Form S-1
Please supplementally provide us with copies of all written communications, as defined in Rule 405 under the Securities Act, that you, or anyone authorized to do so on your behalf, present to potential investors in reliance on Section 5(d) of the Securities Act, whether or not they retain copies of the communications.
No reply letter found.
We note your disclosure in the second sentence under this heading and elsewhere in this filing that you own all of the IDRs in Antero Midstream. This may indicate to your investors that you have rights to all of the IDR cash distributions.Rest of the question
However, you also disclose in multiple locations that following the Reorganization, certain senior members of Antero Midstream’s management team will have rights to a portion of the IDR cash distributions if those distributions exceed certain targets. Please revise your disclosures regarding your ownership of the IDRs to clarify this matter as we believe that understanding your rights to the IDR cash distributions is very important to your investors. If true, you may wish to disclose in close proximity to your statements that you “own all” of the IDRs that following the Reorganization you may not receive all of the IDR cash distributions.
No reply letter found.
We note your discussion of Antero Midstream’s aggregate quarterly cash distributions on IDRs at the bottom of page 2 and the related chart on page 3. Please explain to us why the calculation of the aggregate quarterly distribution to IDRs for the fourth quarter of 2016 is based on “the number of outstanding Antero Midstream units at the closing of this offering.” In doing so, tell us why the narrative disclosure onRest of the question
page 2 and the related chart on page 3 do not reflect the actual quarterly distribution which we note from page 9 was based on the number of units outstanding as of February 1, 2017.
No reply letter found.
Please clearly and prominently indicate after the chart that the amount and increases associated with Antero Midstream historic distributions are not indicative of Antero Midstream’s future ability to distribute similar amounts or continue to in increase such amounts. Should this chart appear in multiple places in your amendment, please make these changes in every instance.
No reply letter found.
Please revise your disclosure after the chart to provide a more balanced presentation to include the potential for a decrease in distributions of cash under certain circumstances. Should this chart appear in multiple places in your amendment, please make these changes in every instance.
No reply letter found.
Please revise your disclosure after the chart to provide a more balanced presentation of the circumstances that could cause a decrease in production.
No reply letter found.
Please disclose the percentage of revenues or volumes attributed to Antero Resources and third-party customers in the most recent annual and interim periods. Although you disclose that Antero Midstream’s forecast for the twelve-month period ending March 31, 2018 contain no third-party volumes, we believe it would be useful for an investor to know the historical activity with third-party customers.
No reply letter found.
If you choose to highlight your strengths in the summary, please balance that disclosure with a discussion of the principal challenges or weakness and the risks and limitations facing you.
No reply letter found.
We note your description of American Midstream’s “at-the-market equity offering program” and revolving credit facility. If applicable and in an appropriate place in your prospectus, describe the impact of this program on the distributions to you. If significant, consider adding a risk factor or modifying an existing risk factor.Rest of the question
Also, consider adding a related footnote to your chart on page 4, Illustrative Example – AMGP Cash Available for Distribution.
No reply letter found.
You disclose under this heading that you will “effectively control” the business and affairs of Antero Midstream and IDR LLC. Similarly, you indicate in a risk factor at the bottom of page 33 that you “manage and control Antero Midstream” but could lose that ability if Antero Midstream’s general partner were removed.Rest of the question
However, you disclose in multiple locations throughout your filing, including on page 91 under the heading “Equity Method Accounting,” that you will not control Antero Midstream and instead will only exercise significant influence over it. Please revise your filing to consistently indicate whether you will control Antero Midstream after the Reorganization. Additionally, please provide us with your detailed analysis of the applicable accounting literature to show us how you concluded that Antero Resources is the primary beneficiary of Antero Midstream following the Reorganization. Restrictions and Limitations on Our Cash Distribution Policy, page 68.
No reply letter found.
In the second bullet point on page 69, please disclose whether your general partner has established, or plans to establish, reserves; disclose the current or planned amount of those reserves; and if applicable, disclose the amount of any shortfall in the those reserves.
No reply letter found.
Please tell us why this table does not include the most recent quarterly distribution declared by Antero Midstream.
No reply letter found.
We note that the period from October 1, 2016 through March 31, 2017 is not accounted for in your calculation of historical pro forma cash available for distribution on page 74 or your calculation of forecasted cash available for distribution presented on page 77.Rest of the question
Please tell us whether there are any significant transactions or events that occurred during this period that would cause the omitted period to materially change the results of the forecast if such omitted period were included. If so, tell us how such transactions or events are considered in your forecast or why they have no continuing impact.
No reply letter found.
We note that your forecast of Antero Midstream’s cash available for distribution indicates that direct operating expenses will only need to increase 12% from the 12 months ended September 30, 2016 in order to support a 43% increase in revenue. This relationship between direct operating expenses and revenue appears inconsistent with the relationship seen in Antero Midstream’s historical financial statements.Rest of the question
Specifically, we note that for the interim period seen in Antero Midstream’s financial statements, direct operating costs increased 222% year over year to support a 66% increase in revenue. Please revise your discussion of assumptions related to direct operating expenses to bridge the gap between Antero Midstream’s historical results and your forecast by explaining why you expect the relationship between direct operating expenses and revenue to change so significantly in the future.
No reply letter found.
