Form S-1
In item (b) on the prospectus cover page, you state that you are registering for resale up to 124,931,453 shares of common stock, which consists of 124,564,920 shares of common stock, 12,326,472 shares of common stock issuable upon the exercise of warrants, and 366,533 warrants by the selling security holders named in your prospectus.Rest of the question
However, in the calculation of the registration fee and on page 14 of the prospectus, you note the selling stockholders are registering up to 124,931,453 shares of common stock, which includes 366,533 shares issuable upon exercise of warrants held by the selling stockholders. Please revise or clarify, as appropriate.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on the prospectus cover page accordingly.Read in the reply
We note that your forward purchase agreements with certain investors provide those investors with the right to sell back shares to the company at a fixed price three months after the closing date of the business combination. Please revise to discuss the risks that these agreements may pose to other holders if you are required to buy back the shares of your common stock as described therein.Rest of the question
For example, discuss how such forced purchases would impact the cash you have available for other purposes and to execute your business strategy.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 68 and 69 accordingly.Read in the reply
The future sales of shares by existing stockholders may adversely affect the market price of the Company’s Common Stock, page 75
Please expand your discussion here to reflect the fact that this offering involves the potential sale of a substantial portion of shares for resale and discuss how such sales could impact the market price of the company's common stock.Rest of the question
Your discussion should highlight the fact that AE Industrial Partners, a beneficial owner of 83.5% of your outstanding shares, will be able to sell all of its shares for so long as the registration statement of which this prospectus forms a part is available for use. General
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on page 77 accordingly.Read in the reply
Given the nature of your offering, including, among other things, the substantial portion of your shares being registered for resale that are held by a single entity relative to the number of shares outstanding, the short time period your outstanding shares have been held, and your relationships with some of the selling stockholders as disclosed in your prospectus, please provide us with an analysis of your basisRest of the question
for determining that it is appropriate to characterize the transaction as a secondary offering under Securities Act Rule 415(a)(1)(i) as opposed to an indirect primary offering. For guidance, please refer to Question 612.09 of the Securities Act Rules Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully submits that the transaction is a secondary offering under Securities Act Rule 415(a)(1)(i).Read in the reply
In an effort to assist registrants in determining whether an offering by selling stockholders may be characterized as a secondary offering that is eligible to be made on a shelf basis under Rule 415(a)(1)(i), the Staff issued Interpretation 612.09 in its Securities Act
Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations (“C&DI; 612.09”).Rest of the answer
C&DI; 612.09 provides that “[t]he question of whether an offering styled a secondary one is really on behalf of the issuer is a difficult factual one, not merely a question of who receives proceeds” and that consideration be given to the following factors:
• how long the selling stockholders have held the shares;
the circumstances under which the selling stockholders have received the shares;
the relationship of the selling stockholders to the issuer;
the number of shares being sold;
whether the selling stockholders are in the business of underwriting securities; and whether under all the circumstances it appears that the seller is acting as a conduit for the issuer.
For the reasons set forth below, the Company respectfully submits that the registration and offering from time to time
(the “Offering”) of up to 124,931,453 shares of common stock and up to 12,326,472 shares upon exercise of the warrants (the “Warrants”) is not, and should not be considered, a primary offering of the shares and warrants to the public.
A. How Long the Shares Have been Held
The vast majority of the shares owned by AE Industrial Partners (105,000,000 of 113,250,000) (92.7%) were received as merger consideration in exchange for equity of BigBear.ai Holdings, LLC they owned since May 22, 2020. Only a small portion of the shares owned by AE Industrial Partners (8,000,000 of 113,250,000) (7.0%) were purchased in connection with the backstop subscription agreement, dated November 29, 2021 between GigCapital4, Inc. and AE BBAI Aggregator, LP (the “Backstop Subscription Agreement”). The remainder of AE Industrial Partners (250,000 of 113,250,000) (0.2%) were received from
GigCapital4, Inc. on December 7, 2021 (the “Closing”).
GigAcquisitions4, LLC (the “SPAC Sponsor”) has held its shares and warrants since the closing of the initial public offering of GigCapital4, Inc. in February 2021 (the “SPAC IPO”). Dorothy Hayes and Brad Weightman have each owned their shares since the SPAC IPO.
