Screener / SEC EDGAR /CIK 0001674910 /10-K filed Nov 21, 2025, compared with Nov 22, 2024 /Numbers from the XBRL of the 10-Ks
NYSE Energy · Miscellaneous Products of Petroleum & Coal

Valvoline Inc VVV

Compare with peers Embed
SEC comment letters, last 20 years

5 reviews of VVV's filings by SEC staff

UPLOAD and CORRESP
Reviews 5 latest letter Mar 12, 2026
Questions asked 33 each answered in the company's own letter
No closing letter 1 reviews without a letter saying the staff completed it

When the SEC's staff reviews a filing, it writes to the company with numbered questions, and the company answers each one in a letter. SEC publishes the exchange once the review is over, at least 20 business days later. A question is not an accusation; most reviews end with the company adding detail to its next filing.

How the reviews went

Every review on EDGAR, from the first staff letter to the letter that closes it

  1. 1. Staff letters 9 UPLOAD
  2. 2. Questions in them 33 numbered comments
  3. 3. Company replies 8 CORRESP
  4. 4. Reviews closed 4 of 5 closing letter

Half the closed reviews took 64 days or less from the first letter to the closing letter.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year ended September 30, 2025

2026-03-12 to 2026-04-24 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2026-04-24
Results discussion (MD&A)Goodwill and impairmentAcquisitions
Management's Discussion and Analysis · Recent Developments, page 31
SEC asked (1)
We note that you provide various disclosures regarding your plans to acquire Breeze Autocare in the annual report and that updates were disclosed in the Form 8-K that you filed on December 1, 2025, and in the Form 10-Q that you filed on February 4, 2026, indicating the transaction was completed in exchange for $638.7 million.
Rest of the question

Please explain to us how you evaluated the significance of this transaction and the requirements in Item 9.01 of Form 8-K, in determining that you would not file an amendment to the Form 8-K within the allotted period of time to include historical financial statements of the entity and pro forma financial statements illustrating the effects of the transaction, based on the guidance in Rule 3-05 and Article 11 of Regulation S-X. Please include the numerical analyses that you performed for each aspect of the significance test requirements along with your reply.

VVV answered
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company respectfully advises that its acquisition of Breeze Autocare (“Breeze”) did not meet the threshold to be considered a significant acquisition pursuant to Rule 3-05 or Article 11 of Regulation S-X as the results of the investment test, asset test, and income test did not exceed the 20% significance threshold.
Rest of the answer

Therefore, the filing of an amendment to Form 8-K to include the historical financial statements of Breeze or related pro forma financial information was not required under Rule 3-05 or Article 11 of Regulation S-X.

The numerical analyses for each significance test are summarized below (the amounts are based on U.S. GAAP audited financial statements of the Company and the most recent pre-acquisition audited annual financial statements of Breeze):

Test

(in millions) Breeze Valvoline Result

Investment test $ 638.7

(a)

$ 4,754.3

(b)

13.4 %

Asset test $ 448.6

(c)

$ 2,670.4

(d)

16.8 %

Income test (e)

Revenue component $ 199.6

$ 1,710.3

11.7 %

Income component $ 39.1

$ 292.3

(a)Represents consideration transferred to Breeze shareholders on December 1, 2025.

(b)Represents the average of the aggregated worldwide market value calculated using the shares outstanding and the daily closing prices of the Company’s common stock on the last five trading days in January 2025 (the last completed month prior to the agreement date of February 17, 2025).

(c)As of and for the fiscal year ended December 28, 2024.

(d)As of and for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2025.

(e)The income test is equal to the lower of the revenue component or the income component. Because the result of the revenue component is lower than the income component, the income test is evaluated using the revenue component.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 26, 2026: 10-Q filed May 7, 2026 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 4, 2026 ↗.

Recent Developments: 39 paragraphs changed; the 3 closest in words to the question are below.

Reworded

Net revenues increased $47.5 $100.6 million, or 11.5% 25.0% for the three months ended December March 31, 2025 2026 compared to the same prior year period, primarily driven by reflecting network expansion growth of 335 331 net new system-wide stores, led driven by the Breeze acquisition, along with favorable improvements in service mix acquisition and pricing. other openings. System-wide SSS also increased 5.8% driven 8.2%, supported by higher average ticket, reflecting ongoing premiumization, ticket from net pricing benefits, ongoing premiumization, and non-oil change service penetration, along with favorable transaction trends. These gains increases were partially offset by lower net revenues as a result of due to disposition activity. The following reconciles the year-over-year change in net revenues:

30 words cut, 26 added sec.gov
Reworded

Gross profit For the six months ended March 31, 2026, Net revenues increased $19.6 $148.1 million, or 12.8%, for the three months ended December 31, 2025 18.1% compared to the prior year period. The increase was largely attributable to volume, cost efficiencies and pricing, year, driven primarily by network growth, including the Breeze acquisition, as well as contributions improvements in service mix and pricing. System-wide SSS revenue grew 7.0%, reflecting higher average ticket from acquired stores. net pricing benefits, continued premiumization, and favorable transaction trends. These benefits were partially offset by higher expenses associated with continued network expansion, including depreciation from new stores. the impact of disposition activity. The following reconciles the year-over-year change in gross profit: year-to-date net revenues:

42 words cut, 54 added sec.gov
Reworded

Net interest legacy and other financing separation-related expenses increased $8.0 $0.1 million and $4.9 million for the three and six months ended December March 31, 2025 2026, respectively, compared to the prior year period. The primarily due to expenses associated with legacy businesses and an increase in expense was largely attributable estimated reserves related to $4.7 million of fees incurred to maintain access to certain obligations assumed from the Term Loan B and related financing in advance of the Breeze acquisition closing, at which time the Term Loan B became effective. Interest expense also increased $3.7 million incurred for the Term Loan B following the close of the Breeze acquisition. Company’s former parent company.

62 words cut, 32 added sec.gov

Paragraphs where only numbers, dates or period words changed are not shown. Cut words struck through, new words highlighted.

Management's Discussion and Analysis · Recent Developments, page 31
SEC asked (2)
We understand from the disclosures on page 10 of your recent interim report that in conjunction with your acquisition of Breeze Autocare, you immediately sold 45 of the 207 stores acquired pursuant to a Federal Trade Commission Decision and Order.
Rest of the question

You state that the fair value was $90 million including an allocation of goodwill, although the sale generated a $57.9 million pre-tax loss, indicating sale proceeds of $32.1 million. Given the disparity between these amounts and considering the timeframe, tell us how you determined that the fair value was not the amount that you agreed to receive in exchange. Please also describe your approach in establishing reporting units and allocating the purchase price and goodwill among them, to include details of how stores to be retained and the stores to be sold were considered in this process. Provide us the numerical analyses utilized in your allocations and any additional information necessary to understand the underlying basis and rationale, also clarifying how the methods appropriately reflect the requirements in FASB ASC 350-20-40-1 through 5, and 9, to the extent applicable, in your view.

VVV answered
In response to the Staff's comment, the Company respectfully provides the following information regarding its accounting for the Breeze acquisition of 204 quick lube service center stores1 on December 1, 2025 and the immediate divestiture of 45 of the acquired stores as required by the Federal Trade Commission ("FTC") Decision and Order.

Disposal Group Held-for-Sale Classification

At the time of the Breeze acquisition, the principal net assets of the 45 stores acquired and required to be divested included inventory, leased store rights and obligations, and store-related furniture, fixtures,
Rest of the answer

and equipment. The Company determined these stores represented a disposal group as defined in ASC 360-10-20, and the disposal group met the ASC 805 definition of a business. Management concluded the disposal group met the held-for-sale criteria as of the acquisition date in accordance with ASC 360-10-45-12 and ASC 360-10-45-9. Specifically:

•A binding Asset Purchase Agreement was executed with the buyer of the 45 stores on November 12, 2025 subject to the FTC-imposed buyer eligibility constraints and approval as described further herein.

