Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021
We note you acquired Genesis Capital LLC during 2021 for cash consideration of approximately $1.63 billion. Please tell us how you considered the requirements to provide audited financial statements of the acquired business in accordance with Rule 305 of Regulation S-X, and unaudited pro forma financial information related to this transaction in accordance with Article 11 of Regulation S-X.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and informs the Staff that the Company’s evaluation of the guidance in Rule 3-05 and Article 11 of Regulation S-X in determining the need to provide separate financial statements and pro forma financial information related to New Residential’s (i) business acquisition of Genesis Capital LLC (“Genesis”) and (ii) asset purchase comprising a portfolio of loans originated by Genesis (the “Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio”) owned by Broad Street Principal Investments, LLC, and Goldman Sachs Bank, both affiliates of The Goldman SachsRead in the replyRest of the answer
Group, Inc. (“Goldman Sachs”) is as follows:
On October 10, 2021, the Company filed a Form 8-K announcing that it had entered into a definitive agreement with Goldman Sachs to acquire Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio. On December 20, 2021, the Company filed a Form 8-K announcing that it had completed its business acquisition of Genesis and purchase of assets comprising the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio from Goldman Sachs, together for an aggregate purchase price of approximately $1.63 billion, concurrently with in-place financing from Goldman Sachs of approximately $1.26 billion. The Company’s equity investment in Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio was determined to be approximately $175 million and $200 million, respectively. Please refer to the “Identifying Business Acquisitions Involving Multiple Transactions” section below for further discussion regarding the Company’s assessment of the Genesis acquisition and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio purchase on a combined basis for accounting purposes under U.S. GAAP versus separately for reporting purposes under Regulation S-X.
The Company applied the guidance in Rule 3-05 and Article 11 of Regulation S-X and assessed the significance of Genesis using the three testing criteria defined in Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X: (i) investment test, (ii) asset test and (iii) income test and compared, for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2020, the financial statements of Genesis to the Company. Based on this analysis, as discussed below, the Company concluded that none of the three testing criteria conditions exceeded 20%. Consequently, the Company determined that the acquisition of Genesis was not deemed to be significant and therefore the separate financial statements and pro forma financial information in connection with the acquisition of Genesis were not required, as set forth in more detail below:
Investment Test
The table below summarizes the significant subsidiary investment test per Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X followed by the Company’s application of Rule 1-02(w):
Numerator Denominator
Market Value Registrant’s and its other subsidiaries investments in, and advances to the tested subsidiary.
Registrant’s aggregate worldwide market value of its voting and non-voting common equity, calculated daily from the last five trading days of the most recently completed month ending prior to the earlier of the registrant’s announcement date or agreement date of the acquisition or disposition, or total consolidated assets where the registrant has no such aggregate worldwide market value.
The Company measured the significance of the Genesis acquisition using the investment test by comparing (i) the Company’s investment in Genesis of $175 million to (ii) the aggregate worldwide market value of the Company’s voting and non-voting common equity. In determining the aggregate worldwide market value of the Company’s voting and non-voting common equity, the Company used the average of such aggregate worldwide market value calculated daily for the last five trading days of September 2021, the Company’s most recently completed month ending prior to the earlier of the Company’s announcement date or agreement date of the Genesis acquisition. The Company calculated such aggregate worldwide market value as approximately $5.2 billion. Based on these amounts, the investment test resulted in a significance of 3.4%.
Asset Test
The table below summarizes the significant subsidiary asset test per Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X followed by the Company’s application of Rule 1-02(w):
Proportionate Share Registrant’s and its other subsidiaries’ proportionate share of total assets of the tested subsidiary (after intercompany eliminations) as of the end of the most recently completed fiscal year. Registrant’s and its subsidiaries’ consolidated total assets (after intercompany eliminations) as of the end of the most recently completed fiscal year.
The Company measured the significance of the Genesis acquisition using the asset test by comparing, as of December 31, 2020: (i) the consolidated total assets of Genesis of $95 million against (ii) the consolidated total assets of the Company and its subsidiaries of $33.2 billion. Based on these amounts, the asset test resulted in a significance of less than 1%.
Income Test
The table below summarizes the significant subsidiary income test per Rule 1-02(w) of Regulation S-X followed by the Company’s application of Rule 1-02(w):
Net Income Component(1)
Absolute value of the registrant’s and its other subsidiaries’ equity in the tested subsidiary’s consolidated income or loss from continuing operations before income taxes (after intercompany eliminations) attributable to the controlling interests for the most recently completed fiscal year. Absolute value of the registrant’s and its subsidiaries’ consolidated income or loss from continuing operations before income taxes (after intercompany eliminations) for the most recently completed fiscal year.