A small number of shares owned by Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. (“Oppenheimer”), William Blair & Company, L.L.C.,
BMO Capital Markets Corp. and Nomura Securities International, Inc. (“Nomura”) (1,495,320 of 124,931,453 registered) were issued to advisors in lieu of cash for fees payable for services in connection with the closing or the SPAC
IPO. The warrants owned by the SPAC Sponsor, Oppenheimer and Nomura were acquired at the time of the SPAC IPO.
B. The Circumstances
Under Which the Selling Stockholders Received the Shares
The vast majority of the shares to be registered pursuant to the Amended S-1 on behalf of the selling stockholders were issued by the Company well before the closing of the Business Combination. As discussed above, AE Industrial Partners purchased its shares to bear the market risk of holding the shares as an investment—and not with a view to distribution. Each of the SPAC Sponsor, Dorothy Hayes and Brad Weightman (collectively, the “Initial Stockholders”) have owned their shares since the SPAC IPO. The SPAC
Sponsor, Oppenheimer and Nomura have owned their warrants since the SPAC IPO and the registration of the shares underlying such warrants is required by the warrant agreement, dated February 8, 2021 between the Company (f/k/a GigCapital4, Inc.) and Continental Stock Transfer & Trust Company (the “Warrant Agreement”), entered into in connection with the SPAC IPO. As a result, each of the selling stockholders have borne the risk that the Company would fail or be unable to register and/or monetize the shares.
C. The Relationship of the Selling Stockholders to the Company
As discussed above, only 1,495,320 of 124,931,453 shares registered (1.2%) were issued to advisors in lieu of cash for fees payable for services in connection with the Closing or the SPAC IPO. The remaining shares were issued in connection with the SPAC IPO, as merger consideration in connection with the Closing and in connection with the Backstop Subscription Agreement. The Company does not currently have an underwriting relationship with any of the selling stockholders.
The Registration Statement registering the shares and warrants was filed by the Company as a result of registration requirements in the Warrant Agreement and investor rights agreement, dated December 6, 2021, by and among GigCapital4, Inc. and the holders named thereto (the
“Investor Rights Agreement”).
D. The Number of Shares Being Registered
The Company acknowledges the large amount of shares of common stock involved, however, the Company does not believe that the amount of shares being registered alone warrants re-characterizing a valid secondary offering as a primary offering. Pursuant to C&DI; 612.09, the amount of shares being offered is only one of several factors to be considered in evaluating whether, under all the circumstances, a purported secondary offering is instead an indirect primary offering. Furthermore, the Staff’s own interpretations support the Company’s position. For example, Securities Act
Compliance and Disclosure Interpretation 612.12 (“C&DI; 612.12”) describes a scenario in which a holder of more than 70% of the outstanding stock is able to effect a valid secondary offering. The interpretation states, in relevant part:
A controlling person of an issuer owns a 73% block. That person will sell the block in a registered ‘at-the-market’ equity offering. Rule 415(a)(4) applies only to offerings by or on behalf of the registrant. A secondary offering by a control person that is not deemed to be by or on behalf of the registrant is not restricted by Rule 415(a)(4).
Additionally, Securities Act Compliance and
Disclosure Interpretation 216.14 (“C&DI; 216.14”), regarding the use of Form S-3 to effect a secondary offering, also provides:
Secondary sales by affiliates may be made under General Instruction I.B.3 to Form S-3, even in cases where the affiliate owns more than 50% of the issuer’s securities, unless the facts and circumstances indicate that the affiliate is acting as an underwriter by or on behalf of the issuer.
The Company believes that these interpretive provisions make clear that a single holder of in excess of 50% of the public float of a company’s common stock can effect a valid secondary offering of its shares unless other facts, beyond the mere level of ownership, indicate that the selling stockholder is acting as a conduit of the issuer. In these circumstances, a group of selling stockholders’ shares are being registered on a Form S-1, the form for general registrations, not a Form S-3.
