Form S-1
Please provide us with a reconciliation of the pro forma net tangible book value and adjusted pro forma net tangible book value amounts shown in this section to your pro forma financial statements. In your response, clarify which pro forma adjustments related to the corporate reorganization, but not directly related to the offering proceeds are excluded from these amounts. Refer to Item 506 of Regulation S-K.
The Company notes that it erroneously accounted for the $7.8 million in goodwill in the net tangible book value calculation by subtracting it from Members’ (Deficit), which had the effect of decreasing the deficit instead of increasing the deficit. This caused the net tangible book value to be higher than it should be.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company has corrected the error in calculation and made the following revisions to the Dilution section on page 49 of the Registration Statement: (i) net tangible book value, after giving pro forma effect to the corporate reorganization transactions, other than the issuance of the shares of Class A common stock, was reduced by $15.7 million from $(51.3) million (or $(0.96) per share of Class A common stock) to $(67.0) million (or $(1.25) per share of Class A common stock) and (ii) adjusted pro forma net tangible book value after giving effect to the sale of the shares in the offering and the receipt of the assumed net proceeds was reduced by $8.7 million (or $0.21 per share of Class A common stock) from $291.1 million (or $3.98 per share) to $282.4 million (or $3.77 per share of Class A common stock). The immediate increase in net tangible book value was increased by $0.08 per share of Class A common stock from $4.94 to $5.02 per share of Class A common stock. The immediate dilution to new investors in the offering was increased by $0.21 per share of Class A common stock from $13.52 to $13.73 per share of Class A common stock. Footnote (1) to the dilution table on page 49 of Exhibit A hereto was also revised accordingly. In addition, page 37 of Exhibit A hereto was revised to reflect immediate and substantial dilution of $13.73 per share.
The Company notes that there are no pro forma adjustments related to the corporate reorganization that are excluded from these corrected amounts, presented in page 49 of Exhibit A hereto.
The requested reconciliation is set forth in the table on Annex 1 hereto.
Expand your disclosure to clarify the basis for the income tax expense adjustment (j), and provide us with the calculation supporting the adjustment. Additionally, provide us with further detail to support the allocation of net income (loss) attributable to Cactus, Inc. and the non-controlling interests.
We have revised the Registration Statement as requested. Please see page F-10 of Exhibit A hereto. The revised disclosure clarifies the basis for income tax expense adjustment (j) to the pro forma financial statements. As revised, income tax expense adjustment (j) will clarify that the pro forma adjustment for income tax expense for the nine months ended September 30, 2017 of $5.9 million represents tax expense on income that will be taxable in jurisdictions after the corporate reorganization that previously has not been taxable.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The adjustment is calculated as pro forma income before income taxes of $55.6 million multiplied by the ownership percentage of the controlling interest of 28.6% and multiplied by the blended statutory rate of 37%. This result is added to the historical income tax expense of $0.9 million which would still be incurred after our corporate reorganization to derive pro forma income tax expense. The pro forma adjustment for income tax expense for the year ended December 31, 2016 of $1.3 million represents tax expense on income that will be taxable in jurisdictions after our corporate reorganization that previously has not been taxable. The adjustment is calculated as pro forma income before income taxes of $4.6 million multiplied by the ownership percentage of the controlling interest of 28.6% and multiplied by the blended statutory rate of 37%. This result is added to the historical income tax expense of $0.8 million which would still be incurred after our reorganization to derive pro forma income tax expense.
The table below sets forth further detail to support the allocation of pro forma net income (loss) attributable to Cactus, Inc. and the noncontrolling interest for the nine months ended September 30, 2017 and the year ended December 31, 2016 (in thousands).
Nine Months Ended September 30, 2017:
Shares Purchased
Net Income (Loss)
Number
Percent
Amount
Existing Shareholders (Noncontrolling Interest)
53,461
71.4
%
$
34,841
New Investors (Cactus, Inc.)
21,429
28.6
13,965
74,890
100.0
48,806
100
Year Ended December 31, 2016: