Form 10-K
Given the significant increase in the line item ‘Acceleration of net earned premiums’ in the table of Net Earned Premiums from the prior year, please separately quantify for us the increase due to refunding or termination of insurance and change in the expected lives of the insured obligations and explain the reason(s) for the increase.Rest of the question
This comment applies to the increase related to the quarters ended March 31, 2016 and June 30, 2016 as well.
The increase in net earned premiums due to accelerations is attributable to changes in the expected lives of insured obligations driven by (a) refundings of insured obligations or (b) terminations of insured obligations either through negotiated agreements or the exercise of our contractual rights to make claim payments on an accelerated basis.Read in the reply
Refundings occur in the public finance market and have been at historically high levels in recent years due primarily to the low interest rate environment, which has allowed many municipalities and other public finance issuers to refinance their debtRest of the answer
obligations at lower rates. The premiums associated with the insured obligations of municipalities and other public finance issuers are generally received upfront when the obligations are issued and insured. When such issuers pay down insured obligations prior to their originally scheduled maturities, the Company is no longer on risk for payment defaults, and therefore accelerates the recognition of the nonrefundable unearned premiums remaining from the original upfront payment, as described in the Company's accounting policy on page 182 of the Form10-K.
Terminations are generally negotiated agreements with issuers resulting in the extinguishment of the Company’s insurance obligation with respect to the insured obligations. Terminations are more common in the structured finance asset class, but may also occur in the public finance asset class. While each termination may have different terms, they all result in the expiration of the Company’s insurance risk, such that the Company accelerates the recognition of the associated unearned premiums.
In future filings, when the variance is material, the Company will provide an explanation similar to the above, provide a breakdown of these two drivers of accelerations within the body of the table as shown below (see highlighted rows for additional breakout), and remove the footnote in favor of providing quantification of the components of the change.
Year Ended
Quarter Ended
December 31,
March 31,
June 30,
2015
2014
2016
(in millions)
Financial guaranty:
First report after the company's reply of Aug 26, 2016: 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 4, 2016 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
You present full non-GAAP income statements to reconcile to your non-GAAP results, which is inconsistent with updated Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations 102.10 on Non-GAAP Measures issued on May 17, 2016. Please review this guidance when preparing your next earnings release and future periodic reports.
The Company reviewed the updated Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (“CDI”) on Non-GAAP financial measures, as well as its previous SEC Staff comment letter response on this topic dated October 8, 2014, when preparing its earnings press release and periodic filings as of and for the periods ended June 30, 2016. The Company has made a number of changes to its disclosures as a result of that review.Read in the replyRest of the answer
For example, the Company revised its reconciliations to show adjustments gross of their tax effect, and now shows the tax effects separately.
While management recognizes the changes made to the CDI in May 2016, the Company respectfully requests that the Staff reconsider management’s assessment of the appropriateness of its current disclosures, especially given the Staff’s recognition that “whether a non-GAAP measure is more prominent than the comparable GAAP measure depends on the facts and circumstances in which the disclosure is made”. We believe greater prominence is placed on the GAAP financial measures in our income reconciliation by virtue of the fact that the reconciliation starts with the GAAP amounts in the first column (bolded) and clearly labels the non-GAAP financial measures as non-GAAP.
We know that various users of our financial statements find the current presentation of our GAAP and non-GAAP results to be informative, useful and transparent because (a) it more accurately reflects the economics of the Company, (b) it is how management and analysts view the Company's performance, and (c) analysts’ models are based on a non-GAAP income statement. Below is an analysis of why management believes the Company’s current reconciliation of the components of GAAP and non-GAAP income is in compliance with non-GAAP rules. This analysis has been updated from the October 8, 2014, SEC comment letter response.
