We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and respectfully advise the Staff that, as disclosed in our previous filings, our
analyses involve highly subjective judgments and assumptions about future cash flows to be generated by our drilling rigs. In future filings, we will enhance our disclosures as illustrated below to describe the methods by which the information underlying these judgments and assumptions is derived. Furthermore, our enhanced disclosures below discuss the highly cyclical and unpredictable nature of our industry and the accuracy of our past assumptions.
Rest of the answer
We have also supplemented our disclosure to discuss the risks and uncertainties and potential events and changes in circumstances that could result in materially different estimates.
Given the numerous factors noted below in our enhanced disclosures that can uniquely and significantly impact the recoverability of our rigs and the complex interdependencies across our judgments and assumptions, we believe it is impractical for us to provide a quantitative sensitivity analysis that would be meaningful to our investors. For example, there is a wide range of interrelated changes in judgments and assumptions that could reasonably occur for each rig, each of which could occur for an individual rig, group of rigs or our entire fleet of 54 rigs. This results in a significant number of variations in the likelihood and magnitude of any potential additional impairment charge that could be expected. We believe the selection of any one of these variations or group of variations of judgments and assumptions would lead to a highly complex, arbitrary and potentially misleading disclosure that would unintentionally imply a level of precision in our cash flow estimates that does not exist.
However, we believe enhancing our disclosure with the below information will provide sufficient additional relevant information to our investors on the risks and uncertainties around our impairment analyses and related estimates.
We respectfully advise the Staff that we will include the following expanded disclosure within the Critical Accounting Policies and Estimates section of Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations in future filings, including in our Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2017. For the Staff’s reference, new or additional language appears in bold underline and deleted language appears with a strikethrough:
Impairment of Long-Lived Assets
We evaluate the carrying value of our property and equipment, primarily our drilling rigs, when events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying value of such rigs may not be recoverable. Generally, extended periods of idle time and/or inability to contract rigs at economical rates are an indication that a rig may be impaired. Impairment situations may arise with respect to specific individual rigs, groups of rigs, such as a specific type of drilling rig, or rigs in a certain geographic location.
For property and equipment used in our operations, recoverability generally is determined by comparing the carrying value of an asset to the expected undiscounted future cash flows of the asset. If the carrying value of an asset is not recoverable, the amount of impairment loss is measured as the difference between the carrying value of the asset and its estimated fair value. The determination of expected undiscounted cash flow amounts requires significant estimates, judgments and assumptions, including utilization levels, day rates, expense levels and capital requirements, as well as cash flows generated upon disposition, for each of our drilling rigs. Due to the inherent uncertainties associated with these estimates, we perform sensitivity analysis on key assumptions as part of our recoverability test.
Our judgments and assumptions about future cash flows to be generated by our drilling rigs are highly subjective and based on consideration of the following:
· global macroeconomic and political environment,
· historical utilization, day rate and operating expense trends by asset class,
· regulatory requirements such as surveys, inspections and recertification of our rigs,
· remaining useful lives of our rigs,
· expectations on the use and eventual disposition of our rigs,
· weighted-average cost of capital,
· oil price projections,
· sanctioned and unsanctioned offshore project data,
· offshore project break-even economic data,
· global rig supply and construction orders,
· global rig fleet capabilities and relative rankings, and
· expectations of global rig fleet attrition.
We collect and analyze the above information to develop a range of estimated utilization levels, day rates, expense levels and capital requirements, as well as estimated cash flows generated upon disposition. The most subjective assumptions that impact our impairment analyses include projections of future oil prices and timing of global rig fleet attrition, which, in large part, impact our estimates on timing and magnitude of recovery from the current industry downturn. However, there are numerous judgments and assumptions unique to the projected future cash flows of each rig that individually, and in the aggregate, can significantly impact the recoverability of its carrying value.
The highly cyclical nature of our industry cannot be reasonably predicted with a high level of accuracy and therefore differences between our historical judgments and assumptions and actual results will occur. We reassess our judgments and assumptions in the period in which significant differences are observed and may conclude that a triggering event has occurred and perform a recoverability test. We recognized material impairment charges during 2014 and 2015 upon observation of significant unexpected changes in our business climate.
There are numerous factors underlying the highly cyclical nature of our industry that are reasonably likely to impact our judgments and assumptions including, but not limited to, the following:
· changes in global economic conditions,
· production levels of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (“OPEC”),
· production levels of non-OPEC countries,
· advances in exploration and development technology,
· offshore and onshore project break-even economics,
· development and exploitation of alternative fuels,
· natural disasters or other operational hazards,
· changes in relevant law and governmental regulations,
· political instability and/or escalation of military actions in the areas we operate,
· changes in the timing and rate of global newbuild rig construction, and
· changes in the timing and rate of global rig fleet attrition.
There is a wide range of interrelated changes in our judgments and assumptions that could reasonably occur as a result of unexpected developments in the aforementioned factors, which could result in materially different carrying values for an individual rig, group of rigs or our entire rig fleet, materially impacting our operating results.
If the global economy deteriorates and/or other events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying value of one or more drilling rigs may not be recoverable, we may conclude that a triggering event has occurred and perform a recoverability test. If, at the time of the recoverability test, our judgments and assumptions regarding future industry conditions and operations have diminished, it is reasonably possible that we could conclude that one or more of our drilling rigs are impaired.
Asset impairment evaluations are highly subjective. In most instances, they involve expectations of future cash flows to be generated by our drilling rigs, which reflect our judgments and assumptions regarding future industry conditions and operations, as well as estimates of expected utilization levels, day rates, expense levels and capital requirements. The estimates, judgments and assumptions used in the application of our asset impairment policies reflect both historical experience and an assessment of current operational, industry, market, economic and political environments. The use of different estimates, judgments, assumptions and expectations regarding future industry conditions and operations would likely result in materially different asset carrying values and operating results.