Moreover, there is no evidence that a distribution would occur if the Amended S-1 is declared effective. The Company is not aware of any agreements or understandings with any person with respect to the distribution of the shares. We note that under Rule 100(b) of Regulation M, a “distribution” is defined to require special selling efforts:
[A]n offering of securities, whether or not subject to registration under the Securities Act, that is distinguished from ordinary trading transactions by the magnitude of the offering and the presence of special selling efforts and special selling methods. (emphasis added)
Accordingly, the Company has not been advised, and is not otherwise aware, of any special selling efforts or selling methods that have been or will take place in connection with the filing of the Amended S-1. Nor is there any evidence that any of the selling stockholders have conducted any road shows or taken any other actions to condition or
“prime” the market for their shares. The mere size of a potential offering does not make a proposed sale a “distribution,” and the Company believes that the other factors discussed in this letter, support the characterization of the offering as secondary in nature.
E. Whether the Selling Stockholders are in the Business of Underwriting Securities
While some of the selling stockholders, particularly, Oppenheimer, William Blair, BMO and Nomura, all of whom received their shares in lieu of consideration for services provided in connection with the SPAC IPO and Closing, may be in the business of underwriting securities and some may be registered broker-dealers, the remainder of the selling stockholders are not, to the knowledge of the Company, in the business of underwriting securities or registered broker-dealers and are, to the knowledge of the Company, not U.S. Persons within the meaning of such term under Regulation S under the Securities Act.
F. Whether Under All Circumstances It Appears That the Selling Stockholders are Acting as a Conduit For the Company
The totality of the facts and circumstances surrounding the Offering demonstrates that the selling stockholders are not acting as a conduit in a distribution to the public. Rather, they are each acting for their own account as an investor in arms-length transactions. The Company believes that the following factors weigh in favor of the conclusion that the Offering is a valid secondary offering:
the vast majority of the shares owned by AE Industrial Partners to be registered pursuant to the Amended S-1 were issued in connection with the bona fide decision of AE Industrial Partners to engage in a long-term investment in the Company;
the Initial Stockholders have borne the risk of investment by holding the shares since their issuance in the SPAC
IPO;
most of the selling stockholders acquired the shares for their fair market value and did not receive any placement fees or commissions from the Company in connection therewith;
the Company filed the Registration Statement to comply with the provisions set forth in the various agreements it has with the different groups of selling stockholders, including the Warrant Agreement and Investor Rights Agreement, and will receive no financial benefits from any future sale of the shares; and the amount of shares involved is only one factor in the facts and circumstances analysis and is not dispositive, especially in light of the Staff’s prior positions taken in C&DI; 612.12 and C&DI; 216.14.
Based on the foregoing considerations, we believe and respectfully submit that the selling stockholders not acting as a conduit for the sale of shares to the public, that the registration of the shares for resale by the selling stockholders pursuant to the
Amended S-1 is a true secondary offering under Rule 415(a)(1)(i) and that there is no risk to the investing public if the Amended S-1 is declared effective.
We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions related to this letter, please contact the undersigned by telephone at (212) 446-4794 or by email at [email protected].
We note your response to prior comment 2. Given the nature of these risks, please include disclosure of them in your prospectus summary. Additionally, clarify whether the forward purchase agreements allow for the option to be exercised at any time until the three-month anniversary of the closing date of your business combination or only on that date.Rest of the question
Disclose, if true, that until each forward purchase agreement is terminated, the agreements require the investors to sell their shares subject thereto only at a minimum price of $10.00 per share even if they do not exercise their option on March 7, 2022. File a copy of these agreements as exhibits to your registration agreement.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 12, 13 and 68 accordingly and has filed a copy of each of the Forward Share Purchase Agreements in the exhibits by incorporation by reference.Read in the reply
Revise to disclose what constitutes a "Fundamental Change" under the indenture for your 2026 Convertible Notes.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 193, 194 and 195 accordingly.Read in the reply
We note your response to prior comment 4. Please provide us with additional information to assess your conclusion that the Offering is a valid secondary offering, specifically with respect to AE Industrial Partners. We note that AE played a significant role in coordinating the business combination of GigCapital4 and BigBear.Rest of the question
We also note that a company owned by AE Partners is or was a customer and business partner of the Company, and that there may be other affiliated relationships.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on the prospectus cover page and on pages 15, 159, 160 and in the Exhibit 107 Fee Table accordingly to remove the registration of the resale of AE Industrial Partner’s common stock as a selling stockholder from the Amended S-1.Read in the reply
We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions related to this letter, please contact the undersigned by telephone at (212) 446-4794 or by email at [email protected].
