We note your response to comment 13 in our letter dated August 5, 2015. To help better understand your determination, please provide the following information:
· You disclosed that your CEO, COO, other family members and other related parties own 100% of the equity of ESW LLC. You also disclosed that your CEO, CFO and other related parties own 100% of the equity in VS. Please provide us with the specific ownership interest of each of your related parties and their specific relationship to all other related parties. Please also provide us with the ownership interest of Technoglass, Inc.
Rest of the answer
Please clarify any direct and indirect interest that your CEO and COO may have in Technoglass, Inc. as well.
· Please provide us with your comprehensive analysis of how you applied the consolidation accounting guidance pursuant to ASC 810. Please specifically address your consideration of the following as it relates to EWS and VS:
· Does a scope exception to the consolidation guidance apply?
· Does a scope exception to the Variable Interest Model apply?
· Does the reporting entity have a variable interest in an entity?
· Is the entity a VIE?
· If the entity is a VIE, is the reporting entity the primary beneficiary?
With respect to the information requested in the first part of the
Staff’s comment, we have provided below the direct and indirect equity interest of the CEO, COO and other related parties.
As of December 31, 2015
(unaudited)
Table I
E. S. Windows LLC
(ESW)
Relationship to CEO
Person
Direct
Equity Interest
Self
CEO José M. Daes, Managing Member
30.6 %
Brother
COO Christian T. Daes, Managing Member
23.4 %
Sister
Evelyn I Daes-Perez, Managing Member
6.0 %
Panamanian Entity
Invelco S.A.
40.0 %
100.0 %
Table II
Direct and Indirect
Christian T. Daes (COO)
0.02 %
Giselle Elena Daes de Amin
49.97 %
Mother
Evelyna Abuchaibe de Daes
None
Alberto Velilla Becerra
Alvaro Velilla Becerra
Table III
Ventanas Solar, S.A.
(VS)
50.00 %
Table IV
Tecnoglass Inc.
Ownership Interests
Person or Entity
Equity
Warrants
Outstanding
Common
Shares
Percent
Energy Holding Corporation
789,082
21,067,141
78.3 %
CEDE & Co (FAST)
3,268,319
3,853,995
14.3 %
Ugo Colombo
-
388,199
1.4 %
Earlybird Capital Inc.
311,522
1.2 %
Child Trust fbo Francesca Weil
253,000
0.9 %
Child Trust fbo Alexander Weil
B Luke Weil
243,760
Child Trust Benjamin Luke Weil
168,000
0.6 %
A Lorne Weil
95,693
0.4 %
Martha L Byorum
110,000
80,000
0.3 %
Steven Levine
47,333
0.2 %
Julio A Torres
47,000
David Nussbaum
24,598
0.1 %
Hoak Public Equities LP
638,647
20,071
Continental Stock Transfer & Trust Co
17,400
Ed Kovary
7,500
0.0 %
Ptolemy Capital LLC
6,424
Robert Stevens
6,000
Eric Carrera
5,000
BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. Itf
229,810
BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. Itf Altairis
3,986
150,000
J Randall Waterfield
209,118
Marjorie Hernandez
45,000
Pinnacle Fund LLLP
452,048
The Cascade Fund LLLP/Ascent
165,204
The Red Oak Fund LP
484,330
The Red Oak Long Fund LP
225,962
Totals
6,771,506
26,895,636
Table V
Direct and Indirect Equity Interest of CEO and COO
In Tecnoglass Inc. (registrant)
CEO
José M. Daes
0.01 %
COO
Christian T. Daes
0.05 %
32.93 %
Children of CEO and COO
1.69 %
Direct and Indirect Equity Interest of Daes Family
67.59 % *
All other non-related persons and entities
32.41 %
100.00 %
* Owned through Energy Holding Corp.
With respect to the second part of the Staff’s comment, we present below an analysis of the Company’s comprehensive application of accounting consolidation guidance pursuant to ASC 810 for both ESW LLC (“ESW LLC”) and Ventana Solar, S.A. (“VS”),or collectively as the “Entities”
:
· Does the Company have a variable interest in the entity?
· If the Company have a variable interest in the entity, is the entity a VIE?
· If the entity is a VIE, is the Company the primary beneficiary?
Does a scope exception to the consolidation guidance apply?