•The FTC Decision and Order issued on November 14, 2025 required the sale of the 45 identified stores no later than 10 days after closing the Breeze acquisition.

•The binding nature of the FTC Decision and Order precluded any changes to the divestiture plan.

•The FTC Decision and Order identified the buyer of the 45 stores.

•The stores were operational and available for immediate sale in their condition at the acquisition date.

•The FTC-mandated sale was completed on December 1, 2025 immediately following the closing of the Breeze acquisition.

Purchase Consideration Allocation

The Company accounted for the Breeze acquisition as a business combination in accordance with ASC 805 and engaged an independent valuation specialist to assist in determining fair values. Fair values were determined using a combination of recognized valuation methodologies, including income, market and cost approaches. The purchase consideration was allocated to the identifiable assets acquired and liabilities assumed based on their estimated fair values at the acquisition date, as required by ASC 805 and as summarized below:

1 Three additional Breeze quick lube service center stores opened post-acquisition during December 2025.

As of December 1, 2025 (in millions)

Fair value of identifiable assets acquired for retained stores $ 193.7

Fair value of liabilities assumed for retained stores (198.3)

Fair value of disposal group less costs to sell (a)

90.0

Total consideration transferred 638.7

Excess of consideration transferred over fair value of net assets acquired (b)

$ 553.3

(a)An acquired disposal group classified as held-for-sale is measured at fair value less costs to sell, which was estimated to be $90.0 million. Note that costs to sell were de minimis and waived as immaterial for further consideration.

(b)The excess of consideration transferred over the fair value of net assets acquired represents goodwill.

Because the 45 stores met the held-for-sale criteria as of the acquisition date, management evaluated the applicable guidance and determined that ASC 805-20-30-22 provides the most relevant framework for measuring the disposal group at acquisition. ASC 805 refers to ASC 360-10-35-43 which specifies that an acquired disposal group classified as held-for-sale is measured as a unit of account at fair value less costs to sell as of the acquisition date, rather than recognizing individual assets acquired and liabilities assumed and residual goodwill. In support of this judgment regarding the unit of account as the disposal group, the Company noted the guidance of ASC 360-10-15-4(b) and the interpretative guidance in the SEC Staff Speech by Adam Brown, Professional Accounting Fellow, Office of the Chief Accountant, “Remarks Before the 2008 AICPA National Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments” that indicated the unit of account is the disposal group as opposed to the individual assets within the disposal group. As the 45 stores were determined to constitute a disposal group within the scope of ASC 360, management concluded that the unit of account should be the disposal group itself.

In this context, the Company respectfully submits that ASC 350-20-40-1 through 5 and 9, which addresses goodwill derecognition after initial recognition at acquisition, was not considered applicable to the initial measurement of the disposal group. As a result, the carrying amount of the disposal group reflects its fair value less costs to sell as of the acquisition date.

This is further supported by ASC 350-20-50-1(b), which explicitly excludes goodwill included in an acquired disposal group classified as held-for-sale from the reconciliation of changes in the goodwill balance, reflecting that the unit of account for an acquired disposal group is the carrying value of the disposal group as a whole as opposed to its individual assets acquired and liabilities assumed and any implicit residual goodwill.

Fair Value of the Disposal Group

The Company evaluated whether the $32.1 million in proceeds received from the FTC-mandated divestiture represented the fair value of the 45-store disposal group in accordance with ASC 820. Based on the weight of evidence, the Company concluded the divestiture transaction was not orderly and therefore, did not rely principally on the transaction price in its fair value determination, consistent with ASC 820-10-35-54I and 35-54J. The Company accordingly placed primary weight on the independent valuation of the disposal group performed by an independent valuation specialist as described further below.

Indicators of a Non-Orderly Transaction

The following circumstances noted in ASC 820-10-35-54I were evaluated as indicators of a transaction that may not be orderly:

Market Exposure

There was insufficient market exposure to conduct customary marketing activities for the FTC-mandated sale of the 45 stores. The Company executed the divestiture under a compressed timeline that was substantially shorter than is customary for comparable quick lube retail transactions, which typically involve several months to identify prospective buyers, conduct diligence, negotiate deal terms, and negotiate and execute a definitive purchase agreement. In this circumstance, the Company negotiated purchase agreements with prospective buyers, obtained necessary third party consents, and obtained FTC approval for the buyer and executed purchase agreement over a two-month period, resulting in FTC approval of the required sale on November 14, 2025.

Regulatory constraints, including FTC-required approval of any prospective buyer and restrictions imposed by the FTC to preserve competition in the relevant markets, significantly limited the pool of potential buyers and prevented broad marketing of the 45 stores. Additionally, prospective buyers’ awareness of the FTC regulatory review of the Breeze acquisition, the impact of the FTC’s competitive analysis, Valvoline’s commitment under the Breeze merger agreement, including transaction deadlines and regulatory efforts provisions, as well as other transaction-related dynamics further reduced the Company’s bargaining power in connection with the sale of the 45 stores. The pendency of the government shutdown in October 2025 further impeded the divestiture process, as the FTC was largely unable to engage with Valvoline or prospective buyers and restricted its evaluation to a single buyer proposal of all 45 stores. These circumstances prevented the Company from submitting alternative divestiture proposals involving multiple buyers that may have yielded greater transaction value. These factors resulted in a forced sale and negotiation between parties compelled to transact as opposed to market participants motivated to transact in an orderly transaction.

Regulatory Compulsion

The Company was under regulatory compulsion to sell the 45 stores to obtain FTC clearance to close the Breeze acquisition. The FTC Decision and Order issued November 14, 2025 imposed the following specific constraints:

•Required divestiture completion within 10 days of closing the Breeze acquisition

•Approval rights over the buyer, limiting the buyer to the party identified in the Decision and Order

•The FTC could appoint a trustee to accomplish the divestiture if it were not completed by the Company

Transaction Price as an Outlier

The following table summarizes the transaction price per store observed in the comparable transactions utilized by the independent valuation specialist, as well as the Breeze acquisition and related divestiture:

Transaction category

Transaction price per store (a)

(in millions)

Comparable transactions (most recent five years) - average $ 2.6

Comparable transactions - range:

Low $ 1.2

High $ 4.7

Breeze acquisition (204 stores) $ 3.1

Breeze disposal group (45 stores) $ 0.7

(a) Per store measures do not represent a valuation methodology and are presented herein for comparative and corroborative purposes only. Differences in transaction price per store reflect variations in store size, location, profitability, and other relevant factors in the comparable transactions.

As reflected in the table above, the per store transaction price for the Breeze disposal group is significantly lower than the average transaction price per store and below the low end of the range observed in comparable transactions, as well as the Breeze acquisition as a whole. This disparity provides corroboration that the disposal group transaction price is an outlier that was not considered to represent an orderly transaction.

Independent Valuation

An independent valuation specialist estimated the fair value of the 45 stores as of the acquisition date using market participant assumptions in an orderly transaction framework. In performing the valuation, the independent valuation specialist obtained an understanding of the relevant facts and circumstances surrounding the FTC-mandated divestiture and determined the most appropriate methodology for estimating the fair value of the disposal group was to employ a market approach. The valuation was performed using the Guideline Merged and Acquired Company method under the market approach and identified comparable transactions involving quick lube retail service center stores during the most recent five years.

Based on these comparable transactions, the independent valuation specialist selected an Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization (“EBITDA”) multiple, which was calculated for each comparable transaction. From the range of the comparable transaction valuation multiples, relevant ranges were established to select a multiple for the divested business. The selected multiple was based on the consideration of quantitative and qualitative factors that take into account differences between the divested business and the comparable transactions. Specifically, with regard to the selected multiple, emphasis was placed on the overall deal multiple considering a discount for the following key factors relative to the disposal group:

•Absence of brand and intellectual property, which limits the ability to leverage pre-established and long-standing market presence; and

•Lack of opportunities for operational scale, national marketing support, capital access, and other benefits of a larger acquired store base.

