Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021
We note your disclosure that you modified the definition of Distributable Earnings to allow for the treatment of sales as realized if GAAP would otherwise view them as realized even when not recorded in GAAP earnings. As a result you made an adjustment to Distributable Earnings to include the cash portion received for the sale of a 20.6% interest in the Woodstar Fund to a third party.Rest of the question
Please tell how you considered Question 100.04 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations on Non-GAAP Financial Measures when determining that the adjustment was appropriate.
We have consistently disclosed in our public filings that in order to address unusual transactions, our definition of DE allows management to make adjustments, subject to the approval of a majority of our independent directors, when such adjustments are appropriate in order for DE to be calculated in a manner consistent with its definition and objective. We encountered such a situation with the sale of an interest in the Woodstar Fund to third parties. The GAAP and tax treatment of this transaction differed.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Under GAAP, the transaction was accounted for as an adjustment to equity resulting in no earnings impact, while the tax rules treated this as a taxable event with a gain recognized for the difference between the $214 million of cash that we received and our tax basis. This gain substantially increased our taxable income for 2021, and thus likewise increased our required distribution under the 90% Test discussed above.
The taxable income and resulting required distribution are very relevant to our dividend outlook. Because we report DE primarily to assist our analysts and investors in assessing the outlook for our dividends, the inclusion of the Woodstar Fund transaction in DE was fundamental to the usefulness and intended purpose of presenting DE. As a result, our management recommended, and our independent directors unanimously approved, that we include the transaction in computing DE. We believe that excluding the impact of this significant transaction from DE would have caused DE to be significantly understated relative to the REIT dividend requirement and to taxable income, and therefore would have been misleading to our stakeholders who use this measure as an indicator of our dividend.
Question 100.04 (and the corresponding answer) relates to non-GAAP measures that substitute individually tailored recognition and measurement methods for GAAP revenues and/or other financial statement line items that could violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G. In this case, we do not view inclusion of the Woodstar Fund transaction as an individually tailored recognition method, but rather the application of our definition of DE, a longstanding and widely-used measure for CM REITs, to a specific and unusual transaction. Our definition contemplates adjustments appropriate to avoid the measure from being misleading and requires a formal process for independent board approval in such cases.
It should also be noted that inclusion of the Woodstar Fund transaction does not accelerate the recognition of a gain from a future period. Because of the GAAP-prescribed equity treatment for this transaction, the gain will never impact GAAP earnings in a future period. We also note that our treatment is factually distinguishable from the situation described in Question 100.04 in a manner that is meaningful to the appropriateness of our presentation. The question presented in 100.04 describes a registrant that adjusts its non-GAAP performance measure to accelerate revenue recognized ratably over time in accordance with GAAP as though it earned revenue when customers are billed. The Woodstar Fund transaction relates to a completed event for which full payment was received and for which there is no GAAP gain to be recognized in future periods.
First report after the company's reply of Aug 18, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 4, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your adjustments to Distributable Earnings under the heading Recognition of Distributable realized gains (losses) on page 77. Please clarify what each adjustment represents and where the amounts are located on your income statement.Rest of the question
In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
The adjustments to DE under the heading “Recognition of Distributable realized gains (losses)” represent the inclusion of the realized portion of GAAP gains and losses that have previously been excluded from DE in the reconciliation section entitled “Reversal of GAAP unrealized (gains) losses.” The purpose of this portion of our reconciliation is to exclude unrealized items that are accounted for at fair value pursuant to GAAP and only include gains or losses once they are realized.Read in the replyRest of the answer
We have applied this approach consistently since our inception, and it aligns with the usefulness and intended purpose of presenting DE as an indicator of our dividend. Realization typically occurs upon a cash event (i.e. sale, settlement or an event which results in the payment or receipt of cash). These adjustments from GAAP to DE can be positive or negative, depending on the direction of the unrealized marks that are included in our GAAP net income in a particular reporting period. However, in all cases, there is no acceleration of income from a future period. These items consist of the following specific adjustments for the year ended December 31, 2021:
•Loans – This line item represents the realized portion of GAAP gains (losses) on residential and commercial conduit loans sold during the period that are carried under the fair value option. We regularly securitize and sell residential and commercial mortgage loans, and given our intention to sell or securitize, we elect the fair value option for these loans. Our hold period between the origination or purchase of a loan and its securitization is approximately three to six months for residential loans and 30 to 45 days for commercial loans. During such hold period, the loans are marked to fair value through the GAAP income statement within “Change in fair value of mortgage loans, net.” When a securitization occurs, the difference between (i) the net proceeds received in connection with the securitization or sale, and (ii) the historical cost basis of the underlying loans is treated as a realized gain or loss for DE purposes. Because of the crossover in financial reporting periods between origination/purchase and securitization/sale, the exact number included in the adjustment cannot be specifically found on our GAAP income statement. However, cumulatively over time, the fair value mark in the GAAP income statement will equal the total realized gain or loss in DE.