No. Scope exceptions in ASC 810-10-15 were not applicable to either legal entity. Neither entity is an investment company, employee benefit plan, governmental organization, an exempted financing entity established by a governmental organization, or any other exempted entity.
Does a scope exception to the Variable Interest
Model apply?
No. Scope exceptions to the Variable Interest
Entity Model are not applicable to either entity. ESW LLC and VS are not non-for-profit entities, does not fall within the business scope exception, “information-out”, nor separate accounts of life insurance entities.
Does the Company have a variable interest in the entities?
Yes. The Company has the following variable interests:
VS: The Company has two payment agreements with VS which are considered as subordinated financing to VS (refer to question #5 for details of the payment agreements).
ESW LLC: Given that the Company has provided subordinated financing to VS, the Company has determined it probably has an implicit variable interest in ESW LLC.
Following the guidance under ASC 810-10-25-22 through
25-36 the Company evaluated the purpose for which the entity was created and the nature of the risks in the entity:
· ESW LLC was created for the purpose of executing normal course-of-business commercial transactions into the U.S. market, not for purposes of passive or active investment, financial support, off-balance sheet financing or other special purposes. ESW LLC is a commercial entity operating since 2003 in the State of Florida that acts as an importer-reseller of the Company’s products and as a freight forwarder of certain raw material inputs for the Company’s manufacturing processes.
· VS was created for the purpose of executing normal course-of-business commercial transactions into the Panamanian market, not for purposes of passive investment, financial support, off balance sheet financing or other special purposes. VS is a commercial entity operating since 2003 in Panama as an importer and installer of products in Panama. VS operates a small warehouse facility for tools and accessories used to install windows and doors and for some minimal storage, handling or transshipment of the products arriving from the Company. The products are usually delivered to and stored at construction sites or other contractors’ facilities and are covered by insurance policies.
The Company also analyzed its ongoing commercial contracts with ESW LLC and VS and evaluated the pricing and credit terms of its contracts to determine whether the contracts acted as implicit variable interests to absorb variability from ESW LLC and VS’s risks. The Company concluded that the margins and credit terms in the commercial contracts have been consistently executed on arms-length terms, similar to other customers.
If the Company has a variable interest in an entity, is the entity a VIE?
ES Windows LLC
Following our prior response to the Staff’s letter dated August 5, 2015, the Company performed a further analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding the Company’s accounting of ESW LLC as a VIE and determined that the prior analysis was in error and that ESW LLC is not a VIE. The Company considered a quantitative and qualitative materiality assessment of the disclosure error and concluded it was not material to the Company’s previously reported financial statements. The Company also considered the error indicative of its previously reported material weakness of financial reporting and closing processes.
As a result of the following analysis, the Company concluded that ESW LLC is not a VIE:
The equity investment at risk represents the amounts funded by the members of ESW LLC (see Table I). The equity holders at risk have the wherewithal to fund their investments in ESW LLC as they have sufficient resources from other businesses in the US and other countries. The Operational Agreement (members agreement) establishes that the members recognize losses and returns of the entity according to the proportion of their contributions. The equity investment by the members was not given or loaned to the members by any related party nor issued in exchange for subordinated financial support in another VIE.
Is the equity investment at risk insufficient to finance the activities of the entity?
No. Since the last reconsideration event prior to and through the dates of the financial statement presented ESW had sufficient equity (approximately 72% of $41.2 million total assets at fair value as of December 31, 2014) to finance its activities, as considered under ASC 810-10-25-45. Additionally, the following qualitative factors indicate that ESW has sufficient equity: a) ESW LLC does not have any debt nor any other off-balance sheet arrangements as of the day of the letter and since its creation, b) ESW LLC has demonstrated its ability to finance its activities without additional subordinated finance support.
Do the holders of the equity investment at risk lack power to direct activities that most significantly impact the entity’s performance?
