Form 10-Q
We note that you filed a Form 12b-25 (Notification of Late Filing and Application for Extension to File) with respect to your Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended April 30, 2010 because of your independent auditor’s evaluation of certain accounting positions previously taken in your audited financial statements included in the Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended July 31, 2009 and the unauditedRest of the question
financial statements included in the Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q for the periods ended January 31, 2009, April 30, 2009, October 31, 2009 and January 31, 2010. In this regard, your independent auditor was addressing issues relating to the accounting treatment for (a) your transactions with Stephen Adams and FreedomRoads that were consummated in January 2009, and (b) repurchase reserves relating to agreements with lenders to your independent dealers and revenue recognition issues with respect to transactions with your independent dealers. Please explain in detail the issue your independent auditor was addressing relating to the accounting treatment for your transaction with Stephen Adams and FreedomRoad, the repurchase reserves, and the revenue recognition issues with your independent dealers. In your response, please further describe these issues, and provide an analysis of the accounting treatment for the transactions and the basis for the conclusions reached.
The matters that our independent auditor was addressing related to our accounting treatment for:Read in the reply
A.
The Company’s January 2009 loans to Stephen Adams, the majority owner of our largest recreation vehicle (“RV”) dealer — FreedomRoads, LLC (“FR LLC”). The matters included i) whether we should consolidate FR LLC pursuant to FIN 46(R) and ii) certain revenue recognition considerations relevant to our sales to FR LLC in light of the January 2009 loans to Stephen Adams, as more fully described below.
B.
The Company’s repurchase obligations under agreements with lenders to its independentRest of the answer
dealers, including related revenue recognition.
The sections below describe these matters more fully, the Company’s analysis of the accounting treatment and the basis for our conclusions.
Item A i) — FIN 46(R) related to FreedomRoads
The following analysis provides a summary of the Company’s evaluation of our involvement with
FreedomRoads and the necessary consolidation considerations pursuant to the guidance of FIN 46R,
Variable Interest Entities (FIN 46R).
Background
The Company is a large manufacturer of RVs and FreedomRoads Holding Company, LLC (“FR Holding”), through its operating subsidiary FR LLC, is the largest dealer network for the Company’s products.
FR Holding is owned principally by Mr. Stephen Adams and is a privately held company. We have been advised by FR LLC that approximately 20% of FR LLC’s 2008 total revenues were represented by
Thor-manufactured products. During fiscal 2009, FR LLC accounted for 11% of the Company’s consolidated net sales and 15% of its RV net sales. The Company, as is common in the industry, has entered into repurchase agreements with FR LLC’s floor plan lenders. The repurchase agreements, under certain conditions such as defaults by FR LLC under the floor plan financing (and as more fully described below in “Item B — Repurchase Obligations”) can require the Company to repurchase inventory previously sold to and still held by FR LLC. At the time of the loans made by the
Company, FR LLC was operating under a forbearance agreement under its floor plan financing arrangements.
Pursuant to the forbearance agreement, FR LLC’s floor plan lenders required certain equity contributions into FR LLC from Mr. Adams, the controlling owner of FR Holding. In that regard, Mr.
Adams initiated negotiations with the Company in order to raise the proceeds necessary for these contributions. Although Mr. Adams has considerable net worth and investments from which he might have raised these funds; it is the Company’s understanding that he approached the Company as another possible alternative in an attempt to avoid expending personal funds at that particular point in time.
In January 2009, the Company entered into two separate loan agreements with principal amounts of
$10 million each (collectively referred to as the “Loans”) to Mr. Adams and the Stephen Adams
Living Trust (the “Trust”). Pursuant to the Loan agreements, Mr. Adams then invested the $20 million into FR Holding which, through various wholly-owned subsidiaries, ultimately contributed the cash to its wholly-owned subsidiary FR LLC. In accordance with the Loan agreements, the $20 million was used by FR LLC to i) pay down $10 million of outstanding floor plan financing related to purchases of the Company’s products and ii) purchase an additional $10 million of product ($6.6 million of new product and $3.4 million of product that had been repurchased from other dealers) from the Company.
The Loans were initially secured by a first priority security interest in Mr. Adams’ equity interest in FR Holding and were initially guaranteed by FR Holding. In addition, the Company has recourse to the assets of Mr. Adams and his Living Trust. Both Loans bear interest at an annual rate of 12%. One Loan was scheduled to mature in full in January 2010 and interest was due quarterly in cash. The other Loan was scheduled to mature in full in January 2014 with interest payable in kind during year one and payable in cash monthly thereafter. One of the main reasons that the Company made the Loans directly to Mr. Adams and the Trust and not directly to FR LLC was to avoid conflict with other dealers of the Company’s products in addition to the fact that the
Company is not in the dealership business and does not want to be involved with sales to retail customers. The Company performed diligence to assess the net worth of Mr. Adams in order to determine his ability to repay the Loans outside of his investment in FR Holding and its affiliates. The Company assessed the creditworthiness of Mr. Adams based upon information provided by him and publicly available information. Our December 2008 assessment established that Mr. Adams had very substantial net worth, indicating that there was sufficient collateral and assets to repay the $20 million of Loans. Additionally, based on the collateral (including Mr. Adams’ interest in the FR entities) securing the Loans and the guarantee by FR Holding, the Company determined that at the time of the making of the Loans, collection was not dependent upon distributions to Mr. Adams from FR Holding and its affiliates. Accordingly, the Loans were approved by management and the
Board of Directors of the Company with the intention to seek recovery of all amounts loaned to Mr.
Adams. Through the date of this letter, Mr. Adams is current on all scheduled principal and interest payments, taking into account the modifications and loan extension discussed below under
“Subsequent Considerations”.
As part of the negotiation in issuing the Loans, FR LLC entered into an exclusivity agreement with the Company whereby FR LLC is required to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs from the Company, subject to certain exceptions, as long as the Company offers the requested product. It is the Company’s understanding that approximately half of FR LLC’s 2008 revenues were from new RV sales. The exclusivity agreement includes a ‘most favored nation’ provision whereby the Company is required to offer FR LLC the lowest price that it offers to its other customers for the same RV. As such, FR
LLC’s price is deemed to be at market and, by extension, not significantly different than if FR LLC purchased the new RV from a different vendor. The exclusivity agreement was initially scheduled to terminate upon full payment of both Loans but was subsequently extended. In addition, it should be noted that the exclusivity agreement was not concluded to be a variable interest in FR LLC as we concluded that there was no fair value associated with the agreement and all pricing was at market terms.
Accounting Evaluation
Paragraph 7 of FIN 46R requires reassessment as to whether an entity is a Variable Interest Entity
(“VIE”) upon the occurrence of certain events. Paragraph 15 of FIN 46R requires reconsideration of the primary beneficiary of a VIE upon the occurrence of certain events. We believe that the
January 2009 transactions represent a reconsideration event under this guidance.
While the Loans were made directly to Mr. Adams and the Trust rather than to FR LLC, we also considered the guidance provided by the SEC relating to “activities around the entity” (such as loans from the reporting entity to variable interests holders of a VIE), and determined that we should consider the Loans in the Company’s consolidation analysis of FR LLC under FIN 46R.
Because the above noted events resulted in a reconsideration event of the consolidation analysis of
FR LLC, the following discussion describes the Company’s consideration under FIN 46R as of January
2009 (and therefore uses pre-Codification literature references).
As certain steps of the VIE analysis are dependent upon identifying related parties and de-facto agents of the Company, we first evaluated our relationship with Mr. Adams. We concluded that Mr.
Adams was neither a related party nor a de-facto agent of the Company. We first concluded that Mr.
Adams was not a related party pursuant to the guidance in FAS 57, Related Party Disclosures, as i) the Company and Mr. Adams do not control each other nor are under common control, ii) neither the
Company nor Mr. Adams hold investments in each others’ equity securities, and iii) the Company does not control or significantly influence Mr. Adams or FR LLC. The Company has a significant number of other dealers, moreover it is the Company’s understanding that Mr. Adams has significant wealth and income generating businesses outside of his relationship with the Company. Therefore, we concluded that neither party’s reliance on the other would be significant enough to suggest that the respective parties were not pursuing their own separate interests and instead acting as a de-facto agent of the other party. We further considered the four factors identified in paragraph
16 of FIN 46R to determine if Mr. Adams was a de-facto agent of the Company.
a.
Can Mr. Adams support his operations without subordinated financial support from the
Company? Yes, the Company, as part of the Loan origination, determined that Mr. Adams had adequate capital resources to support his personal ‘operations’ as evidenced by his substantial net worth and apparent creditworthiness based upon information reviewed by the
Company. His borrowing from the Company was a personal decision he made to avoid having to expend personally available funds to financially support FR LLC at that time.
b.
Did Mr. Adams receive his interest in FR LLC from a contribution or loan from the
Company? While Adams did fund this particular equity investment into FR LLC with the
Loans from the Company, Adams already had a substantial investment in FR LLC and to our knowledge continues to have full benefits and obligations associated with his beneficial interest in FR LLC. In addition, the Loans were originated on an arms-length basis, there were no requirements for Mr. Adams to obtain financing from the Company and the Loans were reviewed and approved by the Board of Directors of the Company looking at the commercial substance of the transaction as well as the Company’s full recourse to Mr. Adams other assets.
c.
Is Mr. Adams an officer, employee or member of the Company’s governance board? No,
Mr. Adams does not participate in any way with the operations or governance of the
Company.
d.
Does the Company have i) an agreement with Adams that he cannot sell, transfer or encumber his interests in FR LLC without the Company’s approval or ii) a close business relationship like the relationship between a professional services provider and a significant client? The Company has no other business relationships with Mr. Adams or his affiliates other than the Loans and their typical vendor/customer relationship through his ownership of FR LLC. As noted above, we concluded that neither parties’ reliance on the other would be significant enough that the parties’ would be considered not to be pursuing their own separate interests and instead acting as a de-facto agent of the other party.
Therefore, based on the above, the Company concluded that Mr. Adams was not a related party or a de-facto agent. Accordingly, the following discussion regarding the Company’s FIN 46(R) analysis does not consider Mr. Adams as a related party or de-facto agent of the Company.
Step 1 — Determine if any of the scope exceptions apply to the Company/FR LLC.
We determined that none of the scope exceptions were able to be applied to the Company’s consolidation analysis of FR LLC, principally due to the Company’s involvement in the redesign of
FR LLC — most notably that the Loans effectively refinanced a portion of FR LLC’s outstanding debt.