Revenue Component(1)
Registrant’s and its other subsidiaries’ proportionate share of the tested subsidiary’s consolidated total revenues (after intercompany eliminations) for the most recently completed fiscal year. Registrant’s and its subsidiaries’ consolidated total revenues (after intercompany eliminations) for the most recently completed fiscal year.
(1) Significance is measured using the lower result of the net income or revenue component.
The Company measured the significance of the Genesis acquisition by first using the revenue component of the income test by comparing Genesis’s revenue in 2020 of approximately $85 million against the Company’s revenue in 2020 of $1.67 billion. Based on these amounts, the revenue component of the income test resulted in a significance of approximately 5%. Because the Genesis acquisition is not significant at a level of greater than 20% based on the revenue component of the income test, the Company did not measure the significance of the Genesis acquisition using the net income component of the income test.
Identifying Business Acquisitions Involving Multiple Transactions
In regard to the acquisition of assets involving multiple arrangements or transactions, an acquiring entity is required to determine whether the transfer of assets should be accounted for as a single transaction or as separate transactions. The distinction is important given the reporting and accounting implications under Regulation S-X and U.S. GAAP, respectively. The Company has outlined below its assessment regarding whether to account for the acquisition of assets involving multiple arrangements as a single transaction or separate transactions. Further, the Company believes this assessment depends on facts and circumstances and requires the use of significant judgment. As part of this assessment, the Company considered the accounting guidance per the Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification (“ASC”) Topic 805, Business Combinations (“ASC 805”), interpretive commentary in the EY Financial Reporting Development – Business Combinations guide (the “EY FRD”), as well as guidance provided in Rule 11-01(d) and Rule 3-05 of Regulation S-X, together with the guidance of the Staff contained in Sections 2010.1 and 2015.12 of the Division of Corporation Finance Financial Reporting Manual (“FRM”) noting that the assessment for accounting purposes under U.S. GAAP and reporting purposes under Regulation S-X may differ.
For reporting purposes under Regulation S-X, the Company believes the determination as to whether multiple transactions should be considered as a single transaction requires an entity to first assess whether each arrangement meets the definition of a “business” in accordance with Rule 11-01(d). Once established, any “related businesses” as defined in Section 2015.12 of the FRM are grouped together and treated as a single transaction. For reporting purposes, the Company assessed the Genesis acquisition separately from the acquisition of the Mortgage
Loans Receivable Portfolio and evaluated whether each acquisition met the definition of a “business.” Based on the Company’s assessment, only the Genesis acquisition met the definition of a “business.”
For accounting purposes under U.S. GAAP, the Company believes the determination as to whether multiple transactions should be considered as a single transaction requires an entity to first consider all of the terms and conditions of the arrangements and their economic effects, including, but not limited to, assessing whether the multiple transactions are entered into at the same time or in contemplation of one another. If an acquirer determines that multiple transactions should be accounted for as a single transaction, the acquirer then applies the definition of a business in accordance with ASC 805 and the transaction is accounted for under the acquisition method in accordance with ASC 805 if it is determined that the acquirer obtained control of a business. For accounting purposes, the Company determined that the Genesis acquisition and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio purchase should be accounted for together as a single transaction and further determined that it had obtained control of a business in accordance with ASC 805.
The discussion below sets forth the Company’s analysis in more detail:
Reporting Assessment
In accordance with Section 2015.12 of the FRM, acquisitions of “related businesses” must be treated as a single business acquisition. Businesses are related under Rule 3-05 of Regulation S-X if:
1.They are under common control or management; or
First report after the company's reply of Jun 7, 2022: 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 6, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your disclosure of core earnings in your earnings release at Exhibit 99.1. This non-GAAP measure includes adjustments for various realized and unrealized gains (losses) and credit loss provision. In light of these adjustments, please tell us how you determined it was appropriate to title this measure as core earnings.Rest of the question
Further, our understanding is that this measure is commonly used by mortgage REITs as an indicator of dividend paying ability. Please tell us if this measure is used by the registrant's management as an indicator of the registrant's dividend paying ability. If so, please revise your filing to disclose that purpose.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and will revise the title of core earnings to “Earnings Available for Distribution” starting with the Company’s earnings release for the quarter ended June 30, 2022. Earnings available for distribution is one of the factors that the Company’s board of directors considers in determining the amount, if any, and the payment date of dividends on the Company’s common stock.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company will include its disclosure regarding how Earnings Available for Distribution can serve as a useful indicator for investors in evaluating the Company’s performance and its ability to pay dividends. Furthermore, the Company will also include disclosure on how Earnings Available for Distribution is different from REIT taxable income.