Background
Assured Guaranty’s operating subsidiaries are financial guaranty insurance companies that provide credit protection products for the benefit of holders of debt instruments and other monetary obligations in respect of defaults in scheduled payments of principal and interest. If an obligor defaults on a scheduled payment due on an obligation, the Company is required under its unconditional and irrevocable financial guaranty to pay the amount of the shortfall to the holder of the obligation. Although the Company’s contracts are written in various forms and may include the insurance of a monetary obligation of a variable interest entity, what the Company guarantees is payment upon the failure of an obligor to make payment on a debt instrument or other monetary obligation when such payment is due. The various state insurance departments that regulate the financial guaranty industry and the rating agencies that assign financial strength ratings to financial guaranty companies consider our financial guaranties to be insurance contracts that should be presented as such under one consistent insurance accounting model. This is consistent with management’s view and with the views of our investors and analysts.
GAAP accounting rules have evolved over the years, often as a response to actual or perceived issues in a broad range of industries. In 2009, when the FASB's financial guaranty industry-specific guidance became effective with the intent to eliminate some of the diversity in accounting practice in the industry, its scope did not include the Company’s contracts written in derivative form, despite the economic similarities of these contracts to those written in the form of a financial guaranty insurance contract. As a result, the Company records changes in the fair value of the contracts that are considered derivatives under GAAP rules in its GAAP reported net income even though the contractual terms of these contracts do not permit the Company to unilaterally exit them. Movements in fair value that are in excess of the present value of expected losses are non-economic and will reverse as the contracts approach their maturities. These changes can be significant.
In 2010, the FASB's new rules regarding the consolidation of variable interest entities became effective, but again did not scope out financial guaranty contracts. This resulted in a third GAAP accounting model for economically similar contracts, which has a significant effect on many of the components of GAAP reported net income. The Company’s economic exposure under a consolidated FG VIE is the same as that of a financial guaranty insurance contract.
Derivative and VIE consolidation rules are the most significant drivers of non-economic volatility in our GAAP reported income statement. We believe that while these rules are valuable in reporting the economics of certain types of financial instruments in other financial services industries, they do not fully consider the unique characteristics of financial guaranty contracts.
Because management, investors, analysts, and insurance regulators view us as an insurance company whose results should be measured consistently regardless of contract form or structure, the Company has developed non-GAAP operating income measures in order to present all contracts under the financial guaranty insurance accounting model in ASC 944. We believe that the GAAP financial guaranty insurance accounting model, which was developed specifically for our industry, is the accounting model that most clearly reflects the economics of our business.
There have been many published reports by analysts and rating agencies that highlight the lack of transparency the derivative and consolidation of variable interest entity accounting models create in determining the economics of the Company’s business. Analysts have communicated their dissatisfaction with these GAAP rules (as they apply to financial guaranty companies) and indicated that they rely on the company’s non-GAAP financial statements because they more accurately reflect the Company’s economic exposure. The disclosures that management currently presents for its non-GAAP measures were formulated in response to requests by users of our financial statements for help in understanding the effect that these and other pronouncements have had on each component of net income.
Over the years, management has devoted much time and effort to creating supplemental disclosures to provide essential information to users that present a more economic view of the results of operations and financial condition, while still complying with SEC rules and regulations, and in a way that disseminates the information timely and consistently to all users in accordance with Regulation FD. We believe that users of our financial statements understand these adjustments and incorporate them in their analysis of the Company’s results.
Compliance with non-GAAP disclosure rules
The primary purpose of the reconciliation between the components of GAAP reported net income and non-GAAP earnings is to present the required reconciliation between each non-GAAP financial measure included in operating income and its most directly comparable GAAP financial measure. We believe that our presentation, while in the form of an income statement, does not place undue prominence on our non-GAAP financial measures, because equal if not greater prominence is placed on the GAAP financial measures by virtue of the fact that the reconciliation starts with the GAAP amounts in the first column (bolded) and clearly labels the non-GAAP financial measures as non-GAAP. For these reasons, we believe this presentation fulfills the requirements of Item 10(e)(1)(i)(A) of Regulation S-K.
