Disclosure on this page notes as one financial performance highlight “[b]asic earnings per share in
2021 of $3.39, adjusted for acquisition costs, partial period operating results, and stockholder activism response costs. Adjustments were made so that operating results may be compared on a year to year basis and to remove costs determined by the
Committee to be out of the control of Company officers.” In addition, we note that the Company refers to “adjusted net income” in various locations throughout the proxy statement.
Rest of the answer
For example, footnote 1 on page 42 indicates that adjusted consolidated net income excludes “one-time transaction costs and partial period operating results related to the recently completed acquisitions of MountainWest and Riggs Distler, and stockholder activism response costs” and notes that the “[e]xclusion of these costs allows operating results to be computed on a comparative basis from year to year and is appropriate because these costs were determined by the Committee to be out of the control of Company executives.”
We also note that the current solicitation in opposition to the Company’s slate of nominees by the Icahn Group argues that an immediate change in the leadership of the Company is needed due to, among other reasons, the underperformance of shares of the Company’s common stock in comparison to the Company’s regulated gas utility peers. In contrast, in the Company’s proxy statement, the Board “strongly urge[s]” stockholders not to sign or return any gold proxy card sent to them by the Icahn Group, and notes that it “believe[s] that [its] nominees’ skills and experience, including their combined knowledge of financial, legal and regulatory matters, enhance the Board’s ability to make decisions that create stockholder value.”
So that stockholders may fully understand key metrics in order to properly assess the performance of the Board and make a fully informed voting decision with respect to the Company’s nominees, please supplement the disclosure described above to provide information about the specific adjustments, the amount for each adjustment and a comparison of such amount to prior periods.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and undertakes to revise the disclosure in the Preliminary Proxy as follows
(strikethrough reflects a deletion and bold and underline reflects new disclosure):
On page 35 of the
Preliminary Proxy, in the first bullet under the heading “2021 Financial Performance Highlights,” the following language will be stricken to reflect that no adjustments were made to basic earnings per share:
“ Basic earnings per share in 2021 of $3.39 adjusted for acquisition costs, partial period operating results, and stockholder activism response costs. Adjustments were made so that operating results may be compared on a year to year basis and to remove costs determined by the Committee to be out of the control of Company officers.”
On page 42 of the Preliminary Proxy, in footnote (1) to the table, the following language will be added regarding the amount of each adjustment to adjusted consolidated net income and adjusted utility net income in 2021:
“(1) Adjusted consolidated net income and adjusted utility net income are non-GAAP measures. In the calculation of actual results under the adjusted net income measures, the Committee excluded the earnings impacts of Company-owned life insurance (“COLI”) policy value changes ($8.8 million) and other one-time items. For the Company, the
Committee excluded one-time transaction costs and partial period operating results related to the recently completed acquisitions of MountainWest ($18.3 million, net of tax) and Riggs Distler ($21.5 million, net of tax), and stockholder activism response costs ($3.4 million, net of tax). For Southwest, the
Committee also excluded the impacts of a $5 million legal reserve ($3.8 million, net of tax) related to an isolated pipeline incident. Exclusion of these costs allows operating results to be computed on a comparative basis from year to year (COLI income was $17.4 million and $9.2 million in 2019 and 2020, respectively; there were no such acquisition or activism costs in 2019 or
2020) and is appropriate because these costs were determined by the Committee to be out of the control of Company executives.”
On page 46 of the Preliminary Proxy, the second through fifth full sentences will be revised as follows regarding the amount of each adjustment to the consolidated EPS performance measure, the utility ROE performance measure and utility net income, respectfully, in each of 2021, 2020 and 2019:
“Each of these measures was adjusted to remove the impact of COLI income of $17.4 million in 2019,
$9.2 million in 2020, and $8.8 million in 2021. For EPS in 2021, the Committee also excluded one-time transaction costs and partial period operating results related to the recently completed acquisitions of MountainWest ($18.3 million, net of tax) and Riggs Distler ($21.5 million, net of tax), and stockholder activism response costs ($3.4 million, net of tax). Exclusion of these costs allows operating results to be computed on a comparative basis from year to year and is appropriate because these costs were determined by the Committee to be out of the control of Company executives. There were no such acquisition or activism costs in 2020 or 2019.”