on a consolidated basis outside the financial statements solely as a valuation metric and that it should not be viewed as a measure of overall operating performance. We further note your inclusion of Adjusted EBITDAR margin on a consolidated basis. Please tell us what consideration you gave to your inclusion of this margin resulting in Adjusted EBITDAR also being viewed as a measure of your overall operating performance. This comment also applies to your earnings release.
Company’s Response: In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that the Company will not disclose Adjusted EBITDAR margin on a consolidated basis beginning with our earnings release and Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2025.
The Company also advises the Staff that, in future filings beginning for the quarter ended September 30, 2025, we will no longer disclose Adjusted EBITDAR on a consolidated basis and will only present Adjusted EBITDAR as our segment measure of segment profit or loss, which will be labeled “Segment Adjusted EBITDAR.” Furthermore, for clarity in future filings beginning for the quarter ended September 30, 2025, “Adjusted EBITDA” will be labeled “Consolidated
Adjusted EBITDA.”
First report after the company's reply of Aug 7, 2025: 10-Q filed Nov 6, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 7, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2025-08-19