To illustrate this point, please consider the following example: Assume we acquire a loan for $100 in Q1, mark it to $105 in Q2, and sell it for $107 in Q3. Recognition would be as follows:
Period GAAP P&L DE Adjustments
Q1 N/A N/A
Q2 +$5 Change in fair value of mortgage loans, net -$5 Exclusion of unrealized gain on loans
Q3 +$2 Change in fair value of mortgage loans, net
-$2 Exclusion of unrealized gain on loans
+$7 Recognition of realized gain on loans
Cumulative YTD Q1-Q3 +$7 Change in fair value of mortgage loans, net +$7 Recognition of realized gain on loans
As you can see from the table above, the cumulative GAAP and DE impact of a $7 gain is the same, but timing differs.
•Realized credit loss – As noted above and in our 2021 Form 10-K, we consider a credit loss realized when such amounts are deemed nonrecoverable. This is generally upon a realization event, such as when a loan is repaid, or in the case of foreclosure, when the underlying asset is sold. Non-recoverability may also be determined if, in our determination, it is nearly certain that amounts due will not be collected. The realized loss amount reflected in DE will equal the difference between the cash received and the book value of the asset. The CECL provision will have previously been reflected within “Credit loss provision, net” in our GAAP income statement.
From our inception through December 31, 2021, we have only foreclosed on five loans totaling an unpaid principal balance of $159 million, out of more than $48 billion of loans originated during this same time period. We have since resolved three of those loans with an unpaid principal balance of $42 million. The GAAP loss reserves on these three loans totaled $15 million. Upon resolution of these foreclosures via sale of the underlying real estate, only one asset resulted in a realized loss of $7 million, while the other two assets resulted in realized gains totaling $93 million and the reversal of $8 million of previously recorded GAAP impairments. This illustrates the usefulness of excluding unrealized amounts from DE. It is also consistent with the tax treatment which drives our distribution requirement. Under the tax rules, a realized loss on a receivable represents the “abandonment of any expectation of receiving the amount.”
•Securities – Similar to loans, this line item represents the realized portion of GAAP gains or losses on commercial mortgage backed securities (“CMBS”) and residential mortgage backed securities (“RMBS”) sold or impaired during the period which are carried under the fair value option. These securities are generally held for investment, but are carried under the fair value option for GAAP purposes because in the vast majority of cases, the securitizations to which they relate are consolidated. During our hold period, the securities are marked to fair value through the GAAP income statement within “Change in fair value of investment securities, net.” If we choose to sell a security, the difference between the cash proceeds received in connection with the sale and the historical cost basis of the underlying security is treated as a realized gain or loss for DE purposes. Similar to realized credit losses on loans, we consider an RMBS or CMBS credit loss to be realized when such amounts are deemed nonrecoverable. Non-recoverability is likewise generally at the time the underlying assets within the securitization are liquidated, but non-recoverability may also be determined if, in our determination, it is nearly certain that all amounts due will not be collected. The realized loss amount reflected in DE will equal the difference between the cash received and the historical cost basis of the security. The credit loss will have previously been reflected within “Change in fair value of investment securities, net” in our GAAP income statement.