We note your response to our comment 1. Please address the following: • We note you entered into the agreement to purchase Genesis Capital LLC ("Genesis") and a portfolio of loans originated by Genesis ("the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio") owned by Broad Street Principal Investments, LLC and Goldman Sachs Bank.Rest of the question
Please expand on the relationship between Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio, including but not limited to, the Genesis initial involvement with respect to such loans, their ongoing involvement, and their involvement immediately prior to the date you acquired these loans. • Please tell us how long the loans were held by Genesis and how long the loans were held by entities other than Genesis prior to your acquisition of such loans. • We note the agreement included in-place financing from Goldman Sachs of approximately $1.26 billion. Please provide us with additional information regarding the terms of this in-place financing. Within your response, please clarify if such financing is seller provided financing or if such financing existed prior to your purchase of Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio. • Please clarify how you allocated the aggregate purchase price of $1.63 billion between Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio. Within your response, please clarify your basis for such allocation. • Please clarify how you allocated the $1.26 billion of in-place financing between Genesis and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio. Within your response, please clarify your basis for such allocation.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and informs the Staff that the Company’s basis for separating the acquisition transactions into two distinct components when determining whether Rule 3-05 financial statements were necessary is as follows:Read in the reply
While the form of the acquisition of Genesis and the purchase of the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio were consummated as part of a single purchase agreement, the Company believes the acquisition and purchase are two separate transactions and treated them as such.Rest of the answer
The Company’s basis for reaching this conclusion is supported by the negotiations and structuring of the purchase agreement for the transactions (the “Purchase Agreement”) as well as the industry and market practice for such transactions. More specifically:
1.The Purchase Agreement was negotiated and entered into with two separate sellers, both affiliates of Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.:
a.“Platform Seller” (Broad Street Principal Investments LLC); and b.“Loan Seller” (Goldman Sachs Bank, N.A.);
Further, as outlined in greater detail in the Company’s response to the Staff on June 28, 2022, prior to the Company’s purchase of the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio, the Loan Seller maintained its own underwriting, accounting and bookkeeping functions, utilized an unaffiliated third party for loan servicing and engaged Genesis to perform portfolio management services pursuant to a services agreement. Genesis operated a loan origination platform and sourced the mortgage loans underlying the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio exclusively for the benefit of the Loan Seller.
First report after the company's reply of Aug 23, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 3, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 6, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to comment 1 from our letter dated June 21, 2022 and your response to comment 1 from our letter dated May 25, 2022. Based on your responses, it appears that you separated the acquisition transaction into two distinct components when determining whether Rule 3-05 financial statements were necessary.Rest of the question
Given this acquisition appears to be a single transaction, please explain to us how you determined it was appropriate to separate the transaction into two components when performing the significant tests in accordance with Rule 3-05 and Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X.
No reply letter found.
First report after the SEC's letter of Aug 3, 2022: 10-Q filed Aug 5, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 6, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to comment 1. Please address the following: • Please provide us with a copy of the contract for the acquisition. • Please provide a more detailed analysis on how you determined it was appropriate to separate the transaction into two components (the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and Genesis Capital LLC) when determining whether you have acquired a business pursuant to Rule 11-01(d) ofRest of the question
Regulation S-X. Within your response, please reference any authoritative guidance relied upon to separate the transaction into two components. • We note in your June 28, 2022 response to comment 1 that Genesis performed portfolio management services for the purchased Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio before the acquisition. Please confirm if Genesis continues to perform such services for these loans after the acquisition. Please tell us how you considered this factor into your analysis to separate the transaction into two components. • Please tell us if Genesis performs portfolio management services for any of your other loan portfolios. • Please tell us the business purpose, if any, for acquiring the two components together. • Please tell us if the acquisition the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio was conditioned on the acquisition of Genesis, or vice versa.
The following numbered responses correspond to each bullet point in the foregoing comment from the Staff:Read in the reply
(1) The Company has supplementally provided to the Staff a complete copy of the purchase agreement under separate cover.
(2) The Company’s determination in separating the transaction into two components (the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and Genesis Capital LLC (“Genesis”)) when determining whether the Company acquired a business pursuant to Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X is as follows:
While the form of the acquisition of Genesis and the purchase of the Mortgage LoansRest of the answer
Receivable Portfolio were consummated as part of a single purchase agreement, the Company believes the acquisition and purchase are two separate transactions and treated them as such. The Company’s basis for reaching this conclusion is supported by the negotiations and structuring of the purchase agreement for the transactions as well as the industry and market practice for such transactions.
Under Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X, the term “business” should be evaluated in light of the facts and circumstances involved and whether there is sufficient continuity of the acquired entity’s operations prior to and after the transactions so that disclosure of prior financial information is material to an understanding of future operations. A presumption exists that a separate entity, a subsidiary, or a division is a business. Among the facts and circumstances which should be considered in evaluating whether an acquisition of a lesser component of an entity constitutes a business are the following: (a) Whether the nature of the revenue-producing activity of the component will remain generally the same as before the transaction; and (b) Whether any of the following attributes remain with the component after the transaction: (i) physical facilities; (ii) employee base; (iii) market distribution system; (iv) sales force; (v) customer base; (vi) operating rights; (vii) production techniques; or (viii) trade names.