Since most line items in the GAAP reported income statement are affected by the non-GAAP to GAAP reconciliation, management believes that it is beneficial to users to have all the components of non-GAAP operating income and GAAP reported net income in one place. Management believes that the benefit to the user of having all components of non-GAAP operating income in one place (even those few line items that have no non-GAAP adjustments) in an easily understandable format far outweighs any potential confusion. It allows the user to easily find the amounts necessary to calculate financial ratios such as the expense ratio and the effective tax rate on both a GAAP reported basis and a non-GAAP basis. Such analysis would be more difficult if we presented separate reconciliations or excluded line items from the presentation. Users would be required to search filings for components necessary to calculate these and other ratios. We know from our discussions with our financial statement users that this schedule is informative and they have commented on its usefulness. In fact, if the Company no longer prepared the non-GAAP income statement format, they would undoubtedly attempt to compile it themselves which would lead to additional confusion and diversity in practice and reduced transparency. We believe that providing this comprehensive reconciliation and presentation fulfills the requirement in Item 10(e)(1)(i)(B), and is responsive to the needs of our financial statement users.
In addition to the quantitative reconciliation, the Company provides extensive qualitative disclosure describing the adjustments to GAAP reported net income and the reasons for each, along with the primary purposes of the non-GAAP financial measures in the section labeled “Explanation of Non-GAAP Financial Measures” in Exhibits 99.1 and 99.2 of the Form 8-K. This satisfies the requirements in Items 10(e)(1)(i)(C) and 10(e)(1)(i)(D).
It is the same format provided to and used by the Board of Directors and executive management of the Company in their oversight and decision making roles. It is our strong belief that this presentation is useful to analysts, investors and other users of the financial statements, conveys management’s view of the results of operations, and is not prohibited by Item 10(e)(1)(i).
To that end, the Company respectfully requests that the Staff consider the Company’s facts and circumstances, particularly the three separate accounting models applicable in the Company’s small industry, the extent of the non-GAAP adjustments developed by the Company in response, the fact that such adjustments affect the majority of the lines of the income statement and the presentation of the GAAP measures first and in bold, and to accept the Company’s proposal to continue the use of this presentation.
In summary, the Company believes that it has complied with the applicable rules and the Staff’s interpretation of such rules.
--------------------------
In connection with its responses, the Company acknowledges that:
• the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and the Company may not assert the Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
First report after the company's reply of Aug 26, 2016: 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 4, 2016 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
In your response to prior comment two you indicate that although the Company’s contracts are written in various forms, the various state and insurance departments that regulate the financial guarantee industry and the rating agencies that assign financial strength ratings to financial guaranty companies consider your financial guarantees to be insurance contracts that should be presented as such under one consistentRest of the question
insurance model. And, that this is consistent with management’s view and the views of your investors and analysts. As a result, you developed non-GAAP operating income measures in order to present all contracts under the financial guaranty insurance accounting model in ASC 944. Please provide us with the following additional information: Tell us whether you continue to write contracts in various forms (i.e. derivative and financial guaranty insurance contracts) or if certain contracts are in run-off. If you continue to write various forms of contracts, explain why, given the “economic similarities” of the contracts. For example, tell us whether customer needs drive the form of the contracts you write; and Tell us your consideration of the updated Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations Question 100.04 on Non-GAAP Measures issued on May 17, 2016, given your presentation of all contracts under ASC 944.
The Company does not currently write new financial guaranty contracts in credit default swap (CDS) form, and has not written any new CDS since 2009.Read in the reply
The remaining term until legal maturity of the inforce book of financial guaranty contracts accounted for as CDS ranges up to 31 years. The estimated weighted average remaining life of the portfolio is 5.0 years as of June 30, 2016.Rest of the answer
The remaining inforce book of financial guaranty business written in CDS form and accounted for as derivatives had a total net par outstanding of $20.0 billion as of June 30, 2016, down from $122.4 billion as of December 31, 2009.
