Form 10-K
In Exhibit 99.1 of your Form 8-K furnished August 2, 2024 you disclosed your estimated earnings per share for the quarter ended June 30, 2024 were negatively impacted between $0.95 and $1.15 diluted share by the CDK Global cyber incident. This impact appears material to you. However, we did not note similar disclosure in this Form 10-Q or whether you expect any continuing impact.Rest of the question
To the extent material, please expand your disclosure to quantify the impact on your historical results and whether the incident is expected to continue to impact your operations and results in future periods. Refer to Item 303 of Regulation S-K.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises that in connection with the CDK incident, the Company conducted a review of the estimated impacts of the CDK incident on the results for the quarter ended June 30, 2024 and the fiscal year ending December 31, 2024, as well in future periods, and concluded that the CDK Global cyber incident was not material and did not otherwise warrant further disclosure in the Form 10-Q, except as disclosed.Read in the replyRest of the answer
The Company’s established process to evaluate materiality took into consideration both quantitative and qualitative factors, including the estimated impact on the Company’s full year financial results. The Company’s Form 10-Q includes disclosures surrounding the impact of CDK Global cyber incident that are necessary to make other statements by the Company materially accurate or not misleading. From time to time, the Company supplements required disclosures in our quarterly and annual reports with additional voluntary information in its earnings releases or other supplemental materials, that the Company does not deem material information relevant to an assessment of the financial condition and results of operations of the Company. As a result, the
Company believes the disclosures included in its Form 10-Q and other SEC filings are appropriate and complete in light of requirements to use a standard of materiality to investors in determining the content of periodic disclosures. Furthermore, based on the Company’s estimates, the CDK Global cyber incident is not expected to continue to impact the Company’s operations and results in future periods. As disclosed in our Form 10-Q, all functions of CDK were fully restored as of July 8, 2024, with other plug-ins and bolt-on applications coming back online in the weeks thereafter. To the extent future recoveries are deemed material, the Company will disclose such recoveries in future periodic disclosures.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 30, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 30, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 9, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You present the non-GAAP measures Pro Forma Adjusted EBITDA and Pro Forma net leverage ratio. Please confirm to us and disclose whether these measures are determined in accordance with the requirements of Article 11 of Regulation S-X. Also, disclose how these measures are used by management in managing and monitoring the performance of your business and the how they provide useful information to investors.Rest of the question
Refer to Question 100.05 of the Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations on Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Item 10(e)(1)(i)(C) and (D) of Regulation S-K. In closing, we remind you that the company and its management are responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of their disclosures, notwithstanding any review, comments, action or absence of action by the staff.
The Company respectfully acknowledges that these measures are not calculated in a manner consistent with the pro forma requirements in ArticleRead in the reply
11 of Regulation S-X and intends to revise its disclosure in future earnings releases accordingly. In Annex A attached hereto, we provide an example of such prospective disclosure to update references to “Pro Forma Adjusted EBITDA” and “Pro Forma net leverage ratio” previously included in the referenced Form 8-K to “Transaction adjusted EBITDA” and
“Transaction adjusted net leverage ratio,” respectively, and update the definition of TransactionRest of the answer
adjusted EBITDA and Transaction adjusted net leverage ratio to disclose how these measures are used by management in managing and monitoring the performance of our business and how they provide useful information to investors.
In connection with our above responses, Asbury
Automotive Group, Inc. acknowledges that: (a) it is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosures in the filings referenced in the Comment Letter; (b) Staff comments or changes to disclosures in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the such filings; and (c) it may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the
United States.
Please address any questions you may have to me at (770) 418-8206 or via email at [email protected].
