to the Staff’s comment, the section of the Registration Statement entitled “Material Contracts” has been revised to include a description of the “Cash Custody Agreement,” as well as the term and termination provisions of each material contract. The Sponsor represents that no instructions have been given to the Bitcoin Custodian as it relates to Incidental Rights and IR Assets.
pursusant to the Staff’s comment, the following disclosure has been added to the section of the Registration Statement entitled
Rest of the answer
terminated or the Bitcoin Custodian or Prime Execution Agent fails to provide services as required, the Trustee may need to find and appoint a replacement custodian, which could pose a challenge to the safekeeping of the Trust’s bitcoins, and the Trust’s ability to continue to operate may be adversely affected.
Trust is dependent on the Bitcoin Custodian, which is Coinbase Custody, and the Prime Execution Agent, Coinbase Inc. to operate.
Coinbase Custody performs essential functions in terms of safekeeping the Trust’s bitcoin in the Trust Bitcoin Account, and its affiliate, Coinbase Inc., in its capacity as Prime Execution Agent, facilitates the buying and selling or settlement of bitcoin by the Trust in connection with cash creations and redemptions between the Trust and the Authorized Participants and the selling of bitcoin to pay Trust expenses not assumed by the Sponsor. If Coinbase Custody or Coinbase Inc. fails to perform the functions they perform for the Trust, the Trust may be unable to operate or create or redeem Baskets, which could force the Trust to liquidate or adversely affect the price of the Shares.
On
March 22, 2023, the Prime Execution Agent and its parent (such parent, “Coinbase Global” and together with Coinbase
Inc., the “Relevant Coinbase Entities”) received a “Wells Notice” from the SEC staff stating that the
SEC staff made a “preliminary determination” to recommend that the SEC file an enforcement action against the Relevant
Coinbase Entities alleging violations of the federal securities laws, including the Exchange Act and the Securities Act. According to Coinbase Global’s public reporting company disclosure, based on discussions with the SEC staff, the Relevant Coinbase
Entities believe these potential enforcement actions would relate to aspects of the Relevant Coinbase Entities’ Coinbase
Prime service, spot market, staking service Coinbase Earn, and Coinbase Wallet, and the potential civil action may seek injunctive relief, disgorgement, and civil penalties. On June 6, 2023, the SEC filed a complaint against the Relevant Coinbase Entities in federal district court in the Southern District of New York, alleging, inter alia: (i) that Coinbase Inc. has violated the Exchange
Act by failing to register with the SEC as a national securities exchange, broker-dealer, and clearing agency, in connection with activities involving certain identified digital assets that the SEC’s complaint alleges are securities, (ii) that Coinbase
Inc. has violated the Securities Act by failing to register with the SEC the offer and sale of its staking program, and (iii) that Coinbase Global is jointly and severally liable as a control person under the Exchange Act for Coinbase Inc.’s violations of the Exchange Act to the same extent as Coinbase Inc. The SEC’s complaint against the Relevant Coinbase Entities does not allege that bitcoin is a security nor does it allege that Coinbase Inc’s activities involving bitcoin caused the alleged registration violations, and the Bitcoin Custodian was not named as a defendant. The SEC’s complaint seeks a permanent injunction against the Relevant Coinbase Entities to prevent them from violations of the Exchange Act or Securities Act, disgorgement, civil monetary penalties, and such other relief as the court deems appropriate or necessary. Coinbase Inc., as Prime Execution Agent, could be required, as a result of a judicial determination, or could choose, to restrict or curtail the services it offers, or its financial condition and ability to provide services to the Trust could be affected. If the Prime Execution Agent were to be required or choose, as a result of a regulatory action (including, for example, the litigation initiated by the SEC), to restrict or curtail the services it offers, it could negatively affect the Trust’s ability to operate or process creations or redemptions of Baskets, which could force the Trust to liquidate or adversely affect the price of the Shares. While the Bitcoin Custodian is not named in the complaint, if Coinbase Global, as the parent of the Bitcoin Custodian, is required, as a result of a judicial determination, or could choose, to restrict or curtail the services its subsidiaries provide to the Trust, or its financial condition is negatively affected, it could negatively affect the Trust’s ability to operate.