•Woodstar Fund investments – This line item represents GAAP income from the Woodstar Fund investments excluding unrealized changes in fair value of its underlying assets and liabilities. Because the Woodstar Fund is required to carry its investments at fair value, we exclude all unrealized gains (losses) from DE, similar to the treatment of loans and securities noted above which are likewise accounted for at fair value pursuant to GAAP. The difference between the Woodstar Fund’s GAAP net income and its unrealized gains (losses) represents changes in working capital and actual cash distributions received. This difference is the component that we treat as realized for DE purposes. Exclusion of the unrealized changes in fair value related to these investments is critical to the DE measure because the unrealized gains related to this fund can be significant, but are not considered taxable income and therefore are not considered in the determination of our dividend to investors.
•Sale of interest in Woodstar Fund – Please refer to the response to Comment #1 above.
•Derivatives – This line item represents the realized portion of GAAP gains or losses on the termination or settlement of derivatives which are accounted for at fair value. Despite serving as effective economic hedges, none of our derivatives are designated in hedging relationships, and therefore changes in their fair value are recorded in GAAP net income. Similar to the other assets noted above that are likewise marked to fair value through net income under GAAP, derivatives are only treated as realized for DE when they are terminated or settled and cash is exchanged. During our hold period, derivatives are marked to fair value through the GAAP income statement within “Gain (loss) on derivative financial instruments, net.” The amount of cash received or paid to terminate or settle the derivative is the amount treated as realized for DE purposes at the time of such termination or settlement.
•Foreign currency – This line item represents the realized portion of foreign currency gains or losses related to assets (principally our commercial loans) and liabilities (principally the related financing) denominated in foreign currency. Because these assets and liabilities represent monetary items, they are included in the determination of GAAP earnings upon translation and are reported as “Foreign currency (loss) gain, net” in our GAAP income statement. Similar to the other assets described above, DE excludes these unrealized changes in fair value until the foreign currency is converted back to USD and the gains or losses are considered realized. The realized portion of foreign currency is calculated as the difference between the foreign exchange rate at the time the asset was placed on the balance sheet (e.g. the time when the loan was originated) and the foreign exchange rate at the time cash is received (e.g. following repayment of a loan) and is offset by the related foreign currency derivative at settlement. Cumulatively over the loan’s life, the GAAP gain or loss from foreign currency translation during the hold period equals the DE recognition upon repayment of the loan and conversion of the foreign currency back to USD. However, the timing of recognition between GAAP and DE differs as these loans typically have a 3-year life.
•Earnings (loss) from unconsolidated entities – This line item represents GAAP earnings (loss) from unconsolidated entities excluding non-cash items and unrealized changes in fair value recorded on the books and records of the unconsolidated entities. Said differently, this is our share of the unconsolidated entities’ DE. Given the nature of our unconsolidated entities, the difference between GAAP and DE for these entities relates to depreciation and unrealized changes in the fair value of mortgage loans and securities.
•Sales of properties – This line item represents the realized gain or loss on sales of properties held at depreciated cost. Because depreciation is a non-cash expense that is excluded from DE, the GAAP gain upon sale of a property is higher than the realized gain reflected in DE (i.e. sales proceeds less undepreciated cost). Effectively, this adjustment represents accumulated depreciation on the sold property and is subtracted from the GAAP gain to arrive at the DE gain. For added transparency and consistency of presentation, we reverse the GAAP gain in the unrealized section of our DE reconciliation, and then include the DE gain in the realized section. GAAP gains on the sales of properties are reflected within “Gain on sale of investments and other assets, net” in our income statement.
As an example, if we acquire a property in Year 1 for $200, depreciate it by $25 in Year 1 and sell it at the beginning of Year 2 for $250, recognition would be as follows:
Year 1 -$25 Depreciation expense +$25 Exclusion of depreciation expense
Year 2 +$75 Gain on sale of investments and other assets, net
-$75 Exclusion of GAAP gain on sale
+$50 Recognition of DE gain on sale
Cumulative LTD +$50 Net P&L +$50 Net P&L
The table above illustrates that cumulative income recognition is the same for GAAP and DE, but timing differs.