Please refer to your discussion of assumptions regarding interest expense, capital expenditures and financing. It is unclear from your current disclosures whether you have assumed that the $449 million of expansion capital expenditures during this period will be fully financed and whether the related interest expense is included in your forecast.Rest of the question
Specifically, the first sentence under the heading “Financing” appears to suggest that you have not decided how it will be funded; however, the calculation of cash available for distribution does not reflect a cash outflow related to these expansion capital expenditures. Please revise to clearly reflect management’s assumption about how these expansion capital expenditures will be funded and any resulting cash outflows. If funding for these expansion capital expenditures is reflected in your assumption that Antero Midstream’s revolver will have average borrowings of $514 million, please clearly state as such.
No reply letter found.
Please refer to your discussion of assumptions regarding financing. We note that you plan to disclose the available borrowing capacity under Antero Midstream’s revolver and under its at-the-market equity offering program as of December 31, 2016.Rest of the question
To assist your investors in understanding the assumptions that underlie your forecast of cash available for distributions, please also disclose the expected available capacity amounts as of March 31, 2018 based on management’s assumptions as reflected in your forecast.
No reply letter found.
Please refer to your discussion of assumptions regarding distributions on Series B Units. Please explain to us in more detail how you calculated the $3 million reserved in your forecast for Series B Units, and revise your disclosure to better explain this to your investors. If the $3 million does not represent the maximum 6% of quarterly IDR distributions in excess of $7.5 million, please disclose that fact.
No reply letter found.
In the last bullet point on page 85, please disclose the actual amount of established reserves, the anticipated amount of planned reserves, and if applicable, the amount of any shortfall in those reserves. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations Antero Midstream’s Results of Operations Nine Months Ended September 30, 2015 Compared to Nine Months Ended September 30, 2016,
No reply letter found.
We note that while revenue increased for each of Antero Midstream’s segments, the direct operating expenses of the water handling and treatment segment increased significantly while the direct operating expenses of the gathering and compression segment remained consistent.Rest of the question
Please expand your disclosure to discuss the types of costs included in this line item for each segment; also explain why these costs appear to have different relationships with the revenue of each segment through an analysis of segment direct operating costs as a percentage of segment revenue or other appropriate means. In doing so, please provide your investors with management’s insight into how you were able to increase gathering and compression revenue by 30% without a significant increase in the related direct operating expenses and whether management expects this trend to continue in the future. Similarly, please provide your investors with management’s insight into why the direct operating expenses of the water handling and treatment segment increased at a faster rate than the revenue of this segment and whether management expects this trend to continue in the future. When explaining the changes in Antero Midstream’s water handling and treatment segment’s direct operating expenses, please consider separately discussing the fresh water delivery and other fluid handling services since the margins on these two services appear very different.
No reply letter found.
Refer to the table on page 117 which presents cash available for distribution as compared to Antero Midstream’s distribution per unit. We note that Antero Midstream’s $1.03 fiscal year 2016 distribution per unit represents distributions earned during fiscal year 2016. Similarly, it appears that the $11 million cash available for distribution is based on distributions earned during that period.Rest of the question
If this is the case, please confirm this to us. If this is not the case, please explain how the $11 million is derived. Also, to the extent that you do not present a reconciliation of the $11 million cash available for distribution in fiscal year 2016 in your amendment, please provide us supplementally with such reconciliation.
No reply letter found.
Please update your executive compensation disclosure to include your recently completed fiscal year. Please refer to Item 402 of Regulation S-K and Regulation S-K Compliance and Disclosure Interpretation 117.05.
No reply letter found.
Please revise to disclose the number of shares to be sold by the selling shareholders in the offering, and the number and percentage of shares to be owned by the selling shareholder after the offering, both in the event that the underwriters do exercise the over-allotment option and do not exercise the over-allotment option.
No reply letter found.
Please revise to disclose the number of shares held by the beneficial owners identified in the table before the offering. Refer to Item 507 of Regulation S-K.
No reply letter found.
Please disclose the date that was used in calculating the beneficial information. Please furnish the information as of the most recent practicable date. Please also disclose the natural person(s) or public company that has the ultimate voting or investment control over the shares held by AMGP GP LLC.Rest of the question
Refer to Question 140.02 of our Regulation S- K Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations located at our web-site, www.sec.gov.
No reply letter found.
Please revise your disclosure to define who a related person is. Also, it appears that you have not yet adopted a written policy. In light of this, please indicate what procedures, if any, were employed to review any of the related party transactions you disclose.
No reply letter found.
Please update the financial statements and related financial information included in the filing, as necessary, to comply with Rule 3-12 of Regulation S-X.
No reply letter found.