For each of the common stock shares and warrants being registered for resale, disclose the price that the selling securityholders paid for such common stock shares and warrants.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on the cover page and pages 137 through 140 accordingly.Read in the reply
Austin Bay
Area Beijing Boston Brussels Chicago Dallas Hong
Kong Houston London Los Angeles Munich Paris Salt Lake
City Shanghai Washington, D.C.
Please disclose the likelihood that warrant holders will not exercise their warrants to the extent the warrants are out of the money. Provide similar disclosure in the prospectus summary, risk factors, MD&A and use of proceeds section and disclose that cash proceeds associated with the exercises of the warrants are dependent on the current trading price of the Company's stock.Rest of the question
As applicable, describe the impact on your liquidity and update the discussion on the ability of your company to fund your operations on a prospective basis with your current cash on hand.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on the cover page and pages 11, 70,Read in the reply
78 and 112 accordingly. Furthermore, the Company advises the Staff that it does not believe the impact on liquidity would be material if the warrant holders do not exercise their warrants.
We note the significant number of redemptions of your common stock in connection with your business combination and that the shares being registered for resale will constitute a considerable percentage of your public float.Rest of the question
It appears that certain of the shares being registered for resale were purchased by the corresponding selling securityholders for prices considerably below the current market price of your common stock. Highlight that these securityholders have an incentive to sell because they will profit on sales given that they purchased their shares at more favorable prices than the public investors. Additionally, discuss the significant negative impact sales of such securities on this registration statement could have on the public trading price of your common stock.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 72 and 137 through 140 accordingly.Read in the reply
We note the discussion of several products, including Brown Bear, Polar, and ARTEMIS, which were not previously disclosed. With a view toward additional explanatory disclosure, advise if these are changes in name or nomenclature, or if they represent new products that you are offering.Rest of the question
Risk Factors Resales of the shares of Common Stock included in the Merger Consideration could depress the market price of our Common Stock, page 73
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully advises the Staff that the products Brown Bear,Read in the reply
Polar, and ARTEMIS do not represent new products. These are internal naming conventions for specific customer deployments. The Company has removed these references in the Amended S-1.
Risk Factors
Resales of the shares of Common Stock included in the Merger Consideration could depress the market price of our Common Stock, page 73
Your risk factor disclosure discusses how the “future” sale of the common stock issued in connection with the business combination may cause the market price of your securities to drop significantly. This statement should be updated given that this prospectus is facilitating those sales.Rest of the question
Additionally, revise this risk factor to further highlight the negative pressure potential sales of shares pursuant to this registration statement could have on the public trading price of your common stock. To illustrate this risk, highlight that certain securityholders have an incentive to sell because they will profit on sales given that they purchased their shares at more favorable prices than the public investors. Disclose the percentage that these shares currently represent of the total number of shares outstanding.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on page 72 accordingly.Read in the reply
We note that the projected revenues for 2021 were $173 million, as set forth in the unaudited prospective financial information management prepared and provided to the SPAC board in connection with the evaluation of the Business Combination. We also note that your actual revenues for year ended December 31, 2021 were approximately $145.6 million.Rest of the question
Please update your disclosure in Liquidity and Capital Resources, and elsewhere, to provide updated information about the company’s financial position and further risks to the Company's business operations and liquidity in light of these circumstances.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on pages 106, 112 and 113 accordingly.Read in the reply
We note your references to your Written Put Option, which appear here but are not defined in your prospectus. Provide disclosure in your prospectus about the Written Put Options and how they relate to your forward share purchase agreements. General
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on page 120 accordingly.Read in the reply
We note the disclosure in Note V of your consolidated financial statements of the Company’s repurchase of 9,952,803 shares of common stock held by certain third-party investors pursuant to forward share purchase agreements with those investors.Rest of the question
You also disclose in Note V that a termination agreement was entered into with Glazer Investors and Meteora Investors on February 23, 2022, as disclosed on Form 8-K and incorporated by reference into your registration statement. Please tell us what consideration was given to disclosing the Company's repurchase of shares from the Highbridge Investors or Tenor on Form 8-K after the repurchases were effected. Additionally, given that restricted cash in the amount of $101,021,000 is no longer be available to the company to use for other purposes, include appropriate risk factor disclosure highlighting the depletion of these assets.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and has revised the disclosure on page 65 accordingly. Furthermore, the Company does not believe disclosure on Form 8-K was required for the Company’s repurchase of shares from the Highbridge Investors or Tenor. Such repurchases were made in accordance with the terms of the previously disclosed applicable forward share purchase agreements.Read in the replyRest of the answer
In addition, the forward share purchase agreement with the Highbridge Investors and Tenor were not amended or terminated, unlike the agreements with the Glazer Investors and the
Meteora Investors.
We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions related to this letter, please contact the undersigned by telephone at (212) 446-4794 or by email at [email protected].
We note that you are registering for resale all 113,250,000 common shares held by your controlling shareholder, AE Industrial Partners (“AE”). Given the nature of your offering, including the size of the offering relative to both the number of shares outstanding and number of shares held by non-affiliates, and your relationship with AE, please provide us with an analysis of your basis for determining that it isRest of the question
appropriate to characterize the transaction as a secondary offering under Securities Act Rule 415(a)(1)(i) as opposed to an indirect primary offering. In your analysis, please address your relationship with AE. For example, we note that AE played a significant role in coordinating the business combination of GigCapital4 and BigBear.ai Holdings LLC. We also note that a company owned by AE Partners is or was a customer and business partner of the company, and that there may be other affiliated relationships.
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully submits that the transaction is a secondary offering under Securities Act Rule 415(a)(1)(i).Read in the reply
In an effort to assist registrants in determining whether an offering by selling stockholders may be characterized as a secondary offering that is eligible to be made on a shelf basis under Rule 415(a)(1)(i), the Staff issued Interpretation 612.09 in its Securities Act Compliance and
Disclosure Interpretations (“C&DI; 612.09”).Rest of the answer
C&DI; 612.09 provides that “[t]he question of whether an offering styled a secondary one is really on behalf of the issuer is a difficult factual one, not merely a question of who receives proceeds” and that consideration be given to the following factors:
• how long the selling stockholders have held the shares;
the circumstances under which the selling stockholders have received the shares;
the relationship of the selling stockholders to the issuer;
the number of shares being sold;
whether the selling stockholders are in the business of underwriting securities; and whether under all the circumstances it appears that the seller is acting as a conduit for the issuer.
AE is a private equity firm specializing in Aerospace, Defense & Government Services, Space, Power &
Utility Services, and Specialty Industrial markets which acquired the Company’s predecessor in June 2020. In December 2021, the Company’s predecessor announced the completion of its business combination with the Company. Pursuant to
Section 2.1(a)(i) of the amended and restated investor rights agreement, dated December 6, 2021 by and among the Company and the holders named thereto, including AE affiliates (the “Investor Rights Agreement”), an affiliate of AE was permitted to nominate seven directors to the Company’s board of directors on December 7, 2021, at the closing of the business combination (the “Closing”). An affiliate of AE nominated Kirk Konert, a
Partner at AE, Jeffrey Hart, a Principal at AE, Peter Cannito, Paul Fulchino and Pamela Braden, Operating Partners at AE, Dr. Louis R. Brothers, the Company’s Chief Executive Officer, and Sean Battle, a former Company executive. Each continues to serve on the Company’s board.
Going forward, AE may cause the Company to nominate a certain number of directors to the board of directors based on its ownership indicated in Section 2.2(b) of the Investor Rights Agreement. Currently AE beneficially owns 89.1% of the outstanding shares of common stock of the Company and so currently remains entitled to cause the
Company to nominate seven directors.
The Company is also party to commercial arrangements with two affiliates of AE—Redwire
Space, Inc. and Edge Autonomy Holdings, Inc. We respectfully refer the Staff to the Company’s disclosure in the section “Certain Relationships and Related Party Transactions” on pages 146 and 147 of the Registration Statement and in
Note U—Related Party Transactions on page F-50 and Note Q—Related Party Transactions on page F-75 of the financial statements to the Registration Statement, which further describe these commercial agreements. The Company has no other affiliated relationships with AE.