Step 2 — Determine if FR LLC is a variable interest entity pursuant to the conditions included in paragraph 5 of FIN 46R.
We determined that FR LLC was a variable interest entity because we concluded that there were several factors indicating that the equity investment at risk of FR LLC was not sufficient pursuant to the guidance in FIN 46R.
Based upon information obtained by the Company, it is the Company’s understanding that at the time of the Loans FR LLC had significant subordinated debt (including various repurchase agreements from its vendors). The existence of this subordinated financial support is a strong indication that the equity at risk is insufficient to support FR LLC’s activities. In addition, the circumstances prompting the need for the Loans indicate that the floor plan finance lenders did not believe that
FR LLC had sufficient equity investment at risk to finance its ongoing operations without additional subordinated financial support. As such, we concluded that FR LLC was a variable interest entity.
Step 3 — Determine what variable interests the Company has in FR LLC.
We determined that the Company’s repurchase agreements with FR LLC’s floor plan lenders would be considered a variable interest in FR LLC. The repurchase agreements would be considered variable interests because they can require the Company to absorb expected losses if FR
LLC defaults on its floor plan financing.
The Loans were provided directly to Mr. Adams (and the Trust) and the terms of the Loans were substantive. As such, we believe that there would be a reasonable basis to conclude that these
Loans were not variable interests in FR LLC. Nonetheless, for purposes of the FIN 46R analysis, the
Company did consider them as variable interests.
Finally, the Company also considered whether it had any other explicit or implicit variable interests in FR LLC. Other than as described above, the Company has no other direct contractual, ownership or other pecuniary interests in FR LLC. There are no other calls, puts, leases, swaps, guarantees or other relationships or agreements to consider (such arrangements being the typical sources of implicit variable interests). The Company notes that it does not have any significant influence over any decision making within FR LLC, it had no related party relationships with other variable interest holders in FR LLC, it had not previously absorbed any losses related to FR LLC,
FR LLC’s floor plan finance lenders were fully aware of the Loans to Mr. Adams, and the Company had no intention and neither communicated or indicated to floor plan finance lenders that the Company would support FR LLC in any way other than through the repurchase agreements. All of these factors support that the Company does not have any other variable interests in FR LLC.
Step 4 — Determine if the Company is the primary beneficiary of FR LLC.
The Company determined that, pursuant to paragraph 14 of FIN 46R, the Company would not absorb a majority of the expected losses or residual returns of FR LLC.
The significant variable interest holders of FR LLC are the equity holders of FR LLC, the floor plan and bank financing lenders, various other subordinated lenders and the Company.
The Company’s maximum losses from its variable interests in FR LLC are primarily represented by its potential obligation under the Company’s repurchase agreements with FR LLC’s floor plan lenders.
While the amount of FR LLC’s borrowings covered by the contingent repurchase guarantees was $73 million as of January 31, 2009, this amount does not measure the Company’s exposure to losses. Even if FR LLC defaults on its obligation to pay the floor plan financing and the lenders then perfect their interests in the related inventory and put that inventory back to the Company (a sequence of events that is less likely than other workout scenarios that the lenders could execute), the
Company would be able to resell that inventory to another dealership. Therefore, the fair value of the Company’s guarantee obligation is far less than the stated value of the guarantee. The Company determined that the repurchase guarantee had an estimated fair value of approximately $3 million as of January 31, 2009.
In regards to the Loans, as noted in the Background section above, because of the creditworthiness and personal net worth of Mr. Adams outside of Mr. Adams’ interests in FR LLC, the Company concluded that this particular variable interest would absorb very little, if any, of FR LLC’s expected losses.
The fair value of the FR LLC equity was estimated to be approximately $50 million as of January
2009. The combined result of the above paragraphs is that the equity holders of FR LLC (as the most subordinate variable interest holder) would absorb expected losses before any such losses would be absorbed by the Company. It is theoretically possible that the expected losses absorbed by the equity holders would fully deplete the fair value of the equity interests, at which point expected losses would be absorbed by the subordinated debt holders (i.e. variable interests held by other third parties). We determined qualitatively that the potential losses absorbed by the
Company, even in a worst case scenario, could not result in the Company absorbing the majority of the expected losses and residual returns.
Accordingly, the Company concluded that its variable interests in FR LLC would not absorb a majority of the expected losses of FR LLC. As such, the Company is not the primary beneficiary and would not consolidate FR LLC pursuant to FIN 46R.
Subsequent Considerations
In connection with the issuance of a third $10 million loan to Mr. Adams and another FR Holding owner in December 2009, the Loan agreements and the exclusivity agreement were modified, as follows: the guaranty by FR Holding and the pledge by Mr. Adams and the Trust of their interests in
FR Holding were each terminated and at the same time the Company received rights to loan prepayments if certain events occur, the repayment schedule of the previous one year loan was extended to three years and the exclusivity agreement was extended to December 2029. The Company reassessed whether it should consolidate FR LLC as a result of the third loan and, for many of the reasons described above related to the first two loans, concluded that consolidation of FR LLC continued to be inappropriate.
The Company more recently reassessed whether FR LLC should be consolidated pursuant to the revised
ASC 810-10 guidance (FASB 167) and also determined that under the amended VIE guidance, it continued to be appropriate for the Company to not consolidate FR LLC as the Company does not have the power to direct the activities of FR LLC that most significantly impact its economic performance.
Item A ii) — Revenue recognition on sales to FR LLC
The Company evaluated the following related to revenue recognition to FR LLC:
Whether the indirect financial assistance via the Loans to Mr. Adams and the Trust would require the Company’s sales to FR LLC to be considered an in-substance consignment arrangement.
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please file the Exclusivity Agreement between you and FreedomRoads Holding Company, LLC, FreedomRoads, LLC and certain subsidiaries of FreedomRoads, LLC. It appears that this is a material agreement that should have been filed as an exhibit to your filing.
The appropriateness of recognizing revenue on FR LLC’s $10 million purchase using the proceeds from the second Loan to Mr. Adams and the Trust.Read in the reply
Additional Background:
In addition to the background provided on the transactions above, the following is relevant to the revenue recognition analysis related to sales to FR LLC.
The second loan agreement with Mr. Adams required that the proceeds of the Loan ultimately be used by FR LLC to make a one-time purchase of approximately $10 million of new and repurchased RVs from the Company.Rest of the answer
FR LLC had the choice of what RVs to purchase from the Company’s available inventory.
FR LLC moved this inventory under normal terms (based on our review of a sales status report for
FR LLC, 59% of these units were sold by July 31, 2009 — in line with a typical 2-3 turns per year). The sale resulted in $10 million of revenue and cost of goods sold of approximately $10.2 million. This loss, which was covered by existing reserves, was attributed to the repurchased RVs.
In the three months after this purchase, FR LLC purchased approximately $45 million more of the
Company’s RVs financed through FR LLC’s normal floor plan financing arrangements. This compares to
$12 million of RV purchases (including the subject $10 million) during the three months ended
January 31, 2009.
The Company notes that FR LLC’s floor plan lender has never taken title to any Company product or required the Company to repurchase any RVs previously sold to FR LLC. Additionally, the Company has never repurchased or allowed FR LLC to return its products to the Company.
Accounting Analysis A.ii.1 — Whether the indirect financial assistance via the Loans to Mr. Adams and the Trust would require the Company’s sales to FR LLC to be considered an in-substance consignment arrangement.
The Company considers many factors in determining whether its shipment of product to dealers, such as FR LLC, should be recognized as revenues rather than delaying that recognition until the dealer sells the product to consumers. The following are the more significant and relevant factors that the Company considers and on which it bases its determination that revenue recognition upon shipment to dealers is appropriate and that they do not represent in-substance consignment
•
Legal title and risk of loss passes to the dealer at the time products are shipped to the dealer
The Company does not dictate the number of units or type of products its dealers purchase
The Company does not sell to dealers unless the dealer has arranged floor plan financing and, other than the credit enhancement provided through the repurchase agreement, does not provide financial assistance to the dealers
The Company has no management rights or active interest in the management of its dealers
The dealers are not allowed to return products to the Company
The Company does not finance the sale to the dealer. It only provides the dealer with a credit enhancement in the form of a guarantee to the lender. That lender is at substantial risk in regards to that financing (as more fully described in the Item B —
Repurchase Obligations section of this comment response)
The proceeds received from the dealer are not contingent upon the amount the dealer receives when the product is resold
Extended payment terms are not granted to the dealer
We believe the above general model applies equally to sales with FR LLC, but due to the loan transactions with Mr. Adams, we made additional considerations as to whether or not sales to FR LLC should be accounted for as an in-substance consignment whereby the Company would not recognize revenue on sales to FR LLC until FR LLC sold the RVs to their end customer.
The differences between the above general analysis on in-substance consignment sales to other dealers and the Company’s transactions with FR LLC are as follows:
FR LLC would have been considered thinly capitalized at the time and was experiencing financial difficulties.
FR LLC was operating under a forbearance agreement with its floor plan financing lenders that required an equity infusion from Mr. Adams.
The Company indirectly provided funds for the equity contribution through the Loans.
The Company indirectly financed the $10 million of purchases using the proceeds from the second Loan.
While FR LLC was thinly capitalized and in need of additional capital, we believe the indirect financial assistance provided by the Company to FR LLC, via the loans to Mr. Adams and the Trust, were substantive transactions with Mr. Adams. The risk assumed by Mr. Adams points to FR LLC being
“carried” by Mr. Adams and not by the Company. As the Loans were made directly to Mr. Adams and the Trust, the Company has recourse against Mr. Adams’ personal assets and intends to pursue his personal assets in the event of non-payment. Mr. Adams’ equity contributions and the risk assumed by Mr. Adams has allowed FR LLC to continue operations. The Company concluded based upon information provided by Mr. Adams and other publicly available information that Mr. Adams has significant assets beyond FR LLC that would enable the Company to recover payment in the event of default. That is, repayment is not solely dependent upon the financial success of FR LLC.
Additionally, the Company continues to believe the loans are collectible from Mr. Adams as evidenced by the fact that Mr. Adams has made all required principal and interest payments and complied with all applicable quarterly covenant compliance reporting requirements.
