3. We note your inclusion of a pro forma adjustment to eliminate of Merger and acquisition expenses. Please tell us how such expenses have a continuing impact in accordance with Rule 11-02(b) of Regulation S-X. Alternatively, you may eliminate this pro forma adjustment from your unaudited pro forma consolidated financial information, though you may continue to disclose but not adjust for merger and acquisition expenses.
We made pro forma adjustments to remove merger and acquisition transaction costs included in
Rest of the answer
the historical results of W. P. Carey and CPA®: 16 — Global from the unaudited pro forma consolidated statements of income as those non-recurring transaction costs were directly related to the two transactions included in the pro forma financial statements, the Merger and the CPA®:15 Merger, based on our understanding of Rule 11-02(b).
Specifically, Rule 11-02(b)(5) states: “Material nonrecurring charges or credits and related tax effects which result directly from the transaction and which will be included in the income of the registrant within the 12 months succeeding the transaction shall be disclosed separately. It should be clearly indicated that such charges or credits were not considered in the pro forma condensed income statement.”[emphasis added]
Further, we relied upon the Financial Reporting Manual Section 3250 “In Business Combinations,” Topic 3250.1(c) “Purchase Accounting,” which indicates the following:
“Transaction costs should be recognized in the pro forma statements as follows:
i. Direct, incremental costs of the specific acquisition which are not yet reflected in the historical financial statements of either the target or acquirer—No adjustment should be reflected in the pro forma income statement, but the pro forma balance sheet should reflect an adjustment (as the costs are non-recurring and directly related to the transaction) ii. Direct, incremental costs of the specific acquisition which are reflected in the historical financial statements of either the target or acquirer— An adjustment should remove those costs from the pro forma income statement (as a non-recurring charge directly related to the transaction) iii. Direct, incremental costs related to one or more other acquisitions that are reflected in the historical financial statements of either the target or acquirer— An adjustment should remove those costs from the pro forma income statement only if pro forma effect is given to the other acquisition as well (Last updated: 3/31/2010)” [emphasis added]
Based on this guidance, we only separately disclosed the projected non-recurring total cost of $43.2 million directly related to the Merger expected to be included in the income statement within the next 12 months on page F-11 footnote D, but did not make a pro forma adjustment to the pro forma consolidated income statement for this amount. We note that we only included a pro forma adjustment to the balance sheet for this amount based on the guidance in Topic 3250.1(c)(i) noted above.
Based on the guidance in Topic 3250.1(c)(ii) noted above, we made pro forma adjustments to the unaudited pro forma consolidated statements of income to remove acquisition expenses directly related to the Merger that were included in the historical statements of income of W. P. Carey and CPA®:16 — Global of $5.2 million and $1.1 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2013 and the year ended December 31, 2012, respectively, as described on page F-13 footnote L.
Additionally, based on the guidance in Topic 3250.1(c)(iii) noted above, we made a pro forma adjustment to the unaudited pro forma consolidated statement of income remove $33.4 million of Merger and acquisition expenses directly related to the CPA®:15 Merger from the historical statements of income of W. P. Carey for the year ended December 31, 2012 as described on page F-11 footnote F.
Based on the staff’s comment, we note that we did not, however, clarify that these expenses were non-recurring in nature. Based on the Staff’s comment, we will revise our disclosures in Notes D, F and L accordingly.
Additional Information
In our call with Mark Rakip of the SEC on November 21, 2013, Mr. Rakip requested details of the Merger and acquisition costs and a statement of why management believed that they were non-recurring in nature.
The Merger and acquisition costs included in the historical financial statements of W. P. Carey and CPA®:16 — Global include the following: accounting and other professional fees, legal fees, appraisal services, transfer taxes and other merger expenses as well as other acquisition costs. Management believes that all these Merger and acquisition costs are non-recurring in nature, based on the guidance in 3250.1(c) noted above. “Other acquisition costs” represent costs associated with property acquisitions that were accounted for as business combinations during the nine months ended September 30, 2013. These property acquisitions were not given effect in the pro forma because they were immaterial and not directly related to the proposed Merger. We have not reflected a pro forma adjustment to remove the costs associated with our immaterial business combinations from the pro forma consolidated statement of income, and the pro forma consolidated statement of income for the nine months ended September 30, 2013 reflects $4.1 million of non-recurring acquisition expenses for the combined company related to immaterial business combinations. We believe this treatment is consistent with the guidance in Topic 3250.1(c)(iii) noted above.