While the Company acknowledges that AE played a significant role in the business combination as the owner of BigBear.ai Holdings LLC and has certain relationships with the Company, for the reasons set forth below, the Company respectfully submits that the registration and offering from time to time (the “Offering”) of up to 113,250,000 shares of common stock of AE is a secondary offering, and should not be considered, a primary offering of the shares to the public.
A. How Long the Shares Have been Held
The vast majority of the shares owned by AE (105,000,000 of 113,250,000) (92.7%) were received as merger consideration in exchange for equity of BigBear.ai Holdings, LLC which they owned since May 22, 2020 in connection with the amended and restated merger agreement, dated August 6, 2021 between the Company and the other parties thereto (the “Merger Agreement”).
Only a small portion of the shares owned by AE (8,000,000 of 113,250,000) (7.0%) were purchased in connection with the backstop subscription agreement, dated November 29, 2021 between the Company and an affiliate of AE, AE BBAI Aggregator, LP
(the “Backstop Subscription Agreement”). The remainder of AE’s shares (250,000 of 113,250,000) (0.2%) were received from GigAcquisitions4, LLC on the Closing pursuant to the Stock Transfer Agreement dated December 6, 2021 by and among the Company, GigAcquisitions4, LLC and AE BBAI Aggregator, LP to induce AE to enter into the Backstop Subscription Agreement.
B. The Circumstances Under Which the Selling Stockholders Received the Shares
The vast majority of the shares to be registered pursuant to the Registration Statement on behalf of AE were issued by the Company pursuant to
Merger Agreement in an arms-length negotiation with the Company. The shares to be registered represented merger consideration in exchange for the equity of BigBear.ai Holdings, LLC that AE had owned since May 22, 2020. As discussed above, AE purchased its shares to bear the market risk of holding the shares as an investment—and not with a view to distribution. As a result, AE has borne the risk that the Company would fail or be unable to register and/or monetize the shares.
In addition, according to Bloomberg, the average daily trading volume of the Company’s common stock as of July 13, 2022, was approximately 280,172 shares. If AE was to liquidate their position in the shares in the open market, it would take approximately 404 trading days for them to do so at that volume, assuming no other person sold a single share of stock during that entire period. No group of rational investors would purchase such a large block of shares with the intent of effecting a distribution in this way. The current float in the Company’s common stock would render any attempt to distribute the shares in this manner practically impossible—the market simply could not absorb that much activity. The Registration Statement will allow AE to monetize its investment in an orderly manner from time to time as market opportunities arise.
C. The Relationship of the Selling Stockholders to the Company
The majority of the shares were issued as merger consideration in connection with the Closing and in connection with the Backstop Subscription
Agreement. The Company does not have an underwriting relationship with AE.
The Registration Statement registering the shares was filed by the Company pursuant to its obligations under the Investor Rights Agreement.
To the extent that AE sells its shares, AE will retain all proceeds from the sale pursuant to the Registration Statement and the Company will not receive any of the proceeds from any resale of the shares to be registered.
D. The Number of Shares Being Registered
The Company acknowledges the large amount of shares of common stock involved, however, the Company does not believe that the amount of shares being registered alone warrants re-characterizing a valid secondary offering as a primary offering. Pursuant to C&DI; 612.09, the amount of shares being offered is only one of several factors to be considered in evaluating whether, under all the circumstances, a purported secondary offering is instead an indirect primary offering. Furthermore, the Staff’s own interpretations support the Company’s position. For example, Securities Act
Compliance and Disclosure Interpretation 612.12 (“C&DI; 612.12”) describes a scenario in which a holder of more than 70% of the outstanding stock is able to effect a valid secondary offering. The interpretation states, in relevant part:
A controlling person of an issuer owns a 73% block. That person will sell the block in a registered ‘at-the-market’ equity offering. Rule 415(a)(4) applies only to offerings by or on behalf of the registrant. A secondary offering by a control person that is not deemed to be by or on behalf of the registrant is not restricted by Rule 415(a)(4).