The selected multiple was applied to the EBITDA of the disposal group and resulted in a fair value indication of $90.0 million.

Reporting Unit Determination

The Company’s process for establishing reporting units involves identifying operating segments or components thereof that constitute businesses for which discrete financial information is available and is regularly reviewed by segment management. Components that are deemed economically similar are aggregated into one reporting unit. Prior to the Breeze acquisition, the Company consisted of a single reporting unit in accordance with ASC 350, as its components—for which discrete financial information was available and regularly reviewed by segment management in accordance with ASC 280—were economically similar, and therefore, aggregated into one reporting unit.

In connection with the Breeze acquisition, the Company evaluated whether its reporting unit determination required modification, considering specifically how the acquired operations would be managed, reported and integrated. This assessment concluded that the Breeze acquisition did not change the Company’s components. Furthermore, the Company’s components continue to exhibit similar economic characteristics as outlined in ASC 280-10-50-11 and ASC 350-20-55-6 to 8. As a result, the Company continues to meet the criteria for aggregation and is considered one reporting unit in accordance with ASC 350-20-35-35.

Based on this assessment, the 159 retained stores were integrated into the pre-existing Company quick lube operations component and ultimately, Valvoline’s single reporting unit. Regarding the 45 stores subject to the FTC divestiture requirement, because they met held-for-sale criteria at the acquisition date and were immediately sold, they were not integrated in any manner and did not impact the Company’s reporting structure.

Goodwill Assignment

In connection with the acquisition of Breeze, goodwill of $553.3 million was recognized as a result of application of the acquisition method of accounting under ASC 805. Goodwill recognized was assigned in accordance with ASC 350-20-35-41 to the Company's single reporting unit, which is expected to benefit from the synergies of the acquisition. Benefits of the acquisition include expected operational synergies as integration activities occur and economic benefits in the respective markets served by the acquired business driven by growth expected to result in increased revenues and earnings from adding to the Company’s retail store network.

Divestiture Accounting

Upon closing the sale of the 45 stores on December 1, 2025, the pre-tax loss of $57.9 million was computed as follows in accordance with ASC 360-10-40-3B and 5 and ASC 810-10-40-5:

Sale proceeds received $ 32.1

Less: Carrying amount of disposal group (a)

(90.0)

Pre-tax loss $ (57.9)

(a)Carrying amount of disposal group at disposition represents fair value less costs to sell. Note that costs to sell were de minimis and waived as immaterial for further consideration.

Summary

Based on the Company’s assessment summarized herein, including the qualitative and quantitative factors, the authoritative literature, and consultation with its external advisors, the Company respectfully submits the most appropriate treatment of the transactions that occurred during the first quarter ended December 31, 2025 reflects the following:

•The 45 stores met held-for-sale criteria as of the acquisition date, such that ASC 805 governed the measurement of the disposal group.

•The disposal group was measured at fair value less costs to sell as of the acquisition date, with fair value independently determined to be $90 million.

•The $32.1 million in sale proceeds reflects a forced sale environment arising from FTC-mandated constraints, and consistent with ASC 820-10-35-54I and 35-54J, was not considered an orderly transaction price representative of fair value.

•The goodwill of $553.3 million recognized for the 159 retained stores was assigned to the Company's single reporting unit expected to benefit from the acquisition.

•The pre-tax loss of $57.9 million represents the impact of the regulatory forced divestiture and was determined in accordance with ASC 360, ASC 810 and ASC 820.

The Company acknowledges its footnote disclosures could benefit from enhancement, and management expects to revise its disclosures in future filings beginning with its next periodic report on Form 10-Q to clarify:

•The valuation methodologies used to determine the fair value of the identifiable net assets acquired, including the held-for-sale disposal group,

•The disposal group met the held-for-sale criteria at acquisition date and was measured as a unit of account at fair value less costs to sell,

•Fair value of the disposal group was not determined to be consistent with the transaction price due to the forced sale circumstances,

•The components of the pre-tax loss on sale in the tabular format as shown above, and

•The Company’s policy for assigning goodwill to reporting units.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 26, 2026: 10-Q filed May 7, 2026 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 4, 2026 ↗.

Recent Developments: 39 paragraphs changed; the 3 closest in words to the question are below.

Reworded

Immediately following the acquisition, 45 of the acquired Breeze stores were sold in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) Decision and Order that required the disposal of certain acquired locations for the Company to receive regulatory clearance to close the acquisition of Breeze. Breeze acquisition. The fair value of the net assets divested, including allocated goodwill, divested was $90.0 million. As a result, the Company recognized a $57.9 million pre-tax loss on sale within Other loss (income), net in the Condensed Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income for the three six months ended December March 31, 2025. 2026.

10 words cut, 11 added sec.gov
Gone

• The Loss from continuing operations in the three months ended December 31, 2025 was $32.2 million and Diluted loss per share was $0.25 primarily driven by the pre-tax loss of $57.9 million on the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) required sale of 45 acquired Breeze stores following the acquisition close.

50 words cut, 0 added sec.gov
Reworded

The decrease in cash flows from investing activities decrease of $695.4 $709.7 million was substantially driven by primarily due to $634.5 million higher net cash consideration paid for acquisitions, mainly related to the Breeze acquisition during the first quarter of fiscal 2026 resulting in $631.2 million higher cash flows used related to acquisitions, net of cash acquired, compared to the prior period. acquisition. In addition, the Company received $57.4 million lower proceeds from sale of operations during the current year compared to proceeds received from disposition activity in the prior year. Finally, higher capital expenditures of $9.8 million from increased maintenance expenditures related to the sale of 10 company stores that occurred during October 2025 and the Decision and Order from the FTC requiring Valvoline to divest 45 stores acquired in the Breeze acquisition. These declines were partially offset by an increase of $3.8 million in capital expenditures during the current year primarily driven by maintenance expenditures for store technology upgrades.

87 words cut, 41 added sec.gov

Paragraphs where only numbers, dates or period words changed are not shown. Cut words struck through, new words highlighted.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2026-04-24

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended September 30, 2024

2025-03-26 to 2025-04-21 · 2 questions · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2025-04-21
Non-GAAP measuresResults discussion (MD&A)Liquidity and cashDebt
Management's Discussion and Analysis · Use of Non-GAAP Measures, page 33
SEC asked (1)
In describing your non-GAAP measure discretionary free cash flow, you state that it is subject to certain limitations, including that it does not reflect adjustments for certain non-discretionary cash flows, such as mandatory debt repayments.
Rest of the question

Please explain how your labelling of this measure as “discretionary” is consistent with this description and provide your consideration of Question 102.07 of the Compliance & Disclosure Interpretations on Non-GAAP Financial Measures in naming this measure.

VVV answered
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has reviewed its non-GAAP measure labeled “discretionary free cash flow.” In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company will revise the title of this non-GAAP measure from “discretionary free cash flow’” to “free cash flow excluding growth capital expenditures” within its future filings and other documents furnished to the Commission in order to not imply that the measure represents the residual cash flow available for discretionary expenditures.
Rest of the answer

An example of the revised disclosure to address the foregoing, with changes marked against the filed Form 10-K, is attached hereto as Appendix I.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 9, 2025: 10-Q filed May 8, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 6, 2025 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Management's Discussion and Analysis · Use of Non-GAAP Measures, page 33
SEC asked (2)
You state that discretionary free cash flow includes maintenance capital expenditure, defined as routine uses of cash that are necessary to maintain the Company’s operations. Please further clarify how you differentiate “maintenance” and “growth” capital expenditures, providing details about the types of costs that you include in each category.
VVV answered
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment. As noted in the Staff’s comment, the Company segregates its capital expenditures into “growth” and “maintenance” based on the nature of the expenditure. The Company defines growth capital expenditures as those related to investments to expand its future business operations, including the opening or expansion of retail service center stores and service capabilities.
Rest of the answer

Maintenance capital expenditures are those which are required to support and maintain the Company’s existing business operations, including its retail service center store network, portfolio of services and support functions.