Also, as noted below in “Item B — Repurchase Obligations”, we do not believe the existence of the repurchase guarantee precludes revenue recognition. Repurchase guarantees are common in the industry and the Company issues the same guarantee to all dealers that utilize floor plan financing. Further, we do not believe that the repurchase guarantee significantly reduces the risk that the lenders incur in extending floor plan financing to FR LLC. The Company issued the guarantee on behalf of FR LLC before FR LLC began to experience financial difficulties and will continue to sell to FR LLC as long as the lenders provide floor plan financing. The lenders have significant additional risk beyond the risk posed to the Company via the repurchase guarantees which only mitigates the lenders’ risk. Lenders will discontinue financing or restrict purchases even with the repurchase guarantee in place. Based upon these factors, the Company believes the guarantees do not represent a material inducement for lenders to make floor plan financing available to FR LLC.
As it relates to FR LLC, we also considered whether the exclusivity agreement provides the Company with any management or ownership rights in FR LLC. The agreement only provides that a certain percentage of FR LLC’s purchases be of the Company’s products. FR LLC’s ability to choose other manufacturers has also been limited due to the recent bankruptcies of certain of the Company’s competitors. As such, the Company believes FR LLC’s purchases of the Company’s products were expected to increase regardless of the exclusivity agreement. The purchases subject to this provision only include new RVs and product offered by the Company. It does not provide for minimum annual volumes or certain types of inventory and provides FR LLC the flexibility to make purchases. Other than the most favored nation terms discussed above, the terms offered to FR LLC under the exclusivity agreement are similar to terms offered to other dealers.
Conclusion
Based on the above analysis, we believe the presence of the repurchase guarantee, exclusivity agreement and financial assistance provided to Mr. Adams do not constitute active management of FR
LLC by the Company and therefore sales to FR LLC should not be viewed as in-substance consignment
Accounting Analysis A.ii.2 — The appropriateness of recognizing revenue on FR LLC’s $10 million purchase using the proceeds from the second Loan to Mr. Adams and the Trust.
We believe the sale to FR LLC using the proceeds from the second Loan is a substantive transaction as are the Loans to Mr. Adams and the Trust. FR LLC’s management indicated that there was a need for the inventory at the time to execute its business plan and that FR LLC needed “fresh” inventory. The timing for the Loan was based upon FR LLC’s need for the equity contribution and was not dictated by the Company in terms of the timing of the sale. Based upon FR LLC wanting “fresh” inventory that it could sell to execute its business plan, it appears that the quantities were not in excess of FR LLC’s needs. We also noted above that FR LLC moved this inventory under normal terms and made subsequent purchases under its traditional floor plan financing arrangement.
When considering the Loan to Mr. Adams and the Trust, the payment terms exceeded normal sales terms, however the Company has determined that collectability is reasonably assured on the basis of
Mr. Adams’ net worth. The Company has the ability and intent to pursue the assets of Mr. Adams and the Trust for repayment considering that their net assets were estimated at the time the Loans were made to significantly exceed the value of the Loans.
Further, the Company notes that this was a non-recurring transaction and that the $10 million of sales and approximately $10.2 million of cost of goods sold is immaterial to the Company’s financial results.
Item B — Repurchase Obligations
We addressed the following related to the repurchase reserves and revenue recognition with the
Company’s independent dealers (excluding FR LLC):
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
We note your disclosure that SJC, for segment reporting, is aggregated in the buses reportable segment because of similar economic characteristics, and the nature of the products, production process, type of customer, distribution channels and regulatory environment.Rest of the question
Please provide us your evaluation of these characteristics in accordance with the guidance in ASC 280-10-50-11, in which all criteria must be met, in support of your assertion that these characteristics are similar. In addition, in light of disclosure on page 1 in your filing that states that your operating subsidiaries continue as independent operations, please tell us how the chief operating decision maker assesses performance of SJC.
The Company’s accounting for repurchase transactionsRead in the reply
Approximately 90-95% of the Company’s RV sales to independent dealers are financed by the dealer through floor plan arrangements with third party floor plan lenders. It is customary practice in the RV industry to enter into repurchase agreements with financing institutions that provide financing to their dealers. Generally, these agreements provide for the repurchase of products by the financing institution in the event of a dealer’s default on the entire floor plan financing arrangement.Rest of the answer
These repurchase obligations are not the same as the customers having a general right of return. In fact, our customers cannot return product to us. It is the floor plan lender that can require the Company to repurchase our products and only after that lender has perfected its interest in the product and has taken title to it. Additionally, a dealer could not default on selected inventory and have the lender put the inventory back to the Company. The dealer would have to default on the entire floor plan financing arrangement which would in turn require the lender to potentially repossess all of the dealer’s inventory. Such acts of default generally occur as a dealer is entering into bankruptcy.
Every unit sold by the Company through floor plan financing is specifically approved by the floor plan lender in advance of shipment. This ensures that the dealer is in good standing with the lender and confirms there is sufficient capacity on their line of credit. Based on our understanding of the lenders’ underwriting policies, lenders require that dealers have a significant amount of equity at stake which incentivizes the dealer to perform and to protect the lender. If a dealer does not have sufficient equity at risk, they are required to have a certain net worth and provide a personal guarantee to achieve the same outcome. The lender’s underwriting decisions and the terms and conditions it negotiates with the dealer, including any amendments that the lender may request or waivers it may agree to due to changes in the dealer’s financial condition are between the dealer and the floor plan lender and do not involve the Company.
The floor plan lender takes on significant risk even with the repurchase agreements in place.
Lenders to the Company’s dealers incur sizable losses in a repurchase situation. In addition to the fact that the lender’s exercise of the repurchase option can only occur when the dealer is in default and almost always results in the dealer entering bankruptcy, the Company’s repurchase obligation only mitigates the lender’s losses as follows:
The Company’s repurchase obligation is limited to unsold new units that have been on the dealer’s lot up to a period of 12-18 months. Older unsold new units are the lender’s sole risk.
The older the unit, the lower the Company’s repurchase price, thus putting the lender at risk for the spread between the original invoice price and the repurchase amount.
The lender bears sole risk for the condition of the unit, and the Company’s repurchase price is reduced for damage, excess wear and tear, or missing standard, accessory or optional items that were included on the unit when shipped.
The lender bears sole risk for units sold out of trust (i.e. the dealer sold the unit and failed to pay the lender as required under the floor plan arrangement).
The lender bears sole risk for used (trade-in) units that are covered under the floor plan arrangement.
For the above reasons, a lender’s risk due to a dealer’s financial problems is far greater than any one manufacturer’s risk (including the Company) related to units it has sold under repurchase obligations. Lenders therefore are not only highly motivated to monitor, identify and solve potential dealer financial issues early, they are also highly motivated to limit a troubled dealer’s purchases of new units.
General terms and conditions of the Company’s sales to independent dealers are the same for all dealers. Key aspects of the sales terms are as follows:
The Company does not have master sales agreements with its dealers and accepts orders through purchase orders.
Title and risk of loss of the RV transfers to a dealer upon shipment, at which point in time the Company recognizes revenue. In the event of the RV being lost, stolen, destroyed, etc. either during shipment or while in the possession of the dealer, the Company has no risk of loss.
Dealers do not have a stated right of return and the Company does not accept returns from the dealers.
The Company does not have any influence over a dealer’s sales, pricing, credit, and/or advertising policies. Stated more broadly, the Company does not have any direct control over the operations of any of its dealers.
The Company does not have an ownership interest in any of its dealers.
Our history of actual repurchases and losses on those repurchases have been immaterial as demonstrated in the table below (dollars in thousands). During the economic downturn the repurchases were not significant. Subsequent to the economic downturn, the repurchases have continued to be immaterial and were approximately 0.4% of net sales in both fiscal 2010 and year-to-date in fiscal 2011. The losses on those repurchases were 0.06% of net sales in fiscal
2010 and 0.07% year-to-date in fiscal 2011. As indicated, the vast majority of the cost of units repurchased is recouped by the Company upon resale of the repurchased unit.
Consolidated
Cost of Units
Repo as % of
Loss Due to
Loss as % of
Period
Net Sales
Repurchased
Repurchase
FY 2010
$
2,276,557
10,001
0.4
%
1,336
.06
FY 2009
1,521,896
32,913
2.2
5,261
.35
FY 2008
2,640,680
11,908
0.5
1,857
.07
FY 2007
2,856,308
10,078
1,017
.04
FY 2006
3,066,276
4,878
0.2
648
.02
FY 2005
2,558,351
11,220
1,865
FY 2004
2,187,739
3,775
642
.03
FY 2003
1,571,404
4,130
0.3
494
Accounting Analysis B.1 — Impact of repurchase guarantees on revenue recognition
To assess the appropriateness of our accounting policy regarding the repurchase guarantees and the associated impact to revenue recognition, we considered the following authoritative literature:
SAB Topic 13.A.1
ASC 605-15 Sales of Product when Right of Return Exists
ASC 470-40 Product Financing Arrangements
In-substance consignment sales
ASC 460 — Guarantees
An assessment of our sales to dealers subject to repurchase guarantees following the SAB Topic 13 revenue recognition criteria is as follows:
Persuasive evidence of an arrangement — we believe persuasive evidence of an arrangement has been satisfied as each dealer submits purchase orders to stipulate the terms of the arrangement.
Delivery — the delivery condition has been satisfied as title transfers to dealers upon shipment, the Company has no risk of loss in the event of a dealer’s RV being lost, stolen, destroyed, and the sales are not legally on consignment. We further considered whether the sales had the characteristics of the following types of transactions to evaluate whether delivery has occurred and the risk of loss has transferred:
Right of Return — The Company has considered whether the repurchase commitment should be considered a right of return accounted for under ASC 605-15-25, Sales of
Product when Right of Return Exists. The Company does not believe that this guidance should be considered applicable to repurchase commitments between a lender and a manufacturer. As stated earlier, a dealer does not have any right of return. The repurchase commitment does not afford the lender a general right of return as contemplated by ASC 605-15-25 in that the lender’s right to ‘return’ the unit does not exist absent default by the dealer on its lending arrangement. The substance of the repurchase commitment is a financial guarantee which provides a credit enhancement to the dealer, not a general right of return as discussed in
ASC 605-15-25 or as discussed in SAB Topic 13 for refund rights in service transactions.
Nonetheless, the Company has considered the criteria in ASC 605-15-25 solely to explore whether any of its concepts would suggest that revenue should not be recognized. As it relates to items (a) — (e) of ASC 605-15-25-1, the Company’s dealers are independent, substantive third parties who bear significant risks related to the product they purchase from the Company and other manufacturers.
Dealers bear the risk of damage to the units, the risk of changes in market conditions that could depress their selling price or affect the demand for the types of products in their inventory, and the risk of going out of business if they default on their floor plan obligations (including the personal risk they assume under any personal guarantees.) The fact that the Company has entered into a credit enhancement arrangement that benefits the dealers does not negate the stand-alone nature of the product sales or create a general right of return. While industry practice has developed such that repurchase commitments with floor plan lenders is customary, the same economic benefit could have been provided via a reduction in the selling price of a unit, resulting in lower dealer carrying costs.