We note you continue to disclose that you will effectively control Antero Midstream through your role as the managing member of Antero Midstream’s general partner, AMP GP. However, your response to comment 10 appears to indicate you believe AMP GP will base its operating and capital investment decisions on the operating and capital investment decisions of Antero Resources, and therefore Antero Resources, rather thanRest of the question
AMP GP effectively controls the most significant decisions of Antero Midstream. Please explain to us in more detail this apparent difference in your identification of the entity effectively controlling Antero Midstream. In doing so, please respond to the following: Please describe to us in detail your ability to direct the activities that most significantly impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance through its general partner AMP GP, and contrast this with Antero Resource’s power. As part of your response, address the following: o Tell us whether AMP GP can sign contracts with other customers such that Antero Midstream is no longer dependent upon Antero Resources. o Tell us the extent to which AMP GP can direct Antero Midstream to differ its capital investment decisions from those made by Antero Resources, and separately describe any legal or economic consequences to such a decision. o Tell us the decisions impacting Antero Midstream’s economic performance that you can make as the managing member of AMP GP, and contrast those to the decisions impacting Antero Midstream’s economic performance that are made by AMP GP’s board of directors. Also provide us with your analysis of whether Antero Resources effectively controls AMP GP’s board of directors. o Provide us with any additional information to help us understand why you believe Antero Resources, rather than AMP GP, directs the most significant activities of Antero Midstream. Explain to us in more detail how you considered your relationship with Antero Resources during your analysis of Antero Midstream’s primary beneficiary. In doing so: o Clarify the extent to which you and Antero Resources have common ownership or are under common control, and revise the organizational structure chart in your filing as needed to clarify this matter to your investors. o To assist us in understanding this matter, please also provide us with an organizational chart depicting the relationship between the Sponsors, Antero Resources, Antero Midstream, and your predecessor ARMM prior to the Reorganization. o Tell us how you considered your shared officers and directors during your analysis of Antero Midstream’s primary beneficiary and explain to us in significantly more detail the extent to which it is possible for you to make decisions and, through AMP GP, direct the decisions of Antero Midstream independently from the decisions made by these shared officers and directors on behalf of Antero Resources. If you believe that Antero Resources controls the most significant decisions made by Antero Midstream and that you, through AMP GP, control less significant decisions, tell us in more detail why you believe it is appropriate to characterize your relationship with Antero Midstream as effectively controlling its business and affairs. Tell us whether it would be correct to state that you control Antero Midstream on behalf of Antero Resources or for the benefit of Antero Resources, and if not, why not.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have provided the analysis below to address the Staff’s request for clarification. We also refer the Staff to the structure charts attached hereto as Exhibits A and B, which reflect our organizational structure before and after the completion of the offering and the related reorganizational transactions described in the prospectus (the “Reorganization”), respectively, as well as the updated disclosure provided on pages 6, 16, 18, 45, 118, 128, F-7 and F-8 to more clearly reflect the analysis below.Read in the reply
In determining whether Antero Midstream Partners GP LLCRest of the answer
(“AMP GP”) or Antero Resources Corporation (“Antero Resources”) will have the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the economic performance of Antero Midstream Partners LP (“Antero Midstream”) and, therefore, to be the primary beneficiary of Antero Midstream, we considered both (i) the power that AMP GP will exercise as the general partner of Antero Midstream pursuant to the Agreement of Limited Partnership of Antero Midstream dated November 10, 2014 and incorporated by reference as an exhibit to the Registration Statement (as amended, the “AM Partnership Agreement”), and (ii) the purpose and design of Antero Midstream, which is to provide services to Antero Resources. In addition, we considered the common membership of the boards of directors of Antero Resources, AMP GP and our general partner (“AMGP GP”), as previously described in our response letter to the Staff dated March 2, 2017 (the “Initial Response Letter”). In considering these elements, we examined in particular the nature and characteristics of Antero Midstream’s activities and operations.
Antero Midstream was designed and formed to act as Antero Resources’ midstream service provider, and Antero Resources continues to supply Antero Midstream with the requisite personnel to fulfill such purpose.
As described in the Registration Statement, Antero Midstream is a growth-oriented limited partnership formed to own, operate and develop midstream energy assets to service Antero Resources’ production. Antero Midstream’s assets are located in North American shale plays in which Antero Resources conducts its operations and consist of gathering pipelines, compressor stations, processing and fractionation plants and water handling and treatment assets, through which Antero Midstream provides midstream services to Antero Resources under long-term, fixed-fee contracts with initial terms of up to 20 years and automatic annual renewal provisions. For the year ended December 31, 2016, Antero Midstream generated 99.86% of its consolidated revenues from these contracts with Antero Resources.
Prior to Antero Midstream’s formation, Antero Resources acquired, developed and operated the assets that comprised Antero Midstream’s initial business. Antero Resources formed Antero Midstream’s predecessor as a separate entity and contributed these assets to Antero Midstream to finance the continued expansion and development of the midstream infrastructure supporting Antero Resources’ business through direct access to the capital markets, among other reasons. Since that initial contribution of assets and its initial public offering, Antero Midstream has continued to develop its asset base to serve Antero Resources’ growing midstream needs. As a result, substantially all of the capital investment and operating decisions of Antero Midstream since its initial public offering have been, and for the foreseeable future will continue to be, dependent on the capital investment and operating decisions made by Antero Resources.
Further, because Antero Midstream does not have any employees, it depends on Antero Resources to supply the personnel who operate Antero Midstream’s business. The officers of Antero Resources act as officers of the general partner of Antero Midstream and provide services to Antero Midstream under a services agreement among Antero Resources, Antero Midstream and its general partner. In addition, Antero Resources also seconds employees to Antero Midstream to provide operational services with respect to the gathering and processing assets and water handling and treatment assets operated for the benefit of Antero Resources pursuant to a secondment agreement among Antero Resources, Antero Midstream and its general partner. Thus, Antero Resources’ employees are responsible for the day-to-day operations of Antero Midstream, including core administrative functions such as accounting, finance, human resources, legal and tax. Similarly, we will not have any employees and will rely on Antero Resources and its officers to provide services on our behalf under the terms of a services agreement to be entered into in connection with our initial public offering. Due to the presence of these factors, AMP GP is practically constrained with respect to the decisions that it can make on behalf of Antero Midstream.