Alternatively, the Trustee could decide to replace Coinbase Custody as the Bitcoin Custodian with custody of the Trust’s bitcoins, pursuant to the Bitcoin Custody Agreement. Similarly, Coinbase Custody or Coinbase Inc. could terminate services under the Bitcoin Custody
Agreement or the Coinbase Prime Broker Agreement (the “Prime Execution Agent Agreement”) respectively upon providing the applicable notice to the Trust for any reason, or immediately for Cause (a “Termination for Cause” is defined in the Bitcoin Custody Agreement as (i) the Trust materially breaching any provision of the Bitcoin Custody Agreement; (ii) the
Trust becomes bankrupt or insolvent; or (iii) the Trust fails to pay and settle in full its obligations to Coinbase Custody’s affiliate, the Trade Credit Lender (as defined below), which may, from time to time, provide financing to the Trust in the form of Trade Credits). Transferring maintenance responsibilities of the Trust Bitcoin Account at the Bitcoin Custodian to another custodian will likely be complex and could subject the Trust’s bitcoin to the risk of loss during the transfer, which could have a negative impact on the performance of the Shares or result in loss of the Trust’s assets. As Prime Execution Agent,
Coinbase Inc. does not guarantee uninterrupted access to the Trading Platform or the services it provides to the Trust as Prime
Execution Agent. Under certain circumstances, Coinbase Inc. is permitted to halt or suspend trading on its trading platform, or impose limits on the amount or size of, or reject, the Trust’s orders, including in the event of, among others, (a) delays, suspension of operations, failure in performance, or interruption of service that are directly due to a cause or condition beyond the reasonable control of Coinbase Inc, (b) the Trust has engaged in unlawful or abusive activities or fraud, (c) the acceptance of the Trust’s order would cause the amount of Trade Credits extended to exceed the maximum amount of Trade Credit (as defined below) that the Trust’s agreement with the Trade Credit Lender permits to be outstanding at any one time, or (d) a security or technology issue occurred and is continuing that results in Coinbase Inc. being unable to provide trading services or accept the Trust’s order, in each case, subject to certain protections for the Trust. Also, if Coinbase Custody or Coinbase Inc.
become insolvent, suffer business failure, cease business operations, default on or fail to perform their obligations under their contractual agreements with the Trust, or abruptly discontinue the services they provide to the Trust for any reason, the Trust’s operations would be adversely affected.
Sponsor may not be able to find a party willing to serve as the custodian of the Trust’s bitcoin or as the Trust’s prime execution agent under the same terms as the current Bitcoin Custody Agreement or Prime Execution Agent Agreement or at all.
To the extent that Trustee is not able to find a suitable party willing to serve as the custodian or prime execution agent, the
Trustee may be required to terminate the Trust and liquidate the Trust’s bitcoin. In addition, to the extent that the Trustee finds a suitable party but must enter into a modified Bitcoin Custody Agreement or Prime Execution Agent Agreement that is less favorable for the Trust, the value of the Shares could be adversely affected. If the Trust is unable to find a replacement prime execution agent, its operations could be adversely affected.
Sponsor may need to find and appoint a replacement Bitcoin Custodian or Cash Custodian quickly, which could pose a challenge to the safekeeping of the Trust’s bitcoin and cash.
Sponsor may need to replace Coinbase Custody as the bitcoin custodian of the Trust’s bitcoin or BNY Mellon as the cash custodian of the Trust’s cash and cash equivalents as a result of the insolvency, business failure or interruption, default, failure to perform, security breach or other problems. Transferring maintenance responsibilities of the Trust’s accounts with the
Bitcoin Custodian and/or Cash Custodian to another party will likely be complex and could subject the Trust’s bitcoin to the risk of loss during the transfer, which could have a negative impact on the performance of the Shares or result in loss of the Trust’s assets. The Sponsor may not be able to find a party willing to serve as the Bitcoin Custodian or Cash Custodian under the same terms as the current Bitcoin Custody Agreement or Cash Custody Agreement, respectively. To the extent that Sponsor is not able to find a suitable party willing to serve as the Bitcoin Custodian or Cash Custodian, as applicable, the Sponsor may be required to terminate the Trust and liquidate the Trust’s bitcoin. In addition, to the extent that the Sponsor finds a suitable party but must enter into modified custodial services agreements that cost more, the value of the Shares could be adversely affected.
