The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment. Set forth in the table below are the stock options granted by D-Wave from July 1, 2021 through the filing of the Registration Statement, including the fair value of the underlying D-Wave Common Shares used to value such awards at the grant date.
Rest of the answer
2021
20-Aug-21
1,687,602
$
0.82
3.67
27,900
747,995
No options granted after Aug 20, 2021
—
November 30, 2021
N/A
5.72
The fair value of the underlying D-Wave Common Shares outlined below were determined by third-party valuations. The third-party valuations were prepared using methodologies, approaches, and assumptions consistent with the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (“AICPA”)
Accounting & Valuation Guide, Valuation of Privately-Held-Company Equity Securities Issued as Compensation (“Practice Guide”).
March 2021 Valuation
As set forth in the table above, the only options granted from July 1, 2021 onwards were options granted on August 20, 2021. D-Wave granted options to purchase an aggregate of 2,463,497 D-Wave Common Shares at an exercise price of $0.82 per share.
The
D-Wave Board determined the fair value of the shares as of the grant date to be $0.82 per share based on a number of factors, including D-Wave’s third party valuation, dated March 31, 2021 (the “March 2021 Valuation”), which determined the fair value of the shares to be $0.82 per share as of such date using the Option Pricing Method (“OPM”). The OPM calculation was primarily based on D-Wave’s prior financing transaction, completed in April 2020, using the Back Solve Method, and also reflected the following considerations:
the prices at which D-Wave sold shares of redeemable convertible preferred stock and the superior rights and preferences of the redeemable convertible preferred stock relative to its common shares at the time of each grant;
external market conditions affecting the research and development industry and trends within the industry;
D-Wave’s stage of development and business strategy;
D-Wave’s financial condition and operating results, including its levels of available capital resources, and forecasted results;
developments in D-Wave’s business;
the progress of D-Wave’s research and development efforts;
equity market conditions affecting comparable public companies; and general market conditions and the lack of marketability of its common shares.
November 2021 Valuation
On August 23, 2021, D-Wave entered into a Letter of Intent (“LOI”) regarding a business combination with DPCM. In light of the LOI and potential transaction contemplated thereby, D-Wave’s management and a third-party valuation firm performed a valuation of D-Wave’s Common Shares as of November 30, 2021 (the “November 2021 Valuation”). Following the execution of the LOI, D-Wave did not grant any additional options.
For the November 2021 Valuation, a hybrid method was determined to be the most appropriate methodology for determining the fair value of D-Wave Common Shares at such time. Two scenarios were examined: (1) the SPAC scenario (the “SPAC Scenario”), and (2) the stay private scenario (the “Stay
Private Scenario”).
The SPAC Scenario represented the potential future value of the D-Wave
Common Shares upon a SPAC transaction like the one contemplated by the LOI. The SPAC price, based on the exit value and total diluted shares contemplated by the LOI, was then discounted at a 35.0% cost of capital to arrive at the implied marketable
SPAC price as of November 30, 2021. The application of the discount was reasonable because the exit value represented a potential future value subject to significant uncertainty, and the SPAC price was risk adjusted to consider inherent risks related to completing a SPAC transaction.
The Stay Private Scenario represented the value of D-Wave if it were to continue operating as a private company. In considering valuation approaches for D-Wave, the third-party valuation firm relied on the market and income approaches.
The final valuation methodology employed a hybrid approach between the Probability-Weighted Expected Return Method (“PWERM”) and OPM, estimating the probability weighted value across multiple scenarios but using the OPM to estimate the allocation of value within one or more of those scenarios. The hybrid method was deemed to be an effective alternative to explicitly modeling all PWERM scenarios because D-wave was explicitly contemplating a potential near-term transaction but was unsure as to whether such proposed transaction would result in a definitive agreement and ultimately be completed.
The resulting fair value of $5.72 per D-Wave Common Share was derived based on a weighted value assigned to the Stay Private Scenario and SPAC Scenario of 25% and 75%, respectively, based on the probability of each scenario, as well as applying a 25% and 9% Discount for Lack of Marketability, respectively. D-Wave assigned a 75% probability to the SPAC Scenario based on the LOI and subsequent negotiations with DPCM prior to the November 2021 Valuation, as a result of which D-Wave determined that the SPAC Scenario was significantly more probable, though still uncertain.
Reassessment of 2021 Awards
To calculate and record stock-based compensation charges, D-Wave retrospectively assessed the fair value of its common shares in connection with its equity awards during the year ended December 31, 2021 using a linear interpolation methodology between respective valuation dates. D-Wave determined that linear interpolation provides the most reasonable basis for the valuation of the D-Wave Common Shares during 2021 because D-Wave did not identify any significant events or changes with respect to its business, operations or prospects that occurred during the period between valuation dates that would have caused a material change in fair value.
Transaction Implied Fair Value
On February 8, 2022, D-Wave and DPCM announced that they had entered into a definitive agreement with respect to the Transaction, which reflected a pre-money equity value for D-Wave of $1.2 billion and implied a fair value up to $10.00 per D-Wave Common Share. While the valuations of D-Wave Common Shares for financial reporting purposes were determined in accordance with the guidelines set forth in the Practice
Guide, D-Wave’s determination of fair value per share in connection with the Transaction was based on 2026 estimated revenues and a revenue multiple, discounted back to 2021.
The Exchange Ratio provided for in the Transaction Agreement is based on the same $1.2 billion pre-money equity valuation of D-Wave as was used in the SPAC Scenario in the November 2021 Valuation. The increase in implied fair value is due to the increase in the probability of the Transaction being completed.
15. Earnings per share, page F-38