* * * * *
Starwood hereby acknowledges that Starwood is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosures it has made in its filings, including the 2021 Form 10-K, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the Staff.
We respectfully believe that the above responses are responsive to the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions or would like further information concerning our response, please do not hesitate to contact me by phone at 305-695-5470 or by email at [email protected].
First report after the company's reply of Aug 18, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 4, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment 1 regarding the adjustment to Distributable Earnings to include the cash portion received for the sale of a 20.6% interest in the Woodstar Fund and your description of Distributable Earnings as an indicator of your dividends per share.Rest of the question
During the fourth quarter, you modified the definition of this non- GAAP measure for this sale; however, you also stated in that earnings call that a special tax distribution was not paid as a result, since you were able to meet the distribution requirements through your carryover dividend from the fourth quarter of 2020 and the quarterly dividends in 2021. Considering your description of Distributable Earnings and the information available to you when disclosing this new adjustment, it appears that Distributable Earnings may be misleading with this adjustment. The application of your definition of Distributable Earnings also should not override the SEC rules, regulations and guidance on non-GAAP. We believe that your adjustments for the sale of interest in Woodstar Fund is inconsistent with the guidance in Question 100.04 of the Non-GAAP Financial Measures Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations. Please exclude this adjustment related to the sale of the interest in the Woodstar fund in your calculation of Distributable Earnings and any other non-GAAP financial measures presented in accordance with Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K or Regulation G.
For the reasons discussed below, we respectfully disagree with the Staff’s conclusion and kindly request a reconsideration.Read in the reply
The purpose of Distributable Earnings.
As noted in our letter dated August 18, 2022, and as we have consistently disclosed, the primary reason we disclose Distributable Earnings (“DE”) is that we believe it is useful to our investors because “historically, over time, Distributable Earnings has been a strong indicator of our dividends per share” (2021 Form 10-K, page 75).Rest of the answer
DE is a strong indicator of dividends because it approximates taxable income far better than GAAP net income, and taxable income significantly influences our dividends per share because as a real estate investment trust (“REIT”), we are required to distribute at least 90% of our taxable income to shareholders each year (the “90% Test”) to maintain our REIT status under the Internal Revenue Code (the “Code”). Further, DE is an important metric that our board of directors considers, in addition to our taxable income, when setting our quarterly dividend. For the same reasons we disclose DE, DE is also widely reported by other commercial mortgage REITs (“CM REITs”). Through our ongoing conversations with CM REIT analysts and investors in the CM REIT sector, it is clear that DE disclosures are broadly used by these constituents as a key indicator of REIT dividends.
The amount of dividends required to be distributed should not be conflated with the timing of those dividends.
In the Comment Letter, the Staff seems to suggest that because the Woodstar Fund distribution did not cause the Company to have to pay a “special dividend” in 2022, the Woodstar Fund distribution adjustment is not necessary to maintain DE’s purpose as an indicator of dividends. However, the annual distribution requirement related to the Woodstar Fund transaction was satisfied. In other words, the gain was distributed as it was required to be under the tax rules in order to comply with the 90% Test.
The purpose of DE is not to precisely determine the quarter in which a distribution must take place during any given year. Not even the tax rules have that goal in mind. Instead, the purpose of DE is to attempt to quantify the amount of income or gain that must be distributed over the course of any given year. It is important to understand that the REIT distribution requirement is an annual requirement, not a quarterly one. If a given REIT earned all of its income in the first quarter or instead that REIT earned all of that same income entirely in the fourth quarter, the satisfaction of the distribution requirement would not depend on ensuring that the associated distribution happened in the same quarter, only that it happened at some point during the year, even if in an entirely different quarter.