Bitcoin Custodian could become insolvent.
Trust’s assets will be held in one or more accounts maintained for the Trust by the Bitcoin Custodian and Cash Custodian.
The Bitcoin Custodian is not a depository institution as it not insured by the FDIC. The insolvency of the Bitcoin Custodian or of any broker, custodian bank or clearing corporation used by the Bitcoin Custodian, may result in the loss of all or a substantial portion of the Trust’s assets or in a significant delay in the Trust having access to those assets. Additionally, custody of digital assets presents inherent and unique risks relating to access loss, theft and means of recourse in such scenarios. These risks are applicable to the Trust’s use of Coinbase Custody.
As it relates to the amount of commercial crime insurance held by the Bitcoin Custodian, the Sponsor, on behalf of the Trust, respectfully directs the Staff’s attention to the section of the Prospectus Summary entitled “Custody of the Trust’s Assets,” the risk factor entitled “Shareholders’ limited rights of legal recourse against the Trust, Trustee, Sponsor, Administrator,
Transfer Agent, Cash Custodian, Prime Execution Agent and Bitcoin Custodian and the Trust’s lack of direct insurance protection expose the Trust and its Shareholders to the risk of loss of the Trust’s bitcoin for which no person is liable” and the description of the material terms of the Bitcoin Custody Agreement set forth in the section entitled “Material Contracts.”
19 – Plan of Distribution Authorized Participants to your response to comment 36. Please revise to identify by name all of the Authorized Participants with which you have an agreement at the time of effectiveness of the registration statement.
Response to Comment 19 to the Staff’s comment, the section of the Registration Statement entitled “Plan of Distribution” has been revised to include the following disclosure:
of January ___, 2024, __________, __________, __________ and ___________ have executed Authorized Participant Agreements with the Trust.
20 – Creation and Redemption of Shares revise to add disclosure clarifying whether the Authorized Participant bears the risk of bitcoin price movements with respect to cash creations and redemptions.
Response to Comment 20
Sponsor, on behalf of the Trust, directs the Staff’s attention to the following disclosure set forth in the section of the
Registration Statement entitled “Creation and Redemption of Shares”:
between the Trust and the Authorized Participant, the expense and risk of the difference between the value of bitcoin calculated by the Administrator for daily valuation using the BRRNY and the price at which the Trust acquires the bitcoin will be borne solely by the Authorized Participant to the extent that the Trust pays more for bitcoin than the price used by the Trust for daily valuation.
21 – Creation Procedures to your response to comment 37. Please revise to disclose whether the Bitcoin Trading Counterparty must have an account with the
Bitcoin custodian and whether the transfer from the Bitcoin Trading Counterparty is on-chain or off-chain in connection with creations and the transfer of bitcoin from the Bitcoin Custodian to the Bitcoin Trading Counterparty in connection with redemptions is on-chain or off-chain, and, if on-chain, who pays for the transfer fee. In addition, please disclose whether excess cash not needed for the purchase of bitcoin is returned to the Authorized Participant if the price of bitcoin has dropped since the Purchase Order
Date. Also please disclose how the Sponsor “seek[s] to purchase bitcoin at [a] commercially reasonable price” by explaining how the Sponsor determines the “commercially reasonable price.”