In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company will enhance its non-GAAP disclosures in future filings and other documents furnished to the Commission to provide further clarification as included herein regarding the differentiation between “growth” and “maintenance” capital expenditures. An example of the enhanced disclosure to address the foregoing, with changes marked against the filed Form 10-K, is attached hereto as Appendix II.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Apr 9, 2025: 10-Q filed May 8, 2025 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Feb 6, 2025 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2025-04-21

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended September 30, 2020

2021-02-01 to 2021-04-06 · 1 question · 1 letter from the SEC, 1 from the company
Review closed 2021-04-06
Risk factorsDerivatives and hedging
After reviewing your response to these comments, we may have additional comments. General
SEC asked
We note that the forum selection provision in your amended and restated articles of incorporation identifies Fayette County Circuit Court of the Commonwealth of Kentucky for certain actions, including any "derivative action;" provided, however, that, in the event that the Fayette County Circuit Court of the Commonwealth of Kentucky lacks subject matter jurisdiction over any such action or proceeding, the sole and
Rest of the question

exclusive forum for such action or proceeding shall be another state or federal court located within the Commonwealth of Kentucky. Please disclose whether this provision applies to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act. If so, please also state that there is uncertainty as to whether a court would enforce such provision. If the provision applies to Securities Act claims, please also state that investors cannot waive compliance with the federal securities laws and the rules and regulations thereunder. In that regard, we note that Section 22 of the Securities Act creates concurrent jurisdiction for federal and state courts over all suits brought to enforce any duty or liability created by the Securities Act or the rules and regulations thereunder, In addition, please provide corresponding risk factor disclosure regarding the impact of your exclusive forum provision on stockholders, including that they may be subject to increased costs to bring a claim and that the provision could discourage claims or limit their ability to bring a claim in a judicial forum that they find favorable. Further, if this provision does not apply to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act, please tell us how you will inform stockholders in future filings that the provision does not apply to any actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act.

VVV answered
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that the exclusive forum selection provision in Section 10.01 of the Company’s Amended and Restated Articles of Incorporation (the “Articles”) is not intended to apply to actions arising under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”) or the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”).

The Company will inform shareholders that the exclusive forum selection provision in Section 10.01 of the Articles does not apply to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act in the
Rest of the answer

Company’s future filings by updating its “Description of Securities” exhibit pursuant to Item 601(b)(4) of Regulation S-K. In addition, the Company intends to add a risk factor in its Form 10-Q for the quarter ending March 31, 2021 stating that the exclusive forum selection provision in Section 10.01 of the Articles does not apply to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act and acknowledging that a forum selection provision could increase costs to bring a claim, limit shareholders’ ability to bring a claim in a judicial forum that they find favorable or discourage claims. Further, to the extent that the Company in the future amends its Articles to include a forum selection provision applicable to actions arising under the Securities Act or Exchange Act, or any other actions arising under state law, the Company will ensure that its filings with the SEC include the appropriate disclosures and risk factors.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Mar 12, 2021: 10-Q filed Apr 29, 2021 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 4, 2020 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2021-04-06

Form 10-K

2017-05-22 to 2017-07-26 · 3 questions · 2 letters from the SEC, 2 from the company
Review closed 2017-07-26
Debt
Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income, page F-4 · Earnings per Share, page F-12
SEC asked (1)
With reference to ASC 260-10-45-10, please explain your basis for utilizing the September 30, 2016 number of shares outstanding as your weighted average common shares outstanding for all periods presented. Ensure your response explains why you did not weight the 34.5 million IPO shares for the portion of the 2016 period that they were outstanding and exclude such shares in prior fiscal periods.
Rest of the question

Please note that this comment also pertains to your earnings per share presentation in your Selected Financial Data where you indicate that per share amounts for periods prior to September 30, 2016 have been presented for comparability only. Please also address this comment as it relates to your 2017 quarterly reports.

VVV answered
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully submits that the guidance applicable to the presentation of earnings per share (“EPS”) contained in ASC 260-10-45-10 was considered relative to the requirement to

Mr. Terence O’Brien weight shares relating to the portion of time within a reporting period that common shares were outstanding.
Rest of the answer

Additionally, we considered ASC 260-10-45-7, which requires EPS to be presented for all periods for which an income statement or summary of earnings is presented, as well as ASC 260-10-55-17, which specifies that in a reorganization, EPS computations shall be based on analysis of the particular transaction.

Given the facts of our particular transaction, the lack of authoritative guidance around the calculation of EPS for entities that previously did not exist, and diversity in practice, we concluded that the shares issued to both Ashland Global and other investors in connection with the Initial Public Offering (“IPO”) of Valvoline on September 28, 2016 should be viewed together given the simultaneous capitalization of Valvoline. Prior to the initial capitalization, Valvoline was an unincorporated commercial unit of Ashland and had no separate capital structure or shares outstanding. Concurrent with the initial capitalization, Ashland contributed the historical Valvoline business (as a segment of Ashland) to Valvoline. Instead of structuring the transaction in a manner in which Ashland Global issued all of Valvoline's initial shares to itself and then resold those shares to other investors, Valvoline issued a portion of the shares to other investors and utilized the proceeds to repay debt that was issued at the direction of Ashland prior to the IPO. In lieu of Ashland Global selling its shares in the IPO for proceeds, the proceeds of the Valvoline debt were remitted to Ashland Global prior to the IPO. Given the substance of the transaction, we concluded that the best EPS presentation was to present basic and diluted EPS to retroactively reflect the entire 205 million shares issued in connection with the initial capitalization, contribution and IPO of Valvoline. We further believe such presentation provides the most meaningful information to the users of our financial statements. We respectively acknowledge alternative views may exist, but believe our unique fact pattern supports our EPS presentation.

ASC 260 does not provide authoritative guidance on calculating EPS for entities that previously did not exist, and represent a carve-out of another entity, as is the case with Valvoline. Accordingly, we have fully disclosed how EPS was calculated for all periods presented. We believe our presentation of EPS is consistent with the authoritative literature referred to previously and ensures users of the financial statements can sufficiently evaluate the operations and performance of the Company over the preand post-IPO periods on a comparative basis. In this regard, it is important to note that Valvoline had no separately identifiable pool of capital for periods prior to the IPO as it was an unincorporated commercial unit of Ashland. We believe the presentation provided meets the objective of measuring the performance of Valvoline over the reporting periods in a way that gives useful information to the users of our financial statements and provides full transparency to the method of our EPS computations.

The conclusions we have made are a result of our analysis of the facts and circumstances surrounding our particular transaction. The key elements we considered in order to reach our conclusions were as follows:

•

Prior to the creation of a holding company structure for Ashland and in contemplation of the IPO and subsequent spin-off of Valvoline (the "Reorganization"), Valvoline was an unincorporated commercial unit of Ashland, and thus, had no separate capital structure or shares outstanding. Ashland Global was the new holding company created in the Reorganization.

Prior to the completion of the Reorganization, Ashland took steps to reorganize its assets and liabilities so that the Ashland businesses and the Valvoline business were held in separate subsidiaries of Ashland.

Immediately preceding the closing of the Valvoline IPO on September 28, 2016, Ashland took steps to further reorganize its assets and liabilities so that the Ashland businesses were contributed to Ashland Global and the Valvoline business was contributed to a newly formed subsidiary, Valvoline Inc. (the "Contribution").

Ashland Global caused Valvoline to complete an IPO on September 28, 2016, during which approximately 35 million shares (approximately 17% of its common stock) were issued to public investors, and simultaneously, 170 million shares were issued to Ashland Global.