Product Financing Arrangements — While the repurchase arrangements have some similarity to those arrangements discussed in ASC 470-40-15-2, there are also significant differences. First, the repurchase amount does not include interest owed by the dealer prior to default (that is, the Company is not responsible for any holding/financing costs that a dealer incurs while the inventory is on its lot). Accordingly, the Company’s sales subject to repurchase guarantee do not meet the definition of product financing arrangements in ASC 470-40-15-2. Additionally, the Company notes that it has no arrangements with the purchaser/dealer of its products to finance the purchase price of those products. The Company’s repurchase obligations are instead with the floor plan lenders and represent a stand-by obligation that can be triggered only upon specific conditions that are outside the control of the floor plan provider. Under these arrangements, the repurchase price does not increase over time (as would be the typical case when interest and holding costs were added to the ‘principal’ balance), but instead actually decrease over time and under certain conditions, such as damage to and aging of the products.
In-Substance Consignment — Legally the Company does not sell its products on a consignment basis, however, if the transactions are deemed to be on an
“in-substance consignment”, revenue would not be recognized until the dealer sold the RV to the end customer (sell through method). We have concluded our sales to independent dealers do not contain characteristics of a consignment sale based upon the following:
Legal title and risk of loss passes to the dealer at the time products are shipped to the dealer
The Company does not dictate the number of units or type of products its dealers purchase
The Company does not sell to dealers unless the dealer has arranged floor plan financing and, other than the credit enhancement provided through the repurchase agreement, does not provide financial assistance to the dealers
The Company has no management rights or active interest in the management of its dealers
The Company does not finance the sale to the dealer. It only provides the dealer with a credit enhancement in the form of a guarantee to the lender
The proceeds received from the dealer are not contingent upon the amount the dealer receives when the product is resold
Collectability is reasonably assured — The Company has no history of collection problems. While the floor plan lenders pay the Company on behalf of the dealers, we considered whether the repurchase commitment between the Company and the lender suggests that the Company’s assessment of collectability should consider the ability of the dealer to pay the lender. We believe the floor plan agreements between the lenders and the dealers are substantive, discrete lending transactions between unrelated parties. The
Company is not a party to the negotiation of those terms, is not a signator to the arrangement, and is not privy to the terms and conditions of the agreement. The floor plan arrangement generally covers both new and used inventory and permits the dealer to borrow against units from a variety of different manufacturers. The Company’s repurchase agreements with individual lenders have been in place in most cases for many years, apply broadly to any dealer to whom the lender extends financing, and are completely independent of any current transaction with any specific dealer. Further, the Company’s long experience is that the floor plan arrangement between the lender and the dealer is viewed by the lender as a substantive underwriting commitment that requires due diligence by the lender.
The resulting borrowing terms reflect the financial wherewithal of each individual dealer, frequently require the maintenance of certain financial ratios and a personal guarantee from the dealer, and permit the lender to inspect and verify on-hand units.
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please provide the disclosures required by ASC 280-10-50-40. It appears that you should be separately quantifying revenue attributable to ambulances. Provide us the disclosure that would have been included in the 2010 Form 10-K.
Seller’s Price Considered Fixed or Determinable — We considered whether sales subject to a repurchase guarantee could be considered a sale with extended payment terms and whether or not those terms prevented revenue recognition. Except in the sale of software products, US GAAP does not provide specific guidance about when extended payment terms would prevent revenue recognition. The software guidance contained these provisions because the risk of concessions is greater with extended payment terms due to the risk of technological obsolescence in software products.Read in the replyRest of the answer
RVs do not have the same risk of technological obsolescence and therefore we do not believe this guidance applies to the
Company’s sales. This coupled with the fact that fees charged to dealers are not subject to change, there is no right of return and the fees are not dependent upon a future event, we believe that the price is fixed or determinable.
The Company believes that the substance of its repurchase obligation with lenders who provide floor plan financing to dealers is that of a guarantee under ASC 460, Guarantees. The Company essentially is offering its dealers the opportunity to purchase a credit enhancement (in the form of a guarantee to the lender) in connection with the purchase of new product.
Credit enhancements in the form of guarantees are common and can take many forms. ASC 460 has a lengthy definition of the guarantees that are within its scope. One such in-scope guarantee are
“contracts that contingently require the guarantor to make payments (either in cash . . . or provision of services) to the guaranteed party based on changes in an underlying that is related to an asset . . . of the guaranteed party.” Clearly the Company’s repurchase commitment requires it
(as guarantor) to make payment (in cash) to the lender (guaranteed party) on a contingent basis that is tied to a dealer’s default (i.e. an underlying of the lender’s asset) under its lending agreement. Thus it meets the criteria of a guarantee covered by ASC 460.
ASC 460-10-15-7(g) notes that a guarantee whose existence “prevents the guarantor from being able to either account for a transaction as the sale of an asset that is related to the guarantee’s underlying or recognize in earnings the profit from that sale transaction” is outside the scope of
ASC 460. This paragraph acknowledges that certain guarantees could prevent revenue recognition.
Examples of the types of guarantees that prevent the guarantor from being able to account for the transaction as a sale are illustrated in ASC 460-10-55-17. While the Company’s sales are not specifically addressed within ASC 460-10-55-17, we considered whether the Company’s sales had any of the characteristics that may prevent revenue recognition. Pre-codification, paragraph A19 of
FIN 45 referred to examples of guarantees whose existence prevents revenue recognition, and referenced examples in paragraphs 25 and 28 of FASB Statement 66, Accounting for Sales of Real
Estate. These examples referenced transactions that had continuing involvement that prevented the risks and rewards of ownership from transferring or guaranteed the buyer’s investment return. The
Company’s sales do transfer the risk and rewards of ownership to the dealers and the Company does not guarantee a return on the lenders investment.
Finally, we considered whether the value of the guarantee could become so significant that substantially all of the risks and rewards of ownership have not been transferred. For example, if the fair value of the repurchase guarantee became so significant to the overall arrangement that it constituted substantially all the value of the arrangement, it may indicate that it is likely that the guarantee will be acted upon and that substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership have not been transferred. Despite the economic downturn and the increase in repurchases in fiscal year 2009, the Company believes that the fair value of the repurchase guarantee is insignificant to the total arrangement.
Further, ASC 460-10-55-23(b) states “If the guarantee were issued in conjunction with the sale of assets, a product, or a business, the overall proceeds (such as the cash received or receivable) would be allocated between the consideration being remitted to the guarantor for issuing the guarantee and the proceeds from the sale. That allocation would affect the calculation of the gain or loss on the sale transaction.” Accordingly, the repurchase guarantee will impact the revenue recognized upon shipment of the RVs; however, in discussing these types of arrangements the guidance does not indicate that the guarantees should preclude sales recognition altogether but supports that the guarantee is one element of a multiple element transaction. As such, the Company accounts for its sales to dealers that are subject to the repurchase guarantees as multiple element transactions in which one element is a product and the other is a guarantee (credit enhancement) that is accounted for under ASC 460 Guarantees.
Based upon all the considerations above, the Company concluded that the repurchase guarantee does not prevent revenue recognition and should be accounted for as one element of a multiple element transaction. Our conclusion that the guarantee is an element of a multiple element transaction is further supported in Chapter 5 of the CCH revenue recognition guide which addresses guaranteeing loans in connection with a sale of products and states “If the company still concludes that collection is reasonably assured and that all other revenue recognition criteria have been met, FIN
45 (ASC 460) requires the transaction be treated as a multiple-element arrangement; one element is the product sale and the other is the loan guarantee”.
Additionally, both the Company and its competitors have consistently accounted for these repurchase obligations as guarantees under ASC 460 since that standard became effective in 2003. While industry practice is no substitute for a comprehensive analysis under the literature, the fact that the industry has consistently followed this model provides at least anecdotal support of the comprehensiveness of the Company’s analysis and the acceptability of the Company’s conclusion.
Accounting Analysis B.2 — Accounting for the repurchase reserves
As noted in the analysis above, the repurchase guarantee is one element of a multiple element transaction that should be accounted for under ASC 460. Under ASC 460, the fair value of the repurchase guarantee should be recorded as a liability at its estimated fair value when that guarantee is entered into (at this time any potential loss is not probable under ASC 450). A new guarantee is entered into with each sale and part of each sale should be attributed to ‘selling’ the guarantee rather than selling the product. Therefore upon each sale, the proceeds of sale should be allocated to the guarantee based upon the fair value of the guarantee with the remaining proceeds allocated to the product sale.
ASC 460 does not explicitly describe how to account for guarantees subsequent to inception. Some options are listed, such as no re-measurement until the guarantee partially or fully expires or is settled, a systematic amortization over the life of the guarantee and re-measuring to estimated fair value each reporting period. However, the use of the fair value method is only appropriate if that method can be justified under GAAP (for example the guarantee is in the scope of ASC 815).
The Company’s methodology approximates the extinguishment model as the ASC 460 liability is adjusted at each balance sheet date for the guarantees currently outstanding.
Additionally, the Company records a contingent liability element associated with the guarantees when a loss is probable of occurring under ASC 450. We also concluded that the classification as revenue of any allocated consideration to the guarantee was appropriate given that the guarantee is issued in connection with our ongoing major or central operations and is considered a separate element in a multiple element transaction.
The Company’s repurchase reserves materially represent the combined ASC 460 liability for the fair value of the guarantee and any contingent liability under ASC 450. Further the Company believes that based upon the historical repurchase rates and the fair value of the guarantee, the balance sheet and income statement impact of the guarantees and actual repurchases is immaterial to the
Company’s financial statements. Even during the economic downturn, the fair value of the liability and the actual amount of repurchases were immaterial.
Accounting Analysis B.3 — Accounting for the repurchase transactions
We also evaluated i) whether the original sale and cost of goods sold should be reversed upon repurchase of an RV ii) if the repurchased inventory should be accounted for as an asset and iii) whether or not the subsequent disposal as a sale should be recorded as an additional sales transaction. We believe that upon repurchase, the original sale and cost of goods sold should not be reversed as it was a valid sale at the time of the transaction and the repurchase is not due to a dealer’s right of return. The repurchased inventory should be recorded at its new cost basis subject to impairment under ASC 330 Inventory. Any subsequent sale or disposal should be treated as a gross revenue transaction as it is a separate substantive transaction, subject to the recognition of any repurchase guarantee associated with the sale. We believe this treatment is analogous to the guidance in ASC 605-15-25-5 which addresses product sold and subsequently repurchased subject to an operating lease and both the original sale and resale are recognized as revenue for the same physical product. The Company’s accounting for its repurchase transactions and reserves materially reflects the impacts of the above conclusions.
Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statements, page
Please file the Exclusivity Agreement between you and FreedomRoads Holding Company,
LLC, FreedomRoads, LLC and certain subsidiaries of FreedomRoads, LLC. It appears that this is a material agreement that should have been filed as an exhibit to your filing.
The Company will file the Exclusivity Agreement between it and FreedomRoads Holding Company, LLC,
FreedomRoads, LLC and certain subsidiaries of FreedomRoads, LLC as part of the Company’s Quarterly
Report on Form 10-Q for the period ending April 30, 2011
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements, Page F-7
Note L: Business Segments, Page F-20
We note your disclosure that SJC, for segment reporting, is aggregated in the buses reportable segment because of similar economic characteristics, and the nature of the products, production process, type of customer, distribution channels and regulatory environment. Please provide us your evaluation of these characteristics in accordance with the guidance in ASC
280-10-50-11, in which all criteria must be met, in support of your assertion that these characteristics are similar. In addition, in light of disclosure on page 1 in your filing that states that your operating subsidiaries continue as independent operations, please tell us how the chief operating decision maker assesses performance of SJC.
Background: Each of the Company’s individual operating businesses have been and continue to qualify as operating segments. However, those operating segments qualify for aggregation into three separate reportable segments (motorized RVs, towable RVs and buses) due to their respective similarities. The primary reporting to the Company’s chief operating decision maker, its chief executive officer, includes operating results and financial position for each operating business with subtotals for each reportable segment. With this information, the chief operating decision maker assesses performance and makes operating decisions for each operating segment.
The Company acquired SJC Industries Corp. (“SJC”) on March 1, 2010. As of and for the fiscal year ended July 31, 2010, SJC’s revenues, pre-tax earnings and total assets represented 0.6%, 0.1% and
2.2%, respectively, of the Company’s consolidated totals. Corresponding percentages were 1.3%,
0.6% and 1.9%, respectively, as of and for the six months ended January 31, 2011. As is evident from these percentages, SJC represents an immaterial component of the Company’s consolidated operations and financial statements. The Company has no reason to believe that SJC’s operating results or financial position will become material to its consolidated results in the foreseeable future.
Through early January 2011, the Company operated SJC similar to how SJC was operated in the past.
SJC continued to be managed by the executives who became Company employees after the acquisition.
Also, like its other operating businesses, the Company continued to have discrete financial information for SJC as evidenced by the Company’s monthly reporting and consolidation. Pursuant to
ASC 280, Segment Reporting, Section 10-50-1, since SJC is engaged in business activities from which it earns revenues and incurs expenses, those activities are regularly reviewed by the Company’s chief operating decision maker and has discrete financial information; SJC qualified as an operating segment. As described in the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended January 31, 2011, the Company internally restructured SJC under management control of its
Goshen Coach bus operations. As a result of that restructuring, Goshen Coach and SJC are managed by a single segment management group and share significant administrative functions.
In determining whether the SJC operating segment should be aggregated within its existing Bus reportable segment, management considered the aggregation criteria of ASC 280-10-50-11 and ASC
280-10-55-7A through 55-7C.
Management’s assessment is as follows:
In regards to the nature of products and services, SJC is a manufacturer in the ambulance conversion industry. It manufacturers and builds the body or ambulance onto a purchased or supplied chassis. It builds to order and its units have high option content. Similarly, our bus companies manufacture and build a bus conversion fitted onto a purchased or supplied chassis that is made to order and, due to required order specifications, also has high option content.
In regards to the nature of the production process, SJC is similar to buses in that most materials are purchased and the cutting and assembly is done by hand. The units are processed through a production line, moving station to station, being built to the specifications of the order.
In regards to the type of customers, like buses, the majority of SJC’s customers are municipalities that go through a bid process. SJC sells through a network of dealers, some of which are the same as our bus companies sell to. SJC will also enter into direct sales with the end customers, like our bus companies.
In regards to the distribution process, SJC distributes its products to customers throughout the
United States primarily on cash-on-delivery terms. SJC uses transport companies if arranged by the customer. Our bus companies also utilize transport companies.
In regards to the regulatory environment, both the ambulance conversion and bus conversion industry are highly regulated. As they both manufacture conversions on motorized chassis, both are regulated by the FMVSS (Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards), and the FMCSA (Federal Motor
Carrier Safety Administration). SJC does not currently sell into Canada, but they are exploring the option and if so would be regulated, as are the buses, by the CMVSS (Canadian Motor Vehicle
Safety Standards). However, they also each follow standards unique to their industry. Buses are subject to Altoona testing — this testing is what is required for federal funding. It is a durability test. Ambulances follow federal requirements for ambulances as defined by General
Services Administration Standard KKK-A-1822: Federal Specifications for Ambulances, the established ambulance standard that all government contracts require, and a list of test requirements established by the Ambulance Manufacturers Division of the National Truck Equipment Association.
In regards to economic characteristics, the Company notes that for the first full fiscal year that
SJC will be included in the consolidated totals (i.e., fiscal year ending July 31, 2011), the
Company’s bus operations are forecast (as adjusted for actual result through January 31, 2011) to realize a pre-tax operating margin of 6.7%, while SJC is forecast to realize a pre-tax operating margin of 3.3%. Excluding amortization expense related to intangible assets established in the purchase accounting for SJC, SJC’s forecasted pre-tax operating margin would be 5.2% as compared to the bus operations pre-tax operating margin of 6.7%. The Company expects that SJC will continue to realize economically similar operating results for the foreseeable future as compared to our bus operations.
As described above, management, in early calendar 2011, restructured the SJC operations under a common management team with its Goshen Coach bus operation. This combination was driven by the commonality of the two operations. The combined group now operates with commingled administrative functions as well as common management.
Accordingly, management’s overall assessment is that the SJC ambulance business does qualify for aggregation with the Company’s bus businesses for purposes of presenting reportable segments.
Please provide the disclosures required by ASC 280-10-50-40. It appears that you should be separately quantifying revenue attributable to ambulances. Provide us the disclosure that would have been included in the 2010 Form 10-K.
Revenues from sales of ambulances for the year ended July 31, 2010 and the quarterly period ended
April 30, 2010 (both subsequent to the Company’s March 1, 2010 acquisition of SJC) were $13.2 million and $6.0 million, respectively. These sales represented 0.6% and 0.9% of total consolidated sales for the year ended July 31, 2010 and the quarterly period ended April 30, 2010, respectively. Moreover, ambulance sales were $14.3 million for the six months ended January 31,
2011, representing 1.3% of total consolidated sales. The Company’s ambulance sales do not represent a material amount of total consolidated sales for any of these periods and are not expected to be material in the foreseeable future. Furthermore, as described above, SJC appropriately aggregates into the Buses reportable segment. The Company’s reportable segments are product-based — namely, Towable RVs, Motorized RVs and Buses. ASC 280-10-50-38 does not require the
ASC 280-10-50-40 disclosures to be made for similar products in such a reportable segment. We believe that buses and ambulances are similar products. ASC 280-10-50-38 indicates “Information required by paragraphs 280-10-50-40 through 50-42 need be provided only if it is not provided as part of the reportable operating segment information required by this Subtopic.” Accordingly, the
Company currently does not believe that disclosure of ambulance sales would be important to readers of its financial statements and does not believe such disclosure is required by the accounting standards. As such, the Company does not intend to provide disclosure of ambulance sales in its annual filings.
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please explain in detail why it was appropriate to recognize revenue on sales to FreedomRoad Holdings, considering that it appears your loans enabled FreedomRoad to repay its principal obligations under floor plan financing.Rest of the question
Collectability must also be reasonably assured before revenue can be recognized and absent the loan to FreedomRoad, it appears that you would have been obligated to repurchase the products sold to the dealer. See our related comment number 1 noted above.
Please see the Company’s response to Comment 1, Section A ii). In addition, we note that FRRead in the reply
LLC’s lender had not exercised its rights under the repurchase agreement with us.
Accordingly, we were under no obligation to have to repurchase the products we sold to FR LLC.
Had Mr. Adams not obtained the Loans from the Company in order to meet his equity contribution requirements under the forbearance agreement, he would likely have obtained the necessary funds through other means and/or continued to negotiate with the lenders rather than letting them deem the floor plan arrangements in defaultRest of the answer
and secure an interest in FR LLC’s considerable inventory. The lender’s apparent willingness to work with FR LLC in this matter demonstrates its reluctance to exercise its repurchase rights. Additionally, we note that payment for all shipments of product to FR LLC, including those associated with the Loans, were and continue to be collected by the Company within normal business terms approximately 15 days after shipment.
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
In addition, provide us your analysis of the loans as variable interests in FreedomRoad. Specifically, provide support for your assertion that you were not the primary beneficiary and that consolidation was not appropriate.
Please see the Company’s response to Comment 1, Section A i).Read in the reply
* * *
In addition, we confirm that:
We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and
We may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the
Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
First report after the company's reply of Mar 22, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Refer to prior comment one. Based on your response and information contained in the Credit Agreements filed as exhibits to the Forms 8-K dated January 22, 2009, February 3, 2009, and December 22, 2009 we understand the following with respect to the loans: A. Mr. Adams was obligated to contribute the loan proceeds as equity to FreedomRoads; B. Mr.Rest of the question
Adams was obligated to require FreedomRoads to purchase an increasing percentage of its inventory from you; C. Mr. Adams was obligated to compel FreedomRoads to immediately spend $10 million of the loan proceeds on purchases of your products; and D. The loans to Mr. Adams were secured by a first priority security interest in all of Mr. Adams’s interests in FreedomRoads and Mr. Adams cannot sell, transfer, or encumber his interests in FreedomRoads without your prior approval. As certain steps of the VIE analysis are dependent upon indentifying related parties and de-facto agents, we note that you concluded that Mr. Adams was neither a related party nor a de-facto agent of the Company. However, it appears that the loan conditions noted above may give rise to a related party under ASC 850 (FAS57) as these conditions appear to allow you a measure of control or significant influence over Mr. Adams and FreedomRoads. Please tell us in detail how you evaluated each of the loan conditions in regards to your assertion that the Company did not control or significantly influence Mr. Adams or FreedomRoads.