We believe the Staff may have misinterpreted the meaning of “special dividend” and may be conflating two separate concepts—the amount of taxable income required to be distributed and the timing of such distributions. The term “special dividend” or “special tax distribution” is not a tax technical term, nor is it a technical term for either DE or GAAP. The term is nothing more than an indication of whether an additional distribution may be required above and beyond already distributed amounts.
It would be a mistake to conclude that simply because no additional amounts were required in order satisfy the annual REIT distribution requirement that the amount of income related to the Woodstar Fund was not distributed. To the contrary, the annual distribution requirement related to the Woodstar Fund transaction was in fact satisfied, and the gain was distributed as it was required to be under the tax rules.
The calculation of the amount of taxable income that is required to be distributed under the REIT tax rules is relatively straightforward, and the taxable gain generated by the Woodstar Fund transaction was included in taxable income for 2021 reported to investors. If we, as the Staff directs, exclude this material distributable gain from DE, we would grossly understate the Company’s distribution requirement and would create a wide chasm between DE and taxable income as opposed to doing what DE is intended to do, which is to eliminate these differences. Doing so would undermine the fundamental framework and purpose of DE.
The reason we did not have to pay a special dividend in 2021 is because the REIT tax rules permit us to count the portion of the fourth quarter 2020 dividend (paid in January 2021) that exceeded our 2020 taxable income as a 2021 dividend for purposes of computing 2021 dividends paid. This excess dividend paid is then carried forward and can be used against taxable income in 2021.
We offer three examples to help illustrate this concept:
1.Assume we had zero DE in the fourth quarter of Year 1. Also assume we paid our normal quarterly dividend of $150 million. This is a plausible scenario for REITs because the consistency of a REIT’s dividend is critical to investors, irrespective of quarterly taxable earnings volatility. Also assume in the immediately succeeding first quarter of Year 2, we had $295 million of DE and likewise paid our normal quarterly dividend of $150 million (so DE exceeded the dividend by $145 million).
In this example, during the first quarter earnings call, we would indicate to our investors exactly what we said during the earnings call that the Staff referenced in the Comment
Letter, which is that there would be no special dividend in the quarter. This does not mean that the $145 million of “excess DE” was not distributable. To the contrary, from a tax perspective, it was required to be distributed and was in fact distributed. However, because we had a carryover distribution from the fourth quarter when the dividend exceeded DE by $150 million, no special distribution would be made.
If we do as the Staff suggests and exclude $145 million from the first quarter DE simply because there was no special distribution, it would indicate that our six-month DE was only $150 million, when in fact, it was $295 million. The $295 million aligns with the $300 million that was distributed, while the $150 million does not.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 18, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 4, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to prior comment 2. In future filings, please revise your disclosure to include the following: • Clarify that consolidated variable interest entities are excluded from Distributable Earnings, and the reasons for such exclusion. • Disclose that line items in the section “Reversal of GAAP unrealized (gains) losses” include both unrealized and realized (gains) and losses under GAAP.Rest of the question
• Include footnotes to the table describing what each adjustment represents and how the amounts are determined. When applicable, include a cross-reference to where in your financial statements (e.g. the face of the statement of operations, the segment footnote, etc.) that amounts can be tied to. Please include a sample of your intended disclosure within your response. Additionally, please clarify if the Loans adjustment includes realized gains on loan sales that do not meet the treatment as a sale under GAAP. If true, please tell us why you believe such adjustment is appropriate
As another example, assume in the first quarter of Year 2 we had a carryover dividend from the prior year of $150 million because our actual dividends exceeded taxable income in Year 1. In the first quarter of Year 2, assume we had DE (pursuant to the definition as disclosed in our Form 10K) of $150 million. In that instance, we could elect to not pay any distribution in the first quarter because the carryover from Year 1 is treated under the tax rules as a dividend paid in the first quarter of Year 2, the year in which that amount was actually paid.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The fact that we did not make an additional distribution the first quarter of Year 2 should not be taken to mean that we had DE of zero for the quarter.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 18, 2022: 10-Q filed Nov 9, 2022 ↗, against the 10-Q filed May 4, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your response to comment 1 and that the presentation of Distributable Earnings (DE) is intended to eliminate differences between DE and taxable income. Please provide a comparison of DE to taxable income for the years ended December 2020 and 2021 and a comparison of DE to estimated taxable income for the period ended September 30, 2022.Rest of the question
To the extent historical and estimated taxable income differs from DE please explain to us the material differences.