The proceeds of the IPO were used to repay indebtedness that was issued by Valvoline at the direction of Ashland prior to the IPO. In lieu of Ashland Global selling its shares in the IPO for proceeds, the proceeds of this indebtedness were transferred to Ashland Global prior to the IPO.

We considered whether a weighted average number of shares outstanding would be appropriate for computing EPS, with the issuance of shares to new investors in connection with the IPO treated prospectively from the issuance date. Based on the facts and circumstances, we concluded that treating the entire transaction as a reorganization and recapitalization was the most meaningful presentation. The entire Valvoline capital structure was created at the time of the IPO and the proceeds of the IPO were used to repay indebtedness issued by Valvoline prior to the IPO at the direction of Ashland Global. Economically, this had the same effect as if Ashland Global had caused Valvoline to issue 205 million shares to Ashland Global that were in turn sold to the investor group. Because the Reorganization, Contribution and IPO all took place simultaneously and in contemplation of each other, we believe the structure of the transaction is similar to a reorganization and exchange of equity interests akin to a change in the form of legal ownership to a new structure. Such transactions are the equivalent of a stock split, which requires retrospective treatment for EPS purposes. In this regard, the number of shares issued by Valvoline simply reflects a re-characterization of the capital account previously held by Ashland. For this reason, the total outstanding shares of 205 million was retrospectively applied to all periods presented within the financial statements included in Valvoline’s Annual Report. Subsequent to the Reorganization, Contribution and IPO, the Valvoline equity structure has not changed through March 31, 2017.

Disclosures have been made in the Company's Annual Report as well as in the fiscal 2017 Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q regarding the retrospective presentation of the financial statements related to the reorganization of entities under common Ashland Global control and the assumptions and methodology have been consistently applied since the completion of our pro forma financial statements in our Registration Statement on Form S-1. The calculations of EPS for each respective period presented have also been disclosed in separate footnotes which detail the number of shares used to compute EPS in each reporting period. We will continue to include such disclosures in future filings. We will also enhance our disclosures in our future periodic reports to clarify our approach and rationale for the outstanding shares utilized in presenting EPS in the pre-IPO periods.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 7, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Apr 28, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Consolidated Statements of Stockholders Equity, page F-6
SEC asked (2)
In light of the restructuring steps and Separation activities, including your September 28, 2016 IPO and with reference to the applicable authoritative literature, please explain why there is a $(1,039) million balance in your Parent Company Investment account as of September 30, 2016. Please also address this comment as it relates to your 2017 quarterly reports.
VVV answered
The Valvoline IPO was the initial phase in a broader plan to separate Ashland into two independent, publicly traded companies. The second and final phase included the distribution of 170 million shares of Valvoline common stock held by Ashland Global to Ashland Global's shareholders through a pro rata dividend that took place in May 2017 ("Final Distribution").
Rest of the answer

The $(1,039) million balance in our Parent Company Investment account represented Ashland Global's cumulative net investment in Valvoline at September 30, 2016 and at each respective balance sheet date thereafter in our fiscal 2017 quarterly reports. Subsequent to the IPO and prior to the Final Distribution, Valvoline remained a controlled and consolidated subsidiary of Ashland Global based on Ashland's 83% ownership of Valvoline. In reaching our presentation conclusion relative to the Parent Company Investment account, we considered section 7410 of the Division of Corporation Finance's Financial Reporting Manual ("FRM"), which states, "registrants that are components of larger entities should consider SAB Topic 1B when preparing financial statements. Also, retained earnings should not be separately reported by a non-corporate entity. The residual interest should be presented as a single component, such as parent's equity in division."

We considered whether the Parent Company Investment account should be reclassified into additional paid-in capital at the time of contribution of the Valvoline business and related issuance of common shares; however, absent specific accounting literature with regard to the required timing when such reclassification should occur, we considered it to be most appropriate to follow FRM 7410 and continue to present the Parent Company Investment account relative to Ashland Global's net investment until Final Distribution. We believe this presentation accurately reflected Ashland Global's continued controlling interest and provided users of our financial statements with incremental information relative to the amount of equity attributable to Ashland Global and the amount attributable to other investors during the period which Ashland Global remained our controlling shareholder. As Final Distribution occurred on May 12, 2017 and each share of Ashland Global common stock received 2.745338 shares of Valvoline common stock, a reclassification between the Parent Company Investment account and additional paid-in capital will be presented in our Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ending June 30, 2017.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jun 7, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Apr 28, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Note 2- Significant Accounting Policies, page F-8 · Earnings per Share, page F-12
SEC asked
We note the following regarding your response to prior comment 1 from our letter dated May 22, 2017:  ASC 260-10-55-17 indicates that in a reorganization, EPS computations shall be based on an analysis of the particular transaction and the provisions of the Subtopic. The referenced Subtopic provides guidance on the restatement of EPS data for certain transactions, including stock splits.
Rest of the question

In this regard, we note your belief that the transactions are the equivalent of a stock split. However, based on the definition of a stock split, as set forth in ASC 505-20-20, it does not appear appropriate to view the 34.5 million shares issued in your IPO as a stock split given they were issued for consideration; and  We note your belief that creating the entire Valvoline capital structure at the time of the IPO and using the proceeds to repay indebtedness issued by Valvoline prior to the IPO at the direction of Ashland Global is economically the same as if Ashland Global had caused Valvoline to issue 205 million shares to Ashland Global that were in turn sold to the investor group. However, we note that as a result of their transactions, Valvoline issued third-party debt and incurred interest expense. Based on the above, it appears that the 34.5 million shares issued in your IPO should be accounted for in accordance with ASC 260-10-45-10 and weighted for the portion of the period that they were outstanding. Please advise.

VVV answered
Mr. Terence O’Brien

We note your belief that creating the entire Valvoline capital structure at the time of the IPO and using the proceeds to repay indebtedness issued by Valvoline prior to the IPO at the direction of Ashland Global is economically the same as if Ashland Global had caused Valvoline to issue 205 million shares to Ashland Global that were in turn sold to the investor group.
Rest of the answer

However, we note that as a result of their transactions, Valvoline issued third-party debt and incurred interest expense.

Based on the above, it appears that the 34.5 million shares issued in your IPO should be accounted for in accordance with ASC 260-10-45-10 and weighted for the portion of the period that they were outstanding. Please advise.

In connection with the Company’s written communications and discussions with the Staff, the Company described that its position with respect to the inclusion of the 34.5 million shares issued in the IPO was based on the substance and unique facts and circumstances of its transactions and a desire to provide users of the Company’s financial statements with the most meaningful and relevant information. The Company, however, understands and respects the Staff’s view that U.S. GAAP requires that the 170 million shares issued to Ashland as owner upon formation of the Valvoline legal entity should be used as the denominator in computing earnings per share (“EPS”) for the Valvoline carve-out business for all periods presented prior to the date of the IPO (September 28, 2016) and that the issuance of 34.5 million shares to new investors in connection with the IPO should be treated prospectively from the issuance date.

In considering the above, Valvoline has concluded that its presentation of EPS in its reported financial statements for periods prior to the IPO was incorrect. Management has evaluated that error within the context of SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99, Materiality (“SAB 99”) and ASC 250, Accounting Changes and Error Corrections. Management has assessed, using both quantitative and qualitative factors, the impact of the error on the previously reported financial statements. Based on the analysis below, management has concluded that the error to the number of weighted average common shares outstanding and resulting impact on EPS would not be material to the consolidated financial statements taken as a whole for the years ended September 30, 2016, 2015 and 2014 and for the interim periods within the years ended September 30, 2016 and 2015. Outlined below is a summary of this materiality analysis that has been prepared by management.