Antero Midstream is limited in its ability to provide significant services to customers other than Antero Resources.
While AMP GP has the authority to execute contracts on behalf of Antero Midstream with customers other than Antero Resources and to direct capital investment decisions away from Antero Resources to other customers, Antero Midstream does not have the physical capacity or the practical ability, based on its asset base, capital and operating personnel to provide a significant amount of services to any customer other than Antero Resources while continuing to perform under its long-term contracts with Antero Resources, which have initial terms of up to 20 years and contain automatic annual renewal provisions. If Antero Midstream were to fail to perform under its contracts with Antero Resources and such contracts were terminated, it is unlikely due to geographical constraints, potential capital investments to meet new customer specifications and other logistical considerations that Antero Midstream would be able to enter into replacement contracts with third parties on similar or more favorable terms, or at all, and such termination could have a material and adverse effect on Antero Midstream. As a result, Antero Midstream relies, and will continue to rely for the foreseeable future, on Antero Resources for virtually all of its revenues. Thus, although AMP GP has the authority under the AM Partnership Agreement to direct the activities of Antero Midstream as the general partner, it would not currently be in AMP GP’s or Antero Midstream’s interest to direct the activities of Antero Midstream in a manner that would not benefit or support the purpose and design of Antero Midstream to serve Antero Resources. For this reason, we have identified for potential investors in our common shares the risks facing Antero Resources’ business and the impact those risks could have on Antero Midstream and, in turn, our investors. Please see, for example, “Risk Factors—Risks Related to Antero Midstream’s Business—Because substantially all of Antero Midstream’s revenue is derived from Antero Resources and Antero Resources’ capital decisions drive our operations, any development that materially and adversely affects Antero Resources’ operations, financial condition or market reputation could have a material and adverse impact on us” in the Registration Statement.
In addition, we acknowledge that the individuals and entities responsible for appointing all of the members of the board of directors of our general partner (collectively, the “Sponsors”) own approximately 31.5% of the outstanding shares of common stock in Antero Resources and also comprise five of the eight members of the board of directors of Antero Resources.
The activities of Antero Midstream that most significantly affect its economic performance are performed under contractual obligations with Antero Resources. The activities that most significantly impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance relate to its capital investment decisions and long-term growth projects associated with its gathering, compression and water systems. In determining whether Antero Midstream should undertake a capital investment to pursue an expansion or modification of its operations, the officers of Antero Midstream consider primarily whether such investment or operational development accords with Antero Resources’ drilling and completion plans. For example, Antero Midstream is unlikely to undertake an expansion of a gathering system or a capital-intensive operational modification unless the increased capacity is supported by a planned increase in Antero Resources’ drilling and completion activity in the region served by the gathering system. By linking its capital investment and operational decisions to the needs of, and its contractual arrangements with, Antero Resources, Antero Midstream is able to ensure a new capital project or modification is supported by a contract capable of generating sufficient revenue to offset the cost of such project or modification over time, reducing the risk associated with large, expensive capital projects and modifications. In addition, Antero Midstream has visibility into Antero Resources’ long-term growth plans through shared personnel, which is critical to its ability to pay and increase quarterly cash distributions to it unitholders over time. As a result, through its familiarity with Antero Resources’ growth plan, Antero Midstream is able to develop assets and undertake related financing activities with an understanding of how its growth plan accords with the long-term requirements of its primary customer. In this way, Antero Resources and Antero Midstream are able to create a “just in time” synergy, whereby Antero Resources generally has contracted midstream infrastructure when needed and Antero Midstream significantly reduces the risks of completing a capital project without the support of a long-term, fixed fee contract. Similarly, as a result of this synergy, Antero Midstream focuses its operational modifications on changes that will benefit Antero Resources. Antero Midstream is unable to achieve a similar relationship with third party customers because it does not share personnel with such customers and, accordingly, lacks comparable visibility into their short-term drilling and completion plans and long-term growth strategy. Thus, Antero Midstream’s investment and operational decisions are substantively controlled by the shared directors, officers and employees of Antero Resources and the fact that Antero Resources owns 59% of the outstanding common units of Antero Midstream. Accordingly, we have concluded that Antero Resources is the primary beneficiary of Antero Midstream.
Comparison of Antero Resources’ Power and AMP GP’s Authority over Antero Midstream
Through its ownership of the general partnership interest in Antero Midstream and pursuant to the terms of the AM Partnership Agreement, AMP GP has the legal authority to direct the activities of Antero Midstream. However, because of (i) the contractual arrangements in place between Antero Resources and Antero Midstream, which utilize substantially all of Antero Midstream’s existing assets and represent virtually all of Antero Midstream’s revenue, (ii) Antero Midstream’s reliance on Antero Resources’ officers and employees to manage and conduct the day-to-day operation of its business and (iii) the substantial overlap between the boards of directors of Antero Resources and Antero Midstream, Antero Resources exerts substantive control over the activities that Antero Midstream that most significantly impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance.