On a quarterly basis, the Company discloses the remaining net par of its contracts accounted for as credit derivatives in the notes to the financial statements, and makes the following disclosure in Note 1 to its quarterly consolidated financial statements filed on Form 10-Q:
"In the past, the Company sold credit protection by issuing policies that guaranteed payment obligations under credit derivatives, primarily credit default swaps ("CDS"). Financial guaranty contracts accounted for as credit derivatives are generally structured such that the circumstances giving rise to the Company’s obligation to make loss payments are similar to those for financial guaranty insurance contracts. The Company’s credit derivative transactions are governed by International Swaps and Derivative Association, Inc. (“ISDA”) documentation. The Company has not entered into any new CDS in order to sell credit protection since the beginning of 2009, when regulatory guidelines were issued that limited the terms under which such protection could be sold. The capital and margin requirements applicable under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act also contributed to the Company not entering into such new CDS since 2009. The Company actively pursues opportunities to terminate existing CDS, which have the effect of reducing future fair value volatility in income and/or reducing rating agency capital charges."
Tell us your consideration of the updated Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations Question 100.04 on Non-GAAP Measures issued on May 17, 2016, given your presentation of all contracts under ASC 944.
Company Response:
The Company carefully considered Question 100.04 and the response to that question in the Staff’s updated Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations on Non-GAAP Measures. In the answer, the Staff observed that "non-GAAP measures that substitute individually tailored revenue recognition and measurement methods for those of GAAP could violate Rule 100 (b) of Regulation G," and that "other measures that use individually tailored recognition and measurement methods for financial statement line items other than revenue may also violate Rule 100(b) of Regulation G." [Emphasis added.] This interpretation was offered in response to a hypothetical question involving a company that wished to present a non-GAAP performance measure that was adjusted to accelerate revenue recognized ratably over time in accordance with GAAP as though it earned revenue when customers are billed. In the example, the individually tailored non-GAAP performance measure appeared to be designed to accelerate (increase) revenue in comparison to the GAAP income measure.
The Company's non-GAAP adjustments are not designed to accelerate revenue or to otherwise adjust a financial measurement, positively or negatively. The Company makes adjustments regardless of whether they represent gains or losses, and there have been periods when the Company had non-GAAP operating income lower than reported GAAP net income, as well as periods when the Company had non-GAAP operating income higher than reported GAAP net income.
The Company’s non-GAAP adjustments are designed to present all financial guaranty contracts (regardless of legal form) on a consistent financial guaranty insurance basis (i.e., in accordance with ASC 944, which is the GAAP pronouncement that best reflects the economics of our business ) because of their economic similarities, as has been requested by investors, rating agencies and analysts following the Company. Since these non-GAAP measures allow these users to analyze the Company’s insured portfolio on a consistent basis, the Company believes these adjustments are useful and informative, and not misleading or in violation of Rule 100(b).
Background:
Financial guaranty policies are structured so that if an obligor on or issuer of a debt instrument or other monetary obligation defaults on a scheduled payment due to be paid on an instrument or obligation insured by the Company, including a scheduled principal or interest payment, the Company is required under its unconditional and irrevocable financial guaranty to pay the amount of the shortfall. This is the case regardless of the form of the contract or the accounting model prescribed by GAAP.
In addition to ASC 944, which was written specifically for the financial guaranty industry, there are two accounting pronouncements to which the Company must adhere that have a significant effect on the recognition and measurement of its financial guaranty contracts: ASC 815, Derivatives and Hedging; and ASC 810, Consolidation.
Impact of ASC 815, Derivatives and Hedging. The Company is in the business of providing credit protection products, primarily in the form of financial guaranties. Prior to the financial crisis, certain users of the Company's products requested the Company to provide its financial guaranty product in derivative form. The Company was willing to provide its financial guaranty product in derivative form as long as the risk it was taking and the reward it received was economically similar to those it took and received with respect to its traditional financial guaranty policy. Consequently, the terms of the contracts written in derivative form were tailored to mirror the insurance terms of traditional financial guaranty insurance contracts, and differed from those typically available in the market. Importantly, the
Company’s contracts written in derivative form, just like its traditional financial guaranty products, do not require the Company to pay on an accelerated basis unless such acceleration is at the sole option of the Company. In addition, because the Company provided irrevocable financial guaranty contracts on the CDS, it cannot unilaterally terminate or sell its exposure under them, just as it cannot do do so under its traditional financial guaranty contracts.