Materiality Analysis

Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99

The SEC’s Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99, Materiality (“SAB 99”) states that a matter is material if there is a “substantial likelihood that a reasonable person would consider it important” in making an investment decision. In addition, SAB 99 also states that “quantifying, in percentage terms, the magnitude of a misstatement is only the beginning of an analysis of materiality” and that the factual context in which the user of financial statements would view the financial statement item must also be evaluated. There are situations in which a quantitatively large error could be considered immaterial upon consideration of qualitative factors and the total mix of information available to investors and there may also be situations where a quantitatively small error could be considered material. Both the Staff and Financial Accounting Standards Board, in their guidance and pronouncements, have consistently emphasized the need for the consideration of qualitative factors in an assessment of materiality. 1

In a situation where errors are quantitatively significant, the determination of materiality must consider both quantitative and qualitative factors as well as the total mix of information from the perspective of a reasonable investor in possession of all available information. The standard in such a situation is the fundamental materiality test set forth by the U.S. Supreme Court of whether there is “a substantial likelihood that the … fact would have been viewed by the reasonable investor as having significantly altered the ‘total mix’ of information available” in addition to consideration of the qualitative factors set forth in SAB 99 and other Staff guidance.2

The following analysis considers both quantitative and qualitative factors in assessing materiality of the error in the calculation of EPS on Valvoline’s consolidated financial statements necessary in connection with using the alternative methodology.

Quantitative Assessment

Our quantitative review considered the impact of the error in calculating basic and diluted earnings per share and the weighted shares outstanding for the relevant periods, which is shown in the following tables:

Year Ended September 30,

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

Net income - as reported

$273

$196

$173

$246

$114

Shares outstanding - as previously reported

204.5

Shares outstanding - as revised

170.3

170.0

Earnings Per Share

Basic and Diluted - as previously reported

$1.33

$0.96

$0.84

$1.20

$0.55

Basic and Diluted - as revised

$1.60

$1.15

$1.02

$1.45

$0.67

% Change

20.3%

19.8%

21.4%

20.8%

21.8%

1 See SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 99 Topic 1-M, Materiality; SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin No. 98 Topic 1-N, Considering the Effects of Prior Year Misstatements when Quantifying Misstatements in Current Year Financial Statements; ASC 250, Accounting Changes and Error Corrections; Financial Accounting Standards Board, Concepts Statement No. 2, Qualitative Characteristics of Accounting Information; Todd E. Hardiman, Associate Chief Accountant, Division of Corporation Finance, SEC, Speech by SEC Staff: Remarks Before the 2006 AICPA National Conference and Current SEC and PCAOB Developments, December 12, 2006; Todd E. Hardiman, Associate Chief Accountant, Division of Corporation Finance, SEC, Speech by SEC Staff: Remarks before the 2007 AICPA National Conference and Current SEC and PCAOB Developments, December 11, 2007; Mark Mahar, Associate Chief Accountant, Office of the Chief Accountant, SEC, Speech by SEC Staff: Remarks Before the 2008 AICPA National Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments, December 8, 2008; Final Report of the Advisory Committee on Improvements to Financial Reporting (the “Final Report”) to the SEC, issued August 1, 2008.

2 TSC Industries v. Northway, Inc., 426 U.S. 438, 449 (1976)

Three Months Ended December 31,

$72

$65

$0.35

$0.32

$0.38

—

18.8%

Six Months Ended

March 31,

Three Months Ended March 31,

2017

$143

$133

$71

$68

$0.70

$0.65

$0.33

$0.78

$0.40

20.0%

21.2%

While we recognize that the differences in the corrected shares outstanding and the EPS amounts appear, on their face, to be quantitatively significant relative to the reported shares outstanding and EPS amounts, we do not believe that these differences would be considered material to our shareholders and research analysts. Further, we do not believe our lenders and bondholders rely on our EPS amounts. As noted above, reported net income was not impacted by the error. In addition, no other measure reported on the face of the financial statements was impacted by the error.

Qualitative Analysis

Valvoline also analyzed the impact of the error from a qualitative perspective. In doing so Valvoline considered both the overall qualitative criteria listed in SAB 99 and additional specific qualitative factors directly applicable to the impact of this error on its users of its financial statements.

With respect to the overall qualitative criteria listed in SAB 99, we concluded the following:

the error had no impact on earnings per share computations in future periods or future filings;

although the error related to an item capable of precise measurement, it was the result of a good faith difference in interpretation in an area that lacks authoritative guidance, after thoughtful consideration of available guidance by Valvoline and consultation with experts;

the error did not change a loss to income or vice versa for any consolidated or segment results;

the error did not have any impact on, nor mask a change in, our earnings trends in any historical period impacted and did not impact trends in EPS in any pre-IPO historical period;

the error did not have any impact on compliance with any regulatory requirements;

the error did not affect compliance with debt covenants or any other contractual requirements; and the error did not have the effect of increasing management’s compensation by satisfying any requirements for the award of any form of base or incentive compensation; the error did not involve the concealment of an unlawful transaction.

In addition, Valvoline considered the following specific qualitative factors:

Valvoline disclosed its EPS calculation methodology and number of shares used to compute EPS for each period presented in the notes to its consolidated financial statements, including the footnotes to the Selected Financial Data provided in Item 6 of the Form 10-K.3 Moreover, the information related to the number of shares issued to Ashland and in the IPO was readily available in Valvoline’s financial statements and elsewhere in its periodic reports. This information was also widely available outside of Valvoline’s SEC filings. Users of Valvoline’s financial statements had sufficient access to all the relevant information necessary to both identify the differences in the EPS calculation methodology that Valvoline used and to recast the reported shares outstanding and EPS based on the correct methodology if they considered it important for their analysis.

The error had no impact on Valvoline’s consolidated balance sheets at September 30, 2016 and 2015. Other than with respect to shares outstanding and EPS, the error had no impact on Valvoline’s consolidated statements of comprehensive income, stockholders’ equity or cash flows for each of the three years in the period ended September 30, 2016 and for any interim period.

Although Valvoline’s historical presentation of EPS was erroneous, it did allow investors to easily compare EPS for preand post-IPO periods, which we believe is meaningful to the users of the Valvoline’s financial statements. EPS based on the actual shares outstanding in the pre-IPO period is not a relevant comparable measure of Valvoline’s pre-IPO performance as ownership during these historical periods was held exclusively by Ashland. In discussions with investors in connection with the IPO, Valvoline’s leadership learned that investors did not view EPS for pre-IPO periods as a meaningful measure; rather, IPO investors were more focused on understanding EPS on a normalized basis going forward and, more generally, their ability to compare Valvoline’s financial results, performance and trends between pre-IPO and post IPO periods. Moreover, similar to Valvoline’s annual and quarterly reports post-IPO, the Registration Statement on Form S-1 filed in connection with the IPO included the description of the methodology, assumptions and number of shares used to compute EPS for each period presented. The number of shares used to calculate the pro forma earnings per share for each period presented in the Form S-1 was based on the number of shares Valvoline expected to be outstanding after giving effect to the IPO, and not only the 170 million shares issued to Ashland. Following the IPO, Valvoline believes that, based on conversations with its investors and research analysts, users of its financial statements find EPS calculated on a comparable basis for all relevant periods to be a useful measure of Valvoline’s financial performance and trends across the pre-IPO and post-IPO periods.

The meaningful financial measures to the users of Valvoline’s financial statements for the periods prior and subsequent to the IPO transaction include revenue, same store sales growth, operating income, EBITDA, cash flows from operating activities and free cash flows, which were not impacted by the error. When comparing pre-IPO to current period performance, these measures were the ones highlighted by Valvoline’s management in its earnings releases and were the focus of the discussion on its earnings calls. Although EPS is discussed in the context of our

3 Disclosures may be found in Note 2 to the consolidated financial statements included in Valvoline’s Annual Report; note 8 to the condensed consolidated financial statements included in Valvoline’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended December 31, 2016; and Note 10 to the condensed consolidated financial statements included in Valvoline’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended March 31, 2017.

communications with the users of the financial statements, we believe that the corrected presentation of EPS, will not be particularly meaningful to the users as previously discussed. Further, this error would have no effect on the EPS reported by the Company in the periods subsequent to September 30, 2016.