No. The board of ESW LLC is comprised of the managing members of ESW LLC (which are the same equity holderssee Table I), which is in accordance with the Operating Agreement, that states that each managing member have the full power and authority to act for and to bind ESW LLC and that all decisions regarding the operations shall be made by the managing members, who are authorized to take any action on behalf of ESW LLC without any liability for those actions. The Operating Agreement indicates that the managing members have the obligation to absorb losses in the same proportion as their contributions and that there is no contract requirements indicating that the decisions should made by the combined approval of the managing members. Board meeting and the process of election is not formally documented as all the decision are taken by the largest owner, IVELCO (through Evalyna Abuchaibe de Daes y Giselle Elena Daes de Amin). The members of the board meet on a quarterly basis and manage the operational, capital decision and other activities such as: budgets, sales margins determinations, client selection, financing and all decisions related to the economic performance are managed by Giselle Elena Daes de Amin.
Is the legal entity structured with non-substantive voting rights?
No. All equity holders at risk have voting rights in proportion to their economic interest in ESW. No equity holder at risk has less voting rights as compared to its total economic interest in ESW.
Do parties other than the holders of the equity investment at risk have the obligation to absorb expected losses?
No. ESW was designed such that its members would absorb the losses of ESW. The equity holders at risk are not protected from absorbing the losses of ESW by any agreement or arrangement.
There are also no separate or additional agreements that require the Company to absorb losses of ESW.
at risk have the right to receive the residual returns?
No. ESW was designed such that its members would receive the residual returns of ESW. The equity holders at risk are not prevented from receiving the residual returns of ESW by any agreement or arrangement. There are also no separate or additional agreements that provide the Company with the right to receive the residual returns of ESW.
dated August 5, 2015, the Company performed a further analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding the Company’s accounting of VS as a VIE and determined that the prior analysis was in error and VS is not a VIE. The Company considered a quantitative and qualitative materiality assessment of the disclosure error and concluded it was not material to its previously reported financial statements. The Company also considered the error indicative of its previously reported material weakness of financial reporting and closing processes.
that VS is not a VIE:
by the shareholders of VS (see Table III). The equity holders at risk have the wherewithal to fund their investments in VS as they have sufficient resources from other businesses. The Pacto Agreement (shareholders agreement) establishes that the shareholders recognize losses and returns of the entity according to the proportion of their contributions. The equity investment by the shareholders was not given or loaned to the shareholders by any related party nor issued in exchange for subordinated financial support in another
VIE.
Is the equity investment at risk insufficient to finance the activities of the entity?
No. Since the last reconsideration event prior to and through the dates of the financial statements presented, VS had sufficient equity (25% of $16.7 million total assets at fair value as of December 31, 2014) to finance its activities, as considered under ASC 810-10-25-45.
Additionally, the following qualitative factors were considered in making this assessment: a) Since the creation of VS in 2004 and until the commencement of the payment agreement with the Company in 2014, VS did not require or receive any additional support from third parties or related parties to fund its operations, b)
Extended payment agreement with VS in 2014 was created as a support to VS as working capital to fund operations; however, Company’s management does not consider these agreements to be troubled debt restructuring as the conditions of these Payment Agreements were made in the ordinary course of their business and were made at arm´s length in Panama and considered to be low –risk, c) No guarantee from shareholders were required to obtain the extended payment agreement or are required to obtain a similar financing by third parties.
No. According the Pacto Social Agreement of VS, there is a three member board of directors appointed by the shareholders. All decisions, including the significant decisions, to operate the entity are made by the majority vote of the directors; however, decisions about appointments of directors are under the responsibility of shareholders, represented by Evalyna Abuchaibe de Daes and Giselle Elena Daes de Amin. The Board meets on a quarterly basis to decide on the significant decisions, including approval of the budget and other commercial decisions. The daily ongoing operational decisions and selection of clients are taken by the President (appointed by the board of directors) of the VS with ongoing support and advice from the shareholders.
in proportion to their economic interest in VS. No equity holder at risk has less voting rights as compared to its total economic interest in VS.
No. VS was designed such that its shareholders would absorb the losses of VS. The equity holders at risk are not protected from absorbing the losses of VS by any agreement or arrangement. There are also no separate or additional agreements that require the Company to absorb losses of VS prior to the shareholders.
No. VS was designed such that its shareholders would receive the residual returns of VS. The equity holders at risk are not prevented from receiving the residual returns of VS by any agreement or arrangement. There are also no separate or additional agreements that provide the Company with the right to receive the residual returns of VS.
If the entity is a VIE, is the Company the primary beneficiary?
Not applicable since the Entities are not considered
VIEs as explained above.