We acknowledge that the substantive power that Antero Resources has over Antero Midstream is different than the legal control that AMP GP will exercise over Antero Midstream as its general partner. As a result, we believe it is accurate to state that AMP GP will control Antero Midstream consistent with its contractual obligations for the benefit of Antero Resources. We further acknowledge that this arrangement is distinguishable from traditional midstream master limited partnerships (“MLPs”) in which the upstream sponsor forms the MLP and continues to own the general partner interest in the MLP, thereby consolidating both the legal control and the substantive power in a single entity.
For the reasons described above and in our Initial Response Letter, we believe that Antero Resources has the power to direct activities that most significantly impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance without itself directly owning the general partner interest in Antero Midstream.
We note that the table on page 25 presents an Adjusted EBITDA metric that includes income and expense attributable to the parent for periods prior to the Water Acquisition and that the tabular reconciliation of Net Income to Adjusted EBITDA on page 27 does the same.Rest of the question
However, the definition of Adjusted EBITDA at the top of page 26 and the related explanation of why management believes this metric is useful indicate that it excludes pre-acquisition income and expense attributable to the parent, and it appears to instead describe the metric titled Adjusted EBITDA attributable to Antero Midstream. Please conform the title of the metric you present and the description of how it is calculated to the tabular reconciliation seen on page 27. If you continue to present the metric currently called Adjusted EBITDA, ensure that your description of why this metric is useful to investors explains why including the income and expenses related to the pre-acquisition period during which Antero Midstream had no control over the water acquisition assets results in a metric that serves as an indicator of Antero Midstream’s performance.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and we advise the Staff that Antero Midstream includes the income and expenses related to the pre-acquisition period during which Antero Midstream did not control the water acquisition assets in its calculation of Adjusted EBITDA because Antero Midstream’s historical financial statements were recast in connection with such acquisition to include the income and expenses related to the pre-acquisition period, as the acquisition occurred between entities under common control.Read in the replyRest of the answer
In addition, excluding the income and expenses related to the pre-acquisition period during which Antero Midstream did not control the water acquisition assets would result in higher period over period Adjusted EBITDA growth, which we believe would be potentially confusing and misleading to our investors.
Refer to the first full bullet point on page 69 which describes the authority AMP GP has over Antero Midstream’s cash reserves that reduce distributable cash and over changes to Antero Midstream’s cash distribution policy. Given that you are the managing member of AMP GP, please revise to clarify to your investors the extent to which you control these items.Rest of the question
It is not clear from your current disclosure that these represent restrictions that are outside of your control.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see page 70.Read in the reply
We note your response to comment 13. We further note your disclosure on page 91 that in 2017 Antero Midstream will make a $275 million capital investment in the Joint Venture. Please revise your narrative assumptions in an appropriate location to clarify the timing of this capital investment and how it will be funded.Rest of the question
We note from your disclosure on page F-35 that a portion of this capital investment was effectively funded with new equity issuances by Antero Midstream, but it is unclear how and when the remainder will be funded and why this would have no impact on cash available for distribution during the forecast period.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see pages 82, 83 and 92.Read in the reply
We have reviewed your response to comment 15 and have the following comments: You state in your response that you expect to fund your expansion capital expenditures with a combination of cash flows from operations and borrowings under your revolving credit facility; however, your “Expansion capital expenditures” $580 million cash outflow line item and “Borrowing to fund expansion capital expenditures” $580 millionRest of the question
cash inflow line item on page 77 suggest you have assumed that all of your expansion capital expenditures will be financed. Please reconcile the assumptions contained in your response with the assumptions presented in your filing. Also, we note that footnote (a) on page 77 and the financing assumptions on page 82 state that your forecasted interest is based on the assumption that you will finance $450 million of your expansion capital expenditures. Please reconcile these statements to the table on page 77 showing that the entire $580 million of expansion capital expenditures will be financed and showing no debt repayments. Antero Resources Midstream Management LLC Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2016 Note (2) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies (b) Investment in Antero Midstream, page F-7
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see pages 78, 79 and 83.Read in the reply
Antero Resources Midstream Management LLC Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2016
Note (2) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
(b) Investment in Antero Midstream, page F-7
We note you account for your ownership of the IDRs of Antero Midstream using the equity method of accounting. Please provide us with your analysis of whether the IDRs are in-substance common stock. Also, tell us how you determined the balance in the investment account should solely consist of IDR distributions attributable to you by Antero Midstream but not yet paid, and whether you considered other presentations ofRest of the question
your rights to Antero Midstream’s net assets such as the HLBV method.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and provide the analysis below to support our conclusion that the equity method of accounting is appropriate for the ownership of the incentive distribution rights (“IDRs”) of Antero Midstream.Read in the reply
In-Substance Common Stock
We respectfully advise the Staff that we do not believe the analysis of whether the IDRs are in-substance common stock is applicable, as ASC 323-10-15-5 states that the guidance of ASC 323-10 does not apply to an investment in a partnership, an unincorporated joint venture or a limited liability company.Rest of the answer
We believe ASC 323-30-S99-1 provides the authoritative support to use the equity method of accounting for the IDRs, which are in form equity interests in a partnership. ASC 323-30-S99-1 requires the equity method of accounting for an investment in a partnership unless the investor’s interest “is so minor that the limited partner may have virtually no influence over partnership operating and financial policies.” We believe that the IDRs represent an interest that is “more than minor” and should be accounted for using the equity method of accounting.