Respectfully,
/s/ Michael D. Welch
Michael D. Welch
Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer cc:
David W. Hult, Chief Executive Officer, President and Director
Maureen F. Morrison, Director and Chair of the Audit Committee
Nathan Briesemeister, Vice President, Chief Accounting Officer and Controller
Dean Calloway, Senior Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary
Joel May, Jones Day
Annex A
The revised tabular disclosure would be presented as follows (excerpt from the Form 8-K furnished on
August 2, 2024, with the revised disclosures being shown in bold, italics font):
For the Twelve Months Ended
June 30, 2024
March 31, 2024
(Dollars in millions)
Net income
$
400.0
568.2
Depreciation and amortization
71.1
69.7
Income tax expense
135.5
190.4
Swap and other interest expense
169.1
164.1
Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (“EBITDA”)
775.7
992.4
Non-core items – expense (income):
Gain on dealership divestitures
(3.6
)
(13.5
Gain on sale of real estate
Legal settlement
—
(1.9
Asset impairments
252.6
117.2
Professional fees associated with acquisition
4.1
Fixed assets write-off
1.1
Hail damage
3.1
4.3
Total non-core items
253.7
107.8
Adjusted EBITDA
1,029.5
1,100.2
Impact of dealership acquisitions and divestitures
26.6
55.5
Transaction adjusted EBITDA
1,056.1
1,155.7
Transaction adjusted net leverage ratio
2.7
2.6
The additional disclosures would be added to the “Non-GAAP
Financial Disclosure and Reconciliation, Same Store Data and Other Data” section of our quarterly earnings releases as follows (new or revised disclosures are in bold, italics font):
Non-GAAP Financial Disclosure and Reconciliation, Same Store Data and Other Data
In addition to evaluating the financial condition and results of our operations in accordance with GAAP, from time to time management evaluates and analyzes results and any impact on the Company of strategic decisions and actions relating to, among other things, cost reduction, growth, and profitability improvement initiatives, and other events outside of normal, or
“core,” business and operations, by considering certain alternative financial measures not prepared in accordance with GAAP. These measures include “Adjusted income from operations,” “Adjusted net income,”
“Adjusted operating margins,” “Adjusted EBITDA,” “Adjusted diluted earnings per share (“EPS”),” “Adjusted SG&A, “ “Adjusted operating cash flow”, “Transaction adjusted
EBITDA” and “Transaction adjusted net leverage ratio.” Further, management assesses the organic growth of our revenue and gross profit on a same store basis. We believe that our assessment on a same store basis represents an important indicator of comparative financial performance and provides relevant information to assess our performance at our existing locations.
Non-GAAP measures do not have definitions under GAAP and may be defined differently by and not be comparable to similarly titled measures used by other companies. As a result, any non-GAAP financial measures considered and evaluated by management are reviewed in conjunction with a review of the most directly comparable measures calculated in accordance with GAAP. Management cautions investors not to place undue reliance on such non-GAAP measures, but also to consider them with the most directly comparable
GAAP measures. In their evaluation of results from time to time, management excludes items that do not arise directly from core operations or are otherwise of an unusual or non-recurring nature. Because these non-core, unusual or non-recurring charges and gains materially affect Asbury’s financial condition or results in the specific period in which they are recognized, management also evaluates and makes resource allocation and performance evaluation decisions based on, the related non-GAAP measures excluding such items. In addition to using such non-GAAP measures to evaluate results in a specific period, management believes that such measures may provide more complete and consistent comparisons of operational performance on a period-over-period historical basis and a better indication of expected future trends. Management discloses these non-GAAP measures, and the related reconciliations, because it believes investors use these metrics in evaluating longer-term period-over-period performance, and to allow investors to better understand and evaluate the information used by management to assess operating performance.
Due to the significant effects that dealership acquisitions and divestitures have on our results of operations, and in order to provide more meaningful comparisons, we present herein “Transaction adjusted EBITDA” and “Transaction adjusted net leverage ratio” (collectively, the “Transaction Adjusted Metrics”), which reflect the effects of the dealership acquisitions and divestitures, if any, as if they had occurred on the first day of the last twelve-month periods being presented. For acquisitions, the pre-acquisition period amount being included in Transaction adjusted EBITDA is determined by pro-rating the forecasted adjusted EBITDA for the year following the acquisition.
For divestitures, including divestitures due to requirements in connection with an acquisition, the adjusted EBITDA associated with the divestiture(s) is excluded from Transaction adjusted EBITDA. We believe that the Transaction Adjusted Metrics provide relevant information to assess our performance at our existing dealership locations for the last twelve-month periods being presented.
The Transaction Adjusted Metrics do not include any adjustments for other events attributable to the dealership acquisitions or divestitures unless otherwise described. We cannot assure you that such financial information would not be materially different if such information were audited or that our actual results would not differ materially from the Transaction Adjusted
Metrics if the dealership acquisitions or divestitures had been completed as of the beginning of the last twelve-month periods being presented.