The error did not mask an EPS trend in the pre-IPO periods. Although EPS will decline when calculated using the as revised presentation from 2016 to 2017, due to the 34.5 million shares issued in the IPO being fully included in the EPS calculation for all periods during 2017, Valvoline does not believe this change will be concerning to shareholders and other users of its financial statements as they would generally consider EPS on the basis consistent with our historical presentation when evaluating the Company’s trends in performance. In that regard, the only factor contributing to dilution of EPS under the corrected calculation is the addition of the new investors themselves to Valvoline’s capital structure. Additionally, there was no impact to net income and therefore no change in the trend of underlying earnings between the pre and post IPO period.

The error would not hide a failure to meet analysts’ consensus expectations. For 2016 and all prior periods, there were no EPS estimates. In addition, the reported EPS in pre-IPO periods resulted in a lower EPS than would the corrected EPS.

Conclusion

When viewed in the context of all of the relevant quantitative and qualitative factors, we have determined the impact of this error to our consolidated financial statements for the years ended September 30, 2016, 2015 and 2014, as well as the interim periods within the years ended September 30, 2016 and 2015, is not material and that users are able to continue to rely on Valvoline’s financial statements. The judgment of a reasonable investor relying upon Valvoline’s consolidated financial statements would not be changed or influenced by correcting the reporting of the number of shares outstanding and EPS for the relevant periods.

Notwithstanding our conclusion that the error is immaterial, we will correct the presentation of EPS in each of our future filings beginning with our Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2017 with disclosure explaining the change.

Read in the reply
In its next report

First report after the company's reply of Jul 25, 2017: 10-Q filed Aug 8, 2017 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Apr 28, 2017 ↗.

Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.

Also in this review: closing letter, 2017-07-26

Form S-1

2016-06-27 to 2016-09-20 · 25 questions · 4 letters from the SEC, 3 from the company
No closing letter
PensionsResults discussion (MD&A)SegmentsExecutive payDebtNon-GAAP measuresRisk factorsLiquidity and cash
SEC letter of Jun 27, 2016 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
General
SEC asked (1)
We note that you intend to provide significant additional information in an amendment to your registration statement, including information regarding management, directors, material indebtedness, and key terms of the various agreements you will enter into with Ashland in connection with the separation.
Rest of the question

To the extent practicable, please include this information and file your agreements with Ashland in your next amendment.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Prospectus Summary, page 1
SEC asked (2)
Please identify those aspects of the offering and your company that are most significant, and highlight these points in plain, clear language. The summary should not, and is not required to repeat the detailed information in the prospectus. The detailed description of your business, competitive strengths, and strategy is unnecessary since you repeat them verbatim in the business section of the prospectus.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Risk Factors, page 19 · Because of the concentration of our sales to a small number of retailers…, page 21
SEC asked (3)
Please identify the customer described as “another large national retailer” in your next amendment. Additionally, please disclose which retailers listed here accounted for more than 10% of Core North America segment’s sales in 2015.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

The competitive nature of our markets may delay…, page 23
SEC asked (4)
We note that you source lubricant additives from a limited number of suppliers. Please disclose the name of these suppliers in your next amendment. Additionally, to the extent any of these supply contracts represents a material contract pursuant to Item 601(b)(10) of Regulation S-K, please file such contract as an exhibit to your registration statement.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Use of Proceeds, page 41
SEC asked (5)
Please tell us whether affiliates of your underwriters are lenders and/or agents of Ashland debt that will be paid with proceeds of the offering. If these relationships exist, please disclose this here or provide a cross reference to this disclosure in the underwriting section.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Use of Proceeds, page 41
SEC asked (6)
Please identify the indebtedness you intend to repay with the proceeds from the offering, explain whether this indebtedness is currently reported on the balance sheet of Valvoline and Ashland, and explain the accounting for the repayment.
Rest of the question

You state, “any remaining proceeds will be used for general corporate purposes.” Please clarify whether remaining proceeds will remain with Valvoline or whether there could be any additional dividends, transfers or other payments to Ashland. Reflect these potential transactions in the pro forma financial statements and accompanying notes as appropriate, as well as in the discussion of capitalization on page 43 and discussion of proceeds on page 14 and elsewhere.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Note B – Pension and other postretirement plans transferred to Valvoline, page 54
SEC asked (7)
Please explain how you will calculate the amounts in pro forma adjustment B and their factual basis. Also, please explain the reasons for any significant variances between the calculated amounts and amounts presented in the carve out historical financial statements
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Note B – Pension and other postretirement plans transferred to Valvoline, page 54
SEC asked (8)
Please clarify whether you are including a material curtailment gain in pro forma adjustment B to the income statement for the year ended September 30, 2015. If so, please explain the basis for including a pro forma adjustment for a curtailment gain arising from the freezing and elimination of certain benefits announced in March 2016.
Rest of the question

Please clarify if the curtailment gain is a nonrecurring credit recognized after September 30, 2015. Refer to Rule 11-01(b), paragraphs (5) and (6).

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Note B – Pension and other postretirement plans transferred to Valvoline, page 54
SEC asked (9)
Please explain specifically how the freezing or elimination of certain benefits supports the reclassification of costs associated with pension and other postretirement plans from cost of sales solely into selling, general and administrative expenses.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Note I – Legacy assets and liabilities, page 56
SEC asked (10)
Please tell us the nature of any significant legacy assets and liabilities that are expected to be transferred from Ashland as a result of the separation. Also, please explain why such assets and liabilities were not included in the historical financial statements of Valvoline.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 57 · Public Company Expenses, page 62
SEC asked (11)
Please disclose an estimate of the additional costs you expect to incur as a result of being a standalone company.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Results of Operations- Combined Review, page 62 · Non-GAAP Performance Metrics, page 62
SEC asked (12)
We note your disclosure of “Losses (gains) on pension and other postretirement plans remeasurement” which are excluded in your reconciliation of net income to Adjusted EBITDA. Please expand your disclosure to quantify the amounts of actual and expected asset returns and the amount of net periodic pension cost that is included in the non- GAAP measure.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Business, page 89 · Intellectual Property, page 106
SEC asked (13)
Please discuss the importance and duration of your patents.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Executive Compensation, page 112
SEC asked (14)
We note you have provided executive compensation for fiscal year 2015. Please note that you are also required to provide executive compensation for fiscal years 2013 and 2014. For further guidance, please see Regulation S-K C&DIs 217.01 and 217.03.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Long-Term Incentive Equity Compensation, page 121 · 2015-2017 LTIP Performance Units, page 122
SEC asked (15)
Please specify how the “Performance Peer Group” is weighted between the S&P MidCap 400 and S&P 500 Materials Group.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Compensation Program of Valvoline Following the Spin-off, page 130
SEC asked (16)
Please discuss whether all stock appreciation rights, performance share awards, restricted share awards, restricted stock units, common stock units and deferred stock units and other incentive awards and deferrals covering shares of Ashland or Ashland Global common stock, whether vested or not vested will remain valid and in full effect for Valvoline officers and employees following the spin-off.
Rest of the question

Describe any terms and conditions of such agreements that would be relevant to the spin-off and resulting change in legal employer of Valvoline officers and employees and the expected resulting impact.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control for Fiscal 2015, page 141
SEC asked (17)
Please tell us whether the reorganization of Ashland, separation of Valvoline, or initial public offering of Valvoline, Inc., or any of the related transactions or other currently anticipated events are expected to result in payments under the change in control agreements or other agreements.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Combined Statements of Operations and Comprehensive Income, page F -7
SEC asked (18)
Please tell us how you consider ASC 360-10-45-5 in excluding the loss on the sale of car care product assets of $26.3 million from operating income.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Note K – Employee Benefit Plans, page F-27
SEC asked (19)
Please tell us where the $46 million loss on the remeasurement of pension and other retirement plans is reflected on the income statement for 2015. If applicable, please reconcile to the actuarial loss for 2015 of $2 million.
Rest of the question