Balance of the Investment Account
In determining the balance of the investment account, we have relied upon ASC 323-10-35-4 which states, “Under the equity method, an investor shall recognize its share of the earnings or losses of an investee in the periods for which they are reported by the investee in its financial statements rather than in the period in which an investee declares a dividend.” Antero Midstream allocates earnings in its financial statements at the end of each reporting period to the holders of the IDRs and the holders of the Common Units to their respective capital accounts. The amount allocated to holders of the IDRs is equal to their rights in the distribution declared shortly after the end of the reporting period and paid within 45 days after the end of the reporting period. We believe that recognizing equity in earnings based on the amount allocated to the capital account of the IDR holders in Antero Midstream’s financial statements is an accurate representation of the amount of cash flow that will ultimately be realized by us. Because we have no other invested balance in Antero Midstream, the balance of the investment account at the end of the reporting period is equal to distributions declared but not yet paid.
Pursuant to the terms of the AM Partnership Agreement, the general partner of Antero Midstream has no equity interest in Antero Midstream or rights upon liquidation other than its right to receive the balance, if any, in its capital account upon liquidation. The AM Partnership Agreement does not provide for the allocation of losses to the general partner of Antero Midstream or the holder of the IDRs and, thus, AMP GP is not obligated to fund any shortfalls as the general partner of Antero Midstream. Therefore, we believe the application of the HLBV method of accounting would result in the same amounts as recorded under traditional equity accounting. We believe that the usual method of applying equity accounting is appropriate for the general partner’s interest in the IDRs.
Please tell us how you complied with the disclosure requirements of ASC 810-10-50-5A.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see pages F-7 and F-8.Read in the reply
Please provide the following information to clarify the company's assessment of the power criterion in accordance with ASC 810-10-25-38 with respect to Antero Midstream Partners LP: We note from your responses your determination that the most significant activities of Antero Midstream are “capital investment decisions and long-term growth projects associated with its gathering, compression and water systems.”Rest of the question
Please explain to us in greater detail the individual decisions you identified that relate to the capital investment and long-term growth activities. In addition, explain to us your consideration of decisions related to operation of existing systems and to financing activities in evaluating whether they represent ones that most significantly impact the economic performance of the Antero Midstream. With respect to your analysis of the power criterion in ASC 810-10-25-38A(a), please identify for us the party that makes the decision or controls the individual activities or groups of activities discussed above. Tell us how you considered the contractual obligations to develop assets in accordance with the agreements with Antero Resources. Address the contractual decision making role of Antero Resources, AMP GP, and the shared officers and directors as well as the ability of AMGP or Antero Resources to select, confirm, and replace the shared officers and directors within your analysis to determine which party has the ultimate ability to control each of the activities or groups of activities identified. To the extent that the individual activities identified are directed by multiple parties, please describe to us how you consider which party has the power to direct the activities that most significantly impact the performance of Antero Midstream.
We acknowledge that various aspects of control over Antero Midstream are directed by Antero Resources, AMP GP and AMGP. However, as described in more detail below, the most significant decisions that impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance are made by Antero Resources.Read in the reply
Antero Midstream was formed by Antero Resources for the specific purpose of providing gathering, compression and water services to Antero Resources. Virtually all of Antero Midstream’s assets service Antero Resources’ wells in Antero Resources’ operating areas.Rest of the answer
The key decisions that impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance relate to:
(i) capital investments in gathering, compression and water systems;
(ii) financing those capital investments; and
(iii) the operation of Antero Midstream’s systems after they are constructed.
ASC 810-10-25-38A states that although more than one reporting entity could have an obligation to absorb losses or receive benefits from a variable interest entity (“VIE”), only one reporting entity (if any) will have the power to direct the activities of the VIE that most significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance. We have concluded that the most significant activity that affects the economic performance of Antero Midstream relates to the capital investment decisions that Antero Resources make, which in turn dictate the capital investments Antero Midstream must make to fulfill its long-term contractual obligations to Antero Resources. These capital investment decisions, which emanate from and are directed by Antero Resources, have a direct impact on Antero Midstream’s operating performance because Antero Midstream’s operating performance is almost entirely dependent on revenues received from, and capital investments contractually required by, Antero Resources under these long-term contractual arrangements. The following describes in more detail, and in chronological order, the power Antero Resources has over the economic activities of Antero Midstream.
Step One: Antero Resources makes capital investment decisions
To grow its natural gas, natural gas liquids and oil production business, Antero Resources develops shortand long-term drilling and development plans. Antero Resources frequently reviews and adjusts these plans based on industry and market conditions, availability of drilling and completion services, availability of transportation and other circumstances. These drilling and development plans are managed by Ward McNeilly, Senior Vice President Reserves, Planning and Midstream of Antero Resources. These plans set forth in detail the timing and location of wells to be drilled, as well as the gathering, compression and water systems required to gather Antero Resources’ production from these wells and complete the wells drilled, respectively. More specifically, (i) Antero Resources’ drilling plans determine the timing, location and capital required for Antero Midstream’s investments in gathering and compression systems, and (ii) Antero Resources’ well completion design and schedule determines the volume and location of water to be delivered by Antero Midstream, which in turn dictates the need for Antero Midstream to establish permanent versus temporary water lines and the size, location and need for water impoundments. Mr. McNeilly also holds the title of Senior Vice President Reserves, Planning and Midstream at Antero Midstream. In this role, he is responsible for implementing the build-out of midstream assets in order to support the above drilling and development plans of Antero Resources.