Refer to prior comment one. Based on your response and information contained in theRead in the reply
Credit Agreements filed as exhibits to the Forms 8-K dated January 22, 2009, February 3,
2009, and December 22, 2009 we understand the following with respect to the loans:
A.
Mr. Adams was obligated to contribute the loan proceeds as equity to
FreedomRoads;
B.
Mr. Adams was obligated to require FreedomRoads to purchase an increasing percentage of its inventory from you;
C.
Mr.Rest of the answer
Adams was obligated to compel FreedomRoads to immediately spend $10 million of the loan proceeds on purchases of your products; and
D.
The loans to Mr. Adams were secured by a first priority security interest in all of Mr. Adams’s interests in FreedomRoads and Mr. Adams cannot sell, transfer, or encumber his interests in FreedomRoads without your prior approval.
As certain steps of the VIE analysis are dependent upon indentifying related parties and de-facto agents, we note that you concluded that Mr. Adams was neither a related party nor a de-facto agent of the Company. However, it appears that the loan conditions noted above may give rise to a related party under ASC 850 (FAS57) as these conditions appear to allow you a measure of control or significant influence over Mr. Adams and FreedomRoads. Please tell us in detail how you evaluated each of the loan conditions in regards to your assertion that the
Company did not control or significantly influence Mr. Adams or FreedomRoads.
FIN 46(R), paragraph 16 requires that variable interests held by related parties be combined for the purposes of determining whether a VIE has a primary beneficiary. As FreedomRoads is the VIE in question, whether FreedomRoads is a related party to the Company does not appear relevant. As noted in our prior response to your previous comment one, we concluded that Mr. Adams should not be considered a related party under FAS 57, or a de facto agent or principal of the Company under FIN
46(R).
Important to our evaluation of the loan is our understanding that the criterion in ASC
810-10-25-42 was primarily included to prevent a reporting entity from avoiding consolidation of a
VIE under ASC 810-10-25-38 by structuring transactions to avoid consolidation while essentially controlling the VIE by having its related parties hold variable interests in the VIE. As we evaluated whether the loan to Mr. Adams (that was used to fund additional equity ownership in
FreedomRoads) created a related party relationship, we considered interpretive guidance issued by our independent accounting firm in making this assessment. We believe the following factors indicated that this arrangement was not structured to achieve such an accounting result:
•
The Company was in no position to be able to influence Mr. Adams to enter into the loan agreement. The Company and Mr. Adams negotiated the loans at arms-length and were not prevented by one another from fully pursuing their own interests.
Mr. Adams receives the full benefits and obligations associated with his equity interest in FreedomRoads and his rights are not meaningfully affected in any manner by the fact that the financing was provided by another variable interest holder.
Mr. Adams was not required to obtain financing from the Company — he could have obtained the incremental interest in FreedomRoads in any manner he chose and he had the financial means to do so.
The loan was negotiated at arms-length at market terms.
The Company has full recourse to the personal assets of Mr. Adams and the ability of Mr.
Adams to repay is not dependent upon the performance of his equity interest in
FreedomRoads.
In making the determination that Mr. Adams is not a related party, we concluded that the specific loan conditions you describe above did not provide us with either significant influence or control over Mr. Adams:
While Mr. Adams was obligated to contribute the loan proceeds as equity to
FreedomRoads, this loan provision does not allow the Company any influence whatsoever in
Mr. Adams’ actions related to the rest of his considerable net worth. Therefore, we do not believe that this provision provides us with significant influence or control over Mr.
Adams. We also note that the requirement to invest the loan proceeds as equity to
FreedomRoads was primarily to satisfy a condition of FreedomRoads’ lender, as opposed to a
Company-mandated condition. The Company merely leveraged this lender condition in order to further protect itself against the proceeds being put to other uses.
Although Mr. Adams was obligated to require FreedomRoads to purchase an increased percentage of its new vehicle inventory from the Company (pursuant to the exclusivity agreement), FreedomRoads was essentially required to do so in any case due to market conditions. Those market conditions included the then recent bankruptcy or suspension of operations of certain large RV manufacturers, thereby leaving the Company as a more significant source of product from all dealers, particularly a large dealer with heavier volume such as FreedomRoads. Additionally, the exclusivity agreement only requires
FreedomRoads to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs (based on certain conditions) from the
Company to the extent that we produce the types of new RVs that FreedomRoads decides to sell. The Company has no influence or control over which products FreedomRoads decides to sell to its customers. Further, the purchases under the exclusivity agreement are made at normal market prices, and there are no minimum quantities required. Finally, we understand that approximately half of FreedomRoads 2008 and 2009 revenues were from new vehicle sales, and the remainder of its revenues were from used units; service, parts and other; finance and insurance; and rental. Thus, the exclusivity agreement would be expected to pertain to less than half of the FreedomRoads revenue. Additionally, as new vehicle sales generally represent a disproportionately low percent of overall dealer margin, FreedomRoads profits are even less impacted by purchases under this agreement.
While Mr. Adams was obligated to compel FreedomRoads to immediately spend $10 million of the loan proceeds on purchases of our products, such inventory was needed by
FreedomRoads and the loan agreements merely document the arms-length negotiations and decisions of both parties. In addition, the amount of this purchase is immaterial to both FreedomRoads’ RV product purchases and the Company’s sales. As a provision involving a one-time purchase of a relatively small amount of product, we do not believe that such a provision could result in the Company having significant influence over FreedomRoads, let alone Mr. Adams. We also note that
FreedomRoads (and hence Mr. Adams) had complete control over which products to purchase from us, that the products were purchased at normal market prices, and that the products they purchased were sold by FreedomRoads in the normal course of their business.
While the original loans with Mr. Adams were secured by a first priority security interest in all of Mr. Adams’ equity interests in FreedomRoads and Mr. Adams agreed to continue to own his interests in FreedomRoads as a negative covenant of the loan agreement, we — based on Mr. Adams’ substantial net worth, (excluding his interest in
FreedomRoads), had no expectations of having to foreclose on the security interest in order to be repaid. Given that we believed that Mr. Adams had ample resources to repay the loans other than through his interests in FreedomRoads, we do not believe that the loan covenant to continue to own those interests provided the Company with significant influence or control over Mr. Adams. Said differently, if Mr. Adams wanted to sell, transfer or encumber his interest in FreedomRoads, he simply could have repaid the loans with funds available from his significant net worth or with the proceeds from a disposition of his interest in FreedomRoads which would retire the loan. While we sought this extra level of collateral protection in our original negotiations, in connection with the third loan to
Mr. Adams in December 2009, the earlier loan agreements were amended to remove these particular provisions.
In summary, while the loan conditions the Staff cites above may appear to limit the scope of Mr.
Adams and FreedomRoads future operational alternatives, these were commercial agreements entered into by willing independent parties, not unlike other commercial loan agreements and exclusivity agreements. Mr. Adams and the management of FreedomRoads continue to maintain all decision making and control over their ongoing operating, investing and financing activities. The Company does not participate in any management committees, hold any board or executive positions and therefore does not have any ability to influence ongoing decision making regarding FreedomRoads.
In addition, we note that even if we had concluded that Mr. Adams had a related party or de facto agent relationship with the Company, our conclusion that the Company is not the primary beneficiary of FreedomRoads would not have changed. Pursuant to the guidance in paragraph 17 of FIN 46(R), the single party in a related party or de facto agency relationship (that together form the primary beneficiary of a VIE) that is more closely associated with the VIE would be considered the ultimate primary beneficiary of that VIE. FIN 46(R), paragraph 17 provides the following factors we considered in determining that Mr. Adams is clearly more closely associated with FreedomRoads than is the Company:
a.
The existence of a principal-agency relationship — In considering whether the Company and Mr. Adams had a principal-agency relationship, we note that:
i.
Neither the Company, nor Mr. Adams, lead the other in any manner.
Neither is in charge of the other.
ii.
Neither the Company, nor Mr. Adams, has acted as a principal or agent of the other in the past.
iii.
Neither the Company, nor Mr. Adams, influenced the other to make their respective variable interests in FreedomRoads. Mr. Adams did request the
Company to make the loans, but the decision to do so by the Company was in no way controlled or compelled by Mr. Adams.
iv.
Neither the Company, nor Mr. Adams, bears any significant risks on the other’s behalf — recognizing that Mr. Adams’ significant net worth, excluding his interest in FreedomRoads, provides adequate means to repay the loans to the
Company.
v.
None of the indicators of principal-agency relationships as described in ASC 470-50, Debt-Modification and Extinguishments and ASC 605-45, Revenue
Recognition-Principal-Agent Considerations are determinatively present in our relationship with Mr. Adams.
Accordingly, we concluded that there is not a principal-agency relationship between the
Company and Mr. Adams, and thus this indicator is not determinative.
b.
The relationship and significance of the activities of the VIE to the parties
— As the primary owner, investor and operator of FreedomRoads, Mr. Adams clearly has a more significant relationship with and influence on its activities. The Company has a typical customer relationship with FreedomRoads that makes FreedomRoads’ dealings with the Company important to the Company, but ALL of FreedomRoads’ dealings with ALL of its customers are important to Mr. Adams. We also note that:
The Company’s operations — as a manufacturer of RVs — is different than the operations of FreedomRoads — as a dealer of RVs. The Company has no equity interests in any dealerships.
The Company’s variable interest in FreedomRoads does not represent a substantial portion of the Company’s total assets. On the other hand, Mr. Adams’ has made a substantial investment in FreedomRoads.
The outputs of FreedomRoads’ operations are not inputs into the
Company’s operations, nor has the Company outsourced any of its operations to
While the Company does sell products to FreedomRoads, such sales do not represent a majority of the Company’s sales.
No employees of the Company are involved in the operations of vi.
The compensation of FreedomRoads employees is not tied to the
Company’s stock or operating results.
vii.
The Company is not obligated to fund any operating losses or other activities of FreedomRoads.
viii.
The Company has no leasing, call or put arrangements with
Because these factors do not indicate increased or unusual association of FreedomRoads to the Company, they serve to support our conclusion that the activities of
FreedomRoads are much more related and significant to Mr. Adams. Thus we believe that this indicator would point towards Mr. Adams as being most closely associated with c.
Each party’s exposure to expected losses of the VIE — The Company’s exposure, as described in our prior response to your previous comment one, is very limited. Mr. Adams’ exposure extends to all variability with his significant ownership interests in FreedomRoads (which we understand to be 90% of the equity of FreedomRoads). Therefore this indicator would point towards Mr.