Notwithstanding our comments, in the event you request acceleration of the effective date of the pending registration statement please provide a written statement from the company acknowledging that:  should the Commission or the staff, acting pursuant to delegated authority, declare the filing effective, it does not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing;  the action of the Commission or the staff, acting pursuant to delegated authority, in declaring the filing effective, does not relieve the company from its full responsibility for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing; and  the company may not assert staff comments and the declaration of effectiveness as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States. Please refer to Rules 460 and 461 regarding requests for acceleration. We will consider a written request for acceleration of the effective date of the registration statement as confirmation of the fact that those requesting acceleration are aware of their respective responsibilities under the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 as they relate to the proposed public offering of the securities specified in the above registration statement. Please allow adequate time for us to review any amendment prior to the requested effective date of the registration statement.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Jul 20, 2016 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
Use of Proceeds, page 35
SEC asked (1)
Please note that once you have included completed pro forma information and related disclosures we will need sufficient time to review such information and may have additional comments based on your compliance with Article 11 of Regulation S -X, as well as the transparency of disclosure relating to your use of proceeds and pro forma capitalization.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Results of Operations- Combined Review, page 57 · Non-GAAP Performance Metrics, page 57
SEC asked (2)
We have read your response to comment 12 in our letter dated June 27, 2016. Please expand your disclosure to quantify the actual and expected returns on pension plan assets you discuss on page 58 or to include a cross-reference to the page(s) where the information can be located.
VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Executive Compensation, page 107 · Summary Compensation Table, page 132
SEC asked (3)
We note your supplemental response to comment 14 of our letter dated June 27, 2016. Given that Ashland is spinning off its Valvoline segment, and that your named executive officers each providing services to Valvoline prior to the spin-off and will continue to provide similar services after the spin-off, we continue to believe that you should provide historical compensation disclosure for your named executive
Rest of the question

officers. Please revise your disclosure accordingly.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

SEC letter of Aug 11, 2016 ↗ no reply letter on EDGAR (the company may have answered in an amended filing)
Management’s Discussion and Analysis, page 52 · Financial Position, Liquidity, and Capital Resources, page 74
SEC asked (1)
We note you entered into a senior secured term loan facility providing you up to $875.0 million of borrowings and a senior secured revolving credit facility providing you up to $450.0 million of borrowing capacity. Further, we note you issued senior unsecured notes in an aggregate principal amount of $375.0 million.
Rest of the question

Please expand your disclosure to include the terms, covenants, and other significant provisions of these debt facilities.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Executive Compensation, page 107 · Summary Compensation Table, page 132
SEC asked (2)
We note your supplemental response to comment 3 in our letter dated July 20, 2016, but remain unpersuaded that Valvoline does not need to provide executive compensation for fiscal years 2013 and 2014. Regulation S-K C&DI 217.03 does not appear to apply here because it is for the specific situation where “officers of the subsidiary previously were officers of the parent” and Mr.
Rest of the question

Mitchell is the only Valvoline officer that was previously an officer of Ashland. Further, Regulation S-K C&DI 217.01 provides clarification of the scope of Instruction 1 to Item 402(c) of Regulation S-K and applies here because even though the assets Valvoline holds post-separation will not be identical to the ones held pre-separation, Valvoline will not be a new company consisting of several different operating segments of Ashland, nor will it have new management. Please revise accordingly.

VVV answered

No reply letter found.

Share Eligible for Future Sale, page 173 · Directed Share Program, page 173
SEC asked
We note your disclosure that shares under the directed share program will be offered to “certain of our employees and certain other persons.” Please revise your disclosure to identify with more specificity the category of persons eligible to participate in the program. Additionally, please disclose whether these shares will be subject to the lockup period.
VVV answered
This letter relates to the Registration Statement on Form S-1 (File No. 333-211720) (the “Registration Statement”) of

Valvoline Inc. (the “Company”). The Company hereby supplementally provides the following transaction size and price range information expected to be included in the Company’s preliminary prospectus (the “Preliminary

Prospectus”) forming part of the Registration Statement which relates to the Company’s proposed initial public offering (the “Offering”) for review by the staff of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the

“Staff”).
Rest of the answer

The Company expects that the Preliminary Prospectus will include the following information:

• an initial public offering price per share of the Company’s common stock (the “Shares”) of between $20.00 and $23.00 per Share, an offering of 30,000,000 Shares (or 34,500,000 Shares if the underwriters’ option to purchase additional shares is exercised in full),

200,000,000 Shares to be outstanding following the Offering (or 204,500,000 Shares if the underwriters’ option to purchase additional shares is exercised in full) and anticipated gross proceeds of $645,000,000 (net proceeds of $605,000,000), such proceeds to be used to repay indebtedness incurred in connection with the separation transactions described in the Preliminary Prospectus.

To assist the Staff in its review, the Company is supplementally providing the Staff with Exhibit A to this letter containing certain pages of the Registration Statement, revised to give effect to the information listed above. In response to the Staff’s comment contained in your letter dated September 2, 2016, relating to the Registration Statement, the Company is also including representative revised disclosure regarding the shares that will be offered under the directed share program.

The Company also expects to include information regarding new directors, corporate governance policy and the registration rights agreement in the Preliminary Prospectus, and is supplementally providing the Staff with Exhibit B to this letter containing certain pages of the Registration Statement revised to provide such updated disclosure.

Finally, the Company intends to include certain artwork on the inside front and inside rear cover pages to the Preliminary Prospectus, and the Company is supplementally providing the Staff with Exhibit C to this letter containing a copy of the proposed artwork.

The Company greatly appreciates the Staff’s willingness to accommodate the Company and respectfully requests that the Staff review

Exhibit A, Exhibit B and Exhibit C in advance of the filing of Amendment No. 4 to the Registration Statement (including the Preliminary Prospectus) and the commencement of the Company’s IPO marketing “road show”, which is expected to occur on Monday, September 12, 2016.

Read in the reply

Also in this review: company letter, Sep 20, 2016, company letter, Sep 20, 2016

Letters without questions

Other letters

UPLOAD and CORRESP
5 other letters: notices that a filing will not be reviewed, requests to declare a registration effective, and the like
  • Jul 13, 2020 · VVV: letter to the SEC · Valvoline Inc. · Registration Statement on Form S-4 (File No. 333-238971)
  • Jun 11, 2020 · SEC: will not review the filing · Valvoline, Inc. · Registration Statement on Form S-4 · Filed June 5, 2020 · File No. 333-238971
  • Jun 5, 2020 · VVV: letter to the SEC · Valvoline Inc. · Registration Statement on Form S-4 · Filed with the Securities and...
  • Nov 21, 2017 · SEC: will not review the filing · Valvoline Inc. · Registration Statement on Form S-4 · Filed November 17, 2017 · File...
  • Nov 21, 2017 · VVV: letter to the SEC · Valvoline Inc. · Registration Statement on Form S-4 · (File No. 333-221652)

From the SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), 26 letters filed since 2016-06-27. Questions and answers are matched by their numbers; topics come from words in each question. The reports are compared word for word (same form, before the first SEC letter against the first report after the company's reply). No AI.

Sources

The SEC's correspondence on EDGAR: staff letters (form UPLOAD) and company letters (form CORRESP), matched question by question. No AI.

Also

Filings: the letters in the filing list.

Work with it

Excel workbook · CSV. Google Sheet that stays up to date: paste =IMPORTDATA("https://tickdelta.com/company/VVV/export.csv") into a cell.

Next in Owners and insiders:Insider trades
Esc

Type a ticker such as AAPL, a name, an investor such as Buffett, or a topic such as tariffs. ↑ ↓ to move, Enter to open.