The disclosures in our periodic filings indicate that over time Distributable Earnings (“DE”) has been a strong indicator of our dividends, but our disclosures also caution that DE does not represent a measure of our taxable income. While DE is not intended to entirely eliminate the differences between GAAP net income and taxable income, DE does have a stronger correlation to our dividend than GAAP net income, which is the primary reason this non-GAAP measure was created.Read in the reply
As noted in our prior communications, one of the principal reasons investors invest in commercial mortgage REITs is toRest of the answer
earn a dividend. Given the low correlation between GAAP earnings and our dividend, DE was designed by commercial mortgage REITs to provide stakeholders with the means to assess our ability to pay dividends while simultaneously attempting to keep this non-GAAP measure as simple, understandable and verifiable as possible. As the dividend coverage data below illustrates, there is a very strong and consistent correlation between DE and our dividend.
While DE is a strong indicator of dividends, it was not designed to equal, and generally will not equal, taxable income. The reasons for this are multifold: (i) the rules under the Internal Revenue Code (the “Code”) are incredibly complex and not generally well-understood by typical REIT investors; (ii) the tax rules are often very different from GAAP; and (iii) taxable income cannot be reliably estimated on an interim basis because it is, by definition, an annual calculation under the Code.
In contrast, the DE construct was designed to be as simple as possible, with adjustments grounded in GAAP. The adjustments in our GAAP to DE reconciliation either equal an amount in our GAAP income statement or are derived by using a GAAP based formulation. Doing so allows such adjustments to be easily understood by readers of the financial statements who are more likely to be familiar with GAAP than the intricate tax rules. As a result, DE is not designed to, and will never, replicate taxable income. In addition, computing taxable income on an interim basis is simply not possible given that the underlying framework is annual.
Further, there is a distinction between taxable income (i.e., the amount that must be distributed) and DE (i.e., the amount of earnings available to be distributed). The former effectively sets a floor on dividends because to comply with the REIT rules, a REIT needs to distribute each year substantially all taxable income to its shareholders. The latter provides a critical measure by which management, boards of directors, analysts and investors can assess the degree to which a commercial mortgage REIT’s dividends are sustainably covered by distributable earnings. Together, these two measures serve as key indicators of the dividends that are paid. Some
REITs, like us, generally set their dividend at levels close to the amount of taxable income and retain the excess available distributable earnings to reinvest in the business. Other REITs distribute a higher percentage of their DE in order to maintain dividends at levels they deem in the company’s best interests, and some REITs pay dividends in excess of DE, presumably in the hopes that future DE will increase and cover the dividend. Investors rely on DE coverage ratios to understand these different practices and assess the long-term viability of the current dividend level.
As reflected in the tables below, the significant differences between taxable income and DE for the periods presented have generally been stock compensation and depreciation. While each of these items represent a deduction in computing taxable income, both of these non-cash amounts have traditionally been added back to GAAP net income to calculate DE.
As discussed above, although taxable income effectively establishes the amount a REIT is required to distribute, large non-cash deductions like depreciation mean that taxable income is not always an accurate measure of earnings that a REIT is able to distribute. This helps explain why DE is not intended to be a measure of taxable income, but rather of distributable income.
As illustrated in the following table, DE, taxable income and dividends paid are highly correlated, while there is traditionally a low correlation between GAAP earnings, taxable income and our dividends paid. Not surprisingly, neither our management, our board, our analysts, nor to our knowledge our investors, consider GAAP net income as an indicator of our dividend or use it to assess dividend sustainability.
