The Company is a retailer of western and work-related footwear, apparel and accessories, operating 205 stores in 29 states and an e-commerce channel. The Company maintains a customer loyalty program (“CLP”) under which customers accumulate points based on their purchase activity. Once a customer achieves a certain point level, he or she can earn awards that are redeemable for credits towards merchandise purchases.
Rest of the answer
Unredeemed awards and accumulated partial points are accrued as unearned revenue and as an adjustment to net sales, and the Company records the unearned revenue on its consolidated balance sheet in “accrued expenses and other current liabilities.” The Company refers to this herein as the “CLP Liability.” The amount of CLP Liability is adjusted each fiscal period by the addition of newly earned points/awards and the deduction of points/awards that are used. The Company includes in the notes to its consolidated financial statements a reconciliation table for this adjustment showing, for each period, (i) the beginning CLP Liability balance, (ii) the additions for newly-earned points/awards, (iii) the deductions for award redemptions, and (iv) the resulting ending CLP Liability balance.
The Company completed its initial public offering and became a reporting company in October 2014. In connection with the preparation of the Company’s fiscal 2015 consolidated financial statements for inclusion in the Company’s initial annual report on Form 10-K (the “10-K”), the Company identified an error in the CLP Liability reconciliation table included in the notes to the consolidated financial statements that had been included in previously issued prior period financial statements. This reconciliation table presented the changes to the CLP Liability balances (labeled as “Provisions” and “Usage”) for the life of the CLP, rather than on a fiscal year-to-date basis. As a result, “Provisions” and “Usage” were each overstated by $1.9 million for fiscal 2013 and by $5.4 million for fiscal 2014. The Company advises the Staff that because both Provisions and Usage were overstated by an equal amount, there was no net effect on the disclosed ending CLP Liability, and the balance for each fiscal year included on the consolidated balance sheet was correctly stated. Additionally, the error in the disclosure did not impact any of the other financial statements, including the cash flow statement, income statement, and statement of stockholders’ equity. The Company’s fiscal 2015 Form 10-K included the corrected fiscal 2013 and 2014 CLP Liability reconciliation table, and disclosed the correction made. In addition, the Company clarified the labeling of the items in the Form 10-K reconciliation by changing them to “Current year provisions” and “Current year award redemptions;” whereas the previously issued financial statements labeled the items in the reconciliation as merely “Provisions” and “Usage.”
The guidance stated in FASB ASC 250 defines an error in previously issued financial statements as follows:
“An error in recognition, measurement, presentation, or disclosure in financial statements resulting from mathematical mistakes, mistakes in the application of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), or oversight or misuse of facts that existed at the time the financial statements were prepared. A change from an accounting principle that is not generally accepted to one that is generally accepted is a correction of an error.”
ASC 250-45-23 further states “Any error in the financial statements of a prior period discovered after the financial statements are issued or are available to be issued shall be reported as an error correction, by restating the prior-period financial statements. Restatement requires all of the following (FAS 154, paragraph 25):
a. The cumulative effect of the error on periods prior to those presented shall be reflected in the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities as of the beginning of the first period presented.
b. An offsetting adjustment, if any, shall be made to the opening balance of retained earnings (or other appropriate components of equity or net assets in the statement of financial position) for that period.
c. Financial statements for each individual prior period presented shall be adjusted to reflect correction of the period-specific effects of the error.”
The Company assessed the error under the applicable guidance for necessity of restatement, noting the following as it relates to the points outlined above:
a. The error related exclusively to the annual activity disclosure for the CLP Liability. Due to the off-setting nature of the error, the ending balances of the CLP Liability ($2.0 million and $1.3 million for fiscal 2014 and 2013, respectively) were accurate in the previously issued financial statements and did not require correction. Therefore, the error had no cumulative effect on the periods prior to those restated and the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities as of the beginning of the first period presented were not affected.
b. No offsetting adjustment needed to be made to the opening balance of retained earnings for those periods for the reasons outlined above.
c. The disclosure error did not necessitate revision of any of the Company’s previously issued balance sheets, income statements, statements of cash flows, or statements of stockholders’ equity. However, the Company restated the annual activity in the CLP Liability disclosure included in the notes to the consolidated financial statements and the nature of each correction was disclosed in the notes to the 2015 consolidated financial statements included in the Company’s annual report on Form 10-K for fiscal 2015.
The Company concluded that this restatement to correct the disclosure error for fiscal 2014 and 2013 in the Company’s financial statements included in its Form 10-K for fiscal 2015, as described above, was an immaterial restatement. In making this determination, we considered ASC 250-45-27 which states, in part, “In determining materiality for the purpose of reporting the correction of an error, amounts shall be related to the estimated income for the full fiscal year and also to the effect on the trend of earnings.” Additionally, ASC 250-10-20 also defined an error in previously issued financial statements as “[a]n error in recognition, measurement, presentation, or disclosure in financial statements resulting from mathematical mistakes, mistakes in the application of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), or oversight or misuse of facts that existed at the time the financial statements were prepared.”
The correction of the error had no impact on or relation to income for the full fiscal year, nor did it have an effect on the trend of earnings, earnings per share, or any key ratios. The error did not impact any financial statement line item, rather it was related to the detailed disclosure in the notes of annual activity in the CLP Liability during the fiscal years in question.
The Company further assessed SAB 99, “Materiality”, and SAB 108, “Considering the Effects of Prior Year Misstatements When Quantifying Misstatements in Current Year Financial Statements,” which provides the following considerations to evaluate if an error is material:
1. Whether the misstatement arises from an item capable of precise measurement or whether it arises from an estimate and, if so, the degree of imprecision inherent in the estimate: The error arose from an item capable of precise measurement, and did not arise from an estimate.