Additionally, Securities Act Compliance and
Disclosure Interpretation 216.14 (“C&DI; 216.14”), regarding the use of Form S-3 to effect a secondary offering, also provides:
Secondary sales by affiliates may be made under General Instruction I.B.3 to Form S-3, even in cases where the affiliate owns more than 50% of the issuer’s securities, unless the facts and circumstances indicate that the affiliate is acting as an underwriter by or on behalf of the issuer.
The Company believes that these interpretive provisions make clear that a single holder of in excess of 50% of the public float of a company’s common stock can effect a valid secondary offering of its shares unless other facts, beyond the mere level of ownership, indicate that AE is acting as a conduit of the Company. In these circumstances, AE’s shares are being registered on a Form S-1, the form for general registrations, not a Form S-3.
We submit that emphasis solely on the number of shares being registered in relation to the shares outstanding or the public float can severely limit a smaller public company’s financing alternatives, which are generally few. The Staff has acknowledged this by accepting, as valid, many secondary offerings where a significant number of shares are being registered but the facts do not otherwise demonstrate that AE is acting as a conduit for the Company to effect a primary offering.
Moreover, there is no evidence that a distribution would occur if the Registration Statement is declared effective. The Company is not aware of any agreements or understandings with any person with respect to the distribution of the shares. We note that under Rule 100(b) of Regulation M, a “distribution” is defined to require special selling efforts:
[A]n offering of securities, whether or not subject to registration under the Securities Act, that is distinguished from ordinary trading transactions by the magnitude of the offering and the presence of special selling efforts and special selling methods. (emphasis added)
Accordingly, the Company has not been advised, and is not otherwise aware, of any special selling efforts or selling methods that have been or will take place in connection with the filing of the Registration Statement. Nor is there any evidence that AE has conducted any road shows or taken any other actions to condition or “prime” the market for their shares. The mere size of a potential offering does not make a proposed sale a “distribution,” and the Company believes that the other factors discussed in this letter, support the characterization of the offering as secondary in nature.
We note further that, even if the number of shares being registered were given disparate weight over the other factors to be considered, we submit that the offering should not raise concerns about a primary offering being made due to the limited trading activity in the Company’s common stock which will limit the ability to sell pursuant to the Registration Statement.
E. Whether the Selling Stockholders are in the Business of Underwriting Securities
AE is not, to the knowledge of the Company, in the business of underwriting securities or registered broker-dealers and are, to the knowledge of the Company, not U.S. Persons within the meaning of such term under Regulation S under the Securities Act.
Additionally, the issuance of shares covered by the Registration Statement was neither conditioned on the prior effectiveness of the Registration Statement nor otherwise conditioned on AE’s ability to resell the shares. The circumstances reflect that AE made the investment decision to invest in the Company. As such, we submit that none of the elements commonly associated with acting as an underwriter are present.
F. Whether Under All Circumstances It Appears That the Selling Stockholders are Acting as a Conduit for the Company
The totality of the facts and circumstances surrounding the Offering demonstrates that AE is not acting as a conduit in a distribution to the public. Rather, they are each acting for their own account as an investor in arms-length transactions. The Company believes that the following factors weigh in favor of the conclusion that the Offering is a valid secondary offering:
the vast majority of the shares owned by AE to be registered pursuant to the
S-1 were issued in connection with the bona fide decision of AE to engage in a long-term investment in the Company;
AE acquired the shares for their fair market value and did not receive any placement fees or commissions from the
Company in connection therewith;
the Company filed the Registration Statement to comply with the provisions set forth in the Investor Rights
Agreement, and will receive no financial benefits from any future sale of the shares; and the amount of shares involved is only one factor in the facts and circumstances analysis and is not dispositive, especially in light of the Staff’s prior positions taken in C&DI; 612.12 and C&DI; 216.14.
Based on the foregoing considerations, we believe and respectfully submit that AE is not acting as a conduit for the sale of shares to the public, that the registration of the shares for resale by AE pursuant to the Registration Statement is a true secondary offering under Rule 415(a)(1)(i) and that there is no risk to the investing public if the Registration Statement is declared effective.
We hope that the foregoing has been responsive to the Staff’s comments. If you have any questions related to this letter, please contact the undersigned by telephone at (212) 446-4794 or by email at [email protected].