The midstream-related project costs embedded in Antero Resources’ consolidated capital plans are then extracted, and, as set forth below, Antero Midstream determines how to finance these capital projects. Also as set forth below, once financing for these projects has been obtained, Mr. McNeilly, in his management role at Antero Midstream, along with other members of Antero Midstream management, oversees the construction of these assets.
Step Two: AMP GP and, to a lesser extent, AMGP oversee Antero Midstream’s financing plans
AMP GP, in its capacity as general partner of Antero Midstream, has oversight authority over decisions related to how to finance Antero Midstream’s capital budget. Glen Warren, President and CFO of Antero Resources and President of Antero Midstream, and Michael Kennedy, SVP Finance of Antero Resources and Chief Financial Officer of Antero Midstream, make recommendations to the board of AMP GP with respect to Antero Midstream’s capital financing decisions. Day-to-day financing decisions of Antero Midstream are made by Messrs. Warren and Kennedy in their roles as officers of Antero Midstream.
Because of the long-term contractual obligations between Antero Resources and Antero Midstream, the directors of AMP GP and AMGP are effectively limited in their ability to determine how Antero Midstream invests capital and makes other operational decisions. Instead, AMP GP and AMGP focus on how to finance the capital budget that Antero Resources establishes for Antero Midstream and also determine the distributions that will be made to their respective shareholders and unitholders. These decisions have significantly less of an impact on Antero Midstream’s economic performance than the capital investment decisions that are driven solely by Antero Resources.
Step Three: Operating decisions made by Antero Midstream are driven by Antero Resources’ drilling and development plans
The day-to-day operating decisions related to Antero Midstream’s expenditures and construction of the gathering and compression and water systems are over seen by Mr. McNeilly in his role as Senior Vice President Reserves, Planning and Midstream of Antero Midstream. The key decisions with respect to the specification of the systems are generally driven by industry standards based on the designed throughput of the systems. A significant portion of the construction of Antero Midstream’s assets is based on fixed price contracts, and the day-to-day management of those construction projects consists primarily of contractor oversight, which does not have a significant impact on Antero Midstream’s economic performance.
Once the gathering and compression systems are installed, the day-to-day operating decisions required to keep the systems operating are relatively ministerial in nature, and those decisions are made by lower-level employees of Antero Resources who are seconded to Antero Midstream.
The key decisions that relate to the operation of the water systems are driven by Antero Resources’ water needs for its well completion activities. As described above, the amount of water required, the rate at which that water should be delivered, the location of the water delivery and the decisions regarding whether to use permanent or temporary water lines are based on Antero Resources’ drilling and development plans.
Decisions by Antero Resources to curtail or increase production impact Antero Midstream’s operations directly. For example, if Antero Resources decides to curtail production in a certain region, that decision will result in Antero Midstream shutting down compressor stations on its systems, thus directly impacting Antero Midstream’s revenues and economic performance.
Under the secondment agreement between Antero Resources and Antero Midstream, Antero Midstream has the right to terminate the secondment arrangement with any Antero Resources employee providing services to Antero Midstream; however, this removal right applies only with respect to work being performed by those employees on behalf of Antero Midstream. As such, Antero Midstream’s removal right is effectively limited to matters relating to the oversight and implementation of construction and other operational decisions that are perfunctory in nature and limited as discussed above. While AMP GP and Antero Midstream have certain rights to remove individuals from their positions as an officer of, or secondee to, Antero Midstream, the decisions made by any individual selected as a replacement would still have significantly less of an impact on Antero Midstream’s economic performance than the capital investment decisions that are driven by Antero Resources.
Significance and Economic Impact
Under the long-term contractual arrangements between Antero Resources and Antero Midstream, Antero Midstream earns fees based on the volumes of oil and gas that flow through Antero Midstream’s systems. Decreases in Antero Resources’ production result in a corresponding decrease in revenue to Antero Midstream for all of the assets that Antero Resources contributed to Antero Midstream prior to Antero Midstream’s initial public offering. Decreases in throughput levels on assets installed subsequent to Antero Midstream’s initial public offering also result in decreased revenue to Antero Midstream.
Antero Midstream’s current water system serves Antero Resources’ completion program. Decisions by Antero Resources on well completion design and the timing of well completions directly impact Antero Midstream’s revenue. The number of wells and amount of water that Antero Resources requests for delivery in each of its well completions determine how much water Antero Midstream will ultimately pump and thereby drive Antero Midstream’s volume based fees that it earns as revenue from its water business.
Because of Antero Resources’ growth plans over the next five years and the long term nature of the agreements, Antero Midstream does not anticipate being able to provide services to customers other than Antero for the foreseeable future other than services that are incidental, immaterial and within Antero Resources’ operating areas.