In sum, the above illustrates that our GAAP net income is not correlated to our dividend, with coverage ranging from 67% to 150% over the periods presented. In contrast, DE provides a much more consistent and highly correlated metric to the dividend and to taxable income, with coverage ranging from 116% to 130% before adjusting for non-cash tax deductions such as stock compensation and depreciation, which brings the coverage range to 95% to 99%. These non-cash tax deductions effectively permit us to distribute less than our full DE and retain the excess to reinvest in our business. To the extent our peer commercial mortgage REITs were consistently not covering the dividend with DE, this would be a crucial signal to investors that the dividend rate may not be sustainable.
Given this relationship between taxable income (an effective floor), DE (an effective ceiling over the long-term) and dividends paid, it is important to monitor whether material differences between the calculations of DE and taxable income exist. It is for this reason that our definition of DE provides for special adjustments which require approval of our independent directors. It is likewise the reason we determined that the Woodstar gain needed to be included in DE. Without this adjustment, the relationship between these three metrics would be materially disconnected.
The Importance of Taxable Deductions to REITs
As a REIT, we are required to distribute at least 90% of our taxable income to shareholders each year to maintain our REIT status under the Code and pay corporate income tax on any undistributed portion between 90% and 100% of earnings. Because of these requirements, REITs have significant constraints on their ability to retain earnings. By acquiring depreciable assets, REITs are able to retain earnings that can be redeployed into additional investments. This is a clear example of how the depreciation adjustment made in computing DE helps arrive at the amount of earnings that are distributable, even if that amount does not represent the amount of earnings required to be distributed pursuant to the Code, which amount is reduced by the deduction for depreciation.
Regarding the addback of stock compensation, it is important to note that while the GAAP expense is added back in arriving at DE, the shares related to this compensation are considered in the fully diluted denominator of DE per weighted average diluted share.
Proposed Enhanced Disclosure
As a result of our engagement with the Staff through this comment letter process, we intend to enhance our future disclosures regarding DE in order to further assist readers in understanding the purpose and utility of DE, and specifically the correlation to our dividend. We propose enhancing our disclosures on the usefulness of DE as follows:
Existing Disclosure Excerpt: We believe that Distributable Earnings (“DE”) provides meaningful information to consider in addition to our net income (loss) and cash flow from operating activities determined in accordance with GAAP. We believe DE is a useful financial metric for existing and potential future holders of our common stock as historically, over time, DE has been a strong indicator of our dividends per share. As a REIT, we generally must distribute annually at least 90% of our net taxable income, subject to certain adjustments, and therefore we believe our dividends are one of the principal reasons stockholders may invest in our common stock.
Proposed Additional Disclosure: DE was designed to provide stakeholders with a relatively simple, understandable, and verifiable way to assess our ability to pay dividends. The nature of the adjustments made to our GAAP net income in order to arrive at DE are similar to those made in arriving at taxable income, although the amounts may differ due to differences between GAAP and tax rules. For purposes of reconciling GAAP to DE, the adjustments are either already included in our GAAP income statement or are determined by reference to the overall GAAP framework.
However, there is a distinction between taxable income (i.e., the amount which determines what we are required to distribute) and DE (i.e., the amount of earnings available to be distributed). DE is not intended to entirely eliminate the differences between GAAP net income and taxable income, but instead is intended to provide investors with a more highly correlated metric to our dividend than GAAP net income. Taxable income cannot be reliably estimated on an interim basis because it is, by definition, an annual calculation under the Internal Revenue Code. In addition, the computation of taxable income is complex and subject to an entirely different set of rules than those prescribed by GAAP. As a result, DE will not, and cannot, equal taxable income. However, given that it has traditionally proven to be a stronger indicator of our dividend than GAAP, DE provides a critical measure which management and our board of directors utilize to determine our ability to pay our dividend and decide whether changes to our existing dividend levels are warranted.
* * * * *
If you should have any questions regarding the above or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me by phone at 305-695-5470 or by email at [email protected].
First report after the company's reply of Dec 20, 2022: 10-K filed Mar 1, 2023 ↗, against the 10-K filed Feb 25, 2022 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: company letter, Jan 19, 2023, closing letter, 2023-01-20