Response to Comment 21 to the Staff’s comment, the Registration Statement has been revised to include a section of the Registration Statement entitled
“The Trust and Bitcoin Prices – Purchase and Sale of Bitcoin” which is responsive to this comment and is set forth in Response to Comment 15.
while the Trust would return excess cash not needed for the purchase of bitcoin, due to the Trust’s procedures in connection with processing Purchase Orders, it is highly unlikely that any such scenario would ever occur. Each night the Trust publishes the Basket Amount for the following day. In connection with received Purchase Orders, the Trust goes into the market and seeks to purchase the Basket Amount of bitcoin from a Bitcoin Trading Counterparty. After the transaction price has been agreed upon for the Basket Amount of bitcoin, the Sponsor informs BNY Mellon the price at which the transaction will take place on the following day. BNY Mellon subsequently notifies the Authorized Participant the amount of cash that needs to be delivered the following day to settle the Purchase Order. The Authorized Participant then delivers that amount of cash the next day. The Authorized Participant only delivers cash to the Trust in an amount equal to the price the Sponsor, on behalf of the Trust, will acquire the bitcoin.
22 – Governing Law; Consent to Delaware Jurisdiction to your response to comment 42. We note that the forum selection provision applies to claims under the Securities Act such that the federal district courts of the United States of America shall be the exclusive forum for the resolution of any complaint asserting a cause of action arising under the Securities Act, or the rules and regulations promulgated thereunder. Please revise to state that investors cannot waive compliance with the federal securities laws and the rules and regulations thereunder. In this regard, we note that Section 22 of the Securities Act creates concurrent jurisdiction for federal and state courts over all suits brought to enforce any duty or liability created by the Securities Act or the rules and regulations thereunder.
Response to Comment 22 to the Staff’s comment, the disclosure set forth in the section of the Registration Statement entitled “Governing
Law; Consent to Delaware Jurisdiction” has been revised as set forth below:
rights of the Sponsor, the Trust, DTC (as registered owner of the Trust’s global certificate for Shares) and the Shareholders are governed by the laws of the State of Delaware. The Sponsor, the Trust and DTC and, by accepting Shares, each DTC Participant and each Shareholder, consent to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of the State of Delaware and any federal courts located in Delaware. Such consent is not required for any person to assert a claim of Delaware jurisdiction over the Sponsor, the Trust.
Section
22 of the Securities Act creates concurrent jurisdiction for federal and state courts over all suits brought to enforce any duty or liability created by the Securities Act or the rules and regulations thereunder. Investors cannot waive compliance with the federal securities laws and the rules and regulations thereunder. Further, there is uncertainty as to whether a court would enforce the exclusive forum jurisdiction for actions arising under the 1933 Act or Exchange Act.
23 – Financial Statement; Note 1. Organization note from the cover page of your filing that you changed the name of the registrant to Bitwise Bitcoin ETF. Tell us why the financial statements continue to refer to the registrant as Bitwise Bitcoin ETP Trust and why and when the name changed.
Response to Comment 23
Sponsor finalized a decision to change the name of the Trust to Bitwise Bitcoin ETF subsequent to November 29, 2023, the date on which the financial statements were issued, and prior to December 4, 2023, the date on which the revised Registration Statement was filed.
24 – Note 2. Significant Accounting Policies include accounting policies for creations and redemptions and calculating the net asset value.
Response to Comment 24 the Trust is currently in organization, the referenced audited financial statements presented in accordance with US GAAP currently include only a statement of assets and liabilities where the sole asset held by the Trust comprises of a cash balance. The Trust has not yet commenced operations. However, the Trust’s accounting policies for creations, redemptions and the calculation of net asset value to be employed when operations commence are described within section of the Registration Statement entitled
“Calculation of NAV.”
25 – Exhibits
With respect to Exhibit 23.1, we note that KPMG LLP refers to the reference to their firm under the heading “Fund Service Providers” and “Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” in the Registration Statement on Form S-1. Please ask them to tell us why they do not refer to the Experts section on page 82. Also, tell us where the Fund Service Providers disclosure is included in the Form S-1.
Response to Comment 25 appreciate the Staff’s commentary, and have obtained an revised and corrected consent letter from KPMG LLP. The corrected consent letter is attached as an exhibit to the Registration Statement.
* * * * * * * * call me at (312) 845-3724 if you have any questions or issues you would like to discuss regarding these matters.