Adams as being most closely associated with FreedomRoads.
d.
The design of the VIE — While we acknowledge the impact of the Loans on the
‘redesign’ of FreedomRoads, it is a very small element in the overall design. As the primary owner and operator, Mr. Adams had a much larger impact on the original and evolving design of FreedomRoads. Therefore we believe that this indicator would point towards Mr. Adams as being most closely associated with FreedomRoads.
Therefore, based on the consideration of the above conditions, we believe that the Company would not be the party most closely associated with FreedomRoads and our accounting conclusions would be unchanged, even if Mr. Adams were considered a related party.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
In addition, we note that (i) Mr. Adams was obligated to contribute proceeds of loans received from you as equity to FreedomRoads and (ii) the loans were secured by a first priority security interest in all of Mr. Adams’s interests in FreedomRoads and Mr. Adams cannot sell, transfer, or encumber his interests in FreedomRoads without your prior approval.Rest of the question
Under ASC 810-10-25-43 (paragraph 16 of FIN 46(R)), these two conditions appear to give rise to a de facto agency relationship. Please tell us in greater detail why you believe that these facts do not give rise to a de facto agency relationship.
In addition, we note that (i) Mr. Adams was obligated to contribute proceeds of loans received from you as equity to FreedomRoads and (ii) the loans were secured by a first priority security interest in all of Mr. Adams’s interests in FreedomRoads and Mr. Adams cannot sell, transfer, or encumber his interests in FreedomRoads without your prior approval. Under ASC 810-10-25-43 (paragraph 16 of FIN 46(R)), these two conditions appear to give rise to a de facto agency relationship.Read in the replyRest of the answer
Please tell us in greater detail why you believe that these facts do not give rise to a de facto agency relationship.
Paragraph 16 of FIN 46(R) provides four factors that could cause another party to be considered a de facto agent of an enterprise. We considered each of those factors in relation to Mr. Adams.
Can Mr. Adams support his operations without subordinated financial support from the
Company? Yes, Mr. Adams (based on representations made by Mr. Adams to us during our due diligence investigation) does have adequate capital resources to support his personal operations as evidenced by his substantial credit-worthiness. His borrowing from the
Company was a personal decision to avoid having to divert other available resources to
FreedomRoads at this particular point in time.
Did Mr. Adams receive his interest in FreedomRoads from a contribution or loan from the Company? While Mr. Adams did fund this particular investment into FreedomRoads with a loan from the Company, Mr. Adams had already made a substantial investment in FreedomRoads
(which we understand to be 90% of the equity of FreedomRoads) — none of which was funded by the Company. Additionally, the loans were negotiated at arms-length at market terms, Mr. Adams could have raised the funds from other resources at his disposal and the loans do not convey any substantive requirements for Mr. Adams to act on the Company’s behalf. Please also refer to the above discussion of the factors considered under the response to
Question 1 which we believe supports why the loans to Mr. Adams do not create a related party / de-facto agency relationship as contemplated by FIN 46(R).
Is Mr. Adams an officer, employee or member of the Company’s governance Board? No.
Does the agreement by Mr. Adams to continue to own his interests in FreedomRoads cause him to be a de facto agent of the Company? No. As noted in paragraph 16d of FIN
46(R), restrictions similar to this covenant only create a de facto agency relationship if they “could constrain the other party’s ability to manage the economic risks or realize the economic rewards from its interests in a variable interest entity through the sale, transfer or encumbrance of those interests.” As the loan provision is only a negative covenant serving to protect our collateral position, Mr. Adams did not need to obtain our approval to sell his interest, and therefore could manage the economic risks or realize the economic rewards of his interest as he saw fit. While selling his interests would have been a covenant violation, the only consequence would have been a need to pay off the loan, with no penalty.
Given Mr. Adams significant wealth or if he chose to sell his ownership in FreedomRoads, we believe he would have been capable of paying off the loan as needed in order to manage the economic risks and rewards related to FreedomRoads.
Further, as noted above, these provisions were removed in December 2009.
Therefore, we do not believe that Mr. Adams has a de facto agency relationship with the Company.
Furthermore, as noted in our response to the previous question the determination of whether there is a de facto relationship has no impact on the ultimate conclusion as to whether the Company should consolidate FreedomRoads.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please tell us why the exclusivity agreement was not concluded to be a variable interest in FreedomRoads and why you concluded that there was no fair value associated with the agreement. It appears that this agreement changed the operating activity of FreedomRoads by requiring it to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs from you, and this may be an indicator of your participation in the redesign of FreedomRoads.Rest of the question
In addition, given that this agreement required FreedomRoads to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs from you, it appears that this exclusivity agreement would have fair value in excess of zero regardless of whether the related inventory purchases were otherwise at market value.
Please tell us why the exclusivity agreement was not concluded to be a variable interest in FreedomRoads and why you concluded that there was no fair value associated with the agreement. It appears that this agreement changed the operating activity ofRead in the reply
FreedomRoads by requiring it to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs from you, and this may be an indicator of your participation in the redesign of FreedomRoads.Rest of the answer
In addition, given that this agreement required FreedomRoads to purchase 80-90% of its new RVs from you, it appears that this exclusivity agreement would have fair value in excess of zero regardless of whether the related inventory purchases were otherwise at market value.
The Company has already concluded that it participated in the redesign of FreedomRoads and was therefore not scoped out of the complete FIN 46(R) assessment. This conclusion is irrespective of the exclusivity agreement’s impact on FreedomRoads or the Company. Instead, this conclusion was largely driven by the fact that the loans to Mr. Adams effectively refinanced a portion of
FreedomRoads’ outstanding debt.
To clarify, the exclusivity agreement requires FreedomRoads to acquire 80-90% of its new RVs from us to the extent that we produce the types of new RVs that FreedomRoads decides to sell. If
FreedomRoads decides to sell other new RVs that we do not produce, it is free to do so and to purchase all of those new RVs from any other vendor. Additionally, we understand that only about half of FreedomRoads revenues are represented by sales of new RVs; the remainder of its revenues arise from used units; service, parts and other; finance and insurance;
and rental.
Paragraph 2b of FIN 46(R) defines a variable interest as a contractual, ownership, or other pecuniary interest in an entity that changes with changes in the fair value of the entity’s net assets exclusive of the variable interest. As indicated in paragraphs B2 through B4 of FIN 46(R), and as expanded upon in paragraph 5 of FSP FIN46(R)-6, identifying variable interests is a two step process that first requires an enterprise (the Company) to identify the nature of the risks in the entity (FreedomRoads) and next requires the enterprise to determine the purpose of the entity and the variability that the entity was designed to create and pass along to its interest holders.
Following this two step approach, it appears that the nature of the relevant risks in FreedomRoads would include:
Sales volume risk — the risk of variability in the sales of new and used RVs as well as the variability in revenues associated with the service and repair of RVs owned by individual customers.
Retail price risk / Inventory price risk — the risk associated with variability in the spread between the cost of inventory and the retail sales associated with such inventory.
Other operating risk — other risks (reputation, repair warranty, etc) associated with the sales and service operations of FreedomRoads.
Because the exclusivity agreement provides for market prices to be paid to the Company for the products that FreedomRoads purchases, we believe that the exclusivity agreement would be a creator/contributor towards the variability associated with Retail / Inventory Price risk, and that therefore this agreement would not be considered an absorber of variability (i.e. a variable interest). Said differently, while the exclusivity agreement may serve to increase the amount of our sales to FreedomRoads, it does not result in the Company absorbing any variability in the fair value of the net assets of FreedomRoads.
With regards to the pricing terms of the exclusivity agreement (which forms part of our conclusion that the exclusivity agreement is a creator, rather than an absorber of variability), the Company believes that the selling prices to FreedomRoads are at market rates due to the ‘most favored nation’ provision in that agreement whereby the Company needs to offer FreedomRoads the lowest price that it offers to its other customers for the same RV. As such, FreedomRoads price is deemed to be at market and, by extension, not significantly different than if it purchased the new RV from a different vendor. While the Company is a large RV manufacturer, the RV market is very competitive with low barriers to entry and the Company has relatively little pricing power. Also, we note that FreedomRoads is essentially the “Walmart” of the retail RV industry and as such, commands favorable purchase prices from its vendors regardless of formal agreements.
With the contractual purchases being at market prices, the only way the exclusivity agreement can absorb any variability of FreedomRoads would be if it required FreedomRoads to purchase more products than it needs or if it required the Company to sell product to FreedomRoads that it otherwise would have sold to others. As the exclusivity agreement does not convey such requirements and for the reasons described above, the Company concluded that it does not represent a variable interest in
In regards to our assessment that the exclusivity agreement has very low or no fair value, our determination again focuses on the fact that the products sold under the agreement are sold at prices that represent current market prices for such products. As with many derivative and other financial instruments whose contractual provisions require others to transact at current market prices, this exclusivity agreement would have a low or de minimis fair value. In essence, such agreements are the equivalent of a contractual right to exchange four quarters for a single dollar.
We acknowledge that the exclusivity agreement may serve to increase our sales to FreedomRoads, but we earn no unusually higher or lower margin on such sales and, presuming end consumer demand existed for the products that we would sell to FreedomRoads, we would instead sell them through other dealers in our extensive network if FreedomRoads did not purchase them from us.
We additionally note that even if the exclusivity agreement represented a variable interest, that determination would not have significantly influenced our conclusion that the Company is not the primary beneficiary of FreedomRoads. This assessment is due to the very low value that such a variable interest would represent, as described above. With a low value, the ultimate inclusion of the exclusivity agreement as a variable interest in the primary beneficiary determination — even on the qualitative basis on which that determination was made — would not have changed the
Company’s conclusion.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please describe for us in greater detail your method of determining the fair value of your repurchase guarantees. In your response, tell us how you considered (i) the probability of failure of individually significant dealers that you know to be experience financial difficulty, such as FreedomRoads, (ii) the reduction in your dealers’ borrowing rate resulting from your guarantee, and (iii) your commitment toRest of the question
undertake the RV remarketing activities in the event an RV is repossessed by the floor plan lender. In addition, tell us how you determined that it is appropriate to classify the consideration allocated to the repurchase guarantee as revenue. Explain how you determined that the income received from your guarantees is part of your ongoing major or central operations.