Because the capital investment decisions are the decisions that most significantly impact the economic performance of Antero Midstream, Antero Resources is the primary beneficiary of Antero Midstream. Through its existing long-term contractual agreements with Antero Midstream, Antero Resources has the ability to direct the capital investment decisions, which have a direct and significant impact on Antero Midstream’s operating performance. This is consistent with the fact that the Antero Midstream business is designed and operated primarily to serve Antero Resources.
We have reviewed your revisions in response to comment 5, including the line item titled “Borrowings and retained cash flow to fund expansion capital expenditures” in the table on page 78, and have the following comments: Please define “retained cash flow from operations.” In doing so, tell us whether this represents cash flow generated in the twelve-month period ending June 30, 2018, cash flow generated duringRest of the question
the six-month period ended June 30, 2017, estimated cash balance at June 30, 2017, or a different metric. Based on your response to the above bullet point, please tell us why it is appropriate to include the $129 million of retained cash used to partially fund your expansion capital expenditures as a cash inflow that is distinct from the cash generated from operations that is already included in Adjusted EBITDA. If “retained cash flow from operations” represents all or a portion of your estimated cash balance at June 30, 2017 resulting from cash flow generated from operations through such date, please address the following: o Please present this cash inflow on a separate line item and provide investors with insight as to how that amount is derived and the assumptions surrounding the estimate. o Please tell us whether you established a cash reserve during the 6-month period ended June 30, 2017 to fund this portion of the capital expenditures, and if so, please disclose this and its impact on cash distributions during that period. Antero Resources Midstream Management LLC Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2016 Note (2) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies (c) Investment in Antero Midstream, page F-8
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised our disclosure in the forecast section to clarify that the estimated $580 million to fund Antero Midstream’s expansion capital expenditures is expected to derive solely from borrowings under its revolving credit facility. Please see pages 78, 79 and 83 of the Amended Registration Statement.Read in the replyRest of the answer
We have not revised the cash interest expense line of the forecast because it already reflected the anticipated interest expense associated with borrowing the full amount necessary to fund Antero Midstream’s expansion capital expenditures during the forecast period.
Antero Resources Midstream Management LLC Financial Statements for the Year Ended December 31, 2016
Note (2) Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
(c) Investment in Antero Midstream, page F-8
We note your response to comment 7. Given the apparent degree of judgment needed for a general partner’s contractual control over a MLP to be overcome by other factors when performing a VIE consolidation analysis, please revise your disclosure to more specifically identify the significant judgments and assumptions underlying your conclusion that Antero Resources is the primary beneficiary of Antero Midstream.Rest of the question
If the capital investment decisions and long-term growth projects of Antero Midstream are the activities that most significantly impact its economic performance, and if you concluded that Antero Resources rather than the general partner controls these activities and there is limited opportunity for long-term growth outside of the relationship with Antero Resources, you should explain this in more detail so that investors better understand why the general partner does not consolidate Antero Midstream. Include in these disclosures more detail of how the contracts in place between Antero Resources and Antero Midstream affect control. Additionally, please ensure that disclosures about the general partner’s relationship to Antero Midstream outside of the financial statements also convey the unique practical constraints placed on the general partner’s control over Antero Midstream to convey a consistent message to your investors that Antero Resources rather than the general partner has effective control over the activities that most significantly impact Antero Midstream’s economic performance.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Amended Registration Statement accordingly. Please see pages F-8 and F-9.Read in the reply
We note the pro forma column of your capitalization table reflects a balance of zero for total equity after the Reorganization. We also note the disclosure in footnote (1) to this table. Throughout your filing where you describe the transactions that will occur in connection with the Reorganization, please make disclosures similar to footnote (1); this footnote appears to be the only location in your filing whereRest of the question
you currently disclose that you will distribute all of the Predecessor’s cash and reduce its total equity to zero prior to this offering. We believe this is important information to convey to your investors.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see pages 16-17, 26, 66 and 89.Read in the reply
In the first paragraph in this section you state that you believe you will be able to pay a quarterly distribution of $0.32 per common share “for each quarter” during the twelvemonth period ending June 30, 2018. Please revise to indicate that the $0.32 distribution is for the entire twelve-month period ending June 30, 2018 rather than for each quarter.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised the Registration Statement accordingly. Please see page 76.Read in the reply
Counsel’s opinion relies upon payment for the Common Shares “contemplated by the form of underwriting agreement,” however, it is not clear what purpose this language serves when counsel should be rendering an opinion that addresses the legality of the Common Shares following the effectiveness of the Certificate of Conversion, as opposed to closing of this offering, considering this is a secondary offering.Rest of the question
Please advise.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and have revised Exhibit 5.1 accordingly.Read in the reply
Please confirm that counsel will file an opinion following the closing of the offering that removes any assumptions as to due authorization and renders an opinion that the Common Shares “are” legally issued, rather than “will be,” and holders of such Common Shares have no obligation to make further payments, etc., rather than “will have.” Refer to Sections II.B.2. and II.B.3. Staff Legal Bulletin No.Rest of the question
19 (CF), located at our web-site.
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment and confirm that an opinion of counsel will be filed following the closing of the offering addressing the Staff’s comment.Read in the reply
Also in this review: company letter, Apr 19, 2017