Same store amounts consist of information from dealerships for identical months in each comparative period, commencing with the first month we owned the dealership. Additionally, amounts related to divested dealerships are excluded from each comparative period.
Amounts presented herein have been calculated using non-rounded amounts for all periods presented and therefore certain amounts may not compute or tie to prior presentation due to rounding.
First report after the company's reply of Sep 30, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 30, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 9, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Refer to your response to prior comment 1 that you believe the impact of the CDK Global cyber incident was not material to your operations and otherwise did not require further disclosure in the Form 10-Q beyond what was disclosed.Rest of the question
The negative impact to your earnings per share for the quarter ended June 30, 2024 of $.95 to $1.15 per diluted share disclosed in your earnings release for the second quarter of fiscal 2024 appears material in that it represented 68% to 83% of your reported diluted per share amount for the quarter. We note numerous references in the June 30, 2024 Form 1. 10-Q to the negative impact of the CDK incident and reference to higher accounts payable and floor plan payable balances impacting operating cash flow for the period. To the extent the CDK cyber incident is cited as a factor affecting results of operations and operating cash flows between periods, please quantify the impact so investors may understand its magnitude and relative impact. Refer to section III.D of Release No. 33-6835 (501.04 of the staff’s Codification of Financial Reporting Releases) for guidance.
The Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment and intends to include the following disclosure in the Overview section of MD&A in the Company’s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2024 (bolded items reflect changes from the FormRead in the reply
10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2024):
“CDK Outage
During June 2024, one of the Company’s vendors (CDK Global) experienced a cyber-incident impacting certain services provided to the
Company and many other automotive retailers, including the Company’s sales, service, inventory, customer relationship management, and accounting functions.Rest of the answer
Upon discovery of the incident, we took immediate precautionary steps to protect our systems. Beginning on June 19, 2024, the outage affected all Asbury locations, with the exception of our Koons stores which utilize a different dealer management system. All functions of CDK were not fully restored for us until July 8,
2024, with other plug-ins and bolt-on applications coming back online in the weeks thereafter.
The CDK outage had a negative impact on our financial results during the quarter ended June 30, 2024 as a result of fewer new and used vehicle sales, which also impacted our F&I business, a reduction in parts and service volumes and certain incremental expenses related to our recovery efforts. We estimated the earnings per share for the quarter ended
June 30, 2024 was negatively impacted between $0.95 and $1.15 per diluted share, without taking into account any potential recoveries related to the incident. The CDK Global cyber incident is not expected to continue to impact the
Company’s operations and results in future periods.
We have cybersecurity insurance coverage of $15.0 million, with a
$2.5 million deductible. The likelihood and timing of recovering some portion of our losses through insurance or other recoveries is difficult to predict. The insurance recoveries we receive, if any, may not occur for several quarters or longer.”
More specifically, with respect to the disclosure of higher than expected accounts payable and floor plan payable balances as of June 30, 2024, we do not intend to provide more detailed, quantitative disclosure in our Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2024 since such balances were paid in a very short time period following the balance sheet date, such that a disclosure would not be meaningful to our year-to-date cash flows and liquidity. However, the Company respectfully acknowledges the Staff’s comment, and when significant or unusual items occur in the future that affect the Company’s results of operations and cash flows, the Company intends to include appropriate quantitative disclosures regarding the impact of such item(s) in the applicable filing as available.
Notwithstanding the aforementioned planned disclosure in our Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2024, we believe that the estimated impacts of the CDK cyber incident on the Company’s financial results for the quarter ended June 30, 2024 were not material taking into consideration both quantitative and qualitative factors.
In connection with our above response, Asbury Automotive Group, Inc.
acknowledges that: (a) it is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosures in the filings referenced in the Comment Letter; (b) Staff comments or changes to disclosures in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the
Commission from taking any action with respect to the such filings; and (c) it may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
Please address any questions you may have to me at (770) 418-8206 or via email at [email protected].
Respectfully,
/s/ Michael D. Welch
Michael D. Welch
Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer cc:
First report after the company's reply of Oct 17, 2024: 10-Q filed Oct 30, 2024 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 9, 2024 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: closing letter, 2024-10-23