These contracts were accounted for under ASC 815 due only to the fact that they did not meet the third criteria in the scope exception in ASC 815-10-15-58(c), which requires the guaranteed party to represent that they will hold the debt obligation to maturity. From the perspective of the Company, as the provider of an irrevocable guaranty on the CDS, the terms of the CDS it entered make the CDS economically similar to traditional financial guaranty insurance.
Impact of ASC 810, Consolidation. Consolidated FG VIEs are traditional financial guaranty insurance contracts that have triggered consolidation under ASC 810, with no change to the Company's obligation to make payments of scheduled principal and interest when due upon default. Typically, these FG VIEs are consolidated only because a performance trigger in the insured VIE allows the Company to exercise its right to change a servicer. The Company does not actually service the underlying contracts or even have the authority to direct the servicer how to service the contracts, but simply has the right to change a servicer when the performance of the underlying contracts breaches an objective measure the parties believed at closing could indicate poor servicing. Because servicing of the underlying assets in a VIE whose debt is insured by the Company is deemed to be its principal activity, under ASC 810 the Company is deemed the primary beneficiary and consequently must consolidate the entire FG VIE. Similar to contracts accounted for as derivatives, this difference in accounting model does not affect the economic obligation of the Company.
Conclusion. The primary users of the Company's financial statements - management, directors, analysts, investors, rating agencies and state insurance regulators - all recognize the similarities of the Company's financial guaranty products regardless of whether they involve CDS or VIEs or not, and prefer to view them on a consistent financial guaranty insurance basis of accounting, which best reflects the economics of our business. In order to present this information to our users, we developed the non-GAAP adjustments discussed in this letter, and users of the Company’s financial statements need this to analyze the Company's results. For example, at pages 10 to 11 of its July 27, 2016 article affirming the Company’s ratings, S&P Global Ratings (S&P) again (as it has for the past several years) addressed the application of ASC 815 and 810 in its section on accounting considerations. Addressing ASC 815, S&P observes: “In our opinion, ASC 815, insofar as it relates to the financial guarantee insurance industry, has introduced some earnings volatility that has little bearing on either the likelihood of a potential claim or a bond insurer’s intrinsic earnings power. Unlike other financial sectors for which ASC 815 may be more relevant, bond insurers’ contracts are not traded, and there is no business intention to realize gains. Therefore, recording a marked-to-market loss because of changing spreads in the marketplace does not make sense from our analytic perspective.” Addressing ASC 810, S&P says: “We do not view consolidation of these transactions as indicating different or incremental risk relative to the company’s non-consolidated insurance exposure. … Because of this, we do not include debt associated with [special purpose entities] in any leverage calculations or fixed-charge coverage ratios.”
The overriding driver of the Company's decision to make the adjustments discussed in this letter was to present all economically similar credit protection contracts on a consistent method of accounting that most accurately reflects the economics of its book of business, which is important to the users of our financial statements. Within GAAP, ASC 944 is the model best suited for this purpose as it was written specifically for financial guaranty insurance contracts, with their unique characteristics in mind. ASC 815 and 810 were written for broader audiences with businesses very different from ours, and unfortunately, certain of the Company's contracts contain triggers or provisions that scope them into these rules, but which do not change the timing and amount of the Company's right to receive premiums or obligation to make payments.
Finally, the non-GAAP financial measures discussed in this letter are key measures in the Company's internal management reporting and decision making process, and are important in determining management compensation. They are therefore a critical component of the Company's disclosures regarding its compensation process and decisions, and are important touchstones for users of the Company's financial statements.
--------------------------
In connection with its responses, the Company acknowledges that:
the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filings;
Staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to Staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filings; and the Company may not assert the Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
First report after the company's reply of Oct 7, 2016: 10-Q filed Nov 4, 2016 ↗, against the 10-Q filed Aug 4, 2016 ↗.
Tickdelta does not hold the text of both reports, so they are not compared here.
Also in this review: company letter, Jan 18, 2017, closing letter, 2017-01-19