Please describe for us in greater detail your method of determining the fair value of your repurchase guarantees. In your response, tell us how you considered (i) the probability of failure of individually significant dealers that you know to be experience financial difficulty, such as FreedomRoads, (ii) the reduction in your dealers’ borrowing rate resulting from your guarantee, and (iii) your commitment to undertake the RV remarketing activities in the event an RV is repossessed by the floor plan lender.Read in the replyRest of the answer
In addition, tell us how you determined that it is appropriate to classify the consideration allocated to the repurchase guarantee as revenue. Explain how you determined that the income received from your guarantees is part of your ongoing major or central operations.
We refer back to our prior response (Item B) to your previous comment one for background regarding our repurchase obligations. In addition to the factors described therein, we provide the following factors which support our overall assessment that the fair value of our repurchase guarantees is not material:
The pricing of our products to our customers is not reduced or increased depending on whether the customer purchases the product under a floor plan arrangement which includes a repurchase obligation from us to the lender. While 90% — 95% of the Company’s products are sold under such arrangements, the Company does sell to dealers on a cash-in-advance basis, a Company credit basis and a dealer-financed basis where that dealer financing is not associated with a repurchase obligation from us.
Fiscal 2009 and 2008 represented unprecedented declines in the recreational vehicle industry. Even during these difficult years, the Company repurchased only $44.8 million of products under repurchase agreements and resold all of that product to other dealers for only a $7.1 million loss, including costs to repurchase and resell and the difference between the Company’s repurchase price and the new dealer’s price.
The Company estimates the aggregate fair value of its repurchase guarantees for all open obligations each quarter end — which represents the sum of the initial fair value estimate of each guarantee when it is issued for those guarantees that are still outstanding as of quarter end.
This calculation of fair value is performed in the aggregate as the Company considers the pool of guarantees to be homogeneous. As the guarantee provisions are dictated by the floor plan lenders, as opposed to the individual dealers, the provisions are very similar across all of the Company’s customers.
The computation is premised on the generally accepted elements that make up such an obligation — a) the expected discounted cash flows to recover the guarantor’s losses and b) profit related to the guarantor’s losses and a capital charge to support the guarantor’s standby obligation. This premise is supported by ASC 460-10-30-2(b) which reads:
“If a guarantee is issued as part of a transaction with multiple elements with an unrelated party (such as in conjunction with selling an asset or entering into an operating lease), the liability recognized at the inception of the guarantee should be an estimate of the guarantee’s fair value. In that circumstance, a guarantor shall consider what premium would be required by the guarantor to issue the same guarantee in a standalone arm’s-length transaction with an unrelated party as a practical expedient.”
The Company estimates its expected losses based on actual historical repurchases as a percentage of sales over both a longer-term (3-5 years) and a shorter-term (12 months). These historical repurchase percentages are probability weighted based on management’s assessment of near-term future conditions relative to longer and shorter-term historical conditions. This weighted average factor is applied to open obligations (i.e., amounts due to floor plan lenders from dealers for products purchased from the Company under arrangements that include a Company repurchase guarantee) to arrive at expected repurchases. This amount is multiplied by a loss factor based on historical incurred losses on repurchased products. As the repurchase losses are generally incurred within two years of the initial sale of products to the dealer, the Company has concluded that time value of money would be immaterial and therefore does not discount its expected losses.
To estimate a profit related to the Company’s efforts to recover its losses and a capital charge to support the Company’s standby obligation, the Company multiplies the open obligations by a factor it believes to represent an average of a range of publically quoted rates for a standby obligation in a letter of credit plus a smaller increment representing a capital charge (in aggregate, 0.25% of obligations).
The aggregate of the expected losses, the profit element and the capital charge represent the Company’s estimate of the fair value of the guarantee obligation. This amount is further adjusted for incremental losses when they become probable in accordance with ASC 450-20 from known repurchases as of the balance sheet date if those losses are greater than the guarantee liability. The Company, as part of its analysis, also considers current economic and market conditions that may differ from historical trends.
The Company notes that, other than FreedomRoads, no single RV dealer is significant to its operations. The above computation does nonetheless consider any recent increased or decreased probability of failure of dealers (for example, during the recent economic declines) by weighing the historical near-term repurchase levels more or less heavily than historical longer-term repurchase levels.
The Company is not aware of what reductions there might be in its dealers’ borrowing rate resulting from our guarantee. However, as described in our prior response to your previous comment one, the lender absorbs significant risks when financing dealers regardless of our guarantee. In regards to the Company’s remarketing efforts in the event an RV is repossessed by the floor plan lender, those related costs are minimal. In substantially all cases, the repossessed products remain on the original dealer’s lot until another of the Company’s dealers in the same geographical area elects to purchase the products — which are essentially still new, but nonetheless carry a lower purchase price. Those units are then shipped the short distance to the new dealer. Any refurbishment costs related to the transferred vehicle are borne by the lender, as described in the previous response. The transportation and general clean up of the vehicle is minor.
In summary, the Company believes that the repurchase guarantee liabilities, coupled with known repurchase loss reserves, as reflected in its consolidated financial statements, and the overall income statement impact related to such reserves are immaterial. As of January 31, 2011,
July 31, 2010 and July 31, 2009, the aggregate repurchase liabilities were $3.9 million, $3.3 million and $6.3 million, respectively, and represented less than 3% of total liabilities as of each date. The loss due to repurchase as compared to consolidated net sales was .07%, .06%, .35%, and .07% for the year to date fiscal 2011, fiscal 2010, fiscal 2009, and fiscal 2008, respectively.
As over 90% of the Company’s RV products are sold under floor plan arrangements that include repurchase obligation provisions, the Company has concluded that the guarantees do represent a component of its ongoing major or central operations and would not be considered a gain because the guarantees are not peripheral or incidental. As such, recognition of the income related to the guarantees as revenues would be appropriate; however, see our response to your comment five below for further description of how the Company actually accounts for this income. The Company further notes that such revenue would represent less than 2% of consolidated revenues over the last 3 fiscal years and through January 31, 2011. We also note that it is common industry practice to report such income as revenues.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You state that you have consistently accounted for your repurchase obligations as guarantees under ASC 460 since that standard became effective in 2003. We note that your current year disclosure was revised to state that you estimate and defer a portion of the related product sale. Please clarify whether you deferred a portion of the arrangement consideration in periods prior to the fiscal year ended July 31, 2010.
You state that you have consistently accounted for your repurchase obligations as guarantees under ASC 460 since that standard became effective in 2003. We note that your current year disclosure was revised to state that you estimate and defer a portion of the related product sale. Please clarify whether you deferred a portion of the arrangement consideration in periods prior to the fiscal year ended July 31, 2010.Read in the reply
As disclosed in our July 31, 2010 financial statements, we believe the appropriate accounting policy, as required by ASC 460, is to defer a portion of the arrangementRest of the answer
consideration. In the ordinary course of business, the Company has actually always recorded a loss reserve for expected repurchases as an increase in selling expenses as opposed to a deferral of initial revenues related to the guarantees. We compare the results of our actual accounting with the accounting required by
ASC 460, and have concluded that the revenue, gross margin and operating income misclassification for any period is immaterial. For fiscal 2008, 2009 and 2010 and for the six months ended January 31, 2011, none of these income statement line items would have required an adjustment of more than 2% of the reported line item balance. In the event of a material discrepancy, we would make any adjustment necessary to ensure our results were reported in accordance with ASC 460. In preparing our 2010 Form 10-K disclosures, we changed our accounting policy disclosure to describe our policy consistent with the requirements of ASC 460, to avoid any confusion that our day-to-day accounting might produce results that are materially inconsistent with GAAP.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please provide us your detailed calculation of the fair value of the repurchase guarantee for FreedomRoads as of July 31, 2010. Explain the significant assumptions used in determining the fair value.
Please provide us your detailed calculation of the fair value of the repurchase guarantee for FreedomRoads as of July 31, 2010. Explain the significant assumptions used in determining the fair value.Read in the reply
As discussed above, the Company computes its repurchase guarantee fair value on an aggregate basis across all of its dealers and did so as of July 31, 2010. The resulting estimate was immaterially less than our recorded reserves at that time.Rest of the answer
We do not have a computation of the fair value of the repurchase guarantee for FreedomRoads as of July 31, 2010 because we view the guarantees to be a homogeneous pool as previously discussed.
On certain occasions, we do require a computation of the fair value of the obligation for a single dealer. As such a computation was necessary for our FIN 46(R) assessment regarding FreedomRoads, the Company did compute an estimate of the fair value of our obligation as it specifically related to FreedomRoads as of when the initial loans were issued. Our computation included the development of potential loss scenarios based on two specific variables — a) the percentage of open repurchase obligations ($73.0 million as of January 31, 2009) that might result in actual repurchases (which we varied from 10% to 50% in 5 to 10 percentage point increases) and b) the amount of loss that might be realized under each repurchase scenario (which we varied from 10% to 20% in 5 percentage point increases and based on historical repurchase losses). The resulting potential losses under these scenarios ranged from $730,000 to $7.3 million and averaged $2,972,000. Accordingly, we used a $3.0 million estimate in our FIN 46(R) assessment. We acknowledge that this valuation method captures an estimate of potential repurchase losses rather than the fair value of the actual outstanding guarantees; however, using the parameters described in our response to your comment four above, the estimated fair value of the guarantees on the $73.0 million is only $0.8 million.
For purposes of our FIN 46(R) assessment, we used the more conservative estimate. In any case, we believe this estimate is very conservative given our belief at the time (for the reasons described in our prior response to your previous comment one) that it was unlikely that FreedomRoads’ lender would actually exercise its rights to repossess inventory and thereafter exercise its right to have the Company repurchase such inventory. Furthermore, although we consider FreedomRoads as part of our homogeneous pool, had we instead determined that FreedomRoads’ then-current financial condition set it apart from our other dealers and the guarantee related to it needed to be calculated separately as the $3 million estimate above, the increase in the total guarantee obligation would not be materially different than what was recorded.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Please tell us how you determined that internal control over financial reporting was effective as of July 31, 2010 in light of the Form 12B-25 filing. It appears that portions of your VIE analysis was not complete.
We note that the 12B-25 filing on June 10, 2010 related to our Form 10-Q for the quarter endedRead in the reply
April 30, 2010. All portions of our VIE analysis were complete as of the time we filed our Form
10-Q for the quarter ended April 30, 2010 on July 1, 2010 and thus were completed prior to July 31,
2010. The Company, under the supervision of its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial
Officer, completed an assessment of the effectiveness of the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of July 31, 2010 and found such controls to be effective as of that date.
* * *
In addition,Rest of the answer
we confirm that:
We are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and
We may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the
Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
First report after the company's reply of May 3, 2011: 10-Q filed Jun 8, 2011 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Nov 30, 2010 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2011-08-10