Based on the Company’s assessment, as outlined in greater detail in the Company’s prior responses to the Staff on June 7, 2022, June 28, 2022, and August 23, 2022 (collectively, the “Prior Responses”), the Company does not believe there is a requirement under Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X to combine multiple transactions completed simultaneously under a single agreement. Rather, the Company believes the determination as to whether multiple transactions should be considered as a single transaction requires an entity to first assess whether each arrangement meets the definition of a “business” in accordance with Rule 11-01(d). Once established, any “related businesses” as defined in Rule 3-05(a)(3) are grouped together and treated as a single transaction. Also as indicated in the Company’s Prior Responses, the Company’s believes the facts and circumstances of the transactions support the analysis as two separate components. Among the factors considered were (i) the structure and nature of the transactions (including, without limitation, separate sellers, separate and independent consideration for each component of the transaction and differing and distinct indemnities and representations), (ii) the fact that the purchase of the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio was the acquisition of a pool of individual loans owned by a different entity within the Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (and not the acquisition of a separate entity, subsidiary or division), as well as (iii) the terms and conditions of the financing which related only to the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and provided differing advance rates based on the underlying attributed of the individual loans. Further, the analysis is consistent with how the Company has viewed other acquisitions of loan portfolios.
(3) As outlined in the Company’s response to the Staff on June 28, 2022, certain portfolio management services were performed by Genesis for the purchased Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio prior to the acquisition. (loan servicing, including collection and remittances, were performed by an unaffiliated third party servicer (the “Servicer”)). Specifically, the Company understands that such portfolio management services included, among other things, administration of draw requests, loan and compliance monitoring in accordance with established guidelines, assisting with managing ongoing relationships with borrowers, and coordinating requests and communication with the Servicer.
Portfolio management services provided by Genesis for the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio (to the extent such loans are still outstanding) subsequent to the acquisition are generally consistent with the Company’s understanding of these services provided by Genesis pre-acquisition. Moreover, the Company factored in the portfolio management services provided by Genesis to the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio preand post-acquisition when assessing whether the loans comprising the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and Genesis each met the definition of a “business” in accordance with Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X. As outlined in greater detail in the Company’s response to the Staff on June 7, 2022, the Company determined Genesis is a separate entity and the nature of the revenue-producing activity, primarily consisting of the origination and sale of mortgage loans and portfolio management services remained generally the same. However, in regard to its purchase of the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio, the Company determined it did not meet the definition of a “business” in accordance with Rule 11-01(d) of Regulation S-X as the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio does not conduct any “revenue-producing activities” but rather provides the holder of the mortgage loans payments of principal and interest based on the underlying unpaid principal balance and contractual interest rate of the mortgage loans. Furthermore, the Company did not acquire, and does not utilize in any manner, the facilities, employee base, sales force, operation rights, or production techniques of Goldman Sachs Bank. All of these items have been expressly retained by Goldman Sachs Bank and were not part of the assets purchased by the Company.
(4) Genesis does not currently perform portfolio management services for the Company’s other loan portfolios other than new loans originated by Genesis and held by a subsidiary of the Company.
(5) As discussed in the Company’s response to the Staff on August 23, 2022, the Company’s motivation for including the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and Genesis as part of a single purchase agreement was largely driven by its desire to acquire both complementary assets as efficiently as possible, including minimizing closing costs, documentation and legal fees.
(6) While the acquisition of the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio and Genesis were related, the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio was not conditioned on the acquisition of Genesis, or vice versa. As discussed in the Company’s response to the Staff on August 23, 2022, the Company’s basis for reaching this conclusion is supported by the negotiations and structuring of the purchase agreement for the transactions as well as the industry and market practice for such transactions.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 24, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 3, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 6, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We have reviewed your response to comment 1 and are unable to agree with your conclusion that is it appropriate to separate the transaction into two components when determining whether you have acquired a business pursuant to Rule 11-01(d).Rest of the question
Please provide audited financial statements of Genesis Capital LLC and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio pursuant to Rule 3-05 of Regulation S-X, and the related pro forma information pursuant to Article 11 of Regulation S-X.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and response. The Company notes that it submitted a waiver request to the staff of the Office of Chief Accountant of the Division of Corporation Finance, which was granted on November 14, 2022, permitting the omission of the financial statements of Genesis Capital LLC and the Mortgage Loans Receivable Portfolio required by Rule 3-05 of Regulation S-X, and the related pro forma information in the Company’s planned filing of a Registration Statement on Form S-11.Read in the reply
First report after the company's reply of Dec 8, 2022: 10-K filed Feb 17, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 17, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: company letter, Jun 28, 2022, closing letter, 2022-12-13